Who is the better player Liam Miller or Barry Ferguson?

[Makalambay]

Having a wee discussion with someone at work, who would you rather have in your midfield, all bias aside.

[Mon Dieu4]

Miller he can pass forward, a concept totally alien to the crab

Also cant see Fergie ever wanting to have signed the Buckie King

[Danderhall Hibs]

Different types. They would probably make a good partnership.

[davemcbain]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Having a wee discussion with someone at work, who would you rather have in your midfield, all bias aside.

Ridiculous question.

One is the most overrated, loathsome, ineloquent, ugly, buckie swilling ned in Scottish football and is a man who makes Ray Wilkins look like an attacking footballer.

The other plays for us.

I would sooner have a septic tank on a sideways only conveyor belt in my midfield than Barry the hun.

[Makalambay]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Ridiculous question.

One is the most overrated, loathsome, ineloquent, ugly, buckie swilling ned in Scottish football and is a man who makes Ray Wilkins look like an attacking footballer.

The other plays for us.

I would sooner have a septic tank on a sideways only conveyor belt in my midfield than Barry the hun.

Fair enough, he's doing alright at Brum City though.

[lyonhibs]

As mentioned above, they'd probably make an interesting combination.

But if I had to choose, Liam Miller, hands down, every time.

[Dibben]

The questions should be:

Who'd make a better midfield partnership?

Miller / McBride

or

Miller / Ferguson



BH.

[Makalambay]

There is a corresponding thread on Follow Follow, Miller taking a bit of a beating.

[RoslinInstHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

The questions should be:

Who'd make a better midfield partnership?

Miller / McBride

or

Miller / Ferguson



BH.

or

Ferguson / Thomson
v
Miller / McBride

which pairing would you rather have?

[davemcbain]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

There is a corresponding thread on Follow Follow, Miller taking a bit of a beating.

Backs up my thoughts exactly - if the neaderthals that bang keyboards on swallow swallow like the ned, then every reason for me to despise him some more.

Just remember folks with every yard he covers on the pitch, it could be your oxygen he's stealing.

[Gus]

I'd persoanlly pick Miller

But

Ferguson is doing very well for the Brum. He also did well for Blackburn.

Miller on the other hand didn't get a look in at Man Utd for one reason or another, Sunderland hit the premiership & he doesn't get a look in again....

Ferguson has won numerous honours/trophies

Miller.....

And although Ferguson is as partial to a backwards pass as much as Nade is to a burger king, I wouldnt put money on Miller scoring more goals up here than Ferguson.

[Hibs On Tour]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Different types. They would probably make a good partnership.

Good point.

[Woody1985]

Would have to wait for a while to decide.

Miller has played half a season for us and about 10 games at Celtic. I've seen most of our games this season and a couple when he played for Celtic.

I've seen Ferguson play a lot more than Miller purely due to OF in the SPL/Europe and playing for Scotland.

[Dunbar Hibee]

I think Ferguson is very overrated. I don't see what others see in him.