Sportscene 22/23

[Orchard_Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Think the fact they showed a nil nil before our highlights which were on last tells you all you need to know.

Yeah I think this just shows how terrible this program actually is

[Jones28]

I’ve completely given up on sportscene. The commentary-free highlights on YouTube are worth the wait until Monday or so when they’re posted.

And the alternate angle camera we have on the go at the moment is excellent.

[AltheHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Is it just me or do they add the commentary to the games in post-production? It always sounds a bit phoney.

It hasn't just happened in football. I recall that the British Touring Car commentary used to be recorded by the legendary Murray Walker who who stand and commentate on a recording of the full races.

Oh for commentators of his and Bill McLaren's quality.

[JohnM1875]

Just finished watching it and they really don't like to give us any praise at all these days eh?

Stewart is a total fud these days as well. Prick.

[Kavinho]

Have to say I agree with that!

A grudging half compliment in there somewhere!

[Lago]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Just finished watching it and they really don't like to give us any praise at all these days eh?

Stewart is a total fud these days as well. Prick.

Totally agree

[Neily1982]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Totally agree

They seem to be bitter we went with Johnson and not one of the older experience SPL managers and don’t seem to like the gib of Ron Gordon much

[SideBurns]

They showed the first-half handball, but no mention in the analysis of that - just on and on about how the one we did get being a liberty. And what about the other handball at the end, when their defender fell on the ball and grabbed it? Linesman standing watching it but did nowt, free-kick to Dons awarded by the ref. Nae footage of that in either thr highlights or studio analysis!!

[DinkyTwo]

Feel that the narrative around Hibs right now is bordering on ridiculous. 25 shots and a 3-1 victory, yet nobody can muster up a single positive thing to say about us.

We don't have an identity, our players are cheats and we have way too many strikers was about as much airtime as we got yesterday

There has been a lot of red cards against our opposition, but maybe that's also indicative of the style of play we have this season. We're creating a lot of chances and getting ourselves into dangerous positions that, if defenders don't get spot it on, will give the referee a decision to make.

For balance though, we had two(?) handball decisions missed yesterday, a penalty against Rangers and their penalty shouldn't have been awarded. Where's the analysis on that?

[JohnM1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Feel that the narrative around Hibs right now is bordering on ridiculous. 25 shots and a 3-1 victory, yet nobody can muster up a single positive thing to say about us.

We don't have an identity, our players are cheats and we have way too many strikers was about as much airtime as we got yesterday

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

Totally.

Bet they have an absolute jizzfest over Hearts win today as well. They'll mention that Hearts are by a distance the third best team in the country right now blah blah blah.

Sick of it! 😂

[mjhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Totally.

Bet they have an absolute jizzfest over Hearts win today as well. They'll mention that Hearts are by a distance the third best team in the country right now blah blah blah.

Sick of it! 😂

The stats of the hearts game are unreal well 25 shots to hearts 10. Certainly a game where the score did not reflect the game.

[DinkyTwo]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The stats of the hearts game are unreal well 25 shots to hearts 10. Certainly a game where the score did not reflect the game.

Caught a bit on the radio and Motherwell seemed well on top. Paul McGinn hitting the post at an open goal and then they had another chopped off for offside at 2-0

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

[Squealing pig]

Showing a nil - nil before our demolition of the sheep

[loanheadhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Totally.

Bet they have an absolute jizzfest over Hearts win today as well. They'll mention that Hearts are by a distance the third best team in the country right now blah blah blah.

Sick of it! 😂

Do you really think Sportscene favour Hearts over Hibs?
It's pretty sad if you do.

[BT58]

They cant wait to say weve got points through other teams getting red cards. Ffs its refs who give red cards, not HFC. Once VAR comes in then hopefully there crap will stop. But then again i doubt it. I used to think Stewart was a good guy but hes coming across as an effing fud !!!
B

[Jim44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

They cant wait to say weve got points through other teams getting red cards. Ffs its refs who give red cards, not HFC. Once VAR comes in then hopefully there crap will stop. But then again i doubt it. I used to think Stewart was a good guy but hes coming across as an effing fud !!!
B

He’s increasingly becoming aware of touting controversy in order to keep ahead of the game in Scottish football punditry. There’s no future in being Mr Honest and Sensible, especially if you have anything positive or complimentary to say about Hibs, the blacksheep target of the BBC sports team. The only real pro Hibs pundit in recent times was Pat Nevin but he didn’t last long. I don’t know if he got the bullet because of his failure to side with BBC policy or whether he saw through them and thought, ‘Sod it I’m out of here!’

[basehibby]

Very bizzare detachment between the BBC Sports team and reality with respect to Hibs. There is a reason that teams are consistently getting players sent off against us and that we are consistently seeing 25 attempts on goal most matches - it's called pace and flair. They should be gushing with enthusiasm but all you get is embittered one sided drivel. Did Big Ron piss in their F-ing cornflakes? The shower of muppets!

[JohnM1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Do you really think Sportscene favour Hearts over Hibs?
It's pretty sad if you do.

[patlowe]

Hearts and Aberdeen are overly represented in terms of ex-players/known supporters on the BBC so do tend to get more focus and an easier ride IMO, though it can go the other way.

In Hibs' case this season it's nothing orchestrated, I just think we are probably the victims of the need for the media to have a clear and settled narrative, ie Hibs are in chaos and the chair is rash and doesn't get Scottish football. And when evidence calls that narrative into question it is easier (and less work) to seek mitigating circumstances rather than acknowledge this. I guess it's just up to Hibs to prove them wrong by winning games and getting up the table.

If there was more of a focus on analysis, rather than personalities and controversy, it wouldn't be hard to see that this Hibs team is a lot more exciting and creative than anything served up under JR and Maloney. Granted, the squad is too big and some of the recruitment and results have been patchy, but the progress on the pitch is there. But that would be far too nuanced to bother with - stick to the easy narrative.

[matty_f]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Hearts and Aberdeen are overly represented in terms of ex-players/known supporters on the BBC so do tend to get more focus and an easier ride IMO, though it can go the other way.

In Hibs' case this season it's nothing orchestrated, I just think we are probably the victims of the need for the media to have a clear and settled narrative, ie Hibs are in chaos and the chair is rash and doesn't get Scottish football. And when evidence calls that narrative into question it is easier (and less work) to seek mitigating circumstances rather than acknowledge this. I guess it's just up to Hibs to prove them wrong by winning games and getting up the table.

If there was more of a focus on analysis, rather than personalities and controversy, it wouldn't be hard to see that this Hibs team is a lot more exciting and creative than anything served up under JR and Maloney. Granted, the squad is too big and some of the recruitment and results have been patchy, but the progress on the pitch is there. But that would be far too nuanced to bother with - stick to the easy narrative.

I agree with this, Hibs need to get some proper representation in the media. The BBC would probably argue that Stewart and Kenny Millar are both ex-Hibs, i suppose but they’re not “Hibs men” in the way that Willie Miller is an Aberdeen man etc

[Davy Mac]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Do you really think Sportscene favour Hearts over Hibs?
It's pretty sad if you do.

They do in my opinion and it runs much deeper that that.

Scottish fitba is full of bigots, I know a number of officals and they are blue as they come, we are not welcome at the table.

I've sat in many a dinner/function/gathering and lets just say they're not toasting the pope thats for sure and rightly or wrongly we are looked upon as the same as Celtic - fact.

[Scotty Leither]

Stewart has had the petted lip with Hibs ever since he was an unused sub in the 2007 LC Final and a 19-year-old laddie called Stevenson got picked in front of him.

He had a face like a smacked @rse in the post-match photos and treated the club disrespectfully. Used to think he was a lone voice of sanity and intelligence amongst a bunch of weegie-centric pygmies, but now he's reverting to the editorial line of the rest of them with their skewed "analysis" of all things Hibs.

[loanheadhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

They do in my opinion and it runs much deeper that that.

Scottish fitba is full of bigots, I know a number of officals and they are blue as they come, we are not welcome at the table.

I've sat in many a dinner/function/gathering and lets just say they're not toasting the pope thats for sure and rightly or wrongly we are looked upon as the same as Celtic - fact.

Wow that's pretty sad if you think that.

[hibsbollah]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Hearts and Aberdeen are overly represented in terms of ex-players/known supporters on the BBC so do tend to get more focus and an easier ride IMO, though it can go the other way.

In Hibs' case this season it's nothing orchestrated, I just think we are probably the victims of the need for the media to have a clear and settled narrative, ie Hibs are in chaos and the chair is rash and doesn't get Scottish football. And when evidence calls that narrative into question it is easier (and less work) to seek mitigating circumstances rather than acknowledge this. I guess it's just up to Hibs to prove them wrong by winning games and getting up the table.

If there was more of a focus on analysis, rather than personalities and controversy, it wouldn't be hard to see that this Hibs team is a lot more exciting and creative than anything served up under JR and Maloney. Granted, the squad is too big and some of the recruitment and results have been patchy, but the progress on the pitch is there. But that would be far too nuanced to bother with - stick to the easy narrative.

Very good post.

I’ve started voting with my feet and didn’t watch Sportscene purely because I knew what to expect. Thankfully when I miss games like I did this weekend there are other options to watch the highlights and get at least a semblance of analysis.

[Cat Stanton]

Hibs have been up and down this season - contrast second half yesterday with first half at Livingston or both halves at St. Mirren. There have been a lot of new arrivals, not all of whom have thus far worked out. So in that sense the "identity" - what Hibs will look like, or are aiming to look like - under Johnson isn't all that clear yet. I think that's what Michael Stewart was saying last night, and I don't think it's a ridiculous thing to say. He also didn't think it should have been a penalty and, to be honest, it was pretty soft.

There's quite a lot of over-sensitivity to criticism on here about certain programmes and pundits. Stewart talks sense most times I hear him.

[JOD]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Hibs have been up and down this season - contrast second half yesterday with first half at Livingston or both halves at St. Mirren. There have been a lot of new arrivals, not all of whom have thus far worked out. So in that sense the "identity" - what Hibs will look like, or are aiming to look like - under Johnson isn't all that clear yet. I think that's what Michael Stewart was saying last night, and I don't think it's a ridiculous thing to say. He also didn't think it should have been a penalty and, to be honest, it was pretty soft.

There's quite a lot of over-sensitivity to criticism on here about certain programmes and pundits. Stewart talks sense most times I hear him.

Good Post. On the whole I think M S does a good job as a pundit compared to the rest in Scotland.

[007]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Do you really think Sportscene favour Hearts over Hibs?
It's pretty sad if you do.

Michael Stewart does.

[cameronw-hfc]

Can confirm I know a few former and one current prem officials and all are rangers fans, only one that I know hides it as well. One use to train on a pitch across from where my former team played/trained and would literally do it in a rangers top, well known official as well.

Edit- should say, the one that "hides it" I don't know personally but I worked with his daughter and she confirmed he was a current season ticket holder. Retired a good few years back.

[bigwheel]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Can confirm I know a few former and one current prem officials and all are rangers fans, only one that I know hides it as well. One use to train on a pitch across from where my former team played/trained and would literally do it in a rangers top, well known official as well.

Edit- should say, the one that "hides it" I don't know personally but I worked with his daughter and she confirmed he was a current season ticket holder. Retired a good few years back.

Who are they ? Sounds like they are open about it - so not secret

[mjhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Hibs have been up and down this season - contrast second half yesterday with first half at Livingston or both halves at St. Mirren. There have been a lot of new arrivals, not all of whom have thus far worked out. So in that sense the "identity" - what Hibs will look like, or are aiming to look like - under Johnson isn't all that clear yet. I think that's what Michael Stewart was saying last night, and I don't think it's a ridiculous thing to say. He also didn't think it should have been a penalty and, to be honest, it was pretty soft.

There's quite a lot of over-sensitivity to criticism on here about certain programmes and pundits. Stewart talks sense most times I hear him.

He is mostly but seems to be going with the herd these days. Seems to be a lack of preperation for the show too very rushed. The dons fans agree with most on here that it was a dubious pen but the result was the right one. There was three pen shouts there was one definite one 50/50 and one not. Not stating that the punch away was a definite penalty is just so poor and gives an unbalanced portrait of the game. Biscuits i dont mind as ive spoke to him a few times and he does speaks well of us. Its just a very poor programme which i used to listen to every time it was on. How times have changed.