Liam Rosenior

[sauzee1989]

Sacked by Hull unfairly. Plays great football and coming from a league of a decent level. Exactly who we should be going for.

[JimBHibees]

Sacked by Hull unfairly. Plays great football and coming from a league of a decent level. Exactly who we should be going for.

Seems incredibly harsh

[Dazzjw1875]

Sacked by Hull unfairly. Plays great football and coming from a league of a decent level. Exactly who we should be going for.

Was just going to post the very same, nominated for manager of the Season in the championship also seems crazy! But the kind of manager I would think BK group would go for.. attacking football and great to watch.

[Mcbizz1998]

I must admit I don't know much about the guy but seems decent on paper.

Would we have any chance of getting him or is he well out of our reach?

[HH81]

Always used to speak very well on sky. One best pundits then got Hull Job and done well.

I'd take him.

[easty]

He’ll get another championship job no bother.

If they end up relegated next season, they’ll have nobody to blame but themselves, like Birmingham this season when they sacked Eustace.

[Murphys Touch]

"Look at the shiny shiny!!!"

Progressive, attacking minded English coach from the championship....heard that before.

(BTW, I agree, shows you how hard it really is and how fickle football fans are!)

[04Sauzee]

He’ll get another championship job no bother.

If they end up relegated next season, they’ll have nobody to blame but themselves, like Birmingham this season when they sacked Eustace.
He could as he's a seemed like a decent manager, played good football the few times I seen them. What championships clubs are looking for a manager?

[Bostonhibby]

Decent guy, listen to him a bit on our local news, got Hull playing well. Think he will pop up at another championship club.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[Unseen work]

Don’t know much about him as a manager.

From an outsider looking in though, him getting nominated for manager of the year despite missing out on the play offs seems a bit off?

I would have though that would have been Hulls target to be in the play offs

As for coming to us, again I’d be worried he doesn’t know enough/understand Scottish football or looks down on it.

[ancient hibee]

Didn’t know we had a vacancy.

[Unseen work]

https://www.not606.com/threads/in-a-nutshell-rosies-management-style-and-next-season.412597/

Interesting views of Hull Fans. Some of it is identical to reading Hibs net!

[ElginHibee]

Exactly like hibs.net the reactions here are the opposite.

https://www.not606.com/threads/rosenior-done-one.412623/

[Exuberance1875]

So long as he brings Greg Docherty with him, we do however need a manager with experience of this league. Another young English manager in my opinion isn’t what we need.

Hecky, LJ, Monty all so similar appointments and all massive failures

[cameronw-hfc]

So long as he brings Greg Docherty with him, we do however need a manager with experience of this league. Another young English manager in my opinion isn’t what we need.

Hecky, LJ, Monty all so similar appointments and all massive failures


This 'Need a manager with experience of our league' is nonsense imo.

We don't need someone with experience, we just need someone decent. I've no idea what makes the scottish league so unique that we need to hire someone who's played/managed here, when no other league is like that.

If Monty goes, Rosenior would be good imo, not sure we'd get him though.

[Exuberance1875]

This 'Need a manager with experience of our league' is nonsense imo.

We don't need someone with experience, we just need someone decent. I've no idea what makes the scottish league so unique that we need to hire someone who's played/managed here, when no other league is like that.

If Monty goes, Rosenior would be good imo, not sure we'd get him though.

Appreciate your point, I just think it’s such a typically under appreciated league by those down south which leads to signing players so far from good enough to actually compete in this league. Whereas you look at the signings made by people who know the league.

[cameronw-hfc]

Appreciate your point, I just think it’s such a typically under appreciated league by those down south which leads to signing players so far from good enough to actually compete in this league. Whereas you look at the signings made by people who know the league.



I see your point, and no doubt there have been people underestimating our league but I think more is down to managers just not being good enough.

There's plenty gems to find in league 2 and league 1 down south, just we don't do it. We try by signing players from there but it rarely works for us, although imo it doesn't make it a bad strategy, just poorly executed.

I want something different, I'm mainly sick of the same few names being branded about everytime we lose, ie, Del and Lennon etc.

[Renfrew_Hibby]

Would need to get a Scottish No.2 in alongside him. I'm sure he's played with a few over the years.

[Silky]

But he doesn't know the Scottish game.

[Exuberance1875]

I see your point, and no doubt there have been people underestimating our league but I think more is down to managers just not being good enough.

There's plenty gems to find in league 2 and league 1 down south, just we don't do it. We try by signing players from there but it rarely works for us, although imo it doesn't make it a bad strategy, just poorly executed.

I want something different, I'm mainly sick of the same few names being branded about everytime we lose, ie, Del and Lennon etc.

Yeah that’s fair, it’s quality issue too.

We can live in hope 😂

[Stevie Reid]

He’ll get another championship job no bother.

If they end up relegated next season, they’ll have nobody to blame but themselves, like Birmingham this season when they sacked Eustace.

Was exactly my thought as well when I read the news - same vibes as Birmingham in the Rowett/Zola and Eustace/Rooney debacles.

On the subject of Rooney, I might be wrong but I think the time that he performed really well as a manager was at Derby with Rosenior as his assistant, and struggled without him since.

If our new investors, as many suspect, don’t want to go for an experienced SPL name, I could definitely get on board with Rosenior.

Pretty sure he’ll walk into another Championship job immediately, as others have said though - in fact, I wouldn’t be at all surprised if his availability leads to someone else in that league losing their job in the next couple of days.

[Winston Ingram]

Sacked by Hull unfairly. Plays great football and coming from a league of a decent level. Exactly who we should be going for.

Hull City
16th highest wage bill in Championship
17th most expensive squad
19th highest revenue
...sack the manager for not finishing in the top 6 and playoffs.

Absolutely no chance we’ll get him. He’s got a great reputation.

He’ll be snapped up by another Championship Club in no time.

https://x.com/kieranmaguire/status/1787890596234891573?s=61&t=WQcv92feu62WUfbidLejfg

[Caversham Green]

He was at Reading during Brian McDermott's time there.

Just saying.

[Gmack7]

He was at Reading during Brian McDermott's time there.

Just saying.

Nothing in this thread points to us going for LR, until this post😁

[Crazyhorse]

Hull City
16th highest wage bill in Championship
17th most expensive squad
19th highest revenue
...sack the manager for not finishing in the top 6 and playoffs.

Absolutely no chance we’ll get him. He’s got a great reputation.

He’ll be snapped up by another Championship Club in no time.

https://x.com/kieranmaguire/status/1787890596234891573?s=61&t=WQcv92feu62WUfbidLejfg

Agree with all that. I saw Hull play this season against QPR and they looked a good well organised side.
He’ll not have long to wait for another club to come knocking.

On the wider point Hibs are unfortunately wasting the opportunity to get someone in and sort the team out for next season. Monty will be sacked before we play 10 games next year.

[tamig]

Don’t know much about him as a manager.

From an outsider looking in though, him getting nominated for manager of the year despite missing out on the play offs seems a bit off?

I would have though that would have been Hulls target to be in the play offs

As for coming to us, again I’d be worried he doesn’t know enough/understand Scottish football or looks down on it.

He saved them from relegation after taking over last season. They missed out on a play-off place on the last day. I think he’s a more than worthy contender.

[SHODAN]

No, no, no. No more managers without any experience up here. Done with it.

[bingo70]

No, no, no. No more managers without any experience up here. Done with it.

What if it was an experienced manager that had achieved success elsewhere?

I don’t know anything about Rosenior but limiting ourselves to Scottish football only seems a bit unnecessary imo.

[Unseen work]

He saved them from relegation after taking over last season. They missed out on a play-off place on the last day. I think he’s a more than worthy contender.

I’m not against him or don’t think he’s a worthy contender.

I don’t know enough him about Hull, the fact he was nominated for manager of the year must mean he’s done something right.

But taking on Hull, keeping them up and having them miss out on the top 6 sounds similar to someone praising Monty by saying he took us over when we were second bottom and just missed out on the top 6 on the last day of the season 🤣

Obviously there’s more to it hence the Hull thread I posted. A lot of different views about the football played, some think it was really boring and some thought it was brilliant but a few comments about it being in April and after a meeting with the board?

Also comments that the owner chucked money at the club in January for them to get the top 6. Last game of the season they lost to the club who were 21st in the league. Again sounds a bit familiar.

I could see Rosenior being the type to come up with a plan with us and not realising certain teams in the league are happy for us to have possession and will only counter.

Like I said, not against him at all and he’s clearly highly rated - but I’d still need to be sold on him and want us to explore more options

Also, the budgets posted were from last season. Not the current one.

[JimBHibees]

What if it was an experienced manager that had achieved success elsewhere?

I don’t know anything about Rosenior but limiting ourselves to Scottish football only seems a bit unnecessary imo.

Agree a bit self defeating to limit ourselves to Scottish experience

[tonyrougier123]

Huge no from me. Followed his career as a manager goes through the motions at each club before sacking or leaving mutually.

[tamig]

Huge no from me. Followed his career as a manager goes through the motions at each club before sacking or leaving mutually.

Eh? Hull was his first full-time post. The guys only 39.

[stantonhibby]

Huge no from me. Followed his career as a manager goes through the motions at each club before sacking or leaving mutually.

Really? Which other clubs would that be then?

[tonyrougier123]

Eh? Hull was his first full-time post. The guys only 39.

Got him and his dad mixed up 😂🤦*♂️his auld man got sacked after minutes of a managerial appointment few years back. Thought it was him still.

[Scouse Hibee]

No, no, no. No more managers without any experience up here. Done with it.

No, no , no. No experience of Scottish football required.

[Bridge hibs]

Got him and his dad mixed up 😂🤦*♂️his auld man got sacked after minutes of a managerial appointment few years back. Thought it was him still.

He was appointed manager of Torquay but at the same time a consortium took them over and put their own man in, Colin Lee and nowt much he could have done about that to be fair

[KeithTheHibby]

This 'Need a manager with experience of our league' is nonsense imo.

We don't need someone with experience, we just need someone decent. I've no idea what makes the scottish league so unique that we need to hire someone who's played/managed here, when no other league is like that.

If Monty goes, Rosenior would be good imo, not sure we'd get him though.

There are 3 teams with significantly lower budgets than ours that finished above us this season who have managers with experience of Scottish football so I’d say that blows your theory out the water.

[MWHIBBIES]

Appreciate your point, I just think it’s such a typically under appreciated league by those down south which leads to signing players so far from good enough to actually compete in this league. Whereas you look at the signings made by people who know the league.

Yeah? I dunno about that. Big names with experience of Scottish football and great ''contacts'' like Lennon, Yogi and Collins signed a lot of dross.

[Winston Ingram]

I do find it amusing those writing this boy off as a bad choice due to lack of experience of Scottish Football.

Don’t worry he’s no coming here. He’s one of the hottest managerial properties in England. He’ll have another Championship job on 3 or 4 times what we could pay him by the end of the month.

[bingo70]

There are 3 teams with significantly lower budgets than ours that finished above us this season who have managers with experience of Scottish football so I’d say that blows your theory out the water.

I’m going to be a dick and point out Mourinho and Klopp are both available this summer, with no experience of Scottish football, you’d turn them down?

Obviously, even with our new found wealth, they’re probably a smidgen on the unrealistic side but I dare say there’s people in between a Pat Fenlon and a Jurgen Klopp, we’d just have to find them.

I’m open minded about who replaces Montgomery, it’s clear he’ll need to be replaced soon I think but I don’t mind where the replacement comes from. I can see the appeal of a proven safe pair of hands, if I was a decision maker I’d probably seriously consider Alex Neil this time round, that said, if an opportunity came up for a Jonny Foreigner who could do better I’d be all for it.

[MWHIBBIES]

There are 3 teams with significantly lower budgets than ours that finished above us this season who have managers with experience of Scottish football so I’d say that blows your theory out the water.

And Aberdeen with Barry Robson and his experience of Scottish football are below us, despite a bigger budget

[WeeRussell]

I’m going to be a dick and point out Mourinho and Klopp are both available this summer, with no experience of Scottish football, you’d turn them down?

Obviously, even with our new found wealth, they’re probably a smidgen on the unrealistic side but I dare say there’s people in between a Pat Fenlon and a Jurgen Klopp, we’d just have to find them.

I’m open minded about who replaces Montgomery, it’s clear he’ll need to be replaced soon I think but I don’t mind where the replacement comes from. I can see the appeal of a proven safe pair of hands, if I was a decision maker I’d probably seriously consider Alex Neil this time round, that said, if an opportunity came up for a Jonny Foreigner who could do better I’d be all for it.

Bingo!

[bingo70]

Bingo!

Sorry, not sure if that’s you agreeing with me or giving me a row cos you were still hoping for a Klopp or a Mourinho and I’ve burst your bubble?

[Since452]

I’m going to be a dick and point out Mourinho and Klopp are both available this summer, with no experience of Scottish football, you’d turn them down?

Obviously, even with our new found wealth, they’re probably a smidgen on the unrealistic side but I dare say there’s people in between a Pat Fenlon and a Jurgen Klopp, we’d just have to find them.

I’m open minded about who replaces Montgomery, it’s clear he’ll need to be replaced soon I think but I don’t mind where the replacement comes from. I can see the appeal of a proven safe pair of hands, if I was a decision maker I’d probably seriously consider Alex Neil this time round, that said, if an opportunity came up for a Jonny Foreigner who could do better I’d be all for it.

I'll be in the Robinson camp again I think. Still think in our league he's terrific.

[bingo70]

I'll be in the Robinson camp again I think. Still think in our league he's terrific.

There’s just something about him that makes me no sure. I really don’t know what it is.

I actually think he seems like a really decent, likeable guy who has done a terrific job at St Mirren, there’s just something that says to me I think he’d flop at Hibs.

In the past I’d have put that down to him having too boring a name but I can’t really use that as a reason when I’ve just suggested Alex Neil. Pretty certain it’s one of the main reasons I just never took to Jack Ross.

[Paulie Walnuts]

There’s just something about him that makes me no sure. I really don’t know what it is.

I actually think he seems like a really decent, likeable guy who has done a terrific job at St Mirren, there’s just something that says to me I think he’d flop at Hibs.

In the past I’d have put that down to him having too boring a name but I can’t really use that as a reason when I’ve just suggested Alex Neil. Pretty certain it’s one of the main reasons I just never took to Jack Ross.

I’m the same. No real reason and on the face of it he could be a good appointment, but Robinson just screams failure as Hibs manager to me for some reason.

[WeeRussell]

Sorry, not sure if that’s you agreeing with me or giving me a row cos you were still hoping for a Klopp or a Mourinho and I’ve burst your bubble?

😁 the former…


I’m no really a klopp fan 😎