Penalties

[DH1875]

How many is that we've had given against us now this season? Is it just me but seems as if we are given one against us in every game. Defo been a few recently.

Also, out if curiosity, how many have we been given? No chance is balances out.

[Itsnoteasy]

Why ask this question, when it is so easy to find the answer yourself. It has taken me the best part of 20 seconds to find the answer. You've obviously got Internet knowledge as your posting on .net

[Biffa Bacon]

We've now conceded 10 penalties (9 in the league and the one in the Scottish Cup yesterday). We've received 3 penalties.

[DH1875]

Why ask this question, when it is so easy to find the answer yourself. It has taken me the best part of 20 seconds to find the answer. You've obviously got Internet knowledge as your posting on .net

Nice. Thanks for sharing 👍

[McGruber]

We've now conceded 10 penalties (9 in the league and the one in the Scottish Cup yesterday). We've received 3 penalties.

One v Forfar and both their fans crying conspiracy

[Onceinawhile]

One v Forfar and both their fans crying conspiracy

The one vs Forfar was never a penalty tbf.

[Hibs1992]

Why ask this question, when it is so easy to find the answer yourself. It has taken me the best part of 20 seconds to find the answer. You've obviously got Internet knowledge as your posting on .net

So you went to the length of finding the answer only to berate the OP for asking the question instead of just giving him the answer. Good for you

[Heisenberg]

Why ask this question, when it is so easy to find the answer yourself. It has taken me the best part of 20 seconds to find the answer. You've obviously got Internet knowledge as your posting on .net

Gets a bit of a discussion going on a football forum. Just provide the stats yourself that you so excellently looked up, no need to be an arse about it.

[Ozyhibby]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SickBoy32]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Behave.

The hun slowed to almost a stop to initiate the contact, that’s a dive.

We also never got a near enough identical ‘foul’ on Boyle vs Celtic

[B.H.F.C]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It’s the fact that, at the other end, I don’t think we get it. We have an example from just a few weeks ago where we don’t get something that is almost identical, against Celtic. In nearly the exact same spot on the pitch ironically.

Those two are refereed completely differently. The speed at which they were given decisions last night and some of the non decisions the other way round were a joke.

[Kato]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkIt's a penalty every day of the week unless you are playing Celtic that week.

The push on Boyle's back seconds before the penalty, completely ignored.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[matty_f]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Every day of the week, except whatever day it was when we didn’t get it.

[Jones28]

Every day of the week, except whatever day it was when we didn’t get it.

Like the day of the week a few weeks ago against Celtic.

[Carheenlea]

Behave.

The hun slowed to almost a stop to initiate the contact, that’s a dive.

We also never got a near enough identical ‘foul’ on Boyle vs Celtic

There’s more pushing in the queue for food as fans squeeze by than the lightest of brushes we saw last night. To date, I’ve not seen anyone fall to the deck on the concourse.

If Boyles was yellow for “diving” the other week, then that one last night was similarly a yellow for diving and a free kick to Hibs.

The debate isn’t so much whether they are penalties are not, it’s why they’re penalties for some clubs and yellow cards for others.

[MWHIBBIES]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Look at the one Kai Havertz didn't get Vs Man United this season. 100x more of a penalty than last night and over ruled. It's completely untrue to say it's a pen every day of the week. 6/7 out of 10 refs wouldn't give that. There is no consistency.

[B.H.F.C]

Look at the one Kai Havertz didn't get Vs Man United this season. 100x more of a penalty than last night and over ruled. It's completely untrue to say it's a pen every day of the week. 6/7 out of 10 refs wouldn't give that. There is no consistency.

Up here there is plenty consistency. It’s just that the colour of your top determines the outcome. Things are then applied consistently based on that.

[LaMotta]

It's a penalty every day of the week unless you are playing Celtic that week.

The push on Boyle's back seconds before the penalty, completely ignored.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

:agree::agree:

[Swedish hibee]

Why ask this question, when it is so easy to find the answer yourself. It has taken me the best part of 20 seconds to find the answer. You've obviously got Internet knowledge as your posting on .net

It is easy then?

Have we had more apologies than saved pens is my thought?

[StockholmHibs]

Why ask this question, when it is so easy to find the answer yourself. It has taken me the best part of 20 seconds to find the answer. You've obviously got Internet knowledge as your posting on .net

The poster puts a point up for discussion because it's a football forum.
What's with your attitude?
Should we all be arsey to each other because we lost a game?

[Biffa Bacon]

One v Forfar and both their fans crying conspiracy
Cheers, I forgot about the Forfar one - so we've received 4 penalties (3 in league, 1 in the cup). We've missed 2 of them as well so poor return.

[marinello59]

It's a penalty every day of the week unless you are playing Celtic that week.

The push on Boyle's back seconds before the penalty, completely ignored.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

Exactly.
I would call out the inconsistency but it's not, its consistent bias towards the Old Firm .

[rodhibs55]

Yesterday was a penalty. Everyday of the week. There is contact from behind and the player goes down. That’s a penalty in every league in the world.
Everyone is hurting because we are out the cup but we just need to take a breath and take responsibility for the mistakes we made.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Whether or not its a penalty is debatable for me. The real point is it should never have got there as Boyle was clearly fouled in the build up. As usual totally ignored at the game and no surprise, sportscene never even looked at it.

[VoltaireHibs]

The problem that all non OF clubs have now is that the OF players, the Huns in particular, know that the refs are giving them the softest of decisions so they're dropping like flies and claiming for the slightest infringement.

Our players now enter the field of play knowing that they have to play a perfect game, that every tackle must be perfect or they'll be penalised, and they be penalised either way of we look like a threat to the Huns or Celtic.

This is why tempers boil over like yesterday. Sheer frustration at the impossibility of playing the OF.

[Hibrandenburg]

Behave.

The hun slowed to almost a stop to initiate the contact, that’s a dive.

We also never got a near enough identical ‘foul’ on Boyle vs Celtic

Yep, and IF it was a penalty then so was the incident at the other end of the park involving Emiliano.

[wookie70]

The problem that all non OF clubs have now is that the OF players, the Huns in particular, know that the refs are giving them the softest of decisions so they're dropping like flies and claiming for the slightest infringement.

Our players now enter the field of play knowing that they have to play a perfect game, that every tackle must be perfect or they'll be penalised, and they be penalised either way of we look like a threat to the Huns or Celtic.

This is why tempers boil over like yesterday. Sheer frustration at the impossibility of playing the OF. It is fairly obvious our players play very differently in the box than they previously did. We simply don't press players in possession for fear they throw themselves to the floor. It is almost like The Rangers get to play a different sport at times.

[Shrekko]

Every day of the week, except whatever day it was when we didn’t get it.

Ref was making the dismissive 'up,up,up' gesture to Martin Boyle for an almost identical foul a minute or 2 before.

I cannot wait until Hibs start getting these calls 'every day of the week'. People think you can justify any decison now with words like 'contact' - it's an absolute joke. The boy dived last night and had no need to go down- it was clear as day.

[Crunchie]

Exactly.
I would call out the inconsistency but it's not, its consistent bias towards the Old Firm .

And Aberdeen and Hearts and Celtic……. whoever is playing us.

[Itsnoteasy]

The poster puts a point up for discussion because it's a football forum.
What's with your attitude?
Should we all be arsey to each other because we lost a game?

Hardly arsey. Past losing sleep over a Hibs result. Lot worse things that could be happening to me in todays world. Yes its a football forum but put up the results 1st to start the debate instead of someone else doing the donkey work for you. It was hardly a difficult stat to find out.

[Greenbeard]

There is an accidental coming together and the Sticky player dives like he's about to race 50m freestyle, instant penalty.
Likewise, second half there is a coming together as Marcondes and Goldson jostle, Marcondes dives and gets hee-haw.
Also a concern is our set up for opposition penalties. The Sticky player who scores the rebound times his run from deep so as the penalty is hit he's already travelling at speed on the follow-up. Newell is the one Hibs player who does likewise but our other two players who follow-in - Fish and Rocky - both start flat footed. Why not have our fastest players designated to follow in to either get to a rebound first or to get in a position to block any attempt on goal? Boyle for example is just stood on the 18 yard line. Surely he would have beaten the Sticky to the rebound, even from a standing start?