Sportscene 2023-24

[Chipper1875]

Wasn’t there and hate forming an opinion on so called highlights. From said highlights once we had our better players on the pitch it was more or less one way traffic and only a matter of time before we scored and went through.

couldn’t make it up. But you have formed an opinion and had a pop at a pundit who was there. You’ve omitted chance Forfar missed.

[greenlex]

couldn’t make it up. But you have formed an opinion and had a pop at a pundit who was there. You’ve omitted chance Forfar missed.
I mentioned the Forfar chance in the first post assuming you’re talking about when the. Boy was through and Marshal saved. Not sure why but it was you who asked me about the second half. I said I hated doing it from highlights but did.
That same pundit doesn’t hide his anti Hibs bias and it was him praising Hibs second half.
Not really sure why you’re having a go at me but bash on as I really couldn’t care less.
Was my highlight based opinion totally wrong?
Did we handle the second balls I asked about? I’m not sure I counted 5 in the highlights but granted I wasn’t really counting.

[Chipper1875]

I mentioned the Forfar chance in the first post assuming you’re talking about when the. Boy was through and Marshal saved. Not sure why but it was you who asked me about the second half. I said I hated doing it from highlights but did.
That same pundit doesn’t hide his anti Hibs bias and it was him praising Hibs second half.
Not really sure why you’re having a go at me but bash on as I really couldn’t care less.
Was my highlight based opinion totally wrong?
Did we handle the second balls I asked about? I’m not sure I counted 5 in the highlights but granted I wasn’t really counting.

Basing your views on sportscene highlights… personally always a strange thing to do .

[JimBHibees]

Basing your views on sportscene highlights… personally always a strange thing to do .

At the complete lack of any alternative evidence as opposed to being there difficult to do anything else beyond highlights and views of people you trust who were there.

[superfurryhibby]

ful


Fair point,certainly historically, Hibernian and the supporters have been viewed as anti-establishment and treated accordingly by those in powerful positions.

As for BBC Scotland it has the lowest satisfaction levels of all the "nations".

Not sure how comparing your views to the Green Brigade and Celtic bear any kind of scrutiny.

Apart from all that,Sportscene is really dire but Sportsound is just beyond even that.

Hardly.

Hibs have contributed several senior office bearers and an SFA President in my time supporting the club. The anti establishment club stuff, I think it originates from a wee minority of fans, the same people who still believe the Plastics schtick about Harry Swan (former SFA President) trying to change the name, colours, took down the harp, blah, blah.

[greenlex]

Basing your views on sportscene highlights… personally always a strange thing to do .
Not being there how else am I supposed to do it? Tens of thousands of Hibs fans will be doing the same thing. One things for sure I wouldn’t be relying on Alan Preston to give a fair account. Apart from the obvious prejudices he (like the rest of them) spend so much time talking absolute crap that’s nothing to do with the game he cant possibly be invested in the game he’s meant to be covering. As I said he’s not alone in that.
Im guessing we dealt with the second balls as we kept a clean sheet. I think I’ll leave it at that.

[Chipper1875]

At the complete lack of any alternative evidence as opposed to being there difficult to do anything else beyond highlights and views of people you trust who were there.

And post on social media like it’s fact … l read people l type - heard X player was rubbish, without witnessing it and forming their own opinions

[greenlex]

And post on social media like it’s fact … l read people l type - heard X player was rubbish, without witnessing it and forming their own opinions
Posting what as fact? My opinion that Sportsound and sportsecene are poor? You really need to pay attention what thread your on.

[Chipper1875]

Posting what as fact? My opinion that Sportsound and sportsecene are poor? You really need to pay attention what thread your on.

Perhaps you should consider taking your own advice. You are commenting on things you haven’t seen. Monty admitted our defending was atrocious. Biscuits said similar things. That’s what l witnessed at station park

[greenlex]

Perhaps you should consider taking your own advice. You are commenting on things you haven’t seen. Monty admitted our defending was atrocious. Biscuits said similar things. That’s what l witnessed at station park
Good for you. I know what I heard and I know what I’ve seen. Both facts. Both programmes are poor.
Monty is correct it was poor. It wasn’t great. It was however on the whole effective and that’s a fact. Clean sheet and into next round. I don’t have to have witnessed that to form that opinion the result speaks for itself. I’m done. Knock yourself out.

[JimBHibees]

And post on social media like it’s fact … l read people l type - heard X player was rubbish, without witnessing it and forming their own opinions

Personally would never do that based on second hand info however if you seen in person the same player in numerous games you are allowed to have an opinion. There are players i have only seen on tv e.g epl or la liga players but will still have an opinion

[BILLYHIBS]

Graphics Dept got off to a bad start tonight showing the Killie crest v Aberdeen for the St Johnstone v Aberdeen game

Another game ruined by VAR as a good St Johnstone goal chalked off for a foul that no one noticed in the hurly burly then Aberdeen taking the lead from a penalty award that the Ref had already awarded a goal kick for after a nothing challenge

Onto the Hibs game the panel seemed to blame Levitt for not seeing the danger and picking up Cantwell for his goal and being distracted but this seemed a stretch tbh as he ( Cantwell) just hit the ball and that was that

How lucky are Hearts by the way ?

[badabing67]

Graphics Dept got off to a bad start tonight showing the Killie crest v Aberdeen for the St Johnstone v Aberdeen game

Another game ruined by VAR as a good St Johnstone goal chalked off for a foul that no one noticed in the hurly burly then Aberdeen taking the lead from a penalty award that the Ref had already awarded a goal kick for after a nothing challenge

Onto the Hibs game the panel seemed to blame Levitt for not seeing the danger and picking up Cantwell for his goal and being distracted but this seemed a stretch tbh as he ( Cantwell) just hit the ball and that was that

How lucky are Hearts by the way ?

Nearly as lucky as Aberdeen

[Greenbeard]

Good to hear McCann saying it was a foul on Vente for their first goal but then turns complete d1ck by saying the red card incident wasn't even a foul in his eyes!

[Iain G]

Good to hear McCann saying it was a foul on Vente for their first goal but then turns complete d1ck by saying the red card incident wasn't even a foul in his eyes!

It was the usual rush through the post game analysis, with them still talking detail about the first goal while the build up to the second goal was ongoing, their timings are awful, it's rush through it to get to the end on time! Wish they actually cared more about Scottish Football to take it seriously enough to put a good highlights and analysis together.

[xbar81]

Good to hear McCann saying it was a foul on Vente for their first goal but then turns complete d1ck by saying the red card incident wasn't even a foul in his eyes!

Mccann was correct about both. Mulgrew was a bit embarrassing with his comment saying "he thought it was a red as that's the rule...but I don't think it should be the rule". Soooo you think the rule is wrong and no a red? Bizzair

[BILLYHIBS]

Hearts celebrate the start of their 150th anniversary year and get a couple of Birthday presents from VAR once again

Great finish by the Foreheid who has been relieved of his penalty kick duties

[xbar81]

Hearts celebrate the start of their 150th anniversary year and get a couple of Birthday presents from VAR once again

Great finish by the Foreheid who has been relieved of his penalty kick duties

Nothing wrong with the Aberdeen goal so it should have been 0-1 which would change the whole game. It was a penalty unfortunatly as that's the era of hand ball we live in. (unless rangers at home)

[matty_f]

Mccann was correct about both. Mulgrew was a bit embarrassing with his comment saying "he thought it was a red as that's the rule...but I don't think it should be the rule". Soooo you think the rule is wrong and no a red? Bizzair

How's that bizarre? He's just saying the referee had followed the rules and so the red card is right, but if it was up to him he'd change the rule as he didn't think a tackle like that warranted a red.

[GreenPJ]

Mccann was correct about both. Mulgrew was a bit embarrassing with his comment saying "he thought it was a red as that's the rule...but I don't think it should be the rule". Soooo you think the rule is wrong and no a red? Bizzair

Mulgrew was saying that as per the rules of the game today its a red. He doesn't agree with the rules but as they are applied today a red card was a correct decision. Not sure what was embarrassing? I actually think he talks pretty well and gives some good technical insight. Suspect he will get a coaching gig soon.

[O'Rourke3]

Mccann was correct about both. Mulgrew was a bit embarrassing with his comment saying "he thought it was a red as that's the rule...but I don't think it should be the rule". Soooo you think the rule is wrong and no a red? Bizzair

What's embarrassing? It's the current rule. Player is deemed out of control when lunging with both feet of the ground and (potentially) injuring an opponent. Playing the ball first isn't impacted by that rule.

[Rumble de Thump]

Nothing wrong with the Aberdeen goal so it should have been 0-1 which would change the whole game. It was a penalty unfortunatly as that's the era of hand ball we live in. (unless rangers at home)

It wasn't a penalthy as the player's arm was in a natural position. Some referees think 'natural position' means arms behind back, tucked in tightly to the body or chopped off. There's a real lack of thought and understanding.

[xbar81]

It wasn't a penalthy as the player's arm was in a natural position. Some referees think 'natural position' means arms behind back, tucked in tightly to the body or chopped off. There's a real lack of thought and understanding.


Don't laugh but chopping arms off temporarily might solve the issue lol. If technology ever gets that good we could do it and reconnect after the game. No more fighting too 😀

[Exuberance1875]

It is 100% a foul on the Hearts player in the build up to the Aberdeen goal, in simpler times without VAR it wouldn’t always get given and that would just become part of the post match debate.

However, with VAR in place, that’s getting given every time, it doesn’t matter if he’s meant it or not, if it happens in the box a penalty gets given and I’d be calling for it on one of our players at ER.

[xbar81]

It is 100% a foul on the Hearts player in the build up to the Aberdeen goal, in simpler times without VAR it wouldn’t always get given and that would just become part of the post match debate.

However, with VAR in place, that’s getting given every time, it doesn’t matter if he’s meant it or not, if it happens in the box a penalty gets given and I’d be calling for it on one of our players at ER.

Naw. Your a yam. You get called that here if you think anything anti hibs

[Exuberance1875]

Naw. Your a yam. You get called that here if you think anything anti hibs

😂😂 for me that goal falls in the same category as the red card yesterday, sometimes you’ll get it and sometimes you won’t without VAR, but as soon as it’s looked at the Killie player has to go.

[Irish_Steve]

Naw. Your a yam. You get called that here if you think anything anti hibs

I always like to look at the post count and years that said poster has been on here

[Colr]

At least Sportscene discussed the VAR even handedly. The Scotsman ranted on about the Killie ankle-breaker red card without even mentioning Vente being held for the OG.

Maybe the journo missed the first half

[number9dream]

The grip on Vente is so blatant. He's being manhandled before the cross is even delivered. A big failure from VAR there.
Red card is perhaps harsh but replays clearly show both feet off the ground and that is always a risk...
Mulgrew tries to explain the rules to McCann, a simple thing more of our pundits should be aware of, rather than what they think should be the case or how it was in their day.

[McD]

Naw. Your a yam. You get called that here if you think anything anti hibs

Can you point out what was anti Hibs about the post?


They’re discussing an incident in a hearts vs Aberdeen match, and saying they’d be looking for a similar outcome if it was against Hibs


Bizarre take that that’s somehow that’s anti Hibs

[LaMotta]

The grip on Vente is so blatant. He's being manhandled before the cross is even delivered. A big failure from VAR there.
Red card is perhaps harsh but replays clearly show both feet off the ground and that is always a risk...
Mulgrew tries to explain the rules to McCann, a simple thing more of our pundits should be aware of, rather than what they think should be the case or how it was in their day.

Spot on.

[Kato]

What's the difference between Aberdeens non-goal on Saturday and the goal they were given in the semi-final when Miller was brought down just before it?

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[Hibernian Verse]

What's the difference between Aberdeens non-goal on Saturday and the goal they were given in the semi-final when Miller was brought down just before it?

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

Miller dived

[McGruber]

It is 100% a foul on the Hearts player in the build up to the Aberdeen goal, in simpler times without VAR it wouldn’t always get given and that would just become part of the post match debate.

However, with VAR in place, that’s getting given every time, it doesn’t matter if he’s meant it or not, if it happens in the box a penalty gets given and I’d be calling for it on one of our players at ER.

Was never a foul and the goal absolutely should have stood - 100%. It was the Hearts player that ran across the Aberdeen player path not the other way round and caused an accidental collision. The Killie goal should have been ruled out he's all over Vente. Absolutely no surprise these decisions go the way they do for both clubs been the same since VAR came in. It wasn't a penalty for Hearts either for my money though not quite as bad as their last one v Dundee game before - they obviously see it differently when ref and Hearts fans check VAR virtually in the Gorgie suite

[xbar81]

Was never a foul and the goal absolutely should have stood - 100%. It was the Hearts player that ran across the Aberdeen player path not the other way round and caused an accidental collision. The Killie goal should have been ruled out he's all over Vente. Absolutely no surprise these decisions go the way they do for both clubs been the same since VAR came in. It wasn't a penalty for Hearts either for my money though not quite as bad as their last one v Dundee game before - they obviously see it differently when ref and Hearts fans check VAR virtually in the Gorgie suite

Aberdeen goal should have stood
Hearts penalty was right
Killie goal should have been chalked off
Not a red card

[Hibernian Verse]

Aberdeen goal should have stood - Sadly it's a foul
Hearts penalty was right - Correct
Killie goal should have been chalked off - Correct
Not a red card - It is under the rules

As above

[McGruber]

Aberdeen goal should have stood
Hearts penalty was right
Killie goal should have been chalked off
Not a red card

Fair enough. Handballs are dicey I suppose and laws are subjective - and some clubs subject to more awards than others!

[Hibbyradge]

Naw. Your a yam. You get called that here if you think anything anti hibs

I love these playing the victim posts. :hilarious

[Callum_62]

How on earth did Dundee's 3 goal stand btw?

Absolutely incredible decision

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[JimBHibees]

How on earth did Dundee's 3 goal stand btw?

Absolutely incredible decision

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

Scandalous decision to be honest how the ref missed it was incredible never mind the var guy. Big decision Livi had just got it back to 2 1 and Dundee were down to ten with twenty to go or so.

[xbar81]

I love these playing the victim posts. :hilarious

think he was only joking

[McGruber]

Aberdeen goal should have stood
Hearts penalty was right
Killie goal should have been chalked off
Not a red card

There's now a video up from Killie's own TV on youtube with a new angle on the red card challenge - looks worse to me than other views

[BILLYHIBS]

i love these playing the victim posts. :hilarious

ltyf

[Nicho87]

Couldn’t be bothered logging in via laptop to upload a screenshot

Posted on another thread

I find this whole lack of media attention to todays news somewhat unsurprising

A billionaire has just bought a decent stake in one of our bigger clubs.

We got a small token snippet on stv news

BBC Scotland football has it way down the top stories now.

Scott McKenna joining a danish team is higher along with Shankland getting offered another deal and **** turning down an approach.

You could guarantee if this was the uglies it would be absolutely everywhere and how it’s so good a forward thinking club bringing more money in the country and league

Hibs, nah, not worthy.

[BILLYHIBS]

No offside for Aberdeen goal both pundits agree McCann and Faddy

Penalty claim for Hibs should have been given arm to ball both pundits agree

Neil McCann cannot understand how the Ref doesn’t look at it on the monitor

Marshall should have had a penalty awarded against him for challenge on Miovski McCann

Manslaughter according to Warnock :greengrin

Check the eyebrows

Thought I was watching Red TV again going by the match commentary

Thought I saw Matty in the Hibs end might be wrong ?

[BILLYHIBS]

Starting now 2240

[CentreLine]

Starting now 2240

Here we go. Let’s hear the non biased version 🙄

[JohnM1875]

Starting now 2240

They’ll highlight the hip contact from Fish but say not enough for a pen I’m guessing. Cause it’s never a pen.

[JimBHibees]

They’ll highlight the hip contact from Fish but say not enough for a pen I’m guessing. Cause it’s never a pen.

Putting money on them saying pen

[Kato]

Putting money on them saying penOne of them an another will say not. It "creates controversy" for their ****ty little TV show.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[hibsbollah]

‘There was certainly contact’

**** off liam mcleod

[BILLYHIBS]

Both pundits McCann and Bell said no pen

Diving wee bassa

[PatHead]

Did anyone else notice the board at the front of the studio said Hearts v Celtic?

[Ron D Hibbie]

‘There was certainly contact’

**** off liam mcleod

Was paul the jambo mitchell that was commentating.

[Jim44]

Both pundits McCann and Bell said no pen

Diving wee bassa

Putting the focus on the player deflects from the real culprit here. Clancy was implicit in the corrupt decision.

[Callum_62]

Rangers certainly got a few "benefit of the doubt" decisions there (surprise surprise)

The one in the first half could easily have been a red for Diomande after a short back pass and a tug on the killie forward

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[flash]

Another ludicrous offside against Curtis Main where the lines are practically on top of each other.

[BILLYHIBS]

Putting the focus on the player deflects from the real culprit here. Clancy was implicit in the corrupt decision.

Yes but Fish’s trailing left leg was not enough to knock him over he was diving already anyway as Fish tried to pull out

Vargas is getting a reputation for it in any Hearts games I have watched but Yes I take your point

If that is Boyle play on nothing to see here

Looked like VAR told him it was a clear and obvious error and to look at it again as you say corrupt

[Nicho87]

Slept on it.

Still can’t believe that ref picks up his wages today

If we were making catalogue errors like that after you get a chance to rectify your mistake my manager would be writing up GTF professional email.

Scandalous refereeing

Please release a statement hibs

[DH1875]

Another ludicrous offside against Curtis Main where the lines are practically on top of each other.

They didn't even discuss or look at our offside goal against Dundee last week.
Not watched last nights yet.

[Cat Stanton]

Sam Nicholson scored for Motherwell. Is that the same genital-waving Sam Nicholson that played for Hearts?

[HibbyAndy]

Sam Nicholson scored for Motherwell. Is that the same genital-waving Sam Nicholson that played for Hearts?


Same bellend , Same guy that dropped to his knees when Hanlon made it 2-2 and the rest is history :cb

[wookie70]

Rangers certainly got a few "benefit of the doubt" decisions there (surprise surprise)

The one in the first half could easily have been a red for Diomande after a short back pass and a tug on the killie forward

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk To me that was about a clear a red as you can get. Without the tug he gets to teh ball first and it is very much a goal scoring opportunity. Surprised he was booked given the strip he was wearing. Bizarrely I wasn't convinced about the pen against the Thes. It wasn't even close to being as obvious as the one we were denied against the Dandy Dons

[Colr]

‘There was certainly contact’

**** off liam mcleod

It’s a contact sport. Away back to your bowls!

[BILLYHIBS]

The Rangers 1 v 2 Motherwell

TV Gold

Jesus wept

[Callum_62]

Interesting that shinnie never conceded a penalty when following through on someone who just had a shot - didn't play any of the ball either

Wonder what the difference is with that and Newell one against Celtic (apart from the fact Newell actually played some of the ball)

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[Kato]

Interesting that shinnie never conceded a penalty when following through on someone who just had a shot - didn't play any of the ball either

Wonder what the difference is with that and Newell again at Celtic (apart from the fact Newell actually played some of the ball)

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using TapatalkAnd Newell got booked which added to our status of being the team who receives the most bookings per foul. Add Boyles booking in that game in there too.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[ChilliEater]

Interesting that shinnie never conceded a penalty when following through on someone who just had a shot - didn't play any of the ball either

Wonder what the difference is with that and Newell one against Celtic (apart from the fact Newell actually played some of the ball)

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

It's a scenario where I've often wondered why penalties are not given - because they rarely are. If you got a pass away in midfield just before you get caught, then the ref might pause to see if there is an advantage, then pull it back for the free kick if there isn't, but get caught after shooting and it's play on. If the shot doesn't go in then there has been no advantage, so I think it should be a penalty, but, as I said, it's never, or almost never, given, so totally baffled as to why it suddenly was given, in stoppage time, against Hibs, with the game level (not really baffled, I'm big on the corruption conspiracy :wink:)

I had pondered it deeply (I'm a sad old man that way :greengrin) on the first VAR weekend. We were 1-0 up on St Johnstone when Martin Boyle got to a cross at the front post and turned it wide as the defender came through the back of him, and I wondered why those were never penalties. Then I watched the Hearts v Celtic game the next day and Cammy Devlin (?) got in front of Carter-Vickers (?) to turn a shot wide of the front post before being caught and the penalty was given. It's the only other time I can think of a penalty being given for that. Apart from shirt colour, the only difference I could think of was that maybe Boyle's shot had gone out of play before contact while Devlin's might still have been in?

[bingo70]

Interesting that shinnie never conceded a penalty when following through on someone who just had a shot - didn't play any of the ball either

Wonder what the difference is with that and Newell one against Celtic (apart from the fact Newell actually played some of the ball)

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

Was that not the same as what happened with the Boyle challenge yesterday in our game?

I’ve not seen it back since so I might be wrong but my first impression was that it wasn’t a penalty as the ball was already away, then I thought back to a penalty we conceded earlier in the season or maybe last season, can’t remember who against (not the Newell one in the last Celtic game although there were similarities), I’m sure there was a penalty for a challenge despite the balls being away and already missed.

[Carheenlea]

Was that not the same as what happened with the Boyle challenge yesterday in our game?

I’ve not seen it back since so I might be wrong but my first impression was that it wasn’t a penalty as the ball was already away, then I thought back to a penalty we conceded earlier in the season or maybe last season, can’t remember who against (not the Newell one in the last Celtic game although there were similarities), I’m sure there was a penalty for a challenge despite the balls being away and already missed.

Rocky vs Rangers early last season. I thought the very same and was wondering yesterday what the difference was?

[Sergio sledge]

Interesting that shinnie never conceded a penalty when following through on someone who just had a shot - didn't play any of the ball either

Wonder what the difference is with that and Newell one against Celtic (apart from the fact Newell actually played some of the ball)

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

Yeah I spotted that too. I don't see why that wasn't a penalty if Newell against Celtic is.

Wonder if Hibs will bring that up with the referees?

[matty_f]

Was that not the same as what happened with the Boyle challenge yesterday in our game?

I’ve not seen it back since so I might be wrong but my first impression was that it wasn’t a penalty as the ball was already away, then I thought back to a penalty we conceded earlier in the season or maybe last season, can’t remember who against (not the Newell one in the last Celtic game although there were similarities), I’m sure there was a penalty for a challenge despite the balls being away and already missed.

Stevenson on McGregor against Celtic last season (i think). Stevenson slides in to block the shot but McGregor doesn’t reach the ball either, the ball Carrie’s on past then both, they collide and obviously the referee sees it as Stevenso. fouling McGregor and not the other way round. Penalty.

[Danderhall Hibs]

Sportscene didn’t show the Boyle penalty claim in the highlights so I’m going to stick with my on field decision of stonewaller.

[bringbackbenny]

Perhaps it's just me but do the highlights of all the matches seek heavily pixelated?

Watching on BBC1 hd via virgin and thought I'd time travelled to 1975 lol

[Viva_Palmeiras]

The more I think about it the more it appeals to be the prospect of a well respected former referee from another top level country to come in as an independent consultant to a club to lobby on the clubs behalf. Even just for the bleep-stirring factor.

If the pundits are not in our corner, the Press / media seemingly favouring the uglies and yams why not?

[Alvin]

Perhaps it's just me but do the highlights of all the matches seek heavily pixelated?

Watching on BBC1 hd via virgin and thought I'd time travelled to 1975 lol

It’s not just you, the pixilation was the same for me.

On a related note, is the camera work on the highlights packages much worse than it used to be? Trying to see what’s actually happening in the penalty box is impossible sometimes – like looking through the wrong end of binoculars. Or am I just an old git who needs a bigger telly?

[JimBHibees]

Rocky vs Rangers early last season. I thought the very same and was wondering yesterday what the difference was?

Was that the one where he had a little hold of the player who dived. 2 2 nine men game?

[JimBHibees]

Sportscene didn’t show the Boyle penalty claim in the highlights so I’m going to stick with my on field decision of stonewaller.

When was this penalty claim?

[BILLYHIBS]

When was this penalty claim?
Might have been the cross that came in from the left that flew past Boyler but the Staggies defender came flying into his back and took him out second half

Seen them given :greengrin

[Danderhall Hibs]

Might have been the cross that came in from the left that flew past Boyler but the Staggies defender came flying into his back and took him out second half

Seen them given :greengrin

That’s the one - in the second half at the F5 end.

[JimBHibees]

That’s the one - in the second half at the F5 end.

Oh yes didn’t think it was

[Real Emerald]

Sportscene coming on, I wonder what Kenny Miller’s take on the incidents will be.? 😂😡

[Bostonhibby]

Sportscene coming on, I wonder what Kenny Miller’s take on the incidents will be.? [emoji23][emoji35]Several penalties to the huns, and some sort of music/literary award for their renditions of sectarian hate songs?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[hibsbollah]

Several penalties to the huns, and some sort of music/literary award for their renditions of sectarian hate songs?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

And the winner for Best Song in a Sectarian Production goes to…

[Bostonhibby]

And the winner for Best Song in a Sectarian Production goes to…The fat purple faced guy in the badly fitting knock off sevco top?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[hibsbollah]

The fat purple faced guy in the badly fitting knock off sevco top?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

Lets leave Coisty out of this

[Bostonhibby]

Lets leave Coisty out of this[emoji23]

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[cubehindthegoal]

Sportscene coming on, I wonder what Kenny Miller’s take on the incidents will be.? 😂😡

I’ve decided I can’t watch this no more. Bye BBC sports scotland … already stopped with the bbc scotland radio .. it’s a total sham. They have no shame.

Thing is … they will enjoy driving people out and away from Hibs .. but they can’t make that choice for us. They hope sickening us with all this will move the fans on .. you see it on the board here …folk are sick of it, year after year, and talk of not going back .. and I understand that … but it is what they will love, and laugh at … you leave, they will laugh…

and it is getting worse … look at the last few matches alone … so it’s harder to hang in there .. until someone speaks out and does something about it ..

[Real Emerald]

It’s quite amazing they didn’t manage to capture the Sevco songs when Boyle was injured. I wouldn’t imagine they deliberately tried to miss it out, would they?

[007]

Silva climbs the barrier to celebrate with the fans without getting booked by the same ref that said to Sir David Gray in 2016, for doing the same, that he had no choice but to book him.

[ekhibee]

Sportscene coming on, I wonder what Kenny Miller’s take on the incidents will be.? 😂😡

Lovell was worse IMO.

[Berwickhibby]

Lovell was worse IMO.

What little respect I had for Archie is now gone…

[FitbaFolkKen]

Jeezo, was Stuart Lovell supposed to be on our side? He’s absolutely nailed us on this


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Real Emerald]

Lovell was worse IMO.

Agree

[matty_f]

Silva climbs the barrier to celebrate with the fans without getting booked by the same ref that said to Sir David Gray in 2016, for doing the same, that he had no choice but to book him.

They choose when they “have no choice”.

[Swedish hibee]

Lovell is the absolute worst to listen too. So bad, I watch Hibs in silence!

[Crunchie]

It’s quite amazing they didn’t manage to capture the Sevco songs when Boyle was injured. I wouldn’t imagine they deliberately tried to miss it out, would they?

It was a song sung regularly back in the day by us all with amended lyrics of course. There’s too many sensitive souls easily offended and with short memories.

[norhfc]

watched the game on HibsTV, or I thought it was HibsTV. Lovell waxing lyrical about all things hun is not what I want to hear. Leave that to BBC Scotland.

[Smartie]

It was a song sung regularly back in the day by us all with amended lyrics of course. There’s too many sensitive souls easily offended and with short memories.

There were quite a few songs sung “back in the day” that wouldn’t cut it nowadays - that Paul Hartley one for starters.

Any equivalent we’ve got for that song isn’t acceptable any more, particularly if a Rangers player was being stretchered off the field, obviously in a bad way.

[Hibrandenburg]

It’s quite amazing they didn’t manage to capture the Sevco songs when Boyle was injured. I wouldn’t imagine they deliberately tried to miss it out, would they?

Could be heard loud and clear on Viaplay.

[we are hibs]

It was a song sung regularly back in the day by us all with amended lyrics of course. There’s too many sensitive souls easily offended and with short memories.

What a moronic take.



"It was fine back in the day so its fine now".

[hibsbollah]

It was a song sung regularly back in the day by us all with amended lyrics of course. There’s too many sensitive souls easily offended and with short memories.

Dont know where to start with this. Utterly without logic.

[BILLYHIBS]

Hibs back to being last on

No shortage of controversy

Cracking opening game at Rugby Park as Killie romp home 5-2 after being 0-2 down

Motherwell robbed of a perfectly good goal as VAR notice a mystery hand ball that wasn’t clear and obvious and Willie Gollum is asked to go to the monitor who in his wisdom sees fit to disallow the strike yet does not bother when the ball strikes Graham Shinnie’s arm in the box in injury time

You decide ?

Beautiful double by Simon Murray against the Yams

Sibbick slept

Neil McCann full of praise for Youan’s wing play and two assists

[Stevie Reid]

Hibs back to being last on

No shortage of controversy

Cracking opening game at Rugby Park as Killie romp home 5-2 after being 0-2 down

Motherwell robbed of a perfectly good goal as VAR notice a mystery hand ball that wasn’t clear and obvious and Willie Gollum is asked to go to the monitor who in his wisdom sees fit to disallow the strike yet does not bother when the ball strikes Graham Shinnie’s arm in the box in injury time

You decide ?

Beautiful double by Simon Murray against the Yams

Sibbick slept

Neil McCann full of praise for Youan’s wing play and two assists

The two decisions in the Motherwell game were absolutely awful. Stevie McLean on VAR for that one, funnily enough.

[Smartie]

Interesting viewing tonight.

Some big calls.

Surprised more wasn’t being made of Johnston’s goal being chalked off for Celtic, that looked a terrible decision.

2 terrible decisions in the Aberdeen game.

I like Shankland being ruled offside at the free kick goal - often you don’t see that happen and they try to justify that the attacker distracting the gk wasn’t interfering with play.

Then Shankland getting booked for diving for a challenge that was significantly closer to being a penalty than the one Vargas bought in our game with them.

Glad VAR is sorting all this mess out.

[BILLYHIBS]

Interesting viewing tonight.

Some big calls.

Surprised more wasn’t being made of Johnston’s goal being chalked off for Celtic, that looked a terrible decision.

2 terrible decisions in the Aberdeen game.

I like Shankland being ruled offside at the free kick goal - often you don’t see that happen and they try to justify that the attacker distracting the gk wasn’t interfering with play.

Then Shankland getting booked for diving for a challenge that was significantly closer to being a penalty than the one Vargas bought in our game with them.

Glad VAR is sorting all this mess out.

Agree good to see Shankland getting pulled up for offside does it all the time blocks the goalies view

Felt sorry for the goalscorer takes a mean free kick

[Sergio sledge]

Noticed in the celtic game there was an incident where kyogo was in the box and got a shot away and was then taken out by the defender. No penalty apparently. I've still never seen another incident like the penalty celtic for against us where newell connected with kyogo after he got his shot away.

[BILLYHIBS]

Noticed in the celtic game there was an incident where kyogo was in the box and got a shot away and was then taken out by the defender. No penalty apparently. I've still never seen another incident like the penalty celtic for against us where newell connected with kyogo after he got his shot away.
Or Nectar’s accidental clash of heads in the box against Celtic

I suppose it could be deemed as being reckless?

Rocky’s hand ball in the box against Hearts that no one in the ground spotted apart from VAR

[Crab apple]

What was the music at the end of the show on Saturday night?

[Salisbury Hibby]

What was the music at the end of the show on Saturday night?

Want Need Love
by
Prospa

[Crab apple]

Want Need Love
by
Prospa

Thanks Salisbury Hibby.

[BILLYHIBS]

Thomson Faddy and McCann all said never a penalty for The Rangers but should have been a retake for encroachment by Wright and Hibs defenders

[Ralphy C]

Thomson Faddy and McCann all said never a penalty for The Rangers but should have retake for encroachment by Wright and Hibs defenders
If the goal had been allowed to stand and the game finished 1-0 I think they would have a different opinion.

[The Baldmans Comb]

Sportscene has always miss the point though in truth are just afraid to go there especially after the BBC caved into Sevco and issued the apology after the years of distrust.

The point being that it's a "penalty" Hibs or any other team could never have been granted and nor would it have even been contemplated by the officials.

[BILLYHIBS]

Faddy and McCann definite stonewaller pen for Hibs in the first half the goalkeeper punches Marcondes in the face and knees him in the ribs how the Referee is not asked to review the VT god knows

[Lago]

Faddy and McCann definite stonewaller pen for Hibs in the first half the goalkeeper punches Marcondes in the face and knees him in the ribs how the Referee is not asked to review the VT god knows
But we do know, poor and incompetent referees.

[Carheenlea]

I thought I’d take a look at Sportscene late on Sunday night to see the Hibs highlights. An hour long show, and I had to fast forward through 45 mins of Old Firm highlights and punditry till the other highlights began. Skipped to the Hibs game and it was the three goals and Marcondes penalty claim.

Total waste of time.

[JimBHibees]

I thought I’d take a look at Sportscene late on Sunday night to see the Hibs highlights. An hour long show, and I had to fast forward through 45 mins of Old Firm highlights and punditry till the other highlights began. Skipped to the Hibs game and it was the three goals and Marcondes penalty claim.

Total waste of time.

The Saturday highlights are longer

[McD]

I thought I’d take a look at Sportscene late on Sunday night to see the Hibs highlights. An hour long show, and I had to fast forward through 45 mins of Old Firm highlights and punditry till the other highlights began. Skipped to the Hibs game and it was the three goals and Marcondes penalty claim.

Total waste of time.



Sunday highlights of Saturday matches are usually just goals/major incidents, get more of the match on the Saturday highlights

[BILLYHIBS]

Bit of a mixed bag for former Hibby’s yesterday Paul McGinn scores his first goal for Motherwell and Alex Gogic and Ross Laidlaw both have nightmares after decent seasons

Simon Murray scored again yesterday on the wrong end of a 1-5 doing at home from Motherwell but Neil McCann reckons he could be the difference in a shoot out with fellow strugglers St Johnstone as Saints don’t have a player like him

[Glory Lurker]

Imagine if BBC Scotland's football coverage got funding anything like what will have been pumped into other minority interests like Trooping the Colour and Glastonbury.

[linlithgowhibbie]

Imagine if BBC Scotland's football coverage got funding anything like what will have been pumped into other minority interests like Trooping the Colour and Glastonbury.

Yeah, we would get hours more coverage of the two cheeks by substandard ex two cheeks players/fans.:greengrin