Murdoch

[The Green Goblin]

Listening to the commentary today and they said Murdoch pulled off a series of amazing saves from what would have been certain goals. Sounds as if he saved us from a real doing today. Hard to find any positives from today but maybe this is one of them.

[Borderhibbie76]

He was a standout today saved us from real hiding and imo should keep his place next week

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

[Tollhouse Hibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He was a standout today saved us from real hiding and imo should keep his place next week

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

It was 2 going on 6 had it not been for Murdoch.

[Baldy]

he was culpable for the first but I put that down to him being too keen to try and impose himself ... however he had just made an outstanding double save then continued to produce great saves.

as Williams is leaving, I would put Murdoch in for the rest of the season

[Diclonius]

Normally I'd put him in goals for our next game based on that performance.

However, it's Hearts and that's a completely different ball game. Also, given that Murdoch is a Hibs fan I'd be worried about nerves overcoming him. Williams back in for me.

[Centre Hawf]

Was excellent today and like most said he saved us from a real hiding.

Not a complaint from me if he plays the rest of the season if Ben is leaving

[blackpoolhibs]

Surely we can't have a keeper just as good as Williams, i didn't think they existed on what we can afford?

[Scouse Hibee]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

he was culpable for the first but I put that down to him being too keen to try and impose himself ... however he had just made an outstanding double save then continued to produce great saves.

as Williams is leaving, I would put Murdoch in for the rest of the season

Yes then we can pick up a keeper from the English leagues who is just as good if not better than Williams, they're in abundance in England apparently.

[heretoday]

Put him in next week if he's on form. He'll have plenty to do.

[Hibercelona]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Normally I'd put him in goals for our next game based on that performance.

However, it's Hearts and that's a completely different ball game. Also, given that Murdoch is a Hibs fan I'd be worried about nerves overcoming him. Williams back in for me.

I think we're better off going with a player who supports the club and is eger to stay, rather than a player that can't wait to leave.

Murdoch will have a point to prove in the derby, Williams won't have anything left to prove.

[HibsNutter]

Respect Murdoch a lot. By the look of his tweets he seems delighted to have been able to play for the team he supports, would happily see him play next week.

[IberianHibernian]

Was very impressed by Murdoch in match in Gibraltar and glad to see him getting a chance .

[Cameron1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I think we're better off going with a player who supports the club and is eger to stay, rather than a player that can't wait to leave.

Murdoch will have a point to prove in the derby, Williams won't have anything left to prove.

Think Williams missus has been due to give birth for the last couple of weeks so guess that will have been playing on his mind.
Don't think Ben has let us down at tynie so far either so I'd be a lot more confident sticking him in goal.

[Scottie]

Very happy the lad's getting his chance at last. Clean sheet next week please Sean

[Hibercelona]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Think Williams missus has been due to give birth for the last couple of weeks so guess that will have been playing on his mind.
Don't think Ben has let us down at tynie so far either so I'd be a lot more confident sticking him in goal.

I agree that he hasn't let us down so far. But with the birth of his child on his mind and other things, I fear his mind just wouldn't be in it this time.

[Pretty Boy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Think Williams missus has been due to give birth for the last couple of weeks so guess that will have been playing on his mind.
Don't think Ben has let us down at tynie so far either so I'd be a lot more confident sticking him in goal.

Apart from the 1st goal in the Caldwell game last season when he came for 3 corners in the 1st half, missed them all and was finally punished at the 3rd one?

Sean Murdoch is a very good goalkeeper who has played a fair few games in the SPL and 1st division. If he's got the gloves then he deserves to keep them. Williams has been pretty poor at times this season and I would have been looking to make a change even if it wasn't enforced.

[Jonnyboy]

Only player worth a pass mark today

[EdinMike]

Sean was my keeper at school, super happy for him and glad he had a good game today. Hope he keeps the gloves for the rest of the season, he deserves his shot !

[B.H.F.C]

Bit like Williams really. Plenty good saves but didn't deal with a ball in from a corner when he should have just come and cleared everyone out.

Plenty good saves today though and it could have been worse if it wasn't for him.

[Greencore]

Good to see him getting a chance for us this season, No dis respect to Williams but if the romours are true and he is heading down south why not play Murdoch for the remaining games to get the boy some confidence, Yes he had ONE good game but it would show that Butcher has faith in him.

[PeterboroHibee]

I think yesterday was the first time Id seen him in goals, and he was decent. He seems a good shot stopper, and was fairly comfortable apart from his mistake on the first goal. The only real negative was that his distribution was a bit hit and miss (something that was apparent during the warm up!), but I think he probably deserves to keep his place next week.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

What he needs is more games and the benefits that come with it.

[Eyrie]

Murdoch is out of contract, so if it's true that Williams is away then it makes sense to give Murdoch the rest of the season to show if he deserves a new deal here. That wouldn't stop us bringing in someone better in the summer, or at least competition for next season.