Jack or Bartley?

[Mango Man]

Did Marv do enough to take over the infamous Matty Jack role?

I guess only time will tell, but I think Marv edges it for me, MJ was quality though.

[3pm]

Bartley.

[Speedy]

Jack had his time.

Bartley won a Scottish cup, beating Hearts in the process

[Shrekko]

50/50- both great guys and cracking Hibs players.

[Tobias Funke]

Both did great jobs in the respective Hibs sides at the time. I don’t think Jack was that great technically but his contribution towards the great 2000/01 season was outstanding. Marv is a better footballer so shades it for me.

I wholeheartedly agree with Shrekkos comment, great guys

[Since452]

Jack is a cult hero. Bartley is a club legend. That's the difference.

[sauzee=legend]

Give them a half each

[Diclonius]

Jack only won one derby in eight and in that derby we were losing when he was substituted. Bartley only lost one derby in ten, and in that derby we weren't losing when he was substituted.

[Yellowcard]

Marv all day every day

[tamig]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Jack only won one derby in eight and in that derby we were losing when he was substituted. Bartley only lost one derby in ten, and in that derby we weren't losing when he was substituted.

Replaced by Lyndon Andrews? And the rest is Hibstory. What a night.

[Greentinted]

Marvin for me, all day and all night long. Nothing against Matty Jack by any means, but Marv just seem to ‘get’ us on every level.

[AgentDaleCooper]

Only one of them has a Scottish Cup winners medal. Only one of them ran the city for four years. It's the Marvin Bartley role now.

[matty_f]

Bartley.

[Sammy7nil]

Jack played in a better team against better players Imho of course.