Several clubs, including Hibs, can rightly feel aggrieved by the way the season has or will be decided. Hibs have more points in the bag than St Johnstone and have one win, one draw and no defeats in matches against them but find themselves below them in the league because St Johnstone had one game in hand. That game was at Ibrox and Saints were unlikely to win it so if it had been played Hibs would have been awarded sixth place instead of seventh. additionally, each club had different teams to play in the now-abandoned end of the season so the PPG approach is intrinsically unfair. I think a fairer approach would have been to apply an average ppg on a head to head basis for the games that still have to be played. For example, Hibs record against Aberdeen was 1W 1D 1L - four points from three games - so Hibs would have got 1.33 points for the remaining game. This broadly ties in with the head to head approach used in World Cup group games.
I've done a very quick analysis of games to be played on this basis, firstly applying it to Partick Thistle as they seemed to be the hardest hit by the method used. This showed that Thistle would have comfortably avoided the drop at the expense of Queen of the South. I then went on to apply it to the Premiership and this shows that Hibs would have made the top six by a couple of points. That would then have led to the following tables:
Top six
Celtic 100.33 points
Sevco 82.17
Aberdeen 58.5
Motherwell 54.66
Livingston 45.83
Hibs 45.33
Bottom six
St Johnstone 44.33
St Mirren 44.17
Kilmarnock 43.5
Ross County 37.33
Hamilton 34.17
Hearts 27.83
Of course this doesn't take account of home advantage or the fact that Hibs were improving under Jack Ross while Hearts were deteriorating under their new manager, but it shows that the clubs that have a genuine grievance were Aberdeen, Hibs and St Mirren, while Hearts got exactly what they deserved.
Results 1 to 16 of 16
-
15-05-2020 02:22 PM #1
A fairer way to decide the leagues?
-
-
15-05-2020 02:33 PM #3
English League Two have just decided their league but have applied weightings to home and away matches separately to help be fair and remove bias. St Johnstone have played 16 home games to our 15. This would be enough to keep us 6th?!
-
-
15-05-2020 02:36 PM #5
It’s done now. I’m happy enough with how it worked out.
Time to worry about getting going again.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
15-05-2020 02:41 PM #6
- Join Date
- Apr 2002
- Posts
- 1,388
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Nah, it's been decided now. There was always going to be people unhappy.
If we argued to change this, then you can't really get at Hearts going on about all the games not being completed.
It is by no means perfect, but let's move on.
-
15-05-2020 02:41 PM #7
It seems fairer for sure and because of how external pressures led to the league ending as it did it's my preferred option.
Weightings for current form and to reflect the home records seem difficult to agree with hindsight.
They might have a chance of working if some methodology could be set in advance and there was a clear understanding about it being binding, so no toys out the pram if clubs don't get what they want.
By the way, how would the table look if you got the numbers and made adjustments for clubs who say they had allocated £X spefically to avoid relegation and had been denied that lofty ambition?
I'm no expert but it might be that just a combination of inferior goal difference and a 4 point deficit is enough?
Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk
"I did not need any persuasion to play for such a great club, the Hibs result is still one of the first I look for"
Sir Matt Busby
-
15-05-2020 02:48 PM #8
Interesting about Thistle.
Why didn’t they make more noise about applying this methodology to their league?
-
15-05-2020 02:49 PM #9
I'm not suggesting the SPFL should change their minds now - it was really just a theoretical exercise to ask whether this or something like it is the way things should have been done. More a point for discussion rather than a call for change.
-
15-05-2020 02:50 PM #10
More proof Hearts will be relegated on merit.
"Washing one's hands of the conflict between the powerful and the powerless means to side with the powerful, not to be neutral.' - Paulo Freire
-
15-05-2020 02:52 PM #11This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk
"I did not need any persuasion to play for such a great club, the Hibs result is still one of the first I look for"
Sir Matt Busby
-
15-05-2020 02:54 PM #12
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Age
- 81
- Posts
- 13,826
I am willing to provide the SPFL with a large hat containing 12 slips of paper containing the words “Heart of Midlothian F.C.”.Mr Doncaster will then be blindfolded and draw out a random slip.Couldn’t be fairer.
-
15-05-2020 02:59 PM #13This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
United we stand here....
-
15-05-2020 03:03 PM #14
Hearts are clinging to the hope that Coronavirus will put a nail in the coffins of a few clubs, enforcing some form of reconstruction where they will get a reprieve. I’ve read a few posts over there where they’ve said that, while they would not wish the disease on anyone, they hoped it would continue for a long time. What a perverse, contradictory and anti-society attitude.
-
15-05-2020 05:32 PM #15This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Anyway you slice it, Hearts deserve to go down.
-
15-05-2020 06:40 PM #16This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
There is after all a mathematical chance that Hearts may have avoided relegation, so only eleven slips should have their name. The twelfth should read "Rangers FC" so that we can find out just how serious Sevco are about being that particular club.
And since Sky will insist on four Old Firm games we'd then get to relegate the other arse cheek at the same time. In fact, let's make all twelve slips "Rangers FC" and just keep Hearts upMature, sensible signature required for responsible position. Good prospects for the right candidate. Apply within.
Log in to remove the advert |
Bookmarks