Stack plays tonight.

[blackpoolhibs]

Fenlon sticks with Stack, a good decision imo, there's nothing between both keepers imo, Stack shades it for me. Dropping him would have been easy, Brown might feel aggrieved, but i feel its the right call.

[IWasThere2016]

Agreed.

[Steven_Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Fenlon sticks with Stack, a good decision imo, there's nothing between both keepers imo, Stack shades it for me. Dropping him would have been easy, Brown might feel aggrieved, but i feel its the right call.

Time will tell if its the right call

[hibeedonald]

Some of the abuse on here was unreal, he had 1 bad game.

[LancashireHibby]

Quite right, doesn't do anyone any good to keep swapping 'keepers. I'm sure Stacky will reward PF's faith.

[Pretty Boy]

No complaints from me.

One of Stack and Brown will move on in the summer imo and we will bring in a new keeper.

Until that time I'm happy to stick with Stack although I wouldn't be unduly worried about Brown playing either.

[bighairyfaeleith]

I agree, both have there faults but I would favour stack.


However should we lose tonight I reserve the right to come back to this thread and basically blame the OP for us getting beat!!

[Spike Mandela]

Everybody deserves a chance to redeem theirselves. Hope he plays a blinder.

[Billy Whizz]

Any idea on potential other changes for tonight?
Are Docherty and Soares fit?
I can see 2/3 changes with 3 games in 6 days

[Judas Iscariot]

Soares & Docherty both fit

[blackpoolhibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Soares & Docherty both bit

Bit who?

[Billy Whizz]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Soares & Docherty both bit

Both bit who😄

[easty]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Soares & Docherty both bit

my finger?

the dust?

[blackpoolhibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

my finger?

the dust?

The first one was Charlie, and the other was freddie Mercury.

[Judas Iscariot]

Fit

[Thecat23]

Stack for me is very average at best. Happy enough he's playing as we don't have much better. But a new keeper in the summer is must. Anything that comes into the 6 yard box a keeper has to come and take or attempt it. He doesn't and this is where he fails badly as a keeper. Good shot stopper but that is what a keeper should be. I might offer my services myself in the summer

[NOLA]

Tam McCourt not play in goals?

[db03]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Stack for me is very average at best. Happy enough he's playing as we don't have much better. But a new keeper in the summer is must. Anything that comes into the 6 yard box a keeper has to come and take or attempt it. He doesn't and this is where he fails badly as a keeper. Good shot stopper but that is what a keeper should be. I might offer my services myself in the summer

Please dont, your worse than Zibbi :)

[Thecat23]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Please dont, your worse than Zibbi :)

haha shut it barker :) Although its a valid point!!

[TornadoHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Some of the abuse on here was unreal, he had 1 bad game.

I take it you don't get to many games then?

Stack has been living off his alleged "hard man" reputation for far too long and people have been over-looking the very obvious and well rehearsed on here weaknesses in his game!

I don't think that this is the best decision for the team tonight but time will tell!

[Ryan69]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Some of the abuse on here was unreal, he had 1 bad game.

1 bad game....?
He is a terrible goalkeeper!

How many goals has he been culpable for this season?
Add a 0 on end of the one and youll be nearer but not quiet there.

[Aldo]

Sorry but Stack for me ahead of Brown every time. So he's had one bad game but saved us in many.

TBH don't see many teams keeping Smellic out and hope they do the same to the pars the nite. We need a big performance against a very good Well side and tbh we will be v lucky to come away with anything. Fingers crossed though.

[Andy74]

Stack was the best keeper at the club before the weekend and still is now.

I'd be delighted if we got a better keeper in the summer, as i'd be delighted to improve any area of the team, but as it stands he should play.

[RiseAbove]

Not a fan of stack on or off the pitch but agree that he is probably better than Brown and has the potential to have a decent game.

I think we will put in a better performance tonight and reckon we could sneak it 1-0 or 2-1.

[Russ]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Some of the abuse on here was unreal, he had 1 bad game.

Seriously?, 1 bad game?, this clown has lost more goals in his 6 yard box than any keeper I can remember in history, he's stuck to his line like glue, he's the main reason our defence is so shaky, he inspires no confidence whatsoever. I was hoping Fenlon would have recognised his frailties and got him and the coaching staff working on it by now, alas, Sunday put that one to bed. Any keeper worth his salt commands his box, this clown can't even command his 6 yard box.

[Devine]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Seriously?, 1 bad game?, this clown has lost more goals in his 6 yard box than any keeper I can remember in history, he's stuck to his line like glue, he's the main reason our defence is so shaky, he inspires no confidence whatsoever. I was hoping Fenlon would have recognised his frailties and got him and the coaching staff working on it by now, alas, Sunday put that one to bed. Any keeper worth his salt commands his box, this clown can't even command his 6 yard box.

Correct, to say stack has had one bad game is simply untrue.

The amount of goals we have lost recently due to him bein glued to his line is unreal. Brown is the better of the 2, id rather have a goalie that struggles with kickin than one that thinks he's playing subbuteo

[500miles]

Stack is an OK keeper. Nothing more, nothing less. Good shot stopper usually, but stays on his line for crosses. We've had better, but we've had a helluva lot worse. In fact, he is the best we've had since Andersson left, and even he is overly romanticised after the Rangers CIS Semi penalty shoot-out.

[Russ]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Stack is an OK keeper. Nothing more, nothing less. Good shot stopper usually, but stays on his line for crosses. We've had better, but we've had a helluva lot worse. In fact, he is the best we've had since Andersson left, and even he is overly romanticised after the Rangers CIS Semi penalty shoot-out.

You can't have been at many games this season if you think he is ok. A keeper is supposed to command his box, this clown can't even command his 6 yard box. It's not even up for debate imo, he is an utter clown.

[Pretty Boy]

I always wonder who folk would have rather than Stack or Brown.

When Graeme Smith was at Motherwell there was a 4 times yearly campaign on here to sign him, when he ended up with us it was a disaster.

When Mark Brown was at ICT everyone was desperate to sign him, we've now got him and folk say they don't rate him or we could do better.

The reason people want Zaluska (who's pish by the way), Randolph, Gallagher or whoever is simply because they don't play for us, if they did we would see their shortcomings (because every SPL keeper has them or they wouldnt be at this level) every week and again want someone better.

[Sodje_18]

So evidently Stack has become the new scapegoat on here since Nish left...

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Seriously?, 1 bad game?, this clown has lost more goals in his 6 yard box than any keeper I can remember in history, he's stuck to his line like glue, he's the main reason our defence is so shaky, he inspires no confidence whatsoever. I was hoping Fenlon would have recognised his frailties and got him and the coaching staff working on it by now, alas, Sunday put that one to bed. Any keeper worth his salt commands his box, this clown can't even command his 6 yard box.

The defence has been shaky because it's been mince, Stack imo has been one of the stand out performers this season.