Andrew Shinnie Signs on Loan

[GISALEGEND]

Great bit of business getting Shinnie, had been keeping eyes peeled on it, for me I think should do the business in the division, yes it's a loan deal but feel he's what we need to bring more attacking depth.
I talk about the deal & Marciano briefly in latest Transfer news video,

[Jim44]

Good addition, especially since Henderson is unlikely to come on loan. I see he's on the bench for Celtic tonight.

[GISALEGEND]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Good addition, especially since Henderson is unlikely to come on loan. I see he's on the bench for Celtic tonight.

Definitely buddy feel Shinnie is a better option than Henderson only on experience but see what happens, Henderson only seems feasible on loan, but no parties want it.

[allezsauzee]

I think Henderson is a much more talented footballer , however Shinnie will likely score more goals. I would still like Liam back as well. Hopefully if Celtic get into the Champions League they might free him to make way for a more experienced player.

[GISALEGEND]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think Henderson is a much more talented footballer , however Shinnie will likely score more goals. I would still like Liam back as well. Hopefully if Celtic get into the Champions League they might free him to make way for a more experienced player.

Obviously Liam has got time on his side as still young enough to develop & Shinnie is now 27 but feel for what we need Shinnie is ideal and is a valid point too.

[Nutmegged]

They're two completely different players, I don't see it as one or the other, there's space in the side for both of them

[Edson Arantes]

Henderson is much more preferable than erm... who?

Hendo is so much a better player.

[sambajustice]

Shinnie has only scored about 6 times in 70 odd games Brum has he not???

If that's the case, he's not the "pat mcginlay" we're crying out for.

If he's been playing English championship however he's been at a much higher level than Scottish Championship (and premier) so is a good signing really.

To really smash this league we need probably a couple of "not strikers" to get 10-12 goals...

I think...

[GISALEGEND]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Shinnie has only scored about 6 times in 70 odd games Brum has he not???

If that's the case, he's not the "pat mcginlay" we're crying out for.

If he's been playing English championship however he's been at a much higher level than Scottish Championship (and premier) so is a good signing really.

To really smash this league we need probably a couple of "not strikers" to get 10-12 goals...

I think...

He generally plays as CM so decent record I'd say even in championship & that's right for his return. Who knows he may get say 8-10 goals/assists would be a solid return from him.