Looking at the current state of our game here in Scotland, do you think youth football is where everything is going wrong? I for one think we're miles behind the likes of Holland, Germany, Spain and many other countries round the world, not just Europe. Most countries are playing 20 hours of football a week at the age of 14/15+ when we're still stuck to the old routine of training on the Tuesday, Wednesday and game on the Sunday. We're lucky if we're getting 3 hours of training a week compared to these other countries.
The way we play the game in Scotland is also outdated in my opinion. We have this win at all cost mentality for teams as young as under 12s. One of the Port Glasgow teams went to Spain last year and beat the Levante 9-0. This is unheard of in this country, it's rare for a pro youth team to even lose to a boys club team never mind getting a 9-0 thrashing? The club secretory was bragging about it for months, talking about how one of his teams gave the Spaniards a footballing lesson. The manager of the the under 12s though was very quiet during this bragging session and rarely spoke about the game. When I got a chance to ask him about it he spoke of the Levante team always giving the ball to the full backs or straight into the midfield, even when they were down 3-0 they still kept passing the ball about and focusing on how the game should be played, the score didn't effect the teams tactics or style of play. He said his boys were faster, stronger far too physical for the small Spanish team although he said the quality of the Spanish team was unreal.
What are your opinions on youth football in Scotland? Do you coach football or help out with a local boys club? My uncle takes Leith Athletic 16s and I was glad to help out at his training last week where his main focus was passing and small possession games. His team lost 4-2 against LK Galaxy the same week although he didn't seem to bothered about the score, more about how his team played and the attitude of the players. I think that's a great example of how youth football should be coached. It's not as if he's getting stuffed every week, I think his team is sitting 3/4 in the table which is good considering they're only going to improve with the football they're being taught.
Results 1 to 26 of 26
Thread: Youth football in scotland?
-
29-09-2011 01:01 PM #1
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 73
Youth football in scotland?
-
29-09-2011 01:16 PM #2
- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Posts
- 888
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Myself and a team of others have setup and run http://www.youthfootballscotland.co.uk (http://www.facebook.com/pages/Youth-...84845868223486 for those Facebookers) which aims to promote all that's good in youth football, highlight correct practice and provide coverage similar to what the pros get, to keep confidence and enthusiasm levels high. Right now our big challenge is to get the clubs to buy into it, but if they all do - we can bring the whole community together for the good of the game. Leith are one of the few in Edinburgh that aren't contributing, so please encourage them to do so! Happy to send our info pack to anyone here, if they want to get a better idea of what we're trying to achieve and how it's being done.
-
29-09-2011 01:34 PM #3
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 73
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
What is it you do? are you a youth development officer or do you just do it in your spare time also?
-
29-09-2011 01:57 PM #4
- Join Date
- Sep 2005
- Age
- 56
- Posts
- 441
A couple of years ago I coached a team of 11 yr olds through a couple of seasons 7 a side , games played mainly on astroturf....goalie not allowed to kick out , build from the back etc. No great aspirations, just the local village team but we got better and showed up well with local pro club academy teams.
Great development, lots of touches.
On moving to 11 a side on public park surfaces aged 12/13 I insisted again that the goalie doesn't kick out, the full backs having to be alert enough to make a quick angle to get things started. The first 6 games we were hunted down by teams which had already played a season at 11 a side. Bobbly surface , one poor touch at the back and the opposition would score. I kept saying what I thought and still think are the right things but in those first 6 games we lost double figures goals each time. I didn't give a monkeys but the boys were getting pretty fed up.
In the 7th game we were again played the team which had beaten us 14-0 on the first day of the season. I saw their wee faces, told them to forget what I had been coaching , we put two big boys up front and kept blootering it as far away from our goal as their wee legs could manage. We drew 2-2.
The boys were beaming with pride even though they knew it was not the kind of football which was going to improve them. One half of me was delighted for them and the other half of me was crying inside ; there ,in microcosm ,was why Scotland is properly ***** at football.
1. the surfaces in winter do not give advantage to a skillful passing approach...... it's much more effective and enjoyable to keep blootering the ball as far away from your own goal as possible.
2. by hiding your own development within a win-at-all-costs team approach you can get through youth football without addressing deficits in basic skills.
Activities tend to be more enjoyable if you are good at them......if the only enjoyment at youth level comes from winning rather than getting better we will continue to be *****.
-
29-09-2011 07:31 PM #5
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 73
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
it's your first season at 11s though, you should stick with it because when it comes to under 15s/16s you will start pishing all over everyone. have you taught the boys how to take it from the keeper? with the ball bounced into their feet so it lands just like a sidefoot pass? also if your giving it to a full back u need to drop deep if the other team is behind the ball. it doesn't always have to go there though, you can still go long from the keeper as long as they're keeping the ball. you should stick with it mate, just get on youtube, fourfourtwoperformance and other youth development websites and look for training drills and help with running a team.
-
29-09-2011 08:11 PM #6
I disagree. I think Scottish youth football is very good at the moment. Some of the division 1 football is terrific as well as teams in lower divisions. The SFA have taught the coaches the training drills and all the ways to coach, which is then followed through to the players. But I find that you should do what first comes into your mind. Otherwise, everyone will be pressured to play exactly the same way, with no one playing unique football, with no touch of magic.
I am a Youth Football player and I play as a Centre Back. I just like to make a crunching tackle and lay off the easy ball and put a few in from corners. I'm doing very well and I hope to continue it too....
There are some good prospects though, so it's not the reason why Scottish Footballs so *****, but the SFA do play a part in it.
-
29-09-2011 08:20 PM #7
Levein and the SFA have brought in a Dutch guy to get us playing total football throughout the age groups.
-
01-10-2011 11:15 AM #8
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 73
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
01-10-2011 12:15 PM #9This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Totally agree with pretty much everything you say.
I used to coach under 7's in Edinburgh, training once a week and then a wee "friendly" match on a Sunday. Essentially, most of my lads just wanted to have a bit of fun and enjoy their football, which to me is part of the point. Have bit of fun, instill good values and technique. Sadly, football for kids is riddled with bitter men who seem to think that they're Alex Ferguson. A case in point - playing a match (under 7's, i remind you) away at another side, their coach was happy to loudly shout from the touchline that his players should "take him out" whenever my players touched the ball. It's a sad state of affairs when football at that age is limited to it all being about winning for some people.
-
01-10-2011 01:17 PM #10
Most of what I've seen in Scottish Youth football is pretty poor. A win at all costs mentality generally, many teams favouring bigger, more developed boys, goalie kick outs, big punts up the park, loud, aggressive and often obnoxious parents, who can do a good job of intimidating opposition players. Coaching ranges from the very good to the absolutely woeful
There seem to be a handful - probably less - of Boys Clubs who either attract the best players, or who simply, go and get them from other Clubs. But the biggest problem is we try to develop the game at U11, 7 a-side and then throw all of that out the window in this huge rush to play 11 a-side football, so that some teams can win Cups and Medals.
The fact there is nothing between 7s and 11s is un-natural and IMHO stupid. Boys have played the mini game and then over one summer have to learn to play on a full-size pitch, in FULL size goals, with offside. Less touches of the ball, more pressure, more room etc.
Until we have a proper player pathway and get away from a rush to competitive football, so we can get away from a win at all costs, only big kids can play - we won't prosper as a nation.
-
01-10-2011 01:49 PM #11This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
01-10-2011 02:01 PM #12
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 73
I have mixed opinions on that subject. I came from 7s - 11s at the age of 10/11 from primary 7 - 1st year high school. I didn't struggle at all but then again I had a very good coach who was intact female. We also trained indoors in a high school games hall and our facilities consisted of cones, 5 aside goals (the small long ones) and a wooden indoor floor. I was never the biggest or the fastest but some how I developed into a decent player who I give most of the credit to my coach anne. I had played for other teams before and wasn't getting a game because my confidence was low as ever and really didn't get a chance. When I did play for other teams before I was very nervous of making a mistake.
Having a good coach who can make you feel confidant is one of the best things you can have as a young footballer in my opinion. When your confidant your willing to take a player on/hitting a shot and you get a chance to express yourself. We ended up finishing above the team I left and ended up 2nd in the league for the whole season only loosing 2 games home and away to the team that won.
I'm aware though in edinburgh a lot of the kids are warped into edina hibs, tyncastle boys and hutchy? My uncle had his best player who played cm leave to play in goal for hutchy because he was a giant.
-
01-10-2011 06:02 PM #13This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Last edited by FranckSuzy; 01-10-2011 at 06:43 PM. Reason: Grrr
-
01-10-2011 06:41 PM #14
i coach a school football team and have heard some pretty shocking and disgusting stuff coming out of the mouths of coaches and parent 'supporters' over the last few years. e.g an 8 year old sub being told to 'shut the **** up' and go and get changed out of his strip because he kept asking when he could get a game.
coaches at early level need to get out of the way of thinking that, if their team are getting humped, then it doesnt mean that they are a sheite manager or a failure. too many egos amongst the adults definitely spoiling the fun for wee ones.
-
01-10-2011 07:37 PM #15This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
They still don't like getting beat, but we win our fair share of games now and hopefully we can keep the group together for a while and not lose our best players to the 'better' teams, as it's hugely rewarding seeing them progress.Follow the Hibs podcast, Longbangers, on Twitter (@longbangers)
https://longbangers.hubwave.net
-
01-10-2011 08:41 PM #16
- Join Date
- Jun 2011
- Posts
- 582
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
The difference between Spanish Football and the Scottish version is that the coaches team who got beat 9-0 was probably affiliated to the club.
All the Scottish boys and girls team coaches do it for free, great to hear Potter has brought in a dutchmen to solve our problems as when my daughter represented the yams junior ladies football team it was Potter who emptied them all when he took over.
And before you say yes I am a hibby.
Unfortunately the SFA don't pay to put you through the kids sfa coaching courses, at the time I managed to get my C certificate don't know what that would be now though.
The best way to improve the coaching at the time for me was to go and watch how other teams done their coaching methods as they used to train in parks etc but that has all changed now with up to date training ground you can't get in.
I feel one of the main reasons is that a lot of the cubs scouts have a vast area to cover and are unable to watch youngsters consistently. Years ago nepotism was rife and and the scouts aunties family member got the chance of a trial instead of the young lad they have went to watch in the first place.
Even when i went to see my son play at under 21's I couldn't understand how so many of the youngsters hadn't been picked up. My son played for a team that Chris O'neil played for who spent time at the Yams JJ's first term there but again Potter emptied him.
Football is a fickle game I am afraid, as again my son attended Hibs invitation training when he was a youngster 7 boys from tynecastle [ Yes that maroon connection again] and Hibs emptied them as they wore their maroon training tops as the coach was proud of the club getting so many boys along, 6 of them were hibby's.
It seems stupid decision making doesn't stop at youth football it also happens at club level as well.
-
03-10-2011 11:44 AM #17This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Set players individual targets - 3 passes or 4 tackles. Make the game as simple as possible for the little ones
The SFA moan about the drop out rate - and cite 'late-developers' as being the biggest thing, yet do absolutely nothing to make it easy for kids to keep playing or develop late. The good players end up at the best Clubs - even at U13 and U14. Win at all costs.
-
03-10-2011 04:05 PM #18
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 73
Yeah I agree the focus in Scotland is win, not develop. It's pretty unfair how it costs plenty to do your badges but that going on to paid work is almost impossible. The closest thing to a job I could get is active schools which has just finished. Even then it wasn't really coaching, more like doing sports days for schools etc.
-
03-10-2011 04:41 PM #19This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
Our last game, we got beat 4-1 from a team that uses an 'elitist' selection policy, i.e. hold trials and you get a game if you're good enough. We actually (IMHO) outplayed them for most of the game and were very unlucky. We gave the boys heaps of praise both at half time and in the second half, but some of the boys still focussed on the fact that they lost. It's a real shame.Follow the Hibs podcast, Longbangers, on Twitter (@longbangers)
https://longbangers.hubwave.net
-
03-10-2011 05:05 PM #20This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
03-10-2011 06:15 PM #21
- Join Date
- Nov 2009
- Location
- Back in the town
- Age
- 60
- Posts
- 11,874
Over the last year or 2 Dundee Utd have brought in an agreement with a local school whereby the boys turn up at 7.30 for training with Dundee Utd. They start classes after a shower and breakfast, (Diet from DU) in the second period of the day ay 9.50. After school they again undertake 2 hours of training and finish at 6.00pm. This effectively mirrors young swimmers/athletes coaching programmes and adapts it to football. There is obviously extra training during holidays. Some of the boys travel from Stirling and surrounding areas and rely on their parents support. Only a few boys in each year are involved. Is this the way forward and should Hibs consider it?
-
03-10-2011 07:15 PM #22Posted this a while ago...
I come back from my game today battered and bruised and have an aboslutely thumping headache, and I was thinking- Why do I bother doing this? It's not like I have to, or I get paid to? I absolutely love playing football, there isn't many things that I enjoy doing more, but I'm sorry juvenile football is an absolute joke and it's not even fun anymore, and that's what football is mean't to be about isn't it?.
Surely if we want Scottish football to improve we have to start at grass roots, and we have to keep kids interested?
-Kick off times, Saturday 2pm, silly IMO because it means the kids playing and their parent won't be able to see their local team if they are playing. I have a mate who has had a season ticket at Pittodrie since he was 5, but this year he has to give it up because he can't make any of the Saturday matches. Now, the reason they have these kick offs is because there might be school football on earlier in the day, why can't the school football then be changed to a Sunday once we reach the age of playing Sat kick off's in juvenile football? Is there no form of communication between the schools and the Juvenile association(or the ADJFA as they are call here)?
-Referees, Now I know these guys give up their spare time for hardly any money, but some of them are absolutely horrendous and don't know the rules. Couple of seasons ago I saved a pen fairly and the ref forced the guy to retake because I moved before the ball was kicked- That rule doesn't even exist anymore!! But anyway maybe I'm being a little hipocritical there
-Parents, Some of them seem to think they are Football geniuses, and can tell us what to do even if it contrasts what the coach says. And some of them are more interested in picking fights with the opposition fans than the actual game!
-The "ADJFA", These guys are an absolute shambles, we don't get a fixture list at the start of a season, we get told a few days before a game who we are playing, which tbh isn't a major hassle but it could easily be sorted. Last season my team played 22 games in the league, we played 12 of those in the 5 weeks, yes I understand that the winter was horrendous and we had to go 3 months without playing but surely it's just common sense to start the season as soon as the schools are back and play midweek games earlier in the year when the pitches are still good? Also, there have been a lot of teams folding over the summer, I think the league could have maybe tried to help the teams that were folding merge with each other. Because in the bottom league there are only 6 teams! Ridiculous! The suspensions are also of a ludicruous length and yellow cards carry on from season to season which is also ridiculous.
-Coaches, Now there are a lot of reasons that I just explained about youth football being bad, but the Coaches have to be the biggest problem with Scottish youth football and tbh Scottish football at the moment. My new coach to be fair to him is a really nice guy, and gets us playing passing football. We used to get away with this, but now we can't and other teams totally bully us out of games. Other teams coaches are so unbelievably short sighted it's unreal! THey don't think about how they are affecting Scottish football, by just getting all the big players and hoofing up the pitch. This means that a lot of smaller players even if they are of better quality than the bigger guys, get fed up of this and just give up playing football althogether. Gamesmanship is also a big issue, there was a guy today who was off the pitch injured, then he proceeded to walk on the pitch and the fall down to waste time.
All these things are part of the reason so many kids are quitting football, even if they are decent players, they are probably fed up of getting a bollocking for doing something wrong or being kicked off the park and nothing being done about it. Scottish football is never going to improve until we look at the bigger picture, not just the short term future of the game.
-
03-10-2011 07:38 PM #23This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
09-10-2011 04:28 PM #24
Yesterday I went to Forth and watched most of their U13? match V Mid Calder.
Forth were already 4 down inside 20 mins or so when I arrived. They eventually won 5-4 with the final goal comong in the last minute or so. I thouroughly enjoyed it as did the boys. Well the Forth boys anyway. The Mid Calder keeper was huge. Nearly the size of me.
Anyhoo. Some decent payers on show but still the odd shout of launch it. Good stuff in any case.
Thought I woud share that.
-
10-10-2011 11:20 AM #25
- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Posts
- 888
This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
-
21-10-2011 09:32 PM #26
- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Posts
- 888
Lots of good insights here. We are trying to help promote youth football far and wide, and could you with your votes in an award we are nominated for. Just got to http://www.talktalk.co.uk/digitalher...egion=scotland and select the 2nd option down, R. Forsyth. Happy to provide any further information about what we are trying to achieve and how this would help.
Log in to remove the advert |
Bookmarks