Aberdeen v Hibernian

[Rumble de Thump]

The problem with introducing VAR to Scottish football was always going to be that the match officials can't be trusted to apply the rules properly or fairly.

[SaulGoodman]

Vars doing its job it us that's not doing ours by not scoring when we are on top

How do you get that when the boy dived?

[cabbageandribs1875]

VAR spent 20 mins desperate to give the penalty in the first place, that player was never ever EVER going to get that ball



daylight freakin robbery

[high bee]

VAR is one of the worst things to happen to football. Totally slows the game down, causes as much controversy as it was supposed to eliminate and takes away from the entertainment with players just hanging about or stalling goal celebrations.

[Jack Hackett]

****ing outrageous!!! CLEAR dive!

[Shrekko]

How on earth does ANYONE believe that’s a pen far less a Hibs fan?

[MelbourneHibees]

So if he scores when off his line is is retaken ?

I hope this isn't a serious question.

[Hibees1973]

Fuming.It reminds me of the game we had away at Dundee Utd.This one stinks as well.Something going on.

[Waxy]

Var here is a laugh. Lets pay more people who dont know what they’re doing.
This ref has to be demoted after this. Its almost a crime

[NC1875]

Can’t wait for Goodwin to call out his player for “conning the ref”

[bringbackbenny]

Whats the the betting some Hun in the VAR studio has asked for the referral?!

No-one who's ever played or been involved with football could see that as a pen.

[Alan62]

Never a penalty. VAR is a complete waste of time.

[Sir David Gray]

I can see myself giving up on football if this is the direction it's going in.

The game's done.

[cammy1969]

Why did no only look at it from one angle


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HibbyAndy]

WOW ! Absolutely stunned , How that ref can go to the monitor and give a penalty is a disgrace , Blatant dive as you will see

[McHibby]

Unfortunately the same dicks referring before VAR are referring with var and using it as a crutch

Yep, you can give crap referees all the tools in the world, but they will still be crap. The standard of refs in Scotland is embarrassing.

[Ozyhibby]

Lack of goals is becoming a real problem for us. We have dominated the game find ourselves behind.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

we can debate all night if it was a penalty or not, that retake was on marshall i'm afraid

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

Shocker of a decision. Giving var to Scottish officials is like giving chimps hand grenades!

[GreenCastle]

VAR is making Scottish football look tin pot.

Awful decisions by part time referees which show them up how bad they are.

[WhileTheChief..]

At least with inconsistent refs we got some decisions to go our way.

This is reckon rotten. Goes against us every time.

[Onion]

WOW ! Absolutely stunned , How that ref can go to the monitor and give a penalty is a disgrace , Blatant dive as you will see

Aberdeen Manager had a quiet word with ref pre-match, asking him to "even things out" ?

[MelbourneHibees]

Corruption at its worst, this needs stamped out, just brutal.

Just checking, are you suggesting that the SFA are biased towards Aberdeen over Hibs?


It's not corruption FFS. It's just ***** refereeing.

[Waxy]

Who is this ref i missed his name?

[Hibee Mac]

The beautiful game is being ruined

[GreenCastle]

Why did no only look at it from one angle


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Scottish football has the cheap version of VAR as teams pay for it depending on end of season leave placing.

Less cameras.

The camera angle behind the goals clearly shows no pen - Marshall pulls hands away.

[FitbaFolkKen]

We need full time refs, we can give them all the systems in the world but they are amateurs.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jeffers]

I said to my mates when it came in we should have asked the guys at Stockley Park to administer it for us. Of course though that would be an admission that our referees are incompetent cheats.

[Hibby-G]

Stops the game for a good 4-5 minutes to check a decision that we can all see on the TV within 30 seconds. Guys already hit the floor by the time Marshall approaches.

VAR is never going to work up here if it's just the same idiots in charge.

[Hibernian Verse]

Boyle gets booked for that

[SeanWilson]

I literally cannot belive they gave the pen there

In real time it was obvious it wasn't a pen

2 replays later its even more obvious

Even if it was hibs I'd be saying it's probbaly a dive but never a pen

Ridiculous state of affairs that decision

No qualms on retake but orginal decision (with replays) is a real shocker

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

👏👍 100pc

[Hibbyradge]

Aberdeen Manager had a quiet word with ref pre-match, asking him to "even things out" ?

He didn't give the penalty initially. He could have.

[SteveHFC]

How do you get that when the boy dived?

At game so only seen it once so if he dived they got it wrong however I'm will to give var time to sort itself out and hopefully mistakes will be highlighted and acted on

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

we can debate all night if it was a penalty or not, that retake was on marshall i'm afraid

Don’t think anyone is disputing the retake.

[easty]

If that’s Boyle it’s a booking for diving.

[Rumble de Thump]

On the BBC Richard Foster looked at the replays and said it was hard to tell if there had been any contact and that there might have been contact. I'm not sure why the VAR has asked the ref to take a look at something that isn't a clear and obvious error.

[Joe6-2]

Yep, you can give crap referees all the tools in the world, but they will still be crap. The standard of refs in Scotland is embarrassing.

CHEATS, the ONLY word to describe them

[J-C]

Lack of goals is becoming a real problem for us. We have dominated the game find ourselves behind.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Little width and not a lot of pace in the team, dominating but not really creating much of anything.

[Carheenlea]

VAR is making Scottish football look tin pot.

Awful decisions by part time referees which show them up how bad they are.

Can actually see VAR being abandoned in Scotland very soon. That fiasco tonight will raise serious doubts.

Unworkable with our officials.

[weecounty hibby]

we can debate all night if it was a penalty or not, that retake was on marshall i'm afraid

That is a real stretch to be blaming any Hibs player. The root of that goal is what looks like a ****ing horrific decision made by two supposed professional referees

[Hibernian Verse]

We need full time refs, we can give them all the systems in the world but they are amateurs.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I’m not a full time ref and I know that isn’t a penalty

[Sir David Gray]

Who is this ref i missed his name?

David Munro.

[Austinho]

Who is this ref i missed his name?David Munro

[HoboHarry]

We need full time refs, we can give them all the systems in the world but they are amateurs.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
It'll still be the same referees, paying them a bigger wage won't make them better. I honestly don't know why the standard in Scotland is so bleak.

[Lago]

I can see myself giving up on football if this is the direction it's going in.

The game's done.
I'm pretty much there now live football is Kirkcaldy and Dysart in EoS league very rarely watch Scottish football on TV take in the various European league on TV, much better for my blood pressure 😊

[Jim44]

we can debate all night if it was a penalty or not, that retake was on marshall i'm afraid

If Marshall hadn’t moved, he probably wouldn’t have saved it so it’s a moot point. You can’t blame Marshall. Blame it on corrupt and incompetent Scottish referees.

[Zambernardi1875]

best ive seen us play up here for years, so no surprise we go 1-0 down with a dodgy decision. id stick mekelson on now as they are absolute gash. no point having Var is the replys are on a commodore 64

[Donegal Hibby]

Terrible decision . Never a penalty. Clear a dive as you will get .no point having VAR when you have incompetent referees right across the game.

[Sir David Gray]

At game so only seen it once so if he dived they got it wrong however I'm will to give var time to sort itself out and hopefully mistakes will be highlighted and acted on

It was a horrendous dive.

[Just_Jimmy]

VAR is making Scottish football look tin pot.

Awful decisions by part time referees which show them up how bad they are.It is tin pot. Just confirming what we knew.

It's bent

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

[degenerated]

WOW ! Absolutely stunned , How that ref can go to the monitor and give a penalty is a disgrace , Blatant dive as you will seeLooked that way to me 26274

[Keith_M]

Disgraceful decision, yes, but we really should have made more of our domination of the first half.

[Hibbyradge]

Just checking, are you suggesting that the SFA are biased towards Aberdeen over Hibs?


It's not corruption FFS. It's just ***** refereeing.

Agreed.

[easty]

We need full time refs, we can give them all the systems in the world but they are amateurs.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I dinnae see how that helps?

I’m no even a part time ref, but I can see it’s never a pen.

[Waxy]

VAR has been around for years now.
Its been in Scotland for a few weeks and already Scottish VAR has made the worst call in VAR history
We may as well just bin it.

[bringbackbenny]

On the BBC Richard Foster looked at the replays and said it was hard to tell if there had been any contact and that there might have been contact. I'm not sure why the VAR has asked the ref to take a look at something that isn't a clear and obvious error.

Shock, Foster (and Sports sound) taking a pro Aberdeen slant

[Not In The Know]

Willie Miller said it wasn’t a pen.

[Northernhibee]

I dinnae see how that helps?

I’m no even a part time ref, but I can see it’s never a pen.
To see that was a dive didn’t need VAR, it needed eyes.

[hibIBZ]

26275

How can the ref see that then go to a monitor and give a penalty, utter joke

[Itsnoteasy]

VAR is making Scottish football look tin pot.

Awful decisions by part time referees which show them up how bad they are.

Same in the richest league in the world

[Up-the-slope]

i was thinking I was disappointed at 44 min with 0-0 given how well we had played (but also that final ball / shot being better we would be well ahead) ... then that shambles..

just hope management & players keep the head and get back out and play rather than get involved in the controversy

[Jack Hackett]

Shocker of a decision. Giving var to Scottish officials is like giving chimps hand grenades!

I keep looking for a 'Like' button :greengrin

[Jones28]

Pie and Bovril Twitter thinks it’s tight but a penalty.

[Bristolhibby]

Even Sheep TV are embarrassed about that “penalty”.

J

[skyehibee]

Utterly laughable decision. Scottish referees are laughing stock.

[The Harp Awakes]

The game in Scotland is ******. Incompetent officials throughout our game. VAR needs binned immediately.

[Dalianwanda]

Even Aberdeen commentators think it was the wrong decision. mental

[easty]

Just checking, are you suggesting that the SFA are biased towards Aberdeen over Hibs?


It's not corruption FFS. It's just ***** refereeing.

Absolutely.

[GreenCastle]

I’ve watched it about 10 times and it’s definitely not a penalty.

He’s trying to play for it - kick ball - lean into Marshall but Marshall slides and stops and his hands are no where near the player.

The angle behind the goal clearly shows that.

If you have any knowledge of football you can see what’s going on.

[FitbaFolkKen]

It'll still be the same referees, paying them a bigger wage won't make them better. I honestly don't know why the standard in Scotland is so bleak.

If they are full time posts then you could have applicants from down south or abroad. With us having amateur refs the “pool” is just the crap we have at the moment as they need to be local.

Put together a decent package for full time referees and the standard will improve.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JamesHFC]

VAR has been around for years now.
Its been in Scotland for a few weeks and already Scottish VAR has made the worst call in VAR history
We may as well just bin it.

I was all for it but dearie me if these are the type of people making the decisions then I'd rather not have it. Disgraceful decision.

[bringbackbenny]

Pie and Bovril Twitter thinks it’s tight but a penalty.

Then they're trolling.

[Hibby70]

Simulation is a free kick and even if Marshall does eventually touch him the dive comes first.

VAR is a complete waste of time up here. Hope it gets scrapped for next season but it won't.

[Itsnoteasy]

Dons TV said never a penalty

[cammy1969]

Scottish football has the cheap version of VAR as teams pay for it depending on end of season leave placing.

Less cameras.

The camera angle behind the goals clearly shows no pen - Marshall pulls hands away.

Yeah that’s what I was getting at from behind goal clear as day no pen if Aberdeen tv has that angle why no the ref unbelievable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hibs90]

https://twitter.com/Malky1875/status/1588630055810236416?s=20&t=b43b-jXJ3KAwvIIuX2uMxQ


How can the referee go and watch that on the monitor and decide that's a penalty?

[Hibbyradge]

26275

He's not anywhere near Marshall and he's already on the way down.

He's the cheat. The referees are just hopeless.

[noz]

even dons tv saying they got lucky with the pen. Ref shouldnt be changing his mind unless clear and obvious

[Hibees1973]

Script 2nd half.

We always dominate possession against everyone apart from the uglies.

Will finish 2-0 Aberdeen.

One, probably two Hibs players sent off.

[Aldo]

We all knew it was going to be the same inadequate officials monitoring VAR.

They can do and say what they want as there are no consequences for them ****ing up!

Goodwin will be happy but I still cannot understand why a penalty was given!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[supershotmo]

Their player booted the ball out the park before Marshall fouled him. Should be a goal kick for Hibs.

[Bristolhibby]

If they are full time posts then you could have applicants from down south or abroad. With us having amateur refs the “pool” is just the crap we have at the moment as they need to be local.

Put together a decent package for full time referees and the standard will improve.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I liked it when the Scottish refs went on strike and we got a bunch of brilliant Latvians and Lithuanian refs for the weekend.

J

[cabbageandribs1875]

That is a real stretch to be blaming any Hibs player. The root of that goal is what looks like a ****ing horrific decision made by two supposed professional referees

it's no stretch whatsoever to see exactly why the penalty was retaken, which i am alluding to, i thought i made it quite clear tbf, doesn't matter a toss how we got to that, it was given we can't take that back

[Feed McGraw]

Never liked the look of this nonsense from first ever seeing it, even worse now it affects our game/team. Utterly sickening and will put people off the game. What a brass neck these refs have got when everyone can see that`s not a pen !!

[Jones28]

Then they're trolling.

Just seen it, they absolutely are. Never a penalty.

[Hibees1973]

https://twitter.com/Malky1875/status/1588630055810236416?s=20&t=b43b-jXJ3KAwvIIuX2uMxQ


How can the referee go and watch that on the monitor and decide that's a penalty?

That's effin criminal.

[1875Sean]

Same in the richest league in the world

Standard down there compared to Scotland is night and day

[cabbageandribs1875]

Duk Duk

Duk of Dives

[Baader]

VAR, with the abysmal standard of refereeing in Scotland, was never going to be anything other than a complete disaster.

[GreenCastle]

Somone post the behind the goal video.

Refs are scared to give pens and every pen will be given via video unless 100% positive.

[Northernhibee]

If referees want to be treated better then they can do their ****ing job.

[McHibby]

https://twitter.com/Malky1875/status/1588630055810236416?s=20&t=b43b-jXJ3KAwvIIuX2uMxQ


How can the referee go and watch that on the monitor and decide that's a penalty?


That's an absolutely minging decision.

[HUTCHYHIBBY]

So if he scores when off his line is is retaken ?

Where's the advantage to the attacking team there?

[Torto7]

That ref is an utter clown.

[JimBHibees]

One of the worst decisions I have ever seen. A clear dive and if any contact it is created by his pathetic dive. Desperate to give a decision against us

[SlickShoes]

If it takes you 5+ minutes to decide if its a foul, is it remotely clear and obvious? how many minutes do we wait and how forensic do we get with the analysis?

[HoboHarry]

If they are full time posts then you could have applicants from down south or abroad. With us having amateur refs the “pool” is just the crap we have at the moment as they need to be local.

Put together a decent package for full time referees and the standard will improve.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Good luck with the Lanarkshire Refereeing mafia allowing that to happen.

[Aldo]

Jesus wept he falls down, uses his left foot to launch himself.

That is plain cheating


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Donegal Hibby]

That ref is an utter clown.
Unfortunately so are all the rest of them too

[CmoantheHibs]

We can still beat these cheating ****ers. Cmon Hibs let's do this.

[GreenCastle]

If it takes you 5+ minutes to decide if its a foul, is it remotely clear and obvious? how many minutes do we wait and how forensic do we get with the analysis?

Takes 5 mins to give something not given at the time then gets more obvious the more you watch it that was a dive but the corrupt / incompetent ref gave it as he’s totally clueless.

Then do we add the time on ? No - just like St J game.

[cabbageandribs1875]

hope this has got the hibs players backs up


get it roond they cants

[Callum_62]

Jesus wept he falls down, uses his left foot to launch himself.

That is plain cheating


Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkIf marshal take him out from the side he doesn't launch himself out behind the goals

I get folk can make snap judgements and get it wrong in real time but watching 40 replays to then give the pen is literally unbelievable

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Hibiza]

High time these " refs" and the VAR " experts" become accountable.

[Joe6-2]

hope this has got the hibs players backs up


If it hasn’t, nothing will

[percy veer]

Who is on var

[snedzuk]

https://twitter.com/malky1875/status/1588630055810236416?s=20&t=b43b-jxj3kawviiux2umxq


how can the referee go and watch that on the monitor and decide that's a penalty?

ffs

[The Spaceman]

They should have to publicise their decision or justification for a monitor review in text format in real time for decisions such as that. Full accountability and transparency.

[JimBHibees]

If referees want to be treated better then they can do their ****ing job.

Absolutely the standard is utterly horrific

[Joe6-2]

High time these " refs" and the VAR " experts" become accountable.

That is one of the problems

[hibstag]

VAR spent 20 mins desperate to give the penalty in the first place, that player was never ever EVER going to get that ball



daylight freakin robbery

This. if they keep looking and looking at the incident they create the infringement to rule on. , the watt sending off is another example of this they showed an angle and still where it looks like he raked his studs on the guy but in reality it was barely a touch

[GreenCastle]

Henderson tries lobbing keeper from 30 yards - seen worse efforts.

Henderson has played well.

[cabbageandribs1875]

sure the commentator said VAR dude was strickland/whoever

[snedzuk]

Who is on var

Stevie Wonder

[delbert]

One of the worst decisions I have ever seen. A clear dive and if any contact it is created by his pathetic dive. Desperate to give a decision against us

Five things for VAR to check and they got 3 out of 5 completely incorrect. Not offside in build up, correct - clear dive missed, incorrect - foul by keeper awarded, incorrect - keeper off line at penalty, correct - clear encroachment by both sides at second penalty means a further retake - goal incorrectly awarded . A 40% success rate using the SFA’s much vaunted new toy, being used by guys clearly not properly trained or up to the task and not aided by one of the worst Grade One referees out there at present, a man with zero foul recognition

[FitbaFolkKen]

I liked it when the Scottish refs went on strike and we got a bunch of brilliant Latvians and Lithuanian refs for the weekend.

J

100%

I don’t see any other option than full time refs other than coming on here and moaning every week which is no fun.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GreenCastle]

Who is on var

Some ref getting paid in Clydesdale House.

12 mins from Ibrox
8 mins from Celtic Park

[Zambernardi1875]

High time these " refs" and the VAR " experts" become accountable.

they need miked up so either the fans or studio can hear his decision on why its given, until then ***** refs will double down

[The Spaceman]

Henderson tries lobbing keeper from 30 yards - seen worse efforts.

Henderson has played well.

They’ve all played well. We’ve dominated this game and are clearly the superior team, but we’ve been cheated.

[JimBHibees]

Who is on var

Boy called Steven Kirkland yep never heard of him either

[Irish_Steve]

**** off

[cabbageandribs1875]

2-0 that'll be game

[JJP]

Game over

[Northernhibee]

That wasn’t in the corner.

[FitbaFolkKen]

Good luck with the Lanarkshire Refereeing mafia allowing that to happen.

Yeah I agree, it is holding our game back and contributing to the duopoly.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SlickShoes]

Ball isn't in the lines at the corner, should be retaken.

[SteveHFC]

Free header

[Sir David Gray]

Game over.

[GreenCastle]

The ball for the corner wasn’t even on the corner circle.

[cabbageandribs1875]

newell steps off of myioski, boom

[Tricla]

That wasn’t in the corner.

Noticed that too.

[Scottie]

Where the ****s the marking :faf:

[J-C]

My streams went down now.

[skyehibee]

Joe Newells man

[Sir David Gray]

Dreadful defending.

[Mon Dieu4]

How about checking VAR to show the ball wasn't in the the right place for that corner, wasn't in the box

[A Hi-Bee]

So were are all the var supporters now, we have a bunch o huns sitting in a caravan in Glesgie someplace watching and making up decisions like that, its never going to get any better. We have a guy who has played the game in goals at the highest level no has to be labelled a cheat as he never touched the guy, to say otherwise is to call Marshall a cheat. The game is ****ed, even more than it used to be.

[Irish_Steve]

That wasn’t in the corner.

Doesn't have to be - as long as part of the ball hangs over the quadrant, it;s in play

[percy veer]

2-0 that'll be game

Amd now they will say the pen made no difference, laughable. Sick of this crap

[Tricla]

Ball isn't in the lines at the corner, should be retaken.

What isn't var checking that?

[Hibs90]

What's the point

[OtleyHibs]

Poor defending from Newell, disappointing after playing well first half

Can get back in this

[CMac1988]

Newell ****ed it. Lack of quality when on top going to be our downfall this season.

[GRA]

Free header in the 6 yard box... Newell FFS get on him!

[Northernhibee]

Ball isn't in the lines at the corner, should be retaken.
VAR doesn’t work that way.

Someome try and put that diving prick out for a while if we can’t win.

[supermcginn]

Laughable defending from Newell

[Callum_62]

If we watch enough replays surely it's a push on newell [emoji23][emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Hibernian Verse]

Game over

[Scottie]

My streams went down now.
You're a lucky boy the JC

[Hibees1973]

You get the feeling that when the ref is 'instructed' to look at the replay on VAR he has no choice but to give a penalty. If that's what VAR is going to be like up here it's going the a complete shambles.

As other posters have said it's ruining the game.

Prior to VAR if a ref made a mistake, then fair enough that's just they way it is.

But to have 3 or 4 guys to pour over an incident for 5 mins and come to that decision really is disgraceful.

[Bristolhibby]

Game over

Actually I’ve bed wet. Plenty of time. But the Dons will shut up shop now.

J

Actually correct original call.

[Jim44]

That farce in the first half has knocked the stuffing out of us. I’m scunnered with Scottish football.

[EGL2000]

So poor from Newell there. Classic Hibs much the better team for the first 45, need to score when on top.

[itslegaltender]

Why do we have Newell who is terrible in the air marking their big striker at a corner? Not the first time Newell has been done over on a cross ball and cost us a goal this season.

[jakedance]

Horrible defending by Newell. Brutal.

[Tambo]

At work so can't watch the game, has it been another lot of chances but no end product?

Disappointed with the score as was a great opportunity to push further ahead.

[A Hi-Bee]

Game over

We do the same thing over and over again, when Newells off his game he is minging.
We should have came out this half so fired up the sheep would not know what hit them, but no what do we do, ffs.

[Callum_62]

Cadden shouod have wnet down there

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Heisenberg]

Done by a shocking penalty decision and ***** defending at a corner. Brutal.

[loanheadhibby]

Laughable defending from Newell

Home games only for Newell.
He gets rated on here but he's a luxury in away games against the better teams.

[McHibby]

You get the feeling that when the ref is 'instructed' to look at the replay on VAR he has no choice but to give a penalty


That seemed to be what Willie Miller was saying, too.

[BILLYHIBS]

Free header in the box

Dearie me !

[Callum_62]

Maggennis is looking sharp again

Puts in some amount of work

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[J-C]

You're a lucky boy the JC

haha, Hibs stream is like nearly in slomo, on the Aberdeen one now with volume down listening to tunes with the wife.

[Aldo]

Stevie Wonder

Even he wouldn’t have given it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Since452]

Oh well that'll be that.

[Tricla]

VAR doesn’t work that way.

Someome try and put that diving prick out for a while if we can’t win.

I thought it checked every goal to make sure there wasn't anything in the build up that would result in it being chalked off? Surely an illegal corner constitutes that?

[cabbageandribs1875]

You get the feeling that when the ref is 'instructed' to look at the replay on VAR he has no choice but to give a penalty. If that's what VAR is going to be like up here it's going the a complete shambles.

As other posters have said it's ruining the game.

Prior to VAR if a ref made a mistake, then fair enough that's just they way it is.

But to have 3 or 4 guys to pour over an incident for 5 mins and come to that decision really is disgraceful.



:agree:

[H18 SFR]

You get the feeling that when the ref is 'instructed' to look at the replay on VAR he has no choice but to give a penalty. If that's what VAR is going to be like up here it's going the a complete shambles.

As other posters have said it's ruining the game.

Prior to VAR if a ref made a mistake, then fair enough that's just they way it is.

But to have 3 or 4 guys to pour over an incident for 5 mins and come to that decision really is disgraceful.

Michael Oliver is the only referee in the history of VAR in the EPL to not change his decision. He’s done that on one occasion.

[MGmick]

Not really a fan of Joe Newall but, when we're playing with three centre halfs, why is their centre forward being marked by a midfielder at a corner?

[Scottie]

haha, Hibs stream is like nearly in slomo, on the Aberdeen one now with volume down listening to tunes with the wife.
:thumbsup: glad its back on mate.

[Heisenberg]

Embarrassing now.

[NC1875]

Again, we could play all night and never look like scoring.

VAR will ruin Scottish football. The same ***** refs in charge of it

[BILLYHIBS]

3-0

[Aldo]

Game was a ****ing bogey before HT with that shocking decision.

I know I’m going to state the obvious but we really do need to start taking our chances!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

collapse complete 3-0

[Jones28]

3-0? Ffs

[J-C]

Looks like we've been reduced to hitting balls into the box and hoping, little guile or creativity.

[Northernhibee]

**** off,

[Sir David Gray]

Embarrassing.

[McHibby]

3-0

ffs

[JeMeSouviens]

I thought it checked every goal to make sure there wasn't anything in the build up that would result in it being chalked off? Surely an illegal corner constitutes that?

It’s not illegal. Ball only has to partly overhang the line. Been like that for years.

[GRA]

How are we losing 3-0. Dominated this game. Deja vu with the Dundee Utd & St Johnstone game. Not converting our dominance into chances.

[truehibernian]

Home games only for Newell.
He gets rated on here but he's a luxury in away games against the better teams.

He won't be here in January, can't see LJ putting up with one game in 5 when he fancies it. Infuriating player, but needs to go - pea hearted sadly :aok:

[JJP]

How have we managed to end up 3 - 0 down? Unbelievable!

[cabbageandribs1875]

needless corner given away by Hanlon

[Itsnoteasy]

haha, Hibs stream is like nearly in slomo, on the Aberdeen one now with volume down listening to tunes with the wife.

It was the same from ER v St Mirren. Same stream but saints tv was faultless, Hibs tv kept buffering

[skyehibee]

How are we losing this 3-0?? Unbelievable

[Paulie Walnuts]

It’s games like this that make me struggle to see us finishing third unfortunately.

[HH81]

That ref giving VAR's decision instead of his own has just deflated players.

Ref cheated
Players been poor since.

Joke.

[Scottie]

Aberdeen no 9 offside in the line of Marshall no var to check :rolleyes:

[OtleyHibs]

needless corner given away by Hanlon

Was really poor

[Tambo]

Think it's going to be another season or inconsistently results.

Think the world cup break will do us good. Regroup and hopefully improve the squad in January.

[CMac1988]

Another set piece more woeful defending. Shambles. Not enough quality, poor mentally.

[Northernhibee]

Someone go through that diving prick

[JamesHFC]

The least 3-0 game I have ever seen. Horrible result though. 3 points needed on Tuesday now.

[SteveHFC]

No excuse for the goals in 2nd half shocking defending

[Since452]

Could be a cricket score now. Lost the plot.

[BegbieHSC]

****ing shambles!

We’ve seen the blatant cheating in the first half, so the players have chucked it! GTF

[Mon Dieu4]

What the **** is the 4th official doing when Goodwin is having a chat with his bench and staff from the seat behind, SFA better be looking into that

[Sir David Gray]

I'd take a 10 game ban to really leave a sore one on that diving ******* Duk.

[Hibernian Verse]

It’s not often I feel for the players when 3-0 down

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

Why do we always fall to pieces up there?!!!

[J-C]

Can't defend crosses with 3 ****ing CH's and a DM FFS, just ****ing brutal again.

I know Johnson said there will be a few heavy defeats now and then but |I assumed he was joking.

[Callum_62]

Hahaha that is another brilliant call by the ref there after duk threw himself through the air [emoji23][emoji23][emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[FitbaFolkKen]

We need to start scoring when on top


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Zambernardi1875]

we just accepted that was a freekick, nobody going daft, terrible mentality

[Waxy]

3-0 down for being the vastly dominant team.
A big glimpse of what var can do.

[cabbageandribs1875]

aberdeen up for it now



not so much hibs players

[SteveHFC]

It’s not often I feel for the players when 3-0 down

Players should feel for fans and put ball in net

[Swedish hibee]

I don't like Friday night football.

[hibIBZ]

Came out from half time and looked like the heads were down, they have chucked ot now

[HH81]

No excuse for the goals in 2nd half shocking defending

So poor mate. End first half rocked them and lost bottle.

[Bristolhibby]

It’s games like this that make me struggle to see us finishing third unfortunately.

For sure. No consistency.

[The Spaceman]

Actually really feel for the players here. We’ve, unbelievably, played well and largely dominated the game. We’ve been unwound by a horrendous decision. Incredibly harsh but that’s football. Play this game 10 more times and we will win 8.

[Northernhibee]

I'd take a 10 game ban to really leave a sore one on that diving ******* Duk.
I’d back any Hibs player who did it.

[1875Sean]

Don’t know why lee left it so long to make a sub and why only make one change

[thebausburst]

What do Hibs do in training all week, lose the same soft goals every week.

[Jones28]

What do Hibs do in training all week, lose the same soft goals every week.

Like last week when we didn’t concede a goal?

[NC1875]

Actually really feel for the players here. We’ve, unbelievably, played well and largely dominated the game. We’ve been unwound by a horrendous decision. Incredibly harsh but that’s football. Play this game 10 more times and we will win 8.

Apart from the terrible defending for the 2nd and 3rd goals of course. That’s the problem, the players are feeling sorry for themselves. Terrible attitude

[Itsnoteasy]

No one is forcing you to watch. Is eastenders not on?

Should have listened to you.

[Joe6-2]

Came out from half time and looked like the heads were down, they have chucked ot now

pathetic, should have came out raging

[Basildon Hibs]

Think it's going to be another season or inconsistently results.

Think the world cup break will do us good. Regroup and hopefully improve the squad in January.

Aye, by getting rid of the large amount of utter dross we have and signing some experienced pros. for a change.

[SteveHFC]

Actually really feel for the players here. We’ve, unbelievably, played well and largely dominated the game. We’ve been unwound by a horrendous decision. Incredibly harsh but that’s football. Play this game 10 more times and we will win 8.
Can play like Brazil but you need to score and we cant

[Northernhibee]

Ball hits Scales arm in the box.

If their one is a penalty, that’s one too.

[thebausburst]

Actually really feel for the players here. We’ve, unbelievably, played well and largely dominated the game. We’ve been unwound by a horrendous decision. Incredibly harsh but that’s football. Play this game 10 more times and we will win 8.

Sorry but that’s just fantasy stuff, Hibs can’t score regularly so game would probably pan out the same, our record at Pittodrie is shocking.

[The Spaceman]

Aye, by getting rid of the large amount of utter dross we have and signing some experienced pros. for a change.

Stay down in Basildon.

[Callum_62]

Came out from half time and looked like the heads were down, they have chucked ot nowDid we?

Aberdeen tv were saying we were well ontop and Aberdeen hadn't started yet

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Jones28]

Nothing like a defeat to bring out the absentee posters.

[J-C]

Actually really feel for the players here. We’ve, unbelievably, played well and largely dominated the game. We’ve been unwound by a horrendous decision. Incredibly harsh but that’s football. Play this game 10 more times and we will win 8.


We've been quite good between the boxes but done nothing up front and hopeless at the back.

[Northernhibee]

Who is this ref?

[Hibees1973]

I'd take a 10 game ban to really leave a sore one on that diving ******* Duk.

Aye and get it reduced to 2 on appeal.

[Since452]

We are capable of dominating teams but crumble at the slightest bit of adversity. Soft as ****.

[blackpoolhibs]

Typical Hibs, no bottle when things get tough, no back bone and not enough goalscorers to make up for that.

[Sir David Gray]

Who is this ref?

David Munro.

[BegbieHSC]

pathetic, should have came out raging

Instead they’ve come out tail between the legs accepting defeat. I don’t feel for them. They need to take a good ****ing look at themselves.

Same as St Johnstone at home. A bad refereeing decision, and the players chuck it.

[loanheadhibby]

He won't be here in January, can't see LJ putting up with one game in 5 when he fancies it. Infuriating player, but needs to go - pea hearted sadly :aok:
I say that every week and get slaughtered.
Keep hearing how good he is particularly from MW Hibbies.
Our players should be judged at Pittodrie, Tynecastle and in Glasgow.
We completely over hype our lads when we beat the likes of St Mirren at Easter Road.
How daft does the thread look now relating to us being above the Hearts. I know it was a bit of fun but they will soon be above us.

[Irish_Steve]

Game on!

[cabbageandribs1875]

hibs goal chalked off for offside

[Itsnoteasy]

3-0 down for being the vastly dominant team.
A big glimpse of what var can do.

You can't blame vat if we can't score whilst in control.

[Heisenberg]

We are capable of dominating teams but crumble at the slightest bit of adversity. Soft as ****.

Wouldn’t say that’s been the case too many times this season. Certainly at Parkhead and tonight but we’ve made plenty comebacks this season and scored last minute goals.

[SaulGoodman]

I say that every week and get slaughtered.
Keep hearing how good he is particularly from MW Hibbies.
Our players should be judged at Pittodrie, Tynecastle and in Glasgow.
We completely over hype our lads when we beat the likes of St Mirren at Easter Road.
How daft does the thread look now relating to us being above the Hearts. I know it was a bit of fun but they will soon be above us.

Don’t be a fud

[Since452]

Wouldn’t say that’s been the case too many times this season. Certainly at Parkhead and tonight but we’ve made plenty comebacks this season and scored last minute goals.

St Johnstone as well

[Northernhibee]

David Munro.
He’s an utter ****.

[cabbageandribs1875]

hibs are fallen apart again sing the home fans



Mmmmmm

[Pagan Hibernia]

Typical Hibs, no bottle when things get tough, no back bone and not enough goalscorers to make up for that.

yep. They never change.

Aberdeen were gifted a half time lead, no doubt, but there’s no excuse for this collapse

[J-C]

Can play like Brazil but you need to score and we cant

Only 1 attacking forward on the pitch, we were playing a front 3 a few weeks ago and have now been reduced to playing 1 up top and 4 central midfielders and a back 3.

[Mon Dieu4]

I actually don't think we have played too badly, just been zero cutting edge and no luck at all

[SteveHFC]

Don't you love var

[Callum_62]

Goal,. Offside

Closer than I thought with Aberdeen right back tho

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk