Rugby

ah well, we done well to hold SA for nearly a full 4 mins

Yellow card for Cummings. Crap call imo. I disagree it was a Croc roll and it certainly wasn't Cummings.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

Cummings card upgraded

can bring someone else on after 20 mins

well

that was a very costly error by ben white costing us 7 points, Try & Con SA 9-19

they've been told, USE IT


great try scotland, well done ben white :) converted 16-19


incredible, converted and now called off, away do one TMO :(

9-19

HT

I thought once the conversion had been taken you couldn’t go back and review?

Ref is at it is he not. Very harsh red card imo. Also the white call in front of the posts. Bizarre a try can be given then kick taken then tmo gets involved.

here we go with the bomb squad subs


idiotic penalty to give away scotland


we're getting hammered in the scrums


some lovely rugby

SA yellow card

15-19

Scotland have been sensational butchered a few opportunities tho

What knock on again right in front of posts

we deserved more from this but those silly mistakes near the try line


that's twice jones has tossed a poor pass to VDM


fgs jamie ritchie that is so bloody stupid

and that's cost us

we certainly didn't deserve that big a gap

Referee and TMO poor for me, usually in favour of SA.


Croc roll was a joke, and th knock on for Scotland’s try was not only dubious, but went back through a number of phases of play (almost like they were looking for something!), and the tmo intervention came after the conversion kick had taken place

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by McD

Referee and TMO poor for me, usually in favour of SA.


Croc roll was a joke, and th knock on for Scotland’s try was not only dubious, but went back through a number of phases of play (almost like they were looking for something!), and the tmo intervention came after the conversion kick had taken place

---

Agree reffing to different rules. Disallowed Scotland try was a joke don’t think it was forward.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JimBHibees

Agree reffing to different rules. Disallowed Scotland try was a joke don’t think it was forward.

---

Sadly, they changed the rules to allow them to go back through the phases and it was undoubtedly a missed knock-on from Jones in the build-up to the try. It sucked, but it was the correct call. That being said, I don't feel the red card was a red card offence (it wasn't a 'croc roll'), and I think the bogus 'knock-on' later on when we had possession near our own goal line that lead to them getting a scrum, penalty and resultant points that made the game safe was visible either.

The better team won IMO, but we definitely got reffed differently to them...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sylar

Sadly, they changed the rules to allow them to go back through the phases and it was undoubtedly a missed knock-on from Jones in the build-up to the try. It sucked, but it was the correct call. That being said, I don't feel the red card was a red card offence (it wasn't a 'croc roll'), and I think the bogus 'knock-on' later on when we had possession near our own goal line that lead to them getting a scrum, penalty and resultant points that made the game safe was visible either.

The better team won IMO, but we definitely got reffed differently to them...

---

Did they also change the rule about not being able to go back once the conversion was taken? I thought it was really odd that they did that

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by McD

Did they also change the rule about not being able to go back once the conversion was taken? I thought it was really odd that they did that

---

That confused me, too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by McD

Did they also change the rule about not being able to go back once the conversion was taken? I thought it was really odd that they did that

---

Yes.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sylar

Yes.

---

Thanks :aok: I wasn’t sure what was happening and I don’t think they made it clear in the commentary

after last weekends games, won't include Ireland winning last night

https://scontent.fman1-2.fna.fbcdn.n..._g&oe=673E1CCC

12-0 Scotland, game has started like a 7s match.

33-7 ht

59-21 ft

England v SA is a good game. 15-19 after 26 mins.

The commentators in the England v South Africa game are doing my head in. It's non stop drivel, just concentrate on the actual game for a change.

🤬

France have the edge here 27-23 against the All Blacks. 15 mins left

:sauzee:

5 mins remaining and i thought it was the wrong decision by Scott Barrett to go for the 3 points and then hoping they got more ball and another penalty that would win it


i was right, shoulda went for that lineout Scotty

i see Lomu: the lost tapes is on again now, watched it last week he had quite a tough upbringing

well worth the watch if anyone hasn't saw it, still so sad a great career cut short early then of course passing away

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cabbageandribs1875

5 mins remaining and i thought it was the wrong decision by Scott Barrett to go for the 3 points and then hoping they got more ball and another penalty that would win it


i was right, shoulda went for that lineout Scotty

---

Great entertainment though. 👏

The anthems and Haka in Paris last night are amongst the most impressive ive ever seen. The in stadium production, lighting, and respect all added up to a true spectacle.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sylar

The anthems and Haka in Paris last night are amongst the most impressive ive ever seen. The in stadium production, lighting, and respect all added up to a true spectacle.

---

Always look forward to watching the Haka, it was superb with the lighting and respect. Makes a change from the English and Irish players marching forwards, and their crowds booing. The silence from the crowd and the darkened stadium was electrifying