The ref tonight.

[Kevvy1875]

Deserve's its own thread IMO. He was shocking tonight. Although no major decisions had to be made which is just as well.

con·sis·ten·cy (kən-sĭsˈtən-sē)
noun pl. consistencies con·sis·ten·cies
a. Agreement or logical coherence among things or parts: a rambling argument that lacked any consistency.
b. Correspondence among related aspects; compatibility: questioned the consistency of the administration's actions with its stated policy.
Reliability or uniformity of successive results or events: pitched with remarkable consistency throughout the season.
Degree of density, firmness, or viscosity: beat the mixture to the consistency of soft butter.


He needs to look this word up in the dictionary find out what it means and apply to his chosen profession.

Tumilty...you were rotten!

Bring back the Maltese officials...anybody but these clowns!

[Jonnyboy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Deserve's its own thread IMO. He was shocking tonight. Although no major decisions had to be made which is just as well.

con·sis·ten·cy (kən-sĭsˈtən-sē)
noun pl. consistencies con·sis·ten·cies
a. Agreement or logical coherence among things or parts: a rambling argument that lacked any consistency.
b. Correspondence among related aspects; compatibility: questioned the consistency of the administration's actions with its stated policy.
Reliability or uniformity of successive results or events: pitched with remarkable consistency throughout the season.
Degree of density, firmness, or viscosity: beat the mixture to the consistency of soft butter.


He needs to look this word up in the dictionary find out what it means and apply to his chosen profession.

Tumilty...you were rotten!

Bring back the Maltese officials...anybody but these clowns!

He was very poor and highlighted it superbly when he booked Spoony for pulling a guy back and then failed to do the same when a St Midden guy pulled Spoony back - all in the space of a couple of minutes

Bring back the foreigners

[Kevvy1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He was very poor and highlighted it superbly when he booked Spoony for pulling a guy back and then failed to do the same when a St Midden guy pulled Spoony back - all in the space of a couple of minutes

Bring back the foreigners

Exactly the incident I was thinking of when I typed the OP!

There were many others....Hibs Mids booked for tough challenges. Fair enough...but why not book St Mirren players for similar 2 mins later?

[Jonnyboy]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Exactly the incident I was thinking of when I typed the OP!

There were many others....Hibs Mids booked for tough challenges. Fair enough...but why not book St Mirren players for similar 2 mins later?

The challenge on Murray was high with studs showing and we never even got a free kick!!!

[vla_di_vla]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He was very poor and highlighted it superbly when he booked Spoony for pulling a guy back and then failed to do the same when a St Midden guy pulled Spoony back - all in the space of a couple of minutes

Bring back the foreigners

Considering he played advantage with them because spoony's challenge was so half hearted and yet spoony get's halved and no booking

[Hibercelona]

The linesmen where equally as gash.

Bring back the foreigners indeed.

[machibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The linesmen where equally as gash.

Bring back the foreigners indeed.

Especially the east side one.

[Hibercelona]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Especially the east side one.

Was going ballistic at that mug!

[monktonharp]

Iwas raging at some of his descisions tonight.1st class clown

[givescotlandfreedom]

That McAusland (number 17) was a disgrace and should never have stayed on. Tummalty was awful.

[Hibby D]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Especially the east side one.

He was clueless (as was the ref) Looked like a munchkin and ran like a two legged equestrian donkey!!

[erin go bragh]

the ref was brutal as was the east stand side[dwarf]i mean linesman[sorry if your a little guy] how fat was that ref , he almost took out deeks at the start of the game when he stood on him . credit to the players as the fight they all showed is whats been missing all season . [how good did it feel when deeks and then spoony hit the back of the net]
ggtth

[Baldy Foghorn]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He was very poor and highlighted it superbly when he booked Spoony for pulling a guy back and then failed to do the same when a St Midden guy pulled Spoony back - all in the space of a couple of minutes

Bring back the foreigners

The referee was abysmal tonight......Guys who have probably never played the game, making decisions and getting most of them wrong.

[Pretty Boy]

What i hate about Scottish refs is the way they talk to the players like a headmaster talking to a pupil. The refs say they want respect but they show the players none.

Oneof the big difference i noticed when we had the Maltese officials was the ref spoke to the players like adults and got far more respect and understanding from the players as a result.

[Bayern Bru]

Does anyone know if Tumilty is a common Paisley/Hamilton name?


Inconsistent beyond the point of belief, but not even the fat man's ineptitude detracted from my enjoyment of tonight.

[I Love Lamp]

Truly shocking decisions. Started pretty well too but gave some baffling calls in the second half.

[PC Stamp]

Mike Tumilty is actually English but based in Edinburgh. As a grade 2 ref he reffed a number of games I played in and I always found him to be excellent. He would talk to players even as the game was going on and if he thought you were gonna half someone he'd tell you "not to dive in," or "stay on your feet" etc to try to save you from a booking.

I was sadly shocked at how very poor he was tonight.

[The Harp]

Diabolical refereeing! He started badly by impeding Deek and got worse as the game went on. This game was in real danger of getting totally out of control. The foul on Ian Murray was brutal and no punishment for the offender, and not even a free kick awarded. Inconsistency from the officials all night, but the decisions definitely favoured St M.

[The Harp Awakes]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Truly shocking decisions. Started pretty well too but gave some baffling calls in the second half.

I agree. After the 1st 15 minutes I thought great, the ref is going to be invisible tonight for a change, then he just lost the plot. That's 2 shocking refereeing performances the last 2 Wednesday's. Have to say that both linesmen were useless tonight though and didn't get involved at all, making the refs job harder.

Murray and Palsson both got taken out by bad challenges in the 2nd half and no foul for either How many handballs did he miss as well

[hibee_nation]

Listening to the radio on HI they were quite worried that Palsson was going to be red carded for a bad tackle and the buddies were going spare it was only yellow. So it seems he was not biased just useless.

[matty_f]

Ref had an absolute shocker tonight. Absolutely woeful.

[Bayern Bru]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Mike Tumilty is actually English but based in Edinburgh. As a grade 2 ref he reffed a number of games I played in and I always found him to be excellent. He would talk to players even as the game was going on and if he thought you were gonna half someone he'd tell you "not to dive in," or "stay on your feet" etc to try to save you from a booking.

I was sadly shocked at how very poor he was tonight.

That's a real pity, as refs in that vein must be few and far between in the Scottish game, and there's a fair few players who could benefit from that sort of treatment.

On a slight change of subject - the auld fella tonight was suggesting that match adjudicators i.e. those who judge the ref's performance release their notes to the public domain - if it's all above board they've got nothing to worry about and it might give some insight into why refs make certain decisions.

[Saorsa]

Poor performance from SFA officials, how unusual


bring back the foreigners

[PeeJay]

Agree the referee was bad, but wouldn't say he was all for St. Mirren and against us: Murray could easily have had a red for his reckless challenge and Palssen was very lucky to see only yellow for his late one. Just watched the highlights again this morning: both bad tackles.

[TornadoHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The challenge on Murray was high with studs showing and we never even got a free kick!!!

The St Midden no 17 got Murray with a horrible "studs up" assault which a lesser person than Murray would have made much more of to try and persuade the ref to take action! He had also hit Palsson a couple of times, the worst one off the ball in front of the Hibs dug out, after Palsson was booked for a very firm but (I thought) fair challenge. Palsson thankfully didn't react to the "off the ball" thuggery and, although Murray did a decent bit of "threatening" when he got up after beig assaulted, thankfully he too calmed down quickly too!

The no 17 could easily have had 6 yellow cards IMO but in the end finished up on the park with oinly one yellow!

The ref was a classic example of why Scottish officials are constantly in the news for being "incompetent"!

[sahib]

I thought all the bookings we got were bookings.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

Murray and Palsson lucky not to have early baths imo but that goes with the rub of the green which we have not been getting recently.

[FromTheCapital]

The number 17. should have been off....

But still 3 points, 2 goals and a clean sheet, Superb !

[blackpoolhibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He was clueless (as was the ref) Looked like a munchkin and ran like a two legged equestrian donkey!!

Snow white must have given him a knock back?

[The Gorf]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I thought all the bookings we got were bookings.

Correct, however so were the St Mirren ones but they weren't yellowed. As others have said:
"totally inconsistent"