Alan Stubbs report card

[theonlywayisup]

It has now been over three months since Alan Stubbs joined Hibs. How would you score his first three months at Hibs?

[GGTTH07]

6/10

[GGTTH07]

Extra point for Monday night!

[Sir David Gray]

6/10.

Encouraging signs of progress but certainly room for improvement.

[Northernhibee]

7.5/10 - started to address the weaknesses in defense and personnel that Butcher left him, much improved style of play and also signed some cracking players.

[Elephant Stone]

His signings are impressive and the existing players are starting to play to their capabilities. There were always going to be some inconsistencies in results and performances with so many changes happening and there will no doubt be more to come but overall I'm happy with how things are going.

[Scottie]

Positive signs but must do better as the AGM is just round the corner.



Luv the big man. Slow start but revolution is under way. 8/10.

[StarMan10]

Like to give my first real judgement after the first round of fixtures finishes. Win the next two games I'd give him a 7/10. Less than that = 6/10

[3pm]

Won 3, Lost 4. 5.5/10 with masses of room for improvement. Potential is exciting.

[MrSmith]

No score from me! We are in the first division or championship or whatever!! I expect him to get us out of this league by promotion, anything less, at this point, is a fail!! Sorry to be so blunt but one good result does not make us unbeatable nor finished article. Good luck to the big fella.

[Brooster]

Having been to East Mains and seen/heard the mess that existed before he arrived I would give him a 7.5. I'm convinced he will get it right given time. His signings have been very good and he knows how to change tactics and players/formations during games. Yes he has made mistakes but he has the will and knowledge to succed. Lets support him along the way.

[Boyle89]

6/10. Not taking off Robertson in the derby loses points and for not beating Alloa aswell. Wasn't at qos or Falkirk games so can't comment. Only gets 1 point for ibrox cause we let in a goal which is unacceptable ;).

[Forza Fred]

Too early to give a mark but is settling in well, despite some early set backs.

Christmas will be the appropriate time to give a considered mark.

[O'Rourke3]

Play every week like we play The Rangers then superb. Play every week like we played against Cowdenbeath then we'll need more luck as well as the increase in fitness. Too early to tell as we've had no run in either direction. I'm hoping for far more like Monday but not every team will try and win against us and give us the space to play in. More positive results against the bottom half are required in order to get a 9/10.

[Turkish Green]

If we are rating the team that played against Rangers then 9/10. However if we rate the team that played against Alloa and Cowdenbeath then 3/10. So averaging 6/10 but I will deduct a point for the derby game tactics which were very poor.

Overall an improving 5/10 must try harder.

[Pretty Boy]

6.5/10.

Much improved in some areas, still lots of room for further improvement.

[SMAXXA]

11/10 for taking over the shambles that was HFC

[B.H.F.C]

Improvement on last year and some good signings. Showed teams too much respect though. Particularly Hearts when that game was there to win.

[HH81]

5 or 6 ish is around where we are at the moment.

[jacomo]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

No score from me! We are in the first division or championship or whatever!! I expect him to get us out of this league by promotion, anything less, at this point, is a fail!! Sorry to be so blunt but one good result does not make us unbeatable nor finished article. Good luck to the big fella.

Yeah definitely AS to blame for us being in this division. :rolleyes

I like the fella. Nice to see a Hibs team trying to play football again.

[MrSmith]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Yeah definitely AS to blame for us being in this division. :rolleyes

I like the fella. Nice to see a Hibs team trying to play football again.

cheers for putting words in my post! I expect us to be out this division not settling for a score card in league we shouldn't be in.

[Keith_M]

Mixed results. Some signs of progress. Needs to improve consistency of better results.

[we are hibs]

5/10. Average start to the season. Need a very good run to even think about promotion.

[Hibeesmad]

6/10. Pre season looked good and we were happy with the majority of the signings. Haven't had the best start to the season but the last 2 games have shown a new formula which seems to suit us and I think we can develop on that. If we had lost on Monday and last tuesday it could have been as low as a 4 or 5 but at the moment id give him a 6

[Ozyhibby]

Pat Fenlon football, Terry Butcher results.
:-(

[God Petrie]

Colin calderwood posters

[Golden Bear]

Agh, they're back.

[Allant1981]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Pat Fenlon football, Terry Butcher results.
:-(

Away and dont talk rubbish

[cleanyman]

No one will ever be as bad as Terry Butcher.

He utterly ruined us

[smithy_hibees]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

No one will ever be as bad as Terry Butcher.

He utterly ruined us

He didn't! the club did he was only with us 6months