Will be gutting to see McGeough playing for that lot. Hope it doesn’t happen.
Printable View
Will be gutting to see McGeough playing for that lot. Hope it doesn’t happen.
We only have 3 pre season games prior to our first competitive game,I would hope we have done some ball work before the game on Wednesday. I would hate to do a 150 mile round trip for nothingQuote:
Originally Posted by CapitalGreen
Honestly, glad we aren’t in for Dylan. He’ll want a huge wage and I think he’ll struggle with injuries. All the bashing with players we signed in league 1, yet Dylan was unable to make any kind of mark down there. Maybe being in a midfield without SJM shows he’s not that great. Time will tell.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Torto7
You sure about that? He wasn't that keen on joining us from Celtic and he wasn't exactly greetin when he left.
Couldn't agree moreQuote:
Originally Posted by Ozyhibby
Quote:
Originally Posted by Torto7
I agree, Dylan stood out when McGinn was doing the leg work which allowed him and Allan time on the ball, if Hecky wants athleticism in his midfield, then Dylan isn't it.
Pressure is now on whoever we get in defensive mid now as well. If he’s not as good as McGeough fans won’t be happy.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Quote:
Originally Posted by gloryhunter
:agree:
Had to really be convinced to join us and even after a seemingly superb offer chose Sunderland, I always got the feeling he didn't really care that much about us in the same way as Allan, McGinn, Boyle, Gray etc who all bought into what the club is all about.
:agree:Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
The Sheep dont like it up em!
Dylan isn’t a defensive midfielder though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ozyhibby
There does seem to be confusion about defensive midfielders and deep lying playmakersQuote:
Originally Posted by 90+2
We’ll do ball work Monday, Tuesday & Wednesday.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ringothedog
Yip, I agree. Always thought Dylan's game very was one dimensional, wasn't that bothered when he left. We need a more dynamic midfielder otherwise we wouldn't have let Milligan go, Mcgeouch just doesn't fit the bill.Quote:
Originally Posted by J-C
I see history is being re-written in regards to McGeouch now it looks like he may be joining Aberdeen.
He'll be a squad player at best with Aberdeen and I honestly think that suits him down to the ground.
Exactly. Great player and very popular with the fans. The send off he received only happens with good players. I’ll be gutted to see him line up against us.Quote:
Originally Posted by CapitalGreen
McGeouch is an utterly fantastic midfielder but is very injury prone, minus his last season. I’d definitely have him back but a midfield of him, Allan and Mallan would get pumped.
No surprise that Aberdeen are going for him again after they went so massive on trying to get him last summer. He’ll be one of, if not their highest paid player. Bryson, Ferguson and McGeouch is a very good midfield at this level.
He will be the best footballer in their entire squad of utter brutalists. Don’t kid yourself.Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Bear
Don't think that's the case. One of my favourite players. There is an obvious way that Heckingbottom wants to play and if McGeouch doesn't fit into that system then I'm going to trust him.Quote:
Originally Posted by CapitalGreen
I'm happy we are signing players to fit a system rather than signing good players and shoehorning them into a team
Could he dictate the game? I’m not sure that’s true.Quote:
Originally Posted by S4uzee
He didn’t really give a monkeys arse about the club when we offered him a great deal to stay and he chose Sunderland, wasted a year of his career in the process
It actually bodes well that our manager might be looking for better
He’s good enough to be a regular at Aberdeen but not sure he’s got that nasty/cynical side that Mcinnes seems to want from his midfielders.Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Bear
They love turning games scrappy, in an open football match they’re nothing special, in a scrap they’re better than most in our league. Shinnie, Ball and Ferguson have been good at that recently and I personally think Mcgeouch is the opposite of that kind of player so be interesting to see how he would fit in, my guess is that he probably won’t.
100% agree. We've been down that road numerous times and it hasn't worked.Quote:
Originally Posted by 04Sauzee
If you sign Dylan you have to sign someone else to job share with him.
Don’t forget Lennon was for punting him before his final season or half season of performances.
We remember a great player and Scottish cup winner, which he was.
We should also remember him as an oft injured player who is not at all arsed about coming to or staying at or coming back to, Hibs.
Feelers were put out in May from his agent-PH actually said we were considering him but decided against it.Quote:
Originally Posted by gloryhunter
The funny thing is he actually was greeting when he left us.
Definitely.Quote:
Originally Posted by 04Sauzee
If McGeouch was to rejoin he would be one of the top 2/3 players at the club.
Unsure how you can say that without seeing the new guys play?Quote:
Originally Posted by CapitalGreen
Surely that could be an argument used against Messi also?Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuart93
Absolutely. Mallan is seen as our playmaker now. McGeouch but further forward. PH changed Mallans role into more of a number 8 when he came in. What we need is the attributes SJM brought albeit unlikely to be at the level he reached. I'm a bit gutted about Ojo tbh. I've seen him play for S****horpe before and he'd be ideal.Quote:
Originally Posted by 90+2
Will be crap if he goes to Aberdeen.
Rubbish if he goes to any other Scottish team - let alone one we are competing against.
Dylan would have been a good addition - he's only been away 1 year.
Add in the fact he knows the club and what's expected.
He was never box to box as such but he can control a game and would still add something as starter or coming on as a sub.
I agree we need energy in the middle and someone like SJM who can win tackles and turn the ball over for Allan and Mallan but we also need depth.