Simon Brown and Graeme Smith were much worse imo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Baader
Tin hat on but when he wasn’t making his mistakes Zibi was actually alright.
Printable View
Simon Brown and Graeme Smith were much worse imo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Baader
Tin hat on but when he wasn’t making his mistakes Zibi was actually alright.
That joker was 100percent on the takeQuote:
Originally Posted by Baader
Without questionQuote:
Originally Posted by SickBoy32
That’s a beauty 😂Quote:
Originally Posted by Paulie Walnuts
Maybe we could run a thread for a non Hibs Disliked XI.
and then have a playoff. Perversely I suspect the outcome would be a dislike of the Hibs XI more… why does that tend to be the case? Some of the scapegoats over the years got it far tighter than even some of the Jambos.
Billy, with respect, Tom Soares was a chicken hearted ***** bag who did the square root of **** all in a Hibs shirt and was part of one of the worst results in our history.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
He should forever be remembered as nothing more than awful, as should the majority of the rest of his colleagues from that team.
Very worthy of a place in this team.
I genuinely believe that.Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomtownHibees
Had he never had to face Hearts I’d suspect he’d be remembered as an alright keeper, no more, no less.
What went on against Hearts though was nothing short of bizarre, verging on being suspicious.
Never thought I'd have seen the day where Tom Soares was labelled "Quality".Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
A genuinely awful footballer.
don’t want to buy his signed framed shirt :) I think it was his i received just before “that” final that shall remain unspoken.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
There's times I read stuff on here and think my memory must be shot to hell, nothing here for me but fond memories of Rob Jones.Quote:
Originally Posted by Se7enUp
Quite enjoyed this despite the negative connotations.
Here goes…
Graeme Smith
Alan Marbury
Ryan McGivern
Shelton Martis
Matt Docherty
Kris Commons
John Rankin
Kevin Thomson
Alan O’Brian
Rowan Vine
Kevin Nisbet
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yeah only made the ten appearances for us must have been the two wins against Aberdeen and Kilmarnock a win against Dunfermline a draw versus Motherwell not forgetting the double he scored away at Rugby Park in a 3-1 win clouding my judgementQuote:
Originally Posted by Jones28
Anyone that makes 160 appearances for Crystal Palace isn’t sh#t
All about opinions though but worse chicken hearted players are Greg Docherty and Brandon Barker imo
Tom Soares had something about him
1-5 wasn’t great but wasn’t alone
Now Owain Tudur Jones I dislike
Quote:
Originally Posted by Se7enUp
He also captained us to a League Cup win, if that counts for anything?
I agree that his form did dip a lot after that though.
That Lithuanian striker we had. Big Dave. Not so much a dislike just pretty anonymous.
He wasn't awful, he'd had a decent career but he was done as a player when we signed him. Poor recruitment and there was plenty of it in that period.Quote:
Originally Posted by Thatdayinmay16
Haven't read the whole thread but Michael Hart has to be in there, as hopeless a right back as you'll see.
I actually agree with him. Blunders against Hearts aside, he was OK. Definitely better than Simon Brown and Bursik. That's actually what makes it all the more suspicious. Most of his blunders came against the one club.Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomtownHibees
Tbf, I didn't say he was **** :greengrinQuote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Maybe it's the cup final with no name result clouding my judgement but I remember nothing positive about him.
Labelling Barker the same as those two is very harsh. He had some real flashes of quality and played his part in some great results that got us a 4th placed finish.
During his time at hibs he was awful.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hiber-nation
We've had many a player who didn't look the part and either succeeded after leaving us or had a decent career prior.
Yup, that’s how I remember him.Quote:
Originally Posted by overdrive
Fully aware you can’t just erase the mistakes :greengrin but as you say, against everyone except hearts he was absolutely fine imo.
I reckon I’d be an awrite goalie as well if you forgot about the mistakes I’d makeQuote:
Originally Posted by overdrive
Makalambay (the regular feigning injury after a blunder)
Doherty (the post-cup final interview, the interview on joining the club where he clearly thought he had signed for Hearts, his face).
Caldwell (didn't mind him during his first stint, just couldn't take to him in the second)
McGivern (see Caldwell but with a tenth of the ability)
Demetri Mitchell (don't think he wanted to be here and a sick-note)
Hartley (nothing to write home about for us, outstanding for the Poppy Thieves)
Wilkins (just why)
Rankin (just can't take to him)
McGeady (see Mitchell)
Vine (so poor for a player who had gone for big money in the past, stupid beard)
Collins (useless - has come onto a game since)
Manager: Caldwerood (I hate him way more than Butcher. At least Butcher came across like he wanted the job and wasn't disrespectful towards us)
Assistant Manager: Billy Brown (Hearts fud. "Uhve been places, uhve dun things, my wife works", related to someone I worked with that I wasn't fond of).
Not sure why so many are including Maybury? I always thought he ranged from mediocre to okay, certainly not one of the worst.
I took the original question to be players you just didn’t like for some reason, not just who’s been the worstQuote:
Originally Posted by Saint Hibee
Barker’s debut he shat a 50-50 right in front of me he got so much abuse from the punters he knew never to do that again in a Hibs jerseyQuote:
Originally Posted by Jones28
Greg Docherty was great for us but he didn’t fancy it against the Hearts even less so against the Sheep in his last two games
I want all players to do well playing for us the ones I truly dislike are the non triers and the utterly hopeless
Quite enjoyed this despite the negative connotations.
Here goes…
Graeme Smith
Alan Marbury
Ryan McGivern
Gary Caldwell
Matt Docherty
Kris Commons
John Rankin
Kevin Thomson
Alan O’Brian
Rowan Vine
Kevin Nisbet
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Would take a fully focused Kevin Nisbet in a heartbeatQuote:
Originally Posted by TelaStella
Tudor Jones and Nelson should feature in every team, words can't describe how bad they were.
He wasn’t awful not great but many can be called awful before himQuote:
Originally Posted by Thatdayinmay16
P 13 W 6 D 1 L 6 in a poor Hibs side
Scored 2 in a 3-1 win away to Killie
Mark Brown
Sean O’Hanlon
George Francomb
Martin Scott
Matt Doherty
Pa Kujabi
Roy O’Donovan
Richie Towell
All played for Hibs at the same time as Tom Soares and in my opinion contributed less at that time to the Hibs cause than Tom Soares
Was MOTM in our relegation decider against Dunfermline was signed because he was better than what we had at the time
Started in 1-5 before Spoonie ?????
This sums it up Still say he had quality just didn’t show it often enough
https://www.hibs.net/showthread.php?...m-Soares/page2
I have no recollection of Scott Martin at all lol.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Are you talking about Martin (Jimmy) Scott? Assaulted Sean Welsh maybe?Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Yip Sorry my mistakeQuote:
Originally Posted by HoboHarry
All good 👍 I looked up Scott Martin and I remember now, according to Wiki he came through our youth system and played 9 times before being loaned out then sold.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Yip was a few years later small pocket battleship of a midfielder think he ended up at HamiltonQuote:
Originally Posted by HoboHarry
List take two
Mark Oxley
Michael hart
Danny swanson
David Stephens
Matt Thornhill
Alan gow
Daryl Duffy
David Van zanten
Quote:
Originally Posted by Paulie Walnuts
Echoes of the old gag there - Apart from that Mrs Lincoln, did you enjoy the play?
Liam Craig, epitomised that team. Heart of a mouse
Nonsense imoQuote:
Originally Posted by CallumHibs07
I liked him as a player. Stand out game was when we spanked the buns 4-0.Quote:
Originally Posted by CallumHibs07
Dearie me !Quote:
Originally Posted by CallumHibs07
This thread is rapidly going downhill
A Club Captain with a heart of a mouse ?
Always gave 100% never hid the guy was a gentleman and put in a shift as club captain well above expectations never failing to miss any commitments
Scored a memorable goal against the Hun in the 4-0 plus two assists
Things didn’t work out for him at Hibs for whatever reason but went on to win a Scottish Cup and a League Cup
Glad to have him back in a coaching role still has the desire for the club
Picked up 16 yellows always fighting our corner constantly in the Referees ear doing a Graeme Shinnie
12 goals in 74 appearances no bad from midfield
Scored a winner against the Hearts a late penalty his chicken heart stood up to the pressure
I've honestly never understood the hate Craig gets from some.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
This thread in general, and I know everyone is different. But i’ll never dislike a player just because they're *****, it’s not the players fault we signed and played them.
It’s why I've only piped up about McGeady, I just don't like the guy! Nothing to do with his ability, he was a brilliant player.
Guy did have an attitude but was unplayable when on it must have been some player in his primeQuote:
Originally Posted by JohnM1875
Opinions eh..Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
I think he hid all the time.
Aw well here’s some moreQuote:
Originally Posted by CallumHibs07
https://www.hibs.net/showthread.php?370019-Liam-Craig
He signed some autographs for some kids? :faf:Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Wow, groundbreaking stuff.
I'd rather he didn't captain us to a relegation but each to their own
He had us safe until Butcher arrived and told the senior pros their services were no longer required in the January :confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by CallumHibs07
Talk about shooting yourself in the foot ?
https://i.ibb.co/DgrYBrtZ/98-E790-D0...-F3-BCE0-D.jpg
Same here and your right he was excellent in that game .Quote:
Originally Posted by ChicoM1875
One goal two assists but he hid ? :confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by Donegal Hibby
Hard to try and figure that one out alright 😂Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Yeah !Quote:
Originally Posted by Donegal Hibby
‘ All the time ‘
Matt Doherty is my most all time hated hibs player. My ideal scenario is for celtic to sign him and we can all unleash on that little fanny.
No such thing as a disliked Hibs team, a lot of players and managers may have let the side down but disliked Hibs team nae, never.
2nd thoughts and by no means an exhaustive list it would need to start with the 2 from the huns Ally Scott and Fyfie, backed up by Jim Blair, disappointing but still Hibs players.
I never had a dislike towards Liam Craig but I do think he should have stepped up as captain in the shoot out v Hamilton and not left it to a 19 year old laddie to take the final kick (Butcher was at fault for that too btw).
Matt Docherty was a decent player whos gone on to do well but his attitude stank and he showed a disgusting level of disrespect to the fans after the 2012 final.
lol as I said the guy in terms of football is a Hibs legend and his name will be spoken for generations to come in regards to that final. He gave me one of the greatest days of my life and I'm forever grateful for that but as a human being the guy is an absolute welt who thinks he's bigger and better than what he is. Arrogant and generally seems a very dislikable character.Quote:
Originally Posted by JimBHibees
Quote:
Originally Posted by 21.05.2016
I agree with you, not a person I’d wish to spend time with. Was apparently an ******** the first time he was here, second time he wasn’t amazing (nor bad either) except for a standout performance for the ages in the final, then acted like a welt the third time round