Penalty claims

[hibee_girl]

Did they look like penalties then?

From the middle of the East it looked like the first claim should have been one but the second looked a bit soft.

[Thecat23]

First one from where I was which is right behind the home dugout looked a stone wall pen. Second I thought yes but not 100% on it.

[hibbybrian]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Did they look like penalties then?

From the middle of the East it looked like the first claim should have been one but the second looked a bit soft.

From the Middle East it looked about the same

[Leighonel]

First one looked like a pen and I thought the second was a foul but it started outside the box, could easily be wrong about the second.

[lord bunberry]

I thought both were penalties, the peonlem is cairney is a markded man because he goes down to easily.

[davhibby]

The first was a pen but I thought the second was outside the box. I'm in the FF though so this is just a guess really

[Taz_hibee]

First defo pen, second free kick just outside IMO

[LaMotta]

First one def pen - why would anyone go down with a free shot at goal 7 yards out?

Second one Collins just flung himself down - no foul ref got it right.

[hibby6270]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

First one def pen - why would anyone go down with a free shot at goal 7 yards out?

Second one Collins just flung himself down - no foul ref got it right.

Agreed

[greenlex]

I didnt think the first one was a foul so no pen for me. The second was defo a foul but couldnt see if it was in the box or not.

[Billy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

First defo pen, second free kick just outside IMO

IMO I'd agree with you

[Emerald]

Gut reaction was the first was a pen and the second was a foul but outside the box. That's from my view at the half way line in the East.

[O'Rourke3]

Can't t remember the order. Collins, probably not. Cairney - stick on again not given.

[matty_f]

They were both fouls, the only thing with the second was whether or not Collins was in the box. Had a great view of both from my seat in the West. Not really sure how bad a foul has to be for Hibs to be given a penalty this season.

[greenlex]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

They were both fouls, the only thing with the second was whether or not Collins was in the box. Had a great view of both from my seat in the West. Not really sure how bad a foul has to be for Hibs to be given a penalty this season.

I thought the first one he was just muscled off the ball. Wouldnt even be a foul anywhere else. Happy to be proved wrong.

[21.05.2016]

First one when Cairney was through defo looked like a pen from when I was sitting.


Second one with Collins, again from where I was sitting looked like a penalty.

I've not seen replays for either, can only judge from what I saw in live action for now.

[TrinityHibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

First one from where I was which is right behind the home dugout looked a stone wall pen. Second I thought yes but not 100% on it.

Just along from TC first yes second 50/50

[PatHead]

We will never know as the BBC will not show it on the highlights. From where I was in the West first was a stonewall penalty and sending off second was just outside box but still a foul.

[18/03/07]

1st one was deffo a penalty and defender should have been shown red card,2nd one not sure if it was in box or outside box but was a deffo foul either way,3rd one Nelson did handle ball in box but i had my green specs on

[BS44]

They both fall down far too easily.

[mutley]

I'll wait to have a better look in the highlights, but for me the first was a penalty . As someone shouted today, what do we need to do to get one, it seems that every penalty decision from the last few games have gone against us.

[weecounty hibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

They both fall down far too easily.

All professional footballers fall down too easily!!

[matty_f]

Just replayed them both in my head, definite penalties. :

[BS44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

All professional footballers fall down too easily!!

Can't ague with that. Collins and Cairneyhill and divers, and diving pees me (and you) right off. I was screaming for penalties at the game, wouldn't be surprised if they both dived

[Danderhall Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Can't ague with that. Collins and Cairneyhill and divers, and diving pees me (and you) right off. I was screaming for penalties at the game, wouldn't be surprised if they both dived

Thing is the refs only give you a foul if you fall down so that's why we have all this "diving" now.

[BS44]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Thing is the refs only give you a foul if you fall down so that's why we have all this "diving" now.

I thought the gollum only gave free kicks for diving today if it didn't affect the game. Craig "fell down".

[greenlex]

Having now seen both. Neither were penalties. If they had been given against us Id be raging.

[MWHIBBIES]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I thought both were penalties, the peonlem is cairney is a markded man because he goes down to easily.

He is a marked man because of Kenny Shiels' lies and Craig Thomson's ineptitude

[givescotlandfreedom]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Can't ague with that. Collins and Cairneyhill and divers, and diving pees me (and you) right off. I was screaming for penalties at the game, wouldn't be surprised if they both dived

If the ref thought they dived surely they should've been booked.

[Onion]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

If the ref thought they dived surely they should've been booked.

First was a penalty. The Killie player was nutmegged and then just threw himself at Crainey with no attempt to play the ball. Just another case of a ref choosing not to apply the rules of the game because it was Hibs & Crainey. Seen far too much of this over recent seasons.

IMHO the second was a decent and fair shoulder charge. Collins didn't get past the Killie defender (same one) and he was just stronger in the challenge.