Winter 2019-20 transfer thread

[SteveHFC]

McGinn agreed.

[Since452]

Hopefully if we sign McNulty it's on a loan with an option to buy. Fwiw I think he'd work very well with Doidge. He's a clever player

[ancient hibee]

Absolutely.

Shaw we were told couldn't be put out to loan because that would have left us with only 2 senior strikers. He's now been sold and nobody looks lined up. We were a striker light when Shaw was here. Got the feeling the McNulty deal won't get done so hopefully there's a plan B

Thought Shaw would have got a chance on Wednesday night.Didn't leave the bench.

[Leith Green]

Am i not correct in thinking mcginn can play defensive midfield as well as right back?

[Billy Whizz]

McGinn agreed.

Where are you reading this

[weecounty hibby]

Where are you reading this

On Sky breaking news. Fee agreed. Medical tonight

[EAZY-ME]

I'm hearing mcgeady is signing but Boyle may be going to Celtic...... guy at work so take with a pinch of salt

[HFC93]

If you look at the Scot Prem Ins and Outs so far for January 2020 the average is about 2-3 In for each team. I'm sure we'll sign a few more. The level of moaning on here though is unreal. What were folk expecting? I dread to think what it would be like if we lost to Dundee Utd.

[Since452]

Every time I see the name McGinn I get a warm fuzzy feeling inside

[Barman Stanton]

If you look at the Scot Prem Ins and Outs so far for January 2020 the average is about 2-3 In for each team. I'm sure we'll sign a few more. The level of moaning on here though is unreal. What were folk expecting? I dread to think what it would be like if we lost to Dundee Utd.

Some would have been in there element. Thats not me saying any Hibee wants us to lose, but some clearly love a good moan.

[ancient hibee]

I don't know how some of the posters would have managed in the days when anyone could be transferred anytime.

[Since452]

I don't know how some of the posters would have managed in the days when anyone could be transferred anytime.

Some would have been detained under the mental health act

[Bobby's Cinema]

Lots of talk of midfielders and strikers.

Defenders!!?

Our problems lie at the back for me. And that was even before we lost two starts for 6 months. We have next to no cover at all in these areas.

[hibbydad]

Lots of talk of midfielders and strikers.

Defenders!!?

Our problems lie at the back for me. And that was even before we lost two starts for 6 months. We have next to no cover at all in these areas.
I could not agree more defence needs serious surgery in the summer

[stantonsboots]

Sky sports news , Mcginn deal agreed . Im delighted :greengrin

[Since452]

Lots of talk of midfielders and strikers.

Defenders!!?

Our problems lie at the back for me. And that was even before we lost two starts for 6 months. We have next to no cover at all in these areas.

McGinn is a start

[Ozyhibby]

How long is mcginn’s deal?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ancient hibee]

Some would have been detained under the mental health act

:top marks

[RossScott1991]

I’m in the would take McNulty but wouldn’t be overly bothered if we didn’t sign him camp.

Good enough for Hibs I suppose. But I wasn’t overly impressed with him in the first spell like others seem to be. Maybe that’s just me, it’s only because the derbies I remember him squandering 2 massive chances at tynie and then missing the target from penalty spot at ER.

if it was permanent signing I’d maybe feel different. But if it’s loan, I’d rather try out Gullan for rest of the season or sign someone else. Not really sure can be bothered having another summer of will we won’t we for the sake of Marc McNulty

[WoreTheGreen]

How long is mcginn’s deal?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

A4

[HFC93]

Some would have been in there element. Thats not me saying any Hibee wants us to lose, but some clearly love a good moan.

Aye, 100%.

[GreenPJ]

I don't understand why we would recall Gullan from a loan if he is just dropping back down to 4th place striker assuming we sign McNulty or AN Other. I am assuming Gullan preferred position is striker.

[we are hibs]

I don't understand why we would recall Gullan from a loan if he is just dropping back down to 4th place striker assuming we sign McNulty or AN Other. I am assuming Gullan preferred position is striker.

Mcnulty in and gullan back out tomorrow i would think.

[NorthNorfolkHFC]

Sunderland just signed a striker on loan.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[number9dream]

I hope we have another striker in mind if McNulty doesn't come back.

I'm with you. The McNulty deal appears complicated and potentially out of our reach in terms of finances.
I'm sure there's a plan B & C but others will have similar contingency lists, which could scupper us.
I certainly wouldn't be letting Murray leave on loan until there's at least one more attacking player in the door.

[craigiehibs]

I don't understand why we would recall Gullan from a loan if he is just dropping back down to 4th place striker assuming we sign McNulty or AN Other. I am assuming Gullan preferred position is striker.


think sunderland playing hardball re releasing him from what i hear. might not happen

[mayo hibee]

As I said elsewhere, there’s a thread on Follow Follow about Kamberi looking at houses in East Kilbride and ensuing discussion about a move to Rangers. None of them fancy him. No offence intended, but it strikes me that a choice of East Kilbride is not what you might expect from a Rangers player.

Lots of them live in Thorntonhall which is an EK postcode.

[Aldo]

Hope it’s a permanent deal for MM!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Heisenberg]

Hope it’s a permanent deal for MM!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Doubt it will be unless we are selling someone. As above looks like it’s a goer if Sunderland sign this boy from Bristol City.

[Aldo]

Doubt it will be unless we are selling someone. As above looks like it’s a goer if Sunderland sign this boy from Bristol City.

We tried in the summer but couldn’t get it over the line. Happy with the loan but would prefer a permanent deal!

Let’s see how it pans out!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[B.H.F.C]

Doubt it will be unless we are selling someone. As above looks like it’s a goer if Sunderland sign this boy from Bristol City.

I think it will be a permanent deal for McNulty. Or maybe a loan with an option to buy in the summer.

I think Reading will have realised they have no chance of getting their money back and will just want rid and that’ll make any fee affordable.

[hibbyfraelibby]

Seen a few bits on twitter, Kamberi to rangers

Tell me when are we next due to play the Thes? Oh yeah so that'll be the obligatory unsettling rumour released by Mordor.

[flash]

Tell me when are we next due to play the Thes? Oh yeah so that'll be the obligatory unsettling rumour released by Mordor.

It really won't be.

[SHODAN]

Anyone worried that talk of a DM has just stopped?

[Jim44]

Anyone worried that talk of a DM has just stopped?

I don’t think JR and the board were doing a lot of talking about a DM and will plod on with a view to getting to grips with it in summer.

[EAZY-ME]

Just read a rumour on line that rangers want kamberi I'll try and find the link

Sorry my phone has a **** predictive text and swaps words randomly

[Hiber-nation]

Just read a rumour on line that rangers want Lambert....I'll try and find the link

Paul? Ricky??

[007]

I’m in the would take McNulty but wouldn’t be overly bothered if we didn’t sign him camp.

Good enough for Hibs I suppose. But I wasn’t overly impressed with him in the first spell like others seem to be. Maybe that’s just me, it’s only because the derbies I remember him squandering 2 massive chances at tynie and then missing the target from penalty spot at ER.

if it was permanent signing I’d maybe feel different. But if it’s loan, I’d rather try out Gullan for rest of the season or sign someone else. Not really sure can be bothered having another summer of will we won’t we for the sake of Marc McNulty

I remember him doing well setting up Horgan's 1st at Tynie, even if he was offside by a baw hair.

[WhileTheChief..]

Omenonga, McNulty, McGinn and Bogdan.

Decent enough quality, happy with that.

[SHODAN]

Just seen it posted on twitter that Rangers are after Herron.

[SMAXXA]

Just seen it posted on twitter that Rangers are after Herron.

Who’s that?

[greenpaper55]

Just seen it posted on twitter that Rangers are after Herron.
Thats the player with the big beak !

[Jim44]

Lambert? Herron? This is getting silly.

[Bostonhibby]

Anyone ever find out if Barrie the stadium announcer got his new tannoy system?Aye, they give him a big traffic cone and told him to shout louder through it[emoji6]

It's the Hibs way, we're saving up for more real estate in east Lothian.

I'll get my coat.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[one day maybe...]

Just read a rumour on line that rangers want Lambert....I'll try and find the link

Twenty

[Iggy Pope]

Just seen it posted on twitter that Rangers are after Herron.

A Sunday Mail stalwart, no surprise there. Expect a statement.

[Hiber-nation]

A Sunday Mail stalwart, no surprise there. Expect a statement.

:greengrin

[EAZY-ME]

Twenty

Was supposed to say kamberi... phone swapped the name

[GillyHibee]

Raith young lad could be going to Fulham

Any idea who?

[w pilton hibby]

Any idea who?

From the EN

English side to beat Hearts to attacking starlet

Hearts are set to miss out on Raith Rovers starlet Kieron Bowie.

The 17-year-old has been attracting interest from clubs around the UK.

The Jam Tarts have been keeping tabs on him as he impresses in League One, netting ten goals in all competitions.

However, it is believed that Fulham lead the race with a six-figure deal expected to be completed with Bowie staying at Rovers for the remainder of the season.

[Hibeesmad]

Hearts signing Marcel Langer from Schalke.

[Unseen work]

I don’t see why some get so annoyed by other posters being unhappy with the transfer window to date and making out they’re moaning for the sake of it.

Since the break our squad has got significantly weaker imo, we have lost

Middleton
Vela
Maxwell
Shaw
Mallan - Injured
Porteous - Injured
Naismith - Injured

and only brought in Omeonga and recalled Gullan?

Add that to a squad that’s had a poor season and lacking a leader and someone with defensive attributes in the middle of the park.

Fair enough it looks like we’re bringing in McGinn who could play right back but also known to play centre mid.

But our squad is so thin at the moment and Ross himself said all fit and available players were in the squad on Tuesday.

We need quality and numbers - huge 30 odd hours coming up.

[Hibeesmad]

I don’t see why some get so annoyed by other posters being unhappy with the transfer window to date and making out they’re moaning for the sake of it.

Since the break our squad has got significantly weaker imo, we have lost

Middleton
Vela
Maxwell
Shaw
Mallan - Injured
Porteous - Injured
Naismith - Injured

and only brought in Omeonga and recalled Gullan?

Add that to a squad that’s had a poor season and lacking a leader and someone with defensive car tributes in the middle of the park.

Fair enough it looks like we’re bringing in McGinn who could play right back but also known to play centre mid.

But our squad is so thin at the moment and Ross himself said all fit and available players were in the squad on Tuesday.

We need quality and numbers - huge 30 odd hours coming up.

Bogdan brought in to replace Maxwell.

[GillyHibee]

From the EN

English side to beat Hearts to attacking starlet

Hearts are set to miss out on Raith Rovers starlet Kieron Bowie.

The 17-year-old has been attracting interest from clubs around the UK.

The Jam Tarts have been keeping tabs on him as he impresses in League One, netting ten goals in all competitions.

However, it is believed that Fulham lead the race with a six-figure deal expected to be completed with Bowie staying at Rovers for the remainder of the season.

cheers for that, some decent prospects in that team and in the lower leagues

[Borderhibbie76]

I don’t see why some get so annoyed by other posters being unhappy with the transfer window to date and making out they’re moaning for the sake of it.

Since the break our squad has got significantly weaker imo, we have lost

Middleton
Vela
Maxwell
Shaw
Mallan - Injured
Porteous - Injured
Naismith - Injured

and only brought in Omeonga and recalled Gullan?

Add that to a squad that’s had a poor season and lacking a leader and someone with defensive attributes in the middle of the park.

Fair enough it looks like we’re bringing in McGinn who could play right back but also known to play centre mid.

But our squad is so thin at the moment and Ross himself said all fit and available players were in the squad on Tuesday.

We need quality and numbers - huge 30 odd hours coming up.

It's ridiculous mate u get shouted down every time for ever questioning Dempster or the Board. How any Hibee could be satisfied with the squad as it stands bewilders me.we are 6th with no real hope of any higher than 5th but that's good enough apparently.

Big 24 hours ahead..let's hope there is more than just Paul McGinn coming in...

[Jim44]

Hearts signing Marcel Langer from Schalke.

I wonder if he’s as good a golfer as his dad?

[greenlex]

Hearts signing Marcel Langer from Schalke.

He will soon get into the swing if things.

[WoreTheGreen]

I wonder if he’s as good a golfer as his dad?

There’s a bunker joke in there but don’t mention the war

[Winston Ingram]

Anyone worried that talk of a DM has just stopped?

Terrified. Our midfield is weak as water. We’ve been gagging for one for 6 months and it’s been so obvious we need one that I was stunned we didn’t have one in the moment the window opened.

[The 90+2]

Hearts signing Marcel Langer from Schalke.

Another quality addition.

[HoboHarry]

I wonder if he’s as good a golfer as his dad?
Or even his sister :greengrin

[Real Emerald]

Terrified. Our midfield is weak as water. We’ve been gagging for one for 6 months and it’s been so obvious we need one that I was stunned we didn’t have one in the moment the window opened.

Were we not told on here that we didn’t go for McGeouch because we had someone better lined up and we need to be patient. That put my mind at rest 🤥

[theonlywayisup]

From the Evening News website:

Hibs have agreed a fee with St Mirren for the transfer of full-back Paul McGinn, according to reports.

The 29-year-old will now undergo a medical and providing there are no issues, he will join the Easter Road club on a permanent deal.

McGinn is the older brother of John, who played for Hibs for three seasons before joining Aston Villa.

Although primarily a right-back, McGinn can also operate in other defensive positions and will compensate for the loss of long-term injury victims Jason Naismith and Ryan Porteous.

Hibs take on St Mirren in the Premiership on Saturday and Hibs hope to have him signed in time for that match.

[adhibs]

Another quality addition.

How's he quality?

A quick look at transfermarkt shows he's never played a first team game at 22 years old

[B.H.F.C]

Another quality addition.

Seen a lot of him aye?

[Col2]

McNulty deal unlikely to happen as Sunderland manager won’t budge.

Nisbet - Dunfermline wanting a lot more than we will pay and lots of wider interest elsewhere.

Stewart from Ross County will be our main striker target.

[The 90+2]

How's he quality?

A quick look at transfermarkt shows he's never played a first team game at 22 years old

Nah. He’s *****. Rather have no defensive midfielder tbh.

[Lee Marvin]

Another quality addition.
You are not even trolling....hahaha

[weecounty hibby]

Seen a lot of him aye?

That's a comment from the most miserable poster on here at the moment. Honestly if we dont sign someone soon we need to get a 24 hour watch on him. Never seen so much negativity in the one place!!!

[bingo70]

Nah. He’s *****. Rather have no defensive midfielder tbh.

So have you ever seen him play to know if he’s quality or not?

[SquashedFrogg]

Hearts signing Marcel Langer from Schalke.

B team. Much happier with Omeonga.

[04Sauzee]

Another quality addition.

Tell me more

[Billy Whizz]

Mikey Johnson Celtic out for a while after last nights injury
Hope they don’t come in for Boyle

[adhibs]

Nah. He’s *****. Rather have no defensive midfielder tbh.

So he's quality just because he plays a position we badly need someone in. Strange way of being able to make a snap judgement on a player's quality.

[HendoDelivered]

Just spoke to Marcs Dad: Sunderland have signed another striker and they’re waiting on club confirming it and then hopefully Sparky can come to Hibs as the gaffer is being difficult.

Also hopes that any deal gets done tonight as they fly to London tomorrow morning for game Sat.

[The Captain....]

I'm not that bothered about getting McNulty tbh. Theres other areas I think we should and hope we are targeting.


Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

[007]

I don’t see why some get so annoyed by other posters being unhappy with the transfer window to date and making out they’re moaning for the sake of it.

Since the break our squad has got significantly weaker imo, we have lost

Middleton
Vela
Maxwell
Shaw
Mallan - Injured
Porteous - Injured
Naismith - Injured

and only brought in Omeonga and recalled Gullan?

Add that to a squad that’s had a poor season and lacking a leader and someone with defensive attributes in the middle of the park.

Fair enough it looks like we’re bringing in McGinn who could play right back but also known to play centre mid.

But our squad is so thin at the moment and Ross himself said all fit and available players were in the squad on Tuesday.

We need quality and numbers - huge 30 odd hours coming up.


Bogdan brought in to replace Maxwell.

And Middleton was only brought in as cover after Boyle got injured. Naismith brought in as David Gray and Tom James were both injured.

[inglisavhibs]

[QUOTE=Winston Ingram;6064318]Terrified. Our midfield is weak as water. We’ve been gagging for one for 6 months and it’s been so obvious we need one that I was stunned we didn’t have one in the moment the window opened.[/QUOTE

Most of the successful Hibs teams in the last 50 years have not used an out and out defensive midfielder. Good example being our cup winning team with a midfield of Fyvie, MCGinn and McGeough. Our midfield on Wednesday was always going to be weak defensively as Allan and Horgan ie half the midfield have not got a defensive bone in their body. The flip side is you get s team who are very creative. The trick is to get the balance right.

[B.H.F.C]

I'm not that bothered about getting McNulty tbh. Theres other areas I think we should and hope we are targeting.


Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

We need another goal scorer. It been pretty much left to Boyle and Doidge since about the start of December. I’d say a striker is pretty important.

[Heisenberg]

I'm not that bothered about getting McNulty tbh. Theres other areas I think we should and hope we are targeting.


Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

We’ve only got two first choice strikers and one of them is woefully inconsistent. Another striker should be near top priority, next to a defensive midfielder.

[HFC93]

Another quality addition.

Slaver.

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

So we are potentially shaping up like this...

Rocky

McGinn
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Newell
McGeady

McNulty
Ballon Doidge

If playing 442 who drops out for the defensive midfielder from that team?

If 451 with someone sitting...

Rocky

McGinn / Gray
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Defensive Mid (Hallberg, Whittaker, McGinn)
Newall
McGeady

Ballon Doidge / McNulty

Are we screaming out for a DM? I’d be happy to go without and get one in the summer. The above teams are dependant on getting in McNulty and McGeough.

[Jim44]

Was 90+2’ s comment not just sarcastic tongue in cheek? He seems to have upset a few.

[04Sauzee]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre

[TheHarpy76]

So we are potentially shaping up like this...

Rocky

McGinn
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Newell
McGeough

McNulty
Ballon Doidge

If playing 442 who drops out for the defensive midfielder from that team?

If 451 with someone sitting...

Rocky

McGinn / Gray
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Defensive Mid (Hallberg, Whittaker, McGinn)
Newall
McGeough

Ballon Doidge / McNulty

Are we screaming out for a DM? I’d be happy to go without and get one in the summer. The above teams are dependant on getting in McNulty and McGeough.

McGeough has signed for Aberdeen.

[macca70]

So we are potentially shaping up like this...

Rocky

McGinn
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Newell
McGeough

McNulty
Ballon Doidge

If playing 442 who drops out for the defensive midfielder from that team?

If 451 with someone sitting...

Rocky

McGinn / Gray
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Defensive Mid (Hallberg, Whittaker, McGinn)
Newall
McGeough

Ballon Doidge / McNulty

Are we screaming out for a DM? I’d be happy to go without and get one in the summer. The above teams are dependant on getting in McNulty and McGeough.

McGeough signed for Aberdeen

[Tug Wilson]

So we are potentially shaping up like this...

Rocky

McGinn
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Newell
McGeough

McNulty
Ballon Doidge

If playing 442 who drops out for the defensive midfielder from that team?

If 451 with someone sitting...

Rocky

McGinn / Gray
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Defensive Mid (Hallberg, Whittaker, McGinn)
Newall
McGeough

Ballon Doidge / McNulty

Are we screaming out for a DM? I’d be happy to go without and get one in the summer. The above teams are dependant on getting in McNulty and McGeough.

Take it you mean McGeady?

Can't see Aberdeen selling us Dylan.

[Lee Marvin]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre

Loan move :faf:

[007]

Was 90+2’ s comment not just sarcastic tongue in cheek? He seems to have upset a few.

That's how I read it.

[Michael]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre

On loan. That would be bizarre.

[J-C]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre

They can have him for the right price

[04Sauzee]

Loan move :faf:

My thought as well but thinking about it not all loans are just covering wages some loan deals have a fee attached to them.

[Jim44]

So we are potentially shaping up like this...

Rocky

McGinn
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Newell
McGeough

McNulty
Ballon Doidge

If playing 442 who drops out for the defensive midfielder from that team?

If 451 with someone sitting...

Rocky

McGinn / Gray
Jackson
Hanlon
Stevenson

Boyle
Omeonga
Defensive Mid (Hallberg, Whittaker, McGinn)
Newall
McGeough

Ballon Doidge / McNulty

Are we screaming out for a DM? I’d be happy to go without and get one in the summer. The above teams are dependant on getting in McNulty and McGeough.

McGeouch???

[Heisenberg]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre

Would only accept that if we got Docherty in as a swap but that would still leave us horrendously short upfront.

[Lee Marvin]

My thought as well but thinking about it not all loans are just covering wages some loan deals have a fee attached to them.

That would struggle to reach 6 figures for Kamberi. What would be the point in that?!

[JDT]

If we can get Docherty in any deal for Kamberi then I say do it, still I think this story is rubbish

[04Sauzee]

That would struggle to reach 6 figures for Kamberi. What would be the point in that?!

No idea how its structured or if there is any truth in it, could be wages covered plus a £K? Loan fee, frees wages and gives us money plus he's still ours unless Rangers buy for the agreed amount?

I'm merely speculating, not saying anything like that will happen

[007]

Loan move :faf:

A loan move with option to buy is a poor option for us. He's playing regularly for us so it's not like we are wanting rid of him and off the wage bill. His value will reduce between now and the summer unless he plays really well which would mean Rangers would want to take up the option, no doubt at less than his value. They can gtf.

[MyJo]

On loan. That would be bizarre.

Maybe a bit of a swap with us letting him go on loan for the remainder of the season while we get a player like Docherty on loan in return so it can be done before the end of the window.

Then we get an arrangement sorted out to make the moves permanent in the summer after the huns sell El Donkio

[weecounty hibby]

If Flo to the Hun happens that will be the most random transfer ever. Surely not on a loan either.

[Tug Wilson]

I really think that a front 2 of Doidge and McNulty would be very useful.

Both make intelligent runs and never give the opposition defenders a minute's peace. And they can score.

The balance in the midfield is the interesting. Would a 3 of Allan, Newell and Omeonga work with Boyle wide right?

Potentially the player to drop out of that 4 is Allan.

Hallberg or Horgan? Slivka? Or McGeady if he comes in.

[007]

My thought as well but thinking about it not all loans are just covering wages some loan deals have a fee attached to them.

True, did they not mug us off by charging about £100k for Middleton?

[Jim44]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre


On loan. That would be bizarre.

This has been touched upon all day and despite a majority on here wanting rid of Kamberi, I think we have to hold on to him for a while yet. I wonder why one of our opponents, superior to us, see his value and worth, yet he’s not good enough for us. :confused:

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

Take it you mean McGeady?

Can't see Aberdeen selling us Dylan.

Yup, McGeady :agree:

[Hibs4185]

This has been touched upon all day and despite a majority on here wanting rid of Kamberi, I think we have to hold on to him for a while yet. I wonder why one of our opponents, superior to us, see his value and worth, yet he’s not good enough for us. :confused:

I was just about to make the same point!

[Steven79]

If Flo to the Hun happens that will be the most random transfer ever. Surely not on a loan either.

They are obviously skint so I wouldn't do any deals with them.

Cash up front and we sell him but on loan makes no sense...

[B.H.F.C]

This has been touched upon all day and despite a majority on here wanting rid of Kamberi, I think we have to hold on to him for a while yet. I wonder why one of our opponents, superior to us, see his value and worth, yet he’s not good enough for us. :confused:

Would be odd if he went there. As for his worth, he needs to show his worth more often as opposed to us just talking about it.

[Hibs4185]

Unless £500k loan fee and £2 million buy option. Also cup ties him incase we play them in the final of the Scottish cup

[The 90+2]

Unless £500k loan fee and £2 million buy option. Also cup ties him incase we play them in the final of the Scottish cup

😂😂😂😂

[Heisenberg]

If it’s simply a loan with option to buy then it’s not worth it for us in the short term. Only the inclusion of Docherty to us makes it worthwhile for me.

[SquashedFrogg]

If Flo to the Hun happens that will be the most random transfer ever. Surely not on a loan either.

Canny be a loan. Imagine when he came back after kissing their badge?

[theonlywayisup]

This has been touched upon all day and despite a majority on here wanting rid of Kamberi, I think we have to hold on to him for a while yet. I wonder why one of our opponents, superior to us, see his value and worth, yet he’s not good enough for us. :confused:

He could be an even better player in a better team.

[Steven79]

Unless £500k loan fee and £2 million buy option. Also cup ties him incase we play them in the final of the Scottish cup

He's played twice in the cup for us against Dundee United.

[The 90+2]

He could be an even better player in a better team.

Mental people want rid. Absolutely crazy man.

[ThatDayInMay]

If it’s simply a loan with option to buy then it’s not worth it for us in the short term. Only the inclusion of Docherty to us makes it worthwhile for me.

Or Jordan Jones 👀

[Andy74]

He could be an even better player in a better team.

That’d be just like him. No use to us if he can’t be better in this team.

[Tug Wilson]

If loaning Kamberi funds bringing in McNulty and McGeady until the end of season then it might have some merit.

If he does well for The Rangers then we might have to fend off some decent bids for him in the summer.

Would be quite funny if The Rangers were to add value to one of our players.

[we are hibs]

Tell the huns to get to ****.

[flash]

This Kamberi thing is strange. Wonder what Rangers are offering us?

[sauzee=legend]

If any deal was to go ahead....
FULL payment upfront & 25% sell on clause.
If the rumours are true, the rangers haven’t paid a penny for Kent yet.

[Hibbyradge]

I don’t see why some get so annoyed by other posters being unhappy with the transfer window

It's because it happens twice a year, every year.

As you have alluded, the window isn't shut yet.

Let the moaning begin at 00.01 on Saturday, not before.

[Wakeyhibee]

Mikey Johnson Celtic out for a while after last nights injury
Hope they don’t come in for Boyle

I think it's more likely he'll go down south for a decent fee after numerous derisory bids from the biscuit tinners.

I hope not though

[Squealing pig]

Loan lol getting the biscuit tin out aye?

[theonlywayisup]

If any deal was to go ahead....
FULL payment upfront & 25% sell on clause.
If the rumours are true, the rangers haven’t paid a penny for Kent yet.

Why would there be a sell on fee, if he's just going there on loan?

[NC1875]

This Kamberi thing is strange. Wonder what Rangers are offering us?

Hoping Kamberi says he wants to go and they take him on loan for 6 months and then can pay for him off there season ticket money in the summer.

Wouldn’t surprise me if Kamberi does say he wants to go if there is anything in it.

[flash]

What's a reasonable fee for Flo? £750,000?

[bingo70]

People at Hibs aren’t daft. They don’t just loan Rangers a player to help them out, we’ll need to be offered a good incentive to do so.

What that incentive is could be quite interesting tomorrow.

[The 90+2]

Loan lol getting the biscuit tin out aye?

Why we are kicking about in the big leagues for top players like super Johns big brother 😂

[SquashedFrogg]

What's a reasonable fee for Flo? £750,000?

Realistic I'd say. £2m to the Huns though.

[The 90+2]

People at Hibs aren’t daft. They don’t just loan Rangers a player to help them out, we’ll need to be offered a good incentive to do so.

What that incentive is could be quite interesting tomorrow.

It will free up another wage and get Ron a holiday home if he performs in the summer.

[The 90+2]

What's a reasonable fee for Flo? £750,000?

Whatever Reading want for Sparky with his wages covered for 2 years. Otherwise it’s a ****ing shambles.

[LaMotta]

This Kamberi thing is strange. Wonder what Rangers are offering us?

Brandon Barker??

[Beefster]

Brandon Barker??

Hopefully not.

[bigwheel]

Hopefully not.

I’ll second that ...

[G B Young]

This Kamberi thing is strange. Wonder what Rangers are offering us?

Very strange. Bizarre in fact. I find it hard to believe Rangers would see Kamberi as a temporary replacement for Defoe. The latter is a consistent goalscorer and while I am fan of Flo and think he has much more to offer he's done nowhere near enough for Rangers to think he can suddenly start turning it on week in week out.

[BlackSheep]

Press saying Flo has a release clause of £2M.... I’d snap the hand off anyone who offer this, but it’s only useful and worth it if the money is used to bring in suitable players!

[Hibbyradge]

It will free up another wage and get Ron a holiday home if he performs in the summer.

:wtf:

[bingo70]

Has Greg Stewart played much for Rangers? Different kind of forward to Flo and could be someone that would suit us better than Rangers for the next 6 months.

[G B Young]

Hopefully not.

I thought Barker was a cracking player in the making when he was with us before. I was really disappointed when we didn't manage to bring him back the following season as I think he'd have thrived at Easter Road. Now he's ended up with stop-start career that doesn't seem to be going anywhere in particular. A Scott Allan-style homecoming to to Hibs might be just what he needs.

[JohnM1875]

We have enough injury problems as it is without throwing Barker into the mix.

[MWHIBBIES]

If any deal was to go ahead....
FULL payment upfront & 25% sell on clause.
If the rumours are true, the rangers haven’t paid a penny for Kent yet.

That is often how deals work, works out well for both clubs in terms of FFP as well. Look into Neto/Cillessen transfer in the summer. Rangers aren't in financial trouble.

[Geo_1875]

Very strange. Bizarre in fact. I find it hard to believe Rangers would see Kamberi as a temporary replacement for Defoe. The latter is a consistent goalscorer and while I am fan of Flo and think he has much more to offer he's done nowhere near enough for Rangers to think he can suddenly start turning it on week in week out.

Would probably thrive in a Rangers side with the backing of a huge crowd and a team of officials giving penalties and the benefit of any doubt.

[HFC93]

It will free up another wage and get Ron a holiday home if he performs in the summer.

Yawn.

[Brightside]

Whatever Reading want for Sparky with his wages covered for 2 years. Otherwise it’s a ****ing shambles.

You are nothing if not consistent.

[keep the faith]

2 in exchange from stewart, barker, jones or docherty and I would be very tempted.

[Geo_1875]

That is often how deals work, works out well for both clubs in terms of FFP as well. Look into Neto/Cillessen transfer in the summer. Rangers aren't in financial trouble.

We don't need to worry about FFP yet. Rangers would be in (more) financial trouble if their debts were ever called in.

[Allant1981]

You are nothing if not consistent.

Boring I think is the right word

[Squealing pig]

Why we are kicking about in the big leagues for top players like super Johns big brother 😂

But this is the famous Glasgow rangers , surely not . Shows how skint they really are.

[hibs4life]

Rangers'well documented funding issues mean they are likely to be either unable or unwilling to shell out anything substantial for Flo just now. They may have an eye on taking him now but loan to the end of the season and then purchase when their season ticket sales roll in.
Still find this slightly strange.
Flo has looked off the pace recently and often looks less than a committed team player at times, so for some, and depending on who we get in, this might not be too upsetting...

[Since452]

I'd want full payment for Rangers. Don't trust them as far as I could throw them

[Real Emerald]

I don’t believe any of this is true but if it is we would really need another 2 strikers in by tomorrow. It’s possible I suppose but it’s just so bizarre!

[Hermit Crab]

Have ever loaned a player to either of the OF. Ever? :dunno:

[Frankhfc]

I thought Barker was a cracking player in the making when he was with us before. I was really disappointed when we didn't manage to bring him back the following season as I think he'd have thrived at Easter Road. Now he's ended up with stop-start career that doesn't seem to be going anywhere in particular. A Scott Allan-style homecoming to to Hibs might be just what he needs.

:top marksBrandon on one flank and Squirrel on the other were enough to fill any opposition defense with anxiety.

On Flo I've already stated that he could be a top player if he'd simplify his game down a good deal by easing off the flicks and trying to skin one defender too many when the easier option is to lay it off to players in better positions. There's no doubt Flo's got the talent but he often makes the wrong choices when on the ball. I'm sure Jack will do whats best for the team if having to choose whether to let Flo leave or not.

[Jones28]

Stewart, Jones and £1m would do.

[Aldo]

Stewart, Jones and £1m would do.

Replace Stewart with Docherty and you’ve got a deal


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[greenlex]

Kamberi in a straight swap for Docherty. Permanent t.

[Nicho87]

I’d take Doherty and barker for kamberi straight swap.

[Real Emerald]

Kamberi in a straight swap for Docherty. Permanent t.

Maybe get Jack Docherty, if he’s still game!

[Dunbar Hibee]

Kamberi in a straight swap for Docherty. Permanent t.

Is this something you’ve heard?

[Shrekko]

Any player in the Rangers squad being sent to Hibs would be totally gutted which would be a bad start.

If Flo went there on loan ... can only imagine how difficult it would be for him to come back here too- don’t think the fans would make his life easy.

[Jim44]

Sky Sports reporting Rangers interested in Kamberi

https://www.skysports.com/app/transfer-centre


I’d take Doherty and barker for kamberi straight swap.

I read somewhere today that Barker is on £10k a week. Even if that is slightly exaggerated, why would he take on a huge wage drop to play for us?

[mentalhibee]

I read somewhere today that Barker is on £10k a week. Even if that is slightly exaggerated, why would he take on a huge wage drop to play for us?

They might pay him off

[Hibees1973]

I reckon Boyle is the most effective player in the SPFL outside of the Old Firm. When he goes he should follow the path of John McGinn and go down to the English Championship and see if he can progress from that level.

It really is typical of the ugly sisters trying to weaken their opposition in Scotland. Hibs should tell them to beat again if they try and get our players on the cheap.

If Hibs really want to push for the Top 4 and a place in the Scottish Cup semis this season we cannot lose any of our players. If we get McNulty, P McGinn and a central defensive midfielder we will have strengthened our main weaknesses and have a good chance to improve over the next few weeks.

[bingo70]

I read somewhere today that Barker is on £10k a week. Even if that is slightly exaggerated, why would he take on a huge wage drop to play for us?

If it’s a loan then he wouldn’t have to take a pay cut, Rangers would pay his wage.

[The 90+2]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

[greenlex]

Is this something you’ve heard?

Wishful thinking.

[Keyser Sauzee]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

Is it ridiculous, we signed him for a small fee in the hope that we can sell him in a couple years for a profit, it’s what the club planned for. I still don’t think he will go just now but I wouldn’t describe it as ridiculous if he did.

[Real Emerald]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

If they pay £2m+ they can obviously have him.

[Since452]

Any player in the Rangers squad being sent to Hibs would be totally gutted which would be a bad start.

If Flo went there on loan ... can only imagine how difficult it would be for him to come back here too- don’t think the fans would make his life easy.

That's my concern. How motivated would they be

[flash]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.
Not in the article I just read.

[Ryan91]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

I'd take anything from that rag with a large pinch of salt

[skyehibee]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

Article mentions nothing that indicates he’s gone? Just says rangers have approached hibs.

[Captain Trips]

A loan???

If he has a £2m clause I do not see what there is to discuss. The fee is £2m.

[Bishop Hibee]

We definitely need to get a striker in if Kamberi leaves. McNulty seems the likely replacement unless Ross can pull a rabbit out the hat.

[500miles]

That's my concern. How motivated would they be

Docherty was plenty motivated for Shrewsbury last season.

[Col2]

They won’t pay £2m.

They will offer a small loan fee that will help us fund another small deal and they will have an option at c£1m in summer.

We will be down to one striker unless we get our finger out.

Ron, where are you Ron?

[Since452]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

Every single Rangers player was spat on and kicked by Dempster who is fuming

[hibbyfraelibby]

The Kamberi chat all followed a post earlier on here. Sloppy journalism but if it sparks a £2m up front us sell on bid and we sign a couple of sparkies then why not.

[flash]

A loan???

If he has a £2m clause I do not see what there is to discuss. The fee is £2m.

It really isn't.

[Robbo6-2]

Cant see Gerrard being interested in Kamberi tbh.

Hes not good enough.
Id be delighted if we got him off wage bill and replace him with someone else

[Aldo]

Am I the only one who doesn’t want Barker back at ER?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Robbo6-2]

Am I the only one who doesn’t want Barker back at ER?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No Speed Boat without a driver

[bingo70]

The Kamberi chat all followed a post earlier on here. Sloppy journalism but if it sparks a £2m up front us sell on bid and we sign a couple of sparkies then why not.

Do you really think Sky sports and the daily Record take transfer rumours from a football forum like here?

They don’t.

People who don’t post in football forums, laugh at people that post in forums.

[Jim44]

Article mentions nothing that indicates he’s gone? Just says rangers have approached hibs.

When will folk learn to ignore everything the DR says. By all means, read it if you want, but don’t attach any credence to their crap. The £2m transfer, trigger, for example, is a figment of their imagination and I’m sure they would never be privy to that sort of information.

[Torto7]

If this is true then I'm expecting McGeady on top of McNulty or another forward/wing player. Otherwise we'll be too light up front.

If the window shuts and it's like for like replacements then my suspicions about this years playing budget being frozen/cut will remain.

I suspect we'll get the new commercial staff/stadium improvements/academy investments news at the AGM and why this is important for the clubs future. Even though we've barely brought through a player since east mains was developed.

Boringly responsible from Hibs.:wink:

[tamig]

Some would have been in there element. Thats not me saying any Hibee wants us to lose, but some clearly love a good moan.

And winning doesn’t stop them.

[Clarence]

Am I the only one who doesn’t want Barker back at ER?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No, I’m sure we’re not the only two either.

Re Kamberi, the loan thing is surely just to unsettle the player.

[CapitalGreen]

That's my concern. How motivated would they be

Not really interest in loaning any Fangers players but Henderson, Stokes and Ambrose were plenty motivated in their loan spells with us.

[Gaffer1875]

Happy to let Tamberi go if we get Docherty and Greg Stewart.

With McGinn all but signed and possibly McNulty or Nesbit, it would be a decent window.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Aldo]

When will folk learn to ignore everything the DR says. By all means, read it if you want, but don’t attach any credence to their crap. The £2m transfer, trigger, for example, is a figment of their imagination and I’m sure they would never be privy to that sort of information.

Exactly. This will be fed to them by Newco to try and turn the boys head.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Steve88]

Why on earth would we loan out one of our only two strikers without a replacement... has anyone here stopped and thought about that... clearly not!

Barker is awful

[WhileTheChief..]

Why would Rangers want to unsettle him or turn his head if they don’t want to sign him? That makes no sense at all.

Just because it’s in the Record doesn’t mean there’s nothing to it.

[Heisenberg]

Why on earth would we loan out one of our only two strikers without a replacement... has anyone here stopped and thought about that... clearly not!

Barker is awful

We’ll absolutely have a replacement lined up, probably McNulty with Gullan taking Shaws place. I’d like someone other than Barker in return if they were to give us a player for 6 months.

[FilipinoHibs]

Am I the only one who doesn’t want Barker back at ER?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No

[bingo70]

Why on earth would we loan out one of our only two strikers without a replacement... has anyone here stopped and thought about that... clearly not!

Barker is awful

I think rather than you being brighter than anyone else on here who’s not thought about that, they recognise the club has probably thought of that.

We’re not just going to loan Kamberi as a favour to them, we’ll need to get a good deal out of it too.

[Kato]

Why would Rangers want to unsettle him or turn his head if they don’t want to sign him? That makes no sense at all.

Just because it’s in the Record doesn’t mean there’s nothing to it.Rangers unsettle players directly or indirectly on a regular basis, whether they end up following through with a purchase is a different kettle of fish.

Sent from my SM-A405FN using Tapatalk

[SquashedFrogg]

Why on earth would we loan out one of our only two strikers without a replacement... has anyone here stopped and thought about that... clearly not!

Barker is awful

If Barker is awful, how do describe Flo?

[Real Emerald]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/florian-kamberi-rangers-transfer-approach-21396975

Kamberi looks gone. Ridiculous.

If they pay £2m+ they can obviously have him.

[jacomo]

Flo no go!

I don’t want any more players to leave this window.

[Steve88]

If Barker is awful, how do describe Flo?

Barker is well off the mark from his days at hibs. There’s a reason rangers want to offload him.

Just because he played for hibs once doesn’t mean we should take him back.

[Keith_M]

It's now in the Herald (https://www.heraldscotland.com/sport/18200357.rangers-eye-loan-deal-hibernian-forward-florian-kamberi/).. though they may have just copied it from the DR and Sun

[Captain Trips]

Under contract tell them its £2m cash upfront and none of yer pish.

[Stokesy's on fire]

We should never ever ever deal with The Rangers they can jog on

[RossScott1991]

I’d be more gutted if they were in for Doidge if I’m being honest.

[Brightside]

Why on earth would we loan out one of our only two strikers without a replacement... has anyone here stopped and thought about that... clearly not!

Barker is awful

MM will be back.

[xyz23jc]

If they pay £2m+ they can obviously have him.

Hopefully Lech Poznan will up their interest to £3m thanks to the unholy unity of the DR and The Rankgers! :greengrin:agree::thumbsup::flag:

[Lmc2105]

STV now reporting Rangers locked in talks with Hibs re Kamberi.

[Since452]

I’d be more gutted if they were in for Doidge if I’m being honest.

They can't afford Doidge

[Col2]

Anyone thinking we are getting Docherty or Barker are kidding themselves.

We don’t fund these type of deals, we don’t have the cash.

Kamberi will go on loan and we might get McNulty but it will be last minute. If we don’t it will be Boyle and Gullen to support Doidge.

[SquashedFrogg]

Barker is well off the mark from his days at hibs. There’s a reason rangers want to offload him.

Just because he played for hibs once doesn’t mean we should take him back.

Why would people want players based purely on the fact they've played with us before? I don't get that logic.

And I'm not advocating him coming back. Just not convinced he's 'awful'. Certainly in comparison to Flo.

[NC1875]

STV now reporting Rangers locked in talks with Hibs re Kamberi.

If it’s a loan with a 2 million fee guaranteed in the summer then that’s fine by me.

[The 90+2]

Is it ridiculous, we signed him for a small fee in the hope that we can sell him in a couple years for a profit, it’s what the club planned for. I still don’t think he will go just now but I wouldn’t describe it as ridiculous if he did.

Yes it is. We already need another striker and we’re offloading our most valuable asset.

[Since452]

Providing we get two strikers in I'd be happy to get Kamberi off the wage bill.

[HoboHarry]

We should never ever ever deal with The Rangers they can jog on
Their money is the same colour as the rest and if it is to our benefit I can't imagine why we wouldn't.

[Real Emerald]

MM will be back.

Still leaves us short, we’re looking to beef up the attack as well as other positions. Ross has already said in the past week that we’re thread bare and having to strip our entire squad for games. That’s not how a club like Hibs should operate. I appreciate you were only talking about strikers though.

[Shrekko]

Yes it is. We already need another striker and we’re offloading our most valuable asset.

He’s not our most valuable asset on the park - he’s not even a guaranteed starter.

[SquashedFrogg]

MM will be back.

Please

[xyz23jc]

Their money is the same colour as the rest and if it is to our benefit I can't imagine why we wouldn't.

All laundered money looks the same, eh? :greengrin

[The 90+2]

Why would Rangers want to unsettle him or turn his head if they don’t want to sign him? That makes no sense at all.

Just because it’s in the Record doesn’t mean there’s nothing to it.

There obviously is. And if the huns don’t get him Poznan will. Meanwhile we might loan another forward.

[B.H.F.C]

Anyone thinking we are getting Docherty or Barker are kidding themselves.

We don’t fund these type of deals, we don’t have the cash.

Kamberi will go on loan and we might get McNulty but it will be last minute. If we don’t it will be Boyle and Gullen to support Doidge.

No danger we will leave ourselves with just those 3 as striking options.

[The 90+2]

He’s not our most valuable asset on the park - he’s not even a guaranteed starter.

Who is then? Who will we realistically sell for more than Kamberi?

[Keyser Sauzee]

Who is then? Who will we realistically sell for more than Kamberi?

Boyle, same length of contract and in far better form, simple really.

[Blaster]

Who is then? Who will we realistically sell for more than Kamberi?

Boyle
Porteous

[The 90+2]

Providing we get two strikers in I'd be happy to get Kamberi off the wage bill.

Good job we have about 24 hours to do so then. That’s “if you know the window” all the super deals are about to magically happen.

[madhatter]

I would sell Kamberi. I don’t think he wants to stay at Hibs. I hate selling or loaning players to Rangers but if they are keen, and will pay, then go for it.

We need to start moving forward and, without hearing from Ron, I suspect selling talent is our main source of income beyond ticket sales so I cannot imagine Hibs can avoid this. Shame as it is but for us to solidify ourselves as the 3rd force we may need to sell quite a few players for some cash along the way. We’re not going to get money from anywhere else. Nothing substantial anyway.

[bingo70]

Who is then? Who will we realistically sell for more than Kamberi?

Boyle.

Nobody is paying £2m for Kamberi

[SquashedFrogg]

He’s not our most valuable asset on the park - he’s not even a guaranteed starter.

Correct. Most valuable asset - possibly. Most valuable to the team - not even close.

I'd be more gutted if Horgan left right now.

[The 90+2]

Boyle
Porteous

We won’t either for more than Kamberi.

[Andy74]

Yes it is. We already need another striker and we’re offloading our most valuable asset.

If he is actually our most valuable asset than we should absolutely be realising that asset if we get the chance because he’s been nowhere near our best player.

Very comfortable that Hibs will know what they are doing here.

[Bronson]

I’d be happy enough to sell flo for the right price. Especially if we have mcnulty coming in.

Loan deal is a total waste of our time though.

[The 90+2]

Boyle.

Nobody is paying £2m for Kamberi

Nobody is paying £2m for Boyle either.

[xyz23jc]

Who is then? Who will we realistically sell for more than Kamberi?

Squirrel maybe, Rocky, Porteous when he fit again, dunno? :agree:

[The 90+2]

Squirrel maybe, Rocky, Porteous when he fit again, dunno? :agree:

No chance.

[Blaster]

We won’t either for more than Kamberi.

I disagree

[The 90+2]

I disagree

Fair enough. 👍 what a football discussion forum is all about.

[SquashedFrogg]

Fair enough. 👍 what a football discussion forum is all about.

I disagree.












😀

[Captain Trips]

How much do Sevco value the title? If they think he is somebody who can help them do that then I would like the release fee of £2m.

[Real Emerald]

I would sell Kamberi. I don’t think he wants to stay at Hibs. I hate selling or loaning players to Rangers but if they are keen, and will pay, then go for it.

We need to start moving forward and, without hearing from Ron, I suspect selling talent is our main source of income beyond ticket sales so I cannot imagine Hibs can avoid this. Shame as it is but for us to solidify ourselves as the 3rd force we may need to sell quite a few players for some cash along the way. We’re not going to get money from anywhere else. Nothing substantial anyway.

Maybe waiting until Ron is revealed in ‘Who’s Behind The Mask’ before plans are made public!

[The 90+2]

If he is actually our most valuable asset than we should absolutely be realising that asset if we get the chance because he’s been nowhere near our best player.

Very comfortable that Hibs will know what they are doing here.

I actually think the chance for him to play in the Europa league and challenge for the league title instead of kicking about for us again in mid table mediocrity will appeal to the board. You never know it might cover another shortfall of not having a sponsor next year and a indoor stadium doesn’t pay for itself. Never mind though, in five years time we will be well ahead of everyone else in terms of infrastructure.

[Not In The Know]

Nobody is paying £2m for Boyle either.

If he plays well for oz in the summer they will

[The 90+2]

I disagree.




😁








😁

[Shrekko]

Who is then? Who will we realistically sell for more than Kamberi?

I said on the pitch- and everyone knows he’s not our best performer.

However ... yes he is one of 3-4 players we’d get decent cash for. Unlike Boyle tho Flo is replaceable

[The 90+2]

If he plays well for oz in the summer they will

With 12 months left on his contract? Highly doubt it. £1m and he will be off.

[Blaster]

Fair enough. 👍 what a football discussion forum is all about.

Absolutely. For me Flo flatters to deceive. Good one week, poor the next out the team the next. Whilst we may disagree on who would command the higher fee, Boyle is more valuable to us on the pitch at this moment in time and would be the more difficult to replace

[Since452]

Kamberi is a strange one. Puffs out his chest and makes faces like Ronaldo. Moves his legs like a 90's rave dancer but doesn't run very fast. Only looks interested once in 3 or 4 games. Makes terrible decisions on the park. I'm actually surprised Rangers think he'd be a good signing

[The 90+2]

I said on the pitch- and everyone knows he’s not our best performer.

However ... yes he is one of 3-4 players we’d get decent cash for. Unlike Boyle tho Flo is replaceable

Replaceable with who? A loan signing? A Ross County player? There’s a very good reason big clubs want Kamberi and it’s not because they want to take him off out bench.

[madhatter]

I said on the pitch- and everyone knows he’s not our best performer.

However ... yes he is one of 3-4 players we’d get decent cash for. Unlike Boyle tho Flo is replaceable

All players are replaceable. Just considering numbers of players globally (even in our price range), we could find a player to replace Boyle. Might need to wait 2-3 years for the player to develop, like Boyle, but it’s far from impossible.

Hibs should stick to the model that allowed us to get McGinn and Boyle and develop them, we need to be more selective possibly as some of the recruitment has been poor - I suspect we had high hopes for Slivka. I don’t think Ron is going to pump cash into the club so we need to go through this sell and replenish cycle. Big clubs like Ajax have to do it as well so it’s not something to dislike. Just has to be done right.

[Shrekko]

Replaceable with who? A loan signing? A Ross County player? There’s a very good reason big clubs want Kamberi and it’s not because they want to take him off out bench.

He’s got 3 league goals this year mate. He’s replaceable - trust me.

He might be great for Rangers but he’s not been for us far too often. I’d rather he stayed but he is 100 percent replaceable.

[Michael]

I wasn't a huge fan of McNulty first time round. He scored a lot at first, but once the goals dried up he didn't really offer much to the team (as I saw it). With Kamberi, even if he doesn't score he still has an impact.

[Mantis Toboggan]

Kamberi is a strange one. Puffs out his chest and makes faces like Ronaldo. Moves his legs like a 90's rave dancer but doesn't run very fast. Only looks interested once in 3 or 4 games. Makes terrible decisions on the park. I'm actually surprised Rangers think he'd be a good signing

Pretty much. Dont think Ross fancies him. If we can swap him for someone decent i would be happy