A little bit of ambition too much to ask boardroom??

[tonyrougier123]

We signed a load of players struggling at our club.

The players were there in the summer to bring in.

Steph omeonga

Efe ambrose

Lawrence shankland

Joe tortalano

Just a few examples of the sort of spine our team needed.

No one can tell me these boys went on to bigger things than hibs.

Its not asking much surely?

Last season we as the fans knew the squad was not balanced well,it cost us a really good coach in neil lennon(some wont agree fair enough).

We brought in heckingbottom got the initial bounce,then we lose the players brought in january who made the difference,even the head coach said himself omeonga was his best defender last season.
Then the summer window opens and business is attended to early,but still the same repetitive recruitment problems are evident in this season's roster.
That is before we even talk about the failings of the coaching team who are unprepared for a relegation dogfight.

If people at the club do not get their heads out of the clouds and see what is happening, we will end up back in the second tier of scottish football scratching our collective heads looking for answers as to what went wrong.

And as a support I think we have adequately raised our collective concerns on the issues needing addressed,across all social media platforms.

Some eloquently and others not so.
But make no mistake we are all hibernian,and thats why we are telling you!!

GGTTH

[oldbutdim]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

We signed a load of players struggling at our club.

The players were there in the summer to bring in.

Steph omeonga

Efe ambrose

Lawrence shankland

Joe tortalano

Just a few examples of the sort of spine our team needed.

No one can tell me these boys went on to bigger things than hibs.

Its not asking much surely?

Last season we as the fans knew the squad was not balanced well,it cost us a really good coach in neil lennon(some wont agree fair enough).

We brought in heckingbottom got the initial bounce,then we lose the players brought in january who made the difference,even the head coach said himself omeonga was his best defender last season.
Then the summer window opens and business is attended to early,but still the same repetitive recruitment problems are evident in this season's roster.
That is before we even talk about the failings of the coaching team who are unprepared for a relegation dogfight.

If people at the club do not get their heads out of the clouds and see what is happening, we will end up back in the second tier of scottish football scratching our collective heads looking for answers as to what went wrong.

And as a support I think we have adequately raised our collective concerns on the issues needing addressed,across all social media platforms.

Some eloquently and others not so.
But make no mistake we are all hibernian,and thats why we are telling you!!

GGTTH

Well said.

[tonyrougier123]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Well said.

You having a sly pop at peoples opinion oldbutdim??😱

[ehf]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

We signed a load of players struggling at our club.

The players were there in the summer to bring in.

Steph omeonga

Efe ambrose

Lawrence shankland

Joe tortalano

Just a few examples of the sort of spine our team needed.



GGTTH

Apparently we refused to meet Tortolano's wage demands, so recruited Newell in his place. We were close to a deal for Benny Brazil but there were complications with his agent and Hecky decided to go for Vela instead.

[Aim Here]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

We signed a load of players struggling at our club.

The players were there in the summer to bring in.

Steph omeonga

Efe ambrose

Lawrence shankland

Joe tortalano

Just a few examples of the sort of spine our team needed.

No one can tell me these boys went on to bigger things than hibs.

Its not asking much surely?

It is.

Omeonga (or at least Genoa), Ambrose and Shankland were asking for more money than Hibs can afford - or at least they're demanding more money than Hibs think they're worth. Genoa think Omeonga is worth more than we can afford to pay for him (and I'm sure we tried to get his loan extended). Ambrose's wages were only cheap due to a mixture of Neil Lennon's influence and Efe's need for a UK visa - he's able to be more picky now. And we were outbid for Shankland by Dundee United who also have a new owner throwing money at their club, and willing to pay silly money for him - and in United's case, it's not silly. If we get Shankland, there's no guarantee he would make that much financial difference to us by getting us into Europe, say. Having him in Dundee United could easily mean the difference between promotion and another year of second-tier football, making him a much more concrete return on investment, financially speaking. Shankland is worth more to them than he is to us, and Dundee United paid out accordingly. (Sure, we're in relegation territory right now and splurging on players to keep us up might be necessary, but nobody expected that in the summer).

And yes, Tortalano's wage bill is perhaps affordable these days, but I'm not sure his first-team fitba' would be up to scratch after twenty years out of the game.

If you know where to find players of the calibre you suggest, at a price that Hibs can afford, feel free to alert the scouting team, but getting players isn't as easy as you're making out.

[SickBoy32]

Absolutely no excuse to have not went for Shankland, was the most obvious signing of the summer.

Not even sure it’s a question of boardroom ambition as the manager was heavily backed, and let’s be honest he wasted all the funds.

I do however think that the delay in the sacking of the manager shows a lack of ambition/bottle though. Quite incredible he lingers on.

[we are hibs]

Shankland wouldve suffered with the way we play.

[Jim44]

There’s no doubting Shankland’s scoring ability, at least at Championship level, so I’ve never understood the lack of interest in him from Premiership clubs. He would score for fun in a good team at the higher level.

[MWHIBBIES]

Board showed ambition, backed the manager and spent money.

[calumhibee1]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Absolutely no excuse to have not went for Shankland, was the most obvious signing of the summer.

Not even sure it’s a question of boardroom ambition as the manager was heavily backed, and let’s be honest he wasted all the funds.

I do however think that the delay in the sacking of the manager shows a lack of ambition/bottle though. Quite incredible he lingers on.

Do you know we didn’t go for Shankland? Seeing as DU have a wage bill 130% of their turnover and no other players of any real note I wouldn’t be surprised if the wages they’re paying him would have blown us out the water.

[Jim44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Do you know we didn’t go for Shankland? Seeing as DU have a wage bill 130% of their turnover and no other players of any real note I wouldn’t be surprised if the wages they’re paying him would have blown us out the water.

I’m not doubting this figure, but I always thought that UEFA or FIFA had rules about the wage bill to turnover amount.

The crux of FFP regulations is the break-even requirement, where clubs are ordered to not spend more than the income that they generate, and that they must balance their books over the course of three years.

[calumhibee1]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I’m not doubting this figure, but I always thought that UEFA or FIFA had rules about the wage bill to turnover amount.

The crux of FFP regulations is the break-even requirement, where clubs are ordered to not spend more than the income that they generate, and that they must balance their books over the course of three years.

I’m sure someone said on here before that we don’t have FFP in Scotland. I wonder if that’s the case?

[Jim44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I’m sure someone said on here before that we don’t have FFP in Scotland. I wonder if that’s the case?

I think we do but I think DU will be working within the rules.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/29361839

[calumhibee1]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think we do but I think DU will be working within the rules.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/29361839

[Since452]

I don't get why people are getting hung up on Shankland. He's out of our price range. Dundee United paying him a fortune. I work up in Dundee and it's well known how much he's earning. Doubt we could afford Omeonga's wages either. Did we not make Ambrose the best offer we could and he decided to use the get out clause instead?

Joe Tortolano is definitely one we could have got in however there's a rumour going about that he would only sign if he could flat share with Jimmy Boco and Rod said no.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

The Dundee UTD £3.7M loss last year maybe goes some way to explain why we didn’t push the boat out for Shankland, McNulty, Omeonga and Ambrose etc.

[The Harp Awakes]

At the start of LD's tenure the ambition was there; we managed to entice NL to the club and we were recruiting players, albeit loanees, from top premiership sides, e.g., Liverpool and Man City (twice).

Our level of ambition nose dived when NL left (perhaps that's the root cause of why he left?) and we appointed a relatively unknown and inexperienced HC with no knowledge of the the Club or the Scottish game. The Board clearly did not do their due diligence on him before the appointment. During Heck's tenure our recruitment has focused on the English lower leagues with disastrous consequences in terms of the quality of player brought in.

Our level of ambition has nose dived at a time when it should have risen; following promotion, the SC win, consolidating our position in the top 4/5 of the SPL, record home gates, feel good factor etc.

Unless there is a major injection of cash from our new owner to get us out of this mess, we will be in for several seasons of scraping draws against clubs with a fraction of our budget. Something has gone badly wrong with leadership at the Club over the past year to 18 months and the inability to put it right/act is generating a huge disconnect between the Club and the fans.

[ScottB]

What do you mean by ‘ambition’ exactly?

The quality of the players we signed is in question, but we undoubtedly used our resources to sign them. I see no evidence we have some unused cash pile sitting around that could have been spent, so, in this case, ambition means let’s run up a big loss on the playing budget?

It’s not ambitious to spend money you don’t have.

[Smartie]

I don’t have much of a problem with the standard of player signed. It’s how the budget only managed to stretch to getting a squad with such serious deficiencies in it that I have a problem with. There are various reasons why that might be.

[WeeRussell]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Board showed ambition, backed the manager and spent money.

That's my understanding too I just think they got the wrong guy.

[Barman Stanton]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What do you mean by ‘ambition’ exactly?

The quality of the players we signed is in question, but we undoubtedly used our resources to sign them. I see no evidence we have some unused cash pile sitting around that could have been spent, so, in this case, ambition means let’s run up a big loss on the playing budget?

It’s not ambitious to spend money you don’t have.

Didnt Gordon reportedly put around £1M into the club? If so then we do indeed have unused cash sitting around. They just dont want to spend it on the actual team.

[The 90+2]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The Dundee UTD £3.7M loss last year maybe goes some way to explain why we didn’t push the boat out for Shankland, McNulty, Omeonga and Ambrose etc.

Or they budgeted on promotion last season and it failed to materialise? They have still shown more ambition to get promoted again with their signings.

[worcesterhibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Or they budgeted on promotion last season and it failed to materialise? They have still shown more ambition to get promoted again with their signings.

I guess it depends whether you consider racking up debt to be ambition or stupidity.

[The 90+2]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I guess it depends whether you consider racking up debt to be ambition or stupidity.

We have hardly been making money ourselves in recent time.

[hfc rd]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Board showed ambition, backed the manager and spent money.

Agree.

100% they backed the manager in the summer but the problem now is that he’s wasted all that money on utter dross. That’s Heckingbottom’s fault and the blame firmly lies at his doorstep.

[tonyrougier123]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Board showed ambition, backed the manager and spent money.

So had he not been backed what type of player would we have brought in? Genuine question.
Looks like the barrel was well and truly scraped summer window,no quality in there whatsoever or ambition,scotty aside who was signed in january pre contract.

Scary thought that was a window the manager was backed in.

Some people are easily convinced what consists of a club the size of ours backing a manager.

Auckinleck talbot got any decent defensive midfielders?

[Andy74]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

So had he not been backed what type of player would we have brought in? Genuine question.
Looks like the barrel was well and truly scraped summer window,no quality in there whatsoever or ambition,scotty aside who was signed in january pre contract.

Scary thought that was a window the manager was backed in.

Some people are easily convinced what consists of a club the size of ours backing a manager.

Auckinleck talbot got any decent defensive midfielders?

It’s not too tricky. Being backed is getting a budget to the limit of what we can afford.

We’ve done that. What the manager has ultimately spent it on is up to him.

[tonyrougier123]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It’s not too tricky. Being backed is getting a budget to the limit of what we can afford.

We’ve done that. What the manager has ultimately spent it on is up to him.

What did we actually spend though?,we already sourced from the bargain section of the transfer market.
We also had a fair few squad places vacant,not like we inflated an already bulging squad.

[hfc rd]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What did we actually spend though?,we already sourced from the bargain section of the transfer market.
We also had a fair few squad places vacant,not like we inflated an already bulging squad.

We did our business very early which showed that the board backed Heckingbottom and were willing to get the players in that he wanted early doors so they could have a pre-season together and build something towards the new season. We spent £200K-£300K on Doidge and had a £120K offer for Ojo accepted by S***thorpe only for him to turn us down for the sheep which looks like we dodged a bullet there too.

Just because these signings haven’t worked out, cannot be the boards fault. The blame lies firmly at Heckingbottom’s doorstep. These are the players that he wanted and it’s shown that they are not good enough.

[Smartie]

It might be that we've seen so little end product in a positive sense from many of our highest earners in the league.

Injury has deprived us of some - Gray and McGregor must be on a few quid each and have played very little football, I'd imagine Boyle's last contract would have seen him up there with our highest earners and we've got 10 minutes out of him in the league (a good 10 minutes mind).

Marciano and Kamberi have been on the bench a lot, they must be 2 of our highest earners. Not many saves or goals from them. Newell won't have come here for buttons, he's not started many games, not created much, not scored any in the league. Jackson hasn't really played much, I'd expect him to be on a decent wage.

In spite of playing every minute have we really seen enough in a positive sense from Stevie Mallan? I'd imagine we've spent a fair bit in wages to get him back from Barnsley, he was last season's marquee signing. The same could be said for Vela - it'll have taken a few quid to get him up here, he's been on the park a lot but what impact has he really made?

And that's before we get on to everybody's favourite goal machine.


That's a lot of season ticket ££££ for very little return.


If you go back a few years and compare the early "return on investment" on the following - what did we get from Martin Boyle for a swap deal with Alex Harris? What did we get from Jason Cummings having signed him from Hutchie Vale and paid him (presumably peanuts) for a year before breaking into the first team? Darren McGregor on his free from Sevco, straight into the team as an outstanding regular. Malonga, signed on a free and a mercurial talent from day one. Scott Allan, a few weeks to get up to speed and a free transfer who was playing out his skin. Marvin Bartley, signed for nowt and dominating the midfield in derbies like we've rarely seen. And then the compensation found for a SJM, a player who is now an established international, a premiership player who is being talked about being transferred for insane figures.