Summer 2019 transfer thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Turnbullsmate

Wee bit harsh no ? I , i am guessing are of the same generation or similar to BSEJVT , and like many Hiibby's over the years "faith is all we had. Never knock it mate.

In answer to your question .... no way would i condone us loaning and developing a ****bo which probably makes me a hypocrite as i abhor the Hun yet am quite open to the loan to us of the player in question.

Fine lines huh !!!

Just to clarify.... The FTB attempted to do worse to us than the Hun ever did...puts some "persective" on it as far as i am concerned.

---

Caught this late Turnbulls Mate but I think you’ve misconstrued the term faith. Everything else you’ve written is correct. Never knock that.

Ultimately, any player that makes Hibs stronger is a good player to have.

Sure, it’s frustrating to either develop a rivals player or put them in the shop window for them, but hell, that describes Liam Henderson, and I’m sure nobody regrets us doing that piece of business!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Davy Mac

Do we honestly think we are getting this guy to improve him prior to him going back to Rangers?

He is in the shop window pure and simple and in my opinion not in Gerrard's future plans, just my take on it.

---

He is a good player but like you I wonder if he will feature for them going forward. The Rangers want to win leagues he will be a bit part player at most. I'm surprised we aren't trying to buy him with a first option to buy back or/and a high percentage sell on fee.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ScottB

Ultimately, any player that makes Hibs stronger is a good player to have.

Sure, it’s frustrating to either develop a rivals player or put them in the shop window for them, but hell, that describes Liam Henderson, and I’m sure nobody regrets us doing that piece of business!

---

For Verona.

We need cover for Boyle and this guy fits the bill. Anything else is secondary really

In other news Agyepong has signed for Waasland-Beveren in Belgium, think it's another loan deal

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 04Sauzee

In other news Agyepong has signed for Waasland-Beveren in Belgium, think it's another loan deal

---

Thought he had signed for Killie

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JimBHibees

Thought he had signed for Killie

---

Not sure where you heard that? Unless I have got it very wrong 😐

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 04Sauzee

Not sure where you heard that? Unless I have got it very wrong 😐

---

Sure that was a rumour a few weeks ago.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 04Sauzee

He is a good player but like you I wonder if he will feature for them going forward. The Rangers want to win leagues he will be a bit part player at most. I'm surprised we aren't trying to buy him with a first option to buy back or/and a high percentage sell on fee.

---

If we are, then barry. I want to win another league before they get one though.

Have Hibs ever loaned a player from a team in the same league before?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Since452

Have Hibs ever loaned a player from a team in the same league before?

---

Scott Allan from Celtc.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Since452

Have Hibs ever loaned a player from a team in the same league before?

---

Allan 🤷🏼*♂️

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 04Sauzee

In other news Agyepong has signed for Waasland-Beveren in Belgium, think it's another loan deal

---

Kilmarnock.

All of a sudden we are not getting a player on loan, we are developing him for Rangers. Not once have I heard anyone on this board claim that we are developing a player for someone else with all of our previous loans. Now we get a player from Rangers on loan the outcry is hilarious. Get a grip FFS.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Since452

Have Hibs ever loaned a player from a team in the same league before?

---

Scott Allan, surely?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lucy Brown

Scott Allan, surely?

---

2 others beat you to it

The player will be developing on loan to rangers' benefit regardless of whether it's at us or another club. The difference in this case is we benefit too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lucy Brown

Kilmarnock.

---

What's Kilmarnock?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Scouse Hibee

All of a sudden we are not getting a player on loan, we are developing him for Rangers. Not once have I heard anyone on this board claim that we are developing a player for someone else with all of our previous loans. Now we get a player from Rangers on loan the outcry is hilarious. Get a grip FFS.

---

I don't agree but understand I think that thought process is down to his age and the likelihood he will never sign for Hibs. I bit like Barker i suppose though some thought we could sign him :greengrin

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jacomo

1. We weren’t in the same division as Celtc for most of those loans, and they are still clearly a fair step ahead of us
2. Celtc haven’t run a propaganda campaign trying to punish our club because they are bad losers.

There are no inconsistencies, just a wilful refusal on your part to understand why people have reservations about doing business with Sevco.

None of this is Middleton’s fault though, and he will have my support if he signs.

---

Sorry

Didn’t know you had first hand information on everyone’s motivations for not wanting to do business with Rangers but it’s great that you can speak for everyone so quickly and clearly

Explain to me the post McGinn discrepancy can you when we were most definitely both in the same division and for a long while Rangers were competing with Celtic for the league and not us for Europe?

Hibs escaped Scot free over Hamden, and although many supporters did not, I don’t think that the supporters experience had much to do with Rangers, more the police’s mishandling of the entire event which created the opportunity and their pathetic attempt at redeeming themselves

Personally I thought Rangers propaganda attempts laughable and most football fans of non Hibs or Rangers persuasion I know thought the same and that rangers embarrassed themselves by their actions

I think that too many folk are giving fatuous excuses as to why they treat a loan from Rangers differently to anyone else and whilst I am not saying for a moment all are for other reasons, my view is some may be, whether they themselves even recognise that difference is debatable.

Regardless neither of us can prove we are right unequivocally so it’s probably way past time to put this to rest.

What I will say in closing is that the Hibs I support and grew up supporting is an inclusive organisation without any of the intolerance or discrimination that sullies the Old Firm or to a far lesser extent Hearts.

If it were to become anything else, I couldn’t continue to support it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Since452

2 others beat you to it

---

Sorry, just logged in, saw the thread, answered.

:na na:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 04Sauzee

What's Kilmarnock?

---

The team he has apparently signed for. :aok:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lucy Brown

The team he has apparently signed for. :aok:

---

Apparently you may be wrong 👍

Thomas Agyepong

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Since452

Have Hibs ever loaned a player from a team in the same league before?

---

Richie Towell from Celtc not so long ago And Scott Bain from Dundee the season before last.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by oneone73

Richie Towell from Celtc not so long ago And Scott Bain from Dundee the season before last.

---

Right enough

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lucy Brown

Scott Allan, surely?

---

You running out of Bobby Darin avatars now you one hit wonder?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 04Sauzee

Apparently you may be wrong 👍

---

Well, that’s fine.

It’s what I read yesterday, pardon me.

Didn't realise it was a point scoring thread.

:na na:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Iggy Pope

You running out of Bobby Darin avatars now you one hit wonder?

---

I’m veering towards Miss Winehouse now.