View Full Version : Greggs Summer transfer thread 2025
SHODAN
14-04-2025, 09:08 PM
Confirmed in (1):
Jamie McGrath, four years (midfielder, Aberdeen)
Confirmed new contracts (4):
Chris Cadden (two years)
Jack Iredale (three years)
Lewis Miller (one year)
Jordan Smith (three years)
Confirmed out (5):
Josef Bursik (Club Brugge)
Nohan Kenneh
Mykola Kuharevich (Swansea)
Hyeok-kyu Kwon (Celtic)
Nectar Triantis (Sunderland)
Confirmed out on loan (0):
N/A
Rumoured in:
Regan Charles-Cook (midfielder, Eupen)
Oisin McEntee (defender, Walsall)
Nectar Triantis (midfielder, Sunderland)
Rumoured new contracts:
Martin Boyle
Rocky Bushiri
Dwight Gayle
Junior Hoilett
Rumoured out:
Max Boruc
Martin Boyle
Rocky Bushiri
Allan Delferriere
Dwight Gayle
Junior Hoilett
Dylan Levitt
Reuben McAllister
Kyle McClelland
Nathan Moriah-Welsh
Jair Tavares
Dylan Vente
Elie Youan
SHODAN
14-04-2025, 09:09 PM
Apologies this one's come so late. Feel free to remind of any I've forgotten.
04Sauzee
14-04-2025, 09:16 PM
Been looking forward to this thread 😁
Unseen Work to post his first YouTube reel by page 3 😁😁
Nicho87
14-04-2025, 09:18 PM
I’d say kennah is confirmed out as the statement pretty much did say he’s off
Ribs1875
14-04-2025, 09:47 PM
I hope we manage to at least retain Boyle.
HoboHarry
14-04-2025, 09:52 PM
Who confirmed Bursik and Kwon are out? I fully expect they will be but when/where was it confirmed?
Haymaker
14-04-2025, 09:59 PM
:hyper
Unseen work
14-04-2025, 10:10 PM
Been looking forward to this thread 😁
Unseen Work to post his first YouTube reel by page 3 😁😁
https://youtu.be/hYwGlwMpOTI?feature=shared
I’ll start it early 🤣
Unseen work
14-04-2025, 10:11 PM
Who confirmed Bursik and Kwon are out? I fully expect they will be but when/where was it confirmed?
I assume he means because their loans are expiring and they’ll be returning to their parent clubs
scoopyboy
14-04-2025, 11:26 PM
A rumoured in from Sunday’s game.
Anthony Ralston, an auld boy was telling me at half time. Was all excited about it as it was from a Celtic employee.
Said he had never got a signing rumour before in all his years watching Hibs
badabing67
15-04-2025, 12:01 AM
About time this thread was opened :aok:
badabing67
15-04-2025, 12:15 AM
A rumoured in from Sunday’s game.
Anthony Ralston, an auld boy was telling me at half time. Was all excited about it as it was from a Celtic employee.
Said he had never got a signing rumour before in all his years watching Hibs
Ralston's contract runs till 2027 the only way I could see him coming here is loan. MM is well in with Brendan so I suspect something would be lined up from there. I also expect Lenny will get a bit of a helping hand for the Pars as well.
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 12:25 AM
What’s Motherwell’s Dan Casey like ? ( not us linked btw ) .
Bridge hibs
15-04-2025, 05:04 AM
A rumoured in from Sunday’s game.
Anthony Ralston, an auld boy was telling me at half time. Was all excited about it as it was from a Celtic employee.
Said he had never got a signing rumour before in all his years watching HibsProbably many wont agree with me but Ive always thought Ralston to be a decent player with celtc but not so much for Scotland, although I said a while back he was chucked into a few Scotland games when he had literarily been bench warming for celtc and it was noticeable he was way off it.
04Sauzee
15-04-2025, 05:24 AM
Been looking forward to this thread 😁
Unseen Work to post his first YouTube reel by page 3 😁😁
Nice 😅
I notice has scores as many with his left foot as he does his right foot.
I’ve missed the NMW rumour, who’s supposedly in for him?
04Sauzee
15-04-2025, 05:42 AM
What’s Motherwell’s Dan Casey like ? ( not us linked btw ) .
Hearts fans seemed to think they were signing him in January.
scoopyboy
15-04-2025, 06:47 AM
Hearts fans seemed to think they were signing him in January.
Seemingly close to signing for them now
green day
15-04-2025, 06:56 AM
Who confirmed Bursik and Kwon are out? I fully expect they will be but when/where was it confirmed?
Its because their loan period ends.
Coco Bryce
15-04-2025, 07:59 AM
We are looking at a Midfielder from Preston North End.
CallumLaidlaw
15-04-2025, 08:07 AM
We are looking at a Midfielder from Preston North End.
https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20250415/d19c609195b47c43081113c85f09e7a4.jpg
Ledson unrealistic?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
we are hibs
15-04-2025, 08:12 AM
https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20250415/d19c609195b47c43081113c85f09e7a4.jpg
Ledson unrealistic?
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkDidn't we try and sign him under Stubbs when he was younger?
Sent from my SM-A405FN using Tapatalk
Bridge hibs
15-04-2025, 08:18 AM
https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20250415/d19c609195b47c43081113c85f09e7a4.jpg
Ledson unrealistic?
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkPre contract perhaps, if it is him ?
Hibernian Verse
15-04-2025, 08:25 AM
Could be Robbie Brady. He would suit our older heads category especially when Gayle is leaving and Hoilett is out of contract.
JohnM1875
15-04-2025, 08:28 AM
Could be Robbie Brady. He would suit our older heads category especially when Gayle is leaving and Hoilett is out of contract.
Hmm played mainly left mid for them this season. He is ex-Bournemouth, though before Black Knights I’m sure.
Could be Robbie Brady. He would suit our older heads category especially when Gayle is leaving and Hoilett is out of contract.
Maybe but with N Cadden and Obita are we not covered in that area?
Coco Bryce
15-04-2025, 09:00 AM
Hmm played mainly left mid for them this season. He is ex-Bournemouth, though before Black Knights I’m sure.
Not sure who it is but I was told it is a recommendation from Tim Bezbatchenko
Paulie Walnuts
15-04-2025, 09:03 AM
I assume he means because their loans are expiring and they’ll be returning to their parent clubs
Jesus, I’d completely forgot Kwon existed.
babahibs
15-04-2025, 09:19 AM
Wasn't Dalby at Dundee Utd rumoured on here a few weeks back, or did I imagine that?
badabing67
15-04-2025, 09:35 AM
We are looking at a Midfielder from Preston North End.
Who? Wouldn't say no to Ally McCann but his contract runs to 2027 so doubt it would be him
Thatdayinmay16
15-04-2025, 09:43 AM
I know we just humped them 4-0 but, I think Josh Mulligan could be a good potential addition, young, played a good number of games at the top level and been one of Dundee's better players in the last 2-3 years.
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 09:53 AM
Hearts fans seemed to think they were signing him in January.
Been mentioned again , one says it’s almost done too . I can’t say I ever really noticed him .
Another article I read said that Sevco are in talks with the agent of Peterborough’s Poku .
Centre Hawf
15-04-2025, 10:00 AM
A rumoured in from Sunday’s game.
Anthony Ralston, an auld boy was telling me at half time. Was all excited about it as it was from a Celtic employee.
Said he had never got a signing rumour before in all his years watching Hibs
Have no ITK on if it's currently happening, but Ralston was one that we tried to get on loan when Lee Johnson was here and was told no. I wouldn't be hugely surprised if that door has reopened.
JohnM1875
15-04-2025, 10:09 AM
Have no ITK on if it's currently happening, but Ralston was one that we tried to get on loan when Lee Johnson was here and was told no. I wouldn't be hugely surprised if that door has reopened.
I honestly think he’s gash.
Thatdayinmay16
15-04-2025, 10:10 AM
I honestly think he’s gash.
Agreed, him and that Liam Scales being at Celtic for as long as they have been is mind boggling.
Unseen work
15-04-2025, 10:14 AM
Have a search of Ryan Ledson on Twitter, he’ll get sent off every week up here 🤣
Some mental challenges!
Looks like he would be a ‘6’ and Triantis replacement. Big lad and seems to have a good range of passing
badabing67
15-04-2025, 10:14 AM
Been mentioned again , one says it’s almost done too . I can’t say I ever really noticed him .
Another article I read said that Sevco are in talks with the agent of Peterborough’s Poku .
Got to wonder what will happen there, would of thought there would be a hold on transfer business till the new owners were in. Bet Lyall Cameron must be concerned about how things will pan out for him now. I imagine there is going to be a pretty big clear out.
EGL2000
15-04-2025, 10:17 AM
A rumoured in from Sunday’s game.
Anthony Ralston, an auld boy was telling me at half time. Was all excited about it as it was from a Celtic employee.
Said he had never got a signing rumour before in all his years watching Hibs
Would be delighted with that he's really improved over the past few years. Just can't see it happening though as still under contract with Celtic.
Centre Hawf
15-04-2025, 10:18 AM
I honestly think he’s gash.
I would say that currently I wouldn't break any budget to get him if we have Chris Cadden/Miller/Megwa all in that position. But I think he'd be a good signing for us if it was a position we were looking to fill. I don't think he's starting for Scotland level personally but I also don't believe he's a terrible player by any stretch.
CapitalGreen
15-04-2025, 10:18 AM
Ralston would be an excellent signing.
EGL2000
15-04-2025, 10:20 AM
I honestly think he’s gash.
He's definitely improved alot I used to think he was guff as well. Even for Scotland recently he's not looked out of place at all.
badabing67
15-04-2025, 10:23 AM
Agreed, him and that Liam Scales being at Celtic for as long as they have been is mind boggling.
It wouldn't surprise me if me if Scales ended up back at Aberdeen next season. And for Ralston I'd think he would only come here if SDG is thinking about having the option of playing 4 at the back. Could be wrong but isn't Ralston pretty much a fullback as apposed to a wingback . Though he can put in a decent cross.
Halmyre Hibee
15-04-2025, 10:25 AM
I know we just humped them 4-0 but, I think Josh Mulligan could be a good potential addition, young, played a good number of games at the top level and been one of Dundee's better players in the last 2-3 years.
I thought he played well going forward on the right against us. Managed a few runs through us on the right hand side. Good age with plenty potential.
CapitalGreen
15-04-2025, 10:33 AM
Not sure who it is but I was told it is a recommendation from Tim Bezbatchenko
Could be Theo Mawene?
Turns 18 in the summer, Brighton and Brentford have been looking at him apparently. Could be one Bournemouth sign and then send up here. Would make sense if Bezbatchenko is involved.
Thatdayinmay16
15-04-2025, 10:33 AM
It wouldn't surprise me if me if Scales ended up back at Aberdeen next season. And for Ralston I'd think he would only come here if SDG is thinking about having the option of playing 4 at the back. Could be wrong but isn't Ralston pretty much a fullback as apposed to a wingback . Though he can put in a decent cross.
I'll be hoping he does end up back at Aberdeen, 2 red cards and about 11 goals shipped in 2 games while he was at the heart of the Aberdeen side's defence when we played them a couple of years ago, he is absolutely rotten.
I'll reserve judgement for Ralston, If he can slot in at full back to help Miller/Cadden then great, plus he has European experience which could help us in the long run.
It also potentially means that O'Hora slots in at CCB and Megwa would then be sold.
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 10:34 AM
Got to wonder what will happen there, would of thought there would be a hold on transfer business till the new owners were in. Bet Lyall Cameron must be concerned about how things will pan out for him now. I imagine there is going to be a pretty big clear out.
There was a video in the sun with Boyd and some other guy talking about a clear out that was needed there . Interesting one that came up was a player they have on loan who Boyd said they must use every loophole they possibly can in order not to sign him as the fee being talked about is around £3mil .
Paulie Walnuts
15-04-2025, 10:36 AM
Ralston would be an excellent signing.
:agree:
keep the faith
15-04-2025, 10:49 AM
I'm hoping for no new signings. Extend Rocky, Boyle and Miller. Hoilet for another year and sell Yoane and Vente. Use that money for a hopeful Triantis bid. Done!
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 10:54 AM
Agreed, him and that Liam Scales being at Celtic for as long as they have been is mind boggling.
I would have agreed with you around the time Scales was at Aberdeen but I think he’s improved a lot and his a better option than Trusty for them ..
As for Ralston , if there was anything in it does that mean Miller is moving on? . I think Ralston is a good club man for them and would be surprised if there was anything in it tbh .
LEaston87
15-04-2025, 10:56 AM
I'm hoping for no new signings. Extend Rocky, Boyle and Miller. Hoilet for another year and sell Yoane and Vente. Use that money for a hopeful Triantis bid. Done!
We need to make signings and constantly improve the team and if we have Group Stage European football next season we need more quality throughout the squad. We can't make the same mistakes we made after finishing third the last time under JR.
andrew70
15-04-2025, 10:57 AM
Scales is terrible. Better than Trusty, no chance.
Ralston would be a good signing and competition for C.Cadden now Miller has found his best position.
Would suit our formation well too.
CapitalGreen
15-04-2025, 11:02 AM
I'm hoping for no new signings. Extend Rocky, Boyle and Miller. Hoilet for another year and sell Yoane and Vente. Use that money for a hopeful Triantis bid. Done!
Ah the good old Hibs hubris after any modicum of success.
badabing67
15-04-2025, 11:18 AM
I'll be hoping he does end up back at Aberdeen, 2 red cards and about 11 goals shipped in 2 games while he was at the heart of the Aberdeen side's defence when we played them a couple of years ago, he is absolutely rotten.
I'll reserve judgement for Ralston, If he can slot in at full back to help Miller/Cadden then great, plus he has European experience which could help us in the long run.
It also potentially means that O'Hora slots in at CCB and Megwa would then be sold.
TBH I could only see the Ralston thing happening if we get guaranteed group stage Euro footie
Hiber-nation
15-04-2025, 11:19 AM
Ralston would be a fantastic signing. Probably best in a back 4 mind you and we don't want to change back to that any time soon. But good at RWB and could also slot in at RCB.
badabing67
15-04-2025, 11:22 AM
I would have agreed with you around the time Scales was at Aberdeen but I think he’s improved a lot and his a better option than Trusty for them ..
As for Ralston , if there was anything in it does that mean Miller is moving on? . I think Ralston is a good club man for them and would be surprised if there was anything in it tbh .
Disagree about Scales he was the main reason we got so many opportunities against them at Parkhead in the league. He was poor that day. Trusty looked much better than him against us in the Scottish Cup
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 11:22 AM
Scales is terrible. Better than Trusty, no chance.
Ralston would be a good signing and competition for C.Cadden now Miller has found his best position.
Would suit our formation well too.
I know a fair few Celtic supporters that would disagree with you in they much prefer a defensive partnership of Vickers and Scales to one of Vickers and Trusty ..
Some of them have singled out quite a few times Trusty has been at fault , one of them being Campbells first goal in our 2-1 victory.
CapitalGreen
15-04-2025, 11:29 AM
Could be Theo Mawene?
Turns 18 in the summer, Brighton and Brentford have been looking at him apparently. Could be one Bournemouth sign and then send up here. Would make sense if Bezbatchenko is involved.
To add to this, he’s yet to sign a professional contract with PNE. If he moved to a Scottish club, the fee would be much lower than if he moved to another English club.
Since452
15-04-2025, 11:31 AM
We really need to build on this season and not screw SDG over the same way we did Jack Ross when we finished 3rd. It's so important we get the summer window right.
If we finish 3rd we have a real opportunity to elevate this club further going forward. What a chance we have. Let's not let history repeat itself.
andrew70
15-04-2025, 11:36 AM
I know a fair few Celtic supporters that would disagree with you in they much prefer a defensive partnership of Vickers and Scales to one of Vickers and Trusty ..
Some of them have singled out quite a few times Trusty has been at fault , one of them being Campbells first goal in our 2-1 victory.
None of the Celtic fans I know rate Scales. He’s a token gesture to most.
Will never play at such a high level once he leaves Celtic and I include Aberdeen, Hibs etc.
badabing67
15-04-2025, 11:42 AM
To add to this, he’s yet to sign a professional contract with PNE. If he moved to a Scottish club, the fee would be much lower than if he moved to another English club.
You found a clip yet
eastmainsmsh
15-04-2025, 11:42 AM
Could be Theo Mawene?
Turns 18 in the summer, Brighton and Brentford have been looking at him apparently. Could be one Bournemouth sign and then send up here. Would make sense if Bezbatchenko is involved.
Is that his dad that was at preston and Aberdeen was decent 🤔
superfurryhibby
15-04-2025, 11:47 AM
Ralston would be an excellent signing.
Who would he displace from the current team? I suppose if Miller is to leave and we want to play a back four, he would do a job there.
I would prefer Miller gets his contract extended, he's turning into a very good RCB, and can play right back if needed.
Billy Whizz
15-04-2025, 11:49 AM
Have no ITK on if it's currently happening, but Ralston was one that we tried to get on loan when Lee Johnson was here and was told no. I wouldn't be hugely surprised if that door has reopened.
Ralston is an out and out right back, not a wing back. If we were to sign him we’d be looking to change shape to a back 4 on a regular basis
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 12:10 PM
None of the Celtic fans I know rate Scales. He’s a token gesture to most.
Will never play at such a high level once he leaves Celtic and I include Aberdeen, Hibs etc.
I didn’t rate him either especially from his time at Aberdeen but I’ve changed my opinion on him having watched him with both Celtic and the ROI . I think he’s improved.
The Celtic fans I know want another CH in the summer that’s better than him and Trusty but most in the meantime prefer Scales to partner Vickers . At least the ones I know do .
You say he will never play at a higher level including Aberdeen , Hibs etc but is he any worse than the likes of Gallagher, Graham ( Dundee Utd ), Halkett ,McCart (hertz ) , Rubezic , Knoester ( Aberdeen) O’Hora ,Ekpiteta or would he be an upgrade on some of these ? .
https://www.skysports.com/football/video/36620/13310704/another-own-goal-jamie-mccart-scores-second-own-goal-to-extend-rangers-lead
Billy Whizz
15-04-2025, 12:16 PM
Got to wonder what will happen there, would of thought there would be a hold on transfer business till the new owners were in. Bet Lyall Cameron must be concerned about how things will pan out for him now. I imagine there is going to be a pretty big clear out.
They haven’t even agreed a fee with Dundee for him yet
Dundee looking for the type of money Aberdeen got for Barron
JimBHibees
15-04-2025, 12:17 PM
Probably many wont agree with me but Ive always thought Ralston to be a decent player with celtc but not so much for Scotland, although I said a while back he was chucked into a few Scotland games when he had literarily been bench warming for celtc and it was noticeable he was way off it.
Personally think a decent player
JimBHibees
15-04-2025, 12:20 PM
What’s Motherwell’s Dan Casey like ? ( not us linked btw ) .
Pretty rugged up and at them centre back. Bit reckless but a decent goal threat from set pieces
AgentDaleCooper
15-04-2025, 12:21 PM
:hyper
No way...is it really true thus time?! :hyper
JimBHibees
15-04-2025, 12:22 PM
I would say that currently I wouldn't break any budget to get him if we have Chris Cadden/Miller/Megwa all in that position. But I think he'd be a good signing for us if it was a position we were looking to fill. I don't think he's starting for Scotland level personally but I also don't believe he's a terrible player by any stretch.
Can’t see Megwa being a first team regular
Can’t see Megwa being a first team regular
Agree
andrew70
15-04-2025, 12:30 PM
I didn’t rate him either especially from his time at Aberdeen but I’ve changed my opinion on him having watched him with both Celtic and the ROI . I think he’s improved.
The Celtic fans I know want another CH in the summer that’s better than him and Trusty but most in the meantime prefer Scales to partner Vickers . At least the ones I know do .
You say he will never play at a higher level including Aberdeen , Hibs etc but is he any worse than the likes of Gallagher, Graham ( Dundee Utd ), Halkett ,McCart (hertz ) , Rubezic , Knoester ( Aberdeen) O’Hora ,Ekpiteta or would he be an upgrade on some of these ? .
https://www.skysports.com/football/video/36620/13310704/another-own-goal-jamie-mccart-scores-second-own-goal-to-extend-rangers-lead
Would rather both our centre halves to be honest. The rest are torture but glad they don’t play for us.
Smartie
15-04-2025, 12:46 PM
I honestly think he’s gash.
Ralston would be an excellent signing.
I could see him being either.
He's not played all that much football over the years so he's actually half decent considering that.
With a solid couple of seasons behind him where he plays every week I wouldn't be surprised if he turned into a very good player.
I just don't think you get to be that player being a reserve for Celtic who has the odd loan behind him and, er, the odd international appearance plus occasionally coming in from the cold to deputise at his club.
CapitalGreen
15-04-2025, 12:57 PM
You found a clip yet
https://www.facebook.com/share/v/16DAytprGx/?mibextid=wwXIfr
badabing67
15-04-2025, 01:20 PM
They haven’t even agreed a fee with Dundee for him yet
Dundee looking for the type of money Aberdeen got for Barron
Will be another tribunal, it will cost Dundee a packet in legal fees
badabing67
15-04-2025, 01:23 PM
https://www.facebook.com/share/v/16DAytprGx/?mibextid=wwXIfr
Good work
HoboHarry
15-04-2025, 01:41 PM
Been mentioned again , one says it’s almost done too . I can’t say I ever really noticed him .
Another article I read said that Sevco are in talks with the agent of Peterborough’s Poku .
If that's the market that Sevco are looking at then they are knackered, they won't catch Celtic if that's the best they can afford.
cubehindthegoal
15-04-2025, 01:47 PM
Agreed, him and that Liam Scales being at Celtic for as long as they have been is mind boggling.
I think they both have “room for improvement” … and part of me thinks we could improve Ralston, and the other part says na, surely celtic would have already. Hmm .. this fence I’m sitting on is comfy it seems 😂
The important thing next season is we don’t do what hearts did this season, and we make the most of our progress, keep as many of the players who have achieved this season like they have that we can, continue to move on the ones who should play no part, and bring in even one or two (I know we may need more depending on who moves on, and I’d add in an extra good goalie in addition actually) like Bowie and Cadden, and aim for more progress.
Cabbage-Patch
15-04-2025, 01:48 PM
Could be Robbie Brady. He would suit our older heads category especially when Gayle is leaving and Hoilett is out of contract.
Correct me if I'm wrong but Gayle retiring isn't 100% confirmed. I'm sure he said after the win at Tynie if he was still scoring goals and enjoying playing he would reconsider.
JohnM1875
15-04-2025, 01:48 PM
If that's the market that Sevco are looking at then they are knackered, they won't catch Celtic if that's the best they can afford.
Could be wrong, but think they have a £4mil obligation to buy that Cortes who’s always out injured for them.
So probably penny-pinching elsewhere.
cubehindthegoal
15-04-2025, 01:54 PM
I would say that currently I wouldn't break any budget to get him if we have Chris Cadden/Miller/Megwa all in that position. But I think he'd be a good signing for us if it was a position we were looking to fill. I don't think he's starting for Scotland level personally but I also don't believe he's a terrible player by any stretch.
Miller is doing a great job at RCH in a back three…. Cadden I am fine with in a pool of right wing backs … Megwa I haven’t as yet been convinced of … so if we find a strong option for RWB, I think it would be a sensible signing … LWB .. I enjoyed watching Obita on Sunday, and he could get better now it’s a 3-5-2 … and Nicky Cadden too … hmm … and there’s more to ponder, and also young players to come through at some point hopefully …
Good to have these “problems”. Well done SDG for getting us to this position, and also moving on when we can those that are better to move on.
.Sean.
15-04-2025, 02:18 PM
Correct me if I'm wrong but Gayle retiring isn't 100% confirmed. I'm sure he said after the win at Tynie if he was still scoring goals and enjoying playing he would reconsider.
He’s never played in Europe. I think (hope) that might sway him
Bostonhibby
15-04-2025, 02:22 PM
If that's the market that Sevco are looking at then they are knackered, they won't catch Celtic if that's the best they can afford.Agree, seen him a few times, good player at that level, not sure about the development potential but no higher up club seriously linked. Never occurred to me that he'd add much to Hibs but you never know.
Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk
HoboHarry
15-04-2025, 02:23 PM
Could be wrong, but think they have a £4mil obligation to buy that Cortes who’s always out injured for them.
So probably penny-pinching elsewhere.
Good grief, I'd no idea lol, yet another calamitous decision by them. Seriously, if we can build on what we currently have and that's where Sevco are at there isn't a reason in the world why we can't finish second next year.
theonlywayisup
15-04-2025, 02:29 PM
Good grief, I'd no idea lol, yet another calamitous decision by them. Seriously, if we can build on what we currently have and that's where Sevco are at there isn't a reason in the world why we can't finish second next year.
I'm getting Dhanda "split the Old Firm" vibes :duck:
HoboHarry
15-04-2025, 02:34 PM
I'm getting Dhanda "split the Old Firm" vibes :duck:
Well to be fair it's more of a reflection on how poor a state Sevco are in financially as opposed to what we are doing. Given their resources they should be out of sight from us but they aren't...
hibee316
15-04-2025, 02:38 PM
Well to be fair it's more of a reflection on how poor a state Sevco are in financially as opposed to what we are doing. Given their resources they should be out of sight from us but they aren't...
...they are
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 02:50 PM
If that's the market that Sevco are looking at then they are knackered, they won't catch Celtic if that's the best they can afford.
I think there were quite a few clubs interested in him before he got injured . How good is he ? I don’t know but he appears to be on Sevco’s radar , probably because his contract is near out ..
https://the72.co.uk/2025/02/19/burnley-peterborough-united-darragh-macanthony-winter-interest-kwame-poku/
The other one that’s interesting is Boyd in the Sun says Sevco must do everything they can to get out of signing Cortes who they have on loan with an obligation to buy for around £3 mill …
I’d love it if they had to pay £3mill for a player they don’t want 😆
tonyrougier123
15-04-2025, 02:54 PM
Got to say I’m a big Liam scales admirer, think he’s perfect kind of cb for our shape, didn’t always rate him though. Still hold out hope we can get pleguezelo if Plymouth go down. Think that’s realistic. Or maybe not 😬
Since90+2
15-04-2025, 02:56 PM
I'm getting Dhanda "split the Old Firm" vibes :duck:
Yip.
Talk of finishing 2nd next season is very jamboesque, let's try and secure 3rd this season before we get ahead of ourselves.
Smartie
15-04-2025, 03:05 PM
Got to say I’m a big Liam scales admirer, think he’s perfect kind of cb for our shape, didn’t always rate him though. Still hold out hope we can get pleguezelo if Plymouth go down. Think that’s realistic. Or maybe not 😬
He’s got a lot of improving to do before he’s fit to clean Jack Iredale’s boots.
HoboHarry
15-04-2025, 03:05 PM
I think there were quite a few clubs interested in him before he got injured . How good is he ? I don’t know but he appears to be on Sevco’s radar , probably because his contract is near out ..
https://the72.co.uk/2025/02/19/burnley-peterborough-united-darragh-macanthony-winter-interest-kwame-poku/
The other one that’s interesting is Boyd in the Sun says Sevco must do everything they can to get out of signing Cortes who they have on loan with an obligation to buy for around £3 mill …
I’d love it if they had to pay £3mill for a player they don’t want 😆
Thay have previous for not reading the fine print too closely lol. If Boyd is saying that publicly then I suspect they know privately they can't get out of it.
Hibby Kay-Yay
15-04-2025, 03:08 PM
Talk of Ralston is making me think of why would we change to a back 4 when a back 3 is our strongest and most balanced system with these players.
Rocky has never looked comfortable in a back 4 and I’m yet to be convinced of Iredale as a LB or Miller/Cadden as a RB.
I wonder if we are considering changing formation. But then I think why giving the run we are on just now.
Thatdayinmay16
15-04-2025, 03:10 PM
Got to say I’m a big Liam scales admirer, think he’s perfect kind of cb for our shape, didn’t always rate him though. Still hold out hope we can get pleguezelo if Plymouth go down. Think that’s realistic. Or maybe not 😬
I'd Genuienly rather Sean Ohanlon than Liam Scales.
Wilson
15-04-2025, 03:11 PM
Good grief, I'd no idea lol, yet another calamitous decision by them. Seriously, if we can build on what we currently have and that's where Sevco are at there isn't a reason in the world why we can't finish second next year.
There is too many moving parts, on our own side even, to consider that a possibility. For example does Rocky stay? Has Gayle got another season? Is Boyle Australia bound? Is there a remote possibility of getting Triantis back?
Not being able to keep a decent team together is an age old hibs problem.
Even considering that the recruitment team knows what they are doing, you have to allow for the new players to bed in. For a dynamic anything close to the current one to be found.
Rightly, we'll be looking to secure top six as soon as possible and THEN seeing how far we can go.
And all this went without saying that typically teams in Europe struggle to maintain their league form while competing on the big stage.
2nd? Crazy talk.
cubehindthegoal
15-04-2025, 03:13 PM
Well to be fair it's more of a reflection on how poor a state Sevco are in financially as opposed to what we are doing. Given their resources they should be out of sight from us but they aren't...
League table says they are, even now … the rangers have been pretty crap, yet are still not catchable now (oh, but I do like to dream it so, but money talks, as they find out in the Champions League time after time too) … celtic and the rangers will always generate more cash than all the other Scottish clubs, from glory hunter appeal … and similarly, there are European teams out of sight from them.
Bridge hibs
15-04-2025, 03:13 PM
Talk of Ralston is making me think of why would we change to a back 4 when a back 3 is our strongest and most balanced system with these players.
Rocky has never looked comfortable in a back 4 and I’m yet to be convinced of Iredale as a LB or Miller/Cadden as a RB.
I wonder if we are considering changing formation. But then I think why giving the run we are on just now.If we get into europe I would expect we may have to switch formations to suit certain ties, that along with having a substantial pool of players to play midweek and weekend schedules. I know europe could be over quickly depending our luck of the draw but I would hope we are making signings with the thought of competing in europe regularly.
Smartie
15-04-2025, 03:15 PM
Talk of Ralston is making me think of why would we change to a back 4 when a back 3 is our strongest and most balanced system with these players.
Rocky has never looked comfortable in a back 4 and I’m yet to be convinced of Iredale as a LB or Miller/Cadden as a RB.
I wonder if we are considering changing formation. But then I think why giving the run we are on just now.
I was thinking on Saturday… that if we’d persisted with these players in a 433 all season and especially with Myko as a single central striker… Gray would be about 4 months gone, we’d be in the bottom 2, we’d be tearing strips off one another, desperately looking forward to the summer rebuild and pondering whether we first need to punt Gray’s successor.
I actually think we might be a bit complacent about what might lie ahead. Sweeping changes to the team (maybe enforced by losing players whose contracts are coming to an end), a change to a formation that doesn’t suit our players and I could see us hurtling backwards as quickly as we’ve recently progressed.
We should really value what we’ve got right now imo.
tonyrougier123
15-04-2025, 03:21 PM
I'd Genuienly rather Sean Ohanlon than Liam Scales.
I’d have thought a year ago, seen Celtic quite a bit with him there, comfortable on ball always looking forward, alert. Aye he’s had some shoddy moments for sheep and Celtic but I really rate him as a modern cb, but I do understand folks pre conceptions of the player he was. I’m not even sure why there was chat about him just seen him mentioned and thought I’d give an opinion the player.
tonyrougier123
15-04-2025, 03:24 PM
I know we just humped them 4-0 but, I think Josh Mulligan could be a good potential addition, young, played a good number of games at the top level and been one of Dundee's better players in the last 2-3 years.
Mulligan would be a very good signing, versatile and scope for further improvement in a decent side.
Can’t see Megwa being a first team regular
He got Thistle's young player of the year however the replies on the twitter post where less than complimentary, think he may have won by default
djw80!
15-04-2025, 03:41 PM
He got Thistle's young player of the year however the replies on the twitter post where less than complimentary, think he may have won by default
Aye they were not very compilentary to him in the replies.
Thatdayinmay16
15-04-2025, 03:50 PM
Mulligan would be a very good signing, versatile and scope for further improvement in a decent side.
At only 22 and out of contract, its one of the lower risk signings.
Definitely worth a punt imo.
JohnM1875
15-04-2025, 03:52 PM
At only 22 and out of contract, its one of the lower risk signings.
Definitely worth a punt imo.
Think he had plenty of the ball for them but didn’t really do anything with it.
Like you say though, out of contract so could be a smart addition to the squad if we make the group stages.
Hibernian Verse
15-04-2025, 03:54 PM
Think he had plenty of the ball for them but didn’t really do anything with it.
Like you say though, out of contract so could be a smart addition to the squad if we make the group stages.
I thought he made some really good runs with and without the ball and recovered it from Triantis a couple of times.
Edit: Looks like he's a Dundee youth product so he will require a development fee despite being out of contract.
Bridge hibs
15-04-2025, 03:57 PM
He got Thistle's young player of the year however the replies on the twitter post where less than complimentary, think he may have won by default
Think they were gutted Brian Graham didnt get it
Thatdayinmay16
15-04-2025, 03:58 PM
I thought he made some really good runs with and without the ball and recovered it from Triantis a couple of times.
Edit: Looks like he's a Dundee youth product so he will require a development fee despite being out of contract.
Can't we just do what Rangers do and drag their feet not pay anything for months?
Hibernian Verse
15-04-2025, 03:59 PM
Can't we just do what Rangers do and drag their feet not pay anything for months?
We probably would if it can't be agreed between the clubs.
Saint Hibee
15-04-2025, 04:03 PM
I wasn't aware Liam Scales had ever escaped from Ryan Porteous's back pocket.
04Sauzee
15-04-2025, 04:09 PM
You found a clip yet
https://youtu.be/ypJqaDgLvEU?si=VXB_lA7tlz33Oqhv
badabing67
15-04-2025, 04:13 PM
Got to say I’m a big Liam scales admirer, think he’s perfect kind of cb for our shape, didn’t always rate him though. Still hold out hope we can get pleguezelo if Plymouth go down. Think that’s realistic. Or maybe not
This all day long for Pleguezelo I really was hoping we would of got him in the last window but he wanted to play against Liverpool in the cup
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 04:39 PM
Seen this guy mentioned on a championship club forum …
https://x.com/jscrimpSTATS/status/1845211908636323897
04Sauzee
15-04-2025, 04:49 PM
Seen this guy mentioned on a championship club forum …
https://x.com/jscrimpSTATS/status/1845211908636323897
Mentioned as in linked with us?
tonyrougier123
15-04-2025, 04:56 PM
I think whatever happens this window, taking numbers we might need for group euro stages in to account, it has been shown how much more can be coached into a side by reducing a huge squad down to 2 eleven's. Malky Mackay deserves huge credit for keeping the right players and trimming us down very quickly. Good football man, glad to have him at the club. And long may that be the case.
ancient hibee
15-04-2025, 05:17 PM
Seen this guy mentioned on a championship club forum …
https://x.com/jscrimpSTATS/status/1845211908636323897
Looks like a lot of dribbling and little end product.
Donegal Hibby
15-04-2025, 05:23 PM
Mentioned as in linked with us?
Sorry .. not us seen someone mentioned him on the Preston forum.
Not transfer news but seen this on another form too …
https://x.com/SwansOfficial/status/1911837103542903206
Northernhibee
15-04-2025, 05:45 PM
Looks like a lot of dribbling and little end product.
Looks very Sylvester Jasper-esque
badabing67
15-04-2025, 06:28 PM
Seen this guy mentioned on a championship club forum …
https://x.com/jscrimpSTATS/status/1845211908636323897
The type we would need to replace Elie
CapitalGreen
15-04-2025, 06:32 PM
At only 22 and out of contract, its one of the lower risk signings.
Definitely worth a punt imo.
Out of contract but would be due Dundee a development fee northwards of £500k.
tonyrougier123
15-04-2025, 06:37 PM
Out of contract but would be due Dundee a development fee northwards of £500k.
Shrewd investment.
EGL2000
15-04-2025, 07:25 PM
Looks very Sylvester Jasper-esque
Was literally about to mention him !
MacGruber
15-04-2025, 08:56 PM
I'm hoping for no new signings. Extend Rocky, Boyle and Miller. Hoilet for another year and sell Yoane and Vente. Use that money for a hopeful Triantis bid. Done!
Would say we have to make new signings but our top targets should be Rocky and Miller. Got to be keeping Boyle aswell and with the year option is a no brainer. I'd also like to see Levitt extend now he's showing the quality he has.
We will lose Youan, Gayle, Myko and possibly Hoilett from those contributing. Kwon, Bursik, Vente, Tavares, Kenneh - there'll be plenty movement in the summer.
McGrath and Manneh in the door already.
500miles
16-04-2025, 10:27 AM
Out of contract but would be due Dundee a development fee northwards of £500k.
Would it be that high? He's been a first pick for the latter half of this season, but in and out before that. Dropped out of the team after they got promoted?
Thatdayinmay16
16-04-2025, 10:50 AM
Would it be that high? He's been a first pick for the latter half of this season, but in and out before that. Dropped out of the team after they got promoted?
He was injured at the start and then again toward the end of the season last year for Dundee that's why he dropped out after the split.
Still played a decent amount of games in a midfield alongside Cameron, McCowan and Sylla last season. Was a hernia injury that kept him out if I remember correctly.
Hibs3-2
16-04-2025, 10:52 AM
Smith
Cadden Miller
Iredale Rocky ohora marv
Cadden Obita
Triantis Mcgrath newell NMW levitt campbell mnneh
Boyle bowie gayle hoilett rudi
If we can keep that squad together, sell tavares/youan/vente to fund triantis deal, then we only really need a GK, CM and a striker. For once we might actually be well prepared for european playoffs rather than having to stick someones mate in goals like we have previous.
CapitalGreen
16-04-2025, 11:11 AM
Would it be that high? He's been a first pick for the latter half of this season, but in and out before that. Dropped out of the team after they got promoted?
The development fee set by Tribunal for Connor Barron was £640k + £250k in potential add-ons and a sell on clause.
Mulligan is the same age as Barron, has played more senior games, has more international caps. He has been developed by Dundee longer than Barron spent at Aberdeen.
I imagine he’ll move South as any fee to move domestically will prove to prohibitive and nobody will want to risk a tribunal.
JohnM1875
16-04-2025, 11:12 AM
The development fee set by Tribunal for Connor Barron was £640k + £250k in potential add-ons and a sell on clause.
Mulligan is the same age as Barron, has played more senior games, has more international caps. He has been developed by Dundee longer than Barron spent at Aberdeen.
Then I’d personally be passing on Mulligan.
bingo70
16-04-2025, 11:18 AM
The development fee set by Tribunal for Connor Barron was £640k + £250k in potential add-ons and a sell on clause.
Mulligan is the same age as Barron, has played more senior games, has more international caps. He has been developed by Dundee longer than Barron spent at Aberdeen.
I imagine he’ll move South as any fee to move domestically will prove to prohibitive and nobody will want to risk a tribunal.
Does it make a difference what European grading the selling club are? (Not sure grading is the right word but hopefully you know what I mean). Sure it’s linked to facilities, number of coaches etc…..
If so, are Aberdeen and Dundee at the same level? If not, I think they would be due less than Aberdeen were for Barron?
eastmainsmsh
16-04-2025, 11:21 AM
Seen this guy mentioned on a championship club forum …
https://x.com/jscrimpSTATS/status/1845211908636323897
Youan without the sore toe
CapitalGreen
16-04-2025, 11:28 AM
Does it make a difference what European grading the selling club are? (Not sure grading is the right word but hopefully you know what I mean). Sure it’s linked to facilities, number of coaches etc…..
If so, are Aberdeen and Dundee at the same level? If not, I think they would be due less than Aberdeen were for Barron?
It does for the FIFA calculation. The SFA don’t publish their methodology so we can only guess but i imagine it will take that into account too.
Dundee’s academy is the level below Aberdeen which is why I don’t think they’ll get as much as Barron went for (£640-890k), and closer to £500k is more likely.
hibsbollah
16-04-2025, 11:41 AM
I'm getting Dhanda "split the Old Firm" vibes :duck:
Yep. It needs to be remembered this group could still end up finishing 5th. And even a chance we might not be in european competition if Hearts or Aberdeen shock everyone and win the cup. Despite the amazing run and the fun we’ve all had, we’ve achieved nowt at this point.
Yep. It needs to be remembered this group could still end up finishing 5th. And even a chance we might not be in european competition if Hearts or Aberdeen shock everyone and win the cup. Despite the amazing run and the fun we’ve all had, we’ve achieved nowt at this point.
If Celtic or Aberdeen win the cup - the team that finishes 5th will get into Europe. If St Johstone or Hearts win the cup - only the top 4 qualify for Europe.
Hibernian Verse
16-04-2025, 01:00 PM
Seen this guy mentioned on a championship club forum …
https://x.com/jscrimpSTATS/status/1845211908636323897
Remember how many goals Harry McKirdy scored in that league
andrew70
16-04-2025, 01:17 PM
Youan without the sore toe
So he’s quality then and would be one of our best players?
In that case sign him.
CapitalGreen
16-04-2025, 01:19 PM
Remember how many goals Harry McKirdy scored in that league
McKirdy scored more goals in that league than Ollie Watkins and Ivan Toney. Should probably judge players as individuals on their own merits rather than tarring every player with the same brush based simply on where they came from.
Smith
Cadden Miller
Iredale Rocky ohora marv
Cadden Obita
Triantis Mcgrath newell NMW levitt campbell mnneh
Boyle bowie gayle hoilett rudi
If we can keep that squad together, sell tavares/youan/vente to fund triantis deal, then we only really need a GK, CM and a striker. For once we might actually be well prepared for european playoffs rather than having to stick someones mate in goals like we have previous.
I think we could have a few of the young lads in the squad as well, especially if we make it into Europe
worcesterhibby
16-04-2025, 01:23 PM
Like others I'd like to see extensions for Boyle, Miller, Rocky and Hoilett. Plus use the £3million we get for Vente to buy Triantis :greengrin
So we would still need:
New 2nd goalie
Replacement for Dwight Gayle
Replacement for Myko
We need at least two GOOD players for event position
Goalies - Smith + Alex Paulsen ? (or another)
Right centre back - Miller + Marvin
Centre Back - Rocky + O'Hora
Left Centre Back - Iredale + Obita
Right wing back - C Cadden + Megwa ?
Left Wing Back - N. Cadden + ? (Obita can cover but not if Iredale is also injured)
Midfield - Triantis/Newell, McGrath/Campbell, Manneh/Levitt, Rudi/NMW
Forwards - Bowie/ ? Boyle/ ? Hoilett/?
I'm assuming the following will be away or retired:
Vente, Youan, Kwon, Bursik, Tavares, Delfierre, Kenneh, Gayle
It's up front that we have the most to get sorted... right now it's basically Bowie and no one else... so we need to get Boyle and Hoilett sorted or we are looking for up to four new forwards!! since as it stands we would be losing Boyle, Hoilett, Myko and Gayle
worcesterhibby
16-04-2025, 01:26 PM
McKirdy scored more goals in that league than Ollie Watkins and Ivan Toney. Should probably judge players as individuals on their own merits rather than tarring every player with the same brush based simply on where they came from.
Your right, but it was still a relevant reminder by HV
Harry was just too lightweight for our league, as well as being severly hampered by illness and bad dress sense. It's not a surprise that we have done much better since we introduced a load of big units to the line up ! Having said that if you are class, you don't need to be a big unit, just look at Dwight Gayle
badabing67
16-04-2025, 01:49 PM
Does it make a difference what European grading the selling club are? (Not sure grading is the right word but hopefully you know what I mean). Sure it’s linked to facilities, number of coaches etc…..
If so, are Aberdeen and Dundee at the same level? If not, I think they would be due less than Aberdeen were for Barron?
A proper can of worms this, if the 2 teams are in the same league would it be reasonable to assume that the clubs spend roughly the same to develop a player. The difference being the clubs with bigger budget can try to develop more players. Ultimately the ability of the player and hence the market value of the player should be the main consideration in setting a development fee. In your scenario, if you were a Motherwell fan. Would you not be a bit upset, if you got a lower level of development fee for Lennon Miller than Aberdeen got for Barron, because of the size of the club or some form of grading.
bingo70
16-04-2025, 01:56 PM
A proper can of worms this, if the 2 teams are in the same league would it be reasonable to assume that the clubs spend roughly the same to develop a player. The difference being the clubs with bigger budget can try to develop more players. Ultimately the ability of the player and hence the market value of the player should be the main consideration in setting a development fee. In your scenario, if you were a Motherwell fan. Would you not be a bit upset, if you got a lower level of development fee for Lennon Miller than Aberdeen got for Barron, because of the size of the club or some form of grading.
It’s always been the case that certain clubs will achieve more for selling a player than other clubs will. We would get more for selling a player than say Ross County would, the scenario you are talking about just sort of formalises it.
It’s not a pie in the sky figure made up out of nowhere, the figure is a reflection on how much that club spends on youth development. If Celtic spend say 10x more than Hibs to produce young players, I understand why when it comes to a tribunal, that would be taken into account. The organisations involved are trying to make sure it’s worthwhile for clubs to spend money on their youth infrastructure.
04Sauzee
16-04-2025, 04:20 PM
🚨 Nectarios Triantis' agent (Jem Karacan) speaking to @JamesDodd89 on rowzfc regarding reports of other clubs in Europe being interested in Triantis:
- 'Playing for the Socceroos is Triantis' dream
- With the season he's had (at Hibs), there is going to be a lot of interest.
- We have to weigh a lot of things up. He is contracted to Sunderland who are a huge club - will they get promoted?
- There's so many things we are still waiting on and those discussions have started to happen.
- The key will be what does Nectar want.
- Ultimately, with the world cup - that changes things - he has to play next year.
- We cannot afford for Nectar to go to a club and be 'bit-part'
- His experience this season of being one of the main-men - he needs to repeat that.
- He needs to make sure that if he gets to a club or returns to Sunderland there is going to be opportunities to play.
- Ultimately, that is our main focus - making sure that he goes to a team where he is going to be an important part of it.
- It will always come down to the player's performance, and we (agency) are trying to put him in the best environment where he can flourish.'
Broken Gnome
16-04-2025, 04:24 PM
🚨 Nectarios Triantis' agent (Jem Karacan) speaking to @JamesDodd89 on rowzfc regarding reports of other clubs in Europe being interested in Triantis:
- 'Playing for the Socceroos is Triantis' dream
- With the season he's had (at Hibs), there is going to be a lot of interest.
- We have to weigh a lot of things up. He is contracted to Sunderland who are a huge club - will they get promoted?
- There's so many things we are still waiting on and those discussions have started to happen.
- The key will be what does Nectar want.
- Ultimately, with the world cup - that changes things - he has to play next year.
- We cannot afford for Nectar to go to a club and be 'bit-part'
- His experience this season of being one of the main-men - he needs to repeat that.
- He needs to make sure that if he gets to a club or returns to Sunderland there is going to be opportunities to play.
- Ultimately, that is our main focus - making sure that he goes to a team where he is going to be an important part of it.
- It will always come down to the player's performance, and we (agency) are trying to put him in the best environment where he can flourish.'
That's fairly positive, in that it doesn't immediately indicate something higher profile than Scotland is essential.
CapitalGreen
16-04-2025, 04:26 PM
🚨 Nectarios Triantis' agent (Jem Karacan) speaking to @JamesDodd89 on rowzfc regarding reports of other clubs in Europe being interested in Triantis:
- 'Playing for the Socceroos is Triantis' dream
- With the season he's had (at Hibs), there is going to be a lot of interest.
- We have to weigh a lot of things up. He is contracted to Sunderland who are a huge club - will they get promoted?
- There's so many things we are still waiting on and those discussions have started to happen.
- The key will be what does Nectar want.
- Ultimately, with the world cup - that changes things - he has to play next year.
- We cannot afford for Nectar to go to a club and be 'bit-part'
- His experience this season of being one of the main-men - he needs to repeat that.
- He needs to make sure that if he gets to a club or returns to Sunderland there is going to be opportunities to play.
- Ultimately, that is our main focus - making sure that he goes to a team where he is going to be an important part of it.
- It will always come down to the player's performance, and we (agency) are trying to put him in the best environment where he can flourish.'
Sounds like he should stay at Hibs.
04Sauzee
16-04-2025, 04:49 PM
Daily Record
Houston Dynamo are closing in on a deal to sign St Mirren’s top scorer Toyosi Olusanya.
CapitalGreen
16-04-2025, 04:56 PM
Daily Record
Houston Dynamo are closing in on a deal to sign St Mirren’s top scorer Toyosi Olusanya.
The MLS transfer window closes on 23/04, presumably he’ll be moving before then meaning he won’t be facing us.
HoboHarry
16-04-2025, 05:19 PM
The MLS transfer window closes on 23/04, presumably he’ll be moving before then meaning he won’t be facing us.
Hope he likes the heat lol, it's only April so still high 20's/low 30's for now but the real temperatures are coming :greengrin
degenerated
16-04-2025, 06:13 PM
We are looking at a Midfielder from Preston North End.The only one I know from there is Ali McCann that used to be at St Johnstone. I'm sure he'd be out of our reach now.
bingo70
16-04-2025, 06:37 PM
The only one I know from there is Ali McCann that used to be at St Johnstone. I'm sure he'd be out of our reach now.
I thought he was a terrific player when he was with them. I rarely notice players playing against us but I thought he always stood out. There were some ridiculous running stats published about him at the time too I’m sure.
I doubt it’ll be him so this is a really pointless reply to you, would be good if it was though.
04Sauzee
16-04-2025, 06:41 PM
The only one I know from there is Ali McCann that used to be at St Johnstone. I'm sure he'd be out of our reach now.
Think he's still contracted for a couple of years and is valued at around £2m on transfermrkt. A fantastic player when he was with St J
Sounds like he should stay at Hibs.
We’re the one club with hard currency in playing him every week - anyone else (including Sunderland) are making promises that he’ll have to hope are genuine, whereas he knows he’s valued and would be starting every week with us
SHODAN
16-04-2025, 08:29 PM
Sounds like he should stay at Hibs.
I think he's the kind of player Rangers would both sign and play regularly.
hibsbollah
16-04-2025, 08:34 PM
I think he's the kind of player Rangers would both sign and play regularly.
We’re not letting him go to the Rangers
GreenNWhiteArmy
16-04-2025, 09:08 PM
We’re not letting him go to the Rangers
Triantis? Doubt we'll have much say. Highly doubt he'll be back at us being honest. If his agent does his job properly, he'll get a few offers in the summer
tug.lismore
16-04-2025, 10:00 PM
Triantis? Doubt we'll have much say. Highly doubt he'll be back at us being honest. If his agent does his job properly, he'll get a few offers in the summerWhat I would love to see is Bournemouth buying Triantis from Sunderland and loaning him to us for the season.
He then gets European experience and develops in his best position.
At only 21 he definitely has time to develop into a Premiership player.
Will Bournemouth take a punt?
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
Springbank
16-04-2025, 10:03 PM
What I would love to see is Bournemouth buying Triantis from Sunderland and loaning him to us for the season.
He then gets European experience and develops in his best position.
At only 21 he definitely has time to develop into a Premiership player.
Will Bournemouth take a punt?
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
One for tim bazbatchenko to intervene on maybe?
Smartie
16-04-2025, 10:21 PM
Triantis? Doubt we'll have much say. Highly doubt he'll be back at us being honest. If his agent does his job properly, he'll get a few offers in the summer
If his agent is being honest about his client’s priorities then we could be in with a very decent shout of getting him back here next season.
It’s easy to downplay our offering, but right now and next season we may well be the closest to exactly what he is looking for.
bingo70
16-04-2025, 10:22 PM
What I would love to see is Bournemouth buying Triantis from Sunderland and loaning him to us for the season.
He then gets European experience and develops in his best position.
At only 21 he definitely has time to develop into a Premiership player.
Will Bournemouth take a punt?
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
We’ve recently tried to buy two players for just over £1m. I don’t know how much it’d cost us to buy him ourselves but it’s not impossible it could be around that mark.
I’d like us to see if we can buy him ourselves before needing the black knights to do it for us. Obviously depending on the cost that may not be an option. Anything from £1m to £1.5m with a decent sell on % would be possible for us I’d have thought if we make the group stages of European football.
CapitalGreen
16-04-2025, 10:23 PM
What I would love to see is Bournemouth buying Triantis from Sunderland and loaning him to us for the season.
He then gets European experience and develops in his best position.
At only 21 he definitely has time to develop into a Premiership player.
Will Bournemouth take a punt?
No chance they would do that with strict FFP rules down south.
JimBHibees
17-04-2025, 06:57 AM
We’re not letting him go to the Rangers
He isn’t our player though
tug.lismore
17-04-2025, 07:07 AM
No chance they would do that with strict FFP rules down south.Not sure how this contravenes FFP. Bournemouth bought Alex Paulsen and then loaned him to Auckland. Same thing?
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
CapitalGreen
17-04-2025, 07:17 AM
Not sure how this contravenes FFP. Bournemouth bought Alex Paulsen and then loaned him to Auckland. Same thing?
It doesn’t contravene FFP/PSR, but Bournemouth paying a fee for Triantis would contribute to their spending under FFP/PSR. The amount Bournemouth have available to spend under FFP/PSR currently is very tight, they aren’t going to be buying players for other teams.
JohnM1875
17-04-2025, 07:29 AM
It doesn’t contravene FFP/PSR, but Bournemouth paying a fee for Triantis would contribute to their spending under FFP/PSR. The amount Bournemouth have available to spend under FFP/PSR currently is very tight, they aren’t going to be buying players for other teams.
Just give us the money to buy him and get him in the group. Problem solved.
PatHead
17-04-2025, 07:30 AM
It doesn’t contravene FFP/PSR, but Bournemouth paying a fee for Triantis would contribute to their spending under FFP/PSR. The amount Bournemouth have available to spend under FFP/PSR currently is very tight, they aren’t going to be buying players for other teams.
Do they not have a young player who is going to be sold to one of the big English clubs at the end of the season?
That will surely help.
Also they would not be buying him for Hibs but for themselves to take back and this would form part of their development.
GreenCastle
17-04-2025, 07:31 AM
Triantis with European football on his CV definitely adds value to his transfer value also.
Reckon it’s 50/50 if he returns - ideally with us in Europe !
Ribs1875
17-04-2025, 07:35 AM
Triantis has been a integral part of the streak. I think it's unlikely he is going to be with us next season. As much as he would be a loss, I think we would learn to live without him. There are plenty of players I am sure we will be in the market for. Triantis despite a slow start, has made us forget about Marcondes.
We are anticipating losing a few key players through contract expiry and transfer fees, but it's not the end of the world. It enables existing players and youth to step up. The fact we are on course to finish strongly makes me enthusiastic about our recruitment this summer coming.
tug.lismore
17-04-2025, 07:37 AM
It doesn’t contravene FFP/PSR, but Bournemouth paying a fee for Triantis would contribute to their spending under FFP/PSR. The amount Bournemouth have available to spend under FFP/PSR currently is very tight, they aren’t going to be buying players for other teams.I'm not suggesting that they buy him for Hibs. More that they see him as having the potential to play for Bournemouth in the future and therefore make an investment akin to the one they made with Alex Paulsen.
Paulsen signed for*a reported initial fee of £850,000, rising up to £2 million*on a 4 year contract.
Would that sort of deal interest Sunderland?
Do Hibs have the buying power to put together something like this?
Would we be able to match Triantis' wage demands?
I sincerely hope that he is a Hibs player next season. Really rate the guy. Gives me Scott McTominay and Declan Rice vibes with the way he runs very upright scanning the field.
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
marinello59
17-04-2025, 07:42 AM
What I would love to see is Bournemouth buying Triantis from Sunderland and loaning him to us for the season.
He then gets European experience and develops in his best position.
At only 21 he definitely has time to develop into a Premiership player.
Will Bournemouth take a punt?
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
I can’t see Bournemouth doing anything like that. They may have infinitely better resources than us but their squad size is nowhere near the size of the big players in their league. By Premiership standards they are a fairly lean operation, buying players and instantly putting them out on loan will be more of a rarity than the norm for them.
marinello59
17-04-2025, 07:46 AM
Triantis? Doubt we'll have much say. Highly doubt he'll be back at us being honest. If his agent does his job properly, he'll get a few offers in the summer
Unlike in previous years I am pretty confident that we have people in place now pre-planning for the potential loss of what Triantis brings with alternatives already identified. I want him to stay but won’t be too despondent about it if he goes.
hibsbollah
17-04-2025, 08:05 AM
He isn’t our player though
I dont care :grr:
Hibernian Verse
17-04-2025, 08:08 AM
McKirdy scored more goals in that league than Ollie Watkins and Ivan Toney. Should probably judge players as individuals on their own merits rather than tarring every player with the same brush based simply on where they came from.
Wasn't brushing anyone with the Harry McKirdy brush, I just meant we have been stung before from that league.
Of course good players can come from anywhere.
Re your point though, Watkins and Toney were kids at 20 and 18 respectively when they played in that league. McKirdy was in his prime at 24/25.
dangermouse
17-04-2025, 08:20 AM
Unlike in previous years I am pretty confident that we have people in place now pre-planning for the potential loss of what Triantis brings with alternatives already identified. I want him to stay but won’t be too despondent about it if he goes.
Is Manneh not meant to be Triantis replacement?
Paulie Walnuts
17-04-2025, 08:22 AM
Wasn't brushing anyone with the Harry McKirdy brush, I just meant we have been stung before from that league.
Of course good players can come from anywhere.
Re your point though, Watkins and Toney were kids at 20 and 18 respectively when they played in that league. McKirdy was in his prime at 24/25.
They also had significantly better goals to games ratios in that league than McKirdy. McKirdy had a better season than either of them ever managed, but over their short careers in League Two they were way more productive than McKirdy was.
Hibernian Verse
17-04-2025, 08:24 AM
They also had significantly better goals to games ratios in that league than McKirdy. McKirdy had a better season than either of them ever managed, but over their short careers in League Two they were way more productive than McKirdy was.
Good point :agree:
CapitalGreen
17-04-2025, 08:31 AM
Wasn't brushing anyone with the Harry McKirdy brush, I just meant we have been stung before from that league.
Of course good players can come from anywhere.
Re your point though, Watkins and Toney were kids at 20 and 18 respectively when they played in that league. McKirdy was in his prime at 24/25.
The player DH shared the link of is the same age as Watkins was.
If we dismissed players simply based on bad previous experiences with players from the same division we would rule out most leagues.
CapitalGreen
17-04-2025, 08:35 AM
They also had significantly better goals to games ratios in that league than McKirdy. McKirdy had a better season than either of them ever managed, but over their short careers in League Two they were way more productive than McKirdy was.
League 2 Records
Toney 1 goal every 255 mins
Watkins 1 goal every 246 mins
McKirdy 1 goal every 205 mins
Hibernian Verse
17-04-2025, 08:36 AM
The player DH shared the link of is the same age as Watkins was.
If we dismissed players simply based on bad previous experiences with players from the same division we would rule out most leagues.
To quote myself "of course good players can come from anywhere".
I'm not disagreeing with you. Maybe this player will go on to great things.
Wilson
17-04-2025, 08:42 AM
To quote myself "of course good players can come from anywhere".
I'm not disagreeing with you. Maybe this player will go on to great things.
In saying that your own first sentence was rendered redundant.
Tyler Durden
17-04-2025, 08:53 AM
No chance they would do that with strict FFP rules down south.
I don't see it happening anyway but I doubt £1m for Triantis will be much concern to Bournemouth. Probably will take in £80m+ on Kerkez and Semenyo this summer.
Unseen work
17-04-2025, 08:54 AM
That lad from Salford surely won’t be coming here.
Salford will likely be paying him a decent amount and championship teams will be well aware of him.
Unseen work
17-04-2025, 08:55 AM
I don't see it happening anyway but I doubt £1m for Triantis will be much concern to Bournemouth. Probably will take in £80m+ on Kerkez and Semenyo this summer.
My concern is if he only costs 1 million there will be plenty other clubs in for him.
Wouldn’t surprise me if both old firm were interested and a load of championship clubs
worcesterhibby
17-04-2025, 09:02 AM
My concern is if he only costs 1 million there will be plenty other clubs in for him.
Wouldn’t surprise me if both old firm were interested and a load of championship clubs
you can be absolutely sure that Rangers do see us as a threat next season. If they can take a key player away from us, they will. I just hope Triantus looks at the state of The Rangers and sees his future elsewhere ( Easter road ideally)
SChibs
17-04-2025, 09:09 AM
I wonder if Vente would consider another crack at Scottish Football now we have a better team. He might be looking at Cadden whipping in excellent crosses every week and fancy his chances of scoring a load. He could be like a new signing replacing Gayle and taking the pressure off Boyle a bit who will be a year older
Centre Hawf
17-04-2025, 09:16 AM
you can be absolutely sure that Rangers do see us as a threat next season. If they can take a key player away from us, they will. I just hope Triantus looks at the state of The Rangers and sees his future elsewhere ( Easter road ideally)
Rangers will not see us as a threat. Not in a million years will they consider any of us below them as such. They'll do what they always do and sign £5/6/7m worth of players for their new manager and push for the title even if they're so far off Celtic still. To split the Old Firm you need about 75 points and that still relies on Rangers being the worst version of themselves that season, the rest of us aren't getting that amount. The worst Celtic team of the last 15 years still finished 14 points ahead of arguably the best Hibs team of the same period.
worcesterhibby
17-04-2025, 09:24 AM
Rangers will not see us as a threat. Not in a million years will they consider any of us below them as such. They'll do what they always do and sign £5/6/7m worth of players for their new manager and push for the title even if they're so far off Celtic still. To split the Old Firm you need about 75 points and that still relies on Rangers being the worst version of themselves that season, the rest of us aren't getting that amount. The worst Celtic team of the last 15 years still finished 14 points ahead of arguably the best Hibs team of the same period.
maybe, maybe, but it’s not stopped Rangers or Celtic taking our best players in the past, despite their protestations that the standard of the league makes it hard for them in Europe. They love being much better than everyone else in the league and they both LOVE proving it by hoovering up the best SPFL players for fun, when they can. Particularly if the can unsettle the player and then lowball us.
we did a great job of resisting it with SJM, we just don’t have the same power over the fate of Triantus.
Donegal Hibby
17-04-2025, 09:38 AM
I wonder if Vente would consider another crack at Scottish Football now we have a better team. He might be looking at Cadden whipping in excellent crosses every week and fancy his chances of scoring a load. He could be like a new signing replacing Gayle and taking the pressure off Boyle a bit who will be a year older
I think Vente has more or less indicated he wants to move and with his contract situation is probably best for all parties , with him doing well we will hopefully make a tidy profit . It will all be needed as we don’t know what’s happening with Myko, Boyle , Gayle and Youan yet?
Paulie Walnuts
17-04-2025, 09:38 AM
League 2 Records
Toney 1 goal every 255 mins
Watkins 1 goal every 246 mins
McKirdy 1 goal every 205 mins
Goals per minute is always a fairly misleading stat imo.
It’s always trotted out when someone hasn’t scored a particularly impressive amount of goals. The stat obviously doesn’t tell us why they haven’t scored a very impressive amount. For example, if McKirdy has a record like that, you’d expect him to have more than 34 in 131 in that league. Ultimately his goals per minute is like that because he spent so much time as a League Two sub striker, starting 76 and being subbed on in 55. Compare that to Watkins who had 21 goals in 68 games and started 55 while being subbed on in 13 then you start to see more of a picture.
Dwight Gayle for example has a better goals to minute ratio than Boyle this season in the league. He hasn’t been better or more productive than Boyle though.
Centre Hawf
17-04-2025, 09:40 AM
maybe, maybe, but it’s not stopped Rangers or Celtic taking our best players in the past, despite their protestations that the standard of the league makes it hard for them in Europe. They love being much better than everyone else in the league and they both LOVE proving it by hoovering up the best SPFL players for fun, when they can. Particularly if the can unsettle the player and then lowball us.
we did a great job of resisting it with SJM, we just don’t have the same power over the fate of Triantus.
Don't disagree that it won't stop them taking a Triantis if they want to, and while I would normally say that the days of the Glasgow two hoovering up the talent in the league has sorta died off, but I think Rangers have been etching closer to getting back to that with the likes of Barron, Cameron, Souttar, Wright etc.
Triantis I think would be a good signing for them sadly.
Hibernian Verse
17-04-2025, 09:55 AM
In saying that your own first sentence was rendered redundant.
Good players can come from anywhere but it's still relevant to consider the level they're playing at when you're watching YouTube reels. McKirdy was just a recent example of a signing from League Two that is fresh in the mind. It's easy for Donegal to get excited. As my Granny would have said, Ca' Canny.
badabing67
17-04-2025, 09:59 AM
I think Vente has more or less indicated he wants to move and with his contract situation is probably best for all parties , with him doing well we will hopefully make a tidy profit . It will all be needed as we don’t know what’s happening with Myko, Boyle , Gayle and Youan yet?
You can throw Hoillet, Miller and Rocky in there as well
CapitalGreen
17-04-2025, 10:11 AM
Goals per minute is always a fairly misleading stat imo.
It’s always trotted out when someone hasn’t scored a particularly impressive amount of goals. The stat obviously doesn’t tell us why they haven’t scored a very impressive amount. For example, if McKirdy has a record like that, you’d expect him to have more than 34 in 131 in that league. Ultimately his goals per minute is like that because he spent so much time as a League Two sub striker, starting 76 and being subbed on in 55. Compare that to Watkins who had 21 goals in 68 games and started 55 while being subbed on in 13 then you start to see more of a picture.
Dwight Gayle for example has a better goals to minute ratio than Boyle this season in the league. He hasn’t been better or more productive than Boyle though.
The numbers were simply presented without comment to conplement the basic goals per game numbers presented.
In fact, your post strengthens my argument that to get a clearer picture of a player, you really have to drill further into what they are doing rather than simply making a judgement based on where they play or their top level stats.
Without a doubt, had Watkins being playing in EFL2 now and been linked to us, their would be numerous posts on this thread dismissing him due to where he plays and citing McKirdy as an example.
Donegal Hibby
17-04-2025, 11:13 AM
You can throw Hoillet, Miller and Rocky in there as well
Forgot about Hoilett in fairness , was meaning more on our attacking options which could be the area we see the biggest change too if we don’t retain some ..
Though your right about Miller and Rocky in the defence who would be a big miss
Kwon , Triantis in midfield and Triantis would be another big miss ..
There’s a few players we have while not impossible but it will be hard to find suitable replacements I think if they leave or we can’t get them back .
Hibiza
18-04-2025, 07:56 AM
What I would love to see is Bournemouth buying Triantis from Sunderland and loaning him to us for the season.
He then gets European experience and develops in his best position.
At only 21 he definitely has time to develop into a Premiership player.
Will Bournemouth take a punt?
Sent from my 2312DRA50G using Tapatalk
Excellent shout.
04Sauzee
18-04-2025, 04:45 PM
Jamie McGrath available for selection for Aberdeen tomorrow. Wasn't expecting to see him in and around the Aberdeen squad before the end of the season and before joining Hibs.
18Craig75
18-04-2025, 06:26 PM
Jamie McGrath available for selection for Aberdeen tomorrow. Wasn't expecting to see him in and around the Aberdeen squad before the end of the season and before joining Hibs.
Agent McGrath
BoltonHibee
18-04-2025, 06:32 PM
That lad from Salford surely won’t be coming here.
Salford will likely be paying him a decent amount and championship teams will be well aware of him.
Salford are currently skint, they are not paying him a lot. He’s no where near the required level for SPL yet
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Ribs1875
18-04-2025, 07:06 PM
I wonder if Vente would consider another crack at Scottish Football now we have a better team. He might be looking at Cadden whipping in excellent crosses every week and fancy his chances of scoring a load. He could be like a new signing replacing Gayle and taking the pressure off Boyle a bit who will be a year older
If he signed an extension then yes, but the club and playerboth keen to part ways by what's been said on each side lately. No point losing someone at the end of next season we forked out good cash on for nothing. Especially on the back of a good season he's had for a diddy Dutch team. He will get cashed in this summer.
Nicho87
19-04-2025, 06:59 AM
If McGrath has a stormer today does he play next week. That he has to be a pretty strange position for a player in that scenario.
CapitalGreen
19-04-2025, 07:02 AM
If McGrath has a stormer today does he play next week. That he has to be a pretty strange position for a player in that scenario.
He won’t play today
Since452
19-04-2025, 07:03 AM
Jamie McGrath available for selection for Aberdeen tomorrow. Wasn't expecting to see him in and around the Aberdeen squad before the end of the season and before joining Hibs.
He's Aberdeens best player. Would be daft not to play him today if he's available. Even if he's moving to a bigger club at the end of the season.
Nicho87
19-04-2025, 07:04 AM
He won’t play today
Don’t think he’ll start but if Aberdeen a chasing a goal I don’t think it’s inconceivable
CapitalGreen
19-04-2025, 08:23 AM
What’s been verdict on Allan Campbell’s spell at Dundee Utd? I noticed he was an unused sub against St Johnstone was hooked before the hour mark against Hearts.
There was a lot of teeth gnashing on here that we didn’t sign him in January, should be in for him in the summer?
Centre Hawf
19-04-2025, 08:27 AM
What’s been verdict on Allan Campbell’s spell at Dundee Utd? I noticed he was an unused sub against St Johnstone was hooked before the hour mark against Hearts.
There was a lot of teeth gnashing on here that we didn’t sign him in January, should be in for him in the summer?
General consensus is he’s been rotten. A well dodged moment from us even if Manneh hasn’t made an impact yet either.
djw80!
19-04-2025, 08:32 AM
What’s been verdict on Allan Campbell’s spell at Dundee Utd? I noticed he was an unused sub against St Johnstone was hooked before the hour mark against Hearts.
There was a lot of teeth gnashing on here that we didn’t sign him in January, should be in for him in the summer?
I Dont think we need him were decent options in the middle of the park with McGrath and Manneh. But I would like us to add pace out wide and upfront.We will also need a bigger squad if we get into Europe, don't think we have enough at present to cover thur sun games. But I'm confident it's under control and we are speaking to players.
Bridge hibs
19-04-2025, 08:47 AM
What’s been verdict on Allan Campbell’s spell at Dundee Utd? I noticed he was an unused sub against St Johnstone was hooked before the hour mark against Hearts.
There was a lot of teeth gnashing on here that we didn’t sign him in January, should be in for him in the summer?I cant remember much gnashing of teeth on here because we didnt go for Campbell unless I missed the posts. I would have been in favour of signing him based on what I saw of him in the past but on recent performances that Ive seen on tv he looked way off the player he was at Well and early doors in England.
The recent game at tiny he looked like he had been plucked from the pub leagues in Edinburgh and I cant think of anything positive he done in that game.
BoomtownHibees
19-04-2025, 10:52 AM
He won’t play today
Starts on the bench. Hopefully with a super sub appearance
JohnM1875
19-04-2025, 10:53 AM
Starts on the bench. Hopefully with a super sub appearance
Just back from a long term injury. Hope he doesn’t feature for them at all this season and comes in for pre-season fresh and raring to go.
BoomtownHibees
19-04-2025, 10:54 AM
Just back from a long term injury. Hope he doesn’t feature for them at all this season and comes in from pre-season fresh and raring to go.
Well I’d be more than happy for him to have a wee 2nd half appearance towards the end of todays game and score the winner
scm70nyd1973
19-04-2025, 11:01 AM
General consensus is he’s been rotten. A well dodged moment from us even if Manneh hasn’t made an impact yet either.
It would be interesting to see how he might have fared with us instead of the Arabs - we seem to have better management and coaching so that players settle in and progress well - not so sure about the Arabs - Jim Goodwin for starters 😡
Donegal Hibby
19-04-2025, 11:06 AM
It would be interesting to see how he might have fared with us instead of the Arabs - we seem to have better management and coaching so that players settle in and progress well - not so sure about the Arabs - Jim Goodwin for starters 😡
I think he’d be struggling to get a game at us tbh .
scm70nyd1973
19-04-2025, 11:14 AM
I think he’d be struggling to get a game at us tbh .
Definitely- but we seem to have a good setup and he might have been ok with us but not with the Arabs - who knows and I suppose who cares - we didn’t seem to want him so I trust our guys to have had a very good reason for this - different days for us - thank goodness 😁
Centre Hawf
19-04-2025, 11:17 AM
It would be interesting to see how he might have fared with us instead of the Arabs - we seem to have better management and coaching so that players settle in and progress well - not so sure about the Arabs - Jim Goodwin for starters 😡
I think the guys a shadow of himself. He’s struggled everywhere he’s been for about 2 years now. Maybe it’s injuries or fitness or just life getting in the way, but at this point I’d be avoiding him entirely.
cubehindthegoal
19-04-2025, 11:21 AM
Well I’d be more than happy for him to have a wee 2nd half appearance towards the end of todays game and score the winner
Dream scenario, can you imagine! What a start to his Hibs career that’d be 😁
GreenCastle
19-04-2025, 12:21 PM
What’s been verdict on Allan Campbell’s spell at Dundee Utd? I noticed he was an unused sub against St Johnstone was hooked before the hour mark against Hearts.
There was a lot of teeth gnashing on here that we didn’t sign him in January, should be in for him in the summer?
He’s been poor for them according to the Utd fans.
dmc1875
19-04-2025, 12:33 PM
He’s been poor for them according to the Utd fans.
Been really poor
Pytheas
19-04-2025, 02:27 PM
Did they say in commentary that Nicky Devlin is out of contract at the Dons? :eyes:
Unseen work
19-04-2025, 03:04 PM
Tbf I was one that really wanted Allan Campbell, always thought he was a really good player.
Doesn’t seem to have hit it off at United.
Shows how hard recruitment can be.
Paton at United is another that a lot wanted and doesn’t seem to have done great
1875Sean
19-04-2025, 03:28 PM
Did they say in commentary that Nicky Devlin is out of contract at the Dons? :eyes:
If he isn’t good enough for Aberdeen then he shouldn’t be a player we are looking at
04Sauzee
19-04-2025, 03:31 PM
If he isn’t good enough for Aberdeen then he shouldn’t be a player we are looking at
Incredibly capped for Scotland this season.
JimBHibees
19-04-2025, 04:59 PM
If he isn’t good enough for Aberdeen then he shouldn’t be a player we are looking at
Think he is a better player than Jensen
1875Sean
20-04-2025, 10:46 AM
Think he is a better player than Jensen
Not so sure about that, since Jensen came in there form has gotten a lot better
hibsbollah
20-04-2025, 10:57 AM
What’s been verdict on Allan Campbell’s spell at Dundee Utd? I noticed he was an unused sub against St Johnstone was hooked before the hour mark against Hearts.
There was a lot of teeth gnashing on here that we didn’t sign him in January, should be in for him in the summer?
I would have no problem in trying to resurrect his career with a cheeky bid if SDG likes him, he wouldnt be the first player to struggle to settle at a new club in a new midfield (Dylan Levitt anyone?).
But if we want help in that position id prefer Josh Mulligan from Dundee if his performance against us is anything to go by. At 22 hes also4 years younger than Campbell.
chippy
20-04-2025, 11:09 AM
Re Josh Milligan
Talking to a Dundee fan yesterday reckons Millwall in for him
CapitalGreen
20-04-2025, 11:21 AM
I would have no problem in trying to resurrect his career with a cheeky bid if SDG likes him, [b.2he wouldnt be the first player to struggle to settle at a new club[/b] in a new midfield (Dylan Levitt anyone?).
But if we want help in that position id prefer Josh Mulligan from Dundee if his performance against us is anything to go by. At 22 hes also4 years younger than Campbell.
Is that all it is, failing to settle at his new club? He’s currently at his 4th club in the last 12 months that’s he’s failed to establish himself in.
CapitalGreen
20-04-2025, 11:22 AM
Re Josh Milligan
Talking to a Dundee fan yesterday reckons Millwall in for him
I think he’ll go south, he would be much cheaper for teams outwith Scotland.
JohnM1875
20-04-2025, 11:58 AM
I think he’ll go south, he would be much cheaper for teams outwith Scotland.
As in the development fee would be less for an English team? Or because they tend to have more money to spend?
If its the former how daft is that! We should be trying to trying to keep our best young players up here
hibsbollah
20-04-2025, 12:36 PM
Is that all it is, failing to settle at his new club? He’s currently at his 4th club in the last 12 months that’s he’s failed to establish himself in.
Like i say, i have faith that our team can make that decision. Mulligan looks a better bet to me but Campbell was excellent not that long ago in that midfield with David Turnbull (now at Cardiff(.
CapitalGreen
20-04-2025, 05:23 PM
As in the development fee would be less for an English team? Or because they tend to have more money to spend?
If its the former how daft is that! We should be trying to trying to keep our best young players up here
Moving outwith Scotland, the buying club would only have to pay the development fee as calculated by FIFA’s Training Compensation framework. Looking at the online calculator FIFA provide, the fee would be about £300k.
Moving to another Scottish Club, the buying team would need to agree a development fee with the selling club, should the clubs fail to agree then a fee would be set by a tribunal plus associated legal costs on top of that.
cubehindthegoal
20-04-2025, 05:34 PM
Moving outwith Scotland, the buying club would only have to pay the development fee as calculated by FIFA’s Training Compensation framework. Looking at the online calculator FIFA provide, the fee would be about £300k.
Moving to another Scottish Club, the buying team would need to agree a development fee with the selling club, should the clubs fail to agree then a fee would be set by a tribunal plus associated legal costs on top of that.
Is there any good reason why we don’t just set a ruling that we use FIFA’s Training Compensation framework .. that seems anyone can see and use … and stop chucking money down the drain in Scottish football, with tribunals and legal fees ? Is it usual SFA soaking up cash for themselves and cronies that would suffer ? Or is there a good reason we don’t ?
CapitalGreen
20-04-2025, 07:26 PM
Is there any good reason why we don’t just set a ruling that we use FIFA’s Training Compensation framework .. that seems anyone can see and use … and stop chucking money down the drain in Scottish football, with tribunals and legal fees ? Is it usual SFA soaking up cash for themselves and cronies that would suffer ? Or is there a good reason we don’t ?
FIFA requires all member associations to have their own rules in place for domestic training compensation. It’s rare it even ends up in a tribunal. The only examples I can think of off the top of my head are the recent Connor Barron transfer and Charlie Telfer joining Dun Utd from Rangers in 2014.
badabing67
21-04-2025, 12:23 PM
Off topic a bit, but is there any rumours relating to the appointment of a new CEO yet
Since452
21-04-2025, 12:43 PM
Did they say in commentary that Nicky Devlin is out of contract at the Dons? :eyes:
I prefer signing Aberdeens best players
Forza Fred
21-04-2025, 12:43 PM
Media article today where the Auckland coach said that goalkeeper Alex Paulsen who pulled off a ‘world class’ save on the weekend has reached a stage where needs to play in a stronger league.
He went on to say that he doesn’t know for sure where he will be playing next season, but it won’t be at Auckland.
I’d like to see him at Easter Road next season, but due to his form I wouldn’t be totally surprised if he goes straight to Bournemouth either.
Lancs Harp
21-04-2025, 12:48 PM
I think he’ll go south, he would be much cheaper for teams outwith Scotland.
Several Championship clubs reported to be taking a look, Hull, Middlesbrough, West Brom and Blackburn to name but 4 in an article I read. Think his head is turned for a move down south.
CapitalGreen
21-04-2025, 12:51 PM
Media article today where the Auckland coach said that goalkeeper Alex Paulsen who pulled off a ‘world class’ save on the weekend has reached a stage where needs to play in a stronger league.
He went on to say that he doesn’t know for sure where he will be playing next season, but it won’t be at Auckland.
I’d like to see him at Easter Road next season, but due to his form I wouldn’t be totally surprised if he goes straight to Bournemouth either.
Bournemouth are signing Udinese’s goalkeeper apparently.
HoboHarry
21-04-2025, 01:48 PM
Media article today where the Auckland coach said that goalkeeper Alex Paulsen who pulled off a ‘world class’ save on the weekend has reached a stage where needs to play in a stronger league.
He went on to say that he doesn’t know for sure where he will be playing next season, but it won’t be at Auckland.
I’d like to see him at Easter Road next season, but due to his form I wouldn’t be totally surprised if he goes straight to Bournemouth either.
Don't know much about Paulsen but I'd be a bit surprised if he went straight from the A League to unseating Kepa at Bournemouth so I'd imagine he'd be out on loan somewhere.
Don't know much about Paulsen but I'd be a bit surprised if he went straight from the A League to unseating Kepa at Bournemouth so I'd imagine he'd be out on loan somewhere.
Kepa is on loan from Chelsea so they will be in the market for another keeper.
HoboHarry
21-04-2025, 01:58 PM
Kepa is on loan from Chelsea so they will be in the market for another keeper.
Oh fair enough that one passed me by, I thought he left Chelsea...
Oh fair enough that one passed me by, I thought he left Chelsea...
Mind you he might end up back there but the poster above has said they were looking at a keeper from Udinese.
04Sauzee
21-04-2025, 05:29 PM
Declan Gallagher to leave Dundee Utd at the end of the season after not being offered a new contract. 36 appearances for Dundee Utd this season.
cubehindthegoal
21-04-2025, 05:43 PM
FIFA requires all member associations to have their own rules in place for domestic training compensation. It’s rare it even ends up in a tribunal. The only examples I can think of off the top of my head are the recent Connor Barron transfer and Charlie Telfer joining Dun Utd from Rangers in 2014.
Ah right, never really paid much attention to what happens, but seems fair enough then.
JimBHibees
21-04-2025, 05:44 PM
Declan Gallagher to leave Dundee Utd at the end of the season after not being offered a new contract. 36 appearances for Dundee Utd this season.
Strange one he has been solid for them
Donegal Hibby
21-04-2025, 05:49 PM
hertz suppose to be losing a youth player to the toffees..
https://www.teamtalk.com/everton/agree-statement-signing-ahead-transformational-summer-window
500miles
21-04-2025, 05:58 PM
Very tight at the bottom of the Championship. Plenty of investable players with a grounding in Scottish football will be affected.
hertz suppose to be losing a youth player to the toffees..
https://www.teamtalk.com/everton/agree-statement-signing-ahead-transformational-summer-window
I actually hate this and it's happening all the time now. English teams looking for bargain scots youth players to boost their academies. I'm hoping we can combat this somehow but I'm not sure what the answer is.
Winston Ingram
21-04-2025, 07:58 PM
I actually hate this and it's happening all the time now. English teams looking for bargain scots youth players to boost their academies. I'm hoping we can combat this somehow but I'm not sure what the answer is.
It’s inevitable now since Brexit. He’ll probably end up getting released.
I noticed with James Wilson that he only signed a 2 year deal. He and their agent already planning a cut price exit.
Onceinawhile
21-04-2025, 08:13 PM
It’s inevitable now since Brexit. He’ll probably end up getting released.
I noticed with James Wilson that he only signed a 2 year deal. He and their agent already planning a cut price exit.
Going to villa soon apparently.
HoboHarry
21-04-2025, 08:14 PM
I actually hate this and it's happening all the time now. English teams looking for bargain scots youth players to boost their academies. I'm hoping we can combat this somehow but I'm not sure what the answer is.
I agree for the most part but when it involves saving
young players from learning Hertzball I consider it an act of kindness from the buying club.
tonyrougier123
22-04-2025, 07:26 AM
Was reading up on Maolida, done reasonably well at a mid table Saudi club, wages under 5g a week surprisingly. Out of contract in June.
Callum_62
22-04-2025, 08:09 AM
Was reading up on Maolida, done reasonably well at a mid table Saudi club, wages under 5g a week surprisingly. Out of contract in June.1000% yes please
Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk
badabing67
22-04-2025, 08:38 AM
Was reading up on Maolida, done reasonably well at a mid table Saudi club, wages under 5g a week surprisingly. Out of contract in June.
Struggling to believe he is on under 5K a week but is not out of contract till June 2026
500miles
22-04-2025, 09:10 AM
Struggling to believe he is on under 5K a week but is not out of contract till June 2026
I wouldn't be surprised if that's what he's received, but I would be surprised if that's what he signed up for.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2025 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.