Bizarrely, the post-mortem was better than the highlights package.
If you weren’t at the game, you’d think we stole 3 points.
Printable View
Bizarrely, the post-mortem was better than the highlights package.
If you weren’t at the game, you’d think we stole 3 points.
It's a stinker - I'm guessing because he was booked he won't get any retrospective action?Quote:
Originally Posted by whiskas
Editing is awful. Looked like we snatched the points [emoji31][emoji31]
Sent from my VTR-L09 using Tapatalk
Whitaker stands his ground. No foul. Maybe not a dive but Whitaker doesn't have to get out of the way just because Edouard runs at him.
Scott Brown tackle is definitely a red card. Late, high, off his feet, out of control. Nowhere near the ball.
Nope. Although after Candeias managed to appeal a yellow card earlier in the season then who knows, they make it up as they go along.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jones28
Whittaker does catch him but as you say he's holding his ground with nowhere to really go. Possibly a free kick but Edouard makes a meal of it after regaining his balance only to go down because he knows Efe was getting to it before him.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tug Wilson
That penalty for Hearts. :confused: :dunno:
Just about to post that!!
Crazy decision
Compare that to the one we were denied in the playoffs against Falkirk a few seasons ago
You stay classy Craig Levein...
Absolute knob. As Michael Stewart says complete deflection to his current form.Quote:
Originally Posted by SouthMoroccoStu
No shock Livi have appealed Jack Hamilton's red card at Dundee yesterday.
Utterly shambolic level of officiating to send him off!
Did the Hamilton keeper get a finger to Smith's penalty? Looked to me like Smith put it onto the bar then headed the rebound but no free-kick given.
Definitely looked like an obvious free kick to Hamilton, but no mention from the sportscene team or any of the football experts on this forum. Maybe they dont know the rules of the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Geo_1875
It's just BBC Scotland trying to get back in the huns good books.Quote:
Originally Posted by kaimendhibs
Best to maintain sanity and not watch Sportscene at all.
Michael Stewart has changed from an interesting pundit to a constantly angry character with predictable soundbites and cliches. Johnathan Sutherland is deeply peculiar. I think he's probably some sort of android. Thompson is just a hun.
And the theme tune. God save us all.
Is the theme not just the same one they used in the 80’s? Love it!Quote:
Originally Posted by hibsbollah
The theme is terrific
A classic
I just wished we had a better presenter. Sutherland is one weird looking guy
MS just has to ensure his view stands out from the others at all times. He's an expert attention seeker.Quote:
Originally Posted by hibsbollah
I like Stewart and think he's a good pundit. I'm not sure working with Sutton has been good for him though. The two of them like an argument with each other and Stewart seems to be taking that argumentative stance with him wherever he goes now. I watched that show on the Ladbrokes facebook page picking the joint Hibs/Hearts team and he came across as a bit of a dick to Darryl Currie (who i'm sure is his mate so got the joke probably better than it came across).Quote:
Originally Posted by DexterStJock
I also think he could do with distancing himself from his mate 'Christophe' when doing the punditry. After the Livi game Stewart was scathing about Sean Clare for not getting up off one knee quick enough but never said a peep about Christophe lying on the ground watching it.
Overall, he's not perfect but he's a million times better than Charlie Nicholas, Andy Walker or Davie Provan at Sky.
Nowt to do with his presenting skills but does he stay near Morningside, sure he has driven past me a few times in the last couple of weeks in a huge big porsche
I enjoy Sportscene. Mikey hates CL, can’t get any better than seeing him laying in to Dr FootballQuote:
Originally Posted by heretoday
Think Stewart stays in the Murrayfield areaQuote:
Originally Posted by allant1981
Charlie Nic. His first game co commentating praised Paul Lambert by telling Archie McPherson that Lambert “ calmed the midfield ratios”Quote:
Originally Posted by bingo70
Maybe wasn't him thenQuote:
Originally Posted by Billy Whizz
Maybe he's capable of driving from Murrayfield - Morningside! 😉Quote:
Originally Posted by allant1981
Thought that too😄Quote:
Originally Posted by HUTCHYHIBBY
Stay’s near the braids in a ex tv stars old houseQuote:
Originally Posted by Billy Whizz
Nah it's a bit far!! I did ask for that I supposeQuote:
Originally Posted by Billy Whizz
Thompson is no hun.Quote:
Originally Posted by hibsbollah
Yeah St Mirren fan growing up. Lived next to Barry Lavety.Quote:
Originally Posted by tamig
It’s not a popular opinion but I think the modern day pundits are great.
They used to roll out the same old tired faces, most with old firm connections and were part of everything that was wrong with Scottish football.
Stewart, Thomson, Sutton, Craigan and the rest are a breath of fresh air in my opinion.
Would hate to be stuck in a lift with Stewart but he hates Craig Levein and most of what he says is spot on, despite the way he presents it.
I'm pretty sure he owns a place in the West End - I won't say the street as I actually quite like him. Maybe a city pad! He breakfasts in the Huxley most mornings.Quote:
Originally Posted by WoreTheGreen
I agree with all of this except for Craigan. I find he gets far too excited when his beloved Huns score.Quote:
Originally Posted by ChazD
In billy Low’s place a lotQuote:
Originally Posted by Crab apple
It's not a popular viewpoint as it seems to be cooler to moan about everything, but I agree.Quote:
Originally Posted by ChazD
The Scottish football coverage over all platforms at the moment is decent.
Finally got to see the highlights
Delightful piece of play from Jamie Mac for our opening chance
Hopefully more to come
Probably my favourite highlights show of the year
On tonight at 10.20
Yip. They generally excel themselves at this stage of the Cup.(Well usually)Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
Here we go
Keeps this crap thread of yours going. I’m in....Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
Aidrieonians goalie was up for this one anyway
This keeper for Airdrie seems a right fud
Scott Brown ha
These disco lights at Celtic might be the worst things I’ve ever seen.
The production team must ask themselves:
Right, what will we put on first? Aberdeen being held? The game at Motherwell? The Fife derby?
No, Celtic doling out a routine thrashing to a team several leagues below them and with about a thousandth of their budget.
Well done Auchenleck, from the highlights they merited their victory. The Ayr bubble has well and truly burst.
St Mirren got out of jail there. 0-2 down and with only 10 men yet they go on to win 3-2 !
Derek McInnes seems to be morphing into Jimmy Calderwood.
Oh my God! Graeme Smith, the goalie for Stenhousemuir. Memories of the 6-6 Motherwell debacle come flooding back...
Oor Gordon at the game
Still loves his football
Lewis Vaughan looks decent
Big Hibby tooQuote:
Originally Posted by Hiberniankb
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Local lad ( gilmerton) Hibby I believeQuote:
Originally Posted by Hiberniankb
Whats not to like?
Gilmerton.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Always looked a decent player and looks like he's got a great attitude. A Hibby too. Worth a punt?Quote:
Originally Posted by Hiberniankb
Hun.Quote:
Originally Posted by SaulGoodman
Good seeing the likes of Dundee United, Dunfermline and Raith Rovers with big supports today. I know the cup is different from run of the mill league games but just shows the fan base is there at these clubs
That was what I said! :dunno:Quote:
Originally Posted by oldbutdim
Gilmerton :greengrin
Wooooooossssshhhhhhhh!
😂😂👏👏Quote:
Originally Posted by oldbutdim
The Rangers celebrations
My God
Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
Details?
Pitch invasion.Quote:
Originally Posted by Keekaboo
WildQuote:
Originally Posted by Keekaboo
On the park and everything
Minter
hug a catholic ; then sing about there hate for them.
vile , thick as **** morons
Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
:aok:
Presumably they'll get a fine for their behaviour, and the SPFL will then make an announcement condemning the fan's sectarian singing.
...then a giant Unicorn will fly into Westmister and sort out this whole Brexit mess.
That Clare boy is really not very good.
Decent side burn thoQuote:
Originally Posted by hibsbollah
Inch.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
yicQuote:
Originally Posted by 90+2
Aye Inch.......What’s not to like? :greengrinQuote:
Originally Posted by 90+2
As clear as day on the tv but I won’t hold my breathQuote:
Originally Posted by chinaman
The analysis from Stewart and Thomson on every game feels like it lasts longer than the match highlights - more fitba’ and less chat would make the programme more appealing to me.
Think it is a birthmark. A bit uncalled for.Quote:
Originally Posted by SMAXXA
Thought Michael Stewart called it absolutely right in respect of Dallas as a referee and his constant errors. 👍🏻
And Rangers have added Defoe as another diving cheat, on top of MorelosQuote:
Originally Posted by CentreLine
THE Inch - birthplace of many of Auld reekie`s finest. :greengrin:flag:Quote:
Originally Posted by 90+2
Dallas is also woeful
He can't even speak to players
On at 12.15 am...
They'll have about 5 viewers for this one
that jake Hastie looks a player,got a bit of sjm's style and bullishness about him.
Out of contract in the summer and on about £60 a week...Quote:
Originally Posted by tonyrougier123
The midweek programmes are a joke with the SPFL's after midnight contract with the BBC. There's always the iPlayer if Hibs ever put up a show worth watching again.
On now. First game St Mirren v Dundee United. Horrendous tackle by Butcher of United. Red card all day long.
Wonder how much of this week's episode will be devoted to McNulty's challenge?
What time is this on?
10.30Quote:
Originally Posted by Keyser Sauzee
#SuttonisagrassQuote:
Originally Posted by PatHead
Pass it on
Apparently kneeing someone in the head isn’t foreceful or dangerous.
What's the point in the pundits saying 'it's a red' when it's already been established earlier this season that you're allowed to kick out at people?Quote:
Originally Posted by PatHead
Hun Thompson said McNulty should have been red carded so the compliance officer will be looking at it. A Celtic player kicked a Motherwell player on the head at head height and I don’t think the ref even booked him. The Sportscene detectives didn’t even consider the incident.
If you watch the replay, McGowan’s foul goes on for at least 20 yards and ends up with him throwing McNulty to the ground then intentionally kneeing him in the thigh. By the time McNulty commits the so called kick out at McGowan his head is buried in the grass with McGowan pushing down on him. McNulty has no way of knowing where McGown is. McGowan’s boot then comes into contact with McNulty’s head. McGowan committed at least three fouls during the incident and McNulty was upside down with his head planted in the turf when the movement of his foot took place. There’s no way that should be a red for McNulty. McGowan should have been off.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim44
MSM have always picked out & ignored key incidents during matches (off-sides, pen claims, tackles etc). It's always been an irritant, especially to non-OF fans, as the media follow followed their own agenda.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim44
But it feels like we've moved into a new and sinister phase, where producers, media owners and pundits are deliberately campaigning for post-match action by the "compliance officer" driven by their own personal or corporate interests. Social media has seriously weakened MSM relevance, but now they've a new purpose - creating the news and affecting the management of the game directly.
Saturday's MOS was a good example. Dundee v Hibs match was a great game with 6 goals, but they dedicated the whole of the first third of the report to .... McNulty's phantom kick out. The only surprise was it wasn't repeated in the Editors Comment section, supported with the compliance officer's phone number. They had so much to say about McNulty's vicious attack that left the Dundee player unconscious and hospitalised that they had no room left to even mention the Dundee player's deliberate boot on Milligan's head.
I made it around 35 secondsQuote:
Originally Posted by PatHead
Was less than I expected.Quote:
Originally Posted by My_Wife_Camille
You missed the final bit when McGowan had his leg wrapped around McNulty’s ankle preventing him from getting up. It seemed deliberate provocation to try and get McNulty to kick out and get red carded.Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunswickbill
Could the BBC not save some money and get the Rangers TV commentators for the next game. They would probably be less biased the Sportscene commentator tonight.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Buc
I noticed the stats, we had 13 shots with 6 on target with Rangers had 19 with 6 on target, the way that game was edited it looked like we had 2 attempts all game and Rangers dominated the whole 90 mins, the possession was 45% to us and 55% to them, much closer than Sportscene portrayed.
Thompson & Miller a nice impartial combo....
Thompson is a plank, banging on about clubs statements (a direct reference to LD's statement methinks) as being "empty words". Jeez it's what he does for a living now !!! Not once during their snide attacks, implying it was every other clubs responsibility, did any of them have the minerals to speak out about the historically ingrained, vile, threatening bigoted behaviour of either of the uglies. More concerned at the reception they would get on their next visit to either of these places upon their next pilgrimage to lap up their heroes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wheat Hound
Fact is they are sterile in terms of authority and ability to affect things...Empty Words? aye you know all about them' Thommo. Yonder ET that presents the programme can GTF in aw'
Kenny Miller a pundit? Sorry Kenny your definitely not.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wheat Hound
Just finished watching the highlights on catch up. Yer bang on mate, he stopped just short of shouting c'mon the Gers, it was like he was commentating on a Scottish team in an away tie in Europe FFS.Quote:
Originally Posted by Buc
Just about to watch on iPlayer and the titles show "Rangers v Hiberian". Don't bother getting the venue right, don't bother getting the spelling right, just don't bother.