Kamberi To Leave St Gallen

[The Modfather]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Played the best football of his career under Lennon.

Maybe should have paid attention to what he was being told back them instead of going in a huff.

Maybe Lennon’s message to Kamberi would have been more effective if Lennon wasn’t going in the huff himself, threatening to quit, questions the club matching his ambition and going AWOL from media duties etc. Having a needless dig can work both ways.

[Jones28]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Because we have a sell-on fee.

Do we?

Smashing, I wish him all the best

[Craig_HFC]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Do we?

Smashing, I wish him all the best

[Diclonius]

[Seveno]

I don’t understand why some people are so keen on sticking the knife into someone who used to play for the club taking no account of his age and being away from home. He gets accused of acting in a childish manners but that accusation can easily be turned against some of his continuing detractors on here.

My advice - grow up and let it be.

[A Hi-Bee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don’t understand why some people are so keen on sticking the knife into someone who used to play for the club taking no account of his age and being away from home. He gets accused of acting in a childish manners but that accusation can easily be turned against some of his continuing detractors on here.

My advice - grow up and let it be.

Well said, and if our club can get some much needed cash in from him getting a better move then bring it on.

[Jim44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don’t understand why some people are so keen on sticking the knife into someone who used to play for the club taking no account of his age and being away from home. He gets accused of acting in a childish manners but that accusation can easily be turned against some of his continuing detractors on here.

My advice - grow up and let it be.

I agree that continual slagging off of Kamberi is a bit OTT but it’s difficult to ignore his acrimonious departure from Hibs. My erstwhile bitterness has been replaced by gross indifference.

[Phil MaGlass]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don’t understand why some people are so keen on sticking the knife into someone who used to play for the club taking no account of his age and being away from home. He gets accused of acting in a childish manners but that accusation can easily be turned against some of his continuing detractors on here.

My advice - grow up and let it be.

The way he left us to the huns is why folk stick the knife into him. **** him and the horse he rode in on.

[.Sean.]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I’d rather he done very well for himself and we made money. It’s of no benefit to us him falling into football wilderness or going on loan.

Going to need to disagree with you for once Sam mate. I hope he floats around from pish club to even pisher club like the nondescript journeyman he deserves to be, the absolute ****

[Onion]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don’t understand why some people are so keen on sticking the knife into someone who used to play for the club taking no account of his age and being away from home. He gets accused of acting in a childish manners but that accusation can easily be turned against some of his continuing detractors on here.

My advice - grow up and let it be.

Can think of two reasons; firstly, he's obviously a talented player but his attitude and application stinks. Players who appear to waste their talent are most likely to be criticised by their own fans. Secondly, compound that with his naive or bitter comments when he joined Sevco (on loan !). He wrote off his Hibs career in that moment and was incredibly disrespectful to the club and us as fans. Overall, he's a idiot with terrible values.

[Bright_Hibee]

He's a rat that disrespected Hibs. I hope he sees even less time on the park at his next club.

[Keith_M]

I'll be absolutely delighted if it turns out that we do get a percentage of any fee paid by Bochum.

[hibbysam]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

So what's the benefit of him doing well? Poor attitude leads to rewards? Falling out with managers is a positive thing for career progression? Hibs are there to get your career on track and then you can **** them over when you want out?

He’s no longer a Hibs player, what he does now makes no difference to us, other than the fact we can make money off a potential move which benefits us massively. He’s already gone, I’m confused as to how him failing going forward somehow means future players will treat us better.

[hibbysam]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Going to need to disagree with you for once Sam mate. I hope he floats around from pish club to even pisher club like the nondescript journeyman he deserves to be, the absolute ****

He can do that after he’s moved and made us money. His attitude won’t change, he’ll fall out with that club and won’t play. Seen it before and it’ll happen in the future tae.

[Stonewall]

Who?

[EI255]

He simply won't get away with one good game in 6 or whatever. That's my point. He simply isn't good enough to play in the top half of B2. Good luck, don't get me wrong, but we all know he isn't that standard. I've watched Bochum several times and they are a very good outift. Premadonnas they don't do. I'd have thought Bundesliga 3 might be his level.

Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk

[hibee-boys]

No interest in having him back but not based on what he said when he signed for Rangers, his stinking attitude when he was with us sealed it for me. Probably in the minority but never found what he said that offensive. An overseas player comes to play in Scotland and wants to play for one of the 2 Scottish clubs that most overseas players have ever heard off, shock horror......sensitive lot us football fans.

[WeeRussell]

Another one in the Matt Docherty category for me that, while didn’t cover himself in glory, I find myself wondering why everyone holds such a big grudge against.

Apart from an ill-advised choice of words in a in interview in a language that isn’t his strongest, and rumours about his attitude circling round a manager we know to be a slavering head case... I just can’t bring myself to hate the boy.

Purely my opinion though and I do seem to be very much in the minority.

I also remember some of these sorts of comments above (and from some of the same posters) about a certain Scott Allan not so long ago.

[Baldy Foghorn]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don’t understand why some people are so keen on sticking the knife into someone who used to play for the club taking no account of his age and being away from home. He gets accused of acting in a childish manners but that accusation can easily be turned against some of his continuing detractors on here.

My advice - grow up and let it be.

A player who brought most of it on himself, saying in his 2nd Hibs match (IIRC), that he knew he wanted to play in Govan. Silly boy

[Jones28]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He’s no longer a Hibs player, what he does now makes no difference to us, other than the fact we can make money off a potential move which benefits us massively. He’s already gone, I’m confused as to how him failing going forward somehow means future players will treat us better.

Well let’s look at it this way. Kamberi’s attitude and actions were an attempt to engineer a move to a bigger club to the detriment of Hibs, agreed surely? He wanted to go to Rangers who were our direct competition at the time. So he went, he wore the red white and blue, made silly comments in the media, came back to Hibs and was swiftly shunted on. He goes to some team I’ve never heard of - my ignorance the most likely reason - and is now, as we speak, sliding in to obscurity and footballing wilderness.

Take someone like John McGinn, who is our biggest successful transfer since Scott Brown. Kept his head down despite it being well known other clubs were interested, still worked his socks off during our European campaign and ultimately got a move to a massive club who are now in one of the top five leagues in Europe.

Compare and contrast the two, then put yourselves in the shoes of an ambitious and talented young player who would look at the two examples and think Hibs might be a good place to go to springboard my career, but on their terms, not mine.

[Stanton Spence]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Well let’s look at it this way. Kamberi’s attitude and actions were an attempt to engineer a move to a bigger club to the detriment of Hibs, agreed surely? He wanted to go to Rangers who were our direct competition at the time. So he went, he wore the red white and blue, made silly comments in the media, came back to Hibs and was swiftly shunted on. He goes to some team I’ve never heard of - my ignorance the most likely reason - and is now, as we speak, sliding in to obscurity and footballing wilderness.

Take someone like John McGinn, who is our biggest successful transfer since Scott Brown. Kept his head down despite it being well known other clubs were interested, still worked his socks off during our European campaign and ultimately got a move to a massive club who are now in one of the top five leagues in Europe.

Compare and contrast the two, then put yourselves in the shoes of an ambitious and talented young player who would look at the two examples and think Hibs might be a good place to go to springboard my career, but on their terms, not mine.

Sent from my G3121 using Tapatalk

[Jones28]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

At what point was kamberi being detremntal to hibs in trying to engineer a move to the huns? If hibs really wanted to keep him then we would have told the huns to bolt when they wanted to take him on loan. As soon as we agreed to let him go there then his hibs career was over and done with simple as that. Hibs wanted shot of him for obvious reasons ie his attitude. I've got nae time for him but not down to the whole rangers are the only team I wanted to play for etc etc. Florian kamberi days at hibs were long gone before anyone even knew that he would end up at ibrox on loan

Sent from my G3121 using Tapatalk

Your first sentence answers your own question ffs 😂

[Stanton Spence]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Your first sentence answers your own question ffs

What I was trying to say was that the relationship was done and dusted and he was never coming back to hibs long before we agreed to loan him to the huns. We tried to punt him and rightly so and he probably couldn't believe his luck that he was going to the rangers. What he said wasn't detremntal to hibs, he was definitely disrespectful but detremntal?? I didn't notice any harm he caused the club

Sent from my G3121 using Tapatalk

[hibbysam]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Well let’s look at it this way. Kamberi’s attitude and actions were an attempt to engineer a move to a bigger club to the detriment of Hibs, agreed surely? He wanted to go to Rangers who were our direct competition at the time. So he went, he wore the red white and blue, made silly comments in the media, came back to Hibs and was swiftly shunted on. He goes to some team I’ve never heard of - my ignorance the most likely reason - and is now, as we speak, sliding in to obscurity and footballing wilderness.

Take someone like John McGinn, who is our biggest successful transfer since Scott Brown. Kept his head down despite it being well known other clubs were interested, still worked his socks off during our European campaign and ultimately got a move to a massive club who are now in one of the top five leagues in Europe.

Compare and contrast the two, then put yourselves in the shoes of an ambitious and talented young player who would look at the two examples and think Hibs might be a good place to go to springboard my career, but on their terms, not mine.

I don’t disagree with any of that, however Hibs got rid of him and rightly so. That shows players we won’t be messed about. His next move isn’t going to change that though. If he goes on and makes us money now, that isn’t going to influence a young player at Hibs. Do you honestly believe if he gets a decent move after being punted by Hibs, that’s going to somehow influence someone coming into Hibs to act like a prat to end up at St Gallen and Bundesliga II, rather than dig in and move down south? No chance.

[NAE NOOKIE]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I agree that continual slagging off of Kamberi is a bit OTT but it’s difficult to ignore his acrimonious departure from Hibs. My erstwhile bitterness has been replaced by gross indifference.

[Keith_M]

Part of me is now wondering if starting this thread was such a good idea.

It was purely because I was surprised the move had failed after only four/five months.

I think that if he can't make it at St Gallen, then a club currently challenging near the top of Bundesliga II must be way above his level.

[Jones28]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What I was trying to say was that the relationship was done and dusted and he was never coming back to hibs long before we agreed to loan him to the huns. We tried to punt him and rightly so and he probably couldn't believe his luck that he was going to the rangers. What he said wasn't detremntal to hibs, he was definitely disrespectful but detremntal?? I didn't notice any harm he caused the club

Sent from my G3121 using Tapatalk

It was detrimental in my opinion because he went from us to one of our rivals, making them stronger and us weaker.

[04Sauzee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It was detrimental in my opinion because he went from us to one of our rivals, making them stronger and us weaker.

Thought we looked stronger with Docherty in the team than Kamberi tbh. Thought we got the better deal.

[hibsbollah]

I’d have him back.


Could do a job in the much undervalued pantomime villain role.

[Jones28]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I don’t disagree with any of that, however Hibs got rid of him and rightly so. That shows players we won’t be messed about. His next move isn’t going to change that though. If he goes on and makes us money now, that isn’t going to influence a young player at Hibs. Do you honestly believe if he gets a decent move after being punted by Hibs, that’s going to somehow influence someone coming into Hibs to act like a prat to end up at St Gallen and Bundesliga II, rather than dig in and move down south? No chance.

It’s all about perception and what someone thinks they could get away with at a club. It’s just an opinion and mines is that Kamberi being a prick, getting shunted on by the club and then fading to obscurity is better for Hibs than him being a prick and moving on to bigger and better things.

John McGinn behaving like a model pro and getting the move he did shows that if you knuckle down at Hibs we are a great club to be at to progress your career, which I think would have been part of the sales pitch to guys like Nisbet.