Summer 2022-23 transfer thread

[bigwheel]

Charlie Austin? Being released from QPR.

Can’t see it. But would be quality

[Jones28]

Charlie Austin? Being released from QPR.

Maybe Warburton will bring him up the road?

[Caversham Green]

Charlie Austin? Being released from QPR.

Andy Carroll's available and doesn't seem to look for a big wage (£1k per week at Reading). Whether he's fit enough is probably questionable.

[Vault Boy]

Charlie Austin? Being released from QPR.

Good pals with Marvin Bartley IIRC.

[Mr. Wonderful]

Stephen Kelly

[04Sauzee]

Stephen Kelly

What about the young laddie?

[andrew70]

Stephen Kelly

I mentioned him ages ago. Top young player.

[Alfred E Newman]

Charlie Austin? Being released from QPR.

He’s got a good engine.

[Dr What If?]

Just a wee list of SPL players I think we should be looking at, not rumours sadly........


Joseph Hungbo (Ross C) - a loanee from Watford so no idea if the home club have plans but what a player. A pacey winger with a bag full of tricks and an end product.
Liam Kelly (Motherwell) - keeper is not the top of our shopping list but this guy is a future Scotland no. 1. At 26 is a good age and would be an excellent long term upgrade on what we have.
Kevin van Veen (Motherwell) - we need strikers and while this guy is not marquee, he would be a challenge to Doige who form can vary.
Alan Forest (Livi) - a few clubs are looking at this lad and no wonder. Direct and exciting, can take a player on and shoot.

[HibbyAndy]

He’s got a good engine.

Nah he was exhausted after 5 minutes the last game i seen him play

[Hibee Mac]

Just a wee list of SPL players I think we should be looking at, not rumours sadly........


Joseph Hungbo (Ross C) - a loanee from Watford so no idea if the home club have plans but what a player. A pacey winger with a bag full of tricks and an end product.
Liam Kelly (Motherwell) - keeper is not the top of our shopping list but this guy is a future Scotland no. 1. At 26 is a good age and would be an excellent long term upgrade on what we have.
Kevin van Veen (Motherwell) - we need strikers and while this guy is not marquee, he would be a challenge to Doige who form can vary.
Alan Forest (Livi) - a few clubs are looking at this lad and no wonder. Direct and exciting, can take a player on and shoot.Liam Kelly seems to get a lot of praise but I've never noticed him any time we've played them

[Hibiza]

Only one class keeper in Scotland - Seigrist.

[ancient hibee]

Just a wee list of SPL players I think we should be looking at, not rumours sadly........


Joseph Hungbo (Ross C) - a loanee from Watford so no idea if the home club have plans but what a player. A pacey winger with a bag full of tricks and an end product.
Liam Kelly (Motherwell) - keeper is not the top of our shopping list but this guy is a future Scotland no. 1. At 26 is a good age and would be an excellent long term upgrade on what we have.
Kevin van Veen (Motherwell) - we need strikers and while this guy is not marquee, he would be a challenge to Doige who form can vary.
Alan Forest (Livi) - a few clubs are looking at this lad and no wonder. Direct and exciting, can take a player on and shoot.

Have you seen Motherwell's goals against total?

[Hibiza]

Nah he was exhausted after 5 minutes the last game i seen him play

Decent mileage for age.

[SaulGoodman]

Only one class keeper in Scotland - Seigrist.

Gordon, McGregor, joe hart?

[Dr What If?]

Have you seen Motherwell's goals against total?
With Hanlon, Porto and McGinn in front of him he could half that number :wink:

[HibbyAndy]

Decent mileage for age.

True , And good at breaking up play

[Alfred E Newman]

Maybe Warburton will bring him up the road?

Would that be the A7 or the A40?

[CapitalGreen]

Have you seen Motherwell's goals against total?

What about it? Goals against is a meaningless stat for goalkeepers unless you know how many shots he faced at least.

[JimBHibees]

Liam Kelly seems to get a lot of praise but I've never noticed him any time we've played them

Agreed dont rate him

[hibs#1]

Surprised Steven Fletcher hasn't been mentioned here yet.

[JimBHibees]

I mentioned him ages ago. Top young player.

Does he play for Salford?

[JimBHibees]

Surprised Steven Fletcher hasn't been mentioned here yet.

Are we linked with him?

[hibs#1]

Are we linked with him?

Just saw he was leaving Stoke.

[CL0762]

Surprised Steven Fletcher hasn't been mentioned here yet.

Would take him back in a heartbeat.

Seen someone on Twitter mention that it would be akin to Brewster/O’Connor back in the early 00’s with what Fletcher could do for Elias.

[hibs#1]

Would take him back in a heartbeat.

Seen someone on Twitter mention that it would be akin to Brewster/O’Connor back in the early 00’s with what Fletcher could do for Elias.


Yeah I agree a couple of year contract if he wasn't looking for big money would be great.

[Since452]

Would take him back in a heartbeat.

Seen someone on Twitter mention that it would be akin to Brewster/O’Connor back in the early 00’s with what Fletcher could do for Elias.

Yup. Would be a brilliant signing for a variety of reasons.

[Jones28]

Would take him back in a heartbeat.

Seen someone on Twitter mention that it would be akin to Brewster/O’Connor back in the early 00’s with what Fletcher could do for Elias.

I’d be pleased with that, Fletcher with a fighting fit Doidge and Nisbet with the likes of Melkerson, Hauge and O’Connor breaking through would be a good starting point.

[Crab apple]

Surprised Steven Fletcher hasn't been mentioned here yet.

Would be a great signing. As would his current manager.

[Johnny_Leith]

West London sport reporting David Marshall set to move to Hibs.

[JamesHFC]

West London sport reporting David Marshall set to move to Hibs.

He’s well clear of Craig Gordon.

[JohnM1875]

West London sport reporting David Marshall set to move to Hibs.

Would be happy with that but thought we weren't making any decisions on signings until a new manager was in place.

[04Sauzee]

He’s well clear of Craig Gordon.

He's definitely not well clear of Gordon.

[GloryGlory]

West London sport reporting David Marshall set to move to Hibs.

https://www.westlondonsport.com/qpr/keeper-marshall-set-for-hibs-move

Just looks like rehash of the rumour doing the rounds last week. No additional information.

[Callum_62]

Liverpool singing Calvin Ramsey from Aberdeen for 4 million

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[JamesHFC]

He's definitely not well clear of Gordon.

Craig Gordon has David Marshall posters on his wall.

[ancient hibee]

Liverpool singing Calvin Ramsey from Aberdeen for 4 million

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Nice tune:greengrin

[Lancs Harp]

Tom Barkhuizen just been released from Preston. Hes a decent player (forward).

[NC1875]

Would be happy with that but thought we weren't making any decisions on signings until a new manager was in place.

Warburtons already ok’d it 🤔

[Jones28]

Liverpool singing Calvin Ramsey from Aberdeen for 4 million

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

That’s a good fee. But should price Doig higher if he goes in the summer.

[GreenCastle]

Tom Barkhuizen just been released from Preston. Hes a decent player (forward).

Hearts probably aware since Joe Savage was at Preston and knows the club well.

[easty]

Tom Barkhuizen just been released from Preston. Hes a decent player (forward).

A wee striker who hasn’t scored a goal since Dec 2020. Pass.

[HoboHarry]

That’s a good fee. But should price Doig higher if he goes in the summer.

You think we'll get more than 4M for Doig? Or am I misunderstanding your comment?

[JohnM1875]

You think we'll get more than 4M for Doig? Or am I misunderstanding your comment?

I don't think we'll get more than 4M for Doig either, but I 100% think he's a better player than Ramsay is and only a year older.

[JimBHibees]

I don't think we'll get more than 4M for Doig either, but I 100% think he's a better player than Ramsay is and only a year older.

Think Ramsay is better in terms of delivery into the box assists and goals. Very good player with huge potential and similar to Trent player wise.

[Since452]

He’s well clear of Craig Gordon.

Nowhere near as good as Gordon. Decent though.

[Tambo]

Speaking ahead of Tuesday night’s trip to Dundee for the club’s penultimate game of the Scottish Premiership season, Clarke insisted he was looking forward to spending next season in the Capital while acknowledging the two break clauses in his contract that allow the Gunners to recall him this summer, or during the next winter transfer window.

[Jones28]

You think we'll get more than 4M for Doig? Or am I misunderstanding your comment?

No sorry, I think it puts a maybe slightly higher price on Doig, but £4m is asking a lot.

[S4uzee]

That’s a good fee. But should price Doig higher if he goes in the summer.

I think we’d be lucky to get £2m for Doig now unless performances drastically improve

[OldEast]

I think we’d be lucky to get £2m for Doig now unless performances drastically improve

I agree we missed the boat by not selling him when we could.

[Brown Hibs]

I think we’d be lucky to get £2m for Doig now unless performances drastically improve

Don't worry about Doig, after a bit of a slow start this season he's improved. We will get more than £4 million for him in the end. He's an unbelievable talent.

[Dmas]

Don't worry about Doig, after a bit of a slow start this season he's improved. We will get more than £4 million for him in the end. He's an unbelievable talent.

Contrary to some opinions (Ron’s included) I actually think Doig improved under maloney, certainly his form anyway, think he was playing more as a LB under Ross in the end and was defensively found out a bit, playing higher up for SM certainly improved his performances

[Edinburgh Green]

Don't worry about Doig, after a bit of a slow start this season he's improved. We will get more than £4 million for him in the end. He's an unbelievable talent.

Honestly can’t see it. Think he lacks the aggression and awareness to make it at a higher level. Would love to be proved wrong.

[ElginHibbie]

https://www.westlondonsport.com/qpr/keeper-marshall-set-for-hibs-move

Just looks like rehash of the rumour doing the rounds last week. No additional information.

Was speaking to my QPR supporting pal and he says West London Sport are always spot on which makes me think more than a rumour

[Smartie]

Don't worry about Doig, after a bit of a slow start this season he's improved. We will get more than £4 million for him in the end. He's an unbelievable talent.

Doig is excellent when played in his best position.

He’s a fairly average centre half but an excellent full back or wing back.

[BoomtownHibees]

Contrary to some opinions (Ron’s included) I actually think Doig improved under maloney, certainly his form anyway, think he was playing more as a LB under Ross in the end and was defensively found out a bit, playing higher up for SM certainly improved his performances

Maloney played him at LCB far too often and his form suffered big time. If we continue with a back 3 then Josh needs to be playing wing back again where he has shown his best form by far

[superfurryhibby]

Honestly can’t see it. Think he lacks the aggression and awareness to make it at a higher level. Would love to be proved wrong.

You won’t be. Doig is still developing, but he’s not had a great season ( in common with most). I can’t see anyone paying a six figure transfer fee for him any time soon. He’s better staying at Hibs and learning the game some more.

[Gordy M]

You won’t be. Doig is still developing, but he’s not had a great season ( in common with most). I can’t see anyone paying a six figure transfer fee for him any time soon. He’s better staying at Hibs and learning the game some more.

Calvin Ramsay is playing in a team who are below us.

[Brown Hibs]

Contrary to some opinions (Ron’s included) I actually think Doig improved under maloney, certainly his form anyway, think he was playing more as a LB under Ross in the end and was defensively found out a bit, playing higher up for SM certainly improved his performances

Agree. One of the reasons I wanted Maloney to stay on and at least get the summer.

[J-C]

Contrary to some opinions (Ron’s included) I actually think Doig improved under maloney, certainly his form anyway, think he was playing more as a LB under Ross in the end and was defensively found out a bit, playing higher up for SM certainly improved his performances

In his recent interview he talks about playing an attacking left midfield role as a youth, he is definitely better going forward than defending.

[Brightside]

In his recent interview he talks about playing an attacking left midfield role as a youth, he is definitely better going forward than defending.

Been saying this for ages. Just coz someone at Hibs reckoned he’d make a good CB everyone jumped on that as his future position. He’s a wing back all day long. It’s his energy and stamina that will get him a big move.

[GreenCastle]

Marshall has signed!

Good to see us trying to improve the spine with a proven GK.

Assume Macey will leave.

[04Sauzee]

Sky Sports Scotland now reporting Marshall to Hibs

🟩 Hibernian will sign goalkeeper David Marshall after his short-term deal at Queens Park Rangers comes to an end. Thoughts on the move, Hibs fans? 👇

[GreenCastle]

Been saying this for ages. Just coz someone at Hibs reckoned he’d make a good CB everyone jumped on that as his future position. He’s a wing back all day long. It’s his energy and stamina that will get him a big move.

Yup - not good enough in the air to be a CB.

Though this is also a weakness for the team as quite a few balls go to back post and he needs to learn to do better.

[Northernhibee]

Sky Sports Scotland now reporting Marshall to Hibs

🟩 Hibernian will sign goalkeeper David Marshall after his short-term deal at Queens Park Rangers comes to an end. Thoughts on the move, Hibs fans? 👇

I'm very happy with that. A quality keeper with bags of experience and character. Would imagine that Macey moves on as I can't imagine he'd want to be a second choice goalie and I don't think he's good enough to be our first choice.

[Since452]

Sky Sports Scotland now reporting Marshall to Hibs

🟩 Hibernian will sign goalkeeper David Marshall after his short-term deal at Queens Park Rangers comes to an end. Thoughts on the move, Hibs fans? 👇

Happy with that. Very good keeper. Just below angry man and Gordon but better than Macey imo.

[Vault Boy]

Very happy with Marshall. Wonder if the new manager has been selected and signed off on this.

[Northernhibee]

Very happy with Marshall. Wonder if the new manager has been selected and signed off on this.

It's an absolute no brainer, not swooping and making this happen with or without a manager would have been silly IMO.

[04Sauzee]

Very happy with Marshall. Wonder if the new manager has been selected and signed off on this.

Cocu signed him for Derby so probably 😁

[Mr. Wonderful]

That’s a good fee. But should price Doig higher if he goes in the summer.

Could get that fee anywhere in England from championship up.

Just need to look at the fee someone (boro?) paid for ikpeazu

[Callum_62]

Cocu signed him for Derby so probably [emoji16]Warburton had him at QPR.....

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Brightside]

Marshall has signed!

Good to see us trying to improve the spine with a proven GK.

Assume Macey will leave.

He’s being signed as back up.

[CapitalGreen]

He’s being signed as back up.

You have no idea what he’s being signed as. Whether he is back up or not will be decided by the yet to be appointed manager.

[500miles]

I'd like to see us move on Jake Doyle Hayes and bring in Jamie Lindsay.

[Callum_62]

He’s being signed as back up.I doubt Marshall will be here as back up

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Paulie Walnuts]

I doubt Marshall will be here as back up

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

He’ll be playing due to the fact he’s considerably better than what we’ve got.

[GreenCastle]

He’s being signed as back up.

Good news is we will have improved options.

It’s an area we need improved and he’s a start - manager or no manager it was simple.

Next up a CH - a new midfield and strikers - plus some wingers !! Let’s go !

[easty]

He’s being signed as back up.

To another goalkeeper we have coming in?

Not a chance he’s back up to Macey.

[Edinburgh Green]

He’s being signed as back up.

A) You don't know that
B) He's better than the 2 there at the moment.

[Leitherhibs]

Marshall is a definite starter. Dabrowski as a relatively cost effective back-up.

Macey will get a good move back down South to League 1/2.

[SHODAN]

Marshall is a fantastic signing. Great bit of business.

[Mcbizz1998]

Delighted with Marshall. And there is no way on earth he is back up for Matt Macey ffs [emoji23]

[04Sauzee]

STV sports news

Hibernian have agreed to sign goalkeeper David Marshall on a two-year deal this summer. https://t.co/CIICokmpDK

[cabbageandribs1875]

i really don't think David Marshall will be a 'back up'

[HibsGW]

i really don't think David Marshall will be a 'back up'

Marshall is miles ahead of Macey of course he won’t be backup

[Scotty Leither]

Good signing...We'll hopefully get a fee for Macey, as I don't imagine he'll be wanting to stay as a back-up/

[Greencore]

David Marshall hasn't came on the cheap and we won't be paying for him to sit on the bench.

[Allant1981]

Good signing, not a chance he will be coming here as back up, he will be wanting his place back in the scotland squad

[04Sauzee]

Have we ever signed an aging Scottish keeper from Down south before who would be hopeful of getting back into the Scotland squad? 👀

[GloryGlory]

STV sports news

Hibernian have agreed to sign goalkeeper David Marshall on a two-year deal this summer. https://t.co/CIICokmpDK

https://twitter.com/STVSport/status/1523957228738383873

[60yearahibby]

Good signing...We'll hopefully get a fee for Macey, as I don't imagine he'll be wanting to stay as a back-up/

Will maybe give us a clue if Macey not in goal tonight

[Brown Hibs]

What was Marshall fourth choice at Derby before moved on? Not sure how he got on at QPR. 37 years old. Content with this but by no means a guaranteed starter.

[superfurryhibby]

Have we ever signed an aging Scottish keeper from Down south before who would be hopeful of getting back into the Scotland squad? 👀

Not sure, but I remember a bandy legged one we signed from Dundee reserves who went on to be a rather successful at reviving his career :wink:

Marshall should be a good signing, hopefully he's still fit enough and has the will to emulate Leighton and have a late career swansong that turns out to be decent at Hibs.

[cannastar]

hopefully marshall will do what jim leighton did when he came to us. could be a very clever signing.

[Nicho87]

Can’t remember the last time I was excited about a keeper

Marshall is a very astute signing if true

Experienced and can hopefully help sort out the defence and perhaps win a few points for us.

[SeanWilson]

What was Marshall fourth choice at Derby before moved on? Not sure how he got on at QPR. 37 years old. Content with this but by no means a guaranteed starter.

Probably still the best keeper we’ve had in years, even at 37 and not much game time.

[GreenCastle]

David Marshall also got a very catchy song.

Good start Hibs - more experienced signings will definitely help us climb back up the table.

[Heisenberg]

Probably one thing we can thank Shaun Maloney for. A good signing and would imagine it’ll see Macey leaving.

[maturehibby]

Have we ever signed an aging Scottish keeper from Down south before who would be hopeful of getting back into the Scotland squad? 👀

Another old goalkeeper who came to Hibs was Ronnie Simpson who went on to to play in the Celtic European cup winning team and was recalled to the Scotland team

[BILLYHIBS]

Welcome to Hibs David

Yes Sir we can boogie….🎼

[Unseen work]

Not see him play in a while so hopefully he is still of a similar standard to a couple of years ago.

If he is then that’s a signing of quality and one the board should be praised for.

I think I’m in the minority of people that actually rate Macey though so will be sad to see him leave (especially if Marshall isn’t the same).

[LaMotta]

Have we ever signed an aging Scottish keeper from Down south before who would be hopeful of getting back into the Scotland squad? ��

No because Jim Leghton signed from Dundee. :greengrin

Marshall could be a great signing. Think there's no doubt he will start as our number 1 next season.

[Unseen work]

No idea how it works as we don’t have a manager or if it’s purely down to us being linked with Robinson but someone just text me saying Ciaron Brown is someone we’re keen on.

Left sided centre back/left back and was at Livi last season.

Could be nonsense.

[GreenCastle]

Looks like Haaland to Man City confirmed soon. Part of the deal was basically City saying yeah come to us for a few years then you can go to Real Madrid. Especially when Benzema/ Mbappe at Madrid next year.

[Big_Franck]

Marshall would be a definite upgrade on Macey. I read he was starting for QPR in the championship until he got injured in March. Cba checking that though.

This does raise more questions over who exactly is making decisions on signings, as we still don't have a manager. All this talk of the manager having the final say is clearly nonsense if we are letting Mueller go and signing Marshall. The only caveat to that would be if we announce a new manager in the coming days then we could argue he was probably consulted on these before he was announced. If we don't sign a new manager soon then clearly someone else at the club is calling the shots on signings.

[Torto7]

Looks like Haaland to Man City confirmed soon. Part of the deal was basically City saying yeah come to us for a few years then you can go to Real Madrid. Especially when Benzema/ Mbappe at Madrid next year.

Thats pure propaganda made up by the Spanish press. Its amazing how b.s is repeated.

[easty]

Thats pure propaganda made up by the Spanish press. Its amazing how b.s is repeated.

Exactly. As if Man City are signing a player as a stepping stone deal :faf:

[Hibdan12]

Marshall could possibly be a new captain? Somthing I feel this team has been lacking.

[ScottB]

Marshall would be a definite upgrade on Macey. I read he was starting for QPR in the championship until he got injured in March. Cba checking that though.

This does raise more questions over who exactly is making decisions on signings, as we still don't have a manager. All this talk of the manager having the final say is clearly nonsense if we are letting Mueller go and signing Marshall. The only caveat to that would be if we announce a new manager in the coming days then we could argue he was probably consulted on these before he was announced. If we don't sign a new manager soon then clearly someone else at the club is calling the shots on signings.

Or that when there is a manager, they make the call, but when there isn’t we still have to react to opportunities.

I can’t imagine the new manager complaining about us having signed an upgrade in a key position, instead of waiting for his arrival and Marshall having gone and signed with someone else.

[MrRobot]

We really should have 3 good keepers in our squad so Id expect to see Marshall, Macey and Dabrowski fight it out for number 1 with Marshall the most likely choice initially.

His experience will be massive to both Macey and Dabrowski in their development.

[SlickShoes]

Marshall would be a definite upgrade on Macey. I read he was starting for QPR in the championship until he got injured in March. Cba checking that though.

This does raise more questions over who exactly is making decisions on signings, as we still don't have a manager. All this talk of the manager having the final say is clearly nonsense if we are letting Mueller go and signing Marshall. The only caveat to that would be if we announce a new manager in the coming days then we could argue he was probably consulted on these before he was announced. If we don't sign a new manager soon then clearly someone else at the club is calling the shots on signings.

Nothing like turning a bit of good news into a negative to have a moan at the club.

[GreenCastle]

Exactly. As if Man City are signing a player as a stepping stone deal :faf:

Listen to the BBC daily podcasts / Euro podcasts and they have discussed it.

Haaland was in demand but after talks with City they were happy to match the wages of other clubs and are aware he wants to go to Madrid.

Reality is Pep wants another striker next season also use Alvarez and may Pep may only be at City for another season or 2.

Haaland will move to Madrid after City just wait and see.

[ScottB]

Listen to the BBC daily podcasts / Euro podcasts and they have discussed it.

Haaland was in demand but after talks with City they were happy to match the wages of other clubs and are aware he wants to go to Madrid.

Reality is Pep wants another striker next season also use Alvarez and may Pep may only be at City for another season or 2.

Haaland will move to Madrid after City just wait and see.

Yeah, Athletic also said that City’s pitch was essentially ‘come here, work with Guardiola, win stuff, then if you still want to play for Madrid, you’ll be 27 when this deal ends.’

Whether he then goes or not I guess we’ll see. Probably also a factor that Madrid very publicly made Mbappe the priority, so questionable whether they could afford both in one summer.

[McGruber]

No idea how it works as we don’t have a manager or if it’s purely down to us being linked with Robinson but someone just text me saying Ciaron Brown is someone we’re keen on.

Left sided centre back/left back and was at Livi last season.

Could be nonsense.

Hopefully not nonsense - he was consistently excellent for Livingston, would be a great addition.

[Ronniekirk]

Marshall is a definite starter. Dabrowski as a relatively cost effective back-up.

Macey will get a good move back down South to League 1/2.

Is Dabrowski still under contract as he now needs to be playing week in week out to improve ? So will he be happy as No 2for another few years Needs to think of his career


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Ronniekirk]

What was Marshall fourth choice at Derby before moved on? Not sure how he got on at QPR. 37 years old. Content with this but by no means a guaranteed starter.

Is he he not currently injured


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JimBHibees]

He’s being signed as back up.

No chance

[GreenCastle]

Is he he not currently injured


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

He got a hamstring injury in March.

[JGS56]

Is Dabrowski still under contract as he now needs to be playing week in week out to improve ? So will he be happy as No 2for another few years Needs to think of his career


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Got another year, contracted until 2023.

[04Sauzee]

Jamie Brandon moves from Hearts to Livi.

[Brightside]

Marshall could possibly be a new captain? Somthing I feel this team has been lacking.

What do you think is lacking in our current captains? I'm interested in what Marshall would bring to the role?

[Springbank]

What do you think is lacking in our current captains? I'm interested in what Marshall would bring to the role?

Anyone who was at the Franck Sauzee dinner would have seen, right away, the immense respect he commanded, from all corners, because of his playing career & character

Not saying Marsh is in that Sauzee-esque category, but he's a national hero from Belgrade, and the only away keeper to keep a clean sheet at Euro 2020 at Wembley, which was not too many moons ago

[OldEast]

What do you think is lacking in our current captains? I'm interested in what Marshall would bring to the role?

I always believed if a team has a good experienced keeper he should be captain. First and foremost to marshall his defenders and make sure they know where they should be in any given situation. Something that is quite evidently lacking this season.

[CapitalGreen]

No harm in having multiple players in the squad who are captain material, when there is only one obvious candidate to be captain then you might need to look at the leadership and experience within the squad.

Our cup winning starting XI had maybe 7 or 8 players in it that you could have made an argument for them being the captain. In the 2007 team there was maybe 5 or 6 players. In our last 2 final defeats there was probably only 2 or 3.

[Tyler Durden]

What do you think is lacking in our current captains? I'm interested in what Marshall would bring to the role?

I would hope that Marshall would lead by example by just doing his own job well.... someone you'd rely on to perform as an 8/10 minimum every week.

Lewis can be relied upon as such but shouldn't really be playing next season. Unfortunately Paul Hanlon certainly cannot be relied upon as a top performing player on evidence of this season. And he has no real other attributes as a captain.

[Ronniekirk]

Got another year, contracted until 2023.

Good still think he hasn’t done a lot wrong when called upon


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Paulie Walnuts]

No harm in having multiple players in the squad who are captain material, when there is only one obvious candidate to be captain then you might need to look at the leadership and experience within the squad.

Our cup winning starting XI had maybe 7 or 8 players in it that you could have made an argument for them being the captain. In the 2007 team there was maybe 5 or 6 players. In our last 2 final defeats there was probably only 2 or 3.

Agree with your last paragraph. This team is sorely lacking in leaders.

[Since452]

David Marshall and Steven Fletcher in would be brilliant and exactly what we need. Don't know how realistic Fletch would be though but i hope we're asking the question.

[MikeyS]

It would be a serious long shot but I'd be enquiring about James Forrest's availability. Still got a year to go on his deal but well out the picture now. Might fancy a loan if he wants to stay in Scotland.

[Coco Bryce]

David Marshall and Steven Fletcher in would be brilliant and exactly what we need. Don't know how realistic Fletch would be though but i hope we're asking the question.

Fletcher and Nisbet up front would be brilliant.

[Hibdan12]

What do you think is lacking in our current captains? I'm interested in what Marshall would bring to the role?

One word: leadership

[MWHIBBIES]

One word: leadership


Did you think Gray was a leader?

[Hibiza]

Can't remember who was quoted as saying " Ive eleven captains " .

[Brightside]

Can't remember who was quoted as saying " Ive eleven captains " .

No idea. But the leadership thing is nonsense.

[Turkish Green]

David Marshall and Steven Fletcher in would be brilliant and exactly what we need. Don't know how realistic Fletch would be though but i hope we're asking the question.

37 and 35 respectively. Not signings for the future and TBH Marshall's legs have gone.

[Turkish Green]

Can't remember who was quoted as saying " Ive eleven captains " .

Was it not Efe Ambrose?

[CapitalGreen]

37 and 35 respectively. Not signings for the future and TBH Marshall's legs have gone.

Nightmare, we’ll miss his gut busting runs up and down the wing.

[blackpoolhibs]

I've not seen anything of Fletcher for a few years, how good is he now?

[SlickShoes]

I've not seen anything of Fletcher for a few years, how good is he now?

He's basically still performing about as well as he always has, not amazing but pretty decent

[delbert]

It would be a serious long shot but I'd be enquiring about James Forrest's availability. Still got a year to go on his deal but well out the picture now. Might fancy a loan if he wants to stay in Scotland.

There is little enough room on our treatment tables without signing James Forrest, the one position we haven’t been short of all season is long term injured !

[Hibernia&Alba]

Looks like Haaland to Man City confirmed soon. Part of the deal was basically City saying yeah come to us for a few years then you can go to Real Madrid. Especially when Benzema/ Mbappe at Madrid next year.

Magnificent signing, they've been looking for a striker and he's one of the very best already. I think he'll be a sensation in the EPL.

[Billy Whizz]

There is little enough room on our treatment tables without signing James Forrest, the one position we haven’t been short of all season is long term injured !

I like Forrest, but as you say he’s regularly not available due to injury

[JimBHibees]

I like Forrest, but as you say he’s regularly not available due to injury

Always injured

[MikeyS]

Always injured

He has been unavailable for 15 this season with injury and last year he had a nightmare ankle injury that lasted the whole season but prior to that missed 10 games in 4 years.

I'd say unlucky more than anything else

[SHODAN]

37 and 35 respectively. Not signings for the future and TBH Marshall's legs have gone.

If that assertion is anything close to the yearly comments previously on here re Steven Naismith then I'm even more optimistic about this signing.

[Jones28]

It would be a serious long shot but I'd be enquiring about James Forrest's availability. Still got a year to go on his deal but well out the picture now. Might fancy a loan if he wants to stay in Scotland.

I’d rather get his brother.

[badabing67]

Surprised Steven Fletcher hasn't been mentioned here yet.

It says on his wiki page he is retired

[easty]

Anyone who was at the Franck Sauzee dinner would have seen, right away, the immense respect he commanded, from all corners, because of his playing career & character

Not saying Marsh is in that Sauzee-esque category, but he's a national hero from Belgrade, and the only away keeper to keep a clean sheet at Euro 2020 at Wembley, which was not too many moons ago

Also from the Sauzee dinner - John Hughes said that even though he wore the armband, Franck was a leader on the park (or something along those lines).

We don’t have to make Marshall captain for his experience to help us. The captains armband doesn’t make a difference.

[badabing67]

Doig is excellent when played in his best position.

He’s a fairly average centre half but an excellent full back or wing back.

I would like to see him and Cadden play in the middle I think both could do a job there.

[MikeyS]

I’d rather get his brother.

Aye he is a good player, could be Hearts bound if rumours are true

[hibs#1]

It says on his wiki page he is retired

Said yesterday he had no plans on retirement just yet.🤷*♂️

[brog]

Aye he is a good player, could be Hearts bound if rumours are true
We've been monitoring Alan Forrest for many years but successive recruitment directors and managers have decided not to go for him. This has been his best season but he's still not been an automatic 1st choice for Livi. TBH, I'm not sure he's any better than what we have and I would much rather we got Jasper under contract.

[weecounty hibby]

It says on his wiki page he is retired
Maybe code for signing for Hibs!! Would be a terrific signing for a season maybe even two

[hibs#1]

Mikey Johnstone don't know how much game time he'll get at Celtic in future might be worth asking. Still plenty to improve on probably needs regular games. Think he's had bad luck with injuries.

[brydekirk]

Very happy with Marshall. Wonder if the new manager has been selected and signed off on this.

It was done when malory was there.

[Paulie Walnuts]

Sol Bamba a free agent.

[HibeeSS0762]

Hopefully bushiri is away to f@@@. Potentially the worst centre back Iv ever seen in a Hibs jersey.

[Ronniekirk]

Could it be that Marshall isn’t the only signing the committee have made subject to new manager approving the deal or deals
A New Manager worth his salt isn’t going to want this nonsense in place especially when the Owners Son is part of the committee
Also if these players bought into Maloney’s vision of the way he wanted us to play a new Manager will have different ideas
It just seems to be getting messier
Karl Robson the latest to be mentioned is on shortleet But all indications are he is happy at Oxford



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Brown Hibs]

Hopefully bushiri is away to f@@@. Potentially the worst centre back Iv ever seen in a Hibs jersey.

Nowhere close. Think he is actually a half decent prospect. Problem is we've too many projects in the team. Getting no protection from midfield and when you have Hanlon as the senior centre half to learn off what chance have you got.

[Callum_62]

How do hearts sign players?

Does Robbie just say get me him or is there more to it?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[andrew70]

How do hearts sign players?

Does Robbie just say get me him or is there more to it?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

The boy Savage is their Sporting Director and by all accounts a very savvy operator.

[JimBHibees]

How do hearts sign players?

Does Robbie just say get me him or is there more to it?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Probably be like most teams a small team or people working together to agree.

[Callum_62]

Probably be like most teams a small team or people working together to agree.Like a Committee?



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[JimBHibees]

Like a Committee?



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Yes 😃

[Callum_62]

Yes [emoji2]Blow me down with a feather [emoji44][emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[ChilliEater]

Probably be like most teams a small team or people working together to agree.

Surely at Hearts it would be a big team? :greengrin

[JimBHibees]

Surely at Hearts it would be a big team? :greengrin

Bound to be 😃

[Stuart93]

Hearts looking at Connor Ronan. Would be a good signing for them.

Pretty ***** for us that their squads only going to get stronger than it is now

[weecounty hibby]

The boy Savage is their Sporting Director and by all accounts a very savvy operator.

My office jambo says he is the real difference for the tarts.

[Northernhibee]

Nowhere close. Think he is actually a half decent prospect. Problem is we've too many projects in the team. Getting no protection from midfield and when you have Hanlon as the senior centre half to learn off what chance have you got.

An international CB with 500 games for the club isn’t someone to learn off of?

[MikeyS]

Nowhere close. Think he is actually a half decent prospect. Problem is we've too many projects in the team. Getting no protection from midfield and when you have Hanlon as the senior centre half to learn off what chance have you got.

You dunno what CHs he's watched at Hibs. I've been going since 91 and can't think of many worse in that time. Probably Stephens, Nelson, O'Hanlon and Beaumont off the top of my head but not many more are as bad as Rocky. He's got a head like a biscuit tin & 2 spare feet!

[greenginger]

Hearts looking at Connor Ronan. Would be a good signing for them.

Pretty ***** for us that their squads only going to get stronger than it is now

Need to speak to Wolves .

[Mr. Wonderful]

My office jambo says he is the real difference for the tarts.

Will remain that way until they inevitably hit some poor form and/or lose a Derby or two. Then watch the knives come out.

Football fans are incredibly fickle.

[04Sauzee]

Hearts looking at Connor Ronan. Would be a good signing for them.

Pretty ***** for us that their squads only going to get stronger than it is now

Watched him closely when we played at Paisley a few weeks back, thought he was average in that game. Very small sample size though 😁

[CapitalGreen]

My office jambo says he is the real difference for the tarts.

They wanted him punted this time last year.

[Tambo]

Rocky has been entertaining that's for sure but I would decline making an offer.

[007]

Can't remember who was quoted as saying " Ive eleven captains " .

Think I remember hearing it recently. Maybe from the Roy Keane interview with Gary Neville on YouTube (link was posted on here recently. Can't remember the context, it might one of them quoting Alex Ferguson.

[Lago]

Like a Committee?



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk
Maybe a recruitment committee?

[Brown Hibs]

You dunno what CHs he's watched at Hibs. I've been going since 91 and can't think of many worse in that time. Probably Stephens, Nelson, O'Hanlon and Beaumont off the top of my head but not many more are as bad as Rocky. He's got a head like a biscuit tin & 2 spare feet!

Some belters in there! Nelson is hands down the worst. Can't believe you haven't mentioned messrs Boco, Murdoch and Rudge though.

[S4uzee]

Some belters in there! Nelson is hands down the worst. Can't believe you haven't mentioned messrs Boco, Murdoch and Rudge though.

I always thought Rudge was decent? Did he not play in the 2-0 derby

[Brown Hibs]

I always thought Rudge was decent? Did he not play in the 2-0 derby

My lasting memory of Rudge was in a 3 nil League cup defeat at East end park. One of the worst individual displays I've ever seen bettered only by Konte away to Falkirk in the same season.

[Stevie Reid]

Some belters in there! Nelson is hands down the worst. Can't believe you haven't mentioned messrs Boco, Murdoch and Rudge though.

Boco was a full back. Remember Duffy trying him as the anchor man in midfield in a derby defeat to Hearts, but not him playing at CH.

[Unseen work]

Another goal for Dylan Levitt tonight and I’m sure he’s out of contract in the summer.

Could do far worse than him, cracking player.

[Callum_62]

Another goal for Dylan Levitt tonight and I’m sure he’s out of contract in the summer.

Could do far worse than him, cracking player.Very good young player

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Mcbizz1998]

37 and 35 respectively. Not signings for the future and TBH Marshall's legs have gone.

A goalkeepers legs have gone? I’ve heard it all now!

[SMAXXA]

A goalkeepers legs have gone? I’ve heard it all now!

😂😂😂😂😂👏

Think people need to also realise just how fickle football is these days. It’s very difficult to sign young players and have the luxury of them developing over 2/3/4 years. Fans demand results and personally couldn’t care if we had a team or over 35s if we delivered on the park and replenished each year as they were no longer upto it.

This fascination with players being over a certain age and past is is mad. Some of our best players have been in their late 20s/30s when joined hibs over the years.

We bring in or bring through a young lad that turns out to be brilliant he’s sold and invariably the money doesn’t guarantee we improve the side of its all reinvested which it very rarely is.

We need a manager and players who are of a certain level regardless of age.

[Libby Hibby]

Another goal for Dylan Levitt tonight and I’m sure he’s out of contract in the summer.

Could do far worse than him, cracking player.

Great player. Cuckoo land if we think he’ll sign for us. If he stays in Scotland next season, he’ll be at United.

[Joe6-2]

😂😂😂😂😂👏

Think people need to also realise just how fickle football is these days. It’s very difficult to sign young players and have the luxury of them developing over 2/3/4 years. Fans demand results and personally couldn’t care if we had a team or over 35s if we delivered on the park and replenished each year as they were no longer upto it.

This fascination with players being over a certain age and past is is mad. Some of our best players have been in their late 20s/30s when joined hibs over the years.

We bring in or bring through a young lad that turns out to be brilliant he’s sold and invariably the money doesn’t guarantee we improve the side of its all reinvested which it very rarely is.

We need a manager and players who are of a certain level regardless of age.

👍

[JimBHibees]

I always thought Rudge was decent? Did he not play in the 2-0 derby

He did and played very well.

[Edinburgh Green]

Great player. Cuckoo land if we think he’ll sign for us. If he stays in Scotland next season, he’ll be at United.

Cuckoo land to think a player would join us over Dundee Utd? Really?

[JimBHibees]

Cuckoo land to think a player would join us over Dundee Utd? Really?

Yep don't think it is either. Offer him more money he would be walking here

[Gmack7]

Yep don't think it is either. Offer him more money he would be walking here

Is he out of contract at man utd?

[Callum_62]

Is he out of contract at man utd?Runs out June 2022 with the option to extend

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Smartie]

Yep don't think it is either. Offer him more money he would be walking here

For the past few years, certainly.

We're yet to see how many season tickets we've sold for next season though, and what our relative financial clout might be over a club who finished above us in the league and will be playing in Europe next season.

[Gordy M]

For the past few years, certainly.

We're yet to see how many season tickets we've sold for next season though, and what our relative financial clout might be over a club who finished above us in the league and will be playing in Europe next season.

They didnt sell a player in January for 3 million though so maybe the budget wont be that reduced, if at all.

[Ronniekirk]

They didnt sell a player in January for 3 million though so maybe the budget wont be that reduced, if at all.

Ron has already said the player Budget is increased from last season He also said The financial gap between us and Hearts wouldn’t be that much
I disagree on the latter and we would need to know by how much player budget is being increased
But it’s how we use that budget that counts and recruitment is key along with a Manager that can play players in best position and analyse which positions we actually need to recruit to , to improve us
If Hearts recruit as well as they did last season third is probably there’s for the taking
But we need to be aiming for fourth



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[bingo70]

https://twitter.com/clydefc/status/1524723106593579008?s=21&t=KgfO6qF1ygDzM2eTglTvQA

Steven Thicot signs for Clyde.

[Jones28]

https://twitter.com/clydefc/status/1524723106593579008?s=21&t=KgfO6qF1ygDzM2eTglTvQA

Steven Thicot signs for Clyde.

Danny Lennon looks like some sort of retired millionaire playboy. :faf:

[Smartie]

They didnt sell a player in January for 3 million though so maybe the budget wont be that reduced, if at all.

Fair point, although they have emptied fewer high profile management teams than us over the past 6 months.

We should be out of sight able to outmuscle United financially, although our actions over the past 12 months will have seriously impacted our ability to do so.

[Greencore]

Danny Lennon looks like some sort of retired millionaire playboy. :faf:

Maybe he is.

[SaulGoodman]

https://twitter.com/clydefc/status/1524723106593579008?s=21&t=KgfO6qF1ygDzM2eTglTvQA

Steven Thicot signs for Clyde.

I like how they’ve squeezed Mercedes Benzema and Nasri into the signing news 😂

[bingo70]

I like how they’ve squeezed Mercedes Benzema and Nasri into the signing news 😂

I’m guessing that’ll be the first and last time that’ll happen with a Clyde transfer.

[SHODAN]

https://twitter.com/clydefc/status/1524723106593579008?s=21&t=KgfO6qF1ygDzM2eTglTvQA

Steven Thicot signs for Clyde.

35 now, wow!

[G15 Hibs]

35 now, wow!

Time flies. Seems like an age since he was at Hibs. The type of player you know you definitely watched several times but can't remember them doing anything at all.

[04Sauzee]

Kyle Lafferty signs on for another season at Killie.

[MikeyS]

Time flies. Seems like an age since he was at Hibs. The type of player you know you definitely watched several times but can't remember them doing anything at all.

Was very good in the Tynie Derby when one of their fans tried to square up to Deek then sh@t his pants!

[Hibbyradge]

Was very good in the Tynie Derby when one of their fans tried to square up to Deek then sh@t his pants!

The Casper game 😂

[TelaStella]

Time flies. Seems like an age since he was at Hibs. The type of player you know you definitely watched several times but can't remember them doing anything at all.

Was he a CB, full back or midfielder? I can remember watching him play all 3 and never understanding what he was actually meant to be.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Since452]

https://twitter.com/clydefc/status/1524723106593579008?s=21&t=KgfO6qF1ygDzM2eTglTvQA

Steven Thicot signs for Clyde.

Wonderkid on Championship Manager

[Hibby-G]

Another goal for Dylan Levitt tonight and I’m sure he’s out of contract in the summer.

Could do far worse than him, cracking player.

Was brilliant for me when I signed him on Football Manager for Hibs, helped win us the title :greengrin

All seriousness, think he's a brilliant young player but can imagine he'll get a move to a decent Championship team in England. Worth a look at though.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

https://twitter.com/clydefc/status/1524723106593579008?s=21&t=KgfO6qF1ygDzM2eTglTvQA

Steven Thicot signs for Clyde.


Wonder what has brought him back to Scotland? Can't be the pull of the Bully Wee surely?

[Billy Whizz]

Wonder what has brought him back to Scotland? Can't be the pull of the Bully Wee surely?

His wife is from Edinburgh

[Mr. Wonderful]

Wonder what has brought him back to Scotland? Can't be the pull of the Bully Wee surely?

Often sighted in and around Edinburgh during the summer, used to see him running in his old hibs training gear.

[04Sauzee]

James Forrest signs on for a further 3 years at Celtic.

[Billy Whizz]

Wonder when Hibs will announce who’s being released. I presume the players finish up on Monday

[GreenCastle]

Wonder when Hibs will announce who’s being released. I presume the players finish up on Monday

Scott Allan
Innes Murray (seems like he’s been at the club for years ?!!)
Drey Wright
James Scott
Rocky
Paul McGinn ??

[Ronniekirk]

Wonder when Hibs will announce who’s being released. I presume the players finish up on Monday

Who will be making the final decision ?re who gets released


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Smartie]

Scott Allan
Innes Murray (seems like he’s been at the club for years ?!!)
Drey Wright
James Scott
Rocky
Paul McGinn ??

I find the Paul McGinn situation a bit weird.

A regular, then out injured for a while, then brought straight back in and a regular again but no new contract?

I realise any new manager might not fancy him but I'd have thought it would have been mutually beneficial to extend for another year?

[Billy Whizz]

I find the Paul McGinn situation a bit weird.

A regular, then out injured for a while, then brought straight back in and a regular again but no new contract?

I realise any new manager might not fancy him but I'd have thought it would have been mutually beneficial to extend for another year?

I thought McGinn had a trigger in his contract for another year if he played X amount of games
I’d 100% be keeping him

[Smartie]

I thought McGinn had a trigger in his contract for another year if he played X amount of games
I’d 100% be keeping him

Me too, I like him as a player.

I don't remember hearing anything about him though, so had assumed he was out of contract this summer.

[JGS56]

Me too, I like him as a player.

I don't remember hearing anything about him though, so had assumed he was out of contract this summer.

His deal is until 2022, with a 1 year option (I assume it is for the club to trigger this option).

[brog]

Scott Allan
Innes Murray (seems like he’s been at the club for years ?!!)
Drey Wright
James Scott
Rocky
Paul McGinn ??

Scott and Rocky are loans. We can't release them.

[Billy Whizz]

Me too, I like him as a player.

I don't remember hearing anything about him though, so had assumed he was out of contract this summer.

It’s probably done and the club don’t want to announce it in the current climate

[Tyler Durden]

I find the Paul McGinn situation a bit weird.

A regular, then out injured for a while, then brought straight back in and a regular again but no new contract?

I realise any new manager might not fancy him but I'd have thought it would have been mutually beneficial to extend for another year?

Presumably it’s within our control for now to trigger an extension? Shambolics if not.

But yeah I’m not sure why they are delaying getting it done and announced.

[Allant1981]

Countinho signs permanently for aston villa

[NC1875]

Countinho signs permanently for aston villa

****** sake Ron 😖

[Paulie Walnuts]

Countinho signs permanently for aston villa

His forms went off a cliff recently but they seem to have got him quite cheap for that league so prob worth a gamble.

[Lago]

His forms went off a cliff recently but they seem to have got him quite cheap for that league so prob worth a gamble.
Has looked very ordinary lately.

[AugustaHibs]

Rumours on Twitter suggesting Rocky and James Scott are both signing permanent deals.

Surely ****ing not?

[jeffers]

Rumours on Twitter suggesting Rocky and James Scott are both signing permanent deals.

Surely ****ing not?

May as well give Drey Wright a new 5 year deal and have done with it ! Scott signed a 3 and a half year deal with Hull in 2020, so I can’t see us paying a fee for him. I’d file that under twitter pish.

[Lendo]

Rumours on Twitter suggesting Rocky and James Scott are both signing permanent deals.

Surely ****ing not?

James Scott’s agent was up for the Dundee game with the aim to getting him out of Hibs asap. Fingers crossed that’s what’s happening.

[Iain G]

James Scott’s agent was up for the Dundee game with the aim to getting him out of Hibs asap. Fingers crossed that’s what’s happening.

Surely he only has to wait til after Sunday? 🤷🏻*♂️

[Coco Bryce]

Rumours on Twitter suggesting Rocky and James Scott are both signing permanent deals.

Surely ****ing not?

False.

[Lendo]

Surely he only has to wait til after Sunday? 🤷🏻*♂️

True, but I’m guessing it’s just to get the ball rolling. I think we will thankfully be seeing the back of him.

[Smartie]

In fairness to James Scott, I'd be amazed if he wants to stay at Hibs any more than we want him to stay.

It's been a grim season for him and he must be miserable.

If anyone ever needed a fresh start somewhere and a clean slate, it's him.

[McGruber]

Rumours on Twitter suggesting Rocky and James Scott are both signing permanent deals.

Surely ****ing not?

Emanating from those of maroon persuasion I imagine. Best ignored

[ian cruise]

Wonderkid on Championship Manager

I was just thinking I remember him more from my championship manager games than Hibs games

[SMAXXA]

James Scott’s agent was up for the Dundee game with the aim to getting him out of Hibs asap. Fingers crossed that’s what’s happening.

Lies

[Fuzzywuzzy]

Scott Allan
Innes Murray (seems like he’s been at the club for years ?!!)
Drey Wright
James Scott
Rocky
Paul McGinn ??

Murray scored really important goal for city on tuesday. You've got to think that at the age of 24 the ship has sailed for him At hibs

[BoomtownHibees]

True, but I’m guessing it’s just to get the ball rolling. I think we will thankfully be seeing the back of him.

There is no ball to get rolling. He will be free to go after the game on Sunday and never to be seen in a Hibs strip ever again

[Keyser Sauzee]

Funny feeling we’ll be seeing James Scott here again next season

[SHODAN]

Funny feeling we’ll be seeing James Scott here again next season

For Arbroath?

[andrew70]

James Scott’s agent was up for the Dundee game with the aim to getting him out of Hibs asap. Fingers crossed that’s what’s happening.

Absolute nonsense. Why would an agent come up to speak to Hibs about his player when he only has one game left to play.

Scott has been seen as a young player with potential for a while now and I believe it’s a long term project. We can all suggest whether we feel these projects are or are not working but in the meantime it looks the way we are going down.

[Lendo]

Absolute nonsense. Why would an agent come up to speak to Hibs about his player when he only has one game left to play.

Scott has been seen as a young player with potential for a while now and I believe it’s a long term project. We can all suggest whether we feel these projects are or are not working but in the meantime it looks the way we are going down.

Well I imagine he’s meeting his client to discuss his options. Believe it or not, hardly seems like a contentious issue.

[Smartie]

James Scott scored in his last game, had an assist in the previous one and has generally knocked his pan in for a team that creates zip for the past month and a bit.

Not saying for a second that I want us to sign him, but I don't think he's been close to being our biggest problem lately and really doesn't deserve the level of criticism that is currently being aimed at him.

David Gray has had a ropey few weeks. Paul Hanlon had an awful month back there. Joe Newell is the ever present part of a midfield that is posted missing weekly. Ryan Porteous has been either suspended or all over the shop in his most recent performances.

Scott was abysmal earlier in the season and has to take his share of responsibility but over the past couple of months, I reckon he can hold his head high.

[SlickShoes]

James Scott scored in his last game, had an assist in the previous one and has generally knocked his pan in for a team that creates zip for the past month and a bit.

Not saying for a second that I want us to sign him, but I don't think he's been close to being our biggest problem lately and really doesn't deserve the level of criticism that is currently being aimed at him.

David Gray has had a ropey few weeks. Paul Hanlon had an awful month back there. Joe Newell is the ever present part of a midfield that is posted missing weekly. Ryan Porteous has been either suspended or all over the shop in his most recent performances.

Scott was abysmal earlier in the season and has to take his share of responsibility but over the past couple of months, I reckon he can hold his head high.

Amazing what two games can do, because before that he was consistently terrible and in the last two games he has barely done any better.

I will say he did well with the assist, the goal against dundee was the bare minimum as he had 3 great chances to score.

The fact you think he can hold his head high shows you how utterly crap we are. We have played most of the season with a single striker fit and getting no service and a midfield that operates at walking pace.

[Nicho87]

Will surely get season tickets flying out now

[AugustaHibs]

James Scott scored in his last game, had an assist in the previous one and has generally knocked his pan in for a team that creates zip for the past month and a bit.

Not saying for a second that I want us to sign him, but I don't think he's been close to being our biggest problem lately and really doesn't deserve the level of criticism that is currently being aimed at him.

David Gray has had a ropey few weeks. Paul Hanlon had an awful month back there. Joe Newell is the ever present part of a midfield that is posted missing weekly. Ryan Porteous has been either suspended or all over the shop in his most recent performances.

Scott was abysmal earlier in the season and has to take his share of responsibility but over the past couple of months, I reckon he can hold his head high.


Jesus Christ. How standards have fallen.

[MyJo]

James Scott isn't the answer.

Having looked at his record he's scored 12 goals in 96 games in his career over 7 seasons. 3 of those were in the league cup against Greenock Morton and Annan.

His agent must be some sort of wizard.

Edit - Just noticed that another three of them where in league one and the EFL cup against Harrogate, Grimsby & MK Dons.

So he's scored a grand total of 6 goals in his career whilst playing in the Scottish Premiership and English Championship.

[Callum_62]

As a Third choice striker I wouldn't be averse to keeping him to be honest

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk