Quote Originally Posted by Peevemor View Post
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
To me that says more about these 2 managers influence on recruitment than it does about Mathie.
Well that's just opening up the whole who makes the signings argument.

To me, if you can't hold the head of scouting partly/mostly responsible for a poor transfer window then what's the point in having a head of scouting at all?

That was Mathies role at the time of the relatively poor windows I was talking about so surely is down to him in some way or another. Not just one transfer here or there but by looking at the transfer window as a whole reflects on the head of scouting if you ask me.