As we are coming to the end of an "interesting" season which can still end in glory I thought I would give my thoughts on the team this season.
Oxley - 5
Disappointing season for the Ox. It seems like nearly every shot goes past him. Still have a wee bit of faith in him though.
Conrad Logan - 10
Saturday may have been a fluke but the big man deserves a mention for a incredible performance.
Lewis Stevenson - 6
Average. Doesn't cause enough threat going forward. Liability at the back sometimes but can use his pace to get him out of sticky situations... sometimes.
David Gray - 7
More of an attacking threat. Makes one to many mistakes for me but love his passion.
Paul Hanlon - 8
On form he is our best defender. So consistent. Not been as good since coming back from injury though.
Darren Mcgregor - 7
Very reliable defender. Not the best form at the moment and his distribution from the back sometimes has been shocking.
Liam Fontaine - 6
Average compared to last season. Too many mistakes. On form is a very good defender. His conversion rate from corners is awful!
Niklas Gunarsson - 6
Not seen much of him. Looked reliable when called into action. Good back up. Would like to see hibs sign him in the summer.
Marvin Bartley - 9
Bartley has been immense. So consistent. Probaly been our most consistent palyer of the season. Great signing!
Fraser Fyvie - 6
Not a big fan of him. You may disagree but I'm a bit underwhelmed whenever he plays. Still has sparks of talent though.
Dylan Mcgeoch - 7
Too many injuries but is very good when he does play and I think we miss him.
John Mcginn - 9
On form he is the best player in the league. Form dropped recently but still a superb talent. Hope we hold on to him.
Liam Henderson - 8
Future celtic star. Been consistently good all season. Occasionally tries one trick too many. Would like him for another year.
Kevin Thompson - 5
Past it for me. Slows the game down. Still can pick out a good pass though.
Jason Cummings - 8
Daft but clinical. Ups and downs for jason this season but its nice that Hibs have a 20+ goals a season striker. That's in the championship though. Can see him gone in the summer.
Anthony Stokes - 7
Been decent while back at Hibs. Not had the best service. Great work ethic even in this league. Very talented when in full flow.
Martin Boyle - 7
"Squirrel" has changed games when coming on for us this season but never seems to impress when he starts. Super sub.
James Keatings - 5
Great start to his hibs career but gone downhill from there. Nothing is going right for him. While on form he is a great striker.
Chris Dagnall - 4
Not been given much of a chance but really disappointing when he is played. Dissatisfied as he was clinical down in England.
Farid El injury -
What are your thoughts on the team this season?
Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
Results 1 to 25 of 25
Thread: Player ratings so far...
-
18-04-2016 07:08 PM #1
Player ratings so far...
-
18-04-2016 07:11 PM #2
- Join Date
- Nov 2015
- Location
- Livingston
- Age
- 40
- Posts
- 972
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
18-04-2016 07:23 PM #3This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
-
18-04-2016 07:37 PM #5
Lewi Stevenson gets the same rating as Gunnarsson? Wtf?
Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
-
18-04-2016 07:44 PM #6This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
-
18-04-2016 07:47 PM #7This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Don't let that get in the way of putting one of our stand out players down though.
Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
-
18-04-2016 07:51 PM #8
A reasonable assessment. Brave of you to post it, there's always going to be folk queueing up to have a go at you!
-
18-04-2016 08:03 PM #9This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
-
-
18-04-2016 08:16 PM #11This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
18-04-2016 08:59 PM #12This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show QuoteThis is how it feels
-
18-04-2016 10:07 PM #13This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
The original poster has posted marks for players as HE sees them........ i dont agree either how he has cast his account of Lewis, but i never will !
I dont agree with his ratings overall either but i know that this is ONE person only and its his view. Whether its right or wrong is up to him.
PS Id give lewis a 10/10 myself but then again im biased!!!
-
19-04-2016 07:40 AM #14This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
19-04-2016 07:44 AM #15This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
19-04-2016 10:14 AM #16
Stevenson has had a far better season than gray. the OPs rating for him appears to be based upon last season.
Neither have been perfect defensively but I can think of more times that Gray has been caught out of position and Stevenson has way more assists.
-
19-04-2016 10:15 AM #17This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
19-04-2016 10:48 AM #18
Lewis Stevenson defense force springs in to action again. You better up your mark for Lewis because you will be accused of abusing him if you don't rate him as highly as his supporters.
I like Lewis the person, I think he hasn't been a 6 this season, probably a 7.
The post is one persons opinion and he's also asking for yours, so post yours don't just berate him for not having the same favourite player as you.
-
19-04-2016 11:00 AM #19This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Last edited by SeanWilson; 19-04-2016 at 11:03 AM.
-
19-04-2016 11:11 AM #20
Ok, rather than disagree with the OP, I'll share my scores.
Oxley - 6 - Not as bad as has been made out. I think he's actually been better this season than last, and was fairly solid for the first half of the season. A couple of errors in the 2nd half have caused people to remember most of his decent work earlier in the season.
Conrad Logan - N/A - 1 swallow does not make a summer so would be unfair on him or anyone else to base his score on 1 game.
Lewis Stevenson - 7
Solid. Decent number of assists, always gives 100%, and covers that whole left side for 90 minutes.
David Gray - 6
Has had a poor season compared to last. Hasn't looked fully fit.
Paul Hanlon - 8
Solid this season. Hope he signs a new deal. Has been missed when out.
Darren Mcgregor - 6.5
Looked like signing of the season when he first came in, but has been off the boil of late.
Liam Fontaine - 6
Another who has gone backwards from last season, but that may be down to injuries and not getting a regular run in the team.
Niklas Gunarsson - 6
Has always looked decent enough when called upon. Would have liked to have seen more of him.
Marvin Bartley - 8
Came in and couldn't quite get a regular place but since January he has been simply outstanding and has been a contender for MOTM nearly every game.
Fraser Fyvie - 6
Good player thats been missed but seems to need a run of games to get to good form and hasn't always managed that this year with injuries.
Dylan Mcgeoch - 6
Probably our most important player but far too injury prone to have had the desired effect this season.
John Mcginn - 8
Super John Mcginn has just been John Mcginn for the last couple of months. Seems jaded, and also wasted when out on the left hand side. Was inspirational early on tho, especially in the big matches.
Liam Henderson - 7
Slow start to his Hibs time, and got dropped for a while but took his chance when he got back in and his passion shines through.
Kevin Thompson - 5.5
Stood tall in the games against Hearts, but tends to slow games down to much, and I can't let him off for that slack pass in the cup final.
Jason Cummings - 7.5
Impossible to argue with his goals, but still al ong way from the finished article. Has definitely improved as a player in the last 2 seasons tho.
Anthony Stokes - 6.5
Not the goal a game we were all expecting, but has had a reasonable return. Took a while to get to match fitness but certainly seems to be working hard.
Martin Boyle - 6
Game changer at times from the bench but looks lost at times when starting. Definition of a supersub.
James Keatings - 5
Looked like we'd gained from Hearts mistake, but a loss of confidence and being played out of position has caused him to be invisible in games at times.
Chris Dagnall - 3
Looked good in his first game but being unable to find the net has really knocked the stuffing out of him and he doesnt look like he'd score if he played 90 mins every week. Hard to be effective in fleeting appearances tho.
Farid El Alagui - 2 - The most frustrating of all. Could be such an important player for us but his appearance on Saturday summed up his whole hibs career.
-
19-04-2016 11:15 AM #21
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Posts
- 22,675
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
19-04-2016 11:44 AM #22
[QUOTE=MWHIBBIES;4653603]Fyvie has had 1 bad game after another all season, never a 6.
Sorted
-
19-04-2016 12:21 PM #23
Oxley - 4. No real howlers but I just don't think he's a good GK.
Lewis - 6. As always 110% effort, but effort alone doesn't win games and this season particularly he's not been good enough going forward.
Hanlon - 8. I think he's getting better and better. Calm and composed and good on the ball.
McGregor - 7. A good addition and generally solid, although has been prone to a few costly mistakes.
Gray - 6. Set the bar very high last year but hasn't matched those standards. I often think he may not be fully fit.
McGinn - 8. 4 year contract. Well done to whoever negotiated that. First half of the season he was a 10/10 but looks to be running out of steam.
Bartley - 8. Unsung hero. The player we've been crying out for for years.
Fyvie - 6. Hot and cold when fit. Needs to add more goals to his game and cut out the mistakes.
McGeouch - 7. Usually the best player on the park when fit. The problem is he's rarely fit.
Henderson - 7. Quality player and gives his all. I do think in the championship he should have a few more goals to his name.
Boyle - 5. I think we need to find a position for him to thrive.
Jason - 8. Goals speak for themselves. Needs to work harder on being a team player though. Still needs to mature a lot too.
Stokes - 6. Hasn't been nearly as good as he could or should have been.
Dagnall - 4. We traded Malonga for him??
Fontaine - 5. Not had the best of seasons.
Keatings - 5. Thought we had a real player on our hands when he hit a purple patch early on in the season, but I've been a bit disappointed since. Bit unlucky with his amount of game time recently.
-
19-04-2016 12:35 PM #24This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
19-04-2016 02:59 PM #25This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Always blows my mind how little people actually understand about football. If a midfielder doesn't smash people or score 15 goals he is rubbish. Fyvie is an excellent player with big potential, really hope people realize that and we don't lose him.
Log in to remove the advert |
Bookmarks