Livi v Hibs

[cabbageandribs1875]

Brandon subbed before he gets a 2nd yellow

[McGruber]

For Vente offside decision. Hearts scored last season when Shankland was offside at the cross but the cross then flicked off a defender head which was deemed to have started a new phase of play. That was a deflection and here the livi boy was sliding in.. what's the difference

[CyberSauzee]

Cliff is co-commentator today. Lovell loves the sound of his own voice.

[worcesterhibby]

He's not even watching it haha

Trust me, it's worse for those of us who aren't ! However I've just dunked my head in a bucket of water with my glasses on so that I'm getting the atmosphere you guys are getting

[Stuart93]

Keep your negativity until we do draw pls haha

Should have been potentially a couple red cards, goal disallowed by VAR…I don’t make the rules of inevitable draws 😆

[Onceinawhile]

For Vente offside decision. Hearts scored last season when Shankland was offside at the cross but the cross then flicked off a defender head which was deemed to have started a new phase of play. That was a deflection and here the livi boy was sliding in.. what's the difference

I think, it wasn't a deliberate action. So doesn't start a new phase. Could be wrong though.

[The Modfather]

The camera is like watching the game from another dimension.

[scm70nyd1973]

Watching this on Hibs tv must be a bit like what all the journalists see at Tiny each time.

[worcesterhibby]

I think, it wasn't a deliberate action. So doesn't start a new phase. Could be wrong though.

That would make sense

[cabbageandribs1875]

I’m seeing a synchronised swimming event


https://media4.giphy.com/media/xUOxeQWMpDf5NpZztC/200.gif?cid=790b7611t6w1qva9jyu4e91ir0pps8hhqfc6ag 2jnajxsets&rid=200.gif&ct=g

[cabbageandribs1875]

Levitt yellow card

[scm70nyd1973]

https://media4.giphy.com/media/xUOxeQWMpDf5NpZztC/200.gif?cid=790b7611t6w1qva9jyu4e91ir0pps8hhqfc6ag 2jnajxsets&rid=200.gif&ct=g

Is that Boyle after the goal 🤭

[cabbageandribs1875]

freakin play it on referee ffs

[BILLYHIBS]

This is like watching Hibs in the year 3000

Nothing’s changed but we live under water

[silverhibee]

i'm seeing 44 players

It’s all a bit blurry.

[cabbageandribs1875]

great save marshall


we're under the cosh a tad here

[Onceinawhile]

Really not been in this game.

[The Captain....]

This will be an instantly forgettable 90 mins but we need to dig in here and stop them getting balls in from wide positions.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[BILLYHIBS]

Good save Marsh

[Hibs90]

Need to get Doidge on.

[Lago]

Some on here seem desperate for Hibs to lose. :confused:

[silverhibee]

We need the next goal, under the kosh right now.

[LunasBoots]

Hard game, crap weather, crap pitch and 1 up, I'd take that all day if that's the end result

[1875Sean]

Cliff is co-commentator today. Lovell loves the sound of his own voice.

Lovell Is an upgrade on the usual guff

[Ronniekirk]

Some on here seem desperate for Hibs to lose. :confused:
Not me I love winning when we’re not playing well

[ChicoM1875]

Some on here seem desperate for Hibs to lose. :confused:

Who does?

[cabbageandribs1875]

Jeggo for Levitt again

[scm70nyd1973]

I’m actually hoping they don’t fechen drown

[cabbageandribs1875]

Some on here seem desperate for Hibs to lose. :confused:


who
where
spill

:dunno:

[silverhibee]

Levitt off, for don’t no.

[badabing67]

Levitt off, for don’t no.

Jimmy jeggo

[Moulin Yarns]

Levitt off, for don’t no.

Jeggo

[silverhibee]

Unlucky Jair.

[Bostonhibby]

Lovell Is an upgrade on the usual guffReally enjoy listening to him, decent analysis the game and he doesn't hold back on the var and refereeing disasters.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[silverhibee]

Jimmy jeggo

Good sub to make by the manager.

[cabbageandribs1875]

obileye and shinnie off for someone else and someone else

[jeffers]

Amazed they’ve not brought on Nouble.

[badabing67]

Good sub to make by the manager.

Needs to bring Doidge on I think

[SaulGoodman]

Amazed they’ve not brought on Nouble.

Shh don’t tempt it

[WhileTheChief..]

Some on here seem desperate for Hibs to lose. :confused:

You can't even wait until someone posts negative stuff to have a go at them? :rolleyes:

[Lago]

Not me I love winning when we’re not playing well
Me too

[The Modfather]

Going to be a long 15 mins. Got 1-1 written all over it when they should be down to 9 men and we’ve had a goal (correctly) chalked off.

[silverhibee]

All the officials are having a mare today, some iffy offside decisions being made.

[Onceinawhile]

We're offering nothing at all.

[Joe6-2]

Not me I love winning when we’re not playing well

We don’t do that nearly enough! Love it

[cabbageandribs1875]

Livi well on top here

[Glory Lurker]

It's coming, eh?

[The Captain....]

Any chance of us stopping a cross coming in, full backs are as mobile as traffic cones

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[Heisenberg]

Could do with a couple more changes here.

[Onceinawhile]

Livi close after Joe newell loses it centrally.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Livi shout for a penalty

[Onceinawhile]

Campbell on for whittaker.

[worcesterhibby]

Livi well on top here

Breakaway goal from Jair..coming soon

[Joe6-2]

Any chance of us stopping a cross coming in, full backs are as mobile as traffic cones

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

Thought we’d stopped that

[yerauldda]

Need another body in midfield. Can’t keep the ball.

[silverhibee]

Campbell on for Whittaker, not the sub I would have made.



We need this 2nd goal.:flag:

[Joe6-2]

If the Herts stay 1-1, what an opportunity to make up some ground
C’mon Hibs!

[WeeRussell]

For Vente offside decision. Hearts scored last season when Shankland was offside at the cross but the cross then flicked off a defender head which was deemed to have started a new phase of play. That was a deflection and here the livi boy was sliding in.. what's the difference

Boyle was offside and went for the ball, I was assuming it was that the offside was for before even knowing Vente was offside too.

With them both being offside I suspect the correct decision was reached somehow!

[cabbageandribs1875]

Livi sub someone for Guthrie

another huge big dude

[J-C]

Newell clattered off the ball, how is that not a yellow card?

[weecounty hibby]

This is the time to play the dirty hearts and sheep way. Waste every possible second, slow everything down. Just kill the game. Its nit what I like to see but needs must

[Off the bar]

Newell clattered off the ball, how is that not a yellow card?

Because it’s Craig Napier in charge and he’s a useless twat.

[Iain G]

Open all mics busy discussing Craig Levein's dress sense 😳 if only there were live games on to discuss.

[J-C]

Campbell's passing does leave a lot to be desired, one part of his game that's still pretty weak.

[Jones28]

This is the time to play the dirty hearts and sheep way. Waste every possible second, slow everything down. Just kill the game. Its nit what I like to see but needs must

Agree with this.

Some would call it streetwise.

[ChicoM1875]

Because it’s Craig Napier in charge and he’s a useless twat.

Incompetent refereeing again today

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

C’mon Hibs, hang in there.

[J-C]

Because it’s Craig Napier in charge and he’s a useless twat.

There is that.

[Hibby70]

Because it’s Craig Napier in charge and he’s a useless twat.

It's Irvine but your point still stands

[cabbageandribs1875]

horrible conditions

[silverhibee]

Is that Martindale screaming obscenities at his players.

[Joe6-2]

It's Irvine but your point still stands

Insert any Scottish referee

[Jones28]

Is that Martindale screaming obscenities at his players.

Can’t be, he’s such a classy, well heeled individual.

[Hibs90]

Definitely feels like it’s coming tbh

[cabbageandribs1875]

5 mins + whatever

[Off the bar]

It's Irvine but your point still stands

Oops. So bad I mistook him for Napier. I

[silverhibee]

C’mon ref blow for full time.

[yerauldda]

Josh Campbell’s awful ability to pass the ball never fails to amaze me

[Wilson]

Oops. So bad I mistook him for Napier. I

That should be an actual grading.

[cabbageandribs1875]

looks like we've 'weathered' the 2nd half Livi storm



Doidge foe Vente

[cabbageandribs1875]

Josh Campbell’s awful ability to pass the ball never fails to amaze me


he's just not got the hang of this surface

[Crunchie]

Definitely feels like it’s coming tbh
I'm not feeling it, i reckon we'll score another.

[silverhibee]

Doidge for Vente.

[cabbageandribs1875]

2-1 aberdeen :greengrin

[Hibs90]

I'm not feeling it, i reckon we'll score another.

Hope so. We have been poor today for whatever reason, conditions have been woeful to so to leave with the three points would be good.

[Kato]

2-1 aberdeenTeehee

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[USA_Hibee]

Hearts getting beat

[badabing67]

Sheep 2-1 Hertz

[Hermit Crab]

2-1 Aberdeen.

[Off the bar]

2-1 aberdeen :greengrin

lol is that us above them?

[SaulGoodman]

I’m saying nothing till full time

[USA_Hibee]

lol is that us above them?

If we win then yes but they have a game in hand.

[SteveHFC]

lol is that us above them?

Indeed.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

lol is that us above them?

Don’t jinx it ffs

[pollution]

Come on Hibs!!!

[silverhibee]

Yip, it’s Martindale.

[cabbageandribs1875]

lol is that us above them?

they are 1

us -1



i think

[blackpoolhibs]

That pitch would not be good enough for my dog to **** on.:rolleyes:

[Joe6-2]

they are 1

us -1

Time for 2 then?

[gaz1875]

I’m saying nothing till full time

This!!

[silverhibee]

I’m saying nothing till full time

:agree:

[jeffers]

Might not be a popular view but Paul Hanlon had been solid today.

[badabing67]

Indeed.

STM 2-0 Ross County

[Iain G]

That pitch would not be good enough for my dog to **** on.:rolleyes:

I would have thought Martindale would be happy with them going to grass, sure he could get a good price...

[cabbageandribs1875]

coulda shoulda been 1-1

[Leithenhibby]

they are 1

us -1

But we'll have a point more IF) we hang in there...

[badabing67]

OOOpphhh

[cabbageandribs1875]

Might not be a popular view but Paul Hanlon had been solid today.

:agree:

[weecounty hibby]

FFS it's five to five. Surely it's FT

[Wilson]

OOOpphhh

Is that a good OOOpphhh?

[Onceinawhile]

Var possible penalty...

[silverhibee]

That pitch would not be good enough for my dog to **** on.:rolleyes:

It looks like it’s hailstones on the pitch but it’s pellets, joke so it is, Livi almost score.

[cabbageandribs1875]

could be a livi penalty against Hanlon ?

[SaulGoodman]

**** **** **** ****

[Up-the-slope]

surely not a pen

[Hibs90]

could be a livi penalty against Hanlon ?

Should be offside

[silverhibee]

Defo penalty but maybe offside..

[Onceinawhile]

Definitely a handball

Hopefully offside.

[Glory Lurker]

Aw man

[jeffers]

F why did I say anything 🙈

[hibee_girl]

Livi are going to get a penalty here

[Dmas]

No way they check the offside here

[SHODAN]

**** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var

[CMac1988]

He's offside.

[Gatecrasher]

If there looking at the penalty then it should be a free kick to hibs for offside.

[Paul1642]

Should be offside

Don’t be silly. VAR can’t make a decision in our favour….

[hibee_girl]

Offside saves us :greengrin

[Hibernian Verse]

They are checking offside

[Glory Lurker]

Yaaaaassssss!

[SHODAN]

**** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var **** var

I take it back

[silverhibee]

Might not be a popular view but Paul Hanlon had been solid today.

Have you spoke to soon. :greengrin

[cabbageandribs1875]

oh wow soooooooooooooo lucky :shocked:

but he IS offside :)

[Onceinawhile]

Looks offside. Thank ****

Bawhair in it.

[Hibs90]

VAR got there in the end but that’s a ****ing shambles.

Sent him over 😂😂😂😂

[OtleyHibs]

I'm stunned, a var decision goes our way?!

[WeeRussell]

Hope so. We have been poor today for whatever reason, conditions have been woeful to so to leave with the three points would be good.

It’s not been vintage stuff but I think folk are going over the top. **** day, **** pitch, and we’re looking like battling to a good away win and important 3 points.

We haven’t played silky, flowing great football for a long time, and Monty is doing well with what we’ve got. I don’t believe some were expecting a classic hibs flair years performance today.

Also - Marshall has been good again today. One or two class saves and a couple of useful blocks from his defenders too.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

What TF is happening?

[badabing67]

got away with one

[et_hibby]

Love VAR ❤️

[Hibernian Verse]

Yasssss finally VAR helps us

[Up-the-slope]

offside..... total heart attack stuff VAR is a shambles

[Gatecrasher]

Correct decision, well done.

[pollution]

Blow your whistle

[WeeRussell]

Clearly offside all along. Another complete tit made of VAR.

[cabbageandribs1875]

VAR is a brilliant thing :agree:

[jeffers]

Have you spoke to soon. :greengrin

Never in doubt Silver. Phew..

[wallpaperman]

They are so gutted on Sportsound all mics that it was offside and not a penalty.

[Dmas]

Stuart Lovell should be in charge of Scottish football

[Lago]

Offside saves us :greengrin
There is a Hibs god:agree:

[hibee-boys]

We’ve rode our luck today.

[The Captain....]

Thank **** for that..was thinking var was going to give the pen. Was defo offside.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[Joe6-2]

offside..... total heart attack stuff VAR is a shambles

I nearly blew a gasket

[The Modfather]

VAR is a nonsense. Confirm the offside before any checks on screen are needed.

[blackpoolhibs]

Great save Hanlon, you were not to know he was offside. :wink:

[silverhibee]

Correct decision.

C’mon the Hibs. :flag:

[GRA]

A VAR decision going our way?!?! First time for everything

[Ray Donovan]

Finally it seems a VAR decision has went our way!

[Stuart93]

Thank **** for var

[jeffers]

Valid point made in commentary, why did the ref get asked to look at an offside decision??

[badabing67]

Mon FT surely

[cabbageandribs1875]

can't be bad when we play badly and still win, can't complain :agree:

FT 0-1

[Rumble de Thump]

VAR asked the ref to go to the monitor to decide if it was offisde or not? Very odd. Seems like they've made a mess of it. But good decision in the end.

[ElginHibee]

Won ugly today. Great to see Marshall continue to be reliable.

Sent from my Pixel 8 Pro using Tapatalk

[SHODAN]

A hard fought win. Well done.

[badabing67]

Yes well done Hibs

[Helensburghhibs]

Cliff and archie have slated the ref all match but it's them that don't have a clue. Var can only give the offside if the ref gives the pen. If he has a look and doesn't think it's a pen then it's a corner.. They can't give the offside unless he gives the pen. That's the process

[SaulGoodman]

One day we’ll have a win where we can relax after an hour.

[Up-the-slope]

great 3 pts... shame jumbos got beat

[Silversand]

FT [emoji16]

Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk

[WeeRussell]

Yasssss finally VAR helps us

No really. It just didn’t kick is in the baws for once 😁

[Stuart93]

Mon hibs

[silverhibee]

Never in doubt Silver. Phew..

:thumbsup:

[Scottie]

Brilliant 3 point well done boys :aok:

[Glory Lurker]

That'll dae.

[cabbageandribs1875]

revenge for our defeat to Livi at ER

[Paul1642]

Up to 4th

[OtleyHibs]

Horrible conditions, horrible pitch, excellent 3 points

[Trinity Hibee]

All about getting the result. Hearts away to Celtic next week so if we can beat St J away we are doing well

[EuanH78]

Honking game of football but good result.

Sent from my XQ-AS52 using Tapatalk

[Leithenhibby]

Valid point made in commentary, why did the ref get asked to look at an offside decision??


VAR works, but the staff working on VAR don't understand how it works...

[supermcginn]

Fantastic result

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

Thank god for that, good away win.

[Crunchie]

It’s not been vintage stuff but I think folk are going over the top. **** day, **** pitch, and we’re looking like battling to a good away win and important 3 points.

We haven’t played silky, flowing great football for a long time, and Monty is doing well with what we’ve got. I don’t believe some were expecting a classic hibs flair years performance today.

Also - Marshall has been good again today. One or two class saves and a couple of useful blocks from his defenders too.
:top marksThat's a superb 3 points considering our injuries and the conditions.

[HH81]

Great result 👏

[Tambo]

Huge 3 points for the Hibees! Thought we played a bit better in the second half, we did give the ball away a bit much but I'll blame that on the **** surface.

[Helensburghhibs]

VAR asked the ref to go to the monitor to decide if it was offisde or not? Very odd. Seems like they've made a mess of it. But good decision in the end.

No they asked if it was a pen. Only at that point they can intervene with the offside

[Unseen work]

Brutal watch in brutal conditions on a brutal pitch.

3 points and back to Edinburgh

Cheers

[Baader]

Big 3 points with the manky Gorgie mob losing. Well done Hibs!

[neil7908]

Great 3 points Hibs. A horrible place to go on a miserable day, where all that matters is winning.

We aren't quite clicking yet but with the money from Melkersen I'm really hoping for 2-3 additions come January.

[The Captain....]

That second half seemed never ending. Not an enjoyable watch but a brilliant 3 points given the performance.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[The Modfather]

A point off 3rd with Lee Johnson’s team. Get building the Montgomery statue now.

[silverhibee]

Now I can post this.

:lolyam:

[Leithenhibby]

Fantastic result


Above the Hearts works for me....:greengrin

[H18 SFR]

Valid point made in commentary, why did the ref get asked to look at an offside decision??

He didn’t, he was sent over to review the pen and then they decided to check the offside.

[Helensburghhibs]

VAR works, but the staff working on VAR don't understand how it works...

See my previous comments the var staff done exactly what the process allows

[Mcbizz1998]

Fantastic result in the conditions. Delighted with that!

[SteveHFC]

Pleasing

[WeeRussell]

Cliff and archie have slated the ref all match but it's them that don't have a clue. Var can only give the offside if the ref gives the pen. If he has a look and doesn't think it's a pen then it's a corner.. They can't give the offside unless he gives the pen. That's the process

I’ve never seen the ref go over to give a pen and then offside being given. Surely as soon as they look, they check the penalty, see it’s offside and tell the ref accordingly.

[Leithenhibby]

He didn’t, he was sent over to review the pen and then they decided to check the offside.

Either way, they don't understand the workings of VAR imo...

[weecounty hibby]

Great result and another way to win. Battle hard, scrap for everything and give 100% in every situation. Not something that would have happened before Monty came in

[Helensburghhibs]

I’ve never seen the ref go over to give a pen and then offside being given. Surely as soon as they look, they check the penalty, see it’s offside and tell the ref accordingly.

No the on field decision was a corner. They can't give offside in the buildup to a corner. When he gives the pen they can then give offside in the buildup to a pen. It's really not that hard. Still think we should scrap the whole thing though

[Lago]

Good result for Hibs on a horrible day on a horrible pitch and against one of my least favourite clubs.

[Hibernian Verse]

Brandon and Obileye should have both been off

[DIXIHIBS]

Well done hibees. Great result. Apparently above hertz....surely not. How is that even possible 😀😀

[yerauldda]

Great win. Wasn’t going to be easy in those conditions against a team desperate for points.

[jeffers]

See my previous comments the var staff done exactly what the process allows

I’m not following that one. If it was offside why was the referee asked to look at the screen ? VAR makes that call without the referee getting involved.

[grunt]

Up to 4th
Not according to the BBC! :brickwall


Hibs strengthen their hold on fifth, while the hosts are cut further adrift at the bottom.

[JohnM1875]

Great win that considering the pitch and conditions. We just don’t lose against teams outside the ugly sisters.

[cabbageandribs1875]

lol is that us above them?


you are indeed correct :agree:

27463


sorry that's a terrible screenshot

[scm70nyd1973]

Quite amusing that the sheep are playing “love will tear us apart” at Pitoddrie 🤭

[Crunchie]

No the on field decision was a corner. They can't give offside in the buildup to a corner. When he gives the pen they can then give offside in the buildup to a pen. It's really not that hard. Still think we should scrap the whole thing though
So all that waiting for nothing? gotcha

[Ryan91]

3 points at a ground where we have often struggled because of a ***** pitch, I'll take that

[Jim Herriot]

BBC site: "Hibs strengthen their hold on fifth".

[Leithenhibby]

See my previous comments the var staff done exactly what the process allows

:aok:

I get that, had they scored then the play would have been pulled back, but only if VAR picks up on the offside...:greengrin

[cabbageandribs1875]

Not according to the BBC! :brickwall


Scottish Premiership Table - Football - BBC Sport (https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/scottish-premiership/table)

[Broxburn Greens]

That second half seemed never ending. Not an enjoyable watch but a brilliant 3 points given the performance.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

Awful viewing, not a day for the style of play we’re using.

Still too many slack passes at times though.

Conditions horrendous and got the three points, ultimately a wins a win.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Helensburghhibs]

I’m not following that one. If it was offside why was the referee asked to look at the screen ? VAR makes that call without the referee getting involved.

They don't for a routine offside though do they? Only for a goal, a red card or a penalty. Until the penalty was given they couldn't get involved. If it hadn't hit his hand it would have been a corner. Var wouldn't have given offside

[Onion]

Brutal watch in brutal conditions on a brutal pitch.

3 points and back to Edinburgh

Cheers

Against Livi, it makes it all the more sweet :thumbsup: Hope they feel aggrieved and hard done by, while we take home all 3 points. Well done Hibs.

[Crunchie]

BBC site: "Hibs strengthen their hold on fifth".
I laughed at that as well, so amateur.

[Helensburghhibs]

Eh? If the ref had went to the screen and said no penalty... It would have been a corner to Livingston. It was only at the point he reviewed and gave a pen they could tell him it was offside

Edit... Quoted a post that was deleted

[Hibrandenburg]

Great day of football, Hibs and Werder Bremen win, Hearts and Bayern Munich lose. Add to that I had a wee €10 Hibs/Aberdeen double to put the icing on the cake. C'mon the lottery numbers.

[eastender1]

BBC not for moving us up to fourth...

"Victory sees Nick Montgomery's side strengthen their position in fifth, while Livingston stay rooted to the foot of the table"

[WhileTheChief..]

Happy that we're now winning the kind of games I expect us to win.

Not bothered at all about the performance or how individual players did, just wanted the points.

[jeffers]

They don't for a routine offside though do they? Only for a goal, a red card or a penalty. Until the penalty was given they couldn't get involved. If it hadn't hit his hand it would have been a corner. Var wouldn't have given offside

I’m not disputing any of that, what I’m not getting is having got involved, drawn their lines and determined it was offside why did the referee need to look at a screen to verify that ?

Or have I lost the plot and imagined he looked at the screen ? 🙈

[Onion]

Scottish Premiership Table - Football - BBC Sport (https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/scottish-premiership/table)

Not one team outwith the Glasgow with a positive goal difference. Shocking, and shows just how tight the race for 3rd might be.

[Heisenberg]

We were ***** on a ***** pitch against ***** opposition and in very ***** conditions. Delighted with another win though. Monty has us going along very nicely with a pretty depleted squad in terms of numbers and quality.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Quite amusing that the sheep are playing “love will tear us apart” at Pitoddrie 🤭


they played "the only way is up" at Livingston


good humour :)

[Helensburghhibs]

So all that waiting for nothing? gotcha

100 percent, another flaw in a system built on flaws

[JohnM1875]

We were ***** on a ***** pitch against ***** opposition and in very ***** conditions. Delighted with another win though. Monty has us going along very nicely with a pretty depleted squad in terms of numbers and quality.

Four wins in our last five with the loss coming away to Celtic. Class stuff. Up to fourth in the league and a point off third after the embarrassing start to the league campaign from LJ.

[Helensburghhibs]

I’m not disputing any of that, what I’m not getting is having got involved, drawn their lines and determined it was offside why did the referee need to look at a screen to verify that ?

Or have I lost the plot and imagined he looked at the screen ? 🙈

He wouldn't have. He would have looked at the handball on the screen, made his decision for a penalty. Then told to give the offside

[WeeRussell]

No the on field decision was a corner. They can't give offside in the buildup to a corner. When he gives the pen they can then give offside in the buildup to a pen. It's really not that hard. Still think we should scrap the whole thing though

I don’t think it’s hard, I know exactly what you’re saying, I’m just not convinced you’re correct.

I’ve never seen it before where they recommend a penalty check, ref goes over after minutes of reviewing it, gives it and is told “by the way it was offside so that was all for nothing”. The first thing they do is check offside to save him having to go over and review it, is it no?

They are allowed to check the offside during the penalty review. It’s one of the crucial parts in determining if it’s a penalty or not, and happens in countless reviews.

I do agree the whole thing should get binned though 👍

[cabbageandribs1875]

Not one team outwith the Glasgow with a positive goal difference. Shocking, and shows just how tight the race for 3rd might be.


scored nine more than heartz

unfortunately conceded ten more than them

[JohnM1875]

He wouldn't have. He would have looked at the handball on the screen, made his decision for a penalty. Then told to give the offside

Why?! It’s completely irrelevant if he’s offside.

[Lancs Harp]

Well done lads sounds like a hard fought win.
Up to 4th now despite only winning 6 out of 17 matches!!

[The Modfather]

Eh? If the ref had went to the screen and said no penalty... It would have been a corner to Livingston. It was only at the point he reviewed and gave a pen they could tell him it was offside

Edit... Quoted a post that was deleted

So VAR have said, you’ve given a corner, you might want to have a look at a potential penalty for handball. It’s offside if you do think it’s penalty, if you don’t think it’s a penalty then we all have to ignore the fact we’ve confirmed it’s offside and go with the corner. What if Livi had scored from a corner given where VAR & the ref have both confirmed it was offside in the move directly resulting in the corner?

I thought VAR was introduced to get the correct outcomes, not tye itself in knots strictly adhering to the rigid processes in place.

[worcesterhibby]

Well done Hibs. Grinding out a win🥳

[Hibs90]

So VAR have said, you’ve given a corner, you might want to have a look at a potential penalty for handball. It’s offside if you do think it’s penalty, if you don’t think it’s a penalty then we all have to ignore the fact we’ve confirmed it’s offside and go with the corner. What if Livi had scored from a corner given where VAR & the ref have both confirmed it was offside in the move directly resulting in the corner?

I thought VAR was introduced to get the correct outcomes, not tye itself in knots strictly adhering to the rigid processes in place.

It got to the right outcome in the end to be fair.

The process is they review the potential penalty first and foremost which is why they've sent him to the monitor. If the ref decides it's a penalty then they review any potential fouls/offsides etc in the buildup.

[WeeRussell]

He wouldn't have. He would have looked at the handball on the screen, made his decision for a penalty. Then told to give the offside

You’re no seriously telling me that VAR have to keep it a secret that someone is offside until the referee reviews the actual handball?

[Helensburghhibs]

Why?! It’s completely irrelevant if he’s offside.

Or you could say the offside is completely irrelevant without him changing his decision to penalty?

[jeffers]

He wouldn't have. He would have looked at the handball on the screen, made his decision for a penalty. Then told to give the offside

That seems totally cockeyed. Go look at a potential penalty, but if you deem it has hit a hand never mind cos it was offside anyway ?

[seanshow]

:flag: Hibs :flag:

[Brightside]

Of course it's debatable. Hanlon's entire career has been him unable to win aerial duals. Rocky so far at Hibs is far better. Why he's been singled out if he has is piss poor management.

What a load of nonsense.

[Bobby's Cinema]

An excellent win in what looked like tough conditions.

Glad to get out of there with the three points - another big contribution from the goalie :aok:

[Helensburghhibs]

So VAR have said, you’ve given a corner, you might want to have a look at a potential penalty for handball. It’s offside if you do think it’s penalty, if you don’t think it’s a penalty then we all have to ignore the fact we’ve confirmed it’s offside and go with the corner. What if Livi had scored from a corner given where VAR & the ref have both confirmed it was offside in the move directly resulting in the corner?

I thought VAR was introduced to get the correct outcomes, not tye itself in knots strictly adhering to the rigid processes in place.

This post is 100 percent correct. And highlights what a farce it could be. I'm guessing he's been told over audio what the state of the situation is and his journey to the screen to confirm he wouild give a pen is just a tick in the box

[Stonewall]

What TF is happening?

Didn’t get away with anything. He was off side.

[Donegal Hibby]

Hibs win and hertz lose .
Not a bad weekend :thumbsup:

[Helensburghhibs]

Of course if the linesman had done his job and gave offside then that would have been checked first and handball never looked at

[Caversham Green]

No they asked if it was a pen. Only at that point they can intervene with the offside

So, if it's a goal or penalty he's offside, if its a corner, goal kick or cleared he's not. Or to put it another way the ball is in play despite the player being offside unless a goal or penalty is conceded, in which case it was never in play.

Probably a discussion for another thread but that is a huge flaw in the way VAR is used IMO.

[Broken Gnome]

Cliff and archie have slated the ref all match but it's them that don't have a clue. Var can only give the offside if the ref gives the pen. If he has a look and doesn't think it's a pen then it's a corner.. They can't give the offside unless he gives the pen. That's the process

That actually makes perfect sense.

In the ground, to be only told it's a possible penalty check when (if you trust the system) the first offside replay rules that out, must have been pretty horrendous.

[WeeRussell]

So if VAR had intervened to decide that foul on Boyle was worthy of a red card, but then spotted he was actually offside (he was miles on I know).

They’d have invited the referee over, allowed him to show the guy a red card, and then tell him to cancel it all because it was offside. But they couldn’t tell him until after he gave a red card because they can’t give an offside for a regular foul..

I’m no having this 😂😂