St Johnstone 3 v Hibs 0

[NOLA]

He’s been ‘coming back’ from this injury since he signed for us.

He’s been an utterly crap signing so far. A total waste of money who has shown nothing so far to justify the risk taken in signing him.

Think we signed him cos we never got McCrorie and JR didn’t want to lose out again on a player with talent which we won’t really see till next season

[WhileTheChief..]

The guy was questing the starting 11. I don't think our starting 11 was the issue

It was the knee jerk reaction to 2-0

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Agreed.

I generally still like JR but he hasn’t got a damn clue when it come to subs. He makes things worse every single time and hasn’t learnt a thing.

[Allant1981]

3rd place? Who cares? We have blown two amazing chances of winning trophies which is what football is all about.

So it never really matters where we finish in the league unless we win a cup? Take it you have never been happy as a hibs fan then!!

[KingPat4]

Normally I'd be moping about for days after a semi defeat but struggling to care. I should but I don't. Strange watching it on TV and not being there.

If you don't care, then just **** off.

[Callum_62]

Mind when Stubbs team were papped out in the play offs, twice.

Change the manager but for christ sake get better than Alan Stubbs

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[snedzuk]

Just to top it off, I just tried to cancel my subscription with Premier Sports only to find that somehow I have signed up to a 6 month £9.99 a metric nth subscription.

FFS.

Unfortunately you'll probably get to see the Scottish cup semi final!

[supermcginn]

So it never really matters where we finish in the league unless we win a cup? Take it you have never been happy as a hibs fan then!!

We have lost to the worst hearts team ever and a rank rotten at Johnstone team to get to two cup finals. Wake up ffs!!!!!!

[Carheenlea]

Our set pieces are shocking, 2 good set pieces from ST Johnstone which were defended really poorly and the game was gone. We huffed and puffed the whole game and never looked like scoring, even from 6 yards out. Really frustrating and disappointing performance

We on the other hand must be the least clinical side in the league. How many games do we dominate early, carve out a barrowload of chances, fail to convert any of them then concede with the opposition's first attempt. Heads go down and don`t threaten to score again.

In the end the 3-0 win didn`t flatter St Johnstone. The better, more clinical side won comfortably on the day

[SHODAN]

Mind when Stubbs team were papped out in the play offs, twice.

Change the manager but for christ sake get better than Alan Stubbs

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

We also beat Hearts twice, Rangers seven times, Aberdeen when they were top of the league, and won two semi finals out of three. There was another thing too but I forget what it was.

[Onion]

Ross should be more concerned about the owner backing him ..

Can't see him putting up with this pish any longer.

Don't think Hibs owner has got a clue what's acceptable for the 1st team. He'll put up with whatever Hibs fans will put up with, and that's all about ticket sale. Jack Ross and the Hibs players can be thankful there are no fans at these matches. The myth about anxiety and pressure coming down from the stands affecting these Hibs snowflakes is well and truly dead. I don't want to hear that ever repeated again.

No ambition, no drive, no spine, no ambition, no pride. A disparate collection of well paid non-achievers at Hibs, managed by someone who's unable to motivate and organise properly for games that really matter.

Under the circumstances, will go down as one of the worst Hibs results at Hampden, and that's saying something.

[HFC 0-7]

Different Jack Ross there. Not defending the players, interesting to see, if any, changes made next match. I would like to see a different captain. I just don’t see enough from Hanlon influencing players on the pitch.

[calumhibee1]

We also beat Hearts twice, Rangers seven times, Aberdeen when they were top of the league, and won two semi finals out of three. There was another thing too but I forget what it was.

:agree:

Stubbs absolutely pisses all over Jack Ross as a manager.

[Coco Bryce]

Jack Ross is "angry" and "we have to do better"

No ****..

[bringbackbenny]

Na you’re alright, sick of wasting my cash on hibs though, so I’ll stop doing it

good lad - make you sure stay on here though as l'll miss your insightful posts :rolleyes:

[Kano Kirsty]

Cancelling HSL subscriptions.....seriously?

No wonder our model will never mirror FOH if that’s the attitude.

Support the team throughout FFS.

[Allant1981]

We have lost to the worst hearts team ever and a rank rotten at Johnstone team to get to two cup finals. Wake up ffs!!!!!!

Pretty sure almost every time we get beaten off hearts we hear that, today was a great chance and they blew it big time, don't think anyone has suggested any different, but all this nonsense about JR needing sacked for the sake of the club etc is laughable

[KingPat4]

3rd place? Who cares? We have blown two amazing chances of winning trophies which is what football is all about.

Been a Hibs fan long, have you?

It is what is.

[KingPat4]

Cancelling HSL subscriptions.....seriously?

No wonder our model will never mirror FOH if that’s the attitude.

Support the team throughout FFS.


This.

[dp00]

Jack not happy .... good

Get gray back in , drop porteous , go with Gray, McGinn, Hanlon & doig

Get Allan back in midfield & dodge upfront


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[hhibs]

[QUOTE=allant1981;6432060]And that decent budget has us in a decent league position, major over reactions as usual on here[/QUOT



So easily pleased.............................it was ***** .again!

[KingPat4]

:agree:

Stubbs absolutely pisses all over Jack Ross as a manager.

Absolute bollocks.

[Allant1981]

Jack not happy .... good

Get gray back in , drop porteous , go with Gray, McGinn, Hanlon & doig

Get Allan back in midfield & dodge upfront


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hanlon hasn't been much better than porteous to be honest, pity we don't have 2 who can replace them

[J-C]

Ross says he's angry, you'd hardly believe it the way he spoke, monotone voice all the way through, I'm still to see any passion from him. If he's angry come on tv and look frigging angry and call the players out for being bottle merchants instead of just saying they need to show more guts and drive to win.

It's your team Jack, the drive, passion and ambition comes from the manager and his coaches, simply not good enough and sussed out at Sunderland before coming here, time's up.

[Callum_62]

We also beat Hearts twice, Rangers seven times, Aberdeen when they were top of the league, and won two semi finals out of three. There was another thing too but I forget what it was.So we should sack Jack Ross and bring in Alan Stubbs?

The Alan Stubbs who's last job was 2.5 years ago

Who had a 7.1% win rate at Rotherham (1 win in 14) and a 22% win rate at St Mirren (2 wins in 9)

I love Stubbs for winning the cup but what a step back that would be



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[snedzuk]

We also beat Hearts twice, Rangers seven times, Aberdeen when they were top of the league, and won two semi finals out of three. There was another thing too but I forget what it was.

Signed players who looked like they knew what a football was

[BSEJVT]

Hes got to go.

Why did he change the formation at 2 0

We were all over them and look terrible at 442.

Seriously weve totally screwed this up

Because he panicked and shat the bed

[Allant1981]

[QUOTE=allant1981;6432060]And that decent budget has us in a decent league position, major over reactions as usual on here[/QUOT



So easily pleased.............................it was ***** .again!


Easily pleased? I'm annoyed as much as the next person about the result but not going to over react about it

[NOLA]

Aye. How many jobs has Stubbs had after being sacked by Rotherham?

Daft suggestion.

Just like certain players suit a particular club ie. Scott Allan, I think Stubbs gets Hibs and would fit right in again

[Stuart93]

Such a grown up adult response, if you can’t take being disappointed on a regular basis then following a football team and Hibernian in particular is probably not for you. Might be better spending the money you are saving from cancelling your HSL direct debit on going to the cinema. Be a lot less stressful for you.

Well I can’t exactly go to the cinema just now but have recently bought a house so the money I’ll save from not *****ing it on hibs will come in very handy

[Coco Bryce]

Ross says he's angry, you'd hardly believe it the way he spoke, monotone voice all the way through, I'm still to see any passion from him. If he's angry come on tv and look frigging angry and call the players out for being bottle merchants instead of just saying they need to show more guts and drive to win.

It's your team Jack, the drive, passion and ambition comes from the manager and his coaches, simply not good enough and sussed out at Sunderland before coming here, time's up.

That monotone voice couldn't motivate anything.

[Halifaxhibby]

Absolutely garbage. Cheers Hibs!!. Let me guess...Hanlon's been a servant...were a player short in this dept...were *****....end of.

[bringbackbenny]

I've forgot more about Hibs than you've ever known son. Only a hearts fan would defend this defeat. Sniff sniff.

that hurts :thumbsup:- I'm not your son and who knows you may have forgotten more about Hibs than I'll ever know as it sure shows in the nonsense Yam reeking posts by you. congratulations on being added to my Yam ignore list.

ttfn.

[PH91]

Glad you aren't the manager, no matter what level you ay at you will almost never keep the same 11 every single week

There will be changes for injuries, suspensions etc. but generally when teams get to a semi final the fans will be able to tell you the strongest 11 and the shape of the team.

No one had any idea of the team today, even when it was announced there was no certainty as to how we would shape up!

I'm not for him to go, he took over a crap team and has us going in the right direction. I think we need to see a more consistency in selection to help the players who are well off form just now though.

[sean04]

Jack not happy .... good

Get gray back in , drop porteous , go with Gray, McGinn, Hanlon & doig

Get Allan back in midfield & dodge upfront


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Gray your having a laugh? Finished

[One Day Soon]

:agree:

This team has a lot of decent attacking players that would suit Stubbs down to the ground.


We would be watching better football, played to a more coherent pattern and we'd be getting more out of the players we already have. Leaders come in all shapes and sizes, some shout and are openly passionate while others don't need to be because their manner conveys an authority and authenticity. I'm afraid that Jack Ross comes across as someone who is either guessing as he goes or or who has already topped out and is as good a manager as he's ever going to be. Either way he simply isn't convincing and I find it hard to believe that this isn't spilling over into the players. Those two major games lost so softly, with a whimper really, tell the story.

[hhibs]

Jack not happy .... good

Get gray back in , drop porteous , go with Gray, McGinn, Hanlon & doig

Get Allan back in midfield & dodge upfront


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk



Keep Porteous make him or anybody else Captain and drop Hanlon.

[Callum_62]

Well I can’t exactly go to the cinema just now but have recently bought a house so the money I’ll save from not *****ing it on hibs will come in very handyGet a projector, my cousin just got one and it's class

Its so big you can almost see emotion in Jack Ross's face

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[mcfly]

Ross says he's angry, you'd hardly believe it the way he spoke, monotone voice all the way through, I'm still to see any passion from him. If he's angry come on tv and look frigging angry and call the players out for being bottle merchants instead of just saying they need to show more guts and drive to win.

It's your team Jack, the drive, passion and ambition comes from the manager and his coaches, simply not good enough and sussed out at Sunderland before coming here, time's up.

Your team, your set up, just go. Embarrassing

Back to crowds of 7 and 8 thousand wiith this loser in charge.

Performances have been awful. If crowds were in he’d have been out by now.

Utter rubbish

[Callum_62]

Who would actually decide to change manager?

Who's doing Leeanns old job?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Onion]

We on the other hand must be the least clinical side in the league. How many games do we dominate early, carve out a barrowload of chances, fail to convert any of them then concede with the opposition's first attempt. Heads go down and don`t threaten to score again.

In the end the 3-0 win didn`t flatter St Johnstone. The better, more clinical side won comfortably on the day

It has become self-fulfilling. Hibs players know it, opposition teams now know it, Hibs fans know it, Jack Ross probably knows it ... and we don't have the characters / personnel to change the script. Spineless boy band who flatter to deceive.

[blackpoolhibs]

So many people just happy to accept this pish, mental.

Can you tell me what difference it makes not accepting the result?:confused:

[Stuart93]

Get a projector, my cousin just got one and it's class

Its so big you can almost see emotion in Jack Ross's face

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Hahaha, Jesus Christ that must be big

[Robbo6-2]

Jack Ross your a disgrace.

So is Mathie.

Ron get both to Falkirk and start again. These serial losers will never be up to the standards of a Hibs manager and head of football

[NAE NOOKIE]

I see the 'ach that's just Hibs' and 'it's always been like this watching Hibs' comments already starting to pile up.

Is the whole point not that the club's whole new ethos first under Leeann Dempster when she arrived, which was then allegedly ramped up when Ron Gordon took over the club, that this attitude wasn't acceptable any more?
That a history of failure in big matches, not to mention utter capitulation in some, couldn't be used as an explanation for the failure of players and managers who had nothing to do with previous historical cock ups and certainly not as a defence of the latest one.

As a club a failure like this has to be unacceptable ... if it isn't we will never progress to the next level, especially when it comes on the back of yet another failure against our bitter rivals at the arse end of a competition.

[supermcginn]

that hurts :thumbsup:- I'm not your son and who knows you may have forgotten more about Hibs than I'll ever know as it sure shows in the nonsense Yam reeking posts by you. congratulations on being added to my Yam ignore list.

ttfn.
Imagine coming on here after that and calling anyone telling it like it is they are a hearts fan 🤣🤣🤣
Get a life son. 🤫 some of us just have standards.

[calumhibee1]

So we should sack Jack Ross and bring in Alan Stubbs?

The Alan Stubbs who's last job was 2.5 years ago

Who had a 7.1% win rate at Rotherham (1 win in 14) and a 22% win rate at St Mirren (2 wins in 9)

I love Stubbs for winning the cup but what a step back that would be



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Would you mind posting what their win rates are at Hibs? You know, the most relevant of win rates seeing as we’re talking about how well they’d fit in at Hibs.

Maybe throw in their record in big games and trophy hauls as well since that’s what fans want to see.

[hhibs]

[QUOTE=hhibs;6432256]


Easily pleased? I'm annoyed as much as the next person about the result but not going to over react about it



When will you react then,you seem to be accepting that and many other performances,

[Callum_62]

Jack Ross your a disgrace.

So is Mathie.

Ron get both to Falkirk and start again. These serial losers will never be up to the standards of a Hibs manager and head of footballFor series losers there win percentage is almost top for all Hibs managers

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Hiber-nation]

So we should sack Jack Ross and bring in Alan Stubbs?

The Alan Stubbs who's last job was 2.5 years ago

Who had a 7.1% win rate at Rotherham (1 win in 14) and a 22% win rate at St Mirren (2 wins in 9)

I love Stubbs for winning the cup but what a step back that would be



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Yes 100%. Try looking at his record at Hibs. Too late though, we're now a National embarrassment.

[One Day Soon]

Aye. How many jobs has Stubbs had after being sacked by Rotherham?

Daft suggestion.


Yeah, because that's how all shortlisting and interview processes go for appointing a manager. We're not interested in how you like your teams to play, what vision you have for the club, what you have learned from your successes and failures, what you think could be done with the present squad and why, what insight you have on training and developing players and what affinity - if any - you have for the club, its fans and its ambitions. There's just one question that matters, how many jobs have you had?

[blackpoolhibs]

Ross says he's angry, you'd hardly believe it the way he spoke, monotone voice all the way through, I'm still to see any passion from him. If he's angry come on tv and look frigging angry and call the players out for being bottle merchants instead of just saying they need to show more guts and drive to win.

It's your team Jack, the drive, passion and ambition comes from the manager and his coaches, simply not good enough and sussed out at Sunderland before coming here, time's up.
And yet when Lennon did that, you called him out for it? :confused:

[KingPat4]

The only positive was Jackson Irvine. Looked like the only ****er that cared.

[hhibs]

I see the 'ach that's just Hibs' and 'it's always been like this watching Hibs' comments already starting to pile up.

Is the whole point not that the club's whole new ethos first under Leeann Dempster when she arrived, which was then allegedly ramped up when Ron Gordon took over the club, that this attitude wasn't acceptable any more?
That a history of failure in big matches, not to mention utter capitulation in some, couldn't be used as an explanation for the failure of players and managers who had nothing to do with previous historical cock ups and certainly not as a defence of the latest one.

As a club a failure like this has to be unacceptable ... if it isn't we will never progress to the next level, especially when it comes on the back of yet another failure against our bitter rivals at the arse end of a competition.

So bloody true !

[yonder1875]

Can you tell me what difference it makes not accepting the result?:confused:

Jeez.

[hibbysam]

Stubbs, Christ, best left alone. Hopeless since he left Hibs, great record against Rangers, aye when they had Ian Black, Fraser Aird and Darren McGregor for the most part. Absolutely zero chance he beats Rangers 4-0 at home now. I was a huge fan but there’s no chance he’s the man to take us forward from here.

[Allant1981]

[QUOTE=allant1981;6432273]



When will you react then,you seem to be accepting that and many other performances,


When will I react! Let's all get down to Easter Road with the pitch forks! Does getting angry on a fans page make one bit of difference on the park? And my wife would disagree with you that I'm accepting of performances as I was getting yapped at all the way through the game. Still doesn't mean I think the manager should be sacked

[Callum_62]

Alan Stubbs has a 58% win rate at hibs although exclusively in the championship

I mind back in they days constant moaning at his tippy tappy, side to side football

Underwhelmed if hibs go for him

I never understand why this board always looks at ex players and managers - baffling

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[KingPat4]

Yeah, because that's how all shortlisting and interview processes go for appointing a manager. We're not interested in how you like your teams to play, what vision you have for the club, what you have learned from your successes and failures, what you think could be done with the present squad and why, what insight you have on training and developing players and what affinity - if any - you have for the club, its fans and its ambitions. There's just one question that matters, how many jobs have you had?

WTF are you on about?

[One Day Soon]

We also beat Hearts twice, Rangers seven times, Aberdeen when they were top of the league, and won two semi finals out of three. There was another thing too but I forget what it was.

Yup, his ability to develop the squad, first team and style of play ready for the Premiership was why we won the cup while beating teams from that league. He was a poorer fit for the Championship but that's not the league, standard or style of football we are facing here. He'd be a perfect fit.

[hhibs]

[QUOTE=hhibs;6432323]


When will I react! Let's all get down to Easter Road with the pitch forks! Does getting angry on a fans page make one bit of difference on the park? And my wife would disagree with you that I'm accepting of performances as I was getting yapped at all the way through the game. Still doesn't mean I think the manager should be sacked



Then write what you actually think.

[calumhibee1]

Yup, his ability to develop the squad, first team and style of play ready for the Premiership was why we won the cup while beating teams from that league. He was a poorer fit for the Championship but that's not the league, standard or style of football we are facing here. He'd be a perfect fit.

:agree:

He’d be a much better fit than Ross, that’s for sure.

[JohnMcM]

Unfortunately you'll probably get to see the Scottish cup semi final!

😂

[cabbageandribs1875]

Because he panicked and shat the bed


on the contrary...the PLAYERS sh*t it as per when going behind in majority of games, a lot of the posts on here leading up to the 1st goal already knew how it was going to go, even though the "bedwetters" (and i) :) were absolutely 110% spot on

[BSEJVT]

Your tye boring one mate

You basically say anything to be negative

Magennis is one of the best young talents In Scotland but ofcourse youd rather just talk *****

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Magennis may reputedly be one of the best young talents in Scotland, but we have seen absolutely zero evidence to back up that assertion.

Ross is taking absolute liberties with him, Murphy, Cadden, Allan & Irvine, playing them in such a high profile game when all 4 of them have barely kicked a ball this season and in some cases far longer.

He is hanging these guys out to dry

[Viva_Palmeiras]

WTF are you on about?

He’s saying number of jobs should not be the bee all and end all or are you being obtuse?

[Allez Hibs]

Stubbs, Christ, best left alone. Hopeless since he left Hibs, great record against Rangers, aye when they had Ian Black, Fraser Aird and Darren McGregor for the most part. Absolutely zero chance he beats Rangers 4-0 at home now. I was a huge fan but there’s no chance he’s the man to take us forward from here.

Stubbs at least could beat Aberdeen and Hearts in the League Cup and Scottish Cup.

[JGS56]

Would you mind posting what their win rates are at Hibs? You know, the most relevant of win rates seeing as we’re talking about how well they’d fit in at Hibs.

Maybe throw in their record in big games and trophy hauls as well since that’s what fans want to see.

Win rates of the last six managers.

Pat Fenlon - 31 in 87 (36%)
Terry Burcher - 6 in 29 (21%)
Alan Stubbs - 59 in 100 (59%)
Neil Lennon - 59 in 123 (48%)
Paul Heckingbottom- 11 in 32 (34%)
Jack Ross - 27 in 54 (50%)

[Allant1981]

[QUOTE=allant1981;6432353]



Then write what you actually think.

Already have, the performance was terrible in the 2nd half, game should have been out of sight by then. Dont think JR should be sacked, not sure what else I need to say

[Kano Kirsty]

Let’s move forwards not backwards. Ross may well lead us to a 2nd place finish the way Celtic are right now but if we have to change we should get Scott Brown in as player-manager. I’m serious.

[Allant1981]

😂

Should be able to cancel, I took the same deal and just cancelled online now

[J-C]

And yet when Lennon did that, you called him out for it? :confused:


I don't mind seeing a manger showing anger when his team have performed like that, I never once called Lennon out for it, my biggest grip with him was his lotto team selections and when his team got beat he blamed them, threw them under the bus is the expression used. It was Lennon's 2nd season that turned me off him, I've given Ross every chance to make me believe he's the right man, yes we're 3rd in the league and tbh we should be either 3rd or 4th given our budget, he's continually lost important games like the Hearts semi, against Aberdeen and now this one, add in the abject performances since christmas and I'd say his time is up.

I see no passion from him, everything is all well thought out before he speaks, I see nothing from him on the touchline either, no geeing players on, no remonstrating with them to get their fingers out nothing, he stands there hands in pockets expressionless, enough already.

[MGmick]

If you get excited about a 4th place finish - have a word.

Crap league and budget way above the rest.

Sums it up perfectly for me.

[A Hi-Bee]

Let’s move forwards not backwards. Ross may well lead us to a 2nd place finish the way Celtic are right now but if we have to change we should get Scott Brown in as player-manager. I’m serious.

That is not a bad shout would take Scotty back in a heartbeat but would he bother now after being on the dark-side for so long?
:aok:

[hibeerealist]

W
Don't think Hibs owner has got a clue what's acceptable for the 1st team. He'll put up with whatever Hibs fans will put up with, and that's all about ticket sale. Jack Ross and the Hibs players can be thankful there are no fans at these matches. The myth about anxiety and pressure coming down from the stands affecting these Hibs snowflakes is well and truly dead. I don't want to hear that ever repeated again.

No ambition, no drive, no spine, no ambition, no pride. A disparate collection of well paid non-achievers at Hibs, managed by someone who's unable to motivate and organise properly for games that really matter.

Under the circumstances, will go down as one of the worst Hibs results at Hampden, and that's saying something.


Well said!

[calumhibee1]

Win rates of the last six managers.

Pat Fenlon - 31 in 87 (36%)
Terry Burcher - 6 in 29 (21%)
Alan Stubbs - 59 in 100 (59%)
Neil Lennon - 59 in 123 (18%)
Paul Heckingbottom- 11 in 32 (34%)
Jack Ross - 27 in 54 (50%)

You’ve made a pigs ear of Lennons :greengrin

So Stubbs had a better win rate, a much better PPG, played much better football, signed much better players and won us the cup.

I know who I’d rather have.

[JohnMcM]

Should be able to cancel, I took the same deal and just cancelled online now

Thanks.
Just tried another 3 times. Still telling me I've signed up for 6 months. Don't know how though:confused:

[One Day Soon]

He’s saying number of jobs should not be the bee all and end all or are you being obtuse?

That's exactly what I'm saying.

[Allant1981]

Thanks.
Just tried another 3 times. Still telling me I've signed up for 6 months. Don't know how though:confused:

Strange, mine took me through a couple of options and then lastly to confirm the cancellation, hopefully you get it sorted

Just double checked mine to make sure! Definitely cancelled as it gives an option to stop the cancellation if I want.

[Callum_62]

Was the term "Hibsed it" coined under Alan Stubbs?


Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[JGS56]

You’ve made a pigs ear of Lennons :greengrin

So Stubbs had a better win rate, a much better PPG, played much better football, signed much better players and won us the cup.

I know who I’d rather have.
Aye, your right - it is 48%

[ads913]

Hibs the whole season has been mediocre ,the style of football not great ,signing's underwhelming (Nisbit aside) and lack of consistency.
Hoof defence diagonal balls and no central play is not great stuff to watch.
I hear Alan Stubbs comeback mentioned were I can agree during his tour we were ten times the team we are now.
If he was to come back and repeat that success is the question, i think he could given the chance.

[Not In The Know]

Alan Stubbs has a 58% win rate at hibs although exclusively in the championship

I mind back in they days constant moaning at his tippy tappy, side to side football

Underwhelmed if hibs go for him

I never understand why this board always looks at ex players and managers - baffling

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

John Mcginn was a huge factor in Stubbs and Lennons teams that skewed the perception of the manager’s ability. As a player when on form he can lift Villa up the premier league. He did that for us.

[KingPat4]

You’ve made a pigs ear of Lennons :greengrin

So Stubbs had a better win rate, a much better PPG, played much better football, signed much better players and won us the cup.

I know who I’d rather have.


Stubbs games were all in the Championship.


:tsk tsk:

[jacomo]

John Mcginn was a huge factor in Stubbs and Lennons teams that skewed the perception of the manager’s ability. As a player when on form he can lift Villa up the premier league. He did that for us.


I’m not joining any bandwagon here, but SJM joined us in Stubbs’ 2nd season, just as Scott Allan left. The style of football was already established before SJM arrived and survived Scotty’s departure.

[Allez Hibs]

Stubbs games were all in the Championship.


:tsk tsk:

Record against Premiership teams was excellent in the Cups.

[hibbysam]

Stubbs at least could beat Aberdeen and Hearts in the League Cup and Scottish Cup.

But lost to Falkirk in a semi where we would’ve played Inverness in the final, lost a final to Ross county, lost a play off to Falkirk, lost a play off against the worst Rangers side of my lifetime.

[cabbageandribs1875]

so much for "the pitch at hampden will suit our players" claims by some, just proves this team can be p@sh on any surface

[ads913]

But lost to Falkirk in a semi where we would’ve played Inverness in the final, lost a final to Ross county, lost a play off to Falkirk, lost a play off against the worst Rangers side of my lifetime.
At least had a go and played with flair. Tonight just hoof ball.

[Coach Jon]

Cheers coach

Your Welcome.

[MinceAndTatties]

Bad choices in the initial line up. Macey should have started. Cadden not fit, Halberg should have been on.
The substitutions reflect the poor choices and were bizarre. Allen and Mcgennis haven't kicked a ball. The shape completely went, players looked clueless
This was never going to be an easy tie but to play like it was a training match in the second half was unforgiveable

Spot on

[hibbysam]

At least had a go and played with flair. Tonight just hoof ball.

I’d say we had a right go in the first half tonight. The players then effectively gave up when they couldn’t score. We had more possession and shots on target today than we had in the Falkirk semi. Zero difference apart from playing a far *****r team back then.

[Lancs Harp]

Consistently when things don't go our way we don't same able to switch to a remotely successful plan B. When things go wrong they stay wrong.

[Sir David Gray]

In St Johnstone's last 12 matches against top flight opposition, they have been in the lead in 5 of them in which they have failed to go on and win. I had hoped when it went to 1-0 that we would take advantage of this vulnerability but as soon as it went to 1-0 we just collapsed and rarely looked like scoring after that.

[Hermit Crab]

In St Johnstone's last 12 matches against top flight opposition, they have been in the lead in 5 of them in which they have failed to go on and win. I had hoped when it went to 1-0 that we would take advantage of this vulnerability but as soon as it went to 1-0 we just collapsed and rarely looked like scoring after that.


After going behind we never looked like getting back into it. Completely shat the bed and hid for the remaining 60 minutes,.

[Bangkok Hibby]

Keep Porteous make him or anybody else Captain and drop Hanlon.

I'm sure getting Ryan into the office for a bollocking/pep talk then have him walk out the office as our new captain would work wonders for him and the team.

[ads913]

I’d say we had a right go in the first half tonight. The players then effectively gave up when they couldn’t score. We had more possession and shots on target today than we had in the Falkirk semi. Zero difference apart from playing a far *****r team back then.

only thing you got right there was we had a go ,then no response once they scored . Completely no back bone no plan B. I doubt that in any of the Falkirk semis we had less possession and played 90mins. Stubbsy teams completely controlled midfield . 2 seasons great to watch football. Tonight was just horrible. BTW he did also win a cup.

[cekim]

We've been ***** for months. Anyone who has watched us would agree we've been ***** for months. I said this after the Hearts debacle and got shot down. How the **** we are so high up the table is beyond me. This result is not a surprise for me we have ridden our luck so many times and got results being *****. Tonight we got found out again ***** defending ***** in front of goal.
We are *****.

[Tambo]

The only positive was Jackson Irvine. Looked like the only ****er that cared.

He won't be here next season anyway.

[Tambo]

We've been ***** for months. Anyone who has watched us would agree we've been ***** for months. I said this after the Hearts debacle and got shot down. How the **** we are so high up the table is beyond me. This result is not a surprise for me we have ridden our luck so many times and got results being *****. Tonight we got found out again ***** defending ***** in front of goal.
We are *****.

Only reason was due to the good start and the other teams playing catch up in my eyes, the football all season has been awful and now we are seeing where we really are as a team as no chance we will finish 3rd or 4th this season.

[hibbysam]

only thing you got right there was we had a go ,then no response once they scored . Completely no back bone no plan B. I doubt that in any of the Falkirk semis we had less possession and played 90mins. Stubbsy teams completely controlled midfield . 2 seasons great to watch football. Tonight was just horrible. BTW he did also win a cup.

You might want to check then as we had more possession yesterday than we did in that semi against Falkirk. They may have controlled the midfield however they were still soft as ****. Peter Houston out thought Stubbs time after time after time. He’s no had a job since he lasted about a month at both st mirren and Rotherham.