I cannot fathom how he was not sent off...
Printable View
I cannot fathom how he was not sent off...
Like Lewis tho, has to be retrospective action from sfa. Not much help to us but fairs fair. Also, when are refs going to make decisions during the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by madhatter
What did Lewis do?Quote:
Originally Posted by loanheadhibby
Just occurred to me that you might be referring to the derby a while back where Walker and Stevenson were punished later.
Lewis and one of the yam fuds had a kick at each other last season and got retrospective bansQuote:
Originally Posted by madhatter
Compliance officer won't do anything. It will be conveniently left out of the bbc highlights.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Do they only act on bbc highlights?Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikeystewart
:agree: I seems so.Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
Depends on who you play forQuote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
Eckersley was only on the park to get himself and a Hibs player sent off. Again they set up not to lose freqent foul etc. First time it's not worked
Gomis should've been off too.
It won't matter to Eckersley as he's off at the end of the season and I can't see him having a future as a football player.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikeystewart
Slight exaggeration there mate...Quote:
Originally Posted by Geo_1875
anybody got a video of it to put up
Perhaps it was the fact it happened so early in the match that saved him, not that it should matter when the head goes in.
I think Allan was lucky not to be in bother. Thought he went in with the elbow in the first half. Maybe just me.
That'd be good - I genuinely can't remember this challenge/incident.Quote:
Originally Posted by Last Minute
I think it was literally in the 1st minute of the game. I don't remember it either (mind you, I only came down the tunnel in the 2nd min), but the jambos on my train said he should have been sent off.Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
Because that would have done the Glasgow Football Associations chances of opening The Rangers path up to the Scottish Premier League no good whatsoever now would it?Quote:
Originally Posted by madhatter
That's just never going to work mate.Quote:
Originally Posted by Last Minute
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGOl...ature=youtu.be
Hope this works.
Also been sent to the compliance officer at the SFA
Thanks - just as bad as I remember it....Quote:
Originally Posted by Last Minute
I would have sent him off.
I missed the incident live and haven't seen the replay but I too would have sent him off.
I would also have sent Zeefuik off for being fat.
Thought he made the guys at half time look trim... :wink:Quote:
Originally Posted by peter douglas
Anyone got any footage of the strangle hold on Jason?, clearly a penalty :agree:
And the others for being really, really ugly.Quote:
Originally Posted by peter douglas
Sure it said in the paper that the ref seen no need to intervene. :confused:
Really ?? There was almost nothing in it - Id have been gutted to see a Hibs player sent off for thatQuote:
Originally Posted by peter douglas
He booked Eckersley and Boyle for bugger all in comparison. I assume that's just a crap excuse. Guessing it was ignored because it was the first minute.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
Can't understand how he'd worked himself up enough inside 70 seconds to stick the head in someone. Mental.
Quote:
Originally Posted by RicheyWhite
Theres not really a lot in it though is there?
He has to get a retrorespective ban when you see the footage of it.Its hard to imagine why someone would do that so early in the game in a nothing incident.:confused:
Not even handbags-more a very small purse.Think he's narked because Hearts won't give him £4K a week to stay.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
Quote:
Originally Posted by CmoantheHibs
I dont see a lot in it!! Several players every week would be suspended if we started dishing out bans for this.
Seriously? - that's not violent? Becausue it missed or because it wouldn't take a player down? Players get red carded for out of control tackles and he was definitely out of control. He's been wound up by the management to get out there and make a name for himself with the fans in his final game...Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
You've seen more pathetic headbutts receive red cards though. And he got booked later for something far more innocuous.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
If it was later in the game he would've been sent off. If seen. Fairly sure of that.
The video doesn't show Scott Allan noising him up/half squaring up to him just beforehand. Both players were at it and I think the ref was right.
By the rules of football, and on countless number of examples as precedent, it is a clear red card.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
Watching that makes me realise how truly glorious being a Hibs fan is. Horrible individual at left back for Hearts. Scott Allen has complete class not to react. The Hearts way, rip off businesses, charities and HMRC, then try to bully with little skill on the pitch.
The first derby next season against them will be a cracker, confident we will be Scottish Cup holders. ....
Usually when a player puts his head into another player's head/face it's a straight red. Doesn't have to break a nose or inflict a knock out. It's standard refereeing practice. And I don't see head butts happening too often so there wouldn't be that many bans despite what you say.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
Honestly , do we really need a thread on this - no one was hurt , the game played on ...and we thumped them. Who cares about a nothing episode compared to that !
Going by that footage, Eckersley's 'tackle' was more of an assault and worthy of at least a yellow. The fact that it was in the 1st minute, was an ideal opportunity for the ref to make it clear he wasn't going to tolerate any over the top behaviour. His performance was cowardly and biased. Also guessing that Scott said something to the thug to make him reactQuote:
Originally Posted by RicheyWhite
This is a classic example of "laying down a marker" on an opponent right at the start of a game. Letting an opponent know what he might be in for. Intimidation if you like.Quote:
Originally Posted by RicheyWhite
I've done it during a game, and had it done to me. You don't necessarily need to use the head. It's usually first "tackle" and someone is up in the air. It was no coincidence Scott Allan was on the receiving end. It's usually who one team see as the "danger man".
It's also another classic example of BOTH the referee and his assistant failing to do their jobs properly and apply the rules correctly. Why are they failing to do their jobs? Are they scared, or what is it?
I was at the game but would really like to see that again.Quote:
Originally Posted by Leithenhibby
That's a red card every day of the week and at any other level he's looking at a ban of at least 5 games!
Plenty intent there, ref/lino & waste of money/space 4th mason bottled it cos it was blatant
Another decision that could've defined a game that went in their favour!
Not to mention the stonewaller of a pen we were denied
What is being overlooked here is that Eckersley is a truly terrible footballer.
Cheers mate. I remember wondering why the West Stand were shouting.Quote:
Originally Posted by Last Minute
Definitely looks like he puts his head towards Allan. It's worth a booking, if Allan wasn't as honest he could've seen red there.
Are you saying retaliations allowed now Peeve?Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
Yet you are on here reading it :confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by bigwheel
Not at all. My own view is that they were both at it and that it wasn't even a head butt. Try butting somebody's forehead with your temple and see who comes of worse.Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
So should we just take out this rule then "Disciplinary Rule 200: Violent Conduct by headbutting or attempting to headbutt an opposing player" :confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
Noising him up?Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
There is Ungentlemanly conduct and there is Violent conduct in the remit for referees to book participants in such instances. I think, from memory, they only have 5 such instances. Can't remember what those are, but these two stick. Deliberate hand ball? Deliberate foul play? Dissent?
'Noising up' was never one. If players were booked for 'noise' we would have some game.
Yellow for Scott at worst for not being a gentleman (and being clattered by the way). Red for the sparryheid for Violent conduct. Quite simple. There is no argument.
Any movement towards another player with the head is seen as aggressive and so a red card for violent conduct. Was the linesman on that side? If he was that's just yet another farcical decision that they have had go in their favour. How many retrospective reds have they had against us recently? 4? Add that to the list.
Whether soft or not, that's a red every day of the week these days. Just like that prick McGowan's head butt on Sproule that he got away with a few seasons ago. That was right in front of the linesman as well
Yes. 5 yards away.Quote:
Originally Posted by Boyle89
He clattered into Scott as their tactics from the off was to break up any momentum we had. I was right above it and saw what he did. Andy Walker called it a headbutt straight away. The replay shows the linesman looking across the field and looked back when he heard the shouts. The ref might not have been able to see it from where he was. Linesman to blame for taking his eye off the ball - literally.Quote:
Originally Posted by Iggy Pope
Superscoreboard@ClydeSSB 1m1 minute ago Adam Eckersley of Hearts given notice of complaint by SFA for alleged headbutt on Scott Allan during Sunday's Edinburgh derby
http://scotfa.co/scmf/OrMCe04Lcp0lOD...-Y0cp0l/eFtxKa
Another retrospective ban for a Hearts player after they play us...when is this going to stop?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Libby Hibby
I'm fed up of Hibs being a soft touch. We should make it public that we are unhappy about the standard of refereeing we've had to suffer in Derby games in recent seasons.
Still waiting on a reply from the compliance officer to which I sent the video too
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Anyone got a clip of Cummings penalty claim in the 2nd half?
Quote:
Originally Posted by emerald green
cannae tell you, "it's a secret" :wink: