We’ve been lucky in the SC draws last few years have we.? - Compared to who exactly...?
Printable View
Yams I know are seething and reckon it’s rigged. One even insisted he will be writing to Budge to get it drawn again..... deluded btw
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I smell a nice wee run to the final and an open topped bus to follow.
Hearts Scottish Cup draws last season
Livingston Home
Auckinleck Talbot Home
Patrick Thistle Away
Inverness Home
They have a cheek to complain
Anyone linking the words Hibs. Scottish Cup and lucky are desperate and deranged.
We seemed to get horrendous draws for a while, there’s no doubt the draw has been generous to us in recent years.
Praying if we get through this that we’d be the Saturday semi. Away to America on the Sunday!
With Hibs and Hearts having home ties the weekend before a televised Tuesday night derby are one of us going to be playing Sunday then Tuesday?
Can they have a lunch time kick off at Tynie and us at 3pm on the same day?
Well we’ve met them twice in the past 8 years but that’s quite a little loose OF formula you’ve got going on in your rationale there. Do you think any team getting drawn in the early rounds to Tynecastle 3 years in a row (including Celtic and Rangers) would consider themselves fortunate.? I just dont see why any Hibs fan would say we’ve been lucky in the Scottish Cup draws in the past few years. Again, I’d ask who do you think amongst the Hearts and Aberdeens have had difficult draws..? We even had the hardest opening round against Dundee Utd a few weeks back that none of the other top teams would have relished.
We've been drawn against an OF side once since 2011, I don't have much memory of ties before then but that's long enough to prove my point. We've 'met' them in a couple of finals, but IMO we've done well to avoid them, more so than Hearts and Aberdeen, for example. We got all the way to the semi final without playing a top flight side back in 14/15 and have generally gotten ties that I would consider to be more favourible at this stage in the competition.
You're welcome to disagree with that, but I personally like that we've managed to avoid the OF for the most part over the last 9 years.
We've had great Scottish Cup draws in recent seasons.
Our toughest run of teams, ironically, was 2016.
Oh it’s the ‘“last 9 years’” now. Ok, well for a start, in most of that time, The Rangers can hardly have been considered a draw to dread for a lot of teams like Hibs, Hearts, Sheep, Utd, so that dilutes your theory by a significant percentage. Can I remind you we have met Celtic twice and Rangers once in an attempt to get our hands on the trophy.. (3 times in your 9 year theory)
The past 3 seasons alone since we’ve won it we’ve been put out by Hearts at Tynie, Aberdeen and Celtic. All difficult ties for any top team.
I’m assuming your comparison is against Hearts, but did you consider their run to the Final last year - and the fact they drew their rivals on their own home turf in that time.?
We played Hearts 4 times, Aberdeen once and Celtic once before the semi final stage.
Hearts played us 4 times, Aberdeen once and Celtic twice.
Aberdeen played Hibs, Hearts, Celtic and Rangers once.
Rangers played Aberdeen once.
Celtic played Hibs and Aberdeen once and Hearts twice.
We don't really get it easy do we? Our four toughest fixtures throughout a year and we have barely avoided all of them til the semi's apart from one season 2014/15.
To be fair, you can't really compare Hibs v Hearts with a South London/Brighton derby.
I does seem a bit strange to have two teams from one city, both travel 40 odd miles to play a match when there's a far better solution right on the door step. Also, are we not currently trying to save the planet? :greengrin
Last 9 years yes. I wasn't making a comparison, I very simply pointed out the factual statement that we have been drawn against the OF once since 2011, I'm happy about that. I don't know why it's been so upsetting to you, by no means does it mean we've had it easy in the Scottish Cup, but we absolutely have gotten some decent draws over the last 9 years, particularly in the latter stages of the competition.
I'd much rather play Hearts at Tynie or Aberdeen than I would Celtic or Rangers prior to the final round and we've done that 8 out of the last 9 years.
You would much rather play Aberdeen or Hearts at Tynie than The Rangers in most of those years you’re mentioning.? They were rank for at half those seasons.
I’m really not upset but bewildered as to why a Hibs fan would suggest we get an easy time in the Scottish Cup compared to others.
Before we get too carried away, ICT played well enough to beat Livingston so they could play well enough to beat us.
This is true. The problem, if you want to call it that, is that the numbers who will turn up whatever the price (within reason) outweigh the people who will become interested when prices are lowered. So the marginal increase in attendance is low.
But that doesn't mean you can't try some other schemes for games like this. Low-price kids tickets, for example, or a 'bring a friend' scheme whereby season tickets can get a second ticket for a fiver, say.
Agree with this. The problem with Hibs giving out free tickets (such as bring a friend) is that we would need to pay ICT half the ticket price, so makes zero sense.
However agreeing with them to reduce prices to £15 for adults and £5 for senior citizens and kids sounds far more sensible.
Loads of us who don't live in Edinburgh and don't have season tickets will travel for the quarter final. Given that it'll cost a fair amount to get to the game, the ticket price isn't going to stop us going.
Introducing a £5 bring a friend sceme would merely lose Hibs £15 for each of us.
I agree, however, it would be great if something could be done to increase attendances, but we've been wrestling with this since the 70s and 80s when crowds were regularly around 4000.
We tried the £10 a ticket thing for a Saturday league game v ICT once (in 2011) and it did add to the attendance IIRC. This is the only time we’ve trialled it as far as I’m aware so is all the evidence we have? So not sure on what basis folk are arguing to the contrary?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/foot...em/9406146.stm
I'd imagine Hibs budget with a cup run in mind so that would impact on ticket prices. However, anything more than £20 and £10 for concessions would be extracting the urine if you ask me. Both teams will be benefitting from TV money as well.
When was the last time hibs featured live on tv for every round?
The argument is that it doesn't make financial sense to slash prices.
It's also unfair on season ticket holders and has implications for future pricing should reductions happen on more than a one-off basis.
The previous ICT game at ER that season attracted a crowd of 11300 do by cutting the walk up price in half, the crowd increased by 2500.
It's a judgement call as to whether it was worth it for the extra bodies, but we took a hit financially.
We’re happy to write off other revenue streams which probably makes it all the more unlikely that costs will be reduced for the paying supporter.
FWIW, £20 for an adult is fine for a cup quarter final. I think it’s kids pricing they need to look at doing something about. Quite often going to away games they have good family deals on. Maybe because I haven’t had to look I’ve just missed them at Easter Road (I know kids can get decent priced season tickets) but not sure about walk up pricing.
If ticket price was the only reason fans were giving for not going, then you could see why having a think about pricing would be worthwhile. Problem is that even with “cheap” tickets, there will be many other excuses and reasons for not going along. It’s not a mouthwatering tie as such and it’s unlikely to be at 3pm Saturday, and if it’s on TV them there will be many reasons why tickets won’t be flying out of the shop.
Wee idea, bring a friend could give 10% off a ticket and £5 off a Hibs strip in the shop?
The sfa rules say Scottish cup games must be a minimum of £8. That’s all. They have nothing to do with whether Hibs and whoever agree £15 or £22.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Also thought both clubs have to agree pricing prior to semi and final
I see that the Motherwell v St Mirren replay has been priced at £12 adults, £6 concessions and £3 under 16's.
Killie and Aberdeen have agreed prices for their Cup Replay
- £15 adults
- £10 concession (Over 65s, U21 and students)
- £5 U16s
Incoming!
:offski:
It's a joke that just over two weeks before one of the games could potentially kick off we are still awaiting for the times/dates.
Just realised that there is a possibility of a Hibs v Aberdeen and Celtic v Hearts semi final draw. I think that's happened before in recent years, but have erased that year's competition from my memory banks.
Thoughts on another Hibs v Hearts final?
Given his shocking treatment by the SFA and their contemptable processes should we give cup winning legend James Keatings a rousing reception when he takes to the field next week...and then pelters when ever he gets on the ball?
If we applaud Keatings then he'll run to the wrong bench :wink:
30 mins to get the reduced price for ST holders.
True, I suppose the age old argument is about the short term boost to finances v trying to turn some of those extra fans into season ticket holders/regulars. The poster I quoted said the price had no effect on attendances when, taking that game in isolation, it would appear to have contributed to a small increase.