Spfl poty

[LewysGot2]

Who do you reckon will be POTY for the league?

Shanklandstein bound to be shortlisted
Miovski?
Bair?

Or the usual Ugly Sister fest…

Butland?
ORiley?
Penalty-Tavenier?


YPotY possibly Lennon Miller?

[JimBHibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Who do you reckon will be POTY for the league?

Shanklandstein bound to be shortlisted
Miovski?
Bair?

Or the usual Ugly Sister fest…

Butland?
ORiley?
Penalty-Tavenier?


YPotY possibly Lennon Miller?

OReilly for me

[Unseen work]

Hate to say it but it’s got to be Shankland.

Oriley was brilliant until January and then fell off quite a bit

[The Spaceman]

Shankland.

He’s single-handedly got Hearts to third. Without him, they are a bottom six side. They’ll be a very different team once he leaves this summer (thank god).

[Winston Ingram]

O’Riley for me

[Alex Trager]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Shankland.

He’s single-handedly got Hearts to third. Without him, they are a bottom six side. They’ll be a very different team once he leaves this summer (thank god).

Agree it’s him.

Don’t agree they’d be bottom six though. They’re solid at the back.

Agree he’ll be gone and they’ll struggle big time without him.

[Is It On....]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Shankland.

He’s single-handedly got Hearts to third. Without him, they are a bottom six side. They’ll be a very different team once he leaves this summer (thank god).

You could also argue that Mioviski has single handedly kept Aberdeen up 🤔

[Pretty Boy]

A non OF striker being the top goalscorer isn't as rare as you would expect. In recent times Michael Higdon, Kris Boyd, Adam Rooney, Liam Boyce and Regan Charles Cook have all achieved it. On that metric alone I'm not convinced Shankland deserves it.

Overall though he has had a very good season and if it was a Hibs player in such a position we would all be screaming he deserved it. I think it should be Shankland based on his all round contribution over the course of the season. He's been the best player in an annoyingly decent Hearts team.

[Diclonius]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

A non OF striker being the top goalscorer isn't as rare as you would expect. In recent times Michael Higdon, Kris Boyd, Adam Rooney, Liam Boyce and Regan Charles Cook have all achieved it. On that metric alone I'm not convinced Shankland deserves it.

Overall though he has had a very good season and if it was a Hibs player in such a position we would all be screaming he deserved it. I think it should be Shankland based on his all round contribution over the course of the season. He's been the best player in an annoyingly decent Hearts team.

To be fair Higdon and Griffiths both won POTY playing for non-OF clubs.

[Albert Kidd 86’]

Macgregor is always my pick, he is the only scottish player from the spl that would start in the top half of the epl imho.

shankland and cantwell would be my other picks.

[Centre Hawf]

I'm not saying it wouldn't be deserved as it probably would be my choice (begrudgingly) but I think when you have someone like Shankland being a massive performer from outside the Glasgow two then I think everyone will likely jump on it as it's a good bit of news for someone else to win it other than O'Reilly or Tav for example. Probably a bit healthier for the game as well.

[easty]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Macgregor is always my pick, he is the only scottish player from the spl that would start in the top half of the epl imho.

shankland and cantwell would be my other picks.

I don't think Cantwell should even be in the picture for it at all. He's been nowhere near O'Reillys level at Celtc this season.

Cantwell has 6 goals and 6 assists in 39 games for Rangers this season. That's not a good return for a Rangers attacking midfielder.

O'Reilly has 14 goals and 16 assists in 43 games for Celtc.

Those stats aside, O'Reilly uses the ball much better and doesn't spend half the time rolling about greetin after someone barely touches him.