No hibs players in spfl team of the year?

[Billy McKirdy]

As it says on the tin.
Thoughts please.

The PFA Scotland Team of the Year was: Kasper Schmeichel (Celtic), Alistair Johnston (Celtic), Cameron Carter-Vickers (Celtic), John Souttar (Rangers), James Penrice (Hearts); Nicolas Raskin (Rangers), Callum McGregor (Celtic), Reo Hatate (Celtic); Nicolas Kühn (Celtic), Sam Dalby (Dundee United), Daizen Maeda (Celtic).

No Hibs players makes this selection a joke 🤡

https://www.hibsobserver.co.uk/news/25110272.no-hibs-players-team-year-mad-say-rivals/?ref=eb&nid=2800&block=article_block_a&u=91172a388223d9db8a6b3a151a2b8868&date=230425

[Carheenlea]

Quite pleased with that to be fair.

I don”t really have much appetite for Hibs to be “one of the lads” - I’m happy ploughing our own furrow without any external cheerleading.

[DH1875]

As it says on the tin.
Thoughts please.

The PFA Scotland Team of the Year was: Kasper Schmeichel (Celtic), Alistair Johnston (Celtic), Cameron Carter-Vickers (Celtic), John Souttar (Rangers), James Penrice (Hearts); Nicolas Raskin (Rangers), Callum McGregor (Celtic), Reo Hatate (Celtic); Nicolas Kühn (Celtic), Sam Dalby (Dundee United), Daizen Maeda (Celtic).

No Hibs players makes this selection a joke 🤡

https://www.hibsobserver.co.uk/news/25110272.no-hibs-players-team-year-mad-say-rivals/?ref=eb&nid=2800&block=article_block_a&u=91172a388223d9db8a6b3a151a2b8868&date=230425

Why is it a joke? Who would you have in and who they replacing?

[CallumLaidlaw]

Why is it a joke? Who would you have in and who they replacing?

Andy Halliday and Tony Watt say that Rocky has been the best defender in the league for months so should be in it and that Triantis should be in it over Raskin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[CropleyWasGod]

Isn't this voted on by the players?

[ancient hibee]

Yes. The PFA is the clue:greengrin.

[CropleyWasGod]

Yes. The PFA is the clue:greengrin.

:greengrin

In which case, I've got a bit more respect for this than I would if it were media-picked.

[Bridge hibs]

Why is it a joke? Who would you have in and who they replacing?Rocky, Iredale and Nicky Cadden over Soutar any day, he is one of the reasons the rangers have been pap at home

[Itsnoteasy]

Andy Halliday and Tony Watt say that Rocky has been the best defender in the league for months so should be in it and that Triantis should be in it over Raskin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's for the whole season, not just the unbeaten run.

[gbhibby]

It's for the whole season, not just the unbeaten run.
Some of the players in that team have not been on it all season.

[HoboHarry]

Never really did see the point of these exercises, we know who the team of the year is, it's Celtic since they won the league. Be as well just picking the 11 players who made the most appearances for Celtic if no recognition is given out to individual stand out players from other teams. IMHO.

[TrumpIsAPeado]

The Hibs players are too busy to make it into the SPFL "team of the year" line up. Which is why it's full of players from clubs who have nothing else to play for.

[ancient hibee]

The team is chosen by the players who are not allowed to choose
club mates.At least that’s how it used to be.-presumably still the same.

[superfurryhibby]

The team is chosen by the players who are not allowed to choose
club mates.At least that’s how it used to be.-presumably still the same.






Assume so. The players player of the year used to be a prestigious accolade?

[Billy Bunter 07]

We are a very good team with no real standouts. Not surprised at all and it's voted by the pros.

[Viva_Palmeiras]

Well I suppose we are beginning to run out of things to have a good old winge about :)

[SHODAN]

I think this just serves to highlight that we are a good team rather than an average team with exceptional players.

[PatHead]

Someone told me that the voting took place in January which would explain why our players weren't selected.

[hibee_girl]

Someone told me that the voting took place in January which would explain why our players weren't selected.

How can a team of the year be decided in January??

Unless it’s calendar year… 🤔

[PatHead]

How can a team of the year be decided in January??

Unless it’s calendar year… 🤔

Just what I was told. I know it sounds odd but since when has common sense ever prevail?

[Billy Bunter 07]

Just what I was told. I know it sounds odd but since when has common sense ever prevail?

If it was voted for in January Khun would be a shoe in for the poty never mind missing out in the team.

[Trinity Hibee]

Someone told me that the voting took place in January which would explain why our players weren't selected.

That would make absolutely zero sense so it’s probably true

[DH1875]

If it was voted for in January Khun would be a shoe in for the poty never mind missing out in the team.

He is in the team though.

[7Hero]

Let's just keep our mega stars out the limelight as much as possible please.

[HIBERNIAN-0762]

Penrice? 😮🤣🤣

[Bostonhibby]

Surely Hearts will be briefing their media chums before going full on statement as there's no nomination for Devlin or whatsisname,? the superstar identified by their computer.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[bingo70]

Rocky, Iredale and Nicky Cadden over Soutar any day, he is one of the reasons the rangers have been pap at home

They said on the open goal podcast as well that Nicky Cadden was listed as an attacker and that’s why he never got in. If he was listed as a left back he probably would have been in there.

[Wilson]

Can't help but feel the pros have had a shocker here. Hope none that voted Penrice get punditry work when they retire!

Can't believe I'm actually looking forward to the journos picks. There are plenty of players, having big impacts for their team, not quoted. A bit of thought and insight might be nice.

[Trinity Hibee]

They said on the open goal podcast as well that Nicky Cadden was listed as an attacker and that’s why he never got in. If he was listed as a left back he probably would have been in there.

Nicky cadden isn’t really a LB either though is he? He plays wing back but all of his impact is in an attacking sense so I’d call him a winger tbh.

Just hoping this fires the players up a bit more for rest of season.

[poolman]

As it says on the tin.
Thoughts please.

The PFA Scotland Team of the Year was: Kasper Schmeichel (Celtic), Alistair Johnston (Celtic), Cameron Carter-Vickers (Celtic), John Souttar (Rangers), James Penrice (Hearts); Nicolas Raskin (Rangers), Callum McGregor (Celtic), Reo Hatate (Celtic); Nicolas Kühn (Celtic), Sam Dalby (Dundee United), Daizen Maeda (Celtic).

No Hibs players makes this selection a joke 🤡

https://www.hibsobserver.co.uk/news/25110272.no-hibs-players-team-year-mad-say-rivals/?ref=eb&nid=2800&block=article_block_a&u=91172a388223d9db8a6b3a151a2b8868&date=230425



Don't care what these prats think

[Nicho87]

Ridiculous decisions in there

Souttar, Penrice, Hatate/Raskin, Kuhn all in the WTF category for me

How on earth rocky, bushiri, triantis, Nicky cadden haven’t appeared even one of them shows what a messed up league this is.

It’s all about voting for your pals and no reflection on what you do on the pitch.