Summer transfer thread 2024/25

[PHeffernan]

Henderson will probably look good in pre season and be a big help to Vente with creating him chances.

One thing Henderson can do is see and execute a pass

Hopefully he’s improved alot as there was a spell he looked miles off it.

Probably for the best he’s moved on though as we need someone with loads of quality and consistency in there.

Henderson is a different type of midfielder from all the others we have and had a good season on loan in the Belgian 2nd tier scoring 7 goals in 31 games.
I've watched highlights of all the games he played and at 24 he could now be ready to break through at Hibs.

[BoomtownHibees]

Henderson is a different type of midfielder from all the others we have and had a good season on loan in the Belgian 2nd tier scoring 7 goals in 31 games.
I've watched highlights of all the games he played and at 24 he could now be ready to break through at Hibs.

He won’t make it at Hibs imo

[Paul1642]

Henderson is a different type of midfielder from all the others we have and had a good season on loan in the Belgian 2nd tier scoring 7 goals in 31 games.
I've watched highlights of all the games he played and at 24 he could now be ready to break through at Hibs.

Would I be correct in thinking that the Belgium 2nd tier is of a lower standard than the Dutch 2nd tier? We have Vente who scored a ton at that level and hasn’t quite cut it here yet (although I still have hope).

I’m not sure Henderson doing decent in the Belgium 2nd means he’s ready to make it here. We like to sell our league short sometimes but the standard here is a lot better than these leagues.

[JohnM1875]

Henderson is a different type of midfielder from all the others we have and had a good season on loan in the Belgian 2nd tier scoring 7 goals in 31 games.
I've watched highlights of all the games he played and at 24 he could now be ready to break through at Hibs.

Don’t think we can have a squad that includes both Henderson and Levitt. For what it’s worth, I actually think Henderson is a better player than Levitt.

[Eyrie]

Don’t think we can have a squad that includes both Henderson and Levitt. For what it’s worth, I actually think Henderson is a better player than Levitt.

I don't think we should have a squad that includes either Henderson or Levitt. Both are good at what they do well, but each has too many deficiencies in other areas to properly contribute to our midfield.

[JohnM1875]

I don't think we should have a squad that includes either Henderson or Levitt. Both are good at what they do well, but each has too many deficiencies in other areas to properly contribute to our midfield.

Aw same. I’d absolutely be moving both on if we could. Just don’t think we’ll be able to.

[.Sean.]

Move Jair on. Bring in Nicky Cadden. Massive upgrade


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Half this forum would be an upgrade on Jair

[JohnM1875]

Dessers gets in some fantastic positions. Should have about 40 goals this season.

[PHeffernan]

Would I be correct in thinking that the Belgium 2nd tier is of a lower standard than the Dutch 2nd tier? We have Vente who scored a ton at that level and hasn’t quite cut it here yet (although I still have hope).

I’m not sure Henderson doing decent in the Belgium 2nd means he’s ready to make it here. We like to sell our league short sometimes but the standard here is a lot better than these leagues.

I am thinking that Henderson may be ready to do something at Hibs next season based on watching him play in Belgium this season.
He has just turned 24 but due to being at Celtic didn't play enough senior games so was well behind in his development when he arrived at Hibs.
He was also very slightly built. I think he may have addressed these issues now. He really needed this years loan.

As for the Dutch and Belgian 2nd tiers, i don't know them well enough to have a credible opinion but based on populations and the number of teams in their top leagues the Dutch 2nd tier should be a little stronger than the Belgian.

Scotland has a population of 5.5 million and 12 teams in our top league
Belgium has double the population of Scotland and 16 teams in their top league
Holland has treble the population of Scotland and 18 teams in their top tier

[CapitalGreen]

Henderson is a Championship level player at best. If he’s involved in the first team next season then we are in for much of the same as the last few years.

[GreenCastle]

I don't think we should have a squad that includes either Henderson or Levitt. Both are good at what they do well, but each has too many deficiencies in other areas to properly contribute to our midfield.

100%

We need better and more consistent in the middle of the park.

Too lightweight and how many chances do they need to get into the team?

[Hibees1973]

I don't think we should have a squad that includes either Henderson or Levitt. Both are good at what they do well, but each has too many deficiencies in other areas to properly contribute to our midfield.

Buying players the calibre of Henderson & Levitt are clear evidence of a failed recruitment strategy and a dire scouting policy.

They have both had loads of chances in the first team and have failed miserably.

[Hibees1973]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.

[Donegal Hibby]

Buying players the calibre of Henderson & Levitt are clear evidence of a failed recruitment strategy and a dire scouting policy.

They have both had loads of chances in the first team and have failed miserably.

I have to own up here but I was happy when we signed Levitt and thought he'd prove to be a good signing , sadly he hasn't lived up to my expectations of him yet . I don't blame the club for that one tbh .

[bingo70]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.

Fairly shoe horned in that criticism of McPherson there 😂

[BoomtownHibees]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.

Some comparison that 🥴

[JimBHibees]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.

Arrogant wtf. Your relentless criticism is impressive

[Hibees1973]

Arrogant wtf. Your relentless criticism is impressive

Sadly at present, I am struggling to find anything or anyone to praise regarding Hibs at present.

No point in sugar coating what's going on.

When they start to deliver results on the park consistently I will. I have in the past, now a distant past.

[J-C]

Buying players the calibre of Henderson & Levitt are clear evidence of a failed recruitment strategy and a dire scouting policy.

They have both had loads of chances in the first team and have failed miserably.

Henderson struggled on 2 loans in the Championship and we only thought he'd be good due to his brother and the fact he was at Celtic. Levitt was a Man U product and had 1 quite good season at Dundee U but was poor when he signed for them permanently, again like Henderson he was signed due to his original parent club and his 1 decent season, both are not at the level we are aiming for, lots of potential but potential doesn't win you anything.

[J-C]

I have to own up here but I was happy when we signed Levitt and thought he'd prove to be a good signing , sadly he hasn't lived up to my expectations of him yet . I don't blame the club for that one tbh .

You're not the only one mate, we obviously forgot about his lower than average season at United when they got relegated.

[CapitalGreen]

Henderson struggled on 2 loans in the Championship and we only thought he'd be good due to his brother and the fact he was at Celtic. Levitt was a Man U product and had 1 quite good season at Dundee U but was poor when he signed for them permanently, again like Henderson he was signed due to his original parent club and his 1 decent season, both are not at the level we are aiming for, lots of potential but potential doesn't win you anything.

Levitt’s first season at Dundee United was more than just quite good, he was their Player of the Year as they finished 4th in the league. He was also a full international in double figures for caps for a highly ranked nation and was included in their squad at the World Cup. Levitt has failed to live up to expectations but his pedigree at the time we signed him was night and day compared to that of Henderson.

[Sioux]

Sadly at present, I am struggling to find anything or anyone to praise regarding Hibs at present.

No point in sugar coating what's going on.

When they start to deliver results on the park consistently I will. I have in the past, now a distant past.

Ok, explain why McPherson is arrogant.

[Jones28]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.

Aw **** me man, the sun is out, the season is over with and there’s reasons at the club for optimism.

Your negativity is staggering. Actually staggering.

[Allant1981]

Sadly at present, I am struggling to find anything or anyone to praise regarding Hibs at present.

No point in sugar coating what's going on.

When they start to deliver results on the park consistently I will. I have in the past, now a distant past.

Thought you weren't going to post until next season

[Lago]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.
I take it this is the opening salvo of your next campaign for season 24/25? Now that NM is gone McPherson the new target ��

[Hibiza]

Henderson is a Championship level player at best. If he’s involved in the first team next season then we are in for much of the same as the last few years.

10/10

[tonyrougier123]

The arrogant Malcolm McPherson said it was depressing reading comments of some on the appointment of MacKay.

What is more depressing is seeing some of these loan players coming back and picking up a wage from Hibs for another year or so.

Arrogance? Is that because he addressed what he had no need too?
Not everyone will agree with McPheeson but he’s hardly been arrogant about any decision.
I’m delighted a hibs man in the boardroom is engaging with the support,long may that engagement continue.
Do people really forget the dark days with no engagement from anyone at the club when the chips were down,2009-2014 only way you could have your say was not turning up and people in they’re droves stayed away lucky if we managed 8,500-9,500 at the games besides cat-As.

Despite the football,hibs is an engaging dynamic city club,and the owners are happy to change things up when it’s not working. Despite the disconnect some fans feel I actually absolutely have faith that everything we are doing is always to better the club under the Gordon family and long may that continue.

We do need to start getting it right though on the pitch.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Wasn't there chat on here that we'd pre contracts lined up or ready to announce?

We thinking we'll announce departures Monday with maybe some agreements announced midweek?

[gorgie greens]

Arrogance? Is that because he addressed what he had no need too?
Not everyone will agree with McPheeson but he’s hardly been arrogant about any decision.
I’m delighted a hibs man in the boardroom is engaging with the support,long may that engagement continue.
Do people really forget the dark days with no engagement from anyone at the club when the chips were down,2009-2014 only way you could have your say was not turning up and people in they’re droves stayed away lucky if we managed 8,500-9,500 at the games besides cat-As.

Despite the football,hibs is an engaging dynamic city club,and the owners are happy to change things up when it’s not working. Despite the disconnect some fans feel I actually absolutely have faith that everything we are doing is always to better the club under the Gordon family and long may that continue.

We do need to start getting it right though on the pitch.
Totally agree regarding Malcolm who is a good Hibs man and only wants the best for the club

[04Sauzee]

Wasn't there chat on here that we'd pre contracts lined up or ready to announce?

We thinking we'll announce departures Monday with maybe some agreements announced midweek?
Only talk I had heard was that a GK had been signed, absolutely no idea if true and I'm not even aware of a name.

[JohnM1875]

Only talk I had heard was that a GK had been signed, absolutely no idea if true and I'm not even aware of a name.

POTY doo tomorrow right? Sure we'll hear a rumour or two after that.

[Mcbizz1998]

Saw that Doidge guy in Ocean Terminal today. Still think we should have held on to him.

[Donegal Hibby]

POTY doo tomorrow right? Sure we'll hear a rumour or two after that.

Picking a POTY should be fun . Only one I can think of giving it too would be Maolida and he only came in on January.

[Hibs4185]

saw that doidge guy in ocean terminal today. Still think we should have held on to him.

ffs

[CapitalGreen]

Saw that Doidge guy in Ocean Terminal today. Still think we should have held on to him.

Why? He’s scored about 2 goals from open play in the English 4th tier, a division in which Harry McKirdy ran riot in. It’s over 3 years now since he last showed any sort of form in a Hibs shirt.

[MagicSwirlingShip]

Henderson will probably look good in pre season and be a big help to Vente with creating him chances.

One thing Henderson can do is see and execute a pass

Hopefully he’s improved alot as there was a spell he looked miles off it.

Probably for the best he’s moved on though as we need someone with loads of quality and consistency in there.

Shame it’s not worked out for him, all the rumours were he was the more talented Henderson brother.

[MWHIBBIES]

Why? He’s scored about 2 goals from open play in the English 4th tier, a division in which Harry McKirdy ran riot in. It’s over 3 years now since he last showed any sort of form in a Hibs shirt.

Injury hurt him a lot. We probably missed his defensive qualities and winning headers, holding ball up, though. I think more games passed Vente by than Doidge

[Paulie Walnuts]

Shame it’s not worked out for him, all the rumours were he was the more talented Henderson brother.

Were they not usually started by Liam? Sometimes wonder if he was just bigging up his brother as there’s never been anything that suggests Ewan is the better of the two when they’ve been playing!

[McD]

Were they not usually started by Liam? Sometimes wonder if he was just bigging up his brother as there’s never been anything that suggests Ewan is the better of the two when they’ve been playing!



There’s a poster on here who played youth football with the 3 Henderson brothers. According to him Ewan was the most talented, and the other brother could have turned pro also but suffered a bad injury - hope I’ve got that right, if the poster in question sees this :greengrin

[04Sauzee]

Some posters would love to see Greg Doherty at Hibs, well he's left Hull. Wonder where he goes next.

[Jones28]

Some posters would love to see Greg Doherty at Hibs, well he's left Hull. Wonder where he goes next.

I’m not at all sold he’d be the answer to any of our issues. He scored a belter against Killie but other than that I’m struggling to remember much about him.

[JohnM1875]

Some posters would love to see Greg Doherty at Hibs, well he's left Hull. Wonder where he goes next.

I’m one of them. We should be all over that!

[Smartie]

I’m not at all sold he’d be the answer to any of our issues. He scored a belter against Killie but other than that I’m struggling to remember much about him.

He was a good player.

Sometimes your last memory is the strongest… and he had an absolute nightmare in n a terrible derby performance in his last game, so he possibly isn’t remembered as positively as he should be.

It can’t be easy going on loan from Rangers to Hibs and I’m pleased we’ve not done much business with them since then, but he was a good wholehearted player.

Had energy - something we’ve often lacked in midfield at times when we’ve been struggling.

[chippy]

I’m not at all sold he’d be the answer to any of our issues. He scored a belter against Killie but other than that I’m struggling to remember much about him.
I’d have him no problem if fit

[JimBHibees]

He was a good player.

Sometimes your last memory is the strongest… and he had an absolute nightmare in n a terrible derby performance in his last game, so he possibly isn’t remembered as positively as he should be.

It can’t be easy going on loan from Rangers to Hibs and I’m pleased we’ve not done much business with them since then, but he was a good wholehearted player.

Had energy - something we’ve often lacked in midfield at times when we’ve been struggling.

That Greg Docherty would definitely take him back

[J-C]

Why has he only played 17 games this season? and if he was half the player some think he is, why haven't Hull offered him an extension? or been linked with a club down there?

[CapitalGreen]

Why has he only played 17 games this season? and if he was half the player some think he is, why haven't Hull offered him an extension? or been linked with a club down there?

Because Hull have been big spenders since their new owners came in. Everyone said it was poor form they sacked Rosenior but for the squad they had they really should have been making the playoffs. In Docherty’s position they have a Turkish international with 79 caps, an Ivorian International with 56 caps and a current U21 international for England. They’ll spend big again this summer as they push for promotion.

[easty]

Why has he only played 17 games this season? and if he was half the player some think he is, why haven't Hull offered him an extension? or been linked with a club down there?

I don’t think him not getting a game at Hull is something we should be turning our noses up at. He was behind Jean Michel Sari, a very experienced player, and Tyler Morton, a well thought of Liverpool loanee.

Allan Campbell was used less at Millwall, a worse side than Hull. Would you rule him out too? Nisbet no good enough because he couldn’t get a game?

[Paulie Walnuts]

I’m one of them. We should be all over that!

:agree:

I’d genuinely make him our top earner and I’d give him a 4 year deal.

Almost always available, great attitude, fit as a fiddle and would improve our midfield immeasurably.

[EGL2000]

Why has he only played 17 games this season? and if he was half the player some think he is, why haven't Hull offered him an extension? or been linked with a club down there?

Hull have much more quality than us. Just because he's not starting there means nothing.

[MagicSwirlingShip]

Were they not usually started by Liam? Sometimes wonder if he was just bigging up his brother as there’s never been anything that suggests Ewan is the better of the two when they’ve been playing!

Heard it personally from a friend of a Celtic youth coach, no idea if he heard it from Liam mind you.

[Unseen work]

Why has he only played 17 games this season? and if he was half the player some think he is, why haven't Hull offered him an extension? or been linked with a club down there?

Could say that for just about every Hibs player past and present.

[CallumLaidlaw]

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20240519/f543bd96f4d38a64e3dc6d18597d0771.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[NC1875]

Boyles not a free agent

[04Sauzee]

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20240519/f543bd96f4d38a64e3dc6d18597d0771.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

2025 his contract expires.
Transfermrkt has it as an option of a further year?

[Aldo]

:agree:

I’d genuinely make him our top earner and I’d give him a 4 year deal.

Almost always available, great attitude, fit as a fiddle and would improve our midfield immeasurably.

I wouldn’t be giving anyone 4 year contracts.

[Is It On....]

Why has he only played 17 games this season? and if he was half the player some think he is, why haven't Hull offered him an extension? or been linked with a club down there?

Hull also sacked their manager who was highly thought of.

[Since452]

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20240519/f543bd96f4d38a64e3dc6d18597d0771.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Tin hat on but he's been as culpable as anyone else for our stinking season. The penalty miss in the derby was a season defining moment. Very poor. Wouldn't be upset to see anyone in this squad leave.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Tin hat on but he's been as culpable as anyone else for our stinking season. The penalty miss in the derby was a season defining moment. Very poor. Wouldn't be upset to see anyone in this squad leave.

It's a good chance for a reset this off season isn't it. I guess we have to balance a complete gutting of the squad between keeping some experienced players and "characters" that "get" hibs around

Probably our biggest overhaul since 2014, which went not too bad either

[Niffy]

Tin hat on but he's been as culpable as anyone else for our stinking season. The penalty miss in the derby was a season defining moment. Very poor. Wouldn't be upset to see anyone in this squad leave.

Yup. St J cup final too. All those so called better players vanished.

[Unseen work]

The thought of losing Boyle, Youan, Maolida and Marcondes in the same window is terrifying.

Even though I thought Marcondes was pretty poor overall.

[bingo70]

The thought of losing Boyle, Youan, Maolida and Marcondes in the same window is terrifying.

Even though I thought Marcondes was pretty poor overall.

I think it’s pretty exciting to see who we replace them with.

[Stuart93]

I think it’s pretty exciting to see who we replace them with.

I’d agree if our track record was better

I’m struggling to remember a time in my hibs supporting life that we’ve replaced our best players with players who’ve ended up as good

I’m sure there’ll be a few exceptions but that sounds like a subject for a new thread entirely

[K-Zazu]

Simon Murray please, bring him home.

[tug.lismore]

It is difficult to make a case for keeping any of the current squad. Think I would be happy if we were to strip the squad to the bare bones and totally rebuild it.

Defence will be overhauled quite simply because of the spaces already in the squad.

If Boyle and Youan leave then the wide midfield/attack areas will need refilled.

We need a new balance in the middle of the park. What we have just doesn't work.

Apparently Montgomery had transfer targets already set up. Presumably Mackay is reviewing those whilst setting out the criteria for a new manager.

Hibs have an opportunity to reset the club.

New manager

New players

New culture

It will not be overnight and with a number of players still contracted to 2025 then it might be the 2025/26 season until we see it fully in operation.

As long as we see definite changes over the summer.

Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk

[Since452]

I think it’s pretty exciting to see who we replace them with.

Me too. More excited about them leaving than staying.

[tonyrougier123]

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20240519/f543bd96f4d38a64e3dc6d18597d0771.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Boyle leaving would be a huge mistake. At his peak now,I would have thought he’s contracted still though 🤔

[JohnM1875]

Boyle leaving would be a huge mistake. At his peak now,I would have thought he’s contracted still though 🤔

He is still in contract

[number9dream]

I don’t think him not getting a game at Hull is something we should be turning our noses up at. He was behind Jean Michel Sari, a very experienced player, and Tyler Morton, a well thought of Liverpool loanee.

Allan Campbell was used less at Millwall, a worse side than Hull. Would you rule him out too? Nisbet no good enough because he couldn’t get a game?

Hibs, Hearts and Aberdeen are surely going to be expressing interest in Docherty and Campbell... Hope our iron is in the fire. One of those two and Amos could be a very solid platform, if Luke can get fit and stay fit.
Been mentioned a few times, but if we don't have a keeper lined up already surely we have to be in for Mitov at St Johnstone. He's been outstanding.

[Broken Gnome]

That completely contradicts what Boyle was saying about stepping up and being a leader of the team.

Know he's not going to reveal all his cloak and dagger negotiations, but odd to sound so committed to Hibs if he was planning a move.

[Phil MaGlass]

This team will be unrecognisable next season, I will be very surprised if we keep any of this lot barr one or two. Wont be too fussed if Boyle leaves too.

[we are hibs]

I think it’s pretty exciting to see who we replace them with.I'd agree if there is a clear revamp of the recruitment side of the club.

Sent from my SM-A405FN using Tapatalk

[J-C]

That completely contradicts what Boyle was saying about stepping up and being a leader of the team.

Know he's not going to reveal all his cloak and dagger negotiations, but odd to sound so committed to Hibs if he was planning a move.

Pity he's not showing that today because he's been anonymous so far.

[Stick]

Simon Murray please, bring him home.

Yep

[badabing67]

Simon Murray please, bring him home.

Him and Mitov would be a good start to the window imo. Murray is out of contract at the end of the month

[NC1875]

Yep

Agree, Murray on a free contract is a no brainer. Surely MM will have a relationship with him from Ross County.

[Paul1642]

Him and Mitov would be a good start to the window imo

Is the Kilmarnock keeper who has had a good season not on loan from Bournemouth. There must be a good chance in him ending up at Hibs next season.

As for Murray, we should never have let him go but signing him isn’t what we need IMO.

[EGL2000]

Wouldn't even be that fussed If Boyle left. Imagine he's one of if not the highest earner and contributed very little this season. Take his huge wage and reinvest.

[B.H.F.C]

Boyle isn’t the player he was but he’s still contributed 11 goals this season. We’ll lose Maolida, we might lose Youan, I’d be looking to keep Boyle around. We’re going to have a lot of work to do this summer, I really hope we don’t piss about and get moving quickly.

[NC1875]

As for Murray, we should never have let him go but signing him isn’t what we need IMO.

I disagree, as a free agent and a relatively low wage, it’s a no brainer.

We need more players with similar attitudes to Murray.

[Northernhibee]

Is the Kilmarnock keeper who has had a good season not on loan from Bournemouth. There must be a good chance in him ending up at Hibs next season.

As for Murray, we should never have let him go but signing him isn’t what we need IMO.

Simon Murray is everything we need. Just now we’ve got an expensive striker who only scores if he gets the perfect opportunity, Murray may miss a few more but he creates so much through effort and also his winning mentality. Character the main characteristic I would be looking for in any signing this summer - someone who isn’t afraid to get stuck in with the ugly stuff and make things happen whether ahead or behind.

Absolute no brainer.

[ancient hibee]

Agree, Murray on a free contract is a no brainer. Surely MM will have a relationship with him from Ross County.
Depends on the kind of relationship.Did he play Murray regularly?

[badabing67]

Is the Kilmarnock keeper who has had a good season not on loan from Bournemouth. There must be a good chance in him ending up at Hibs next season.

As for Murray, we should never have let him go but signing him isn’t what we need IMO.

Just seen his goal on Sportscene his 21st of the season in all competitions. I think he is exactly what we need and he is a free agent.

[badabing67]

Depends on the kind of relationship.Did he play Murray regularly?

It was MM that signed him for Ross County.

[Trinity Hibee]

I agree Simon Murray would be a good option. It’s not a marquee signing but he’d bring qualities we lack.

Boyle hasn’t performed this season but you’d have to think once we get a settled side and use him in the correct way he’d be back closer to his old self. Should still be able to impact games in this league.

[Trinity Hibee]

I’d also like us to look at Harry Milne of Partick. Watched the game the other night and his work rate up and down the pitch was excellent, got stuck in, won a few headers at set pieces. Think he could be a really good buy

Scored 50 career goals from LB.

[chrisski33]

Think Boyles best years are past now but not to say a new manager won't bring the best of him out again. 2 oz clubs rumoured to be after him.

[stoneyburn hibs]

Can't believe that some are saying that they are not fussed if Boyle was to go.
Poor season by his standards but was out injured and still chipped in with eleven goals, I think he'll be an integral part of the squad next season.

[easty]

Can't believe that some are saying that they are not fussed if Boyle was to go.
Poor season by his standards but was out injured and still chipped in with eleven goals, I think he'll be an integral part of the squad next season.

:agree:

He'll end up playing for some other SPL team in a year or 2 and the same folk who didn't want him now will be saying we should bring him back. Like Simon Murray.

[JohnM1875]

Can't believe that some are saying that they are not fussed if Boyle was to go.
Poor season by his standards but was out injured and still chipped in with eleven goals, I think he'll be an integral part of the squad next season.

Agree and hope he's still here next season as well. Plenty rumours that he's heading to the A-League though.

[Tyler Durden]

I didn't see the game yesterday but what did people make of Tete Yenghi for Livi?

I think he could be a decent option as a squad player. Different profile to anything we have and there's not many big target men across the league. Looks like someone who could develop into a good player at this level in time and give us a Plan B off the bench.

More yellow cards than goals this season but 1 in 4 isn't terrible in his first season in a relegated team.

[badabing67]

It was a very poor game yesterday nobody really stood out. But for Livi the guy Anderson who scored their goal was possibly their MOTM

[Donegal Hibby]

Can't believe that some are saying that they are not fussed if Boyle was to go.
Poor season by his standards but was out injured and still chipped in with eleven goals, I think he'll be an integral part of the squad next season.

I would rather have Boyle than not . Good pre season behind him and he'll be fine

[Dmas]

It was a very poor game yesterday nobody really stood out. But for Livi the guy Anderson who scored their goal was possibly their MOTM

McInnes trying to sign him for killie

[GreenCastle]

It was a very poor game yesterday nobody really stood out. But for Livi the guy Anderson who scored their goal was possibly their MOTM

Think he will end up at Killie.

[Brightside]

Simon Murray wants to stay up north.

[badabing67]

Simon Murray wants to stay up north.

Even if County go down or is he wanting to go to Aberdeen

[EGL2000]

I didn't see the game yesterday but what did people make of Tete Yenghi for Livi?

I think he could be a decent option as a squad player. Different profile to anything we have and there's not many big target men across the league. Looks like someone who could develop into a good player at this level in time and give us a Plan B off the bench. More yellow cards than goals this season but 1 in 4 isn't terrible in his first season in a relegated team.

He didn't look anything special to me 2 of his 4 goals have been penalties as well. Bruce Anderson probably looked there most deadly always thought he's a decent finisher but still wouldn't be bothering with him.

[ruthven_raiders]

I would rather have Boyle than not . Good pre season behind him and he'll be fine

He's got two good seasons in him, he says he wants to play in the A league eventually, so will head there after he leaves us.

[Brightside]

Even if County go down or is he wanting to go to Aberdeen

Both, Dundee an option also.

[The Modfather]

Can't believe that some are saying that they are not fussed if Boyle was to go.
Poor season by his standards but was out injured and still chipped in with eleven goals, I think he'll be an integral part of the squad next season.

The issue for me is he’s probably not on wages of an important squad player but wages of a star player and talisman, which he no longer is.

[K-Zazu]

Both, Dundee an option also.

Booooo

[KWJ]

The issue for me is he’s probably not on wages of an important squad player but wages of a star player and talisman, which he no longer is.

This.

If we can get something back for him now then it makes sense to sell and bring in another instant key player.

[PHeffernan]

Agree and hope he's still here next season as well. Plenty rumours that he's heading to the A-League though.

Two ways of looking at Boyle.
First is he has come back from a bad injury and lots of other players were hamstrung by the Montgomery game plan. A pre season and a new manager could see him off and running again.

Alternatively sell him for £400k with a year left on his contract and save his rumoured £7k a week wage which is another £350k and buy Maolida with the £750k.

[Mcbizz1998]

Boyle has been playing in a stinking team and still contributed 11 goals. He hasn't been at his best recently but put him in a proper team with a proper manager and lets see how he gets on. Punting him will come back to haunt us if he stays in Scotland, you can almost guarantee it.

[J-C]

I think I'll wait till a new, hopefully better manager comes in with better players around him, if then he looks like regressing, he can go in January with our thanks.

[matty_f]

I thought Boyle started to look more like his old self in the last few games and so with a pre-season in him I think he's definitely one to keep.

[Frogga]

It was a very poor game yesterday nobody really stood out. But for Livi the guy Anderson who scored their goal was possibly their MOTMYeah, agreed. Was saying to my mates he'd be a decent replacement for ALF - same type of player.

Sent from my SM-A336B using Tapatalk

[Paulie Walnuts]

Boyle has been playing in a stinking team and still contributed 11 goals. He hasn't been at his best recently but put him in a proper team with a proper manager and lets see how he gets on. Punting him will come back to haunt us if he stays in Scotland, you can almost guarantee it.

Agree. Playing in a better team his 11 goals probably becomes 14 or 15 and we’re not having this discussion anymore.

I also think all his goals have been from open play?

[Forza Fred]

Agree and hope he's still here next season as well. Plenty rumours that he's heading to the A-League though.

The original article suggesting there were two A League clubs trying to sign Boyle was written by someone who has frequently exaggerated or just got things plain wrong.

The fact that his article was premised on the ‘fact’ that Boyle was a free agent probably sums up the value of his ‘research’.

Also, as an Oz based close follower of Boyler, I have never heard him once say that he ‘planned’ to play in the A League as stated in the article.

I have heard him say that he was committed to Hibs but that after that he wouldn’t rule out the possibility of playing in it,…..in answer to a question…..but that is a long way away from having any ‘plans’ to do so.

Also one of the clubs supposedly interested..Perth Glory are in such a perilous financial state that the APL directed them to loan their highest paid player to another A League club to reduce their financial burden.

The A League is in serious financial trouble and very few players will be coming here for big bucks in the near future.

Also other than the article referred to there has been no rumours of Boyler coming to the A League over here, and his comments about being part of the leadership group at Hibs in the future tend to also suggest that he plans to stay in Scotland.

He will be coming to Perth though, and is due to fly out on the 28th May for a World Cup qualifier against Palestine in early June, and a few days later heading off to play Bangladesh.

[Iain G]

Can't believe that some are saying that they are not fussed if Boyle was to go.
Poor season by his standards but was out injured and still chipped in with eleven goals, I think he'll be an integral part of the squad next season.

Wouldn't be bothered if Boyle left but let's get in Simon Murray, it's like some people enjoy being bottom six 😁

[badabing67]

Yeah, agreed. Was saying to my mates he'd be a decent replacement for ALF - same type of player.

Sent from my SM-A336B using Tapatalk


Why just not keep ALF he is a better player and I'm sure there is another season in him

[Paul1642]

Why just not keep ALF he is a better player and I'm sure there is another season in him

I can only assume this comes down to money. In terms of ability and fitness he is more than good enough to be our impact sub striker however I can only guess that his salary is higher than what we are willing to pay for that. Anderson probably wouldn’t get paid half of what ALF is on.

It’s a shame because I would definitely like to have him for another year.

I have only watched Livi play against Hibs this season but think we need to be aiming higher. Your only ever a few injuries away form a squad player becoming a starter and from what I know of Anderson he’s not good enough to lead the charge for 3rd. A fully fit ALF is.

[Tyler Durden]

Tin hat on but ALF will leave as the most overrated player since Paco Luna.

He’s been decent, nothing much more than that. A stop gap squad member whose output (due to availability mainly) was predicted by many when he signed. Good player on his day but won’t be missed IMO.

[Unseen work]

Myziane now posting his goodbye

“A very rewarding season, despite the ups and downs.

Forever grateful for the welcome and love I received here.

Thanks for everything! @hibernian football club”

[tamig]

Wouldn't be bothered if Boyle left but let's get in Simon Murray, it's like some people enjoy being bottom six 😁

I’ve thought that Boyle was looking like his best days had gone until the last month or so. I’ve been pleasantly surprised that he seems to found a bit more pace from somewhere. I think people not being bothered if he stays or goes should be careful what they wish for.

I also didn’t appreciate it was because of players like Martin Boyle that we ended up in the bottom six. Thats a new one for me.

[GreenCastle]

Myziane now posting his goodbye

“A very rewarding season, despite the ups and downs.

Forever grateful for the welcome and love I received here.

Thanks for everything! @hibernian football club”

While I never expected him to stay he did extremely well in a short space of time in a crap team. Without his goals I do wonder where we would have been.

Worryingly we need to replace those goals and IF Ellie goes too I really hope they can find some replacements who know where the goal is.

Would also sign Simon Murray (would never have let him go). Not as a replacement but a good hard working option.

[04Sauzee]

Myziane now posting his goodbye

“A very rewarding season, despite the ups and downs.

Forever grateful for the welcome and love I received here.

Thanks for everything! @hibernian football club”
I think most players do that as that's the end of the season and I'm not sure when their contract with Hibs actually ends?

[easty]

Tin hat on but ALF will leave as the most overrated player since Paco Luna.

He’s been decent, nothing much more than that. A stop gap squad member whose output (due to availability mainly) was predicted by many when he signed. Good player on his day but won’t be missed IMO.

:agree:

In 4 or 5 years time folk will bang on about how we never replaced ALF. The guys played 29 games, got 5 goals and 2 assists. I don't think we'll miss him at all.

[cameronw-hfc]

I think most players do that as that's the end of the season and I'm not sure when their contract with Hibs actually ends?


Might be reading too much into it but it doesn't feel like as definite a goodbye compared to Marcondes. Feels more like an end of season not sure where he's going type message rather than an outright goodbye.

I am desperate for us to keep him though so this could be pure delusion 😂

[PHeffernan]

I can only assume this comes down to money. In terms of ability and fitness he is more than good enough to be our impact sub striker however I can only guess that his salary is higher than what we are willing to pay for that. Anderson probably wouldn’t get paid half of what ALF is on.

It’s a shame because I would definitely like to have him for another year.

I have only watched Livi play against Hibs this season but think we need to be aiming higher. Your only ever a few injuries away form a squad player becoming a starter and from what I know of Anderson he’s not good enough to lead the charge for 3rd. A fully fit ALF is.

ALF was quality but is 38 later this year. That's too old and another injury is probably round the corner.
Has only managed 956 league minutes this season which is equivalent to less than 11 whole games.
Suspect he is on something like £6k a week so £300k for the season. Poor value.

Far better keeping Paul Hanlon for another year.

[Silky]

ALF was quality but is 38 later this year. That's too old and another injury is probably round the corner.
Has only managed 956 minutes this season which is equivalent to less than 11 whole games.
Suspect he was on something like £6k a week so £300k for the season. Poor value.

I'd hazard a guess that Vente and, possibly Levitt have potentially been poorer value!

[B.H.F.C]

:agree:

In 4 or 5 years time folk will bang on about how we never replaced ALF. The guys played 29 games, got 5 goals and 2 assists. I don't think we'll miss him at all.

His record in the league was pretty decent when you consider a lot of his appearances were off the bench late on in games. He played under a thousand minutes. Vente got the same number of league goals in about double the time.

No issue with letting Le Fondre go though, thought he offered about as much as he was ever likely to in his time here. We badly need a couple of strikers this summer.

[PHeffernan]

I'd hazard a guess that Vente and, possibly Levitt have potentially been poorer value!

Vente, aged 25, managed 1947 mostly uneventful league minutes and
Levitt, aged 23, managed 1372 league minutes including a catastrophic minute against St Johnstone

Not a lot of return on £1 million to date

[JohnM1875]

Vente, aged 25, managed 1947 mostly uneventful league minutes and
Levitt, aged 23, managed 1372 league minutes including a catastrophic minute against St Johnstone

Not a lot of return on £1 million to date

Awful return. Makes it even more frustrating that, to me at least, both signings made complete sense and I was buzzing about both.

[Iain G]

I’ve thought that Boyle was looking like his best days had gone until the last month or so. I’ve been pleasantly surprised that he seems to found a bit more pace from somewhere. I think people not being bothered if he stays or goes should be careful what they wish for.

I also didn’t appreciate it was because of players like Martin Boyle that we ended up in the bottom six. Thats a new one for me.

Swapping Boyle for Murray would defo have us bottom 6 was my point!

[Smartie]

His record in the league was pretty decent when you consider a lot of his appearances were off the bench late on in games. He played under a thousand minutes. Vente got the same number of league goals in about double the time.

No issue with letting Le Fondre go though, thought he offered about as much as he was ever likely to in his time here. We badly need a couple of strikers this summer.

I liked Le Fondre.

He’s about as good a “reliable man off the bench” type as you’re going to get and at his stage in his career, likely to be fairly happy about it.

I probably had greater issues with all of our forwards bar Maolida this season.

[B.H.F.C]

I liked Le Fondre.

He’s about as good a “reliable man off the bench” type as you’re going to get and at his stage in his career, likely to be fairly happy about it.

I probably had greater issues with all of our forwards bar Maolida this season.

Agree with this. Le Fondre as a squad player is/was decent. Problem is that we went most of the season without a good, consistent centre forward.

[AFCBfan]

It's early days and there will be so many comings and goings this summer I can't tell you who might be available but if you get linked to one of ours, I'll come by and share what I know.

If you need a keeper then Will Dennis seems the obvious link.

How did things go in the end with Marcondes and Moriah-Welsh? Will you try and sign Marcondes when he's out of contract?

[AlbertK86]

It's early days and there will be so many comings and goings this summer I can't tell you who might be available but if you get linked to one of ours, I'll come by and share what I know.

If you need a keeper then Will Dennis seems the obvious link.

How did things go in the end with Marcondes and Moriah-Welsh? Will you try and sign Marcondes when he's out of contract?

Cheers mate


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Unseen work]

Myziane now posting his goodbye

“A very rewarding season, despite the ups and downs.

Forever grateful for the welcome and love I received here.

Thanks for everything! @hibernian football club”

Youan now commenting “they won’t see a duo like this again”

[Smartie]

It's early days and there will be so many comings and goings this summer I can't tell you who might be available but if you get linked to one of ours, I'll come by and share what I know.

If you need a keeper then Will Dennis seems the obvious link.

How did things go in the end with Marcondes and Moriah-Welsh? Will you try and sign Marcondes when he's out of contract?

I'd be surprised if we try to sign Marcondes. Obviously a good player but faded as the team's performance level dropped off a cliff. He'd be looking for a significant wage, possibly more than we could afford at the best of times so a permanent move for him looks unlikely.

Moriah-Welsh started well and was playing regularly in a team that had looked improved after some arrivals in January. He got injured, missed a few games then came back into a struggling side. I think most fans rate him though and he seems to be generally forgiven for any role he may have played in the downturn in performance. He's done a few nice bits and pieces off the field for fans which reflect well on him. There was a point where I was of the opinion that he was possibly the only person I 100% wanted to be around next season, that was maybe harsh but I do think he brought a fair bit of what we'd previously lacked when he came in and I'm definitely looking to see him be a big part of our play and hopefully improved form next season.

[04Sauzee]

Youan now commenting “they won’t see a duo like this again”

When did Youan remove all his Hibs content from Instagram?

[Ozyhibby]

Henderson is a different type of midfielder from all the others we have and had a good season on loan in the Belgian 2nd tier scoring 7 goals in 31 games.
I've watched highlights of all the games he played and at 24 he could now be ready to break through at Hibs.

Spare me. Sick of watching non tackling Hibs midfielders.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Paulie Walnuts]

It's early days and there will be so many comings and goings this summer I can't tell you who might be available but if you get linked to one of ours, I'll come by and share what I know.

If you need a keeper then Will Dennis seems the obvious link.

How did things go in the end with Marcondes and Moriah-Welsh? Will you try and sign Marcondes when he's out of contract?

Marcondes was a massive disappointment. Didn’t impact games nearly enough and we looked a better team without him in it.

NMW had a couple of good games but not a lot more to write home about than that. Struggled to get back into the side after an injury.

[PHeffernan]

Awful return. Makes it even more frustrating that, to me at least, both signings made complete sense and I was buzzing about both.

I had concerns about Vente after watching him in youtube clips playing in one man and his dug attended games but thought Levitt was a great signing at circa £300k. What shocked me about Levitt was how slow he is. Hadn't seen it mentioned.
However, I'm hopeful both players will improve next season with a new manager who plays to our players strengths and weaknesses.

[JohnM1875]

When did Youan remove all his Hibs content from Instagram?

Gutted if he's away.

[Hibiza]

Im just confused (wouldn't be hard ) , disallousioned and generally p***ed off

[Hibiza]

The thought of losing Boyle, Youan, Maolida and Marcondes in the same window is terrifying.

Even though I thought Marcondes was pretty poor overall.
Goodbye and good luck to all .

[PHeffernan]

It's early days and there will be so many comings and goings this summer I can't tell you who might be available but if you get linked to one of ours, I'll come by and share what I know.

If you need a keeper then Will Dennis seems the obvious link.

How did things go in the end with Marcondes and Moriah-Welsh? Will you try and sign Marcondes when he's out of contract?

Marcondes was mostly icing and very little cake. Looked like what he is, a Championship player coming back after a long injury. Caveat is that almost every Hibs player struggled with the managers playing style especially the flair players and defenders. I believe Marcondes will return to Denmark this summer unless he can get a Championship club to pay him circa £10k a week.

Moriah-Welsh is a young guy doing his best and that will buy him time with the supporters. As someone else said he has also made an effort off the pitch with some good engagement with fans groups. He's currently no better than the midfielders we have but has just turned 22 so has time on his side and a good attitude.

I expect Dennis and Bevan plus one more will arrive from Bournemouth this summer.

[Hibiza]

Spare me. Sick of watching non tackling Hibs midfielders.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yup , there all mostly " show ponies" ,hate being Club/ team critical but its only Imho the truth.

[number9dream]

Not been impressed by Dennis at Killie, although McInnes was singing his praises and saying he'd like him back.
Mitov has been the stand out keeper in this division at our price range.

[04Sauzee]

Not been impressed by Dennis at Killie, although McInnes was singing his praises and saying he'd like him back.
Mitov has been the stand out keeper in this division at our price range.

How much are St J wanting for Mitov? Is it just a year he has left on his contract.

Stats for Dennis look decent

https://i.ibb.co/h9Stzzx/Screenshot-20240520-203331.png (https://ibb.co/6wkfCCc)

[Crab apple]

Youan now commenting “they won’t see a duo like this again”

Both heading to France I think.

[Dublin07]

Not been impressed by Dennis at Killie, although McInnes was singing his praises and saying he'd like him back.
Mitov has been the stand out keeper in this division at our price range.

Dennis has the best save percentage in the league. Mitov is second and butland 3rd. Also played more games against better teams than mitov.
I think both are decent but mitov has not been the standout keeper although he has been brilliant against us.

[Donegal Hibby]

We've still got Jair though :duck:

[SteveHFC]

Joel Nouble and Bruce Anderson leaving Livi.

[JohnM1875]

Joel Nouble and Bruce Anderson leaving Livi.

And Shinnie.

I know it's a close away day, but I really hope they don't get back up next season. Nothing against the club at all, but that pitch is horrific.

[bingo70]

And Shinnie.

I know it's a close away day, but I really hope they don't get back up next season. Nothing against the club at all, but that pitch is horrific.

There’s a vote going to take place to ban astro pitches anyway so might not be an issue.

[Lago]

We've still got Jair though :duck:
Naughty :greengrin

[JohnM1875]

There’s a vote going to take place to ban astro pitches anyway so might not be an issue.

I know it's likely that the vote will pass, but it is Scottish football, anything can happen.

[McGruber]

Gutted if he's away.

Yeah, me too

[SHODAN]

Joel Nouble and Bruce Anderson leaving Livi.

Apparently Nouble only scored once in the league this season, against Motherwell - could have sworn he got one against us!

[LaMotta]

His record in the league was pretty decent when you consider a lot of his appearances were off the bench late on in games. He played under a thousand minutes. Vente got the same number of league goals in about double the time.

No issue with letting Le Fondre go though, thought he offered about as much as he was ever likely to in his time here. We badly need a couple of strikers this summer.


I liked Le Fondre.

He’s about as good a “reliable man off the bench” type as you’re going to get and at his stage in his career, likely to be fairly happy about it.

I probably had greater issues with all of our forwards bar Maolida this season.

:agree::agree: His good performances were very good. That touch to set up Vente v Luzern was as good a bit of skill as I've seen at Easter Road for sometime Aberdeen away and Livvy at home he was tremendous during his time on the pitch. Obviously he didn't play enough minutes to make as big an impact as we all would have liked.

I dont think anyone has ever suggested he was the long term answer. If anything though I think people have been underrating him rather than overrating him as has been suggested. Maolida apart and Youan for 2 minutes at Tynie, Alf was the only player that got me a wee bit excited this season.

[JammyDoidger]

When did Youan remove all his Hibs content from Instagram?

Bit childish that, glad if he's away tbh, not someone I'd want in the trenches, we need men, not boys.

[Rumble de Thump]

Bit childish that, glad if he's away tbh, not someone I'd want in the trenches, we need men, not boys.

He's done nothing wrong.

[easty]

Bit childish that, glad if he's away tbh, not someone I'd want in the trenches, we need men, not boys.

What's he done wrong? Deleted some photos? His instagram biography has a link to Hibs page, and the only post on his account right now is a photoshoot from Hibs Quarterly last year.

What's childish?

[JJP]

It doesn't sound like Maolida will be back. I didn't expect he would be either unless he was really struggling for options. He doesn't have anything left to prove here. Came in and did very well in a struggling side. Will be sad to see Youan and Boyle go as well if the rumours are true. I know people are looking for an overhaul of the squad this summer but I would be happy to see those efforts concentrated on the defence and trying to retain as much of our attacking talent as we can. We scored enough goals to achieve our targets this season it's just that we couldn't score enough to make up for our defensive frailties.

[thebausburst]

Greg Docherty released, we should be all over that manager or not.

[J-C]

It doesn't sound like Maolida will be back. I didn't expect he would be either unless he was really struggling for options. He doesn't have anything left to prove here. Came in and did very well in a struggling side. Will be sad to see Youan and Boyle go as well if the rumours are true. I know people are looking for an overhaul of the squad this summer but I would be happy to see those efforts concentrated on the defence and trying to retain as much of our attacking talent as we can. We scored enough goals to achieve our targets this season it's just that we couldn't score enough to make up for our defensive frailties.

Thanked Hibs and then spoke of playing at a high level club, that'll not be us then.

[BILLYHIBS]

:agree::agree: His good performances were very good. That touch to set up Vente v Luzern was as good a bit of skill as I've seen at Easter Road for sometime Aberdeen away and Livvy at home he was tremendous during his time on the pitch. Obviously he didn't play enough minutes to make as big an impact as we all would have liked.

I dont think anyone has ever suggested he was the long term answer. If anything though I think people have been underrating him rather than overrating him as has been suggested. Maolida apart and Youan for 2 minutes at Tynie, Alf was the only player that got me a wee bit excited this season.

Fox in the box experienced striker knew the ropes did more in his cameo’s than Vente offered in most matches it was like night and day imho

Should have signed him 10 years ago if doable at the time 😀

[Paul1642]

Greg Docherty released, we should be all over that manager or not.

Absolutely. Only 27 so could get a good few years out of him too.

[ruthven_raiders]

Fox in the box experienced striker knew the ropes did more in his cameo’s than Vente offered in most matches it was like night and day imho

Should have signed him 10 years ago if doable at the time 😀

ALF was mentioned for years that he would be signing, in a joking way, pity, imagine him ten years ago, he'd be over a 100 goals by now!

[EGL2000]

Any indication on when we will release the squad list. Saying who's leaving, who's staying, available for transfer etc. see a number of other teams have already announced there's.

[jacomo]

Absolutely. Only 27 so could get a good few years out of him too.


Only if he is motivated and wants to play for us.

[easty]

Only if he is motivated and wants to play for us.

That applies to any new signing

[jacomo]

That applies to any new signing


Indeed - but particularly to those who have already played for us and showed limited enthusiasm for the club last time around.

[Paulie Walnuts]

Indeed - but particularly to those who have already played for us and showed limited enthusiasm for the club last time around.

Did he? :confused: scoring 3 goals and having 5 assists in 8 games from centre midfield doesn’t exactly scream ‘limited enthusiasm’ to me.

[Hibernian Verse]

Did he? :confused: scoring 3 goals and having 5 assists in 8 games from centre midfield doesn’t exactly scream ‘limited enthusiasm’ to me.

The rewriting of Docherty's time at Hibs is wild. You'll not get far offering stats up, they don't wash on .net :wink:

[JimBHibees]

Only if he is motivated and wants to play for us.

Why wouldn’t he be?

[McD]

The rewriting of Docherty's time at Hibs is wild. You'll not get far offering stats up, they don't wash on .net :wink:


:agree:

The guy has been retconned into some kind of wage thief, despite his positive stats and play, because he was poor on 1 match (against hearts) along with many of his teammates, because he chose to go down south when he left us/rangers, and because he didn’t kiss the badge or proclaim ever dying loyalty to Hibs.

[JimBHibees]

:agree:

The guy has been retconned into some kind of wage thief, despite his positive stats and play, because he was poor on 1 match (against hearts) along with many of his teammates, because he chose to go down south when he left us/rangers, and because he didn’t kiss the badge or proclaim ever dying loyalty to Hibs.

Agree he was decent when with us. Would definitely be happy if he returned

[Paulie Walnuts]

The rewriting of Docherty's time at Hibs is wild. You'll not get far offering stats up, they don't wash on .net :wink:

:agree:

Although he was only here a short time I genuinely think he’s the closest thing we’ve had to a John McGinn replacement. And nobody else even comes close.

[J-C]

Docherty as everyone has said had a stinker against Hearts but the whole team did. He went to English Championship for a lot more money and a higher quality of football, if he's motivated enough and wages aren't too daft, then he's the type we should be looking at.

[McD]

:agree:

Although he was only here a short time I genuinely think he’s the closest thing we’ve had to a John McGinn replacement. And nobody else even comes close.



I agree, had that box-to-box drive, carrying the ball up the pitch, liked a tackle, drove the team forward

[Unseen work]

Will Fish now posting his goodbye message

https://x.com/_wfish/status/1792887121264423187?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

[bingo70]

Will Fish now posting his goodbye message

https://x.com/_wfish/status/1792887121264423187?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

Fair play to him, nice message however I’m pleased he’s away, vastly over rated defender imo.

Poor mans Darren Dodds.

[Since452]

Will Fish now posting his goodbye message

https://x.com/_wfish/status/1792887121264423187?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

Sure his time here will stand him in good stead. Good luck to him.

[blackpoolhibs]

Fair play to him, nice message however I’m pleased he’s away, vastly over rated defender imo.

Poor mans Darren Dodds.

I'm glad he's gone too, although i do like him, he's another inconsistant player who will probably get better but he's not worth the money yet that he would probably cost.

Our league needs two central defenders who are no nonsence defenders, players who know how to defend first, and give the ball to players who are better at creating.

I'm convinced we need two full backs and two central defenders, as none of what we have now are that good.

[easty]

Fair play to him, nice message however I’m pleased he’s away, vastly over rated defender imo.

Poor mans Darren Dodds.

I think that's harsh. Definite potential there, he was only 21 in Feb. I doubt playing in a side not set up to defend well at all, and alongside Rocky the majority of the season, did him much good development wise.

I don't think he'll ever be a top level centre half, but I wouldn't be in the slightest bit surprised to see him being a steady English Championship player. Maybe have a couple seasons in Prem with a bottom of the table side.

[badabing67]

Will Fish now posting his goodbye message

https://x.com/_wfish/status/1792887121264423187?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw


Wow did you scroll down a bit and see that Rijeka fan...... Scary or what.

[Blaster]

A bit harsh some of the comments on Fish. He needed some proper experience beside him due to his age and got Rocky! Best wishes Will

[easty]

Wow did you scroll down a bit and see that Rijeka fan...... Scary or what.

I can't see what you're talking about? I don't see any Rijeka fan??

[Paul1642]

Gutted to see both Fish and Molida posting goof by messages. Would have liked us to sign both.

[badabing67]

I can't see what you're talking about? I don't see any Rijeka fan??


It looks like the thread has changed but this post was further down

(2) Hooligans.cz Official on X: "19.05.2024🇭🇷Armada Rijeka fan on match Osijek - Rijeka https://t.co/Fjy3xrlEmQ (https://x.com/hooliganscz1999/status/1792654944102727946) https://t.co/YnV8KYP666" / X

[Paulie Walnuts]

I see Celtic are apparently wanting £50m for Matt O’Reilly with Brighton interested.

[Unseen work]

I see Celtic are apparently wanting £50m for Matt O’Reilly with Brighton interested.

50😂

[Brightside]

:agree:

Although he was only here a short time I genuinely think he’s the closest thing we’ve had to a John McGinn replacement. And nobody else even comes close.

Him and Allan Campbell would be unreal in our team.

[The Modfather]

Him and Allan Campbell would be unreal in our team.

How realistic it is I don’t know, but would love to see a midfield of NMW, Docherty & Campbell next season. With Amos & Newell as backup.

[JohnM1875]

50😂

Totally, not a chance they’ll get that. Reckon they'll get about £20m for him though. Unbelievable money. Add that to the Champions League money and they really should be steamrollering every team in the league.

[FifeHibs]

How realistic it is I don’t know, but would love to see a midfield of NMW, Docherty & Campbell next season. With Amos & Newell as backup.

Docherty and Campbell would be good, personally I don’t really see much in NMW (hopefully I’m wrong).Amos is a worry though been training with Hibs since November, think his injuries are mounting up now.

[JohnM1875]

Docherty and Campbell would be good, personally I don’t really see much in NMW (hopefully I’m wrong).Amos is a worry though been training with Hibs since November, think his injuries are mounting up now.

Amos has been back in full training a good wee while now. Just don't think we’re rushing anything with him. If he stays fit and gets a full pre-season I think he'll be our best midfielder next season.

Really like NMW as well. Full of energy and covers every blade of grass. His technical game should improve the more he plays as well.

[Since452]

Docherty and Campbell would be good, personally I don’t really see much in NMW (hopefully I’m wrong).Amos is a worry though been training with Hibs since November, think his injuries are mounting up now.

I just don't see Amos playing much football with Hibs. Seen this movie before.

[Lago]

Totally, not a chance they’ll get that. Reckon they'll get about £20m for him though. Unbelievable money. Add that to the Champions League money and they really should be steamrollering every team in the league.
They will

[FifeHibs]

Amos has been back in full training a good wee while now. Just don't think we’re rushing anything with him. If he stays fit and gets a full pre-season I think he'll be our best midfielder next season.

Really like NMW as well. Full of energy and covers every blade of grass. His technical game should improve the more he plays as well.

Fingers crossed his is, although he done a full preseason last summer with QPR and has been training with us since November.

should be an interesting summer whatever happens 🤣

[Joe6-2]

It looks like the thread has changed but this post was further down

(2) Hooligans.cz Official on X: "19.05.2024🇭🇷Armada Rijeka fan on match Osijek - Rijeka https://t.co/Fjy3xrlEmQ (https://x.com/hooliganscz1999/status/1792654944102727946) https://t.co/YnV8KYP666" / X

🤢

[Hibernian Verse]

Totally, not a chance they’ll get that. Reckon they'll get about £20m for him though. Unbelievable money. Add that to the Champions League money and they really should be steamrollering every team in the league.

The thing with O'Riley is that he qualifies as home grown for EPL teams so they will get over £20m for him no bother IMO.

[JohnM1875]

The thing with O'Riley is that he qualifies as home grown for EPL teams so they will get over £20m for him no bother IMO.

Hope not.

Honestly don't think his game suits the English Premier League. Chat of Atletico Madrid and Inter Milan being interested. Think Italy would be a good fit.

[04Sauzee]

Liam Kelly back to The Rangers

[Heisenberg]

Liam Kelly back to The Rangers

He’s been horrendous for a while now. What a move for him though, second/third choice on likely a couple thousand a week.

[Smartie]

Was he not set to move to Celtic?

Have Celtic not lined up someone from the Scottish league to join them as a sort of back up GK?

[J-C]

Fish seemed a likeable lad but similar to Levitt, just because you're at Man U it doesn't guarantee you're top notch, he leaves just the same as he came without really advancing as a CH, bottom Championship player.

[badabing67]

Was he not set to move to Celtic?

Have Celtic not lined up someone from the Scottish league to join them as a sort of back up GK?


Were they not linked with the goalkeeper from Burnley

[badabing67]

Brandon Barker has been released from Morecombe wonder if Lenny will take him to Rapid for another reunion.

[Paul1642]

Fish seemed a likeable lad but similar to Levitt, just because you're at Man U it doesn't guarantee you're top notch, he leaves just the same as he came without really advancing as a CH, bottom Championship player.

The difference with Fish is that he has shown he can do it. He was great for us 22/23 season. I’m not really sure what got into him last year but I would still want him to sign if the option was there.

[badabing67]

The difference with Fish is that he has shown he can do it. He was great for us 22/23 season. I’m not really sure what got into him last year but I would still want him to sign if the option was there.


He never got a chance to play in a settled defence this season.

On his right he has played along side Allan Delferriere, Rory Whittaker, Lewis Miller, Keyano Megwa and Chris Cadden and on his left he has played alongside Rocky, Hanlon, Triantis and Obita. Dunno if I have missed any.

[Hibiza]

Firstly ,probably best to concentrate on getting rid of a forest of " dead wood " .

[Smartie]

He never got a chance to play in a settled defence this season.

On his right he has played along side Allan Delferriere, Rory Whittaker, Lewis Miller, Keyano Megwa and Chris Cadden and on his left he has played alongside Rocky, Hanlon, Triantis and Obita. Dunno if I have missed any.

Possibly had Lewis Stevenson on his right for a short spell at the end of a game, I forget which.

[badabing67]

Possibly had Lewis Stevenson on his right for a short spell at the end of a game, I forget which.


I think you are right that did happen, can't remember which game either. But that amount of player turnover in the defence is absolutely shocking.

[500miles]

The difference with Fish is that he has shown he can do it. He was great for us 22/23 season. I’m not really sure what got into him last year but I would still want him to sign if the option was there.

He's also a centre half that just turned 21 a couple of months ago. Mistakes are key to development.

[Smartie]

He's also a centre half that just turned 21 a couple of months ago. Mistakes are key to development.

Probably a more prolonged downturn in form was inevitable at some point too - and part of a learning process.

"The path to success is never a straight line..."

An argument could be made that we can only really afford to have a certain number of young and inconsistent (or older and inconsistent) players learning their trade with us at any given time, and we've lately had a fair few.

[04Sauzee]

Young Robbie Hamilton said his goodbyes also.

[Iain G]

He's also a centre half that just turned 21 a couple of months ago. Mistakes are key to development.

Needs an experienced and vocal partner playing along side him, had that last year and not so much this year.

[JimBHibees]

Possibly had Lewis Stevenson on his right for a short spell at the end of a game, I forget which.

Motherwell at new year I think

[Unseen work]

Jamie McCart available for transfer from Rotherham, will we revisit him?

One I’d 100% take as out of contract at Rotherham is Jamie Lindsay. Box to mix midfielder with loads of energy.

[Vault Boy]

Jamie McCart available for transfer from Rotherham, will we revisit him?

One I’d 100% take as out of contract at Rotherham is Jamie Lindsay. Box to mix midfielder with loads of energy.

Owners pulled the plug on a deal for McCart previously so I’d be surprised if we do

[Gaffer1875]

Steven Caulker one year deal?

Stated on sacked in the morning Malky Mackay was his best manager and he has a great relationship with him [emoji102]

Impressive career, only 32, currently player manager of Malaga city and still playing for Sierra Leone.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JohnM1875]

Steven Caulker one year deal?

Stated on sacked in the morning Malky Mackay was his best manager and he has a great relationship with him [emoji102]

Impressive career, only 32, currently player manager of Malaga city and still playing for Sierra Leone.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It would be very Hibs, after billionaire investment and appointing a new sporting director, that our first summer signing is a 32 year old ex player of the SD, currently player managing in the Spanish fifth tier.

[Gaffer1875]

It would be very Hibs, after billionaire investment and appointing a new sporting director, that our first summer signing is a 32 year old ex player of the SD, currently player managing in the Spanish fifth tier.

I wouldn’t be against a one year deal but I agree with you, not sure how it would land with the Twitter warriors!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Iain G]

I wouldn’t be against a one year deal but I agree with you, not sure how it would land with the Twitter warriors!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Malcolm appoints his mate Malky, Malky signs his mate Stephen... 😁

[Greencore]

Steven Caulker one year deal?

Stated on sacked in the morning Malky Mackay was his best manager and he has a great relationship with him [emoji102]

Impressive career, only 32, currently player manager of Malaga city and still playing for Sierra Leone.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Aim higher.

[easty]

It would be very Hibs, after billionaire investment and appointing a new sporting director, that our first summer signing is a 32 year old ex player of the SD, currently player managing in the Spanish fifth tier.

It is the fifth tier, but even then it's regional, so split into 18 different regions. Caulkers side sitting 15th in the table of region 9.

I dunno what the equivalent in Scotland would be...coming third in the Thursday night league at the Pitz?

Safe to say I think Caulker is not an option :greengrin

[04Sauzee]

McCowan and Armstrong both in their final year of their contracts. Both of them good ages. I wonder what kind of combined fee they would go for. That's if the likes of Armstrong wanted to give up European football this season

[K-Zazu]

McCowan and Armstrong both in their final year of their contracts. Both of them good ages. I wonder what kind of combined fee they would go for. That's if the likes of Armstrong wanted to give up European football this season

Giving up a couple of qualifying rounds maybe even one.

[JimBHibees]

It is the fifth tier, but even then it's regional, so split into 18 different regions. Caulkers side sitting 15th in the table of region 9.

I dunno what the equivalent in Scotland would be...coming third in the Thursday night league at the Pitz?

Safe to say I think Caulker is not an option :greengrin

:faf:

[we are hibs]

Baccus signs for Mansfield

Sent from my SM-A405FN using Tapatalk

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

ALF confirmed he's away now

https://www.instagram.com/p/C7RSryLNB2w/?igsh=b3M3dW04MWR4NTh1

[.Sean.]

Le Fondre complaining on Instagram about how certain people treated him? :confused:

[JohnM1875]

Le Fondre complaining on Instagram about how certain people treated him? :confused:

"Disappointed with how the season panned out and how certain people treated me but that’s for another day"

Aye, weird one that right enough. Just guessing but maybe it's with the club wanting to bring the age profile down and we've made him clear about that? Could be anything though I suppose.

[Hiber-nation]

Le Fondre complaining on Instagram about how certain people treated him? :confused:

And not LJ, BM or NM....

[Ronniekirk]

So the most recent press release indicates we are t prepared to pay compensation to get the right candidate in as Head Coach .If true we are limiting our options from the outset
All the money wasted over the last few years on paying off management teams and speculating on players, who in the main have made us no money ,but are getting better wages than we have previously paid
It’s all led to nothing but Debt being incurred
it remains to be seen who we appoint and who we recruit and how our tie in with The Black Knoghts works in practice
Interesting few months ahead

[Smartie]

And not LJ, BM or NM....

That's the intriguing bit, isn't it?

You'd think it would be one of them he'd have a beef with if he'd felt he'd been treated badly.

If not them... then who?



I liked ALF and I'm disappointed to see him go. Even with his advancing years his brain and touch meant he still has a lot to offer, I wish him well for the future

[Unseen work]

Weird weird post from ALF

Surely not just spitting the dummy out because he never got a new contract?

[LaMotta]

Could be Sergio Raimundo given some of the rumours about players not liking him. Or Kensell if there was maybe some promise of a contract extension that wasn't followed through?


Strange comments about weirdos in the dressing room too.

[B.H.F.C]

That's the intriguing bit, isn't it?

You'd think it would be one of them he'd have a beef with if he'd felt he'd been treated badly.

If not them... then who?

Got to be further up the tree. Maybe thought he was getting a contract and it got pulled or something. Could be anything I suppose.

[bingo70]

"Disappointed with how the season panned out and how certain people treated me but that’s for another day"

Aye, weird one that right enough. Just guessing but maybe it's with the club wanting to bring the age profile down and we've made him clear about that? Could be anything though I suppose.

Potentially ties in with people not getting told they were being released and contracts just allowed to run down with no conversation had.

I was told Hanlon and Stevenson had a chat in January when they were told what would likely happen in the summer but would re-visit it closer ti the end of the season. The next Hanlon and Stevenson heard was from the media guy telling them there would be a statement the following day.

If you look at the wording in one of Montgomery’s last press conference, he pretty much said as much as well.

[we are hibs]

Could be Sergio Raimundo given some of the rumours about players not liking him. Or Kensell if there was maybe some promise of a contract extension that wasn't followed through?


Strange comments about weirdos in the dressing room too.Not that strange. Was clearly meant as a joke.

Sent from my SM-A405FN using Tapatalk

[JimBHibees]

Could be Sergio Raimundo given some of the rumours about players not liking him. Or Kensell if there was maybe some promise of a contract extension that wasn't followed through?


Strange comments about weirdos in the dressing room too.

Think weirdos comment was a joke. Assume possible promise of an extension then changed who knows total guess work.

[Ronniekirk]

Le Fondre complaining on Instagram about how certain people treated him? :confused:
Without knowing the context and how he was treated it’s difficult to comment
But his talent and ability to bring others into play was never in question

[LaMotta]

Not that strange. Was clearly meant as a joke.

Sent from my SM-A405FN using Tapatalk

Calling folk weirdos isnt a great joke, it comes across as more of a dig at people's characters. Not a great thing to put in an otherwise decent farewell message IMO.

[Unseen work]

Calling folk weirdos isnt a great joke, it comes across as more of a dig at people's characters. Not a great thing to put in an otherwise decent farewell message IMO.

I took the weirdos as a jokey comment and not serious at all.

[Broken Gnome]

Calling folk weirdos isnt a great joke, it comes across as more of a dig at people's characters. Not a great thing to put in an otherwise decent farewell message IMO.

Harry McKirdy wouldn't bat an eyelid at being called a weirdo surely. Badge of honour.

[truehibernian]

Good player ALF but give me Simon Murray any day of the week before him (extending contract) - more goals, more energy, better end product, costs less, and 5 years younger.

[Brightside]

Calling folk weirdos isnt a great joke, it comes across as more of a dig at people's characters. Not a great thing to put in an otherwise decent farewell message IMO.

Not really - I imagine most would call Mckirdy a weirdo.

[raeburnhibs]

Weird weird post from ALF

Surely not just spitting the dummy out because he never got a new contract?

It really, really isn't. Quite measured actually. Says his thanks to the people who signed him and managed him. Says his goodbyes to the dressing room and the fans. Suggests he believes someone regarding an unstated issue treated him poorly, that is his prerogative, especially as we don't know the facts. Maybe a certain tanned individual with a wee beard made some promises and then backtracked....the weirdo thing is clearly a joke

[NC1875]

Calling folk weirdos isnt a great joke, it comes across as more of a dig at people's characters. Not a great thing to put in an otherwise decent farewell message IMO.

I think the laughing emoji kinda gives it away.

[Unseen work]

It really, really isn't. Quite measured actually. Says his thanks to the people who signed him and managed him. Says his goodbyes to the dressing room and the fans. Suggests he believes someone regarding an unstated issue treated him poorly, that is his prerogative, especially as we don't know the facts. Maybe a certain tanned individual with a wee beard made some promises and then backtracked....the weirdo thing is clearly a joke

I know the weirdo bit is a joke.

I just think he knows how the fans feel about the club right now and he’s adding to it with very vague comments without any context.

Rumours will spread from this and be directed, as you’ve already done, at Kensell.

For all we know it could just be he wasn’t offered a new contract.

[LaMotta]

I think the laughing emoji kinda gives it away.


Not really - I imagine most would call Mckirdy a weirdo.


Harry McKirdy wouldn't bat an eyelid at being called a weirdo surely. Badge of honour.

Yeah I'm sure he loves being called a weirdo for being a bit different.

[Brightside]

Yeah I'm sure he loves being called a weirdo for being a bit different.

He's probably not that precious.

[Since452]

Hamilton Accies trying to sign Docherty