Murray Johnson

[leith lynx]

Can we cut his loan short and bring him back now?……hope so.

[JohnM1875]

He's playing for a team bottom of the Championship with a -12 goal difference. Probably not ready yet.

[TrinityHFC]

Can we cut his loan short and bring him back now?……hope so.

He’s in the right place. Still has a lot to learn and is making mistakes. Hopefully he can be someone we can rely on for the long term but this isn’t the time for him.

[Unseen work]

I’ve no idea if he’s good enough.

But he’ll be better than Bursik

[truehibernian]

Boruc is the best keeper at the club. Some of the players think that.

[Onceinawhile]

Can we cut his loan short and bring him back now?……hope so.

No. We're not in a transfer window.

[HFC93]

Aye, the young lad who is conceding goals for fun at Airdrie is the solution.

[Nicho87]

Bursik just doesn’t get it

We scored the equaliser had the momentum, he then faffed about walking with the ball. Gray whistled over and told him to move it!

I’d be looking to cut short the loan fairly quickly

[GreenCastle]

Mad to think we signed 2 keepers. I genuinely think marshall would have still been better this season and didn’t want him staying on as his reactions were poor.

One is undroppable.

The back up is poor too and happy to be 2nd choice and just pick up a wage.

Any decent recruitment and we have 2 guys fighting it out.

[The dalmeny]

Can we cut his loan short and bring him back now?……hope so.

There's a reason why the spfl isn't full of 20yo keepers ( 3 or 4 I think) Murray is a long term investment. Bringing him in to that shambles of a defence would be a disaster.

We could only get him back on an emergency loan and that probably would need to be written in his loan. And that's before any discussion of how he's actually playing.

[Northernhibee]

I wonder how much it’d take to get Dabrowski back in? A good shot stopper, and for some reason we’re turning our noses up a goalies who can stop a shot.

[scoopyboy]

I wonder how much it’d take to get Dabrowski back in? A good shot stopper, and for some reason we’re turning our noses up a goalies who can stop a shot.

He is definitely not the answer, one of the reasons Raith didn't go up last season.

If he was that good do you think he would still be there?

[Pretty Boy]

I really rate Murray Johnson and I don't buy this idea you have to wrap keepers in cotton wool until they are about 28. Maybe 30 years ago but plenty top keepers have been playing first team football at 17/18.

He's not the answer now though. Throwing a young, inexperienced guy into this shambles isn't fair. He's better staying well out of it and learning his trade this season.

[Northernhibee]

He is definitely not the answer, one of the reasons Raith didn't go up last season.

If he was that good do you think he would still be there?

He’s a hundred times better than the two options we have just now. I’d even beg Marshall to dust off the gloves at this moment in time.

[scoopyboy]

He’s a hundred times better than the two options we have just now. I’d even beg Marshall to dust off the gloves at this moment in time.

None you have mentioned are the answer in my opinion, I think we need to bring a good goalie in early January,

[Crab apple]

None you have mentioned are the answer in my opinion, I think we need to bring a good goalie in early January,

January is going to be huge again. We definitely need a new keeper. And as the lowest scorers in the league we need to find a Maolida. Otherwise I think we are in real danger of relegation as there is no Livi this year to bail everyone out.

[Unseen work]

Will Dennis in January, has to be

[Stokesy's on fire]

Best left out on loan not fair to force him into this team with the problems we have

[leith lynx]

I really rate Murray Johnson and I don't buy this idea you have to wrap keepers in cotton wool until they are about 28. Maybe 30 years ago but plenty top keepers have been playing first team football at 17/18.

He's not the answer now though. Throwing a young, inexperienced guy into this shambles isn't fair. He's better staying well out of it and learning his trade this season.
On reflection, agree with this.Reliable, steady keeper a must in January though.

[Jamesie]

Boruc is the best keeper at the club. Some of the players think that.

I would agree with them.