Winter transfer thread 2023/24

[Brightside]

Boyle and Messi are hardly comparable.

Both equally Australian

[Rumble de Thump]

When it comes to Boyle, Messi and McGinn are irrelevant. Martin has had a terrible time of it with injury in the not too distant past, and a lot of players retire from international football as they get older in order to prolong their club careers. I wouldn't be surprised if he opts to do that at some point. In any case, he'll be unavailable for Hibs for a while and we will miss him.

[Since90+2]

Both equally Australian

Didn't realise Messi also had Australian family heritage.

[Stairway 2 7]

Boyle and Messi are hardly comparable.

Hibs are hardly PSG. Martin is also much younger at 30.

[brog]

Definitely think Kenneh will be off as well. Similar to Melkersen, don’t think these young players have a great opinion of Hibs due to their time here. Understandable in my opinion.

Now they’re out, playing every week and enjoying football. I’m sure Kenneh will want a move as well.

Kenneh started well with Shrewsbury but had been left out recently until last week's cup game. If we can get another £1m for him then BK is god!

[Donegal Hibby]

Kenneh started well with Shrewsbury but had been left out recently until last week's cup game. If we can get another £1m for him then BK is god!

Hopefully with a 20% sell on clause too 😂

[superfurryhibby]

Perhaps John McGinn should give the Euros a miss next summer so he’s has time off to return fit and refreshed for Aston Villa’s Champions League campaign next season. He’s already played at a European Championship so should be putting Villa first.


Exactly, which makes going to experience a major tournament for someone like Boyle even more special.

If you sign players who play for national teams in certain parts of the world then it comes with an acceptance that they might miss a few games every now and again.


Hibs are hardly PSG. Martin is also much younger at 30.


Yes, and Boyle has just recovered from a serious injury, is hardly setting the heather ablaze at Hibs, relies on pace as his main footballing asset.

Comparison to McGinn or the inane of that's what international players do, they go away etc. :rolleyes:.

I just happen to believe that Boyle's Hibs career would be better served if he concentrated on playing for Hibs, given his recent injury, diminishing effectiveness (that's up for debate), age and reliance on pace etc.

If we can jump past the Janet and John level of debate please:wink: I also understand that Boyle's not really bothered by what I think :not worth:greengrin

[CapitalGreen]

Kenneh started well with Shrewsbury but had been left out recently until last week's cup game. If we can get another £1m for him then BK is god!

That’s not correct, he’s started all but 1 league game this season which he has been available. The 4 league games plus 1 cup game where he was left out the squad are when he has been away on international duty with Liberia.

[Stairway 2 7]

It's baffling to think he wouldn't go to one of the biggest football tournaments in the world. If you'd say post the tournament there might be a discussion all be it slim

[CapitalGreen]

It's baffling to think he wouldn't go to one of the biggest football tournaments in the world. If you'd say post the tournament there might be a discussion all be it slim

It’s also incredibly entitled to think a player should pass up on possibly their last opportunity to play at a major international tournament.

[JohnM1875]

If we have even the slightest chance of getting Fish on a permanent we should be chucking money at it. Don’t think I’ve ever seen a better 20 year old centre half at Hibs.

[Nicho87]

If we have even the slightest chance of getting Fish on a permanent we should be chucking money at it. Don’t think I’ve ever seen a better 20 year old centre half at Hibs.

Boateng
























😀

[Johnny_Leith]

If we have even the slightest chance of getting Fish on a permanent we should be chucking money at it. Don’t think I’ve ever seen a better 20 year old centre half at Hibs.

Agreed. Big future in the game.

[makaveli1875]

If we have even the slightest chance of getting Fish on a permanent we should be chucking money at it. Don’t think I’ve ever seen a better 20 year old centre half at Hibs.

Porteous

[Hibernian Verse]

Porteous

Fish will go on to have a career levels above Porto IMO.

[Libby Hibby]

I said yesterday re Fish that he has to be one of the best loan signings to have played for us. Plays well every week, he’s a solid, no nonsense defender who seems to like playing for us and gets us.

I don’t think there is any chance him signing in permanently but to keep him to the end of the season would be brilliant on current form.

[Since90+2]

Fish is probably ultimately destined for the English Championship as we won't be able to compete with what some of those clubs can pay.

[Since90+2]

Fish will go on to have a career levels above Porto IMO.

Not sure about that. Porteuos is now a regular starter for the best Scotland team in generations and will be playing at the Euros next summer.

Fish is a good player but I don't see him as being better tha Porteuos at a comparable age. I think Porteuos made his debut at 17 and was a regular at 18.

[Hibernian Verse]

Not sure about that. Porteuos is now a regular starter for the best Scotland team in generations and will be playing at the Euros next summer.

Fish is a good player but I don't see him as being better tha Porteuos at a comparable age. I think Porteuos made his debut at 17 and was a regular at 18.

You can’t compare international careers between a Scotsman and an Englishman. However, I meant domestically.

My mates a Watford fan and he said he will be surprised if he’s still starting for Watford next season.

[Since90+2]

You can’t compare international careers between a Scotsman and an Englishman. However, I meant domestically.

.

That is of course correct but the level of performance Porteuos has shown in those international games does show what he is capable of. Fish has shown he can be a good player at Scottish Premier level, as of yet nothing above that.

Watford are currently 10th but only 2 points off the play off places and Porteuos starts every week. Your mate my have that opinion but fans opinions are very often incorrect, we had some fans wanting Montgomery gone only a few weeks ago as an example.

I think it's a stretch to make a claim he'll end up "levels above" Porto at this time. That would suggest he'd regularly be starting in the English Premier League. IMO that's a complete unknown as to if he'd ever reach that level.

[ChilliEater]

Being linked here:
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/sport/scottish-titans-hibernian-join-top-irish-league-trio-in-the-hunt-for-cliftonvilles-ben-wilson/a42080559.html

to a 22 year old striker at Cliftonville, although the story on the right of the page about the boy being fined for peeing through someone's letterbox is more entertaining :greengrin

[LaMotta]

Kenneh started well with Shrewsbury but had been left out recently until last week's cup game. If we can get another £1m for him then BK is god!

If we can get anything for Kenneh then it would be tremendous business. A really poor player at our level.

[Nicho87]

Yeah I don’t see enough in Kenneh

Another million for him please BK

[Puddocky]

Being linked here:
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/sport/scottish-titans-hibernian-join-top-irish-league-trio-in-the-hunt-for-cliftonvilles-ben-wilson/a42080559.html

to a 22 year old striker at Cliftonville, although the story on the right of the page about the boy being fined for peeing through someone's letterbox is more entertaining :greengrin

The peeing story isn't showing up anymore when I follow that link, so just to be clear - the letterbox guy and the striker we're linked with are two different guys, yeah?

Like 'Scottish Titans' tag though :thumbsup:

[ChilliEater]

The peeing story isn't showing up anymore when I follow that link, so just to be clear - the letterbox guy and the striker we're linked with are two different guys, yeah?

Like 'Scottish Titans' tag though :thumbsup:

There we go: https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/news/i-dont-remember-a-thing-ballycastle-man-fined-500-for-drunkenly-urinating-through-letterbox/a890035035.html

I don't think they're the same guy, but you never know.....

and "Titans" that's got to be bigger than "Big team", hasn't it? :take that:hilarious

[badabing67]

If we can get anything for Kenneh then it would be tremendous business. A really poor player at our level.


Bet you were saying exactly the same thing about Jair, give the guy a chance and see what he can do at our level.

[Unseen work]

Bet you were saying exactly the same thing about Jair, give the guy a chance and see what he can do at our level.

I think the difference is we saw a decent amount of Kenneh and he had a more than decent run of games

I just don’t think he’ll ever be comfortable enough on the ball to play centrally for us. Very good at winning it back though

[WhileTheChief..]

Bet you were saying exactly the same thing about Jair, give the guy a chance and see what he can do at our level.

He's had a chance though no?

Why not just sell him and get someone better instead of waiting to see if he'll turn good?

[Brightside]

Kenneh started well with Shrewsbury but had been left out recently until last week's cup game. If we can get another £1m for him then BK is god!

Pretty sure he’s only been dropped post international games. But we dont play a DM any more so I agree it’s likely he will move on.

[cameronw-hfc]

That is of course correct but the level of performance Porteuos has shown in those international games does show what he is capable of. Fish has shown he can be a good player at Scottish Premier level, as of yet nothing above that.

Watford are currently 10th but only 2 points off the play off places and Porteuos starts every week. Your mate my have that opinion but fans opinions are very often incorrect, we had some fans wanting Montgomery gone only a few weeks ago as an example.

I think it's a stretch to make a claim he'll end up "levels above" Porto at this time. That would suggest he'd regularly be starting in the English Premier League. IMO that's a complete unknown as to if he'd ever reach that level.


I use to work with a watford fan and kept in touch when Porto went down.

His exact words when I asked him how he's doing copy and pasted-

He's OK, plenty passion and a good character but brain farts and poor decisions let him down almost weekly


Great for Scotland, but everyone is in that team. Doesn't sound like he's doing it at club level currently and seems to be making the same errors he has at hibs

[WeeRussell]

You can’t compare international careers between a Scotsman and an Englishman. However, I meant domestically.

My mates a Watford fan and he said he will be surprised if he’s still starting for Watford next season.

I don’t think Fish will end up being better than Porteous at all, never mind levels above. Difficult to say with any certainty though.

Fish wouldn’t get near our national side (aside from not being Scottish). Porto is an important part of it. Appreciate there’s almost 4 years between them..

Porto was regarded as our best player when playing with largely the same squad as fish is now. Fish has potential and has been good for us no doubt, but he still has it to prove where Porto already has, in my opinion.

I also know a Watford fan. He was a big fan of Porteous and thought he’d been brilliant… this was in February though and I think both Watford and RP have probably went off the boil since then!

[JimBHibees]

Being linked here:
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/sport/scottish-titans-hibernian-join-top-irish-league-trio-in-the-hunt-for-cliftonvilles-ben-wilson/a42080559.html

to a 22 year old striker at Cliftonville, although the story on the right of the page about the boy being fined for peeing through someone's letterbox is more entertaining :greengrin

Scottish Titans 😃

[HUTCHYHIBBY]

I use to work with a watford fan and kept in touch when Porto went down.

His exact words when I asked him how he's doing copy and pasted-

He's OK, plenty passion and a good character but brain farts and poor decisions let him down almost weekly


Great for Scotland, but everyone is in that team. Doesn't sound like he's doing it at club level currently and seems to be making the same errors he has at hibs

Is that Watford fan a football genius or a fud? 😉

[JohnM1875]

Not sure about that. Porteuos is now a regular starter for the best Scotland team in generations and will be playing at the Euros next summer.

Fish is a good player but I don't see him as being better tha Porteuos at a comparable age. I think Porteuos made his debut at 17 and was a regular at 18.

I think Fish is already better than Porto. At the defending side of the game anyway. Porto definitely uses the ball better.

[erin go bragh]

Armstrong from Killie would be a great signing imo.

[jeffers]

I think Fish is already better than Porto. At the defending side of the game anyway. Porto definitely uses the ball better.

Porto much better for me, but his nonsense lets him down.

[GreenPJ]

Armstrong from Killie would be a great signing imo.

👍

[cameronw-hfc]

Is that Watford fan a football genius or a fud? 😉

😂, he seems to genuinely like him, just does his head in with his rash moments, which he was prone to here as well.

[04Sauzee]

Armstrong from Killie would be a great signing imo.

18 months left on his contract, would take a fair amount of money I'd guess. Think he'd suit Hibs, fair amount of pace , creates chances and isn't the worst defensively.

[Donegal Hibby]

Porto would be better driving forward with the ball and passer though Fish imo is a more solid defender with a better attitude . I'd have Fish over Porto every day of the week.

[Since90+2]

Porto would be better driving forward with the ball and passer though Fish imo is a more solid defender with a better attitude . I'd have Fish over Porto every day of the week.

Porto's attitude is absolutely top drawer.

Not saying Fish doesn't have that, but if there was one thing about Porteuos you could say was he never in awe or overawed at anything. Laddie was absolutely fearless.

[Donegal Hibby]

Porto's attitude is absolutely top drawer.

Not saying Fish doesn't have that, but if there was one thing about Porteuos you could say was he never in awe or overawed at anything. Laddie was absolutely fearless.

Agree about him being fearless though still think the shouting at his own teammates , throwing himself about looking for freekicks his attitude wasn't right especially last 3 or 4 months he was here .

In saying that if he ever became available I take him back alright though I don't think we have missed him since we got Fish . Both are good though I think Fish is a more solid defender .

[The Modfather]

18 months left on his contract, would take a fair amount of money I'd guess. Think he'd suit Hibs, fair amount of pace , creates chances and isn't the worst defensively.

Maybe we could offer them another of our perma injured midfielders in JDH as part of the deal 😀

[Smartie]

😂, he seems to genuinely like him, just does his head in with his rash moments, which he was prone to here as well.

That’s what I was like with him tbh. Loved so much about him and felt that with a wee screw of the nut he had (still very much has) the potential to be a genuinely top class player.

Some of his decisions though…

Which he doesn’t seem to have for Scotland, which begs the question what they’re all about?

I’d put Fish in a similar bracket tbh. Both are excellent players and ver the years we won’t get that many that much better.

[BS44]

The peeing story isn't showing up anymore when I follow that link, so just to be clear - the letterbox guy and the striker we're linked with are two different guys, yeah?

Like 'Scottish Titans' tag though :thumbsup:

Titans is shortened a bit when they talk about the tarts.

[LaMotta]

Bet you were saying exactly the same thing about Jair, give the guy a chance and see what he can do at our level.

I wasn't actually:na na:. There wasn't enough evidence to confirm either way from Jair's limited time on the pitch. Kenneh had plenty of chances at this level though. It was seriously worrying when Kenneh struggled against part time opposition in the league cup shambles last season - and some of his league performances were dreadful. That attempt at tracking back at Livvy last year when Nouble scored was so bad it was unreal.

[Unseen work]

https://www.footballscotland.co.uk/spfl/scottish-premiership/musa-toure-hibs-transfer-interest-28273367

Montgomery comfirms Toure is a player we’re interested in/looking at.

Not many clips of him but for those with TikTok he posts some Elie Youan esque clips - Musa2re69 is his account

[Callum_62]

https://www.footballscotland.co.uk/spfl/scottish-premiership/musa-toure-hibs-transfer-interest-28273367

Montgomery comfirms Toure is a player we’re interested in/looking at.

Not many clips of him but for those with TikTok he posts some Elie Youan esque clips - Musa2re69 is his accountWonder how is injury is

With the manager confirming I imagine we think we have him

Edit - fromn another thread he's out for atleast 1 month
Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[allezsauzee]

I think Fish is already better than Porto. At the defending side of the game anyway. Porto definitely uses the ball better.

I'd agree and he's played less than 50 first team games. If he has reasonable luck with injuries I'll think he'll be playing at a higher level than Porto in a couple of years.

[04Sauzee]

Fancy Tom McIntyre will be out the door at Reading come the summer. I think he was linked with a Scottish club in the summer, not saying it was Hibs mind. I know he can play LCB and LB. He was highly rated a fews seasons ago. No idea if he has been injured or dropped recently. Wonder if it could be the kind of player we'd potentially be interested in.

[HoboHarry]

Fancy Tom McIntyre will be out the door at Reading come the summer. I think he was linked with a Scottish club in the summer, not saying it was Hibs mind. I know he can play LCB and LB. He was highly rated a fews seasons ago. No idea if he has been injured or dropped recently. Wonder if it could be the kind of player we'd potentially be interested in.
Jeezo is he still playing? Seems like a lifetime ago he was scoring in the final against Dumfermline.....

[Eyrie]

Jeezo is he still playing? Seems like a lifetime ago he was scoring in the final against Dumfermline.....

Not just me that thought that then :greengrin

[ancient hibee]

Not just me that thought that then :greengrin

I thought he’s had some career-almost as long as Roy Race.

[HoboHarry]

Not just me that thought that then :greengrin

:greengrin

[Basildon Hibs]

We need a couple of tough midfielders.

[Vault Boy]

We need a couple of tough midfielders.

Jeggo is pretty tough but he’s an impact sub at the minute, with two in the middle I’m not sure that’s really what we’re missing tbh. We need a forward and a left back. In an ideal world, a keeper and left sided centre half too.

Longer term, I’d like to see improvements in the midfield, but I can’t see it being a priority for Jan.

[Onceinawhile]

I thought he’s had some career-almost as long as Roy Race.

I'll never forgive that Judas for leaving melchester

[LaMotta]

I'll never forgive that Judas for leaving melchester

Blackie Gray was a better player anyway. :greengrin

[Allant1981]

Jeggo is pretty tough but he’s an impact sub at the minute, with two in the middle I’m not sure that’s really what we’re missing tbh. We need a forward and a left back. In an ideal world, a keeper and left sided centre half too.

Longer term, I’d like to see improvements in the midfield, but I can’t see it being a priority for Jan.

Obita is doing just fine at LB in my opinion,

[Unseen work]

Obita is doing just fine at LB in my opinion,

Obita is a class act imo and so underrated it’s criminal.

Lovely left foot, composed, athletic and good defensively.

A younger player to compete/cover for him as he picks up some niggles maybe or maybe a cheaper option - Penrice? As I don’t think Stevenson suits the current style and is getting on a bit

[Dmas]

Obita is a class act imo and so underrated it’s criminal.

Lovely left foot, composed, athletic and good defensively.

A younger player to compete/cover for him as he picks up some niggles maybe or maybe a cheaper option - Penrice? As I don’t think Stevenson suits the current style and is getting on a bit

LB essential IMO I like obita but as you say some young blood to compete with him is important I can’t see Stevenson being around next year so we’re short.

On that anyone any idea how Macintyre is doing at QOS? could we call him back and give him a few months see if he can be the answer?

[neil7908]

We need a couple of tough midfielders.

I'm not sure it's a priority given how the manager has us playing.

Unless they can pass a ball and dictate play that is. Very hard to find big, tough tacking midfielders who can also pass at our level though.

[Vault Boy]

Obita is doing just fine at LB in my opinion,

I agree, we’re just short in depth there and Obita does pick up a few niggles. Both players at LB are 30+ so we need to be prepared.

[JimBHibees]

I agree, we’re just short in depth there and Obita does pick up a few niggles. Both players at LB are 30+ so we need to be prepared.

Obita does seem to pick up an injury or two

[Mcbizz1998]

I agree, we’re just short in depth there and Obita does pick up a few niggles. Both players at LB are 30+ so we need to be prepared.

Agree, I really rate Obita but we need solid back up for him. Would be pleased if we could strengthen that area in Jan.

[Onceinawhile]

Obita is a class act imo and so underrated it’s criminal.

Lovely left foot, composed, athletic and good defensively.

A younger player to compete/cover for him as he picks up some niggles maybe or maybe a cheaper option - Penrice? As I don’t think Stevenson suits the current style and is getting on a bit

I heard a small rumour that we were in for Penrice. But it was 3rd hand info, so no idea if it's true or not.

[Gordy M]

Agree, I really rate Obita but we need solid back up for him. Would be pleased if we could strengthen that area in Jan.

Whilst you are right, this is where i think clubs like ourselves are in a tricky position. How much do we spend on a left back who is 2nd choice? And who is going to sign to sit on the bench? Are we then lowering the quality of the squad, or do we spend bigger amounts and Obita is 2nd choice? Ideally we would have a youngster waiting in the wings to step in when needed.

[Chip shop Joe]

I heard a small rumour that we were in for Penrice. But it was 3rd hand info, so no idea if it's true or not.

Was watching Penrice at Livi. He can certainly whip in a cross and this is something we have not had in left back/midfielder for a good while.

[superfurryhibby]

Was watching Penrice at Livi. He can certainly whip in a cross and this is something we have not had in left back/midfielder for a good while.

Obita delivers a lovely crossed ball?

[JimBHibees]

Was watching Penrice at Livi. He can certainly whip in a cross and this is something we have not had in left back/midfielder for a good while.

So can Obita

[NC1875]

Agree, I really rate Obita but we need solid back up for him. Would be pleased if we could strengthen that area in Jan.

Jacob Farrell is one I heard NM wants but not heard anymore about it.

[Unseen work]

https://x.com/archiemeldrum75/status/1734928381886505325?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

This guys looks like what most are saying we’re missing in the middle of the park..

[Hibernian Verse]

https://x.com/archiemeldrum75/status/1734928381886505325?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

This guys looks like what most are saying we’re missing in the middle of the park..

Pfft he is part of the midfield problem that has us 4th, have you not been keeping up?

[CapitalGreen]

https://x.com/archiemeldrum75/status/1734928381886505325?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

This guys looks like what most are saying we’re missing in the middle of the park..

Would be nice to see some highlights from games against the Old Firm or Hearts.

[A Hi-Bee]

We need to hold fire on hopes this transfer window at least until we see what the new investment looks like it could be a real game changer and pretty sure Hibs will be prepared for this.

[K-Zazu]

Josh Doig loan? Looks to be out of the picture at Verona recently? Not sure if the manager their doesn’t fancy him not sure

[Caversham Green]

Jeezo is he still playing? Seems like a lifetime ago he was scoring in the final against Dumfermline.....

I did wonder if he was related when he first appeared at Reading. He's locally born but his father is Scottish and young Tom has played for under-age Scottish national sides.

I haven't seen him play since lockdown but he looked very promising as a teenager. Definitely a centre half rather than a full back IMO.

[Unseen work]

Would be nice to see some highlights from games against the Old Firm or Hearts.

You would if you watched more than 4 seconds

[HendoDelivered]

Josh Doig loan? Looks to be out of the picture at Verona recently? Not sure if the manager their doesn’t fancy him not sure

No chance, Josh has no intentions of coming back to Scotland anytime soon.

[Tambo]

I see Hibs have posted a video on twitter with Mckirdy playing snooker with Fish.

Any news on when he'll be back training? New year maybe?

[CapitalGreen]

I see Hibs have posted a video on twitter with Mckirdy playing snooker with Fish.

Any news on when he'll be back training? New year maybe?

He’s been back training for quite a while, not sure what level of training that’s been ramped up to but he’s definitely been involved outside with the squad.

[HoboHarry]

We need to hold fire on hopes this transfer window at least until we see what the new investment looks like it could be a real game changer and pretty sure Hibs will be prepared for this.
Aye right, if we havnae re-signed McGinn and Messi for a back up by the second week of January, Foley can sling his hook.....

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Anyone know if there's drop dead date for United to trigger will fish return?

Last thing we need is a month of uncertainty and recalled in the last days/hours because they want to rent him out to a higher level

[Forza Fred]

Jeggo is pretty tough but he’s an impact sub at the minute, with two in the middle I’m not sure that’s really what we’re missing tbh. We need a forward and a left back. In an ideal world, a keeper and left sided centre half too.

Longer term, I’d like to see improvements in the midfield, but I can’t see it being a priority for Jan.

Jacob Farrell is a left back.

Best one in Australia just now, but has a year to run on his contract and would incur a fee Hibs may not wish to pay

[Blaster]

I see Hibs have posted a video on twitter with Mckirdy playing snooker with Fish.

Any news on when he'll be back training? New year maybe?

Be better playing with a snooker cue…..

[HoboHarry]

Be better playing with a snooker cue…..

A swordfish might work?

[Blaster]

A swordfish might work?

True

[MagicSwirlingShip]

Jacob Farrell is a left back.

Best one in Australia just now, but has a year to run on his contract and would incur a fee Hibs may not wish to pay

Melkerson cash might make this fee possible Fred. What do you think you would be looking for?

[Gmack7]

Anyone know if there's drop dead date for United to trigger will fish return?

Last thing we need is a month of uncertainty and recalled in the last days/hours because they want to rent him out to a higher level

The way they are leaking goals he might go straight into the 1st team

[Bridge hibs]

I see Hibs have posted a video on twitter with Mckirdy playing snooker with Fish.



Aw **** is he new to snooker, he would get on better if he used balls instead of fish !

[Real Emerald]

Aw **** is he new to snooker, he would get on better if he used balls instead of fish !

I saw Kirk Stevens playing snooker with a mullet.

[AlbertK86]

Obita is doing just fine at LB in my opinion,

Agree … Obita very good going forward and strong at the back


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[AlbertK86]

Obita delivers a lovely crossed ball?

Correct


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ddoc]

Correct


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


As does Chris Cadden. looking forward to him being back in the squad and seeing what he can bring to the team under this management team.

[Hibbyradge]

I saw Kirk Stevens playing snooker with a mullet.

👍

[Auckland Hibs]

I saw Kirk Stevens playing snooker with a mullet.

👌

[Tambo]

Aw **** is he new to snooker, he would get on better if he used balls instead of fish !

The fish slithered into the tight pockets, Harry did look healthy and in good spirit. Not that it's the same as real life but on my Hibs save on FM24 mobile he was available for selection in January.

[JimBHibees]

Jacob Farrell is a left back.

Best one in Australia just now, but has a year to run on his contract and would incur a fee Hibs may not wish to pay

Be surprised if we weren't in for him.

[04Sauzee]

🗣️"He’s still got a lot of developing to go before he goes overseas."

Hibs told Musa Toure going nowhere as Adelaide United to trigger new contract and fend off transfer interest

📎footballscotland.co.uk/spfl/scottish-…

[tonyrougier123]

Will Dennis at kille anyone? Been liking look of him between the sticks.

[Hibernian Verse]

Will Dennis at kille anyone? Been liking look of him between the sticks.

Not for me. Three absolute howlers recently, one versus us where Campbell megged him, and two own goals.

[Edinburgh Green]

Will Dennis at kille anyone? Been liking look of him between the sticks.

Killie fans think he's rotten.

[GloryGlory]

Will Dennis at kille anyone? Been liking look of him between the sticks.

I wouldn't think goalie is a priority recruitment area just now. We brought in Wollacott and Boruc in the summer and Murray Johnstone is on loan but still in the plans.

[Jones28]

I wouldn't think goalie is a priority recruitment area just now. We brought in Wollacott and Boruc in the summer and Murray Johnstone is on loan but still in the plans.

If all goes well and they all develop to reach their potential then we shouldn't need to worry about GK for a good wee while.

[Not In The Know]

I suppose the big question is will the new investment go through in time for the Jan window? if not should the club spend the cash anyway as they know its coming in the next couple of months? Id hope they would..

[King Cosell]

I suppose the big question is will the new investment go through in time for the Jan window? if not should the club spend the cash anyway as they know its coming in the next couple of months? Id hope they would..

We'll almost certainly be getting 1 or 2 players on loan from Bouremouth, no reason why that can't go through early.

[Trinity Hibee]

We'll almost certainly be getting 1 or 2 players on loan from Bouremouth, no reason why that can't go through early.

Do you think? Has that been mentioned in all of the recent coverage?

[matty_f]

Do you think? Has that been mentioned in all of the recent coverage?

I’m sure I read that Bournemouth signed a player for £15m and immediately loaned him to Lorient, so if that’s the case I wouldn’t be surprised to see players come here.

[Trinity Hibee]

I’m sure I read that Bournemouth signed a player for £15m and immediately loaned him to Lorient, so if that’s the case I wouldn’t be surprised to see players come here.

Fair enough, might be our best option at the moment given getting the Foley deal through and getting signings in might be a struggle for January given timescales

[badabing67]

I wouldn't think goalie is a priority recruitment area just now. We brought in Wollacott and Boruc in the summer and Murray Johnstone is on loan but still in the plans.

I got to be honest I was wanting a new goalie for a while but Marshy has turned it round. So i agree with this

[Not In The Know]

Hamed Junior Traorè would be a good option.

[CapitalGreen]

Hamed Junior Traorè would be a good option.

So would Solanke while we are at it.

[worcesterhibby]

In truth we are far more likely to get players from Bournemouths development squad.

Baylin Johnson - forward who has been on Loan in Italy to Lecce.. has just returned to Bournemouth - Only 5 appearances and didn't really make an impact, but interesting back history wit Arsenal

Lewis Brown - Midfielder who they have high hopes for.

Gavin Kilkenny is a forward who is currently on loan at Charlton and getting limited opportunities, played against us in the pre-season match

As "Not in the know" has mentioned above Traore would be a very good shout. Attacking midfielder who they bought last year but who is struggling to get minutes in their first team.

[Hibernian Verse]

In truth we are far more likely to get players from Bournemouths development squad.

Baylin Johnson - forward who has been on Loan in Italy to Lecce.. has just returned to Bournemouth - Only 5 appearances and didn't really make an impact, but interesting back history wit Arsenal

Lewis Brown - Midfielder who they have high hopes for.

Gavin Kilkenny is a forward who is currently on loan at Charlton and getting limited opportunities, played against us in the pre-season match

That doesn't fit with Monty's understanding going by his remarks about shopping in a new market.

[worcesterhibby]

That doesn't fit with Monty's understanding going by his remarks about shopping in a new market.

I think there are a number of possibilities.. 1)Bournemouth buy players and then loan them to us (as they have done with Lorient) 2)Hibs buy players from new markets at higher prices than previously...3) Bournemouth loan us existing players that are better than we have, but can't get in their team.

in the above I was only talking about the third of those options.

[Hibiza]

I saw Kirk Stevens playing snooker with a mullet.

😃

[bingo70]

That doesn't fit with Monty's understanding going by his remarks about shopping in a new market.

I think there’s two types of loans you can get from Premiership clubs, like Bournemouth.

Development players who have no chance of making it with them but are under good contracts and are just seeing out there time there. That’s the kind of loans we currently get from these clubs.

Development/Fringe players who they’ve got high hopes for but not able to break into the team just now. I think this is the kind of loan signing we will be hoping for from them going forward.

[King Cosell]

I think there’s two types of loans you can get from Premiership clubs, like Bournemouth.

Development players who have no chance of making it with them but are under good contracts and are just seeing out there time there. That’s the kind of loans we currently get from these clubs.

Development/Fringe players who they’ve got high hopes for but not able to break into the team just now. I think this is the kind of loan signing we will be hoping for from them going forward.

If you look at their squad on Transfermarkt, it's far stronger than Rangers' or Celtic's, so another type of player might be players not part of their plans, want to stay in UK, worth a few million, and a move to us puts them in the shop window.

[Tambo]

In truth we are far more likely to get players from Bournemouths development squad.

Baylin Johnson - forward who has been on Loan in Italy to Lecce.. has just returned to Bournemouth - Only 5 appearances and didn't really make an impact, but interesting back history wit Arsenal

Lewis Brown - Midfielder who they have high hopes for.

Gavin Kilkenny is a forward who is currently on loan at Charlton and getting limited opportunities, played against us in the pre-season match

As "Not in the know" has mentioned above Traore would be a very good shout. Attacking midfielder who they bought last year but who is struggling to get minutes in their first team.

What kind of midfielder is Lewis Brown?

[Hibbyradge]

If you look at their squad on Transfermarkt, it's far stronger than Rangers' or Celtic's, so another type of player might be players not part of their plans, want to stay in UK, worth a few million, and a move to us puts them in the shop window.

Excellent punctuation. Definitely Hibs class.

:not worth

[Bad Habits]

Hamed Traore would be phenomenal at this level, unfortunately I can't see it :(

[HoboHarry]

Excellent punctuation. Definitely Hibs class.

:not worth
Pfffffttttt, his fechin dad's a Tory and went tae a private school mair like....

[007]

Imagine Bournemouth meeting the asking price for Shankland then loaning him to us. 🤔

[PHeffernan]

I saw Kirk Stevens playing snooker with a mullet.

Do you still have it?!

[Unseen work]

Hopefully the investment is done soon.

Need a lot of quality in January, our starting 11 and bench needs a lot of additions

[Chip shop Joe]

Imagine Bournemouth meeting the asking price for Shankland then loaning him to us. 🤔

Monty would probably play him left back😃

[500miles]

We need another player who can do a bit of everything like Newell and drive forward with the ball at his feet. While Jeggo and Levitt both have some excellent qualities, we lack a driving force in the middle of the park without Newell. Jamie Lindsay is a player who I admired at Ross County years ago who seems to flit between the Championship and League 1 down south and isn't getting as much game time these days. Maybe Baccus could be an option, but he seems to be used more defensively by St Mirren.

Depending on his recovery, I think Murray Aiken could be recalled and fit that mould.

If we want to play 2 in the middle, we need these kinds of players and there isn't many about.

[Hibs4185]

If we are playing 4 forwards, Vente, Boyle, Youan and Jair, there is no way we can play 4-4-2.

4 attack minded players and 4 defenders, leaves 2 midfielders.

I’m no expert but if Jeggo and Levitt are the midfield then it’s no wonder the forward players are getting supplied.

Newell does bridge the gap a bit better but either the squad doesn’t fit the managers plans or the manager doesn’t fit the squads attributes.

We badly need a better midfield or I think it’s going to get tricky for NM pretty quickly

[Trinity Hibee]

I thought 4-3-3 was what suited our attack best? Boyle Vente and Youan. Still leaves you 3 in the middle of the pitch.

I’m a fan of the old 4-4-2 but the front 4 currently playing there doesn’t really work. No physical presence up top and the wingers aren’t much defensively.

[eastmainsmsh]

I thought 4-3-3 was what suited our attack best? Boyle Vente and Youan. Still leaves you 3 in the middle of the pitch.

I’m a fan of the old 4-4-2 but the front 4 currently playing there doesn’t really work. No physical presence up top and the wingers aren’t much defensively.

4-3-3 would suit us better

[eastmainsmsh]

I thought 4-3-3 was what suited our attack best? Boyle Vente and Youan. Still leaves you 3 in the middle of the pitch.

I’m a fan of the old 4-4-2 but the front 4 currently playing there doesn’t really work. No physical presence up top and the wingers aren’t much defensively.

4-3-3 would suit us better

[McGruber]

I think we do have good players and we have been getting results in spite of the 4-4-2 not because of it. I think we would have won the same points and more with other formations and looked a more rounded team.

The other teams in the league must be delighted we have adopted a system and formation that doesn't lend to Boyle, Youan and Vente's strengths

Whether you think 442 is right or not in the modern game, or for this set of players might be up for debate.
What isn't up for debate is that you can't have one formation for every game in every circumstance. I really like Montgomery and hope he learns to be flexible

[JammyDoidger]

I think we do have good players and we have been getting results in spite of the 4-4-2 not because of it. I think we would have won the same points and more with other formations and looked a more rounded team.

The other teams in the league must be delighted we have adopted a system and formation that doesn't lend to Boyle, Youan and Vente's strengths

Whether you think 442 is right or not in the modern game, or for this set of players might be up for debate.
What isn't up for debate is that you can't have one formation for every game in every circumstance. I really like Montgomery and hope he learns to be flexible

This! I don't get why you can't still adopt the same philosophy and principles in a different formation that suits the players you've got. You don't need to play 4-4-2 in order to play out from the back for example.

[Hibbyradge]

Pfffffttttt, his fechin dad's a Tory and went tae a private school mair like....

He's a King. What did you expect? :rolleyes:

[neil7908]

This! I don't get why you can't still adopt the same philosophy and principles in a different formation that suits the players you've got. You don't need to play 4-4-2 in order to play out from the back for example.

The thing is, players move around in game, regardless of how you set the play up. Strikers come deep, fullbacks push up, midfielders get into the box etc.

I think too much is made about formation. I just don't think we have the standard needed to play a passing game. Folk are talking about playing more direct and quicker.

Direct sounds to me like long ball. To Vente and Boyle.

Quick passing is not easy for a mid table SPL side.

[JammyDoidger]

The thing is, players move around in game, regardless of how you set the play up. Strikers come deep, fullbacks push up, midfielders get into the box etc.

I think too much is made about formation. I just don't think we have the standard needed to play a passing game. Folk are talking about playing more direct and quicker.

Direct sounds to me like long ball. To Vente and Boyle.

Quick passing is not easy for a mid table SPL side.

In a 4-4-2 your wide men will do a lot more defensive work, their starting or base positions will be deeper than in the 4-3-3, in a 4-3-3 you've got the extra man in midfield covering. We don't want Boyle, Youan Tavares even vente doing much defensive work. Leave them high in a 4-3-3 and bring in a bit more protection behind them.
A 4-3-3 would allow Levitt to play a bit higher aswell, I honestly don't think his game is a deep playing playmaker, he needs to play much higher up the park. So many players being wasted in this team atm, Monty won't change though. This is going to be it, so we better get used to it.
Midfield is where most games are won and when we are 2 against 3 in there every week we are up against it. 3-5-2 and 4-3-3 is what we should be switching between imo depending on opposition, if you look at teams that have been successful in Scotland recently it's in these shapes. We always try and be too clever imo, we are that desperate to be different.

[blackpoolhibs]

In a 4-4-2 your wide men will do a lot more defensive work, their starting or base positions will be deeper than in the 4-3-3, in a 4-3-3 you've got the extra man in midfield covering. We don't want Boyle, Youan Tavares even vente doing much defensive work. Leave them high in a 4-3-3 and bring in a bit more protection behind them.
A 4-3-3 would allow Levitt to play a bit higher aswell, I honestly don't think his game is a deep playing playmaker, he needs to play much higher up the park. So many players being wasted in this team atm, Monty won't change though. This is going to be it, so we better get used to it.
Midfield is where most games are won and when we are 2 against 3 in there every week we are up against it. 3-5-2 and 4-3-3 is what we should be switching between imo depending on opposition, if you look at teams that have been successful in Scotland recently it's in these shapes. We always try and be too clever imo, we are that desperate to be different.

Spot on, we get outnumbered most games because our wide men either get tired or lazy. We've got away with it too many times for it to last, we give up too many chances for the opposition, but dont create nearly enough of our own to say its too successful to keep in my opinion.

[The Modfather]

In a 4-4-2 your wide men will do a lot more defensive work, their starting or base positions will be deeper than in the 4-3-3, in a 4-3-3 you've got the extra man in midfield covering. We don't want Boyle, Youan Tavares even vente doing much defensive work. Leave them high in a 4-3-3 and bring in a bit more protection behind them.
A 4-3-3 would allow Levitt to play a bit higher aswell, I honestly don't think his game is a deep playing playmaker, he needs to play much higher up the park. So many players being wasted in this team atm, Monty won't change though. This is going to be it, so we better get used to it.
Midfield is where most games are won and when we are 2 against 3 in there every week we are up against it. 3-5-2 and 4-3-3 is what we should be switching between imo depending on opposition, if you look at teams that have been successful in Scotland recently it's in these shapes. We always try and be too clever imo, we are that desperate to be different.

These players have either seen of numerous managers or just Johnson. They also fluctuated from winning streaks to losing streaks last season, losing to every team in the league and starting the season off with 3 league defeats and even worse performances.

There’s not anyone I’d worry about losing or not take money for. I think it’s time to stick with a manager who has a set formation and way of playing. For me the players are playing for their future. Lots of them are stars on paper, however if the likes of Boyle, Youan, Levit etc don’t start consistently performing in this formations I’d back Montgomery to start moving them out as starters and eventually move them on. Making space and budget for players that can fit into a Montgomery team and finally begin to show some consistency.

[blackpoolhibs]

These players have either seen of numerous managers or just Johnson. They also fluctuated from winning streaks to losing streaks last season, losing to every team in the league and starting the season off with 3 league defeats and even worse performances.

There’s not anyone I’d worry about losing or not take money for. I think it’s time to stick with a manager who has a set formation and way of playing. For me the players are playing for their future. Lots of them are stars on paper, however if the likes of Boyle, Youan, Levit etc don’t start consistently performing in this formations I’d back Montgomery to start moving them out as starters and eventually move them on. Making space and budget for players that can fit into a Montgomery team and finally begin to show some consistency.

Thats my hope for the future.:agree:

[Eaststand]

These players have either seen of numerous managers or just Johnson. They also fluctuated from winning streaks to losing streaks last season, losing to every team in the league and starting the season off with 3 league defeats and even worse performances.

There’s not anyone I’d worry about losing or not take money for. I think it’s time to stick with a manager who has a set formation and way of playing. For me the players are playing for their future. Lots of them are stars on paper, however if the likes of Boyle, Youan, Levit etc don’t start consistently performing in this formations I’d back Montgomery to start moving them out as starters and eventually move them on. Making space and budget for players that can fit into a Montgomery team and finally begin to show some consistency.

Yep, I agree with you 100%

GGTTH

[greenlex]

These players have either seen of numerous managers or just Johnson. They also fluctuated from winning streaks to losing streaks last season, losing to every team in the league and starting the season off with 3 league defeats and even worse performances.

There’s not anyone I’d worry about losing or not take money for. I think it’s time to stick with a manager who has a set formation and way of playing. For me the players are playing for their future. Lots of them are stars on paper, however if the likes of Boyle, Youan, Levit etc don’t start consistently performing in this formations I’d back Montgomery to start moving them out as starters and eventually move them on. Making space and budget for players that can fit into a Montgomery team and finally begin to show some consistency.
And another.

[Unseen work]

Watched the last half an hour of the Central Coast Mariners this morning - was interested in seeing a couple of players were linked with.

The stand out was Nisbet who was playing in a more advanced role. Pretty much one of the front 2 that would drop deep into the hole like Campbell was doing for us in the 442.

His height never seemed an issue, very good and comfortable on the ball and something that I really like was his movement off the ball - drifting into wide areas, going in behind, dropping deep.

Albeit think under Monty he was one of the midfield 2 so would likely play there for us. But his ability to turn or go past a man could be beneficial.

Farrell never had a huge amount to do from what I saw but the commentators were raving about him (and Nisbet). His build and running style reminds me of Callum Booth, looked comfortable on the ball and solid enough defensively however I’d argue it was his decision making that lead to the equaliser

[Real Emerald]

In a 4-4-2 your wide men will do a lot more defensive work, their starting or base positions will be deeper than in the 4-3-3, in a 4-3-3 you've got the extra man in midfield covering. We don't want Boyle, Youan Tavares even vente doing much defensive work. Leave them high in a 4-3-3 and bring in a bit more protection behind them.
A 4-3-3 would allow Levitt to play a bit higher aswell, I honestly don't think his game is a deep playing playmaker, he needs to play much higher up the park. So many players being wasted in this team atm, Monty won't change though. This is going to be it, so we better get used to it.
Midfield is where most games are won and when we are 2 against 3 in there every week we are up against it. 3-5-2 and 4-3-3 is what we should be switching between imo depending on opposition, if you look at teams that have been successful in Scotland recently it's in these shapes. We always try and be too clever imo, we are that desperate to be different.

This 100%.

You can’t expect to play with Jair, Boyle, Youan and Vente in the team and expect a 442 to work. On top of that we have one centre mid and a defensive mid. It’s basically playing without a midfield and he expects them to pass out from the back with nowhere to go. He either needs players to work his system or change it for now until we do.

[bingo70]

This 100%.

You can’t expect to play with Jair, Boyle, Youan and Vente in the team and expect a 442 to work. On top of that we have one centre mid and a defensive mid. It’s basically playing without a midfield and he expects them to pass out from the back with nowhere to go. He either needs players to work his system or change it for now until we do.

Why is playing with one centre midfielder and one defensive midfielder basically playing with no midfield?

[Real Emerald]

Why is playing with one centre midfielder and one defensive midfielder basically playing with no midfield?

Because we’re normally up against 3 in midfield. I’m obviously exaggerating the fact but our midfield becomes overwhelmed, you know what I mean. 😀

[Hibiza]

Foley mega million investment and Epl starlets on loan - probably just a folly dream .

[andrew70]

Watched the last half an hour of the Central Coast Mariners this morning - was interested in seeing a couple of players were linked with.

The stand out was Nisbet who was playing in a more advanced role. Pretty much one of the front 2 that would drop deep into the hole like Campbell was doing for us in the 442.

His height never seemed an issue, very good and comfortable on the ball and something that I really like was his movement off the ball - drifting into wide areas, going in behind, dropping deep.

Albeit think under Monty he was one of the midfield 2 so would likely play there for us. But his ability to turn or go past a man could be beneficial.

Farrell never had a huge amount to do from what I saw but the commentators were raving about him (and Nisbet). His build and running style reminds me of Callum Booth, looked comfortable on the ball and solid enough defensively however I’d argue it was his decision making that lead to the equaliser

Nisbet would be a fantastic signing. Very astute in everything he does. Has high stats on and off the ball.

[neil7908]

This 100%.

You can’t expect to play with Jair, Boyle, Youan and Vente in the team and expect a 442 to work. On top of that we have one centre mid and a defensive mid. It’s basically playing without a midfield and he expects them to pass out from the back with nowhere to go. He either needs players to work his system or change it for now until we do.

But generally it has worked. We've just lost our first game under the new manager to a team outwith the OF.

I'm not saying we're the finished article by any means but folk are talking like he's lost 5 on the bounce.

[marinello59]

But generally it has worked. We've just lost our first game under the new manager to a team outwith the OF.

I'm not saying we're the finished article by any means but folk are talking like he's lost 5 on the bounce.

:agree:

[Real Emerald]

But generally it has worked. We've just lost our first game under the new manager to a team outwith the OF.

I'm not saying we're the finished article by any means but folk are talking like he's lost 5 on the bounce.

I’m not saying we’re the finished article either. He needs to get his own players in but he also needs to adapt. Managers get praised for changing things within games if it’s not working and counter acting opponents tactics. You can’t just keep flogging a dead horse, he got lucky v Aberdeen and Livi and Celtic could have had a barrow load. Setting up with 4 forward and starving them of service is really poor. Was it 3 shots on target v Livi and St J combined? Mmm

[Forza Fred]

Nisbet would be a fantastic signing. Very astute in everything he does. Has high stats on and off the ball.

Only thing that discourages overseas clubs signing Josh is his height..or lack of it…at 5’3”………but he would definitely be the hardest working midfielder in our squad if we signed him.

As for Farrell…..Hibs have known about him since before they signed Miller but haven’t yet made a move for him.

I think this window may well be their last opportunity as he’s being talked about as the next on the overseas conveyor belt.

Having said that, Farrell is a very shy, quiet laddie who may not wish to leave the comfortable lifestyle he enjoys on the NSW Central Coast….he nearly left the game a few years ago, and hasn’t expressed any public overseas ambitions……and indeed he’s not someone who is comfortable sticking his head in front of a camera……but he is undoubtedly the best left back in Australia at the moment, and although skinny, is as tough as nails.

Guess we’ll see soon enough if any of Nisbet, Farrell and/or Tullio are on Monty’s wish list

[JimBHibees]

But generally it has worked. We've just lost our first game under the new manager to a team outwith the OF.

I'm not saying we're the finished article by any means but folk are talking like he's lost 5 on the bounce.

Absolutely. He was getting criticised early doors for drawing games we should have won, then started winning now it's style. Desperate to criticise.

[Greenio]

After any loss there is % of fans that will overreact - players are awful, formation is wrong, manager is clueless, club is directionless etc etc

Not saying they dont have the the right to a pov, of course they do.

Fact is we played badly overall, made a silly mistake and took zero form the game - it happens.

What the match did tell me was that Newell missing was a big miss, Rocky can really get forward very well if he's given the instructions to. Boyle, Jair and Youhan are all way below where they can and should be

I expect us to come back form this with a win

[Forza Fred]

Haven’t heard anything to suggest it’s going to happen, but if you join the dots….

Marco Tilio is considered not up to it at Celtic and given he’s not going to get any game time there it’s logical he’ll be sent out on loan.

Now, I don’t fancy him, but Monty may.

[keep the faith]

Maybe Monty could use his contacts to bring back all time A league top goalscorer Jamie MacLaren!

[McGruber]

But generally it has worked. We've just lost our first game under the new manager to a team outwith the OF.

I'm not saying we're the finished article by any means but folk are talking like he's lost 5 on the bounce.

We can win games in 442 and have been and we can also win those games with other formations. I think we win those more convincingly playing in a set up that suits our better players more. I'm not hung up on the label of formations, more that Vente is playing deep with Boyle and Youan wide right or left. Having the extra man in the middle pushes those 3 higher up the pitch and personally what I want to see as think they are our best attackers - even though Jair came on massively. Also think playing those 4 is too much and leaves too much graft for the others covering. That said we have still been getting results, we have good players - we just make it more difficult for them IMO

[Springbank]

After any loss there is % of fans that will overreact - players are awful, formation is wrong, manager is clueless, club is directionless etc etc

Not saying they dont have the the right to a pov, of course they do.

Fact is we played badly overall, made a silly mistake and took zero form the game - it happens.

What the match did tell me was that Newell missing was a big miss, Rocky can really get forward very well if he's given the instructions to. Boyle, Jair and Youhan are all way below where they can and should be

I expect us to come back form this with a win

I think I've seen enough in games we haven't lost recently (such as Ross County 2-2) to see what we have on our hands with Dylan Levitt and the ageing stalwarts at the back.

It's far from all doom, as NM and his coaching team have really brought a different improved dimension to Jair's game (and he looks a real asset now).

The puzzle for me is how Vente has gone from having a Next-Level workrate (when he first joined) to what we see with our eyes now, and why we think we can go to places like Perth and Parkhead with an understaffed midfield coupled with workshy forwards like Boyle and Youan, who really are just benchmen / impact players in these sorts of games.

[worcesterhibby]

I'm a fan of Monty.. but I have to admit I was very dissapointed by our perfromance in the 2nd half yesterday. Admittedly I wasn't there and have only watched the highlights, but there seemed no evidence that he managed to change things for the better after a very poor first half. There are a lot of talented players in that Hibs team, certainly when compared to St Johnstone, but they created absolutely nothing.

[Callum_62]

I think I've seen enough in games we haven't lost recently (such as Ross County 2-2) to see what we have on our hands with Dylan Levitt and the ageing stalwarts at the back.

It's far from all doom, as NM and his coaching team have really brought a different improved dimension to Jair's game (and he looks a real asset now).

The puzzle for me is how Vente has gone from having a Next-Level workrate (when he first joined) to what we see with our eyes now, and why we think we can go to places like Perth and Parkhead with an understaffed midfield coupled with workshy forwards like Boyle and Youan, who really are just benchmen / impact players in these sorts of games.Are you suggesting Vente doesn't work hard anymore?

[emoji50]

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[ancient hibee]

Are you suggesting Vente doesn't work hard anymore?

[emoji50]

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

And Boyle and Youan.

[MikeyS]

And Boyle and Youan.

I don't think it's up for debate with those 2 really.

I wouldn't say Boyle has ever been one to help defensively and we would be better of just chucking an extra ball on at times for Elie to play with while the games goes on around him!

[Nicho87]

Marshall

Miller
Fish
New CH
Obita

New 6
Levitt
Newell

Boyle / Youan
Vente
Jair / New winger / striker

That set up looks more solid (I think)

I do feel we give a lot of chances away with the current set up and in recent weeks listening to the stats, we give up some amount of chances

A proper 6 which allows newell and levitt to be further forward and drive gets us up the park quicker

I am in favour of how Monty wants to play I do think it will come good

But the formation just now looks unbalanced with the current players

[Iain G]

Because we’re normally up against 3 in midfield. I’m obviously exaggerating the fact but our midfield becomes overwhelmed, you know what I mean. 😀

If we are fluid and intelligent enough on the pitch, a centre back steps up to make the midfield 2 a 3, or the second striker drops back in to do the same thing.

The traditional 442 can be quite restrictive but it can also be quite dynamic and fluid, with the right training, personnel and belief on the pitch to take risks.

[JohnM1875]

Ovie Ejaria Just left Reading. Probably already has a move lined up and maybe out our price range.

[Iain G]

Marshall

Miller
Fish
New CH
Obita

New 6
Levitt
Newell

Boyle / Youan
Vente
Jair / New winger / striker

That set up looks more solid (I think)

I do feel we give a lot of chances away with the current set up and in recent weeks listening to the stats, we give up some amount of chances

A proper 6 which allows newell and levitt to be further forward and drive gets us up the park quicker

I am in favour of how Monty wants to play I do think it will come good

But the formation just now looks unbalanced with the current players

What is a proper 6?

[ErinGoBraghHFC]

What is a proper 6?

Jeggo


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Chipper1875]

Jeggo


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Jeggo is terrible. Poor on the ball . No pace and no upper body strength

[Chipper1875]

Marshall

Miller
Fish
New CH
Obita

New 6
Levitt
Newell

Boyle / Youan
Vente
Jair / New winger / striker

That set up looks more solid (I think)

I do feel we give a lot of chances away with the current set up and in recent weeks listening to the stats, we give up some amount of chances

A proper 6 which allows newell and levitt to be further forward and drive gets us up the park quicker

I am in favour of how Monty wants to play I do think it will come good

But the formation just now looks unbalanced with the current players

Levitt has no drive , that’s the issue. Can’t run and get about the park

[Hibernian Verse]

Jeggo


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

In the Scottish Championship maybe. No athleticism whatsoever to perform at the level we need from a proper 6.

[18Craig75]

Assuming the billions don’t land in the account in time then we need to go out and sign O’Hara. Seems to me tailor made to play this system alongside Super Joe.

[Allant1981]

In the Scottish Championship maybe. No athleticism whatsoever to perform at the level we need from a proper 6.

Apart from the fact he has been and hasn't really had a bad game you are correct

[HendoDelivered]

Assuming the billions don’t land in the account in time then we need to go out and sign O’Hara. Seems to me tailor made to play this system alongside Super Joe.

St mirren would command a fee similar of what we paid of Vente for him

[SickBoy32]

Assuming the billions don’t land in the account in time then we need to go out and sign O’Hara. Seems to me tailor made to play this system alongside Super Joe.

Totally agree, O'Hara would be a brilliant signing for us - as would Armstrong from Killie IMO.

Use the Melkerson cash and get it done

[The Modfather]

St mirren would command a fee similar of what we paid of Vente for him

Wonder if we could kill several birds with one stone. Cash plus JDH & Doidge. Anything is possible given we managed to find someone to take Magennis.

[Hibernian Verse]

Apart from the fact he has been and hasn't really had a bad game you are correct

He's been fine yeah. If the ringing endorsement is "hasn't really had a bad game" then he's not the "proper 6" we need.

He's a decent squad player.

[JimBHibees]

Jeggo is terrible. Poor on the ball . No pace and no upper body strength

Quite a critique. Has been decent alongside Newell recently

[Paulie Walnuts]

Wonder if we could kill several birds with one stone. Cash plus JDH & Doidge. Anything is possible given we managed to find someone to take Magennis.

On that note, I see Magennis has just returned after 10 games out. Looks like we made the right call.

[Centre Hawf]

Totally agree, O'Hara would be a brilliant signing for us - as would Armstrong from Killie IMO.

Use the Melkerson cash and get it done

I like both of them but I do think they'll command too high a fee for even us. Armstrong will be closer to 7 figures than we can afford.

I can't imagine anyone will take our dreggs off us either with the wages they're likely on.

[TrinityHFC]

On that note, I see Magennis has just returned after 10 games out. Looks like we made the right call.

He only lasted a few minutes before being subbed again.

[Billy Whizz]

I see Ryan Shanley has signed for Falkirk. Just one of a number of Edin City players moving. It’s a 6 month deal with an option of another year
Great move for the lad, hope he knuckles down and makes the grade

[theonlywayisup]

Jeggo is terrible. Poor on the ball . No pace and no upper body strength

I take it you are a "black & white" thinking type of guy, with no shades of grey.

He's not brilliant, but he's certainly not as bad as you portray. Unless, you're comparing him alongside Messi.

[Paulie Walnuts]

I see Ryan Shanley has signed for Falkirk. Just one of a number of Edin City players moving. It’s a 6 month deal with an option of another year
Great move for the lad, hope he knuckles down and makes the grade

What’s going on at Edinburgh City? Handling moved recently as well.

Financial trouble?

[Northernhibee]

What’s going on at Edinburgh City? Handling moved recently as well.

Financial trouble?

Big time by the sounds of it. Seen a report that they may be struggling to pay all their players.

[Billy Whizz]

Big time by the sounds of it. Seen a report that they may be struggling to pay all their players.

Seems to be pretty bad. Not sure if it will be admin or liquidation, that’s how serious it is

[Paulie Walnuts]

Didn’t expect that. That’s a shame.

[Billy Whizz]

Didn’t expect that. That’s a shame.

You have to hope it’s only admin. Hibs have a long association with them.
Could be a good place for some of our talented Under 18’s to play after the winter break

[Hibs4185]

You have to hope it’s only admin. Hibs have a long association with them.
Could be a good place for some of our talented Under 18’s to play after the winter break

Could be a good buy for Hibs, our unofficial B team so all the youth, development teams get serious games in a proper league.

Wouldn’t cost the club much or an investor and the benefits could be huge

I’m a big fan of B teams but this would be a lot better and easier.

[Centre Hawf]

I was actually quite surprised after our initial partnership announcement how little we seen of our players move there. I know there's likely a limit on how many you can have at one time but after an initial run of a few names it seemed to dry up. Don't think we even sent anyone there in the summer.

[Dmas]

Could be a good buy for Hibs, our unofficial B team so all the youth, development teams get serious games in a proper league.

Wouldn’t cost the club much or an investor and the benefits could be huge

I’m a big fan of B teams but this would be a lot better and easier.

Didn’t they move to new ownership recently?

Guy that played for west side afc made his debut for them at the weekend I started to wonder what was going on that a Sunday league player got signed

[Onceinawhile]

I was actually quite surprised after our initial partnership announcement how little we seen of our players move there. I know there's likely a limit on how many you can have at one time but after an initial run of a few names it seemed to dry up. Don't think we even sent anyone there in the summer.

From memory, there was rumours of a falling out. I think we recalled the players who were on loan last season then sent them elsewhere.

Emmanuel Johnson (Mind him?!?) was one of them. Now he's on loan in the US.

[Since90+2]

Could be a good buy for Hibs, our unofficial B team so all the youth, development teams get serious games in a proper league.

Wouldn’t cost the club much or an investor and the benefits could be huge

I’m a big fan of B teams but this would be a lot better and easier.

Don't think we'd be allowed to buy them even if wanted to?

[Hibiza]

Wonder if we could kill several birds with one stone. Cash plus JDH & Doidge. Anything is possible given we managed to find someone to take Magennis.

👍

[He's here!]

Absolutely. He was getting criticised early doors for drawing games we should have won, then started winning now it's style. Desperate to criticise.

It's more simple than that. It's the fact we couldn't muster up a single shot on target against St Johnstone which deserved severe criticism. We were second best throughout and that just shouldn't happen against run of the mill sides. If we'd lost narrowly in a game where we'd simply been out of luck with our finishing but created a decent number of chances the flak would have been significantly less.

[JimBHibees]

It's more simple than that. It's the fact we couldn't muster up a single shot on target against St Johnstone which deserved severe criticism. We were second best throughout and that just shouldn't happen against run of the mill sides. If we'd lost narrowly in a game where we'd simply been out of luck with our finishing but created a decent number of chances the flak would have been significantly less.

So purely one game reactionary nonsense sounds fair

[SHODAN]

Wonder if we could kill several birds with one stone. Cash plus JDH & Doidge. Anything is possible given we managed to find someone to take Magennis.

You will never sell The Doidge.

[Edinburgh Green]

Totally agree, O'Hara would be a brilliant signing for us - as would Armstrong from Killie IMO.

Use the Melkerson cash and get it done

O'Hara is having a pretty poor season by all accounts, seen a few St Mirren fans on twitter asking for him to be dropped.

[JimBHibees]

O'Hara is having a pretty poor season by all accounts, seen a few St Mirren fans on twitter asking for him to be dropped.

To be honest never been a fan and think would struggle in a two and don’t think good enough on the ball.

[Paulie Walnuts]

Didn’t they move to new ownership recently?

Guy that played for west side afc made his debut for them at the weekend I started to wonder what was going on that a Sunday league player got signed

Who was that? Have played against them many times.

[Edinburgh Green]

Who was that? Have played against them many times.

Kenny Fisher

[Paulie Walnuts]

Kenny Fisher

:aok:

[Hibs4185]

Didn’t they move to new ownership recently?

Guy that played for west side afc made his debut for them at the weekend I started to wonder what was going on that a Sunday league player got signed

I’m not sure just seen the rumours about admin or insolvency mentioned above.

Surely to buy them out of admin or whatever it may be, would only be £100k or something which would be reasonable.

Our very own multi club model!

Maybe the Hibs foundation could buy it so it’s a seperate entity to get around ownership rules. Have it is a community club with players loaned from us etc.

Maybe there is a lot of rules/restrictions but it keeps them afloat and gives us a good breeding ground. Win win

[Chipper1875]

What’s going on at Edinburgh City? Handling moved recently as well.

Financial trouble?

Not been paying the players. Circa 9 walked out . Be lucky not to go
Into administration. Three players have joined new clubs in the last week

[Unseen work]

Rumoured 6 million initial investment from Foley with the majority going towards recruitment.

Wonder how that affects us/who we go for in January if the money is received by then. Definitely exciting times.

What I would say though is fans still need to be realistic, Aberdeen and hearts both got 6 million for the conference league each over the last 2 seasons so it’s unlikely we’re going to sign players for ridiculous fee’s.

But 6 million plus the 1.2 for Melkersen is a brilliant start.

[JohnM1875]

Rumoured 6 million initial investment from Foley with the majority going towards recruitment.

Wonder how that affects us/who we go for in January if the money is received by then. Definitely exciting times.

What I would say though is fans still need to be realistic, Aberdeen and hearts both got 6 million for the conference league each over the last 2 seasons so it’s unlikely we’re going to sign players for ridiculous fee’s.

But 6 million plus the 1.2 for Melkersen is a brilliant start.

It really is!

Though I think Aberdeen could be in for a huge sell on this summer for Ferguson. Smashing it for Bologna this season and captained them the past few games. Think they’ll get decent fees for a few players as well.

So really important we invest this Jan and get good quality I reckon.

[B.H.F.C]

I’m still sceptical that we’ll be seeing multiple expensive signings in January. I think it’ll be the summer before we get the benefit of the investment transfer wise.

I do still think we will spend a bit in January on the back of the fee for Melkersen though.

[HoboHarry]

I’m still sceptical that we’ll be seeing multiple expensive signings in January. I think it’ll be the summer before we get the benefit of the investment transfer wise.

I do still think we will spend a bit in January on the back of the fee for Melkersen though.
:agree:

[Unseen work]

I’m still sceptical that we’ll be seeing multiple expensive signings in January. I think it’ll be the summer before we get the benefit of the investment transfer wise.

I do still think we will spend a bit in January on the back of the fee for Melkersen though.

I think it will be similar to what we saw in the summer.

Thought we recruited well and spent quite a bit, 700k or so on Vente and Youan, couple of hundred thousand on Levitt etc.

If we were to spend 500-750k on a couple of key positions it could help massively - however the option to pay players and extra 1k a week etc could be more beneficial than anything and exploit potential free agents

Baccus
Strain
Yan Dhanda

Are 3 examples of players that are regularly mentioned on here as ones we should look at, all out of contract in the summer.

[HoboHarry]

I think it will be similar to what we saw in the summer.

Thought we recruited well and spent quite a bit, 700k or so on Vente and Youan, couple of hundred thousand on Levitt etc.

If we were to spend 500-750k on a couple of key positions it could help massively - however the option to pay players and extra 1k a week etc could be more beneficial than anything and exploit potential free agents

Baccus
Strain
Yan Dhanda

Are 3 examples of players that are regularly mentioned on here as ones we should look at, all out of contract in the summer.
I might be wildly wrong of course but if Foley is serious about a link up our sights will be elsewhere - plenty won't work out obviously but I'd imagine we'd be trying to recruit players who it was at least hoped that they could go much higher than any of the three you mentioned, otherwise what's the point from Foley's point of view?

[B.H.F.C]

I think it will be similar to what we saw in the summer.

Thought we recruited well and spent quite a bit, 700k or so on Vente and Youan, couple of hundred thousand on Levitt etc.

If we were to spend 500-750k on a couple of key positions it could help massively - however the option to pay players and extra 1k a week etc could be more beneficial than anything and exploit potential free agents

Baccus
Strain
Yan Dhanda

Are 3 examples of players that are regularly mentioned on here as ones we should look at, all out of contract in the summer.

I don’t think we’ll spend as much as that in this window. We’ll spend a fee if we need to but I’m not convinced it’ll be to that level, January window is always a bit different though.

I do agree that just a couple of good players could make a big difference. You look at the window last January and folk were cracking about it but Jeggo and Egan-Riley both made a big difference.

I just don’t see a big spend in January. A reasonable amount maybe, but not the kind of numbers some are hoping for. Not yet!

[Unseen work]

I might be wildly wrong of course but if Foley is serious about a link up our sights will be elsewhere - plenty won't work out obviously but I'd imagine we'd be trying to recruit players who it was at least hoped that they could go much higher than any of the three you mentioned, otherwise what's the point from Foley's point of view?

100%, was just an example. Maybe using the likes of Docherty and Clarke when they were here and turning loans permanent is a more likely type of player. Potentially a Owen Beck or Mika Biereth type?

One I hope we get despite there being no sell on value is Van Veen, even on loan I think would be a brilliant signing and a real focal point

[blackpoolhibs]

£6m is a very good start, and i'd imagine we could recieve some loans on top of that too.

Please spend it properly Monty. :thumbsup:

[Hibernian Verse]

Not sure a player that often doesn't get a start for Ross County is what we need.

[tonyrougier123]

Zinédine machach looks a decent attacking mid for Melbourne Victory.

[J-C]

Zinédine machach looks a decent attacking mid for Melbourne Victory.

All very well but Montgomery doesn't play with an AM, not unless he changess 442 to 4231.

[04Sauzee]

All very well but Montgomery doesn't play with an AM, not unless he changess 442 to 4231.

Looking at transfermrkt it looks like he can play a few positions, he's played as a 2nd striker, Attacking midfielder and a Central midfielder. Can't recall seeing him play so no idea how go or not he is

[eastmainsmsh]

Some talent in A League but if there is 6 Million ? Should we be dipping into that market ?

[Forza Fred]

I say again Josh Nisbet.

Just watched him again serve it up in the pouring rain against Brisbane.
, in a 3-0 victory to the Mariners.

He might be small but he’s such a clever, clever player……

[Since90+2]

I'm not really sure the Aussie market is where we should be looking if we want to be getting 3rd.

[Nicho87]

I’d take

Beck at Dundee / Liverpool
Baccus at St Mirren
Trevor Carson at Dundee I think

I’d bid for Shankland just for banter

[Unseen work]

I say again Josh Nisbet.

Just watched him again serve it up in the pouring rain against Brisbane.
, in a 3-0 victory to the Mariners.

He might be small but he’s such a clever, clever player……

Brilliant play again for the second and third goals.

[Unseen work]

I'm not really sure the Aussie market is where we should be looking if we want to be getting 3rd.

Where should we be looking?

[Aldo]

I say again Josh Nisbet.

Just watched him again serve it up in the pouring rain against Brisbane.
, in a 3-0 victory to the Mariners.

He might be small but he’s such a clever, clever player……

He was very good today. The centre of everything good for CCM.

He even won a header!

[EGL2000]

mika biereth could be one to try for. On loan till the summer though.

[Forza Fred]

I'm not really sure the Aussie market is where we should be looking if we want to be getting 3rd.

There's good players in MOST leagues...just got to find them.

Mo Saleh played in the Egyptian league at one point.

[Smartie]

There's good players in MOST leagues...just got to find them.

Mo Saleh played in the Egyptian league at one point.

I always find the idea of turning our noses up at where players were signed from utterly bizarre.

The best players in our history have been signed from Dundee North End and Deveronvale and the like.

If they have something they should be signed and if necessary, developed.

[J-C]

I say again Josh Nisbet.

Just watched him again serve it up in the pouring rain against Brisbane.
, in a 3-0 victory to the Mariners.

He might be small but he’s such a clever, clever player……
What is the level of players he's up against though?

[Bridge hibs]

I'm not really sure the Aussie market is where we should be looking if we want to be getting 3rd.

Im sure hearts managed 3rd and a cup final with players from the Aussie market in their team

[Dmas]

mika biereth could be one to try for. On loan till the summer though.

Has he done anything except bully us? Not digging out or anything I just haven’t noticed him anywhere since

[EGL2000]

Has he done anything except bully us? Not digging out or anything I just haven’t noticed him anywhere since

6 goals and 2 assists in 780 mins in an awful Motherwell team.

[Dalianwanda]

There's good players in MOST leagues...just got to find them.

Mo Saleh played in the Egyptian league at one point.

Exactly look at the league John McGinn came from and he’s flying in the EPL 👀

[eastmainsmsh]

The young centre half Blokzijl for Groningen at Easter Road with fair hair was classy a player like that could stand out and get bigger move

[greenlex]

Young left wingback at Livingston could provide a good bit competition for obita. At the heart of most things going forward thinking at Livingston and likes a tackle. He’s big, strong and swings in a lovely cross. He wouldn’t cost a fortune. We struggled to contain him at ER in the first game against them.
Unfortunately I can’t see McIntyre making it at Hibs as he is small in stature and will eventually move on to a lower level.

[JohnM1875]

Young left wingback at Livingston could provide a good bit competition for obita. At the heart of most things going forward thinking at Livingston and likes a tackle. He’s big, strong and swings in a lovely cross. He wouldn’t cost a fortune. We struggled to contain him at ER in the first game against them.
Unfortunately I can’t see McIntyre making it at Hibs as he is small in stature and will eventually move on to a lower level.

Penrice? Aye, he’s looked decent when I’ve seen him against us.

[greenlex]

Penrice? Aye, he’s looked decent when I’ve seen him against us.
The very chap. :agree:

[Unseen work]

Young left wingback at Livingston could provide a good bit competition for obita. At the heart of most things going forward thinking at Livingston and likes a tackle. He’s big, strong and swings in a lovely cross. He wouldn’t cost a fortune. We struggled to contain him at ER in the first game against them.
Unfortunately I can’t see McIntyre making it at Hibs as he is small in stature and will eventually move on to a lower level.

Penrice is quality I think.

Not sure what he is like in a 4 at the back though as I mainly see him at wing back so he’s got a bit more cover.

25 tomorrow so not a young lad anymore, but now hitting his peak. Fast, direct, can beat a man and whip in a great cross.

Wouldn’t be against him coming in to compete with Obita (who I rate highly) as he suffers injuries now and again.

[JimBHibees]

Assume we would be in for Nesbit and Farrell from ccm

[Mcbizz1998]

Assume we would be in for Nesbit and Farrell from ccm

As with his namesake, it’s Nisbet!!!

[JimBHibees]

As with his namesake, it’s Nisbet!!!

Where’s the fun in that 🤩

[1875Sean]

I’d take

Beck at Dundee / Liverpool
Baccus at St Mirren
Trevor Carson at Dundee I think

I’d bid for Shankland just for banter

Out of interest why Baccus when he hasn’t been a regular for St Mirren?

Carson is getting on a bit and for me isn’t any better than what we have

[Bridge hibs]

Out of interest why Baccus when he hasn’t been a regular for St Mirren?

Carson is getting on a bit and for me isn’t any better than what we have

Agree, Baccus is a pretty ordinary player who I dont think would enhance our team, Carson is decent and would make a decent understudy but that said I would rather promote within with either Boruc or Johnston

[ErinGoBraghHFC]

Penrice is quality I think.

Not sure what he is like in a 4 at the back though as I mainly see him at wing back so he’s got a bit more cover.

25 tomorrow so not a young lad anymore, but now hitting his peak. Fast, direct, can beat a man and whip in a great cross.

Wouldn’t be against him coming in to compete with Obita (who I rate highly) as he suffers injuries now and again.

He was a couple years above me at school, was at Hibs pro youth for a wee while circa 2012. Always been a very good player technically, might be worth the punt tbh .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Nicho87]

Out of interest why Baccus when he hasn’t been a regular for St Mirren?

Carson is getting on a bit and for me isn’t any better than what we have

I’ve always liked him when I’ve seen him

Think he’ll be thought of by Monty

Better squad depth than what we already have.

[1875Sean]

I’ve always liked him when I’ve seen him

Think he’ll be thought of by Monty

Better squad depth than what we already have.

For me we need to aim for a player to play along side newell! With this new investment I would like to think we could aim for better, may be ok for back up as you said but I’m not convinced based on this season

[Nicho87]

For me we need to aim for a player to play along side newell! With this new investment I would like to think we could aim for better, may be ok for back up as you said but I’m not convinced based on this season

I agree

But based on reports no extra money this window

[Forza Fred]

What is the level of players he's up against though?

Not as good as him.

[Unseen work]

https://x.com/aleaguemen/status/1737794301613191442?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

This assist from Nisbet is exactly what we’re missing.

Get him playing just off Vente as he did for CCM the other night and it would give us a much better balance imo

Interesting too that a player scoring regularly for them (hat trick and then double) called Angel Torres was identified and signed under Monty and Sergio. Presumably through Sergios knowledge/contacts in Portugal as he was previously at Porto. The other main attacker for them, Marco Tulio was identified in similar fashion as he was at sporting.

Really intrigued what gems they can ID with a bigger budget.

[Unseen work]

What is the level of players he's up against though?

Kye Rowles, Nathaniel Atkinson, Cammy Devlin and Calem Nieuwenhof sort of standard 😉

[Dmas]

https://x.com/aleaguemen/status/1737794301613191442?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

This assist from Nisbet is exactly what we’re missing.

Get him playing just off Vente as he did for CCM the other night and it would give us a much better balance imo

Interesting too that a player scoring regularly for them (hat trick and then double) called Angel Torres was identified and signed under Monty and Sergio. Presumably through Sergios knowledge/contacts in Portugal as he was previously at Porto. The other main attacker for them, Marco Tulio was identified in similar fashion as he was at sporting.

Really intrigued what gems they can ID with a bigger budget.

Nisbet and the left back Farrell look good players at CCM I’d be more than happy if we signed them, I’ve not been impressed with tulio though he has ability no doubt but I think he’d struggle here bit of a lack of pace quite a laid back style and probably too similar a striker to Vente as in comes deeper to link rather than your around the 18 yard box type of striker not sure he’s what we need.

There’s no doubt NM and the coaching staff done a great job there though hopefully we’re able to see some deals done next month to allow them to put more of a mark down on their team, interesting and exiting times ahead IMO

[MikeyS]

Kye Rowles, Nathaniel Atkinson, Cammy Devlin and Calem Nieuwenhof sort of standard 😉

Wouldn't thank you for any of that lot.

I do like how you've handily ordered them in talent order from awful to dog sh*t though.

[Forza Fred]

Nisbet and the left back Farrell look good players at CCM I’d be more than happy if we signed them, I’ve not been impressed with tulio though he has ability no doubt but I think he’d struggle here bit of a lack of pace quite a laid back style and probably too similar a striker to Vente as in comes deeper to link rather than your around the 18 yard box type of striker not sure he’s what we need.

There’s no doubt NM and the coaching staff done a great job there though hopefully we’re able to see some deals done next month to allow them to put more of a mark down on their team, interesting and exiting times ahead IMO

Tullio can play, and score some pearlers, but I agree with you totally about his lack of pace.

I think the slower paced, more technical build up in the A League suits his style, as does the tendency for defenders not to mark closely, and he would struggle with the close marking that he would also be subject to in the SPL.

If I was in charge of Hibs and was given enough money to bring 3 A League players in it would be

Josh Nisbet and Jacob Farrell…Central Coast Mariners and Joe Gauci, Adelaide United.

That’s not to say there are no other good players in Oz..but they would be my picks.

Having said that Adelaide are about to kick off against Newcastle in a few minutes so no doubt Gauci will have a mare!