Hearts v Hibs

[greenlex]

Surely as clear a booking as you'll ever see?
As stick a yellow as you’ll see.

[Iain G]

Fallen apart since the goal.

We really haven't, what are you watching?

[ElginHibee]

Can we get a bit more context

Fish took the freekick.... straight to the Hibs dugout.

[HibeesGal]

Celtic 5 nil up against Dundee now

[SerenityGreen]

Vente has done some amount of running so far

good stuff, he always does, which is great to see in a forward, defend from the front.

[CentreLine]

Where his ****ing yellow?

Quickl to book Rocky for something nobody else saw. That was as clear a yellow A you’ll see but no card. One day it will be evened up apparently. God help the team we’re playing that day.

[cubehindthegoal]

My wee pep talk with him worked I see. :greengrin

😁

[Fuzzywuzzy]

Can we get a bit more context

Free kick to us and booted straight across the pitch for a shy to them

[Dmas]

These decisions are why you end up thinking it’s a different rule book for us, on what planet was that not a yellow card

[staunchhibby]

Deliberate foul from cochineal should have been booked

[hibsbollah]

As stick a yellow as you’ll see.

Boyle must be the most fouled player weve ever had.

[Joe6-2]

When even the sportsound flumps say thats a booking for a hearts player, thats a definite booking.

I’m getting pissed off big time with the blatant cheating of our hopeless referees

[greenlex]

Can we get a bit more context
Tried to play a diagonal free kick. Scuffed it miles from target and out for a throw at the half way line.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

We need to get a hold of the ball again. Gar better attacking than just sitting in

[One Day Soon]

Deliberate foul from cochineal should have been booked

Cochineal? Should he have seen red?

[VoltaireHibs]

Ffs

[hibsbollah]

Penalty hearts

[Stuart93]

Hopefully no sucker punch before ht

Aw ffs

[cabbageandribs1875]

fish gives away the penalty

varga snipered

[USA_Hibee]

Of course it's a penalty.

[hibsbollah]

Var misery now.

[hibee_girl]

That's never a penalty

[Onceinawhile]

Ffs penalty hearts.

Will fish disaster class.

[GreenCastle]

That’s never a pen

[hibsbollah]

Even brian says no pen.

[ElginHibee]

Surely not confirmed.

[-Jonesy-]

Will fish that’s absolutely horrendous

[Moulin Yarns]

Feckiin penalty to them

[Callum_62]

That has to be overturned and a booking for Vargas surely

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[Stuart93]

They always seem to get a pen when they’re struggling

Annoying we couldn’t have seen this out until ht

[Onceinawhile]

Total dive

[NC1875]

That’s a dive 100%

[Gatecrasher]

The first one was a pen imo, the second one isn't.

[GreenCastle]

2 dives from the yams

[hibsbollah]

Look at the monitor now

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Never a pen ffs

[Trinity Hibee]

Fish did not touch him but that horrible touch created the problem. Just get rid. Fish and Rocky are not CBs I’m afraid. Far too many basic errors

[OtleyHibs]

Neither are pens for me

[007]

We don't get decisions in our favour like this.

[Stuart93]

Let’s see if var finally works in our favour

[we are hibs]

Fish has been poor again so far. Such a woeful touch.

[hibsbollah]

Cheat. Unbelievable.

[One Day Soon]

I’ll be astonished if he doesn’t give it. Not because it’s a pen but because Hibs.

[jeffers]

Absolute dive. There was contact but that’s never enough to award a penalty.

[CMac1988]

This **** will be desperate to stick to his decision.

[VoltaireHibs]

That’s a dive 100%

Boyle does that we know the outcome.

[cabbageandribs1875]

i'll be surprised if this is overturned

[-Jonesy-]

What’s fish thinking there dallying on the ball in the box with a man haring in at him

[JJP]

Is VAR going to help us out here?

[greenlex]

Never. A penalty in a million years.

[OtleyHibs]

Going to monitor

[Onceinawhile]

Come on ref.

[Kentao1985]

Never a pen, if it's given I'm finished with Scottish football

Sent from my moto g32 using Tapatalk

[Moulin Yarns]

Radio not convinced that either is a penalty

[Vault Boy]

****ing typical

[JJP]

What a joke.

[ElginHibee]

Absolute ****ing joke! Never a pen.

[lyonhibs]

That was never getting reversed

[Northernhibee]

Cheats.

[we are hibs]

Clancy is a cheat. Been proven on countless occasions against Hibs. He shouldnt be allowed to referee Hibs games

[Torto7]

Another fud ref. Why even bother turning up?

[cabbageandribs1875]

i feel fish knew what he was doing bumping into him with his lower body

[jeffers]

****** cheat.

[GreenCastle]

Game is ****ed

So corrupt

[HFC 0-7]

Games ****ed now. Never a penalty.

[hibee_girl]

He was never changing his mind.

Even though its the wrong decision

[-Jonesy-]

****ing joke what’s the point of var

[One Day Soon]

****ing outrageous. If he’d been right they’d never have called him over. Cheating goat ****ers.

[jamie_1875]

I can't believe what I just saw.

[Mon Dieu4]

More of a dive than anything Boyle gets abused about every ****ing week

[Onceinawhile]

Unreal.

[J-C]

They're saying the 1st challenge is a pen and the 2nd isn't.

[HH81]

Sticking with it and couldn't wait to give it originally.

Cheat.

[Gatecrasher]

Never a pen.

[Callum_62]

Honestly Scottish referring is an absolute disgrace

How the **** has he stuck with that

Ridiculous

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[Hibs4185]

Surprise surprise, the only time the red goes against the VAR is against us

[Iain G]

Cheating ****

[Stuart93]

Why does VAR always go against us

[GreenCastle]

**** VAR and Scottish Football

Absolute disgrace

[007]

Flung himself to the ground.

[Bakerman]

Clancy Cheat

[SHODAN]

**** you **** you **** you **** you ****ing corrupt ****ing twat

[USA_Hibee]

Even on sky they said it's never a penalty.

Mental.

[Scottie]

fish knew what he was doing bumping into him with his lower body
******g idiot when will we ever learn

[staunchhibby]

A dive by varga

[Stuart93]

There’s no point in football anymore

VAR’s ruined it completely

[HFC 0-7]

Absolute ********s throwing stuff on the pitch.

[cabbageandribs1875]

look at vargas giving the punch salute to the roseburn


t*tface

[MWHIBBIES]

I can't believe that's been given. Absolutely unreal. Neither was a foul.

[Torto7]

We shouldn't bother coming out second half the whole game is rigged up here.

[Forever_Green93]

Thats never a pen in a million years!

**** off!

[GreenCastle]

That would never be given in an old firm game.

Jammiest team in the world - been dominated by Hibs this half and given a penalty which was a massive dive.

[-Jonesy-]

Will the SFA be apologising to us again

[One Day Soon]

No one commentating thinks that’s a pen. None of them, including Preston.

[VoltaireHibs]

Clancy's ego was never going to be wrong.

[NC1875]

That’s a ****ing disgrace by the way

[Northernhibee]

Clancy is a cheating ****bag. Confirmed on the radio it was the challenge he gave the penalty for he viewed on VAR. Utter ****ing prick.

[Ozyhibby]

Absolutely ******** ***** from Will Fish.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Johnny_Leith]

Disgraceful decision. What's the point in VAR?

[Bostonhibby]

We've been Clancy'd again.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[Stuart93]

We’re getting cheated every week

[dp00]

Even hearts tv saying that’s not a pen… that tells you everything


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ChicoM1875]

3 games in a row we've had awful decisions. Can't be a coincidence

[Unseen work]

Pen or not that’s awful from Fish.

[EdinMike]

We seem to give away a penalty every other week…

[GreenCastle]

Miller is a weakness in this team - just not at the level of others.

Nearly 2-1 Hibs - great save

[Joe6-2]

There’s no point in football anymore

VAR’s ruined it completely

It’s the *** cheating refs that are ruining it, VAR should have improved things

[Smartie]

It's an absolute f*****g scandal that that **** gets another chance to look at that decision and still sticks with it.

Despicable decision and demonstrates a total lack of understanding of the rules of the game.

There is contact - but totally insufficient in a CONTACT SPORT to be classed as any sort of foul that merits the reaction from the Hearts player. If that is a foul then there should be a dozen penalties every game.

These clowns are killing the game.

[Stuart93]

SFA trying to make an example of us

[MrRobot]

we’re a ****ing joke.

i know that’s never a penalty but we are all over them until we score and let them attack us like **** until they score.

[blackpoolhibs]

What is the ****ing point anymore?

[MWHIBBIES]

There’s no point in football anymore

VAR’s ruined it completely

The ref gave it. Var recommeded a second look. He gave it again. Absolutely nothing wrong with var here. The ref is the idiot.

[Scottie]

The club need to grow a pair and call this cheat out. That’s another scandalous decision against us

[JohnM1875]

That only happens to us. ****ing ridiculous decision for the pen

[greenlex]

As sickening as that is Will Fish needs to keep himself switched on. He was in control there.

[J-C]

Now saying on radio that Clancy only looked at the 2nd challenge and all the commentators saying it wasn't a penalty, corruption or just poor refereeing, you decide.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Great save clark!!

[HendoDelivered]

I think I am done with football after that one. Sickened!!!

[VoltaireHibs]

Disgraceful decision. What's the point in VAR?

In fairness to VAR, they tried to get Clancy to rethink his decision. Clancy couldn't allow himself to be wrong. Absolute clown of a man.

[SHODAN]

And of course we've had about 5 shots cleared off the line

[CMac1988]

3 games in a row we've had awful decisions. Can't be a coincidence

Don't want to be the team who puts pressure on refs though. Too classy for that... How's that working for us?

[LunasBoots]

Clancy never gives us anything, been evident down the years

[Onceinawhile]

Good save their keeper then one off the line an aw.

[neil7908]

There’s no point in football anymore

VAR’s ruined it completely

I'm honestly ready to give up.

Why spend hundreds of pounds a year to take part in a rigged game?

[Stuart93]

The ref gave it. Var recommeded a second look. He gave it again. Absolutely nothing wrong with var here. The ref is the idiot.

So it’s completely pointless then

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

And another cleared off the line!!

[MrSmith]

That referee should be hounded off the pitch by our players and it is now time for our owners to call this out! Clancy needs sacked, again he has cheated us and should not get away with it this time. He should not get the second half! Cheating ****!

[007]

A dive by varga

10 times worse than anything Boyle's ever done.

[Scooter]

How the hearts boys not been booked for diving I'll never know

[Ray Donovan]

Disgusting penalty decision. What chance you got.

[Hibeesdaft16]

That is genuinely a ****ing joke. Clancy is giving them everything and now that.

[MrRobot]

Miller is a weakness in this team - just not at the level of others.

Nearly 2-1 Hibs - great save

:confused:

what has he done wrong?

[Onceinawhile]

Just hit the deck every time someone is near you. Guaranteed free kick / penalty.

[Torto7]

Clancy is a *****bag and their fans are greasy dirty tramps trying to intimidate refs and players.

[ElginHibee]

In fairness to VAR, they tried to get Clancy to rethink his decision. Clancy couldn't allow himself to be wrong. Absolute clown of a man.

Absolutely, VAR actually did what they were supposed to do there.... the ref is the problem.

[HIBERNIAN-0762]

Cheating diving ******* 😡

[cubehindthegoal]

Clancy is a cheating ****bag. Confirmed on the radio it was the challenge he gave the penalty for he viewed on VAR. Utter ****ing prick.

We need to challenge that again … evidence is there on the radio he has “got it wrong”.

[GreenCastle]

It’s the *** cheating refs that are ruining it, VAR should have improved things

Clancy had a chance to correct his poor decision
And then even bottled that.

About time Hibs called out the fan behaviour at Tynecastle too - dans getting touched every time they take a throw or corner.

[Smartie]

Pen or not that’s awful from Fish.

A fair point, which will probably get a bit lost amongst the understandable anger.

[Northernhibee]

Just hit the deck every time someone is near you. Guaranteed free kick / penalty.

Not if you’re in a Hibs shirt.

[The Modfather]

That’s unbelievable it was given. The foot that wasn’t touched is the one that crumpled.

Saying all that I’ll be glad to see the back of Fish in the summer. Yet another schoolboy error.

Can play say so well this half but go in level because our defenders aren’t good enough. Feel sorry for Montgomery with the defence he inherited.

[Calidad]

Pen or not that’s awful from Fish.

Agreed.

[neil7908]

And of course we've had about 5 shots cleared off the line

We've seen this a thousand times. Hibs play well but can't take their chances. They get a dodgy penalty and then sclaff in a late minute winner completely against the run of play.

[cabbageandribs1875]

was it clancy that gave a penalty to falkirk at ER yonks ago

or something else

cany mind

[Golden Bear]

Ridiculous penalty but yet again we went on the back foot after scoring. It only invites pressure.

[jeffers]

Pen or not that’s awful from Fish.

Absolutely. Fish gave that diving wee prick the opportunity.

[Hibs4185]

These *unts are always the luckies *unts alive.


Dodgy penalty, good save and a clearance of the line.

Still confident we will win but I hope the players use the injustice to fire themselves up at half time

[Kato]

We're paranoid though.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[hibsbollah]

I dont know what we do about this anymore.

[JohnM1875]

Get Rocky off man.

[FastEddieFelson]

Surely var did it's job there? That's just pure incompetence from Clancy

[Just_Jimmy]

What is the ****ing point anymore?There's none. No amount of money or investment matters. Scottish football is bent.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

[Silky]

we’re a ****ing joke.

I know. Chucking a pyro on after Emi's goal absolutely killed the momentum.

[Murphys Touch]

Pen or not that’s awful from Fish.

Blasted a free kick into dug outs a few mins before and then does that. Edinburgh derby and trying to take a touch in the box....a hopeless touch at that!

For the abuse Rocky gets....this boy costs us just as much

[King conrad]

Penalty or not Will Fish with sunday amateur defending, He has to do better

[Nicho87]

The way he gave it - I just knew he wasn’t going to change his mind

He wanted to give it

Least the sfa can just copy and paste the apology email

[SHODAN]

Don't bring the team back out. ****ing call this charade for what it is.

[blackpoolhibs]

Just make Clancy full time, that will sort it.:rolleyes:

[Stuart93]

Scottish fitbaws absolute ***** now. Referees ruining games left right n centre every week

[staunchhibby]

No chance with glance and muir on var

[HH81]

Hearts tv laughing saying jt was an awful decision.

[Iain G]

Better team first half, only a clearly arrogant or corrupt refereeing decision means we are not ahead.

[lyonhibs]

Agreed.

Yup. Murder touch in his own box just before half time.

[hibsbollah]

That’s unbelievable it was given. The foot that wasn’t touched is the one that crumpled.

Saying all that I’ll be glad to see the back of Fish in the summer. Yet another schoolboy error.

Can play say so well this half but go in level because our defenders aren’t good enough. Feel sorry for Montgomery with the defence he inherited.

:agree: Monty has done a great job today. Has them playing tremendously well.

[EGL2000]

Freighting that a ref gets a second look and that and still thinks it's a penalty. As much as I hate VAR it's done it's job there. Never a pen!

[Bakerman]

If that had been Boyle, it would have been turned down, and Boyle called a cheat. That was never a penalty.

[hfc-1875]

That is a disgrace the decision. That being said fish should have just lumped it up the park, get in at half time 1 up.

We sat far too deep inviting them onto us after the goal then start playing again after they score.

[Callum_62]

It's up there with honestly one of the most ridiculous decisions I've seen (again) after watching it on replay on a TV screen

Absolutely scandalous to watch that and stick with the penalty decision

Understandable giving it live as it could look like fish went through him but to watch it on replay and stick with it is a complete joke

We should be full on rangers on this

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[cubehindthegoal]

Those that threw stuff on .. hope you realise you’ve just gave them an excuse to deflect from the truth of the penalty. Well done guys

… ps already the radio commentators are jumping on it, from the moment you did it. Yes it’s annoying it’s the usual hearts bbc worker/fan doing it, but we need to do ourselves some favours when we are up against being discriminated against

[HH81]

If that had been Boyle, it would have been turned down, and Boyle called a cheat. That was never a penalty.

He'd have been booked too.

[Tricla]

Absolute joke. Our game is totally knackered.

[Golden Bear]

Get Rocky off man.

Eh???

[Stuart93]

A dodgy pen for them and a few cleared off the line

It’s got a ****ing hearts win all over it, horrible

[GreenCastle]

Don't want to be the team who puts pressure on refs though. Too classy for that... How's that working for us?

The club needs to grow a backbone and continue to call out these dodgy / awful decisions and continued sectarian singing at ER by Old Firm.

[lyonhibs]

No chance with glance and muir on var

VAR told the ref to look at it again. The ref stuck with his original decision.

VAR for once was not the issue here.

[Since90+2]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.

[Heisenberg]

Are we still lucky to have Will Fish? ****ing rotten and costs us nearly every week.

[MKHIBEE]

The game is being ruined by cheats. I’m out

[Unseen work]

Rocky being on a booking makes me nervous - can’t help but feel Hearts will get him send off with Shankland and Vargas antics.

From a Hibs point of view we need to get Maolida on the ball more

[Iain G]

Yup. Murder touch in his own box just before half time.

It was like having Porto back! But it was never a Bloody foul

[MagicSwirlingShip]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.

Takes a better touch there’s no penalty shout

[high bee]

What an absolute embarrassment this is, every VAR decision seems to be worse than the last. The hertz guy should’ve been booked for diving let alone giving them a penalty. I honestly despair at the officiating in this country, it’s surely too bad to just be incompetent?

[Tambo]

Surely var did it's job there? That's just pure incompetence from Clancy

Looks that way, even the hearts main commentator thought it wasn't a penalty.

Very frustrating way to end a decent first half, Fish is a bit reckless with a heavy touch but still never a penalty, a couple of chances right at the end to make it 1-2.

[Callum_62]

Are we still lucky to have Will Fish? ****ing rotten and costs us nearly every week.He literally took 1 bad touch but rectified him mistake by not diving in

It's the ref (again) that's done is so far

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[JohnM1875]

Eh???

He’s not had a great first half there. Booked for **** all mind you, but keeps letting the ball bounce.

My comment was pretty reactionary to the panic clearance before half time.

[MrRobot]

I know. Chucking a pyro on after Emi's goal absolutely killed the momentum.

100% mate; agree with that.

I dunno why we didn’t go for the second though, we just tried to soak up the pressure when our defence is utterly pathetic.

[21.05.2016]

Tells you all you need to know when even HeartsTV guys are saying it was dramatic and they’d be raging if that had been given against them. They were expecting it to be overturned.

Clancy cheating *******, absolutely desperate to give it. Absolutely SHOCKING decision.

[Not In The Know]

Get the team on the bus and head home. Make a stand **** the points.

[Helensburghhibs]

People jumping on our player need to give their heads a wobble. He made a mistake then pulled out the challenge. There was no foul, this one is squarely on the sfa,, cheats through and through

[Unseen work]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.

Fish someone allowed it to become a chance for Vargas. I don’t know if he was waiting for a foul to be given on the challenge just before, but he is dallying on the ball in the box and actually gives away a pen from pulling out. If he just went through the ball and Vargas there is probably no pen.

It’s really poor from him

[Bakerman]

Sickening what so called referees get away with in Scotland. There was a tiny bit of contact, and he dived like a fish. We would never have got that.

[Jack Hackett]

No chance with glance and muir on var

tbf... they handed it back to Clancy... who made his mind up before he watched the replays

[Iain G]

What an absolute embarrassment this is, every VAR decision seems to be worse than the last. The hertz guy should’ve been booked for diving let alone giving them a penalty. I honestly despair at the officiating in this country, it’s surely too bad to just be incompetent?

As noted above, VAR did it's job and told the ref to view it again, he chose to ignore the evidence and stick to his original decision

[GreenCastle]

If that had been Boyle, it would have been turned down, and Boyle called a cheat. That was never a penalty.

That’s a fair point…

Hibs were the better team in that half - scored - off the line - good save by Clark - Hearts weren’t in it until that decision by the clown Muir.

Honestly couldn’t name 1 decent ref in Scotland - they are all absolutely awful and ruin the game nearly every week.

Another derby when we have been screwed over by a shambles decision.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Vargas is a little woos

[Broxburn Greens]

Fish is too busy looking the other way and then airballs the clearance, really poor.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[CentreForward]

Clancy had a chance to correct his poor decision
And then even bottled that.

About time Hibs called out the fan behaviour at Tynecastle too - dans getting touched every time they take a throw or corner.

It’s our own fans who should surely be looked at. Dozens of missiles raining down on Shankland when he took the penalty some of which hit Marshall.

[Since90+2]

Takes a better touch there’s no penalty shout

Defenders take bad touches all the time. He's done the right thing and pulled out the challenge.

[HarpOnHibee]

Just honest "incompetence" though. :whistle:

[Ronniekirk]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.
Agree wasn’t a pen but he lost control of the ball in the first place , which then led to the incident that led to pen being given

[lyonhibs]

It was like having Porto back! But it was never a Bloody foul

There shouldn't have been a contestable ball for Vargas to get near in the first place. Entirely avoidable.

[1875M]

People jumping on our player need to give their heads a wobble. He made a mistake then pulled out the challenge. There was no foul, this one is squarely on the sfa,, cheats through and through

It’s not a foul but he’s put himself in a stupid position for a foul to be given by not concentrating and defending like a schoolboy. Horrific from Fish whether it’s a foul or not.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Clancy didn't want to admit he got it wrong

[Hibees1973]

Better team in the 1st half without a doubt.

Difficult though to win a game against an opposition of 12.

Aberdeen and now this.

Sickening.

[Bakerman]

Get the team on the bus and head home. Make a stand **** the points.

Its getting closer to that point evermore. Take the players off the pitch. The ref's a bogey.

[Rumble de Thump]

Hearts have been massively helped by the officials every step of the way so far this season. It's absolutely no surprise it's happened again.

[Hibee Mac]

I'm close to calling it a day with modern football. Honestly that is a disgusting decision, absolutely scandalous.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

[Greensunshine]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.

He’s guilty of switching off in his own box, I think he takes a big chunk of the blame!

Not only that moments earlier he took a free kick and passed it straight out of play! You really couldn’t make it up!

[The Modfather]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.

It’s horrendous defending from Fish either way.

[JHFC]

I think I am done with football after that one. Sickened!!!

That's how I'm feeling. What is the f*****g point? Let's be serious.

[GreenCastle]

It’s our own fans who should surely be looked at. Dozens of missiles raining down on Shankland when he took the penalty some of which hit Marshall.

I’m surprised fans didn’t run onto the pitch after that awful decision.

[Since90+2]

Fish someone allowed it to become a chance for Vargas. I don’t know if he was waiting for a foul to be given on the challenge just before, but he is dallying on the ball in the box and actually gives away a pen from pulling out. If he just went through the ball and Vargas there is probably no pen.

It’s really poor from him

He made an initial mistake and then pulled out the challenge correctly. If the ref doesn't **** us nobody blinks an eye

FFS we've been done. Folk are way to quick to turn on our own.

[Hibee Daft]

Even hearts commentary saying it wasnt a penalty

[HH81]

Clancy didn't want to admit he got it wrong

Hibs need to call it out. Send the goalie coach out to the interview and call the ref what he is.

[MrRobot]

Those that threw stuff on .. hope you realise you’ve just gave them an excuse to deflect from the truth of the penalty. Well done guys

… ps already the radio commentators are jumping on it, from the moment you did it. Yes it’s annoying it’s the usual hearts bbc worker/fan doing it, but we need to do ourselves some favours when we are up against being discriminated against

what difference would it make? it’s stupid throwing stuff on but nothing is going to change these ****ing shambllic decisions from these utterly incompetent and pathetic officials that are ruining our game. they are an absolute joke ruining scottish football.

[HH81]

Even hearts commentary saying it was a penalty

No they said it wasn't. They were laughing it was given.

[thebausburst]

Fish was distracted checking if a pen was being given against Miller, that delay caused the contact that led to the pen, albeit it shouldn’t have been given.

[Crab apple]

That is a ****ing disgraceful decision. VAR did its job. Clancy is a cheat. He’s done us before in a derby. He’s a **** ref but this is more than incompetence.

[Waxy]

I hope the black knights realise the prejudices we are up against here.

[Tricla]

Fish is too busy looking the other way and then airballs the clearance, really poor.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Not. He was looking upfield and never saw Vargas initially. When he noticed him me pulled out of the challenge, there was a brushing, and the wee cheat dived. Then the cheating ref took over. Not sure what you were watching.

[OtleyHibs]

It's a poor touch, that being said he did recover it cos that was never a penalty so were not level due to Fish for me, that's on Clueless Clancy

We are the better team, couple of decent efforts near the end of the half.

Keep the heads and we can batter them second half

[hibee-boys]

When I seen the replay I was 100% certain it would be checked and overturned. Don’t think I’m being over dramatic to say that decisions like these are really questioning why I should bother paying money to travel to games and buy tickets, sick to death of putting up with this blatant cheating.

[Smartie]

People jumping on our player need to give their heads a wobble. He made a mistake then pulled out the challenge. There was no foul, this one is squarely on the sfa,, cheats through and through

The decision to take a touch rather than launch it is poor, then the touch being heavy is equally poor.

No, it's not a penalty, but the fact that there's a decision to be made rather than the ball being somewhere over the Wheatfield is on Fish.

Sorry.

[cubehindthegoal]

He'd have been booked too.

yup … it’s incessant now .. as does our retort to it as a club have to be … but unfortunately it’s so easy in Scottish football to plead “conspiracy theorist” against those who see what’s clear as day … let’s face it, we see that here in this forum … so what chance does the club have, if we don’t back it.

[GreenCastle]

Clancy didn't want to admit he got it wrong

Exactly - makes him look a bad ref to change his mind.

I think it’s worse he’s made the decision live then looked at it again and still not realised it’s a dive.

[Broxburn Greens]

The refereeing is just cheating though, despite the ***** clearance it’s never a penalty.

Borderline cheating…

But we’ll just take it again with our spineless board of directors sitting on their hands.

Looked pretty comfortable even being under a bit of pressure but then the helping hand comes out for them.

Was really confident we’d win especially when we scored, now think we’ll lose…. Ah well another £50 I’ll no see again.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[hibsbollah]

Hibs need to call it out. Send the goalie coach out to the interview and call the ref what he is.

Im afraid we’ll do our usual ‘unfortunate decision’ ‘we dont think it was a penalty’

[Unseen work]

Defenders take bad touches all the time. He's done the right thing and pulled out the challenge.

He just misses the ball more than properly pulling out

https://x.com/parry187507/status/1762939454208037229?s=46&t=jmxs-mZWT_cnYbURW-GKJw

[ChuckNor]

We need to call this out. Honestly referees in this country are out to get us and no one can convince me otherwise.

[Kentao1985]

Another apology incoming from the SFA, not 1 person has thought it was a pen, hearts TV couldn't believe it was given. Tells it's own story.

Rocky booked for bumping 5head of the ball. Alex cockring just spoken to after smashing Boyle.

Hearts are getting free kicks for minimal or no contact and we get nothing from Clancy the chest.

Sent from my moto g32 using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

Hibs need to call it out. Send the goalie coach out to the interview and call the ref what he is.


you jest :greengrin took them long enough to finally say something about the flares etc




then over to our own fans tonight :(

[high bee]

As noted above, VAR did it's job and told the ref to view it again, he chose to ignore the evidence and stick to his original decision

Yeah you’re right. It’s just disheartening that even with the video replays the game is still a bogey. There’s been a few decisions this year where I’ve expected to to get overturned and VAR has reviewed it and said no case to answer, this one is worse in that he actually did get told to check and still stood by it.

[CentreLine]

Can’t let the half time go without mention how unacceptable some of our fans have been. Flare on the park then a disgraceful barrage of missiles thrown.
Why?

[Ozyhibby]

Let's not blame fish FFS. That's one of the worst decisions I've seen. It's actually embarrassing.

Crap decision but horrific defending from Will Fish again at Tynecastle. [emoji35]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[WhileTheChief..]

One of these days VAR will get to right when we're playing. I mean, they can't always get it so wrong, can they?

[staunchhibby]

Why was shankland not booked after penalty for his gestures to hibs supporters

[Bakerman]

He'd have been booked too.

:agree:

Very likely to have been. Its beyond ridiculous now. As some have said we should just pack the kit bags, and get the bus back to ER. The games snookered with those referees.

[Broxburn Greens]

That's how I'm feeling. What is the f*****g point? Let's be serious.

Yup, starting to feel the same, better things to do than watch my team cheated by the officials week in week out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Trinity Hibee]

Can’t let the half time go without mention how unacceptable some of our fans have been. Flare on the park then a disgraceful barrage of missiles thrown.
Why?

Cos folk are boozed up and think they are entitled to do what they like

[Waxy]

I'm close to calling it a day with modern football. Honestly that is a disgusting decision, absolutely scandalous.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Spot on. Thousands have been lost to this over the years.Hearts play with twelvemen every derby.
Time to bring in impartial officials before its too late.

[givescotlandfreedom]

It's every game now. What's the point?

[Manxhibs]

Think it’s the case Clancy didn’t want to admit he was wrong. Now he looks an even greater plum for not overturning it. Of course, as usual, we are on the other end of it.

Keep thinking we are due one as it normally balances out. Just seems it’s going to be a weekly occurrence. Not sure what we can do to stop this, as even speaking out hasn’t helped.

[Tricla]

Another apology incoming from the SFA, not 1 person has thought it was a pen, hearts TV couldn't believe it was given. Tells it's own story.

Rocky booked for bumping 5head of the ball. Alex cockring just spoken to after smashing Boyle.

Hearts are getting free kicks for minimal or no contact and we get nothing from Clancy the chest.

Sent from my moto g32 using Tapatalk

Alex Cockring! 😂

[Kato]

Surely var did it's job there? That's just pure incompetence from ClancyPure incompetentence? Its simply not.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[cubehindthegoal]

The decision to take a touch rather than launch it is poor, then the touch being heavy is equally poor.

No, it's not a penalty, but the fact that there's a decision to be made rather than the ball being somewhere over the Wheatfield is on Fish.

Sorry.

… and this is why … when we make apologies for their wrong decisions … that the club isn’t ever going to be able to change it … your comment bows to a wrong decision - again - against us.

[Trinity Hibee]

I'm close to calling it a day with modern football. Honestly that is a disgusting decision, absolutely scandalous.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

It’s bad enough when you are watching as a neutral but for that to happen in a derby we had been doing well in is a sickener

[Forever_Green93]

It was a stupid mistake from Fish in the build up to the penalty, but it's never a pen.

It's an absolute ******* disgrace that Clancy looked at that multiple times on the VAR monitor, and still thought it was a foul.

[Murphys Touch]

Takes a better touch there’s no penalty shout

44th min in an away derby, 1-0 up and you've just put a free kick into the dug outs 50 yards off target.

Why are you tacking a f***** touch? Get the ball out of our half and see to half time. Defend first FFS

[Unseen work]

You could tell Clancy was on one when he gave the free kick on the edge of our box.

Hearts player shoots, Moriah Welsh jumps to block the shot and a free kick is awarded.

Then the Cochrane tackle on Boyle

[shetlandhibee]

Rocky being on a booking makes me nervous - can’t help but feel Hearts will get him send off with Shankland and Vargas antics.

From a Hibs point of view we need to get Maolida on the ball more:top markstot agree any slightest touch from him they will roll on the ground like theve been shot,,, i hope Hanlon comes on 2nd half because of this, and i personally think hes a better player as well,:agree: