St Johnstone v Hibs

[The Captain....]

VAR is an absolute farce in this country...refs, var officials and sfa totally incompetent. I've just about had enough of football now.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[Dunbar Hibee]

People still honestly think it’s just incompetence? It’s blatant ****in cheating and always has been. Cheating corrupt hun ****ing *******s the lot of them

[J-C]

The game's bent, didn't even catch the player and won the ball cleanly, that's atrocious and this ref should never be at this level,

[#2 Double Tap]

What a lotta pi sh, v a r is just a joke.

[GreenGray]

Been shafted a few times by refs this season, Dundee United and Ross County come to mind.

I don’t think there’s a conspiracy against us there just ****ing truly incompetent


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HH81]

Muppets in charge.

[BroxburnHibee]

Scottish refs are corrupt as hell

[pollution]

Not on at all

[GRA]

Thing is we can't even appeal that joke of a red as it will never get overturned.

[Helensburghhibs]

Was never getting reversed after the shinnie saga

[overdrive]

Much more from these corrupt ********s and I’m done with football. Absolute criminals the lot of them

[Stuarty1875]

Standard of refereeing in this country is a joke. That’s want even a foul.

Shocking decision.

[jakedance]

Just a joke of a decision. Makes you wonder why we bother.

[greenlex]

How is VAR not seeing that for what it is. It’s not even a foul. FFS.

[Dunbar Hibee]

VAR is an absolute farce in this country...refs, var officials and sfa totally incompetent. I've just about had enough of football now.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

It’s **** all to do with VAR though, cheating orange ***** with a whistle

[Keith_M]

Well that'll be that then

:rolleyes:

[cabbageandribs1875]

even preston saying this referee is having a mare

[Callum_62]

Ref aboslutely lost the plot here

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[high bee]

That is an absolute disgrace, was a good tackle. I thought the one earlier in the season was bad but this one is in another level, this can’t just be incompetence.

[#2 Double Tap]

This is a farce.

[GreenCastle]

Been shafted a few times by refs this season, Dundee United and Ross County come to mind.

I don’t think there’s a conspiracy against us there just ****ing truly incompetent


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Aberdeen away penalty. Never a pen.

The sooner officials explain these decisions the better.

[BroxburnHibee]

Refs lost the plot

[Callum_62]

Was never getting reversed after the shinnie sagaNothing like the shinnie tackle though

Jeggo foot is on the grass, not at shin level

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

nisbet goes down, waves the physio away to keep the game going but the referee stops it to bring on the physio

that referee is a grade A freakin clown

[Torto7]

Reminder that we're bottom and its not even close in penalty awards this season. Rangers and Hearts are at the top of course.

[SHODAN]

We should take this to court if this results in bottom six.

[J-C]

Ref's lost it, Considine elbows Nisbet and no foul and then forces Nisbet off when he didn't want the physio, this guy is a laughing stock.

[Carheenlea]

It is appearing more evident by the week that referees actually really hate football. Appears to be an orchestrated campaign to ruin as many games as they can.
VAR just assists with this narrative.

[cabbageandribs1875]

willie miller says never a red

[HarpOnHibee]

I don’t think there’s a conspiracy against us there just ****ing truly incompetent

How many times are we going to keep telling ourselves that? :hilarious

[Dunbar Hibee]

If Hibs don’t make a big fuss about this, they can **** off too. Corruption at its finest. I’m honestly about done with Scottish football at this point

[Callum_62]

Nisbets tackle was worse than Jeggo there [emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

that's a silly challenge by nisbet

[Carheenlea]

We should take this to court if this results in bottom six.

100%

[easty]

It’s no even a foul for **** sake

[staunchhibby]

Is this referee qualified

[Broken Gnome]

How many times are we going to keep telling ourselves that? :hilarious

Why would there be a conspiracy against us?

[easty]

https://twitter.com/freddie_23_23/status/1649793272116543494?s=46&t=D_9KaoRnzKU_iJPtdJwUXQ

[Irish_Steve]

Even preston says it's nowhere near a red card - I take back my statement of earlier lol

[greenlex]

It’s **** all to do with VAR though, cheating orange ***** with a whistle
Yes it is. The refs got it wrong on one view. VAR get multiple views and agrees with the refs decision. If VAR didn’t agree they would ask him to look at it. They didn’t so agreed. VAR is the joke in that decision.

[NC1875]

If Hibs don’t make a big fuss about this, they can **** off too. Corruption at its finest. I’m honestly about done with Scottish football at this point

Yup, these clowns are completely ruining the game. What’s the point

[Dunbar Hibee]

How many times are we going to keep telling ourselves that? :hilarious

Exactly mate, how can anyone honestly believe it’s incompetence? Head in the sand

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

Johnson has to call that out at the final whistle no matter what the score ends up as. I will happily chip in to pay the fine. That's just abject decision making from the man who is supposed to be in charge and enforce fair play.

[Callum_62]

https://streamable.com/5umhln

Honestly

Madness

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Pretty Boy]

A lot of 'honest mistakes' going against us since we made a fuss about the referee at Celtic Park.

VAR won't work here because the officials are corrupt/incompetent (delete depending on your viewpoint).

[Torto7]

If Hibs don’t make a big fuss about this, they can **** off too. Corruption at its finest. I’m honestly about done with Scottish football at this point

Just honest mistakes like the Boyle and Porteous treatment. Or our fans getting their doors kicked in or our managers getting sectarian abuse.

[The Captain....]

This ref is a right little ****..needs a ****ing good shoeing after the game.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

Referee:Craig Napier

clown


no idea who the clown in the Van is though

[Dunbar Hibee]

Yes it is. The refs got it wrong on one view. VAR get multiple views and agrees with the refs decision. If VAR didn’t agree they would ask him to look at it. They didn’t so agreed. VAR is the joke in that decision.

Sorry mate but the ref has a clear view of it. It’s not even a foul. How can he look at that and think it’s a red??

[overdrive]

Is this referee qualified

Quite incredible that the Tory twit is the most competent official on show today.

[HoboHarry]

Exactly mate, how can anyone honestly believe it’s incompetence? Head in the sand

Incompetency has no discernable pattern, refereeing in Scotland most certainly does.

[SHODAN]

Sue the SFA.

[GreenGray]

Exactly mate, how can anyone honestly believe it’s incompetence? Head in the sand

Every team gets bad decisions every single team. Of course as fans we may think it’s only our team but the refs are just a truly **** standard. We’d have been better spending the money we spent on VAR on employing full time referees from abroad.

Don’t get me wrong two certain teams get decisions but the rest of us suffer just as much as each other due to the refs incompetence


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HarpOnHibee]

Why would there be a conspiracy against us?

Why wouldn't there be? Our manager and board have already came out and pointed out "questionable" decisions. That instantly gets your club into the SFA naughty book. Not to mention that our game is still very much ran by complete bigots.

[Mr Grieves]

https://twitter.com/freddie_23_23/status/1649793272116543494?s=46&t=D_9KaoRnzKU_iJPtdJwUXQ

Wow, that's a farcical decision.

[Callum_62]

Clear Rd card for Hanlon there

[emoji849][emoji28]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[DIXIHIBS]

https://streamable.com/5umhln

Honestly

Madness

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Ffs thats barely a foul. Shocker.

[HoboHarry]

Sorry mate but the ref has a clear view of it. It’s not even a foul. How can he look at that and think it’s a red??

That's not the important point. VAR was meant to prevent obvious errors, yet again it hasn't.

[DaveF]

Is this referee qualified

I have my doubts. It's as bad a decision as we have seen (and there have been so many to choose from)

All the clubs need to call these incompetent idiots out.

[Torto7]

Every team gets bad decisions every single team. Of course as fans we may think it’s only our team but the refs are just a truly **** standard. We’d have been better spending the money we spent on VAR on employing full time referees from abroad.

Don’t get me wrong two certain teams get decisions but the rest of us suffer just as much as each other due to the refs incompetence


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Stats don't suggest that and haven't for a number of years.

[cabbageandribs1875]

even Tom English calling that red a shocker



preston said the referee got his card out in 1-2 seconds, didn't even think about it

[Dunbar Hibee]

That's not the important point. VAR was meant to prevent obvious errors, yet again it hasn't.

Fair enough, I do agree, just ****ing furious

[GreenGray]

Stats don't suggest that and haven't for a number of years.

Okay, maybe bar two teams.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Kato]

Just honest mistakes like the Boyle and Porteous treatment. Or our fans getting their doors kicked in or our managers getting sectarian abuse.Truth

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[GreenCastle]

Don’t forget the higher up the league the more you pay for VAR.

[The Captain....]

That's not the important point. VAR was meant to prevent obvious errors, yet again it hasn't.Exactly, the inconsistent application of VAR has been a farce this season. Our incompetent officials were only going to make things worse using it. Used correctly it reverses that decision today, its as simple as that.

Sent from my SM-S906B using Tapatalk

[Torto7]

Okay, maybe bar two teams.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No it's clearly one team.

[easty]

There’s nae conspiracy against us. Clowns being ***** at their job doesn’t mean they’re cheating.

[Ronniekirk]

So how are we playing with 10men we still need to make sure we don’t get beat and hit them on break for winner

[Hibs90]

That’s genuinely one of the worst decisions in history.

How the **** can VAR look at that and say yes it’s a red card.

We need a club statement calling out this **** after the game regardless of the result.

[Up-the-slope]

Even preston says it's nowhere near a red card - I take back my statement of earlier lol


hes slating the refs 'performance'

[cabbageandribs1875]

Egan-Riley yellow card




preston says the referee has totally lost it here

[greenlex]

Sorry mate but the ref has a clear view of it. It’s not even a foul. How can he look at that and think it’s a red??
You’d need to ask him but assume he thinks it’s reckless. The VAR is there to correct wrong decisions. It’s clearly not a red card and the fault is with VAR.

[HendoDelivered]

That ref is a genuine skinny rat

[cabbageandribs1875]

great save marshall

[greenlex]

So how are we playing with 10men we still need to make sure we don’t get beat and hit them on break for winner
We need to calm the **** down.

[NAE NOOKIE]

https://twitter.com/freddie_23_23/status/1649793272116543494?s=46&t=D_9KaoRnzKU_iJPtdJwUXQ

To be sent off for that is an absolute ****ing JOKE !!! it's barely a foul, never mind a red card. How can anybody look at that on a TV screen and think it's not worth sending the ref for a look at the monitor?

If I was LJ my post match rant would be so expletive ridden the BBC wouldn't be able to broadcast it ..... if this isn't corruption it's a level of incompetence that can't even be measured !!!

[Gatecrasher]

What is wrong with the ref up here, that's not even a foul. Never mind a Red Card.

[cameronw-hfc]

This is hands down the worst refereeing performance I have ever seen, all in 20 minutes

[Hibbyradge]

Brilliant save by Marshall

[Jones28]

Alan Freeland levels of refereeing here.

[Lago]

Referee:Craig Napier

clown


no idea who the clown in the Van is though
Is he new to referring the top league?

[Stairway 2 7]

What is wrong with the ref up here, that's not even a foul. Never mind a Red Card.

Too ****ing right madness. A howler by the ref. Both feet near the ground gets good connection on the ball. No free kick

[Callum_62]

Ref (and the one on var) totally ruined any chance of the game being a spectacle and might end up costing us the final chancd at Europe

I don't even think I can come up with anything to say against Jeggo for the tackle

He stretches a bit but it's not over aggressive, it's literally grass height

Can't fathom how any qualified ref can watch a replay and say its correct to give a red

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

Henderson coming on for........

[one day maybe...]

Wow just dumbfounded by that decision. What’s worse is he has the opportunity to go and check that, a chance to reverse the decision or agree with his red card but he can’t be bothered walking the 40 yards to even check. Absolutely shocking

[DIXIHIBS]

Decisions like that could have cost hibs a top 6 finish/ europe etc. Disgrace.

[Heisenberg]

We’ll probably not even get it overturned on appeal. ****ing joke.

[Irish_Steve]

St. Mirren down to 10

[Up-the-slope]

SJ player made a 'back' there for KN... should be foul and booking... not even a foul :rolleyes:

[Callum_62]

Can you ever in your life imagibe Callum Mcgregor or Ryan Jack being sent off for that?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[greenlex]

Wow just dumbfounded by that decision. What’s worse is he has the opportunity to go and check that, a chance to reverse the decision or agree with his red card but he can’t be bothered walking the 40 yards to even check. Absolutely shocking
He didn’t get the opportunity.

[HIBERNIAN-0762]

St J milking every challenge here

[Dunbar Hibee]

We’ll probably not even get it overturned on appeal. ****ing joke.

He’ll probably get an extra game ban if we appeal🤣

[cabbageandribs1875]

Is he new to referring the top league?


nah sure i've heard of him before



as for the man in the van....i think he's been pulled off the street



preston/miller/english still going on about how poor that red card decision was

[Gatecrasher]

St J milking every challenge here

because they know the refs a clown and can fool him into handing out cards.

[Dunbar Hibee]

He didn’t get the opportunity.

You on the SFA payroll or something? How do those boots taste?

[LunasBoots]

Can you ever in your life imagibe Callum Mcgregor or Ryan Jack being sent off for that?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Ryan Jack made the same challenge twice just after Xmas and they where deemed not red cards, I rest my case, one rule for them and another for everyone else

[grunt]

Hibs are going to win this.

[e2los]

We’ll probably not even get it overturned on appeal. ****ing joke.

Still have to appeal it, else no point in even playing.

[Callum_62]

Actually feel for Johnson here

We need a. Point in awe livi come back but we ideally need a. Win for top 6 and Europe

Tough call what to do given the hand we've been dealt

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

Wow just dumbfounded by that decision. What’s worse is he has the opportunity to go and check that, a chance to reverse the decision or agree with his red card but he can’t be bothered walking the 40 yards to even check. Absolutely shocking


it's up to the tw@t in the van to suggest he maybe double check, this one is on Var imo

although napier didn't have to act so quickly showing a card

[BroxburnHibee]

Need to calm the **** down

[CMac1988]

We need to calm the **** down.

**** that. Someone needs to take a red and go clean through the ref! :D

[Torto7]

Weird sub that hopefully it works.

[MWHIBBIES]

Scottish referees deserve all the abuse they get. And more

[greenlex]

You on the SFA payroll or something? How do those boots taste?
He can’t go and check if he’s got it correct unless he’s invited by the VAR. VAR agreed with his decision so didn’t ask him to. It’s not really that difficult. If we didn’t have VAR Jeggo would still have been sent off. We have VAR so he shouldn’t have. Like I say it’s not difficult.

[cabbageandribs1875]

i'm quite sure we will appeal that

[e2los]

Hibs are going to win this.

Absolutely we will win, despite the referee trying to stop us.

[Aldo]

VAR is supposed to eradicate any clear and obvious error by officials however what is the ****ing point!

Having seen the tackle every single person can see it’s not a foul let along a card.

The club need to call this. We better not sit in our hands and say **** all.

This is pure cheating not just by one but by numerous officials.

[Dunbar Hibee]

He can’t go and check if he’s got it correct unless he’s invited by the VAR. VAR agreed with his decision so didn’t ask him to. It’s not really that difficult. If we didn’t have VAR Jeggo would still have been sent off. We have VAR so he shouldn’t have. Like I say it’s not difficult.

If we didn’t have VAR Jeggo would still have been sent off.

So you agree it’s the ref’s fault then…

[Up-the-slope]

awful pitch... awful kicking from Marshall (he has made couple of good saves) which they keep winning back

[greenlex]

If we didn’t have VAR Jeggo would still have been sent off.

So you agree it’s the ref’s fault then…
No. We have VAR so it should have been corrected. It’s VARs fault. What are you not getting?:confused:

[GreenCastle]

We have VAR but it should be used to check situations like that.

A ref card has a major affect on the outcome of a game.

Think the refs are scared to correct decisions and make the pitch refs look bad.

Awful amateur refs in full time league showing how incompetent they regularly are.

These things always made worse if we appeal and it’s over turned. The damage is already done to the game taking place!!

[Up-the-slope]

Joe Newell making good blocks and tackles

[Scottie]

i'm quite sure we will appeal that
No point in appealing he’ll get another game ban on top like Shinnie at Aberdeen. Games ******

[Hibs90]

Club statement please with a detailed list of the decisions that have gone against us that have been blatantly wrong. Show them up for the cheating **** they are.

[Dunbar Hibee]

No. We have VAR so it should have been corrected. It’s VARs fault. What are you not getting?:confused:

You’re a slaver

[DIXIHIBS]

Its now basically impossible to stretch into a tackle without being penalised. Jeggo clearly won the ball,his foot wasnt high, whats he meant to do. Tackling is almost finished in the modern game.

[NAE NOOKIE]

No. We have VAR so it should have been corrected. It’s VARs fault. What are you not getting?:confused:

No point in folk arguing with each other over the details of it. Without VAR the ref has indeed made a knee jerk terrible decision that we can all agree has been amplified a million fold by the fact that a 5 year old kid could have watched the replay and ..... A) telt the ref his decision was mince ... B) sent him to the monitor to see for himself how totally wrong it was.

[BroxburnHibee]

Saints players are throwing themselves to the ground at every opportunity.

Can't blame them

[greenlex]

No point in appealing he’ll get another game ban on top like Shinnie at Aberdeen. Games ******
If we do and don’t win it is absolutely the SFA protecting the officials. Both got it wrong. It’s not even debatable. We should absolutely be appealing that.

[Hibbyradge]

You’re a slaver

He's right.

The referee made an error. VAR's job is to correct errors.

[greenlex]

You’re a slaver
:aok::rolleyes:

[one day maybe...]

Managers should be allowed challenges for the ref to go check decisions like that , if the guy in the VAR seat can’t be pooped or has nipped for a coffee, just like they do in tennis (2 per game) extra 1 if game goes into extra time..

[tamig]

You’re a slaver

The ref got it wrong with the red card. VARs role is to review and correct errors. They obviously agreed there was no error and the ref called it right. VAR didn’t do it’s job here.

[Callum_62]

Can someone tell me what Joe Newell done wrong there?

Stodd still boy ran right into him

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Not In The Know]

Refs aside. All the usual failings today.

[Up-the-slope]

rubbish pitch or not we need to pass more... defending well and then hoofing it is just bringing the pressure straight back

[cabbageandribs1875]

2-0 dundee U lovely goal fletcher


top six confirmed i would think ;)

[O'Rourke3]

2 - 0 United. Livvy out of this

[overdrive]

Scottish referees deserve all the abuse they get. And more

Yep. They need to end this horrifically corrupt wee closed shop cabal that they have.

[Irish_Steve]

Dundee Utd score

[badabing67]

Fletcher scored for DD Utd

[Scottie]

If we do and don’t win it is absolutely the SFA protecting the officials. Both got it wrong. It’s not even debatable. We should absolutely be appealing that.
I agree with what you say but what’s the point because we know the outcome. A further game ban for having the audacity to appeal will be the decision.

[Up-the-slope]

5th as it stands

[Heisenberg]

Miller on for Youan

[AZhibee]

Goal United

[Lago]

Dundee Utd score
Fletcher

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

5th as it stands

But dropping points on those ahead of us.

[Moulin Yarns]

I've only seen the tackle on twitter and it looks like he kicks the ball with his toe a good bit before the saints player arrived.

[Onceinawhile]

Youan was anonymous the day.

[Callum_62]

Keeps Johnson in a job

A really hope hibs go all guns blazing after this game on that decision

I'm still totally pissed off at it and the general farce we have made of the VAR implementation

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[SHODAN]

Looks like we're getting top six regardless of the result.

[Helensburghhibs]

Time wasting away to st Johnstone hanging on for a point regardless of having 10 men is not acceptable

[cabbageandribs1875]

great save marshall from hallberg

[J-C]

All the talk about the ref and VAR, it has to be said we're pretty pi sh today, apart from the Lewis's goal we've shown nothing.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

We need VAR for VAR

[HoboHarry]

Time wasting away to st Johnstone hanging on for a point regardless of having 10 men is not acceptable

Yes it is when so much is at stake.

[Irish_Steve]

Time wasting away to st Johnstone hanging on for a point regardless of having 10 men is not acceptable

But it's the professional thing to do

[Bostonhibby]

We need VAR for VAROr officials in var van that aren't part of the Scottish refereeing gang.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[GRA]

Fair play to Marsh he's kept us in it this half with some fab saves.

[Hibbyradge]

Another brilliant save by Marshall 👏👏👏

[Lago]

But dropping points on those ahead of us.
Overtaken St. Mirren

[NC1875]

Time wasting away to st Johnstone hanging on for a point regardless of having 10 men is not acceptable

We’ve been crap. Terrible decision for the red but we’ve been crap. European football is a pipe dream, we’re not good enough.

[grunt]

Hoppe on to score the winner!

[HendoDelivered]

If anyones gonna score its gonna be them

[SaulGoodman]

Time wasting away to st Johnstone hanging on for a point regardless of having 10 men is not acceptable

Derp

[givescotlandfreedom]

Motherwell's performance against Celtic shows we could have got a point or more without another couple of honest refereeing mistakes.

[cabbageandribs1875]

huge blunder for the goal again but marshall has had at least three great saves since

[Dunbar Hibee]

Keeps Johnson in a job

A really hope hibs go all guns blazing after this game on that decision

I'm still totally pissed off at it and the general farce we have made of the VAR implementation

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Be very surprised if we do. In my near 30 years of life we haven’t before so can’t see us starting now

[SickBoy32]

Yes it is when so much is at stake.

What's at stake? Literally a singular point, Arabs have secured top 6 on our behalf

[greenlex]

I agree with what you say but what’s the point because we know the outcome. A further game ban for having the audacity to appeal will be the decision.
There’s enough dubiety for it to be a genuine appeal challenge rather than a frivolous one. Again if a further game ban is added it would 100% just decide the appeal process is finished. Are we saying because VAR is now here there is no appeal without a view of an incident that VAR maybe doesn’t have access to? Might be the case but we really have to appeal that. It’s a plain wrong decision.

[DIXIHIBS]

Time wasting away to st Johnstone hanging on for a point regardless of having 10 men is not acceptable

You rather we go all out for a winner and leave it open for breakaway? Get out the game with a point in spite of the referee. Losing the game now would be unacceptable, not wasting time.

[e2los]

Backs to the wall here... Would reluctantly take the point.

[Helensburghhibs]

But it's the professional thing to do

But highlights we are nowhere near good enough. Poor mentality as well. No players willing to put their foot on the ball and take responsibility. People questioning why the young lads won't sign contracts need look no further than Henderson. He is a waste of a Jersey and its inconceivable how we try and rely on him over and over

[Silky]

We’ve been crap. Terrible decision for the red but we’ve been crap. European football is a pipe dream, we’re not good enough.

Neither are any of the top six outside of the bigots.

[J-C]

Nisbet has been getting fouled all game and gets nowt from this ref, just a joke.

[greenlex]

What's at stake? Literally a singular point, Arabs have secured top 6 on our behalf
It’s close but not a done deal yet. Horrible situation for the coaches to be in. Hoppe on maybe we are now.

[NC1875]

Neither are any of the top six outside of the bigots.

Yeah but Hearts and Aberdeen have 4 and 6 point head start on us after the split. We’re just pretty crap. Aberdeen in 3rd place says it all

[Hibs90]

Hoppe on to score the winner!

He's abysmal.

[Heisenberg]

Full time

[cabbageandribs1875]

well done the fans that travelled


disappointing for them we couldn't put a show on for them and that's not just down to the red card

[e2los]

FT.... Thank goodness, but terrible all over.

[Torto7]

****** the SFA, that is all.

[Stairway 2 7]

Take the positive top 6. Ref a joke so done well with 10

[Brightside]

Awful stuff. Crap Ref and 2 Crap Teams.

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

If we play like that then the best we’ll do is 5th but likely 6th.

[Up-the-slope]

good fight and defending after going down to 10

[Pretty Boy]

Done well in the circumstances. Got the job done and no terminal damage in the race for 3rd and 4th. Essentially a 4 team shoot out now, anything from Glasgow is a bonus.

[CMac1988]

huge blunder for the goal again but marshall has had at least three great saves since

That he has. Come the end of the season though I'd expect Hibs to be looking for another keeper. A few good saves doesn't make up for a lot of the needless goals that he's conceded. His saves per shots stats tell you all you need to know.

Good point all things considered. Thankfully results everywhere went our way. Ref should be back on Sunday league duties. Areshole.

[dmc1875]

good fight and defending after going down to 10

The fight was good. The team were horrific before Jeggo got sent off though once again not turning up which we have seen too many times this season.

[JamesHFC]

Fuming. One of the worst performances this season. About 3,600 fans through there to receive that showing. Yes we are up to 5th and top six secured but that was embarrassing. A lot of work to do.

[Hibbyradge]

A point away from home, with 10 men, against a team with a new manager which is battling for its league survival, is a decent result.

[HarpOnHibee]

Gave Marshall some flak at the end of the first half. But he's the only reason we're taking anything from the game with his second half display.

[HIBERNIAN-0762]

Dreadful performance,so many failures, Lewis the only pass mark for me, Marshall redeemed himself with a few good saves.

[Glory Lurker]

That was a tough watch. Don't know why I bother ever watching us against that lot. The Doidge hat-trick match apart, I can't remember the last time a match with them wasn't grim. They are such a bogey team, even without terrible refereeing in the mix, too.

[Ozyhibby]

Johnson has been a failure but he’s safe in his job while the club drifts on. Nothing will happen unless we get new owners now. Mediocrity is now acceptable.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[DaveF]

Marshall deserves a lot of credit for those 2nd half saves. He more than made up for that howler.

[e2los]

Gave Marshall some flak at the end of the first half. But he's the only reason we're taking anything from the game with his second half display.

Yup, we could do a lot worse than Marshall.

[Tambo]

We done well to come away with the point and the players worked hard when we went down to ten men.

Shocker with the goal but Marshall kept us in that game with some good saves in the second half.

Ref was a joke today and if I was Nisbet I'd be straight in his dressing room asking about that performance, never a red card either.

Top 6 though but I honestly can't see us finishing higher than 5th but if that gets us Europe then I'll take it.

[Ozyhibby]

Marshall deserves a lot of credit for those 2nd half saves. He more than made up for that howler.

The mistakes are becoming an almost weekly occurrence. And he’ll be a year older next season. We should be looking for a new no 1.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Mcbizz1998]

Done well in the circumstances. Got the job done and no terminal damage in the race for 3rd and 4th. Essentially a 4 team shoot out now, anything from Glasgow is a bonus.

I would say that is terminal damage. 6 points off Aberdeen and effectively 5 off hearts considering goal difference. Realistically we aren’t getting anything from the old firm, got to go to Tynecastle as well. Terminal.

As for getting the job done, our point was irrelevant as United did us a favour - would be been top 6 anyway. Stinker of a result.

[cameronw-hfc]

If Macey made the mistakes Marshall has this season he'd be hung from the forth bridge by his feet by our fans.

One good save and a few routine ones doesn't make up for consistently giving away goals.

[Callum_62]

I would say that is terminal damage. 6 points off Aberdeen and effectively 5 off hearts considering goal difference. Realistically we aren’t getting anything from the old firm, got to go to Tynecastle as well. Terminal.

As for getting the job done, our point was irrelevant as United did us a favour - would be been top 6 anyway. Stinker of a result.Our point have us 2 options to top 6

Livi lose and or st mirren lose

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Man Down Under]

Watching a replay of St Johnston's goal. Nisbet was blocking the ball from going in the net but spun at the last second to let it past him. Marshall defo not expecting him to move out the way. Probs should have still saved it but he had to react very quickly to Nisbets movement.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

[J-C]

Forget about the red card, that's still 2 points dropped to a crap St Johnstone side.

[JamesHFC]

I would say that is terminal damage. 6 points off Aberdeen and effectively 5 off hearts considering goal difference. Realistically we aren’t getting anything from the old firm, got to go to Tynecastle as well. Terminal.

As for getting the job done, our point was irrelevant as United did us a favour - would be been top 6 anyway. Stinker of a result.

Need to beat both Aberdeen & Hearts to stand a chance. Can’t see it happening but it’s the hope which kills you. 5th has to be taken.

[The Modfather]

Is the season over yet.

[Mcbizz1998]

Need to beat both Aberdeen & Hearts to stand a chance. Can’t see it happening but it’s the hope which kills you. 5th has to be taken.

Agree. Are we likely to have Aberdeen at home? Obviously hearts away where I don’t ever hold out much hope.

[Callum_62]

Forget about the red card, that's still 2 points dropped to a crap St Johnstone side.I think forgetting about playing with 10 men for 45 minutes is a bit harsh

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Greenio]

Ref was a joke.

You could see he was on a massive power trip, built like a bookies pen too

[ekhibee]

Wasn't at the game but it would appear Marshall made a mistake but then helped us get a point in the 2nd half. Sounds a bit like Marciano, he made mistakes too but still put in some decent performances. They're more similar than I first thought.

[JamesHFC]

Agree. Are we likely to have Aberdeen at home? Obviously hearts away where I don’t ever hold out much hope.

Aberdeen, Celtic & Hearts away is the rumour.

[Mcbizz1998]

Aberdeen, Celtic & Hearts away is the rumour.

If it’s Aberdeen away then I think today is indeed “terminal”

[Golden Bear]

Watching a replay of St Johnston's goal. Nisbet was blocking the ball from going in the net but spun at the last second to let it past him. Marshall defo not expecting him to move out the way. Probs should have still saved it but he had to react very quickly to Nisbets movement.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

Exactly that. Keeper was caught off guard as he didn't expect Nissy to let the ball run thru to him.

[MWHIBBIES]

Wasn't at the game but it would appear Marshall made a mistake but then helped us get a point in the 2nd half. Sounds a bit like Marciano, he made mistakes too but still put in some decent performances. They're more similar than I first thought.

Marciano pretty much never made mistakes like today. Marshall is nothing like him. Rocky was consistently high up the league for save percentage. Marshall is dead last.

[Silky]

Aberdeen, Celtic & Hearts away is the rumour.

0 points from those ones then! Och well.

[SHODAN]

Think we only realistically have a shot at 5th, which gets us Europe if the OF win the cup.

[Mcbizz1998]

Marciano pretty much never made mistakes like today. Marshall is nothing like him. Rocky was consistently high up the league for save percentage. Marshall is dead last.

Agreed. Marciano was the best all round Hibs keeper in the last 20 years or so imo. He had his faults but overall was excellent for us.

Marshall would at one time have been up there but is quite clearly done.

[JamesHFC]

Think we only realistically have a shot at 5th, which gets us Europe if the OF win the cup.

St Mirren at home is pretty much our cup final. Wouldn’t put it past them taking points from Hearts/Aberdeen though.

[JimBHibees]

Refs have had a hard on for Hibs all season. We need to seriously call it out publicly. That wee gimp today has done us over many times. The one last season at Er when he didn't send off the Saints player with the most obvious red ever is unforgiveable

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

Forget about the red card, that's still 2 points dropped to a crap St Johnstone side.

Or it's the one point needed to make Top Six

[marinello59]

Forget about the red card, that's still 2 points dropped to a crap St Johnstone side.

Without the red card we would have won that.

[J-C]

I think forgetting about playing with 10 men for 45 minutes is a bit harsh

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Apart from Lewis's strike we really did nothing before the sending off, they're a poor team and we should be dominating them, too many long punts and poor choices, even with Marshall's mistake he made about 3 good saves to give us the draw. The poor refereeing changed that game though.

[JimBHibees]

Marciano pretty much never made mistakes like today. Marshall is nothing like him. Rocky was consistently high up the league for save percentage. Marshall is dead last.

Marciano was dropped for Hibs wasn't he

[brydekirk]

We’ve been crap. Terrible decision for the red but we’ve been crap. European football is a pipe dream, we’re not good enough.

This

[Bishop Hibee]

That’s the worst referee I’ve seen since Craig Thompson. Ignorant wee scrote looked up at the stand as we were booing him off and was laughing. Incompetent undoubtedly and given what an easy decision VAR would have had to overturn it I can only assume corruption of some sort.

[MWHIBBIES]

Marciano was dropped for Hibs wasn't he

Does that mean anything?

Hecky dropped him for the much worse Chris Maxwell. Jack Ross quickly sorted that idiocy out.

[Since452]

Marciano was dropped for Hibs wasn't he

For two different keepers.

[HarpOnHibee]

Without the red card we would have won that.

Not so sure we would have. But we'll never know.

[MWHIBBIES]

For two different keepers.

He was not dropped for Bogdan. He was injured.

[JamesHFC]

Marciano is by far the best keeper we’ve had in a long time. Bogdan not far behind. Marshall had the best career of the lot but for us he’s been average.

[Callum_62]

Apart from Lewis's strike we really did nothing before the sending off, they're a poor team and we should be dominating them, too many long punts and poor choices, even with Marshall's mistake he made about 3 good saves to give us the draw. The poor refereeing changed that game though.Agree we were poor 1st half, as we have seen many times though (for and against) that doesn't really indicate how the 2nd half will be

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Carheenlea]

I’m the light of refereeing scandal resulting in playing most of second half with 10 men after a phantom red, it’s a good point on paper and the team deserve some plaudits for staying resolute to earn a draw.

Ultimately though, it was a performance that fell way before our standards and what we are capable of, so there’s also an element of disappointment.

Too 6 and in the mix for euro placings. After the topsy turvy season we’ve had I’m thankful we have that to be fair.

We can still turn an ordinary season into a very good one over the last 5 games.

[MagicSwirlingShip]

Agreed. Marciano was the best all round Hibs keeper in the last 20 years or so imo. He had his faults but overall was excellent for us.

Marshall would at one time have been up there but is quite clearly done.

I can’t clearly remember his faults. Was a pretty solid all round keeper

[Hibbyradge]

I just showed that video to a friend who reports on games for Sky.

He said "Never a sending off. Not even a foul".

[Bristolhibby]

I just showed that video to a friend who reports on games for Sky.

He said "Never a sending off. Not even a foul".

That’s exactly what my Dad said to me. Assume we will appeal it.

Worryingly why didn’t they go to VAR?

J

[Coach Jon]

Without the red card we would have won that.

No chance, we were very poor today, even before the ridiculous RED card.

[Callum_62]

That’s exactly what my Dad said to me. Assume we will appeal it.

Worryingly why didn’t they go to VAR?

JIt did go to var (as all reds card are checked)

The ref on VAR agreed with the onfield decision

Which is frankly mystifying

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Dalianwanda]

I’m the light of refereeing scandal resulting in playing most of second half with 10 men after a phantom red, it’s a good point on paper and the team deserve some plaudits for staying resolute to earn a draw.

Ultimately though, it was a performance that fell way before our standards and what we are capable of, so there’s also an element of disappointment.

Too 6 and in the mix for euro placings. After the topsy turvy season we’ve had I’m thankful we have that to be fair.

We can still turn an ordinary season into a very good one over the last 5 games.

Exactly...Hopefully the players can show more belief than some on here..Still all to play for :flag:

[Hibbyradge]

That’s exactly what my Dad said to me. Assume we will appeal it.

Worryingly why didn’t they go to VAR?

J

It will have gone to VAR, everything does.

It's unbelievable that VAR didn't ask the ref to check it.

[StockholmHibs]

Without the red card we would have won that.

Aye ok mate, Utter pish. We are a god awful football side that scraped top 6!
Love the optimism

[Scotty Leither]

Agree we were poor 1st half, as we have seen many times though (for and against) that doesn't really indicate how the 2nd half will be

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

The wind in the first half was blowing right down the park towards Marshall’s goal, and the goal aside I thought if we got to half time level, and then we’d get the advantage of the conditions second half.

The ref killed that notion though, and we simply must appeal that card, abd he needs to be demoted PDQ.

[easty]

Aye ok mate, Utter pish. We are a god awful football side that scraped top 6!
Love the optimism

Scraped the top 6th in 5th place, and 6 points behind 3rd.

We’re no great, but utter pish is bollocks.

We could easily have gone on and won that game with 10 men today.

[ancient hibee]

Exactly...Hopefully the players can show more belief than some on here..Still all to play for :flag:

Yes the ones who were on here writing us off before the Derby are out in force today.

[Callum_62]

The wind in the first half was blowing right down the park towards Marshall’s goal, and the goal aside I thought if we got to half time level, and then we’d get the advantage of the conditions second half.

The ref killed that notion though, and we simply must appeal that card, abd he needs to be demoted PDQ.To be honest I'd say the ref that was on VAR shouod be the one demoted more so than the onfield ref (for this one decision)

However he was absolutely hopeless all game

Demote them all imo [emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[hhibs]

The mistakes are becoming an almost weekly occurrence. And he’ll be a year older next season. We should be looking for a new no 1.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Completely agree,frightens the life out of me,seems to be losing goalkeeping abilities by the week.

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

Scraped the top 6th in 5th place, and 6 points behind 3rd.

We’re no great, but utter pish is bollocks.

We could easily have gone on and won that game with 10 men today.

How? We were lacklustre in the final 3rd.

[easty]

Yes the ones who were on here writing us off before the Derby are out in force today.

Nae surprise at all really.

A point away at St Johnstone isn’t a terrible result at the best of times, never mind when we’re down to 10 men for a half.

We can still finish in the European places.

[Hibbyradge]

How? We were lacklustre in the final 3rd.

I think he meant with 11 men. :dunno:

[easty]

How? We were lacklustre in the final 3rd.

Aye we were, then we came out the second half and before we had a chance to take whatever Lee Johnson instructed into the performance, we got a terrible red card.

With 11 men, and Nisbet up top, I’ll always fancy us to get another goal.

[easty]

I think he meant with 11 men. :dunno:

I did aye, my bad.

[shamo9]

Nae surprise at all really.

A point away at St Johnstone isn’t a terrible result at the best of times, never mind when we’re down to 10 men for a half.

We can still finish in the European places.

True. Earlier in the season we were 1-0 up at home against St Johnstone and a red card in the 65th minute caused us to collapse and lose the game. Given the circumstances (playing almost the entire second half with 10 men) a draw is decent. Remember St Johnstone are fighting for their lives to avoid relegation. You only need to look at the wins for Dundee United and Kilmarnock today to see that the threat of impending doom gives you a wee bit extra impetus.

[blackpoolhibs]

Wasn't at the game but it would appear Marshall made a mistake but then helped us get a point in the 2nd half. Sounds a bit like Marciano, he made mistakes too but still put in some decent performances. They're more similar than I first thought.

Marciano is a lot better than this version of Marshall for me.

He needs replaced for next season.

[ekhibee]

I can’t clearly remember his faults. Was a pretty solid all round keeper

Do you remember the one when he ran miles out of his box and handled the ball and got sent off? Can't remember who it was against. He was still a pretty dependable keeper though.

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

I think he meant with 11 men. :dunno:

Yeah, and we were lacklustre with 11 and the same with 10

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

Aye we were, then we came out the second half and before we had a chance to take whatever Lee Johnson instructed into the performance, we got a terrible red card.

With 11 men, and Nisbet up top, I’ll always fancy us to get another goal.

Nisbet does give us a chance but the supply was terrible today.

[Callum_62]

Have I missed the interview with LJ?Not released yet

Probably still in the refs room

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[eastmainsmsh]

Marciano is a lot better than this version of Marshall for me.

He needs replaced for next season.

Marshall is a great GK 👍 but I'd love to see Marciano back next season