James Dunleavy

[Hibby Bairn]

This is the guy who killed his mum, dismembered her body and buried remains in a shallow grave at Corstorphine.

He got 9 years custodial sentence plus 9 years supervision on release.

I haven't read all the details but he sounds like he is a risk to society...no?

9 years seems like a very low sentence especially if out within say 5?

[EH6 Hibby]

This is the guy who killed his mum, dismembered her body and buried remains in a shallow grave at Corstorphine.

He got 9 years custodial sentence plus 9 years supervision on release.

I haven't read all the details but he sounds like he is a risk to society...no?

9 years seems like a very low sentence especially if out within say 5?

I only heard a short snippet on the news, but I believe the sentence was due to diminished responsibilty. Apparently he believed his mum was a Reptile.

[Hibrandenburg]

Can we sign him on a pre-release agreement? Discuss!

[Phil D. Rolls]

Be surprised if he isn't in Carstairs within the year. Then he has to prove he is sane before he ever gets out - this usually takes a lot longer than the time it would take to serve his sentence.

You'd have to be mad to bury your victim a mile away from your house.

[heretoday]

I was amazed by this sentence. He chopped up his old mum for god's sake!

[Geo_1875]

Be surprised if he isn't in Carstairs within the year. Then he has to prove he is sane before he ever gets out - this usually takes a lot longer than the time it would take to serve his sentence.

You'd have to be mad to bury your victim a mile away from your house.

How far from your house would be a sensible distance?

[Phil D. Rolls]

How far from your house would be a sensible distance?

5 and a quarter miles.

[NAE NOOKIE]

Be surprised if he isn't in Carstairs within the year. Then he has to prove he is sane before he ever gets out - this usually takes a lot longer than the time it would take to serve his sentence.

You'd have to be mad to bury your victim a mile away from your house.

This

[Phil D. Rolls]

This

Out of interest, what would be a sensible distance from your house to bury your victim?

[silverhibee]

Out of interest, what would be a sensible distance from your house to bury your victim?

Yards, i have a big enough garden to fit a few victims in it.

[lord bunberry]

Yards, i have a big enough garden to fit a few victims in it.
Fred West thought that as well:greengrin

[HUTCHYHIBBY]

Fred West thought that as well:greengrin

As did Mandy Jordache, never seems to end well.

[Scouse Hibee]

As did Mandy Jordache, never seems to end well.


The good old days of Brookie :greengrin