Summer 2020-21 transfer thread

[erin go bragh]

Lazio bid €100k for Hickey as he is a championship player and into his last year of his contract :cb
Thats £87k 😂😂 be funny if they accepted it 😃😃

[Ozyhibby]

Lazio bid €100k for Hickey as he is a championship player and into his last year of his contract :cb
Thats £87k [emoji23][emoji23] be funny if they accepted it [emoji2][emoji2]

Especially as they have to give 33% to Celtic.[emoji23]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[The Modfather]

Lazio bid €100k for Hickey as he is a championship player and into his last year of his contract :cb
Thats £87k 😂😂 be funny if they accepted it 😃😃

Hibs should match the bid. We need a new LB and there’s gems to be found in the lower leagues.

[Heisenberg]

Back in for Ross Stewart at County. Backup for Doidge or we going for two big strikers up top? Article does mention he’s more of a target man.

https://t.co/SByRfNWXLG

[JimBHibees]

Back in for Ross Stewart at County. Backup for Doidge or we going for two big strikers up top? Article does mention he’s more of a target man.

https://t.co/SByRfNWXLG

Suppose also possibility of interest down south for Doidge.

[Ozyhibby]

Back in for Ross Stewart at County. Backup for Doidge or we going for two big strikers up top? Article does mention he’s more of a target man.

https://t.co/SByRfNWXLG

If we have him and Doidge next season then we better get a couple of full backs who can cross a ball. Both excellent in the air.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Clarence]

He would be a decent signing.

[HendoDelivered]

Back in for Ross Stewart at County. Backup for Doidge or we going for two big strikers up top? Article does mention he’s more of a target man.

https://t.co/SByRfNWXLG

Wonder if this means Nisbet is off the cards then.

[Heisenberg]

Wonder if this means Nisbet is off the cards then.

I would imagine so, Ross has worked with Stewart before I think so he may prefer him.

[Robbo6-2]

Nice to see a rumour at least

[jacomo]

I would imagine so, Ross has worked with Stewart before I think so he may prefer him.


I’m not sure another no.9 is what we need. I would prefer a different option up front.

[Callum_62]

If Flo goes we have 1 senior striker with Gullan

We need 2 in

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[we are hibs]

What kind of player is he? Can he play off the left?

[Ozyhibby]

I’m not sure another no.9 is what we need. I would prefer a different option up front.

We need more than one forward. Right now we have Doidge and the untested Gullan. We def need more than that.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Since452]

Lazio bid €100k for Hickey as he is a championship player and into his last year of his contract :cb
Thats £87k 😂😂 be funny if they accepted it 😃😃

And they are due Celtic a percentage of that

[TelaStella]

Personally think Gogic, Dicker and evening Halliday would offer that.

Halliday has already said he can’t stomach the idea of playing against his beloved queen’s 11 and admits he would struggle in a match. Somehow I don’t see that attitude being what we’re looking for or making him any more popular than he already is. Move to America on the cards for him apparently


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[brog]

If we have him and Doidge next season then we better get a couple of full backs who can cross a ball. Both excellent in the air.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm not sure he & Doidge could play together. Far too similar & neither is particularly mobile. Stewart is however only 23, almost 24, so has scope for improvement.

[H18 SFR]

I'm not sure he & Doidge could play together. Far too similar & neither is particularly mobile. Stewart is however only 23, almost 24, so has scope for improvement.

I’d fancy Doidge and Boyle being a good centre forward pair - worth trying.

[Ozyhibby]

I’d fancy Doidge and Boyle being a good centre forward pair - worth trying.

I like Boyle playing on the wing. I think unless he signs a new contract Boyle will be away this summer.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[we are hibs]

Boyle is better out wide. Hes at his best when he has space infront of him to get going. He wont get as much space playing through the middle. We really need a left winger to add some balance. I dont think Horgan is good/consistent enough.

[Billy Whizz]

Dundee Utd interested in Johnny Hayes as well
Must have some budget for next season

[04Sauzee]

Dundee Utd interested in Johnny Hayes as well
Must have some budget for next season

Don't want to be one of the 3 clubs who coukd potentially be relegated 🥴🙄

[Since452]

Dundee Utd interested in Johnny Hayes as well
Must have some budget for next season

I read somewhere they had the 4th biggest budget in Scotland last season

[badabing67]

Dundee Utd interested in Johnny Hayes as well
Must have some budget for next season

I knew they were going to be really competitive in the transfer window. They took a risk to get up running at 130% of there income. If they sell Shankland they could strengthen all areas of their squad. I think they will push into the top 6

[Speedway]

I read somewhere they had the 4th biggest budget in Scotland last season

They appear to be ignoring everything and just spending what they had planned to spend before all this happened.

What could possibly go wrong?

[SMAXXA]

They appear to be ignoring everything and just spending what they had planned to spend before all this happened.

What could possibly go wrong?

Or they could have an acutely better handle over their finances that me or you and know what they can and cannot spend 😂

[Hibs90]

Weird that we are not being linked with Nisbet again. I'd have thought we went straight back in for him if we supposedly wanted him that badly.

[delbert]

Back in for Ross Stewart at County. Backup for Doidge or we going for two big strikers up top? Article does mention he’s more of a target man.

https://t.co/SByRfNWXLG

While we are at it, their captain Marcus Fraser has turned down a new contract, and we badly need some decent new defenders, have to say I would take him before Stewart.

[Billy Whizz]

While we are at it, their captain Marcus Fraser has turned down a new contract, and we badly need some decent new defenders, have to say I would take him before Stewart.

Middlesbrough in for Stewart too

[JohnMcM]

Weird that we are not being linked with Nisbet again. I'd have thought we went straight back in for him if we supposedly wanted him that badly.

D Utd are linked to him and Johnny Hayes. Interesting to see if that happens and if they would line up with those two and Shankland. Potentially good strike force.

[JohnMcM]

Middlesbrough in for Stewart too

Hope he wants to stay in Scotland and develop for another couple of years. We can't compete with their money, or can we?

[MWHIBBIES]

I knew they were going to be really competitive in the transfer window. They took a risk to get up running at 130% of there income. If they sell Shankland they could strengthen all areas of their squad. I think they will push into the top 6

They'll need to sign an entire back 4, 2 central midfielders and a striker to replace Shankland, with money from Shankland (is there actually any rumours of him going anywhere for a good price?)

I cant see them getting anywhere near top 6 but if they signed quality them maybe.

[MWHIBBIES]

Hope he wants to stay in Scotland and develop for another couple of years. We can't compete with their money, or can we?

They'll still be getting prem parachute payments. Not a chance in hell.

[JohnMcM]

They'll still be getting prem parachute payments. Not a chance in hell.

:grr:

[SHODAN]

Middlesbrough in for Stewart too

Ah well. Next!

[SteveHFC]

Would like to see us both go for Nisbet and Stewart.

[badabing67]

They'll need to sign an entire back 4, 2 central midfielders and a striker to replace Shankland, with money from Shankland (is there actually any rumours of him going anywhere for a good price?)

I cant see them getting anywhere near top 6 but if they signed quality them maybe.

Not seen any direct links so far this summer but Stoke were interested/monitoring him in Jan. But there seems to be thinks happening in England. Lyle Taylor at Charlton has refused to play and been linked to Celtic. The old firm have also been linked to Ivan Toney at Peterborough. Barry Fry says he want £15M for him so who knows but if clubs down there start needing strikers there is bound to be interest in Shankland.

[erin go bragh]

Would like to see us both go for Nisbet and Stewart.
The courier has a piece on Dundee Utd and Nisbet . Said this about our bid in Jan .

Hibs were the first club to show their hand in the race for Nisbet, submitting a £350,000 offer plus £150,000 worth of add-ons for him. 😉

[Heisenberg]

The courier has a piece on Dundee Utd and Nisbet . Said this about our bid in Jan .

Hibs were the first club to show their hand in the race for Nisbet, submitting a £350,000 offer plus £150,000 worth of add-ons for him. 😉

If that’s true that’s a big bid by Scottish league standards. Our ability to chuck that kind of money around has probably changed now though.

[Ozyhibby]

If that’s true that’s a big bid by Scottish league standards. Our ability to chuck that kind of money around has probably changed now though.

Dunfermline’s need for cash has probably changed a bit as well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[badabing67]

Dunfermline’s need for cash has probably changed a bit as well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

If Nisbet is still one of our targets we should try our best to get a deal done early as possible but Dunfermline will probably hold out I imagine. Wonder if we are still interested in Mikel Miller

[04Sauzee]

If Nisbet is still one of our targets we should try our best to get a deal done early as possible but Dunfermline will probably hold out I imagine. Wonder if we are still interested in Mikel Miller

I'm not sure why we didn't offer him a pre contract? Maybe we did right enough and he declined but he's now out of contract I belive

Also rumours that we are interested in that winger from down south

[brog]

I'm not sure why we didn't offer him a pre contract? Maybe we did right enough and he declined but he's now out of contract I belive

Also rumours that we are interested in that winger from down south

He has another year on his contract. We wouldn't have been offering £350k for an out of contract player.

[Billy Whizz]

He has another year on his contract. We wouldn't have been offering £350k for an out of contract player.

Think he means Miller, Brog

[04Sauzee]

Think he means Miller, Brog

Sorry I did, apologies if I didn't make that clear

[brog]

Sorry I did, apologies if I didn't make that clear

No probs,I can't understand my own posts sometimes!

[ekhibee]

They'll still be getting prem parachute payments. Not a chance in hell.

Are you sure they still get parachute payments? I thought that only applied to clubs that remained in the Premiership for more than 1 season, in which case they would have got 20% in the third year after relegation. They were only up for 1 season then relegated in 2016/17, so that doesn't apply.

Parachute payments[edit]
Parachute payments are unique to the English game and currently see clubs relegated from the Premier League receive a percentage of the equally shared element of broadcasting rights each Premier League club receives. This percentage drops progressively over a three year period – 55% in the first year, 45% in year two and, if the club was in the Premier League for more than one season before relegation, 20% in the third year. This system was introduced for clubs relegated in 2015/16 onwards, with the previous system having a similar structure but with payments spread over 4 years.[6] If a club is promoted back to the Premier League during the parachute payment period, then it no longer receives parachute payments.

[Speedway]

Or they could have an acutely better handle over their finances that me or you and know what they can and cannot spend 😂

They’ve got form for that, right enough.

[MWHIBBIES]

Are you sure they still get parachute payments? I thought that only applied to clubs that remained in the Premiership for more than 1 season, in which case they would have got 20% in the third year after relegation. They were only up for 1 season then relegated in 2016/17, so that doesn't apply.

Parachute payments[edit]
Parachute payments are unique to the English game and currently see clubs relegated from the Premier League receive a percentage of the equally shared element of broadcasting rights each Premier League club receives. This percentage drops progressively over a three year period – 55% in the first year, 45% in year two and, if the club was in the Premier League for more than one season before relegation, 20% in the third year. This system was introduced for clubs relegated in 2015/16 onwards, with the previous system having a similar structure but with payments spread over 4 years.[6] If a club is promoted back to the Premier League during the parachute payment period, then it no longer receives parachute payments.

Fair enough, didn't know that. Still significantly richer than Hibs, he'll be away to them if they are actually interested.

[Keyser Sauzee]

Not in any way a rumour but I just seen highlights of Ali McCann’s season up at St Johnstone. Looks excellent at winning the ball back and getting them back on the front foot, as well as driving them forward from midfield, attributes that aren’t always appreciated. I didn’t think he was a standout against us at ER this season but certainly impressed me watching that, all be it highlight reels are edited to do that. It reminded me a little of watching John McGinn’s early performances at St Mirren. Could be one to watch over the next year or 2.

[04Sauzee]

Not in any way a rumour but I just seen highlights of Ali McCann’s season up at St Johnstone. Looks excellent at winning the ball back and getting them back on the front foot, as well as driving them forward from midfield, attributes that aren’t always appreciated. I didn’t think he was a standout against us at ER this season but certainly impressed me watching that, all be it highlight reels are edited to do that. It reminded me a little of watching John McGinn’s early performances at St Mirren. Could be one to watch over the next year or 2.

Highly though of and only 20 with 3 years left on his contract. He was picked out a few times on sportscene and agree he's very good

[Keyser Sauzee]

Highly though of and only 20 with 3 years left on his contract. He was picked out a few times on sportscene and agree he's very good

Not surprised to see that length of time left on his contract, he looks a prospect, granted I’m basing my opinion on a minute or 2 video but he looks impressive 😂

[Gmack7]

Not in any way a rumour but I just seen highlights of Ali McCann’s season up at St Johnstone. Looks excellent at winning the ball back and getting them back on the front foot, as well as driving them forward from midfield, attributes that aren’t always appreciated. I didn’t think he was a standout against us at ER this season but certainly impressed me watching that, all be it highlight reels are edited to do that. It reminded me a little of watching John McGinn’s early performances at St Mirren. Could be one to watch over the next year or 2.
I'm sure he's an Edinburgh lad, his brother i think plays for Dunfermline

[Billy Whizz]

Not surprised to see that length of time left on his contract, he looks a prospect, granted I’m basing my opinion on a minute or 2 video but he looks impressive 😂

He’s been playing in the development leagues for a few years
Think he played for Hutchie

[ekhibee]

Fair enough, didn't know that. Still significantly richer than Hibs, he'll be away to them if they are actually interested.

Yeh, you're probably right. I would've had a personal interest though, he used to work beside my wife (before he was a professional footballer obviously lol).

[Ozyhibby]

With 3 years left on his deal we would need to hope St. Johnstone are desperate for cash and that we have some. He looks decent and exactly the type of midfielder we need but can’t see it happening.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[badabing67]

Not in any way a rumour but I just seen highlights of Ali McCann’s season up at St Johnstone. Looks excellent at winning the ball back and getting them back on the front foot, as well as driving them forward from midfield, attributes that aren’t always appreciated. I didn’t think he was a standout against us at ER this season but certainly impressed me watching that, all be it highlight reels are edited to do that. It reminded me a little of watching John McGinn’s early performances at St Mirren. Could be one to watch over the next year or 2.

Where did you see the highlights

[Keyser Sauzee]

Where did you see the highlights

It was on SPFL Facebook page.

[Ozyhibby]

Where did you see the highlights

https://twitter.com/spfl/status/1270304478185611265?s=21


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[badabing67]

If Galantes & Block didn't get released with the others from the development side could they be making the breakthrough this season. They have both been on the fringes for a while now. Galantes is an international & I've not seen him play for us.

[erin go bragh]

If that’s true that’s a big bid by Scottish league standards. Our ability to chuck that kind of money around has probably changed now though.
The report said Utd came in with a better bid for Nisbet but that also was rebuffed 😉

[badabing67]

https://twitter.com/spfl/status/1270304478185611265?s=21


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Cheers

[Keyser Sauzee]

With 3 years left on his deal we would need to hope St. Johnstone are desperate for cash and that we have some. He looks decent and exactly the type of midfielder we need but can’t see it happening.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yeah I can’t see us offering the kind of money St Johnstone would most likely be looking for. He’s scored a few goals last season too, like u say he’s the right kind of midfielder we should be looking to sign.

[04Sauzee]

If Galantes & Block didn't get released with the others from the development side could they be making the breakthrough this season. They have both been on the fringes for a while now. Galantes is an international & I've not seen him play for us.
Haven't seen Galantes play, think he was Lowland League last season? I'd be surprised if he's close to the first team but I'm sure others who have seen more of him woukd have a better idea.

[jacomo]

I’m convinced we will see several development players in the first team next season.

[MWHIBBIES]

If Galantes & Block didn't get released with the others from the development side could they be making the breakthrough this season. They have both been on the fringes for a while now. Galantes is an international & I've not seen him play for us.

Has Galantes even been in a first team squad? He definitely hasn't played for us. Honestly, being an international for the Philippines means very little.

He is supposed to be good but also very small and easily bullied. Doubt he makes a breakthrough this season.

[bingo70]

I’m convinced we will several development players in the first team next season.

I think so too.

I think we’ll sign a few players but won’t be anything like a normal transfer window and there’ll be a bigger reliance than normal on bringing through young players.

[04Sauzee]

I think so too.

I think we’ll sign a few players but won’t be anything like a normal transfer window and there’ll be a bigger reliance than normal on bringing through young players.

I'd love to see some young boys come through but not sure which ones we will see, other than Porteous, Gullan and Murray who else could get game time? Block, Doig? I'm sure there are a couple of gems in our Development squad

[Unseen work]

McCann would be an excellent signing but imo with 3 years left on his deal and on the way up we would be priced out. I also think he’s very similar to Docherty who we will be desperate to get back

Imo the next ones to come through will be Doig and Shanley.

Gullan will be a permanent fixture from now on in the first team, for me Fraser Murray really needs to up his game or he will be off. He’s not an out and out winger and he will never play in the hole ahead of Allan or Mallan. Don’t think he’s good enough defensively to play deeper. Mackie I have been impressed with on several occasions however he’s also had some poor performances, he certainly has the physical attributes and technique however.

Ben Stirling has always impressed me too but never made a competitive first team appearance and is running out of time. Josh Campbell also seemed to be highly rated by Hecky.

Not seen too much of Ross Stewart but think he’s more than your standard target man and is quite direct with his running.

Also think we should try get Greg Stewart from Rangers as I can’t see them wanting to keep him.

[badabing67]

McCann would be an excellent signing but imo with 3 years left on his deal and on the way up we would be priced out. I also think he’s very similar to Docherty who we will be desperate to get back

Imo the next ones to come through will be Doig and Shanley.

Gullan will be a permanent fixture from now on in the first team, for me Fraser Murray really needs to up his game or he will be off. He’s not an out and out winger and he will never play in the hole ahead of Allan or Mallan. Don’t think he’s good enough defensively to play deeper. Mackie I have been impressed with on several occasions however he’s also had some poor performances, he certainly has the physical attributes and technique however.

Ben Stirling has always impressed me too but never made a competitive first team appearance and is running out of time. Josh Campbell also seemed to be highly rated by Hecky.

Not seen too much of Ross Stewart but think he’s more than your standard target man and is quite direct with his running.

Also think we should try get Greg Stewart from Rangers as I can’t see them wanting to keep him.

Don't think Aberdeen would want him back either could be a good reason for that, done well at Killie though

[jacomo]

How about Jack Hodge?

Seemed highly rated when we got him from St Johnstone.

[MacGruber]

How about Jack Hodge?

Seemed highly rated when we got him from St Johnstone.

Was he not released? .. not sure

[04Sauzee]

Was he not released? .. not sure

He was

[Leitherhibs]

McCann would be an excellent signing but imo with 3 years left on his deal and on the way up we would be priced out. I also think he’s very similar to Docherty who we will be desperate to get back

Imo the next ones to come through will be Doig and Shanley.

Gullan will be a permanent fixture from now on in the first team, for me Fraser Murray really needs to up his game or he will be off. He’s not an out and out winger and he will never play in the hole ahead of Allan or Mallan. Don’t think he’s good enough defensively to play deeper. Mackie I have been impressed with on several occasions however he’s also had some poor performances, he certainly has the physical attributes and technique however.

Ben Stirling has always impressed me too but never made a competitive first team appearance and is running out of time. Josh Campbell also seemed to be highly rated by Hecky.

Not seen too much of Ross Stewart but think he’s more than your standard target man and is quite direct with his running.

Also think we should try get Greg Stewart from Rangers as I can’t see them wanting to keep him.

:agree: Pivotal year for Shanley, has to make the step up this season really too.

[Brightside]

If Galantes & Block didn't get released with the others from the development side could they be making the breakthrough this season. They have both been on the fringes for a while now. Galantes is an international & I've not seen him play for us.

Galantes is the classic lightweight player that we seem to produce. Bundles of talent but needs to show that at senior level quickly or he will be another that will move on to lower league. I've not seen anything form Block to suggest he will become a first team regular.

[Callum_62]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.eveningtelegraph.co.uk/fp/dundee-united-ilmari-niskanen-transfer/amp/

According to the cat on twitter we are also keen

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Robbo6-2]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.eveningtelegraph.co.uk/fp/dundee-united-ilmari-niskanen-transfer/amp/

According to the cat on twitter we are also keen

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Here comes the 10 page Cat debate

[PPZPOL]

I really liked the look of Cameron McPherson from St.Mirren, only seen him a couple of times versus us and a couple of live games but liked what I saw. I know nothing about him so he might be rated highly there?

[easty]

Not in any way a rumour but I just seen highlights of Ali McCann’s season up at St Johnstone. Looks excellent at winning the ball back and getting them back on the front foot, as well as driving them forward from midfield, attributes that aren’t always appreciated. I didn’t think he was a standout against us at ER this season but certainly impressed me watching that, all be it highlight reels are edited to do that. It reminded me a little of watching John McGinn’s early performances at St Mirren. Could be one to watch over the next year or 2.

Yeh he’s a good player. With 3 years left on his contract seems unlikely we would get him just now though.

I really like that Allan Campbell at Motherwell. I’m sure I read he’s only got one year left on his contract.

[eastmainsmsh]

The left winger for St mirren is quality

[H18 SFR]

I’m convinced we will see several development players in the first team next season.

I’m sure this will be the same at all clubs apart from Celtic and Rangers.

[Andy74]

I think so too.

I think we’ll sign a few players but won’t be anything like a normal transfer window and there’ll be a bigger reliance than normal on bringing through young players.

I don't think we will see young players in numbers unless they are good enough, as usual. We have a biggish squad already and there's no doubt that a bit of a correction all-round means that there will be a lot of players available. We are in as good a position as any to add some players when required.

[Leitherhibs]

Yeh he’s a good player. With 3 years left on his contract seems unlikely we would get him just now though.

I really like that Allan Campbell at Motherwell. I’m sure I read he’s only got one year left on his contract.

Campbell would be a great signing, he'll go to a club with more wealth than us sadly.

[The Modfather]

Yeh he’s a good player. With 3 years left on his contract seems unlikely we would get him just now though.

I really like that Allan Campbell at Motherwell. I’m sure I read he’s only got one year left on his contract.

Whatever happened to David Turnbull? Has the big injury he suffered taken its toll, or is he still working to get back to where he was? He looked the real deal but never heard his name mentioned since his injury.

Who was the St Mirren midfielder we were apparently after a window of two ago, Maggenis was it? Think he also suffered a season ending injury, but was encouraged he was the kind of ambitious signing we seemed to be looking at.

[brog]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.eveningtelegraph.co.uk/fp/dundee-united-ilmari-niskanen-transfer/amp/

According to the cat on twitter we are also keen

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Remember when Hawrts said we were no longer their rivals? Seems like they finally got that one right & they've been supplanted by Dundee Utd, both in terms of league status & as our main rivals for signings! :greengrin

[Ozyhibby]

Whatever happened to David Turnbull? Has the big injury he suffered taken its toll, or is he still working to get back to where he was? He looked the real deal but never heard his name mentioned since his injury.

Who was the St Mirren midfielder we were apparently after a window of two ago, Maggenis was it? Think he also suffered a season ending injury, but was encouraged he was the kind of ambitious signing we seemed to be looking at.

Just signed a new deal with Motherwell. Sat out last season with injury. Out our price range.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[04Sauzee]

The left winger for St mirren is quality

Ilkay Durmas? Always looked good when I seen him play which wasn't that often but still he looked good

[Stuart93]

Trying to get Gogic in for a trial to win a deal with us

[we are hibs]

Hibs considering offering Gogic a trial.

[HendoDelivered]

Former Hamilton defender Alex Gogic is on Hibs’ radar and he could be offered a chance to win a deal at Easter Road.

Edinburgh Live report Jack Ross wants to take a closer look at the 26-year-old Cypriot after his exit from Accies.

The former Olympiacos man has suitors across Europe but it’s understood he wants to remain in Scotland.

But the player is also keeping a open mind as he maps out his future amid a pandemic.

[04Sauzee]

Good story on him here

https://bensmagazine.wordpress.com/2020/03/12/alex-gogic-the-most-underrated-midfielder-in-the-scottish-premiership/amp/?__twitter_impression=true

[The 90+2]

Trying to get Gogic in for a trial to win a deal with us

Ram the trial get him signed.

[Heisenberg]

Ram the trial get him signed.

I agree. Exactly what we need in midfield to stop teams strolling through us.

[Onceinawhile]

Ram the trial get him signed.

He played 20 odd games in the league this season, how have we not seen him enough?

[MWHIBBIES]

I agree. Exactly what we need in midfield to stop teams strolling through us.

Is it? I don't know much about the guy but Hibs strolled through Hamilton many times in the last 3 years.

[eastmainsmsh]

Ilkay Durmas? Always looked good when I seen him play which wasn't that often but still he looked good

That's him m8

[MWHIBBIES]

He played 20 odd games in the league this season, how have we not seen him enough?

Because it is based on more than that? Does his personality fit with the squad? Has he kept himself fit? Can he play in a more attacking side with more responsilbity on him to move the ball around?

[Stuart93]

Is it? I don't know much about the guy but Hibs strolled through Hamilton many times in the last 3 years.

Quite a poor argument questioning a player because we’ve beat his team a few times over the past few years?

Have a read at this, obviously written by someone who’d have a more valid opinion than the majority of us on this thread. Sounds exactly like the kind of player we’re lacking

https://bensmagazine.wordpress.com/2020/03/12/alex-gogic-the-most-underrated-midfielder-in-the-scottish-premiership/amp/?__twitter_impression=true

[tonyrougier123]

Anybody take jason holt?decent energy can get goals from midfield,jambo and sevco links but says he's open to anything.

[Heisenberg]

Quite a poor argument questioning a player because we’ve beat his team a few times over the past few years?

Have a read at this, obviously written by someone who’d have a more valid opinion than the majority of us on this thread

https://bensmagazine.wordpress.com/2020/03/12/alex-gogic-the-most-underrated-midfielder-in-the-scottish-premiership/amp/?__twitter_impression=true

Exactly this. Good players can play in poor sides. He seems to have done an effective job in that position for Hamilton.

[supermcginn]

Anybody take jason holt?decent energy can get goals from midfield,jambo and sevco links but says he's open to anything.
Our midfield is lightweight enough.

[Vault Boy]

Anybody take jason holt?decent energy can get goals from midfield,jambo and sevco links but says he's open to anything.

Not for me, he seems rather injury prone - above anything else. Would rather have Allan and Mallan getting our goals from midfield, with targets like Omeonga and Gogic for the other options.

[The 90+2]

Because it is based on more than that? Does his personality fit with the squad? Has he kept himself fit? Can he play in a more attacking side with more responsilbity on him to move the ball around?

Let’s get him on trial then and then he signs for Aberdeen as they showed they wanted him more by signing without one.

[The 90+2]

Anybody take jason holt?decent energy can get goals from midfield,jambo and sevco links but says he's open to anything.

No he’s *****. Hun/Hearts version of Ross Chisholm.

[SHODAN]

Anybody take jason holt?decent energy can get goals from midfield,jambo and sevco links but says he's open to anything.
Past his best, and his best wasn't even that good.

[The 90+2]

[QUOTE=MWHIBBIES;6198728]Is it? I don't know much about the guy but Hibs strolled through Hamilton many times in the last 3 years.[/He was a stand out for Hamilton even against the old firm.

[Since452]

I'd rather Ross had a closer look at him before deciding. I'm comfortable with that

[JohnM1875]

Let’s get him on trial then and then he signs for Aberdeen as they showed they wanted him more by signing without one.

Can almost guarantee this happening. Bizarre.

[MWHIBBIES]

Quite a poor argument questioning a player because we’ve beat his team a few times over the past few years?

Have a read at this, obviously written by someone who’d have a more valid opinion than the majority of us on this thread. Sounds exactly like the kind of player we’re lacking

https://bensmagazine.wordpress.com/2020/03/12/alex-gogic-the-most-underrated-midfielder-in-the-scottish-premiership/amp/?__twitter_impression=true

Not as poor as believeing this 1 player will stop us from getting ran over. Its a team effort to defend properly and be hard to beat.

I'm not judging the guy either way before I see him but he must be some player if he is going to solve all our issues alone. Remember, Docherty and Omeonga are away so he'd be playing with Hallberg and Mallan, will he be enough to stop us getting ran over next to them?

[MWHIBBIES]

Let’s get him on trial then and then he signs for Aberdeen as they showed they wanted him more by signing without one.

He'll go to whoever offers him the most money, not the one who trials him first.

[The 90+2]

He'll go to whoever offers him the most money, not the one who trials him first.

Money/who shows they want him most. Sure it’s happened before, us offering a trial and player goes to the club that doesn’t want him to prove himself. I do understand having given three year contracts to Tom James we have to be a lot more cautious but this guys proven he’s got it.

[Heisenberg]

Not as poor as believeing this 1 player will stop us from getting ran over. Its a team effort to defend properly and be hard to beat.

I'm not judging the guy either way before I see him but he must be some player if he is going to solve all our issues alone. Remember, Docherty and Omeonga are away so he'd be playing with Hallberg and Mallan, will he be enough to stop us getting ran over next to them?

Sorry, I’ll rephrase what I said to - he’s exactly the type of player we need to help us defend better as a team, particularly in the middle of the park.

[The 90+2]

He'll go to whoever offers him the most money, not the one who trials him first.

Money/who shows they want him most. Sure it’s happened before, us offering a trial and player goes to the club that doesn’t want him to prove himself. I do understand having given three year contracts to Tom James we have to be a lot more cautious but this guys proven he’s got it.

[The 90+2]

Sorry, I’ll rephrase what I said to - he’s exactly the type of player we need to help us defend better as a team, particularly in the middle of the park.

Exactly. I’m really unsure why that would even be up for debate.

[Smartie]

Not as poor as believeing this 1 player will stop us from getting ran over. Its a team effort to defend properly and be hard to beat.

I'm not judging the guy either way before I see him but he must be some player if he is going to solve all our issues alone. Remember, Docherty and Omeonga are away so he'd be playing with Hallberg and Mallan, will he be enough to stop us getting ran over next to them?

Our midfield needs a fair bit of work done to it.

For the third season in a row.

Hopefully it goes a bit better this time than the last twice.

If Gogic is primarily defensive, he might provide the appropriate cover to allow the likes of Hallberg, Newell and Allan to make things happen further forward, but I still think we're an energetic player short in there.

[B.H.F.C]

I know Gogic seems to have got himself a decent reputation but I can’t really remember coming away from a game thinking he’d really help improve us. That’s not to say he wouldn’t though.

The season just finished was really the first time he’s played a full season at 25/26. Not played a lot prior to that but maybe being converted from a centre half to midfielder was what he needed.

[green day]

Money/who shows they want him most. Sure it’s happened before, us offering a trial and player goes to the club that doesn’t want him to prove himself. I do understand having given three year contracts to Tom James we have to be a lot more cautious but this guys proven he’s got it.

Havent we committed to not signing players until we are paying ours the deferral cash?

[davhibby]

Havent we committed to not signing players until we are paying ours the deferral cash?

Presumably we’ll be back paying full wages when we start back training

[easty]

I know Gogic seems to have got himself a decent reputation but I can’t really remember coming away from a game thinking he’d really help improve us. That’s not to say he wouldn’t though.

The season just finished was really the first time he’s played a full season at 25/26. Not played a lot prior to that but maybe being converted from a centre half to midfielder was what he needed.

I’m with you. I’m glad we’re bringing him in for a trial rather than chucking a deal at him. If he comes on trial and we don’t offer a deal, I’d not be surprised at all.

[Lancs Harp]

Midfielder Lewis Macleod is out of contract I think. He's been on the periphery of things since moving south both at Brentford and at Wigan, but looked a decent prospect at Rangers as a youngster, still in his mid 20s and a career possibily in danger of stagnating. Worth a punt?

Edit to add Paul Gallagher is out ofcontract at Preston too. Not sure if they are offering a him a new one but although 35 now still played in over 40 games for Preston last season.

[aljo7-0]

Ali McCann was in my daughter's year at school. He was a Hibs fan as a wee kid despite his Dad supporting Sevco. Still staying in Edinburgh.

[Andy74]

Havent we committed to not signing players until we are paying ours the deferral cash?

I can’t tell if this is now a running joke or not now?

[Blaster]

I can’t tell if this is now a running joke or not now?

Was thinking the same mate.

[jacomo]

I can’t tell if this is now a running joke or not now?


If it is, it’s not really amusing me anymore.

[bingo70]

I can’t tell if this is now a running joke or not now?

Yeah, even when we do get back signing players it’ll be a while till we’re paying anything like the £750k we paid for Ulises De La Cruz.

[Leitherhibs]

Holt - Poor man's Stevie Mallan.

Gogic - Midfield destroyer we've been crying out for - Get him signed.

Ali McCann - Would love to sign him but sadly he'll end up going for well out of our price range.

Campbell & Turnbull - See above.

[Andy74]

Yeah, even when we do get back signing players it’ll be a while till we’re paying anything like the £750k we paid for Ulises De La Cruz.

Steady.

[davhibby]

If we wanted McCann we needed to try for him earlier this year before he signed a new contract. The ship has well and truly sailed as he’ll go down south or to one of the old firm now

[HFC93]

What's Gogic's best position?

[Leitherhibs]

What's Gogic's best position?

Holding mid.

[Brightside]

We arent in for Mccann. Is this all because of his youtube clip?

[badabing67]

Is it? I don't know much about the guy but Hibs strolled through Hamilton many times in the last 3 years.

Rangers didn't stroll through them at Ibrox like they strolled through us. Hamilton got a win there last season, we didn't and we didn't have a player like Gogic. We need him or someone like him and have done since we let Bartman and Spike walk away.

[erin go bragh]

Rangers didn't stroll through them at Ibrox like they strolled through us. Hamilton got a win there last season, we didn't and we didn't have a player like Gogic. We need him or someone like him and have done since we let Bartman and Spike walk away.
Spot on badabing . He would be a brilliant signing. Fingers crossed.

[Ozyhibby]

We arent in for Mccann. Is this all because of his youtube clip?

Think so. There is very little chance of us getting players under contract from the same division as us.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MWHIBBIES]

Rangers didn't stroll through them at Ibrox like they strolled through us. Hamilton got a win there last season, we didn't and we didn't have a player like Gogic. We need him or someone like him and have done since we let Bartman and Spike walk away.

Thats one match. We put 6 past gogics Hamilton last season. That was also just one match.

If hes like Marv i'd rather avoid him because Marv wasn't really what we needed to move forward. If he is more dynamic and can move the ball around then sure but a pure destroyer is not what he need.

[JimBHibees]

Thats one match. We put 6 past gogics Hamilton last season. That was also just one match.

If hes like Marv i'd rather avoid him because Marv wasn't really what we needed to move forward. If he is more dynamic and can move the ball around then sure but a pure destroyer is not what he need.

Get the impression he is more destroyer type.

[Billy Whizz]

Get the impression he is more destroyer type.

7 yellows and 1 red last season would suggest that😄

[The 90+2]

Thats one match. We put 6 past gogics Hamilton last season. That was also just one match.

If hes like Marv i'd rather avoid him because Marv wasn't really what we needed to move forward. If he is more dynamic and can move the ball around then sure but a pure destroyer is not what he need.

I disagree, our midfield is soft as ****. We need someone in there to stop the opposition play and can put in a tackle.

[J-C]

I disagree, our midfield is soft as ****. We need someone in there to stop the opposition play and can put in a tackle.

We've needed a Matty Jack type player and we also let big Marv go which was another mistake. Gogic is exactly what's needed to shore up a soft centre, his style allows the flair players to do their thing.

[Www1875hfc]

Wonder what price Hibs will expect to get for Boyle ?

What do you think would be a realistic price ?

And who would you bring in as a replacement?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[bingo70]

Wonder what price Hibs will expect to get for Boyle ?

What do you think would be a realistic price ?

And who would you bring in as a replacement?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

£2m is what I think we’d ask for but we’d get a bit less.

No idea about replacements, that boy from St Johnstone maybe?

Have you heard there could be bids coming in.

[Michael]

Wonder what price Hibs will expect to get for Boyle ?

What do you think would be a realistic price ?

And who would you bring in as a replacement?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I think he's similar level to Ivan who was around £500K I think. In this market probably closed to £350K, I'd guess.

[Stuart93]

I think he's similar level to Ivan who was around £500K I think. In this market probably closed to £350K, I'd guess.

£350k for Boyle? Come on

By far one of the best wingers in the league. If we sold Boyle for £350k we may as well chuck it

[Alex Trager]

£350k for Boyle? Come on

By far one of the best wingers in the league. If we sold Boyle for £350k we may as well chuck it

Cannot help but agree hahah. £350K would be a joke

[04Sauzee]

I think he's similar level to Ivan who was around £500K I think. In this market probably closed to £350K, I'd guess.

What would Nisbit cost if you rate Boyle at £350k in the current market?

[MWHIBBIES]

I disagree, our midfield is soft as ****. We need someone in there to stop the opposition play and can put in a tackle.

We'll never go anywhere with guys who can only kick. This is 2020, not 1985, footballers need a bit more. You can tackle and win the ball and be able to pass it about. Mcginn, fyvie, mcgeouch could all win it and pass it. No one would ever describe that trio as being soft.

Marv was excellent at the job but extremely limited and correctly moved on. It's a player with the skills of Whittaker but a bit more physical attributes that we need. Not another marv.

[JimBHibees]

£350k for Boyle? Come on

By far one of the best wingers in the league. If we sold Boyle for £350k we may as well chuck it

Anything less than 1m for Martin would be poor imo.

[B.H.F.C]

£2m is what I think we’d ask for but we’d get a bit less.

No idea about replacements, that boy from St Johnstone maybe?

Have you heard there could be bids coming in.

Current climate with a year left on his contract, I don’t think we’d get a seven figure fee for Boyle. I don’t think he has much in the way of re sale value either for any potential buyer either. If/when he gets a move, that’ll be his big move IMO.

[Stuart93]

Current climate with a year left on his contract, I don’t think we’d get a seven figure fee for Boyle. I don’t think he has much in the way of re sale value either for any potential buyer either. If/when he gets a move, that’ll be his big move IMO.

If that would be the case then he’d be more valuable to us if he stays here for his final year imo

[B.H.F.C]

If that would be the case then he’d be more valuable to us if he stays here for his final year imo

I agree.

[The Modfather]

We'll never go anywhere with guys who can only kick. This is 2020, not 1985, footballers need a bit more. You can tackle and win the ball and be able to pass it about. Mcginn, fyvie, mcgeouch could all win it and pass it. No one would ever describe that trio as being soft.

Marv was excellent at the job but extremely limited and correctly moved on. It's a player with the skills of Whittaker but a bit more physical attributes that we need. Not another marv.

Depends how you set the team up. Killie have had recent success (in relative terms) with Power & Dicker as a two. I may be doing them a disservice, but my perception of them is that they were there to primarily do the dirty side of the game, while Killie were still decent enough to watch.

I’d rather look to replicate the blend in midfield we had with the McGrough, McGinn & Allan axis (although McGinn was like an extra player so difficult to replicate that blend), but if we are to continue to sign technical, but soft, midfielders, or get the best out of who we currently have, maybe a throwback destroyer would help make us more than the sum of our parts.

[JimboHibs]

We've needed a Matty Jack type player and we also let big Marv go which was another mistake. Gogic is exactly what's needed to shore up a soft centre, his style allows the flair players to do their thing.

Jeez how many years since Matty Jack played for us, may as well add we need a Latapy & Sauzee type player also.

[J-C]

Jeez how many years since Matty Jack played for us, may as well add we need a Latapy & Sauzee type player also.


Nothing to do with number of years, it's the type needed in midfield, McGinn gave us energy but also had that wee bit of dig in him, plus he could play. Players like that are very few, Big Marv was limited talent wise but was a decent enforcer, if we cannot get a McGinn type then an midfield enforcer is a must as we have a soft centre. Allan, Mallan, Hallberg and Murray are all poor defensively, we need someone to play in front of the back 4.

[madhatter]

More than anything our squad needs some bite especially in middle area. We had injuries to our back 4 last season and had to make do with what we had at times, did the midfield help? No, midfield made the situation worse as we gifted opportunities by not tracking and not tackling. One of our biggest weaknesses for a while. Letting Bartley and Milligan go was a ridiculous decision without any plan to replace, crazy in Scottish football not to have a hard working midfielder who can tackle.

Look at Arturo Vidal, talented player but got big moves because, more than anything, he hounds players and is a nuisance. He also takes pride in the less attractive side of the game. I remember he tackled a Dortmund player when he was at Bayern and lost his balance, he threw himself head first to header the ball on the ground to prevent the ball tumbling through to the opponent. Sort of stuff Bartley and Milligan did frequently - at all costs type of defending, pride in being the enforcer.

Not sure if Gogic is the answer but we need something. I suppose the question is, we already have 6 senior midfielders, most of which would like to be starting most weeks so I'm not sure how this all works with the current financial hit. We may not sign many players tbh, I have a feeling it will already be 1 in 1 out. Money for Kamberi might change that but not by much unless he is on big wages as well.

[Unseen work]

Gogic would be a good addition and very shrewd bit of business imo.

Imagine a trio of him, Docherty and Allan.

He knows the league, is at a good age and is used to having to dig deep and grind out results.

Jon McLaughlin
Jason Naismith/ Stephen O‘Donnell
Danie Harvie/Niko Hamalinen
Gary Dicker/ Gogic
Docherty/Kyle Magennis
Scott Fraser/Luke Berry
Jordan Clark/ Mikael Miller
Steven Lawless/Aidan Mcgeady
Ross Stewart/Kevin Nisbett
Alex Shalk/ Chris Maguire

One of each and we’re sorted :greengrin

[The 90+2]

We've needed a Matty Jack type player and we also let big Marv go which was another mistake. Gogic is exactly what's needed to shore up a soft centre, his style allows the flair players to do their thing.

100%. Whats he going to do on trial? Flatten Stevie Mallan? :greengrin.

Imo we need a Jim Goodwin type and Gogic fits that perfectly. He can also cover in defence if we don’t get the CHs sorted completely.

[The 90+2]

Jeez how many years since Matty Jack played for us, may as well add we need a Latapy & Sauzee type player also.

Nothing to do with the player, it’s the role. Rocky and Bartley both played it for us very well. Bamba too until he came back from the ACN and decided he was playing centre half or nowhere. Honourable mention to Kevin McBride too.

[SouthMoroccoStu]

Seen on Facebook (so be mindful)

Hibs deal with Alex Gogić is complete according to his agent... looks decent one of the best players in the league last season

[tonyrougier123]

Seen on Facebook (so be mindful)

Hibs deal with Alex Gogić is complete according to his agent... looks decent one of the best players in the league last season

Who's his agent?,happy with that if true.

[PH91]

100%. Whats he going to do on trial? Flatten Stevie Mallan? :greengrin.

Imo we need a Jim Goodwin type and Gogic fits that perfectly. He can also cover in defence if we don’t get the CHs sorted completely.

I agree with the posts on here with regards to the type of midfielder we need to bring in and Gogic on the face of it fits the bill.

But as well as being the right type of player technically they also have to be the right character. We are desperate for a leader in the middle of the park. An organiser and voice on the pitch. As much as Hibs might have seen Gogic play we probably don't know too much about what kind of character he is. A trial will let the management team get to know him a bit. I think its sensible given we will likely only be signing a few players and it's really important we get this position right this time!!

[hfc rd]

Seen on Facebook (so be mindful)

Hibs deal with Alex Gogić is complete according to his agent... looks decent one of the best players in the league last season

Very good player but probably take it as a pinch of salt as anyone can post random rubbish on Facebook. For instance I remember seeing something on Facebook last week that Ofir Marciano is wanted by both Middlesbrough & Legia Warsaw. Not heard this anywhere else.

[04Sauzee]

Motherwell sign Ricki Lamie

[The 90+2]

I agree with the posts on here with regards to the type of midfielder we need to bring in and Gogic on the face of it fits the bill.

But as well as being the right type of player technically they also have to be the right character. We are desperate for a leader in the middle of the park. An organiser and voice on the pitch. As much as Hibs might have seen Gogic play we probably don't know too much about what kind of character he is. A trial will let the management team get to know him a bit. I think its sensible given we will likely only be signing a few players and it's really important we get this position right this time!!

Aye fair enough 👍

[Lago]

Anything less than 1m for Martin would be poor imo.
Can't see him going for 1m, half that perhaps.

[Heisenberg]

Who's his agent?,happy with that if true.

I looked it up and the name Zoran Kikleski came up on the FB post in question. It’s also mentioned on twitter, someone seems certain his agent has confirmed the move is happening but I can’t actually find it anywhere. I reckon they have found out his agents name and are taking wild punts at it.

[Unseen work]

Motherwell sign Ricki Lamie

Good signing for them.

[CapitalGreen]

Could the “trial period” just be a means of us getting him in and training before we are able to start signing players again if players revert to full pay from the start of July.

[04Sauzee]

More about Gogic

https://twitter.com/PureFitbaw/status/1270719180916977666?s=19

[Heisenberg]

Could the “trial period” just be a means of us getting him in and training before we are able to start signing players again if players revert to full pay from the start of July.

Good shout.

[Tug Wilson]

Currently we have Allan, Mallan, Hallberg and Newell as central midfielders so we have to add some more.

There is a definite lack of bite amongst those guys.

Don't think that any of the young players coming through will add that.

If we can get either or both Docherty and Omeonga back then they add energy and drive.

However, again neither are going to fill that holding role.

Can't say if Gogic is the answer but I do think he is the type of player our midfield needs.

Agree that we don't want to turn into an overly physical side (eg Aberdeen) but a bit of steel would be good.

[Keyser Sauzee]

We arent in for Mccann. Is this all because of his youtube clip?

Think this may be my fault, I did state it wasn’t a rumour but that I like him from what I seen on a clip of his.

[easty]

More than anything our squad needs some bite especially in middle area. We had injuries to our back 4 last season and had to make do with what we had at times, did the midfield help? No, midfield made the situation worse as we gifted opportunities by not tracking and not tackling. One of our biggest weaknesses for a while. Letting Bartley and Milligan go was a ridiculous decision without any plan to replace, crazy in Scottish football not to have a hard working midfielder who can tackle.

Look at Arturo Vidal, talented player but got big moves because, more than anything, he hounds players and is a nuisance. He also takes pride in the less attractive side of the game. I remember he tackled a Dortmund player when he was at Bayern and lost his balance, he threw himself head first to header the ball on the ground to prevent the ball tumbling through to the opponent. Sort of stuff Bartley and Milligan did frequently - at all costs type of defending, pride in being the enforcer.

Not sure if Gogic is the answer but we need something. I suppose the question is, we already have 6 senior midfielders, most of which would like to be starting most weeks so I'm not sure how this all works with the current financial hit. We may not sign many players tbh, I have a feeling it will already be 1 in 1 out. Money for Kamberi might change that but not by much unless he is on big wages as well.

Arturo Vidal is a brilliant footballer and that’s why he got his moves. He’s over 100 caps for Chile and has won titles at Juve, Bayern and Barca. The only thing he and Gogic have in common are the number of letters in their surnames.

Being a player who’ll throw everything they have into stopping the opposition isn’t always a good thing anyway. When you’re good at it, it’s brilliant, when you’re rash it lets the whole team down.

[H18 SFR]

Motherwell really on the ball getting their recruitment done early.

[we are hibs]

Hibs back in for Nisbett but dundee utd favourites according to the DR.

[Heisenberg]

Hibs back in for Nisbett according to the DR

It doesn’t really say that in the article, bit of a mischievous headline from the DR. Just says Dundee United are going to “steal a march on Hibs” by making the first move for him.

The Hibs bit only says “ Hibs sporting director Graeme Mathie is also weighing up a move for Nisbet but his club are unable to do anything until they come through the COVID-19 situation.”

[MWHIBBIES]

Arturo Vidal is a brilliant footballer and that’s why he got his moves. He’s over 100 caps for Chile and has won titles at Juve, Bayern and Barca. The only thing he and Gogic have in common are the number of letters in their surnames.

Being a player who’ll throw everything they have into stopping the opposition isn’t always a good thing anyway. When you’re good at it, it’s brilliant, when you’re rash it lets the whole team down.

Indeed. Vidal was a world class footballer. Scored plenty of goals as well.

Pure enforces are really becoming a thing of the past. ****e, Casemiro, Vidal etc can all play and pass to a very high level.

[jacomo]

Indeed. Vidal was a world class footballer. Scored plenty of goals as well.

Pure enforces are really becoming a thing of the past. ****e, Casemiro, Vidal etc can all play and pass to a very high level.


That’s because they are top level, possibly world class players.

Back in the real world, ie the SPFL, you might have noticed that there aren’t many players with the same balance of attributes. The job is to build a team that can attack, defend and do what is needed.

No question that Hibs could be cut open with alarming ease last season. We need a better balance in midfield, and that means more defensive nous.

[madhatter]

Arturo Vidal is a brilliant footballer and that’s why he got his moves. He’s over 100 caps for Chile and has won titles at Juve, Bayern and Barca. The only thing he and Gogic have in common are the number of letters in their surnames.

Being a player who’ll throw everything they have into stopping the opposition isn’t always a good thing anyway. When you’re good at it, it’s brilliant, when you’re rash it lets the whole team down.

Not really sure what your point is. Gogic is closer to Vidal type of players than Mallan or Allan is. Both Gogic and Vidal can tackle? Is that not a commonality? I never said Vidal isn’t a very good player. Pretty sure his work ethic and ability to tackle are a factor in why he got his moves though...Barcelona needed a hardworking midfielder...didn’t need a lazy attacking midfielder.

Again, not sure why you decide to make a point of saying “being a player who’ll throw everything they have into stopping the opposition isn’t always a good thing”...pretty much a moot point. I’ll just reply saying “having a flamboyant midfield that just focus on attacking side of game isn’t always good thing. When you give ball away it lets the whole team down as you...”

Point is balance and we have been devoid of it since Milligan and Bartley left.

Watch some of the highlights from last season, we conceded quite a few from decent defensive shape because midfield players viewed it as get into shape but never get close to man or tackle. Interceptions are easier than tackling but harder to achieve if you aren’t putting ball carrier under pressure. Give them time and they will make right passing choice. Both intercepting and tackling are very difficult if you aren’t actively defending, compare Whittaker when defending to Slivka or Hallberg. There’s a reason why Whittaker started getting some game time again...also part of reason why Newell got some game time in centre. In terms of solidity in the middle we are honestly just a wee bit mince.

[Ozyhibby]

Much being made of the fact Gogic is hard as nails but from what I remember he is also a decent passer of the ball.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HendoDelivered]

Motherwell really on the ball getting their recruitment done early.

We also done that last year...

[HendoDelivered]

I’d be happy with Gogic and Nisbet to kick things off. Hopefully we can pull it off.

[04Sauzee]

Hibs being linked with the following over the last few days


Nisbet
Gogic
Wright
Miller
Stewart
Clark

Not to shabby 😅

[easty]

Not really sure what your point is. Gogic is closer to Vidal type of players than Mallan or Allan is. Both Gogic and Vidal can tackle? Is that not a commonality? I never said Vidal isn’t a very good player. Pretty sure his work ethic and ability to tackle are a factor in why he got his moves though...Barcelona needed a hardworking midfielder...didn’t need a lazy attacking midfielder.

Again, not sure why you decide to make a point of saying “being a player who’ll throw everything they have into stopping the opposition isn’t always a good thing”...pretty much a moot point. I’ll just reply saying “having a flamboyant midfield that just focus on attacking side of game isn’t always good thing. When you give ball away it lets the whole team down as you...”

Point is balance and we have been devoid of it since Milligan and Bartley left.

Watch some of the highlights from last season, we conceded quite a few from decent defensive shape because midfield players viewed it as get into shape but never get close to man or tackle. Interceptions are easier than tackling but harder to achieve if you aren’t putting ball carrier under pressure. Give them time and they will make right passing choice. Both intercepting and tackling are very difficult if you aren’t actively defending, compare Whittaker when defending to Slivka or Hallberg. There’s a reason why Whittaker started getting some game time again...also part of reason why Newell got some game time in centre. In terms of solidity in the middle we are honestly just a wee bit mince.

You’re the one that brought up Vidal when talking about Gogic. Gogic is closer to Vidal than Mallan is. Yeah ok. In the same way that a coat hanger is closer to a peg than a lightbulb.

[H18 SFR]

A consequence of league reconstruction will be the Nisbet bid in the bin and not being made I’d imagine.

[The 90+2]

Motherwell really on the ball getting their recruitment done early.

As usual.

[MWHIBBIES]

That’s because they are top level, possibly world class players.

Back in the real world, ie the SPFL, you might have noticed that there aren’t many players with the same balance of attributes. The job is to build a team that can attack, defend and do what is needed.

No question that Hibs could be cut open with alarming ease last season. We need a better balance in midfield, and that means more defensive nous.

Fraser Fyvie could win the ball and pass it. So could mcgeouch, so could Mcginn. Nothing to do with being world class.

[The 90+2]

A consequence of league reconstruction will be the Nisbet bid in the bin and not being made I’d imagine.

Hope not, we really need forwards and we have sold a massive amount of season tickets.

[MWHIBBIES]

Much being made of the fact Gogic is hard as nails but from what I remember he is also a decent passer of the ball.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's good, vitally important he can if he's going to play central midfield.

[MWHIBBIES]

Folk are pretending Marv was actually playing in his last 18 months. Whittaker was often chosen over him in midfield by Lennon.

And we were generally hopeless when Milligan was here too. He wasn't even the answer so replacing him isn't the aim.

It is and always has been Mcginn and Mcgeouch that need replacing. Good footballers who will run, win it back and keep the shape defensively. Dynamic players who can do multiple aspects of the game.

[badabing67]

Could the “trial period” just be a means of us getting him in and training before we are able to start signing players again if players revert to full pay from the start of July.

Also a chance to fit in a medical.

[Ozyhibby]

Folk are pretending Marv was actually playing in his last 18 months. Whittaker was often chosen over him in midfield by Lennon.

And we were generally hopeless when Milligan was here too. He wasn't even the answer so replacing him isn't the aim.

It is and always has been Mcginn and Mcgeouch that need replacing. Good footballers who will run, win it back and keep the shape defensively. Dynamic players who can do multiple aspects of the game.

I never thought of Marc as being a first pick. He always seemed to be back up. Still managed to get in a lot of games for us but when everyone was fit he tended to be on the bench.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[badabing67]

Hibs being linked with the following over the last few days


Nisbet
Gogic
Wright
Miller
Stewart
Clark

Not to shabby 😅

I know we made a move for Mikel Miller in January but I have not seen a link to him this summer. Is there a definite link, I think another link with Omeonga will crop up maybe another loan move, I think he still has a year left at Genoa it would be cool if we could get him on a pre contract in January. Think he would go for it

[Ozyhibby]

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20200610/bf9f24bb95763888480f5e535524aeaf.plist
In not bad company even if he was 4th and a long way back.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Lancs Harp]

Its about balance in the team and the squad. Yes we have obviously struggled to replace SJM and Dylan most teams would, but the likes of Bartley played more than their parts around them. Marv played over 120 games for us. In the Championship when the emphasis was more on getting forward we didnt need a holding player so much but he was worth his weight in gold playing against the likes of Rangers Celtic and Hearts where we were required to battle more in midfield and had to work harder to getthe ball back and break up the opposition. I certainly agree with the opinion that we are light weight in midfield currently, basically in midfield when we havent got the ball we're bloody awful and bordering on powder puff. Half decent when we've got the ball but we are long way off what we had a couple of seasons ago.

If its true we are signing Gogic then I wish him luck and hope he is at least part of the solution to a better balanced midfield. Cant comment from personal experience as to be honest havent really seen anythng of him.

[The 90+2]

You’re the one that brought up Vidal when talking about Gogic. Gogic is closer to Vidal than Mallan is. Yeah ok. In the same way that a coat hanger is closer to a peg than a lightbulb.

What?

[04Sauzee]

I know we made a move for Mikel Miller in January but I have not seen a link to him this summer. Is there a definite link, I think another link with Omeonga will crop up maybe another loan move, I think he still has a year left at Genoa it would be cool if we could get him on a pre contract in January. Think he would go for it

Not much of a link but it's reported in this story

https://www.edinburghlive.co.uk/sport/football/hibs-transfer-news-alex-gogic-18394516

[badabing67]

Not much of a link but it's reported in this story

https://www.edinburghlive.co.uk/sport/football/hibs-transfer-news-alex-gogic-18394516

I missed that cheers, think he would be a good signing

[Unseen work]

Iv seen County are in the paper saying if we want Stewart it won’t be cheap, be interesting to see how it develops. He’s 24 next month, 6 foot 3 and a strong runner, also scored quite a few this season.

Nisbet I think is a must buy, he has looked brilliant when Iv seen him and imo is the sort of player the fans would take to straight away. He’s a big powerful lad and is in great shape right now with lockdown.

Would be a massive sign of intent signing Nisbet and Stewart.

The good and interesting thing with the rumours is that the vast majority are players that know the league well and have performed to a good level. They might not be as exciting as someone who is unknown but will do well.

Miller
Stewart
Gogic
Nisbet
Drey Wright

All linked from the SPFL.

[04Sauzee]

From twitter regarding Gogic

A lot of comments about it being a trial offer. I think the suggestion is that he has been invited to train until Hibs sort the wage deferral scheme, possibly more a way of integrating him into the squad quickly?

[Vault Boy]

From twitter regarding Gogic

A lot of comments about it being a trial offer. I think the suggestion is that he has been invited to train until Hibs sort the wage deferral scheme, possibly more a way of integrating him into the squad quickly?

That's from a journalist too IIRC. It makes the most sense, there's no chance it's due to us needing to scout him any further.

[madhatter]

You’re the one that brought up Vidal when talking about Gogic. Gogic is closer to Vidal than Mallan is. Yeah ok. In the same way that a coat hanger is closer to a peg than a lightbulb.

Not been on in months and remember why I stopped now...

Just fyi, I used Vidal to highlight missing hard working tackler in midfield, you made the first direct comparison between Vidal and Gogic: "The only thing he and Gogic have in common are the number of letters in their surnames.". I'm not suggesting Gogic joins Barcelona or Vidal joins Hibs - calibre of player is completely different but tough tackler is a commonality, again something I think I made clear. What is a suitable player comparison criteria, running gait?

I mean I even said "Not sure if Gogic is the answer but we need something.". Fill your boots though, may need to find someone else for your witty retorts though...sorry

[davhibby]

Can't see him going for 1m, half that perhaps.

Seriously? Even with a year left on his deal I wouldn’t even be picking up the phone to answer any bids below £1m for Boyle. He’s worth at least 2 imo but we’ll struggle to get that with a year left.

Really happy with the names that we’re being linked with so far, we should always be looking to take the better players from other Scottish clubs. Nisbet should be our number 1 target though, was as good as the much revered Shankland in a poor Dunfermline side this year

[kaimendhibs]

Ram the trial get him signed.100 per cent this

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

[Dmas]

Danny Rogers released by aberdeen, always thought he looked a decent keeper when he was at Falkirk playing against us, spent most of his time out on loan with aberdeen only making 3 appearances, worth a try as back up to rocky?

[SouthMoroccoStu]

Danny Rogers released by aberdeen, always thought he looked a decent keeper when he was at Falkirk playing against us, spent most of his time out on loan with aberdeen only making 3 appearances, worth a try as back up to rocky?

He always played like Neuer meets Buffon against us

[J-C]

From twitter regarding Gogic

A lot of comments about it being a trial offer. I think the suggestion is that he has been invited to train until Hibs sort the wage deferral scheme, possibly more a way of integrating him into the squad quickly?


This happened with Bogdan earlier this year, came in to train while a deal was being sorted.

[Heisenberg]

Looks like Nisbet wanted to move in January but Dunfermline wouldn’t budge. I’m hoping we go back in but Dundee Utd currently seem like they are willing to commit sooner than we are.

Quotes from the DR:

“There was a lot of interest in January and Hibs put an offer in, and I wanted to go. It looked like it was going to happen, but then the bid was rejected, as was the one from Dundee United, and I stayed at Dunfermline. Of course, I was disappointed the move didn’t happen for me.”

[J-C]

Looks like Nisbet wanted to move in January but Dunfermline wouldn’t budge. I’m hoping we go back in but Dundee Utd currently seem like they are willing to commit sooner than we are.

Quotes from the DR:

“There was a lot of interest in January and Hibs put an offer in, and I wanted to go. It looked like it was going to happen, but then the bid was rejected, as was the one from Dundee United, and I stayed at Dunfermline. Of course, I was disappointed the move didn’t happen for me.”


Think I read somewhere, maybe here that Nisbet is a Hibs fan, this could be a major help to us if true.

[Ozyhibby]

Think I read somewhere, maybe here that Nisbet is a Hibs fan, this could be a major help to us if true.

Biggest help would be someone giving us money for Kamberri. Obviously Boyle as well but I’d rather that didn’t happen.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hibs90]

Looks like Nisbet wanted to move in January but Dunfermline wouldn’t budge. I’m hoping we go back in but Dundee Utd currently seem like they are willing to commit sooner than we are.

Quotes from the DR:

“There was a lot of interest in January and Hibs put an offer in, and I wanted to go. It looked like it was going to happen, but then the bid was rejected, as was the one from Dundee United, and I stayed at Dunfermline. Of course, I was disappointed the move didn’t happen for me.”

Wonder if Dunfermline regret that now. Good to see he wants to be here.

[Hibs90]

Think I read somewhere, maybe here that Nisbet is a Hibs fan, this could be a major help to us if true.

Born in Glasgow, brought through Partick youth set up if that makes any difference.

[HendoDelivered]

Wonder if Dunfermline regret that now. Good to see he wants to be here.

Tbf, he also mentioned the bid being knocked back from Dundee Utd which he was also disappointed about.

[J-C]

Born in Glasgow, brought through Partick youth set up if that makes any difference.


Didn't have a clue where he was born, just remember someone saying he was a Hibs fan, maybe not if he's from Glasgow, the fact that he seemed disappointed the transfer didn't go through made me think he was maybe a fan.

[J-C]

Tbf, he also mentioned the bid being knocked back from Dundee Utd which he was also disappointed about.


Obviously a big hike in wages was the disappointment then to both deals being knocked back.

[04Sauzee]

Obviously a big hike in wages was the disappointment then to both deals being knocked back.

Dissapointing enough?

Maybe playing in the top league, playing in front of bugger crowds, playing with and against better players, do well get condisidered for Scotland, but these would all be a consideration

[JimBHibees]

Dissapointing enough?

Maybe playing in the top league, playing in front of bugger crowds, playing with and against better players, do well get condisidered for Scotland, but these would all be a consideration

Saying nothing :faf::faf:

[04Sauzee]

Saying nothing :faf::faf:

Oops 🥴

[J-C]

Dissapointing enough?

Maybe playing in the top league, playing in front of bugger crowds, playing with and against better players, do well get condisidered for Scotland, but these would all be a consideration

The only flaw in your argument is Dundee U were the other team in for him, playing in the same league and not exactly huge crowds or with/against better players.

[04Sauzee]

The only flaw in your argument is Dundee U were the other team in for him, playing in the same league and not exactly huge crowds or with/against better players.

Pretty sure everyone expected Dundee Utd to be top flight this season

[easty]

Wonder if Dunfermline regret that now. Good to see he wants to be here.

They’ll definitely be regretting it now

[Alex Trager]

I wonder why Dundee Utd bid for him in Jan with Shankland on the books and by all accounts not for sale.

They must have a lot more cash these days

[MrRobot]

Looks like Nisbet wanted to move in January but Dunfermline wouldn’t budge. I’m hoping we go back in but Dundee Utd currently seem like they are willing to commit sooner than we are.

Quotes from the DR:

“There was a lot of interest in January and Hibs put an offer in, and I wanted to go. It looked like it was going to happen, but then the bid was rejected, as was the one from Dundee United, and I stayed at Dunfermline. Of course, I was disappointed the move didn’t happen for me.”

He would surely choose Hibs over Dundee Utd if given the option.

[HendoDelivered]

He would surely choose Hibs over Dundee Utd if given the option.

You’d think so. Also how much money he was getting offered would be a factor as well. If Dundee Utd offered more than us wages wise, that could be enough to tempt him there.

[Greencore]

I wonder why Dundee Utd bid for him in Jan with Shankland on the books and by all accounts not for sale.

They must have a lot more cash these days


Cos they want to Build a team, good on them.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

I wonder why Dundee Utd bid for him in Jan with Shankland on the books and by all accounts not for sale.

They must have a lot more cash these days

Their owner was on sportsound a few months ago explaining that their MO was to buy/invest in up and coming talent and then sell them on for a profit.

Probably the same as every other club but he said he’s prepared to invest a lot in this model and has financial backing from other investors.

[Ozyhibby]

Their owner was on sportsound a few months ago explaining that their MO was to buy/invest in up and coming talent and then sell them on for a profit.

Probably the same as every other club but he said he’s prepared to invest a lot in this model and has financial backing from other investors.

It’s what most clubs in Scotland do, even Celtic. I think Nisbet is worth the gamble. If we can get a few for Kamberri and use it to bring in Nisbet then I think we will be ahead on the deal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jacomo]

Cos they want to Build a team, good on them.


Dundee Utd are spending beyond their means. Time will tell if it’s wise or not...

[Greencore]

Dundee Utd are spending beyond their means. Time will tell if it’s wise or not...

Never knew that. Was under the impression they had a new owner who was loaded and willing to invest in the playing squad.

[Smartie]

Their owner was on sportsound a few months ago explaining that their MO was to buy/invest in up and coming talent and then sell them on for a profit.

Probably the same as every other club but he said he’s prepared to invest a lot in this model and has financial backing from other investors.

It’s a dangerous game.

You can get it right (and if you hit the jackpot with 1 or 2 then it can allow for a good few more mistakes) but most clubs who gamble with this strategy lose.

A cash-strapped Scottish football environment might be the place to pull it off, especially being next door to England, where they will probably still have (relatively speaking) pots of cash but be looking to use it more wisely.

[04Sauzee]

Have Hibs official announced we will be back in training from Monday yet? Can't rember if we are or aren't?

If we are assuming they will be back on full pay? Do we think all staff will be back on full pay or just the players, or are coaching staff and some other staff?

[Peevemor]

Have Hibs official announced we will be back in training from Monday yet? Can't rember if we are or aren't?

If we are assuming they will be back on full pay? Do we think all staff will be back on full pay or just the players, or are coaching staff and some other staff?

Hibs are about to put forward a 6-6-14-2-7-7 set up which, apart from being as sensible as anything else that's been proposed, means that we won't play until February thus saving a fortune in wages.

[SteveHFC]

Jon McLaughlin released by Sunderland. Wonder if we’ll end up making a move for him.

[Greencore]

It’s a dangerous game.

You can get it right (and if you hit the jackpot with 1 or 2 then it can allow for a good few more mistakes) but most clubs who gamble with this strategy lose.

A cash-strapped Scottish football environment might be the place to pull it off, especially being next door to England, where they will probably still have (relatively speaking) pots of cash but be looking to use it more wisely.

It's ashame they value our game so little.

[Ozyhibby]

Jon McLaughlin released by Sunderland. Wonder if we’ll end up making a move for him.

Only happen if someone takes Marciano of our hands. We can’t afford both.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[The 90+2]

Jon McLaughlin released by Sunderland. Wonder if we’ll end up making a move for him.

Turned down a new deal, going to Blackburn 👍

[mjhibby]

Gogic would be a cracking signing. Always stood out for Hamilton and a real warrior jus what we need. I’d prefer Stewart over nisbet as he shine it in the spl. Promising signs on recruitment though.

[04Sauzee]

Gogic would be a cracking signing. Always stood out for Hamilton and a real warrior jus what we need. I’d prefer Stewart over nisbet as he shine it in the spl. Promising signs on recruitment though.

Long + Nisbet or Stewart would be great, not that we are rumoured to be in for Long just my opinion

[Lago]

Seriously? Even with a year left on his deal I wouldn’t even be picking up the phone to answer any bids below £1m for Boyle. He’s worth at least 2 imo but we’ll struggle to get that with a year left.

Really happy with the names that we’re being linked with so far, we should always be looking to take the better players from other Scottish clubs. Nisbet should be our number 1 target though, was as good as the much revered Shankland in a poor Dunfermline side this year
Yip, seriously. Don't see Hibs spending much cash in the transfer market think there will be a few disappointed folk on here.

[JimBHibees]

I wonder why Dundee Utd bid for him in Jan with Shankland on the books and by all accounts not for sale.

They must have a lot more cash these days

Personally think Shankland will move.

[SteveHFC]

Turned down a new deal, going to Blackburn 👍

Would have been a decent replacement if Rocky went.

[badabing67]

Jon McLaughlin released by Sunderland. Wonder if we’ll end up making a move for him.

Blackburn in for him

[Vault Boy]

Nisbet says he wanted to join Hibs in January and was disappointed it didn't happen, but is hopeful of making a move now. EEN.

Edit: I see this was a few hours ago so likely already posted!

[Tambo]

I would happy sell flo and get Nisbet but could hamper gullans progress so at the moment who is the better player?

Also seen a headline with rangers flop sadiq linked with Manchester United.

[Since452]

I would happy sell flo and get Nisbet but could hamper gullans progress so at the moment who is the better player?

Also seen a headline with rangers flop sadiq linked with Manchester United.

Wonder if Dunfermline would fancy a straight swap. Kamberi for Nisbet

[Ozyhibby]

I would happy sell flo and get Nisbet but could hamper gullans progress so at the moment who is the better player?

Also seen a headline with rangers flop sadiq linked with Manchester United.

We should have 4 forward on the books. Just now we only have Doidge and Gullan. If he’s good enough he’ll force his way in.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MWHIBBIES]

I would happy sell flo and get Nisbet but could hamper gullans progress so at the moment who is the better player?

Also seen a headline with rangers flop sadiq linked with Manchester United.

We hampered Gullans progress by recalling him then never playing him. We gave him about 10 minutes Vs BSC. We hampered Shaw's by never trusting him and playing him either.

I don't really think signing another striker will hamper Gullan. He has to get games in cup ties, easier home games etc regardless or he'll just stagnate like so many others. We definitely need more than 2 strikers if we're going with 2 up top so Gullan should play a part.

[Leitherhibs]

We hampered Gullans progress by recalling him then never playing him. We gave him about 10 minutes Vs BSC. We hampered Shaw's by never trusting him and playing him either.

I don't really think signing another striker will hamper Gullan. He has to get games in cup ties, easier home games etc regardless or he'll just stagnate like so many others. We definitely need more than 2 strikers if we're going with 2 up top so Gullan should play a part.

Agree re Gullan, Shaw had plenty chances though.

[MWHIBBIES]

Agree re Gullan, Shaw had plenty chances though.

He did early on and generally did well. In his last 2 years he barely featured at all and certainly didn't get plenty of chances. Seriously, his chances were non existent. 11 starts in the last 2 years with us is pathetic. He scored in 6 of those starts btw.

Hibs really let him down and recalling Gullan to give him 10 minutes against a pub team was also very poor.

[scoopyboy]

He did early on and generally did well. In his last 2 years he barely featured at all and certainly didn't get plenty of chances. Seriously, his chances were non existent. 11 starts in the last 2 years with us is pathetic. He scored in 6 of those starts btw.

Hibs really let him down and recalling Gullan to give him 10 minutes against a pub team was also very poor.

Did Gullan score against ICT without being on the pitch? :greengrin

[Shrekko]

Did Gullan score against ICT without being on the pitch? :greengrin

And he also started the last game we played and came on against Hearts.

I think he’s getting a decent run.