Worst performance under Monty

[Crab apple]

Given that there isn't much choice on highlights under NM what do you feel has been our worst performance under him. For me the last trip to Perth where we were awful from the start.

[BILLYHIBS]

0-3 versus St Mirren first half

Human statues

Made Gogic look like Van Basten

[Nicho87]

I’ll got st Mirren at home 0-3

In what was another must win

It was one of the most pathetic displays imo this season

Granted I didn’t attend Perth

But for me with my eyes st Mirren at home

[GreenCastle]

Take your pick..


St Johnstone home (loss)
Ross County away (draw)

St Mirren home (loss) - 3-0 at home is probably the worst and probably could have been sacked after that.

Motherwell home (draw)
St Johnstone away (loss)
Ross county home (draw)
St Mirren away (draw)
Motherwell away (draw)

[Since452]

Seems strange to say but our 1-0 win at Livi was one of the worst games of football I've ever seen. Conditions were crap but so we're the teams. Never been so bored at the football.

[JohnM1875]

0-3 versus St Mirren first half

Human statues

Made Gogic look like Van Basten

Easily this one for me. First time in a very long time I'd actually been shocked at just how **** we were.

[NC1875]

Has he won a single game convincingly? I can’t remember a single one off the top of my head.

[Hibee Mac]

Seems strange to say but our 1-0 win at Livi was one of the worst games of football I've ever seen. Conditions were crap but so we're the teams. Never been so bored at the football.Did you not just describe every game at the Tony Macaroni borefest-drome?

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

[Alfred E Newman]

We were awful at Forfar. Could have been 2 or 3 goals down before we scored.

[Paulie Walnuts]

Has he won a single game convincingly? I can’t remember a single one off the top of my head.

Livi 3-0. It almost worked against us in excitement terms that we went 3-0 up so early as the remaining 70 mins played out like a pre season match. It was definitely a convincing win though.

[Nicho87]

Has he won a single game convincingly? I can’t remember a single one off the top of my head.

Livingston

Only one

[Bobo]

0-3 versus St Mirren first half

Human statues

Made Gogic look like Van Basten

Monty should have been bulleted after that game and maybe we wouldn't be in the position we find ourselves now.

In reality we haven't kicked a ball in anger for at least the past 3 seasons, while the level of underachievement has continued to get worse with an all too familiar regularity.

We're a soft submissive club with no backbone and have continued to show very poor mental attitude under various leaderships. Until this is addressed we will always be the pathetic laughingstock that we have become.

[MWHIBBIES]

Livingston

Only one

Na. Beat st Johnstone, Ross county, Inverness, Aberdeen all quite easily.

[Hermit Crab]

We were awful at Forfar. Could have been 2 or 3 goals down before we scored.


That was very nearly an upset, missing a penalty then absolutely stealing it with bad keeper error. We actually looked like league 2 side that day.

[Nicho87]

Na. Beat st Johnstone, Ross county, Inverness, Aberdeen all quite easily.

Aberdeen missed loads of chances and a penalty I seem to remember

[DIXIHIBS]

Considering the level of the opposition...Forfar the worst.

[HIBERNIAN-0762]

Diabolical reading, empty soon.

[The Tubs]

Aberdeen missed loads of chances and a penalty I seem to remember

We were very lucky. We played much better in the game at Pittodrie with Gray in charge.

[matty_f]

St Mirren 0-3. One of the worst Hibs performances I’ve ever seen. If he had been sacked in the dressing room at full time he couldn’t have had any complaints.

[erin go bragh]

0-3 versus St Mirren first half

Human statues

Made Gogic look like Van Basten
Sackable offence for that showing and to think he said we were unlucky 2nd half.
Ive renewed as I always will but he is not the man to take us forward. Hopefully the powers that be, agree and get someone in with a backbone.

[Smartie]

The number of credible candidates relative to the “best performances” really provides damning evidence.

Last week was the worst for me but I’ve not been all that often this season. It just failed to meet any sort of a minimum expectation from a Hibs performance and with hindsight, a point in that game probably gets us top 6.

[MWHIBBIES]

Aberdeen missed loads of chances and a penalty I seem to remember

And we took ours and won by 2 goals.

Marshall did his job for once. Mostly routine saves other than penalty.

[Unseen work]

I’ll go for a different and rather unexpected one

1-0 victory against killie at Easter Road.

I couldn’t believe how boring we were to watch. Was horrendously frustrating to watch.

Funnily enough I think that time period was our best run under Monty

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

0-3 v's St Mirren is one of the worst showings I've ever seen from a Hibs team. When Gogic was playing with no shin pads and his socks rolled down it said everything about us.

[DaveF]

The 1-0 loss at Perth was everything this Hibs team is under Montgomery's management.

Insipid in attack, concede a ridiculous goal and not even a glimmer of hope of getting back into the game.

[Not In The Know]

Take your pick..


St Johnstone home (loss)
Ross County away (draw)

St Mirren home (loss) - 3-0 at home is probably the worst and probably could have been sacked after that.

Motherwell home (draw)
St Johnstone away (loss)
Ross county home (draw)
St Mirren away (draw)
Motherwell away (draw)


Deary me that’s a grim list.

[matty_f]

The 1-0 loss at Perth was everything this Hibs team is under Montgomery's management.

Insipid in attack, concede a ridiculous goal and not even a glimmer of hope of getting back into the game.

That was awful. A game that would have football stopped.

[wookie70]

We were awful at Forfar. Could have been 2 or 3 goals down before we scored. That would be my choice. The St Mirren game was dreadful but they are better than us this year. Forfar were the better team against us for much of that match and the players looked liked they couldn't care less. The squad has gotten off really lightly as a group from supporters. they have worked nowhere near hard enough this season imo

[hibstag]

We were awful at Forfar. Could have been 2 or 3 goals down before we scored.

This is the game for me we should have been back fresh after the break, lower league opposition an opportunity to 'turn it on' and show that the message was getting across.
However no change, out fought out thought I felt like we had gone backwards, through due to a lucky goal when as you say we could have been and better forfar finisher would have had us 3 down.
The Derek Adams outburst kept the press off him afterwards

[Mikey_1875]

St Mirren one is miles ahead for me. Plenty poor performances this season but I think that first half will still be recalled for years to come.

[Baader]

St Mirren at home was up there with the worst I've ever seen us. Made my mind up that the manager isn't up to it after seeing that.