The Ultimate Poll - Maka or Stack?

[cocopops1875]

think on balance i feel both have their pros and cons but i vote maka based purely on his ability to make the big save stack is like colgan never really made a big stop but was ok

[Feed McGraw]

I know that this goalie debate has probably gone on long enough, but I have to say I am amazed at the support Maka gets on this board. He is undoubtedly a very nice big fella, but as a goalkeeper he is one of the worst I`ve seen in 50 years supporting Hibs. Stack has only just arrived at the club so should be given time before all these conclusions are made about him. I have a strong feeling that if Stack had performed how Maka has performed for these last couple of years there would be nowhere near the level of support for him that Maka is getting now.

[HibbyAndy]

Stack for me over Makalamby every single day off the week.

[Hibercelona]

Maka 138
Stacks 108

Oh.... how the tables have suddenly turned after one performance.

[Cabbage1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I know that this goalie debate has probably gone on long enough, but I have to say I am amazed at the support Maka gets on this board. He is undoubtedly a very nice big fella, but as a goalkeeper he is one of the worst I`ve seen in 50 years supporting Hibs. Stack has only just arrived at the club so should be given time before all these conclusions are made about him. I have a strong feeling that if Stack had performed how Maka has performed for these last couple of years there would be nowhere near the level of support for him that Maka is getting now.

I'm unconvinced about Stack but Maka gets nowhere near the gloves for me.

[TornadoHibby]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Maka 138
Stacks 108

Oh.... how the tables have suddenly turned after one performance.

Not one performance - Stack has now played in five games so people are now getting nearer to be able to assess him properly on what they see in match time rather than on the Youtube "hard man" clips and opinions based on that from other on here!

If the guy was as good as some claim (not me as I'm still very uncovinced by him) then he would get more support in the poll as he played more games whereas the opposite seems to be happening!

[Golden Bear]

A ridiculous poll - as has been mentioned previously.

Stack needs far more games under his belt before he can be fairly judged.

Come back 6 months down the line please.

[Perspective]

FourFourTwo's pre-season club-by-club guide asked the Plymouth contributor which player they'd most like to get rid of.

His answer? Graham Stack. No elaboration required.

[mim]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Maka 138
Stacks 108

Oh.... how the tables have suddenly turned after one performance.

The tables haven't turned. Maka had a small lead before the cup tie.
It's no great surprise that he has a bigger lead now.

[Golden Bear]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

FourFourTwo's pre-season club-by-club guide asked the Plymouth contributor which player they'd most like to get rid of.

His answer? Graham Stack. No elaboration required.

But was that a result of his on field performances or his off field antics?

We need to know.

[Perspective]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

But was that a result of his on field performances or his off field antics?

We need to know.

That's all it said I'm afraid.

Maybe I can't see past Maka (who I believe is a good prospect), but to me Stack looks a liability. His moment of madness the other night when he came charging out was ridiculous.

People should remember that until the Lee Miller howler (which actually came during a decent performance in which he made an excellent penalty save), Maka was a pillar of strength in the final games against Hearts and the Old Firm.

[jakedance]

Maka for me. Neither fill me with confidence though.

[Hibs90]

Maka it is then?

[Franck is God]

at the end of the day Yogi has to decide who's going to be in goals and although my choice is Maka out of the two I'm still not hoping that Stack makes the mistakes that will end up with him being dropped.

Stack has had the last five games and to me has done nothing to show that he is a better option than Maka, he's been luckier than Maka in that the mistakes he has made have not resulted in goals conceded but that is all.