McGhee and Boyle fouls !

[Donegal Hibby]

I’m at a loss to how one wasn’t a yellow and the other was . The only thing I can think of is the refs let McGhee off because he’s already booked him and decided to book Boyle because he hasn’t been booked up until that point…

Where’s the consistency in that though when both merited yellow cards ? . It’s really infuriating the inconsistency in decisions that can affect a game which this might have today too .

[Unseen work]

Second yellow every day of the week now a days

[Jim44]

I’m at a loss to how one wasn’t a yellow and the other was . The only thing I can think of is the refs let McGhee off because he’s already booked him and decided to book Boyle because he hasn’t been booked up until that point…

Where’s the consistency in that though when both merited yellow cards ? . It’s really infuriating the inconsistency in decisions that can affect a game which this might have today too .

I agree. Referees shouldn’t even begin to consider the potential effect of their decisions. A spade is a spade. Whiffs of favouritism at best and corruption at worst.

[Bostonhibby]

Not just because it affects Hibs, but just when I thought Scottish football officiating couldn't reach even more incompetent comedic standards of refereeing this new guy splats onto the scene and shows there are no depths that cannot be plummeted to.

Utter clown who likes a yellow,realised what a mess he'd created then shat it when a second yellow was required.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[Chorley Hibee]

Ridiculous decision and definitive proof that they're making up the rules as they go along.

It was quite obviously a yellow card and the only reason he didn't give it was it would have resulted in a red.

He then dished out a yellow card to a Hibs player, 60 seconds later, for almost the same foul.

Surely the assessor see this and marks them down?

[Alfred E Newman]

Not just because it affects Hibs, but just when I thought Scottish football officiating couldn't reach even more incompetent comedic standards of refereeing this new guy splats onto the scene and shows there are no depths that cannot be plummeted to.

Utter clown who likes a yellow,realised what a mess he'd created then shat it when a second yellow was required.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

He’s not new and he was equally incompetent last season. What really annoys me about Scottish football and the standard of refereeing is that this guy has no chance of getting to officiate at a Glasgow derby or most games featuring that pair yet we regularly get lumbered with the likes of him and most of the other second raters

[Bostonhibby]

He’s not new and he was equally incompetent last season. What really annoys me about Scottish football and the standard of refereeing is that this guy has no chance of getting to officiate at a Glasgow derby or most games featuring that pair yet we regularly get lumbered with the likes of him and most of the other second raters[emoji106]

Sorry, new on my radar, but I'm more of a Beaton, Walsh & Napier conspiracy theorist[emoji16]

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[green day]

The ref dished out 8 yellows in what was not a dirty match.

He has, every time I have seen him, lost control and flashed cards all over the place.

He should be demoted for not showing a second yellow for the blatant shirt tug.

[LaMotta]

Kwon could have been booked at least twice as well. And Tiffoney for them early doors.

[Carheenlea]

What makes it worse was the nonsense booking of Rudi for a half hearted “bounce” of ball for “dissent” which resulted in him having to pull out of fully committed tackles for fear of a yellow.

Would he have been allowed to commit another foul in the same manner as McGee?

[LaMotta]

What makes it worse was the nonsense booking of Rudi for a half hearted “bounce” of ball for “dissent” which resulted in him having to pull out of fully committed tackles for fear of a yellow.

Would he have been allowed to commit another foul in the same manner as McGee?

That is such a daft rule. Why are you not allowed to bounce the ball in frustration? Especially when you are putting the ball towards where the free kick should be taken. A Dundee played bounced the ball later in the game. No booking.

[green day]

What makes it worse was the nonsense booking of Rudi for a half hearted “bounce” of ball for “dissent” which resulted in him having to pull out of fully committed tackles for fear of a yellow.

Would he have been allowed to commit another foul in the same manner as McGee?

I think that refs have been told to book things like that.

It did seem pernickety but I think it's just the instructions they are given

[Real Emerald]

I’m at a loss to how one wasn’t a yellow and the other was . The only thing I can think of is the refs let McGhee off because he’s already booked him and decided to book Boyle because he hasn’t been booked up until that point…

Where’s the consistency in that though when both merited yellow cards ? . It’s really infuriating the inconsistency in decisions that can affect a game which this might have today too .

That is exactly the reason McGhee didn’t get a yellow. It was as obvious a yellow for a professional foul you’d see. Refs are just mince but I’ll bet you any money Porteous would have walked for it.

[The Harp Awakes]

I’m at a loss to how one wasn’t a yellow and the other was . The only thing I can think of is the refs let McGhee off because he’s already booked him and decided to book Boyle because he hasn’t been booked up until that point…

Where’s the consistency in that though when both merited yellow cards ? . It’s really infuriating the inconsistency in decisions that can affect a game which this might have today too .

Scottish refs are brutal. That's such an obvious 2nd yellow for McGhee.

Every liklihood we'd have gone onto win the game comfortably v 10.

[HibeeMackenzie]

What makes it worse was the nonsense booking of Rudi for a half hearted “bounce” of ball for “dissent” which resulted in him having to pull out of fully committed tackles for fear of a yellow.

Would he have been allowed to commit another foul in the same manner as McGee?

It was Simon Murray who’d also been booked already

[Posh Swanny]

Then you see the second yellow the St Johnstone boy got at Tannadice and wonder WTF is going on! 😂

[JJP]

I think he was the same ref we had up at Dingwall last season that allowed them to take a late throw in that they scored from many yards up the park from where the ball went out of play. Seemed to be really fussy about where throw ins were taken from today though.

[Donegal Hibby]

Scottish refs are brutal. That's such an obvious 2nd yellow for McGhee.

Every liklihood we'd have gone onto win the game comfortably v 10.

Totally agree that if McGhee had a went off it would have changed the outcome of the game alright.

From being card happy to that moment when McGhee committed the foul it looked like it was a case of ‘ I’m not going to draw any attention on myself by sending this guy off’ only to not being able to get his card out quick enough to book Boyle for a totally similar offence. Shocking refereeing.

[overdrive]

Simon Murray also sarcastically clapped the ref when he won a foul in the first half when he was already on a booking. Given Molotnikov had been booked for dissent at that point, Murray should have been off.

[LaMotta]

Simon Murray also sarcastically clapped the ref when he won a foul in the first half when he was already on a booking. Given Molotnikov had been booked for dissent at that point, Murray should have been off.

noticed that too...

[Real Emerald]

Simon Murray also sarcastically clapped the ref when he won a foul in the first half when he was already on a booking. Given Molotnikov had been booked for dissent at that point, Murray should have been off.

His fouling, shoving and cheating today was beyond belief, he’d done way enough to earn 2 yellows.

[Dueday]

I’m at a loss to how one wasn’t a yellow and the other was . The only thing I can think of is the refs let McGhee off because he’s already booked him and decided to book Boyle because he hasn’t been booked up until that point…

Where’s the consistency in that though when both merited yellow cards ? . It’s really infuriating the inconsistency in decisions that can affect a game which this might have today too .

It was a not a yellow because Kuharevich had his back to goal, also the perception was that the ball was running away from him, and therefore not deemed as a promising attack.

The Boyle yellow was because the Dundee player was running forward with control of the ball resulting in preventing a promising attack.

[Donegal Hibby]

It was a not a yellow because Kuharevich had his back to goal, also the perception was that the ball was running away from him, and therefore not deemed as a promising attack.

The Boyle yellow was because the Dundee player was running forward with control of the ball resulting in preventing a promising attack.

It shouldn’t matter what way the players facing , he’s actually on the turn I think when he’s tugged/pulled and not able to get to the ball because of it , a fouls a foul imo .