(Greggs) Kieran Charnock

[Hamish]

Text received that Hibs are in talks with this guy. Defender currently at Torquay Utd.

Tomato, Brown and pretty unreliable.

[--------]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Text received that Hibs are in talks with this guy. Defender currently at Torquay Utd.

Tomato, Brown and pretty unreliable.

Started at Wigan, then Southport, Northwich Victoria, Peterborough, Accrington and now Torquay.

5'11", just turned 26. An England 'C' cap, whatever that means.

I'll say it and get it over with - he's not Hibs class, and it's a total disgrace that we're even looking at a player from the lower reaches of the English Leagues, get-it-sorted-Petrie, Yogi-you-must-be-joking-leave-NOW.

There. Sorted.

I think you're the first for a long time to come out right off and say your source is unreliable. Who knows? We may end up signing this bloke.

[Big90inOz]

What about Worcester ?

[fife hfc]

looks to me that he has just signed for Torquay (certainly going by wikipedia, if correct).

[heretoday]

There's only one Kieran Charnock.....

[hibbie02]

Any relation to Charnock Richard?

[ancient hibee]

Whatever happened to guys with normal names like Paul Kane,John Fraser or Yannick Zambernardi?

[erin go bragh]

5.11 what good would that be. we need a big 6.2plus commanding centre half ffs

[Danderhall Hibs]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

5.11 what good would that be. we need a big 6.2plus commanding centre half ffs

I heard his standing jump is 4 inches higher than that of your average 6ft2inch centre-half.

[--------]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What about WORCESTER ?

SAUCE?




I'll get ma coat.....

[Scotthibs1875]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Started at Wigan, then Southport, Northwich Victoria, Peterborough, Accrington and now Torquay.

5'11", just turned 26. An England 'C' cap, whatever that means.

I'll say it and get it over with - he's not Hibs class, and it's a total disgrace that we're even looking at a player from the lower reaches of the English Leagues, get-it-sorted-Petrie, Yogi-you-must-be-joking-leave-NOW.

There. Sorted.

I think you're the first for a long time to come out right off and say your source is unreliable. Who knows? We may end up signing this bloke.

You havent even seen him play!

[HibeesLA]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

You havent even seen him play!

I refer the poster to the Fundamental Principles & Doctrines of Hibs.net.

Specifically rule #2:

- No signing is ever 'Hibs class'. Those that become Hibs Class will have been predicted by 270 individual posters on here, who told us all along from the beginning what great quality the player would be. You will not be able to trace their posts to confirm this.

[Ringothedog]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

you havent even seen him play!

whooooooooooosh!

[Bostonhibby]

travelling up to Bolton today with a guy who watches the "Posh" so will get the low down and he can tell me afterwards if Hibs are Charnock "class"

[--------]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

You havent even seen him play!

Of COURSE I haven't seen him play!

Since when has anyone on this board been required to have seen a player play before rubbishing him and writing him off?

You some sort of Bolshevik revolutionary, son?


Seriously, we would do well to remember one James Alan Holton from Lesmahagow, who was signed by Manchester United from Shrewsbury Town.

United were in the old Second Division (Championship to the infants) at the time.

Shrewsbury were goodness knows where - Seventh Circle of Hell, facing relegation to the Eighth, for all I know.

Anyway, Holton signs for United.

Cue universal chorus of "Who????????" and "What the ****?" and "HE's never United class!" and "What a huddy!"

Not a bad player, as it turned out, Big Jim ....

"Six foot two, eyes of blue, Big Jim Holton's after you, na-na-NA-na, na-NA-na, na-naaaaa...."

Ah, my mis-spent youth!

I don't think we'll sign this lad Charnock, but I won't discount him till I've seen him.

[Disc O'Dave]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Any relation to Charnock Richard?

He might provide better service to the midfield and forwards.....

[BEEJ]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Of COURSE I haven't seen him play!

Since when has anyone on this board been required to have seen a player play before rubbishing him and writing him off?

Seriously, we would do well to remember one James Alan Holton from Lesmahagow, who was signed by Manchester United from Shrewsbury Town.

I don't think we'll sign this lad Charnock, but I won't discount him till I've seen him.

Doddie, despite diving in in anticipation of a chorus of wailing, there is none on this thread, bar a gentle swipe at the guy's name!

I realise that for you, like me, the departure of Mixu eclipses all other transfer activity this summer.

But folks do still have some cause to express their reservations at this stage in the proceedings. Personally, I will form a judgement on the squad come 1st September.

[Hibiza]

Any news on this one. seen it in a makkam paper. prob greggs.

[RIP]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Text received that Hibs are in talks with this guy. Defender currently at Torquay Utd.

Tomato, Brown and pretty unreliable.

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What about Worcester ?

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

SAUCE?
I'll get ma coat.....

Doddie am I missing something?

Hamish starts us off with "Tomato, Brown" (Sauce), Big90 replies with a witty reposte of "Worcester" (Sauce) but then you add an odd reply of ....."SAUCE"



Please explain