That was me, and at the time i did hate them although i've never wanted Monty out. There's no crisis in my opinion, maybe boredom or apathy have crept in, but crisis i dont think so.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbar81
Printable View
That was me, and at the time i did hate them although i've never wanted Monty out. There's no crisis in my opinion, maybe boredom or apathy have crept in, but crisis i dont think so.Quote:
Originally Posted by xbar81
you were just emotional mate. Next derby take a tranquliser :na na:Quote:
Originally Posted by blackpoolhibs
Before Mourinho was sacked there was speculation ( only paper talk ) that Newcastle had held talks with him about replacing Eddie Howie . Probably all s**** though is Eddie Howie another manager under pressure depending on next few results? .
Before or after? :wink:Quote:
Originally Posted by xbar81
half time lolQuote:
Originally Posted by blackpoolhibs
Both just to be sure G.Quote:
Originally Posted by blackpoolhibs
Hope so. I chucked a tenner on him to be next prem manager to leave at 7/1 after they lost consecutive games to (I think) luton and forestQuote:
Originally Posted by Donegal Hibby
What little feeling I have for Newcastle would evaporate if they appointed Mourinho. His race his run and his stay at every club is the same, short term success followed by a trail of destruction and leaving the place a mess.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donegal Hibby
Wouldn’t be all that surprised. Think they’ve lost 6 of their last 7 I read somewhere (can’t be bothered to check, that seems astonishing if true but I’m going to presume it is). That’s not good enough at that level.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donegal Hibby
Haha, I only turned against LJ near the end when he got booted, I was neither for or against him during his time, his BS was the only real thing that annoyed me about him, I wanted him gone after the cup defeat against Hearts and the 0-3 defeat against them earlier didn't help. Looking back on last season reminded me how streaky his time was, 4 losses and then 4-5 wins and repeat.Quote:
Originally Posted by Since452
Unlike you who's been against Montgomery since day one and have let everyone know in almost every thread you post on.
No. We could have better quality in depth but that's about it. That Monty hasn't got as much out of Youan as Lee did is a worry. That a proven talisman like Boyle is ineffective is a worry. That Vente can't buy a goal is a worry.Quote:
Originally Posted by B.H.F.C
If for Monty's system to work means the existing talent fails then I'd start questioning the system.
There's the problem, players injured long term and having young 17yr olds on the bench instead, the starting 11 feel no pressure on them and their places are almost guaranteed, complacency sometimes sets in.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilson
He can’t go, I sold his season ticket that he launched along with his scarfQuote:
Originally Posted by xbar81
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The Youan thing I think has been overplayed. He’s scored six since Monty came in the door having scored nine in the whole of last season. He’ll improve on that this season and continue to go from the sublime to the ridiculous from minute to minute. Playing Boyle up front week in, week out I totally disagree with. That’s a mistake.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilson
It’s not just lack of quality in depth, it’s just a total lack of quality in certain positions, namely centre half, and that is what is costing us more than anything.
There are things Montgomery could and should be doing differently but there are things that are absolutely on the players. He can’t header the ball away in the last minute of the derby for Rocky or score the penalty for Boyle and that’s just a couple of examples of big errors players have made that have cost us that are absolutely nothing to do with anything tactical.
Nonsense. You’ve previously admitted you sussed LJ out early on and wanted him out.Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
That’s fine but then don’t go over dramatic on people who think that way about the current manager. Accusing people of not being Hibs fans and ignoring people left, right and centre is pathetic behaviour just because this time they have a different view from you.
:faf:Quote:
Originally Posted by BoltonHibee
This and I’d be very surprised if the board aren’t thinking the very same. They’ve spent a fortune on these 3 and it’ll be a lot cheaper to bullet Monty than it’d would to write off the amount paid for that lot.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilson
And yet there’s numerous posts from you from November 2022 onwards (possibly even earlier but I’ve not read any earlier threads) saying to get him out the club, time to go etc.Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
How can you be arsed trawling through posts from over a year ago, can you find them and show them as I can't recall what I posted last week.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stubbsy90+2
https://www.hibs.net/showthread.php?359917-Manager-needs-to-goQuote:
Originally Posted by J-C
8 November 2022. 19 games into his tenure.
Interesting thread. If you didn't know, it could be about Montgomery, Johnson, Maloney. Easy to see where the problem is.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stubbsy90+2
Reading that thread, its exactly the same arguments we have today. Managers fault, players fault, recruitment fault or tactics.Quote:
Originally Posted by Since452
I’ve quite enjoyed reading some of the older threads :greengrinQuote:
Originally Posted by Since452
So far there’s been numerous folk who can’t even fathom talk of managers being sacked so early who were asking for previous managers to be sacked even earlier, folk who are currently calling fans entitled for daring to question whether Montgomery is under pressure who wanted previous managers out after 7 games (W3, D2, L2) and folk who are insistent that our formation and system under NM doesn’t actually matter who were very insistent that Maloneys formation and system was the problem :greengrin
Yup. Shows how poorly we've been run on the football side of things since the Gordons took over that fans are having often heated debates over all you've mentioned above. All started with the sacking of Jack Ross after failing to back him that summer. Sad and frustrating.Quote:
Originally Posted by blackpoolhibs
I noticed one prominent poster on that thread saying that LJ should be gone for sticking to 433 all the time and hoping for the best. Same poster scoffs at the idea of NM being critisised for the exactly the same thing. Gave me a wee chuckle.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stubbsy90+2
I get that this is more speculation but say there was little progress by NM come the summer and Ian Murray had got Raith promoted either as champions or the play offs. Do we think he’d be in with a shout of getting the Hibs job.
Listened to the open goal interview with IM and he seems grounded, not lost in any buzzwords etc, obviously gets the club. Would be interesting
:greengrinQuote:
Originally Posted by Since452
Think the moral of the story is we’re all guilty of talking utter ***** on here so getting yourself worked into a tizzy over other peoples posts is just daft.
Quite surprised I don’t seem to have wanted him out by then. My shout that Will Fish will probably never play for us has turned out to be a belter.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stubbsy90+2
I really like Murray, and hope he gets Raith up as I like them too.Quote:
Originally Posted by Trinity Hibee
If we are in a similar position come the summer the manager won’t be sacked though.
If NM goes for whatever reason IM would be very high on my list of targets.
IM is an obvious choice he live an breaths hibsQuote:
Originally Posted by Jones28