Printable View
Anywhere else on the pitch the ref gives a free kick. Goldson makes the challenge and there is enough contact .Duk is entitled to protect the ball with his body he should have stayed down and not got up. I am sure the other Aberdeen player is pointing that out to him.Quote:
Originally Posted by GreenGray
Sent from my SM-A127F using Tapatalk
Even if people don't think it is a penalty (there's absolutely no mention of it on the VAR review video on the BBC website, so they obviously don't think it is contentious...) is there not a case to say that Goldson was denying a clear goal scoring opportunity with his initial tug on Duk? If you look at Stuart Dougal's arguments here about the Cochrane and Mulgrew challenges https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/av/football/65523934 then surely the same has to apply to Goldson here. There are no covering defenders and Duk turns into the box so Goldson's initial tug on him is denying Duk a clear run and chance of a shot at goal.Quote:
Originally Posted by Carheenlea
Did VAR even look at this during the game?
The Rangers have not conceded a pen in 50 games in this age of VAR
At worst this is a foul outside the box and a sending off
Absolute disgrace
https://twitter.com/mstewart_23/stat...0ikIP1rStFdqBg
Yeah that stat is a disgrace, think we’ve conceded 13 in the league since they last conceded oneQuote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Great tackle if he's stopping him scoring a try.Quote:
Originally Posted by HibbyAndy
Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk
A Fergie Aberdeen side would have been surrounding the referee and be in his face.
All football fans just want consistency by refs,there should be no excuse as we have VAR now to highlight clear and obvious errors.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gbhibby
TBH, I used to hate it when Fergie's teams did that, but I can see why he probably felt it necessary when he was at Aberdeen.
They will get a couple awarded against them v St Mirren/the Hertz now there's nothing to play for.
But they've never provided a definition of what that is.Quote:
Originally Posted by gbhibby
I think they could start off by having a time limit on how long they can replay the footage e.g. 30 secs and if they are still not sure then it's not clear and obvious
That in itself should be clear obvious...Quote:
Originally Posted by hibby rae
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
Didn't even get mentioned on ref watch on sky.
Noticed that , Nothing to see here move along , He did say it was a deserved red at Tynecastle tho , Which i agree withQuote:
Originally Posted by gbhibby
Just watched this clip in utter disbelief. Whilst I would suggest the initial offence was outside the box and therefore not a penalty if that was any other player outwith the OF the ref has the red card out before the player hits the ground.
If this was the other way round you can guarantee penalty and red card.
Blatant cheating by the officials
:top marks just a pity it will never happen.Quote:
Originally Posted by Carheenlea
Or the BBC’s VARdictQuote:
Originally Posted by gbhibby
BBC making a complete ass of themselves once again with the match stats from the game today!
Apparently Aberdeen had more shots at goal and even more on target than Hibs today and 50/50 possession,could have sworn the highlights I just watched showed a totally dominant performance despite the fact we couldn`t convert
at least 1 for the win!
On Sportscene they said we had 17 shots on goal, Aberdeen had nothing like that.Quote:
Originally Posted by rossevenil
Stats from the BBC website
Possession
Home 47% Away 53%
Shots
Home 8 Away 17
Shots on Target
Home 2 Away 5
Corners
Home 3 Away 8
Fouls
Home 10 Away 17
The good old BBC lol 😂.
Stop complaining and get off your knees and give them the GTF as their comeback is non existent. 😂
I think it was from a different game.Quote:
Originally Posted by rossevenil
They had the attendance as 7k odd.
Didn’t see the game but looks from sportscene like we should have won. Disappointing. Awful penalty from Nisbet.
Hearts red card is a shocker. How a ref can watch that and then a VAR team can also watch it and say it’s a red card is beyond me.
The red card for Haring is simply Jimmy Jeggo levels of unbelievable - infact it's probably worseQuote:
Originally Posted by Stubbsy90+2
Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk
I just watched it - I thought he came lunging in, missed the ball completely and cleaned up his opponent. Thought it was a stick on red :confused::confused: Might have to watch it again. Their penalty was very soft.Quote:
Originally Posted by Callum_62
They also had the crowd as 7000 and players who are long gone from the club being bookedQuote:
Originally Posted by rossevenil
There's probably no one on this site - and they'd be right - that thinks Grant Brebner's was a red card all those years ago. Brebner was more of a red than Haring I'd have thought, who's was the sort of tackle that's always been a yellow and no more.Quote:
Originally Posted by ChilliEater
I thought the red was a bit like Porteous's v Rangers 2 or 3 seasons ago.Quote:
Originally Posted by ChilliEater
https://youtu.be/Ahp_9eK16jw?t=216
Yes thought penalty was soft but was the St Mirren guys own stupid fault for putting his hand on Ginnelly at all. He was going away from goal.
Would like to see the foul from another angle which St Mirren scored their 2nd from as, to be fair, looked like the Hearts guy won the header fairly but guess his arm must have caught the boy with his arm at the same time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 007
I thought about the porteous similarities too
as for the penalty, it’s as soft as the one rangers got against us, ginnelly waited for the guy to touch him and collapsed in a heap, the defender was stupid to touch him, in those situations keep shepherding the guy continue towards the byline, make him do something rather than give him an easy out.
I’m frustrated that they got a cheap penalty, but the defender has to take the blame. Defenders do exactly the same when facing their own byline with an attacker at their back, wait for a brush then throw themselves forward and the linesmen always give a cheap free kick
Are you implying that rangers are playing to different rules than the rest of us.how many goals has tavanier scored through penalties alone.Quote:
Originally Posted by BILLYHIBS
Fair do’s
Brilliant finish from Ginnelly -goal of the season contender
Excellent finish from the foreheid
Muted celebration from the exAberdeen player - probably thought he was miles offside-until he realises the magnitude of his goal when awarded
Hearts look vulnerable at set pieces
Still not convinced by either Manager long may they continue
Only the 52Quote:
Originally Posted by big gogs
13 missed
:confused:
March 2023