Whats Kenny Sheils saying aboot this then????

[greenlex]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=uwq0h-snMfU

[Alfred E Newman]

didn't appear to be booked either.

[vanNISHtelroy]

At the game and looking at that once, it looked like Rory stumbled, played the ball after that and didn't appeal for a penalty....didn't react towards the ref until the Hearts players were saying that he should be booked.

[lobster]

The silence is deafening
However given the opposition, definitely a penalty

[Pretty Boy]

Stonewaller.

[Future17]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

At the game and looking at that once, it looked like Rory stumbled, played the ball after that and didn't appeal for a penalty....didn't react towards the ref until the Hearts players were saying that he should be booked.

It's a strange one because it's almost too poor to be a dive. However, although he doesn't claim, he does appear to acknowledge it or apologise to the ref afterwards and doesn't take issue with the Hearts players giving him pelters. Therefore, I think it was an ill-thought-out dive.

I suppose the question is whether a situation like this warrants a yellow card or not.

You may have commented on this on another thread, but what did you think of Cairney's booking for simulation against you guys?

[Woody70x2]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Stonewaller.

Definite stonewaller and Gowan sent off! That could have been a nasty one.

[vanNISHtelroy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It's a strange one because it's almost too poor to be a dive. However, although he doesn't claim, he does appear to acknowledge it or apologise to the ref afterwards and doesn't take issue with the Hearts players giving him pelters. Therefore, I think it was an ill-thought-out dive.

I suppose the question is whether a situation like this warrants a yellow card or not.

You may have commented on this on another thread, but what did you think of Cairney's booking for simulation against you guys?

Commented about it on the thread about it I think. Wasn't sure from where I was sitting...thought it could have been a pen but wasn't sure...but having seen it on the tele it was a stonewaller. Even if it hadn't been a penalty (whether there had been doubt about if he went down easily etc) it wasn't a dive.

[The Green Goblin]

He's lucky to be alive.

[DC_Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

At the game and looking at that once, it looked like Rory stumbled, played the ball after that and didn't appeal for a penalty....didn't react towards the ref until the Hearts players were saying that he should be booked.

I'll put more of a neutral slant on it.

He anticipated a challenge coming in and started to go over. He realised he'd made a james hunt as no challenge was forthcoming so he swung a leg at the ball, never claimed for a foul and then sheepishly kept his heid down.

Kenny Shiels version "The boy Macgowan should have been nicked for attempted murder".

[blackpoolhibs]

He dived, but very quickly realised he was making himself look stupid and tried to stop himself. Silence is deafening though from Sheils, maybe he's decided to abstain from talking bollox on every subject?

[vanNISHtelroy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He dived, but very quickly realised he was making himself look stupid and tried to stop himself. Silence is deafening though from Sheils, maybe he's decided to abstain from talking bollox on every subject?

Yeah people on our forum seem to be agreeing with the first part.

Well when hes not being interviewed post match because of his ban he doesn't get that much chance, maybe he will when he does prematch stuff? Probably not though

[HibbiesandtheBaddies]

Craig Thompson would have awarded a penalty to Hearts.

[ekhibee]

Obviously a dive, but McGowan's one of the ones who gets his wages on time, hence the love affair with Hearts, so I would have given a penalty!

[Tha Cabbage Kid]

shiels wouldnt know coz he doesnt need to watch a replay. ash whole!

[Green Fish]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

shiels wouldnt know coz he doesnt need to watch a replay. ash whole!

I like Shiels even though he's a tit - be a boring world if all managers were like McGlynn!!