Since Mallan arrived we have been deadly from set pieces. It’s making a massive difference in tight games like yesterday.Quote:
Originally Posted by weecounty hibby
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Printable View
Since Mallan arrived we have been deadly from set pieces. It’s making a massive difference in tight games like yesterday.Quote:
Originally Posted by weecounty hibby
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ozyhibby
True. We’ve been crying out for goals from midfield for years, as well as better set pieces.
Who were the first team to beat them that season? I am struggling to recall!Quote:
Originally Posted by Jack Hackett
Struggle all you want you don't want this season to end the way that one did. Pick another one.Quote:
Originally Posted by jgl07
Not sure I agree with the chaps’ analysis of the Hibs goal. Green tinted maybe but as far as I can see the St Mirren defenders are also grappling as if they fear Kamberi as the target of the ball in.
Quote:
Originally Posted by SonOfDavidFrancey
That goal would've been chalked off at the World cup, they clapped down on all the wrestling in the box, Kamberi was very strong to hold off the 2 St Mirren players but it was a clear foul, he just needs to be more cute in future. It was a well worked training ground manoeuvre but on another day it may have been seen as a foul, I'll still take it though.
I found it interesting, and it was pointed out by Steven Thomphson, that there was no protest from the St Mirren players afterwards. Tbf Thompson did give credit to Hibs for it being a well-worked goal.Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
Another one thought up by Gary Parker?
I see Scott Brown took the bit of paper that McInnes seems to be handing out to Shinnie these days
That's what you call a captain
If I was a st mirren fan I would asking why one Hibs player was able to hold back 2 defenders. Team full of weaklings & I hope they are relegated after the treatment handed out to Alan Stubbs...
Quote:
Originally Posted by c31
Stubbs is his own worst enemy. It's not the Buddies fault he was hopeless.
If it had been the World Cup, as David Gray was freeing himself from the grasp of the St Mirren defender he could have fallen over and it would have been a penalty.Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
Why does Kamberi have to be more cute? That’d only be the case if he’d given a foul away?
Looked like they were backing into him to me.Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
:agree: Its a trend we are seeing in posts more and more, we will need to score more, defend better and be more cute in future games while scoring more than the opposition, not conceding any goals and scoring cute goals like on Saturday now?Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
Good post. It’s almost as if conceding zero goals is still too many.Quote:
Originally Posted by blackpoolhibs
Stubbs made an absolute erse of it at St Mirren. If that was a St Mirren legend mismanaging us we would have run him out of town too.Quote:
Originally Posted by c31
Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
It was well worked training ground move that gave us a goal, Kamberi did what he had to do and that was to use his body strength to give Gray the space, another ref may have seen Kamberi using his arms to hold the defenders back, this time he got away with it, another time maybe not. A win is a win and all these things even themselves out during a season, some are seen and some are not.
Penalty to Hibs if anything :agree:Quote:
Originally Posted by I'm_cabbaged
On at 5.55 pm
26 goals to look forward to
Must be a recordQuote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
Why is Michael Stewart half dressed
Here come the Hibees
Some terrible decisions this weekend. Jones penalty and McHugh booking for GBH the two that stand out.
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
Hearts defending at first goal 🙈
that McHugh is a thug, Livi good goal chalked off as well
Shinnie did a “Ramos” on the St Mirren player
Didn't realize yesterday that kamberi 3 assists yesterday, boyle and mallan twice.scores and caused the own goal which Would've been another assist for gullan. Also set boyle thru for a great chance and won the flick on that set horgan thru on goal
We were talking about that leaving the game yesterday.Quote:
Originally Posted by sean04
Thought he was pretty poor but still manages to have an impact like that!
If he hadn’t been injured we’d be sitting top of the league IMO.
Was just saying to my jambo mates that were only 2points behind and we haven't been able to play fully fit flo and Mecca yet. We've had a few annoying injuries that has had an effect. McGregor, hanlon and gray, macca and rocky(don't think bogdan should be dropped)Quote:
Originally Posted by B.H.F.C
Had to wait on bogda n mulligan , kamberi, macca, wee tam, hyndman and horgan getting up to speed as well
I took a neutral to Hibs v Aberdeen game. He hadn’t seen Hibs this season. He thought Kamberi was brilliant. He also liked the look of Porteous. He couldn’t believe he was only 19.
We really are starting to have a real depth to our squad. McLaren, Hanlon, Macgregor not involved yesterday
Add in Bartley and AgyepongQuote:
Originally Posted by 007 Mickey Weir
If horgan boyle aygepong hyndman macca all hit form Lennon has a real headache. Hopefully slivka can reach his potential aswell . Real depth at center half, 2 good keepers, nelom pushing Lewis. Mulligan, flo and Ambrose are the 3 we need to keep fit
That shinnie is a horrible little scroat isn't he?? Gets away with murder week after week...unbelievableQuote:
Originally Posted by Billy Whizz
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
Quote:
Originally Posted by Borderhibbie76
All he does is puts the boot in and screams at refs for 90 minutes, mostly unpunished as well.
Shinnie makes Aberdeen tick - he's a top player. No surprise they lose or play poorly when he is absent. I'd take him at Hibs in a heartbeat :agree:Quote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
No thanks from me...one of the worst players to be capped for Scotland imo...he's a horrible wee pr$%# mate.Quote:
Originally Posted by truehibernian
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
Agreed how he never got sent off at ER 2 weeks ago was beyond me...don't think he even got bookedQuote:
Originally Posted by Hermit Crab
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
Quote:
Originally Posted by truehibernian
He played against us in the cup and Aberdeen were gash!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Borderhibbie76
No I don't think he did and he took out Boyle with one of the most cynical tackles you'll see.
Agree, I'd definitely have him at Hibs.Quote:
Originally Posted by truehibernian
Kilmarnock forward Jordan Jones faces a potential two-game ban for diving after being cited by the Scottish FA.
Jones has been issued with a notice of complaint for simulation as a result of going down in the box to win the decisive penalty in Kilmarnock's 2-1 win at Dundee on Saturday.
Footage suggested there was no contact on Jones from Dundee's Cammy Kerr.
give him a 12 match ban, might make some others think twice about falling over :agree:
He didn't claim the penalty though. The officials should be banned in this instance, not the player.
They should take the points off Kilmarnock and demote that joke of a ref.
Much as I agree with you, the reality is, Kilmarnock have 2 extra points and the player has a 2 week holiday?Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
Its very much a win win for Killie, as for Dundee, manager could be sacked, and the officials will get a pat on the back and a cup semi final!!!!
Why did he fall over?Nobody touched him.Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
I think he tried to turn inside but his momentum took him the other way.Quote:
Originally Posted by ancient hibee
Having watched it many times, i dont think he dived, but simply tripped over himself?Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
And when doing so, he did not claim for a penalty, which those who normally dive do.
Sometimes players do fall over without being fouled, and i think in this instance he should be cleared, but i can see why they might take the other option and keep the two game ban.
The main gripe i have is how the ref saw it as a trip, he had a clear view of the incident and if he see's this as a trip then he clearly has eyesight trouble and needs to be assessed again by the SFA and an optician.
I'm convinced he just caught his feet on the ground and tripped over. As you say he doesn't claim for penalty, he just puts his head in his hands as he knows if he stayed up he was through on goal.Quote:
Originally Posted by blackpoolhibs
Could argue he should tell the ref he wasn't fouled but realistically no player is doing that and if it was one of your players that did, as a fan you'd be furious.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
As I said above, I think he tripped, he wasn't diving. Thinking a bit more about this, if I was the player I'd be claiming I didn't say it was a penalty however when the ref blew and gave the penalty I assumed I must have been mistaken when I thought I tripped and it was actually a foul which the ref saw.
Sounds a very believable story right enough [emoji23]Quote:
Originally Posted by ian cruise
A player can't be punished for accepting a referee's decision.
They can if they’ve cheated to influence the referees decision. That’s like saying Lafferty shouldn’t have been punished for that pathetic dive a few years back because the referee decided that the Aberdeen player head butted him. He conned the ref, as Jones did last week.Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
Also, he didn’t claim for the pen, IMO, as he instantly regretted diving and knew how bad it would look on the TV. Doesn’t make it any less of a ‘crime’ though.
It's up to them to prove he's lying.Quote:
Originally Posted by RyeSloan
I would love to think the referee and link's learn from the compliance officers stance with Jordan Jones and make good decisions, also hope the compliance officer becomes consistent with his retrospective decision making for all teams ...but I doubt it !! Whilst I totally agree in the Jones outcome ...There are.far worse situation that have taken place involving stampjng, kicking out, cynical tackles, which the compliance officer has done nothing ...hugely inconsistent and therefore totally inept at the job ...supported ably it would seem by his equally useless bisses. Threads about woeful refereeing and compliance decisions will be with us every week of the season.
Then they're being punished for cheating, not for contradicting the ref.Quote:
Originally Posted by NadeAteMyLunch!
Think we are saying the same thing? He’s being punished for cheating ie diving. The ref deciding it was a pen doesn’t make it any less cheating on Jones part.Quote:
Originally Posted by Peevemor
I agree with the point above though there has been far worse ignored by the farce that is the Compliance officer this season. I’m sure the first time a player from one of the lesser teams kicks an opponent off the ball, that will become a retrospective red card offence again [emoji849]
Watch Mickey Weirs goal in cup final against the Pars, he trips over his own feet penalty awarded to Hibs and Mickey with a big grin as he has won a penalty for nothing.
He didn't dive or try to con the ref he just made an arse of it. :agree:
Sportsound and not sportscene but still worthy of a mention
“you can’t lead a duck to water”
John Rankin
10/10/18
5.45 pm today
An hour and 15 minutes tonight ?
Wit
Hibs on first of course
What is Clancy doing ?
Fool
Accies need a new goalie
Agree worst goalie by a mile not the first time he has thrown in a couple v them.Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
🤣🤣🤣Quote:
Originally Posted by Danderhall Hibs
I'll no be watching tonight
But a pencil must be leadQuote:
Originally Posted by beensaidbefore
I will to see the 5 Celtic goalsQuote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
I broke late last night and watched the 2nd half of yesterdays game.Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
Was it as awful on telly as it was in person?Quote:
Originally Posted by CMurdoch
Anybody watching tonight ?
....
Fortunately, a week has passed and i can't remember now.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jones28
So
Who's watching ?
6 pm
Did you have to remind us..🙁
Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
Wont need to.
You will tell us how **** we are .
Sounds about rightQuote:
Originally Posted by Lemonade
I shudder to think what people like you would have been like on here when we actually were *****.Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
I demanded Butcher's sacking in February.Quote:
Originally Posted by flash
If only the board had listened
Paul Hanlon part to blame in both goals. Poor poor defending all round. Boyle couldn’t tackle a fish supper.
Hanlon looks even worse on the replays
Strange, pundits didn't mention anything about us being likely relegation candidates.
Hanlon's shortcomings brutally exposed on highlights, static & slow, should have been able to intervene & prevent both Dundee goals.
IMO, was worst Hibs player on the day
Hanlon very poor for both goals, napping for the 1st and caught wrong side for the 2nd when he should've shown McGowan to the outside, slow and poor decision making.
Hanlon understandably rusty perhaps.
Curiously, I doubt the Aberdeen forums are beating themselves up about this either.Quote:
Originally Posted by lapsedhibee
I thought Hanlon was played pretty well tbh, but was caught out for both of the goals, horribly for the second one meaning that he has to be held largely culpable for us throwing the game away.Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
Hanlon was really poor yesterday, he looked way off the pace and very laboured. I was surprised he was put straight into the starting line up after a long lay off, really unfair on him.Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
From the highlights shown:
At 1-0 Boyle shoots from a poor angle instead of playing it to Kamberi at the front post for a tap in.
Later in the 1st half there is the double shot from MacLaren in the box. Instead of taking the 2nd shot he should have squared the ball to Kamberi to his right who had a tap in.
The goal called offside was very tight and on another day might have been given.
The Dundee goals
1st - non existant challenge from Boyle as the guy heads for the dead ball line on the left wing and then Mallan who is running alongside fails to make the block and the ball is squared for Miller who has got himself on front of Hanlon at the front post. IMO opinion Mallan had the best chance to prevent it but made a powder puff challenge.
2nd goal - Milligan slightly too far forward and gets wrongside of McGowan receiving the ball who then turns away from him and heads towards the Hibs goal and Hanlon who must force him outside but over compensates and McGowan cuts inside and hits an unsaveable shot past Bogdan. Ultimately must blame Paul for this goal although Milligans initial mistake set McGowan on his way.
Some goal from the St Mirren player.
Seeing the goals back, our ‘attempts’ at making a tackle in the build up to both were absolutely pathetic.
That it was.Quote:
Originally Posted by PatHead
I'm surprised at Hanlon being so at fault with both goals, as he's normally reliable, but he's another who's coming back from injury and rusty.Quote:
Originally Posted by Smartie
We played well enough to be well in front, also miss a few other decent chances through decision making and poor finishing that our mess of a midfield had created.
But poor defending put paid to all that.
Since Hibs won we can watch again
On at 6
Anybody get the Hibs crowd yesterday ?
Couple of thousand or thereabouts 👍🏻Quote:
Originally Posted by cleanyman
That was roughly the attendance all in I think.Quote:
Originally Posted by GreenProfessor
Our game just about to start on BBC2 now, might be worth a watch tonight :aok::greengrin
Not a booking for Edouard away to **** 😂😂😂😂😂
I’m still incredulous that anyone can think that tackle by Brown isn’t a straight red
Tackle on Slivka looked worse on TV alright. Shame the highlights are so brief, but that’s where Hibs TV’s value comes in.