Nice! And the follow through was even better :greengrinQuote:
Originally Posted by Northernhibee
Printable View
Nice! And the follow through was even better :greengrinQuote:
Originally Posted by Northernhibee
I’ve seen us lose some bad goals over the years but from a defensive point of view I think that’s up there with the very worst I’ve ever seen.Quote:
Originally Posted by Northernhibee
I’d absolutely do my nut if Hibs lost a goal like that, it’s woeful.
A point I tactfully made in a group chat I’m in that has a couple of United fans it it who were through at the game.
Think the keeper is out for the rest of the season.Quote:
Originally Posted by Eyrie
Least there are some positives for Dundee United fans.Quote:
Originally Posted by 007
Decided to take a look at the Hibs highlights. Just fast forwarded to our game and watched what was barely a minute of “highlights”.
Didn’t bother with the punditry as what exactly would there have been to say about that?
Total waste of everyone’s time. In a country where a large chunk of the population is passionate about football, it should be impossible to fail at making a decent programme about football. To do so in the manner that the BBC has done with not only Sportscene, but Sportsound as well, it really is quite an achievement.
What with? EmbarrassmentQuote:
Originally Posted by 007
Sportscene just moved on from the Hibs highlights. Didn't show the third or fourth goal.
Neil McCann started off a sentence by saying he didn't think Fitzwater was the last man and that the red card was harsh, before saying it was accidental but the referee probably got it right. He's away with it.
Amateur production. How can you miss 2 goals of the analysis? And not mention Martindale getting sent off.Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnny_Leith
Really poor from the BBC - obviously running behind and so had to cut analysis short, probably because they spent nearly 30 minutes on the Huns game. Also regardless of whether it was accidental or deliberate, he's last man, denying a goal-scoring opportunity, it's a red.Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnny_Leith
Imagine another country in which the national broadcaster’s one hour long flagship football show fails to show two of the goals in one out of just FIVE games they have to cover.
Embarrassing.Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnny_Leith
Some of the folk on YouTube put together a more professional show than these clowns.
Absolutely embarrassing show.
I think a group of students could put together a better show. Compare it to match of the day it’s night and day. Genuinely shameless.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chorley Hibee
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Brutal viewing - amateur hourQuote:
Originally Posted by Chorley Hibee
BBC Scotland have a limited budget for the show obviously, but one has to wonder how much of the budget goes towards paying the pundits, and if a better product might be had by ditching these pundits?Quote:
Originally Posted by Chorley Hibee
One thing I'd like to see would be a former referee on the show, someone who knows the game, and someone who can take a look at these "controversial" incidents that get highlighted and give an opinion from a ref's standpoint rather than having pundits attempting to cover their backside by saying they don't think it's a red, before saying the ref made the right decision.
I'd like to hope that the BBC might consider looking at these youtubers to see if they could learn a thing or two, but that would require them to actually realise that the program needs improving.
The audio editing for the Aberdeen Dundee United game was unbelievable.
There would be no point having a ref on at all. You ever heard when they get one on sportscene? They would never admit that ref has made a mistake.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryan91
I’d agree on your point on pundits though, they’re pointless.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Having any sort of debate around one of the most obvious red cards ever was just weird. All of our goals were just due to bad defending. Would it kill them to say we are playing well?
Noticed that too. Nothing positive to say about Hibs play, just analysing the part played by Livi which led to our goals. It's really getting beyond a joke now - more fool me for watching this dross.Quote:
Originally Posted by SlickShoes
exactly! that managed to fawn over hearts and say how great they are instead of highlighting how lucky they were with the deflection and cross which went in...they took plenty of time to slate us when we were doing badly, highlighting lack of identity / club in crisis etc etc but nothing substantial on how well we've played recently. think they even got the length of the unbeaten run wrong!Quote:
Originally Posted by SlickShoes
it is incredible just how bad it is in comparison to MOTD but then I guess it also shows symmetry with the money differential between the EPL and SPFL!
They really don't like us. Which makes our run even more delightful.Quote:
Originally Posted by SlickShoes
Am I reading this right? Sportscene didn’t didn’t show our 3rd and 4th goals? Or was it just omitted from the “analysis”?Quote:
Originally Posted by hibsbollah
The goals were shown in the highlights, but there was no discussion about them with Thompson smugly saying "moving on".Quote:
Originally Posted by Carheenlea
We will be expected to be grateful for what we get.Quote:
Originally Posted by HarpOnHibee
Sportscene’s not produced for our benefit. We’re merely filler.
Don't worry, it's not like we're forced to pay for it or anything.
The BBC doesn't give a fig for Scottish football. It knows Sky, BT and Viacom are hoovering up the gruesome twosome so sees no point in wasting cash on good coverage if it's only the diddies that watch it.
Not sure how that squares with being a "public service broadcaster", but there you go.
If they spent less time analysing Rangers goals or refereeing decisions inside out they might have time to show other teams goals [emoji2371]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
It’s easier not to watch it! Once the license fee is done away with, they are finished.
Towards the end of the Hearts v St Johnston game the Saints had a shot stopped on the line by a defender . In real time it looked like it hit an arm but no slow motion replay or analysis on Sportscene which suggests to me it must have hit an arm.
Has anyone seen a clip to clarify the incident.
Just watched it on BBC I player. Can't believe (well I can actually) they didn't do any analysis of the 3rd and 4th goals. Very amateurish.Quote:
Originally Posted by Carheenlea
Yup,it definitely felt like it was making excuses for Livingston and not praising Hibs. Probably because some of their favoured teams have struggled there, too.Quote:
Originally Posted by SlickShoes