Injury time - non old firm clubs

[Criswell]

Who actually decides how much time is added on? Is it the Referee or the off-field officials?

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Who actually decides how much time is added on? Is it the Referee or the off-field officials?

I believe it’s the referee who communicates to the 4th official how much time is to be added.

The 3 minutes today was a joke. I genuinely don’t know what you put it down to. Celtic scored their winner in the seventh or eighth minute of injury time. Rangers were still playing by the time I’d got from my seat in the back of the West Upper, got into my car, waited for the road to open, and driven to the bottom of the Royal Mile.

[Donegal Hibby]

If it had been sevco yesterday with Dundee in exactly the same circumstances as us with Beaton and Walsh there would have been a lot more injury time added on than we got though I'm convinced they'd have gave a penalty for a similar challenge that Youan got in the box anyhow.

The notion that Beaton and Walsh weren't going to be bad because it was only Dundee we were playing is bonkers. Both are Huns and are anti Hibs . We rarely get decision's going in our favour with either never mind both .

I'm more annoyed with our club for just accepting it and letting it happen again and again . Both Walsh and Beaton should be nowhere near Hibs games imo .

[McGruber]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Could’ve played on all night and it wouldn’t have made a difference in the outcome

Understand the sentiment, did feel that way. Watched the Spurs v Liverpool game waiting on Spurs for coupon playing 9 men and that felt the same. If full time was blown there at 93 it's a 1-1 draw and Spurs fans saying they could have played all night. You never know, we were creating chances at a fair rate.
More to the point though if we would have scored or not is why one rule for us and one for old firm if it isn't flat out cheating

[One Day]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

If that was Dundee playing at Ibrox or parkhead about 8 mins would have been added

Exactly what i said at the time.

[Joe6-2]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Steven mclean up to his usual today just the 13mins injury time at ibrox when thry were trailing

Absolute f****** scandal

[Pretty Boy]

3 minutes was a farce.

There were 4 separate occasions when subs were made. They had 2 players down with cramp, we had Newell down for a short spell, breaks in play for a couple of bookeings and there was 1 minutes 49 seconds whilst the Kerr/Obita situation sorted itself out (see below how I know that)

I'm a bit sad at games and use the stopwatch on my phone to time stoppages in the game. I had 5 minutes 26 seconds yesterday. I'm not saying I'm spot on but I think my count is more realistic than what we actually got.

[weecounty hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

3 minutes was a farce.

There were 4 separate occasions when subs were made. They had 2 players down with cramp, we had Newell down for a short spell, breaks in play for a couple of bookeings and there was 1 minutes 49 seconds whilst the Kerr/Obita situation sorted itself out (see below how I know that)

I'm a bit sad at games and use the stopwatch on my phone to time stoppages in the game. I had 5 minutes 26 seconds yesterday. I'm not saying I'm spot on but I think my count is more realistic than what we actually got.

Loving the geekism of using your watch!! I use the timer on the big screens and like you i had it at over 5 mins. Beaton teally is a very very poor ref and added to that i do firmly believe he just doesnt like Hibs

[basehibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Scottish refs are terrible. Are they biased, I’m not convinced. Inept definitely but biased who knows. Interestingly, I had a Hun taxi driver recently and he was up in arms about Gollum describing him as a known Roman Catholic. I was sitting there thinking WTF. So maybe all football fans think refs are biased.

Bias is a different thing to corruption - which involves money changing hands and is a criminal offence.

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Understand the sentiment, did feel that way. Watched the Spurs v Liverpool game waiting on Spurs for coupon playing 9 men and that felt the same. If full time was blown there at 93 it's a 1-1 draw and Spurs fans saying they could have played all night. You never know, we were creating chances at a fair rate.
More to the point though if we would have scored or not is why one rule for us and one for old firm if it isn't flat out cheating

That’s a cracking point.

[JimBHibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Loving the geekism of using your watch!! I use the timer on the big screens and like you i had it at over 5 mins. Beaton teally is a very very poor ref and added to that i do firmly believe he just doesnt like Hibs

Clearly hates us for some hunknown reason

[Malonga's Cat]

3 mins was a laughable amount but not surprising. The amount of time wasting in Scottish football is really frustrating. Goal kicks, unnecessary treatment and throws in are particularly frustrating. I know we do it too at times but really seems rife from visiting teams at Easter Road. Also not surprising to hear that The Rangers had 13 minutes and Celtic clearly got the time they needed for their winner at Fir Park.

[JimBHibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Bias is a different thing to corruption - which involves money changing hands and is a criminal offence.

Would you genuinely rule it out given the level of financial wrong doing in the game by in particular two of our biggest clubs and some very shady characters owning and being in boardrooms.

[Renfrew_Hibby]

Would love the official stats on total added on time in games involving the old firm and the games not involving them. Would be quite interesting viewing.

[Victor]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Would you genuinely rule it out given the level of financial wrong doing in the game by in particular two of our biggest clubs and some very shady characters owning and being in boardrooms.

Doesn’t have to be money. Referees could be doing it for influence or just to impress other like minded people. There is definitely an air of prejudice about their dealings with Hibs, whether that’s down to sectarianism, dislike of the Capital clubs, or just that they are Old Firm supporters. It would be almost impossible to prove. It’s not being paranoid to think that we are treated differently.

[Onion]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Could’ve played on all night and it wouldn’t have made a difference in the outcome

Doesn't excuse Beaton and the SFA treating this club like crap - should have been 6-8 mins.

[flash]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Could’ve played on all night and it wouldn’t have made a difference in the outcome

Pretty sure there's a match thread for inane drivel like this.

Beaton has been at it for years.

Not necessarily massive errors but, as someone else said, referees matches like ours with complete indifference barely leaving the semi circle. We predicted either 5 or 6 minutes to be added but weren't remotely surprised he came up with 3.

No doubt he just couldn't be ersed doing any more than that.

[NAE NOOKIE]

In reality the only issue a ref should have with added on time is the interpretation of how much to add on for perceived time wasting, the rest should simply be set rules EG 30 seconds per sub and stopping his watch whenever he stops or holds up play for an on field incident.

You could even have a rule that if he books a player for time wasting he automatically adds on two minutes.

[dchibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Would love the official stats on total added on time in games involving the old firm and the games not involving them. Would be quite interesting viewing.

They would only need the extra time when they are drawing or getting beat,but it is obvious they get it when required depending what side the officials are for.